Apple, Intel persuade U.S. Patent Office to enter Qualcomm fight

“The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has decided to wade into a global licensing battle between Apple Inc. and Qualcomm Inc., with billions of dollars at stake,” Susan Decker and Christopher Yasiejko report for Bloomberg.

“The Patent Trial and Appeal Board agreed to consider the validity of two Qualcomm patents, according to notices posted on its electronic docket Tuesday,” Decker and Yasiejko report. “Apple and ally Intel Corp. had claimed the patents didn’t cover new inventions and the board conducted a preliminary analysis to determine if Apple had a ‘reasonable likelihood’ of winning its argument. The board will hear arguments from both sides and issue a final decision in about a year.”

MacDailyNews Take: The expeditiousness astounds.

“Apple and Intel, which makes the chips in the newest models of iPhones, have filed more than three dozen challenges at the agency. They are hoping to expose vulnerabilities in Qualcomm’s patent holdings,” Decker and Yasiejko report. “Apple has argued its former supplier unfairly leverages its position as the biggest supplier of chips for smartphones to force payment… The U.S. Federal Trade Commission has agreed with Apple’s view of Qualcomm licensing practices, and a trial over the government’s antitrust case is in its second week in San Jose, California.”

Read more in the full article here.

MacDailyNews Take: Qualcomm is obligated, and should finally be forced, to license their technology on fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms.

Apple’s COO Jeff Williams delivers blistering testimony on Qualcomm’s ‘onerous demands’ – January 15, 2019
Apple was paying Qualcomm over $1 billion per year in licensing – January 15, 2019
German court throws out Qualcomm’s latest patent case against Apple – January 15, 2019
Qualcomm posts $1.5 billion bond required to enforce iPhone sales ban in Germany – January 3, 2019
U.S. FTC v. Qualcomm set to begin; case could upend Qualcomm’s predatory business model – December 27, 2018
Qualcomm places high-stakes bet on iPhone injunction in Germany – December 21, 2018
Apple pulls some older iPhones from sale in Germany after patent ruling – December 20, 2018
Qualcomm wins dubious envelope tracker patent case against Apple in Munich – December 20, 2018
German court rules Apple infringed Qualcomm patent – December 20, 2018
Qualcomm warns Apple to take China’s ban of older iPhones very seriously – December 19, 2018
Qualcomm claims Apple is violating Chinese court order, despite software changes – December 18, 2018
Apple releases iOS 12.1.2 – December 17, 2018
Apple denies iPhone import ban in China – December 10, 2018
China ‘bans the import and sale’ of most iPhones, Qualcomm claims; Apple says iPhones still available – December 10, 2018

1 Comment

  1. If USPO validates these old Qualcomm patents that all network/cell chips depend on… why was Apple not granted patents on “multi-touch” and “pinch to zoom”… those are in my opinion ESSENTIAL for touch interfaces…

    if all these smartphones didn’t have multi-touch, no gaming… touch gestures would be limited. interfaces would have been clunky…

    how about Apple charge 5% of all smartphones/tablets/touchscreen laptops worldwide… and call it even?

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.