“Apple is suing Samsung in California over ‘slide to unlock,’ but a little-known Swedish touchscreen phone, the Neonode N1m, already had that feature (though Apple’s version undoubtedly has a more elaborate graphical representation) well before the iPhone was launched,” Florian Müller writes for FOSS Patents.
“After Apple sent one of the named inventors on its ‘slide to unlock’ ‘721 patent to the Wall Street Journal for a pretrial story, I figured that it was going to place particular emphasis on this patent because it’s the easiest one of their patents-in-suit to explain and the one with which one can mislead a jury into believing that Samsung ‘copied’ Apple’s patents-in-suit,” Müller writes. “But to me, after 3.5 years of following Apple’s Android litigations on a cross-jurisdictional basis, ‘slide to unlock,’ an invention over which I attended more court hearings and trials than presumably anyone else on this planet, stands for quite the opposite of what Apple’s trial counsel says and implies. The litigation track record of this patent, more than of any other, has over the years changed my perspective on Apple’s Android lawsuits from ‘bullish’ to ‘bearish.’”
“Yesterday a few people asked me on Twitter whether or why my attitude towards Apple’s lawsuits has changed recently. I think some of it is attributable to a misperception of what I had been saying over the years. I wasn’t nearly as ‘pro-Apple’ or ‘anti-Android’ as some people made me out to be, but when I said something positive for Apple, it reaffirmed many people’s beliefs, and when I said something positive for Android, it didn’t fit into the picture,” Müller writes. ” Fere libenter homines id quod volunt credunt. [Men generally believe what they want to.] Maybe I will list at some point all the “pro-Android” and “anti-Apple” positions I had taken over the years — and the length and the substance of the list would shock a lot of people. But in any event, there are three things I can’t and won’t ignore…”
Read more in the full article here.
Apple CEO Steve Jobs declared ‘Holy War’ on Google over Android patent infringement – April 2, 2014
Apple v. Samsung jury is seated in California patent trial – April 1, 2014
What are the five iOS features Apple says Samsung (or Google) stole? – April 1, 2014
Apple again seeks decisive U.S. court ruling against convicted patent infringer Samsung – April 1, 2014
Florian Müller: When all is said and done, despite years of Apple litigation, Android will continue to be world’s most popular mobile platform – April 1, 2014
Apple v. Samsung II: Convicted patent infringer Samsung now claims all patents aren’t worth very much – March 31, 2014
Google is central to new Apple v. Samsung patent infringement lawsuit – March 31, 2014
Apple’s war on Samsung has Google in crossfire – March 31, 2014
Apple already has its first victory in new $2 billion Samsung patent infringement fight – March 31, 2014
Apple v. Samsung patent infringement trial begins today (link to live blog) – March 31, 2014