Darren Waters recently spoke with Brad Duea, president of online music service Napster, for BBC News.
“Mr Duea says online music sales can transform the whole spectrum of music production and consumption – from artist to music lover,” Waters reports. “The most high profile of all the services is probably Apple’s iTunes, which has a very different model to Napster’s. There are no subscribers to iTunes, users purchase songs either on a per track basis or in the form of albums. It has sold more than 500 million songs world-wide, but Mr Duea is critical of the approach Apple has taken. He says Apple boss Steve Jobs has ‘tricked people into buying a hardware trap’ as iTunes songs can only be taken away and played on an iPod.”
aters report, “And the ubiquitous iPod itself can play paid-for songs with copy protection that are bought from iTunes and none of the other services, but it can play any MP3s. Apple’s approach means the market remains essentially cut down the middle – between the iTunes service, which works only on the iPod, and services which use a Windows Media format, essentially everyone else. ‘The dream is that Napster would work on any PC, any player in any territory and work seamlessly,’ said Mr Duea.”
Full article here.
iTunes Music Store (iTMS) songs can be burned to a CD and imported into any second- or third-rate software jukebox and, subsequently, into any second- or third-rate portable music player. Everyone else uses Windows Media format? Less than 20% use WMA based stores vs. Apple’s market-dominating iTMS. If that’s “everyone else,” so be it, but it bears menitioning that despite Napster’s “dream” of working on any PC, they’d have a slim chance of us actually believing them if they made a Mac version, so that the 15% or so of the personal computing (PC) population that are using Macs could use Napster if they somehow dramatically lost the ability to reason.
Apple’s iTunes, iPod, and iTunes Music Store comprise the only seamless solution that works on both Mac and PC (covering the vast majority of personal computer users). Keep dreaming, Napster, if you think people can’t see through your hypocrisy and FUD.
Napster is a joke and the only thing that Napter’s missing, besides a clue, is the sock puppet. Die with dignity? Not, Napster, obviously.
Related articles:
16-percent of computer users are unaffected by viruses, malware because they use Apple Macs – June 15, 2005
Survey shows Apple Macs owned by nearly 10 percent of US small and medium-sized businesses – February 17, 2005
More people use Apple Macs than you think; 8-12 percent of homes use Macs – March 31, 2004
10 percent of computer users use a Mac; 3 percent is Mac’s approximate quarterly market share – February 10, 2004
Syracuse Post-Standard: 3 percent is a false stat; Mac holds ’10 to 12 percent of the market for PCs – August 27, 2003
Napster: the only thing missing is the sock puppet – August 04, 2005
Enjoying Apple’s iTunes and iTunes Music Store without owning an iPod – May 11, 2005
Apple launches ‘iTunes on Campus’ institutional site license program – April 28, 2004College students refuse to buy a single song from Napster – July 10, 2005
SmartMoney: Napster is a snooze, gushing money and renting music is un-American anyway – July 06, 2005
Colleges should not exclude Mac and iPod users with Dell, Napster music hardware, software offering – July 06, 2005
Napster, other Windows Media-based music services ‘chasing a niche opportunity’ – June 29, 2005
Napster To Go Soon? Reports $24.3 million net loss on $17.4 million net revenue – May 12, 2005
Napster users admit sharing passwords to save on subscription costs – April 08, 2005
Napster is a joke – April 05, 2005
Napster raises fourth-quarter revenue forecast from $16.5 to $17.5 million – April 05, 2005
Colleges offering students music services that aren’t cross-platform, don’t work with iPod – March 22, 2005
Mossberg: Apple’s iTunes Music Store vs. Napster To Go – March 18, 2005
Napster CEO Gorog: Steve Jobs ‘must be pretty frightened’ of Napster To Go – March 14, 2005
Apple’s iTunes Music Store downloads pass 300 million songs milestone (with chart) – March 02, 2005
Napster’s math does not add up – February 28, 2005
Napster’s dirty little secret: changing subscription services into downloads is easy – February 18, 2005
Napster feels the heat over flawed copy-protection scheme – February 17, 2005
Apple CEO Steve Jobs warns record industry of Napster To Go’s security gap – February 16, 2005
Users thwart Napster To Go’s copy protection; do the music labels realize the piracy potential? – February 15, 2005
Napster-To-Go’s ‘rental music’ DRM circumvented – February 14, 2005
Napster CEO Gorog: ‘it’s stupid to buy an iPod’ – February 10, 2005
Report: Napster faces uphill fight to gain share, Apple prepared to run iTunes at a loss – February 10, 2005
Napster’s ‘iPodlessness’ doesn’t bode well for its future – February 10, 2005
$10,000 to fill an iPod? Napster’s going to end up with egg on their face – February 04, 2005
Why ‘Napster To Go’ will flop – February 03, 2005
Napster CEO: We’re ‘the biggest brand in digital music, much more exciting than Apple’s iTunes’ – February 03, 2005
Cornell University’s Mac users ‘uniformly unhappy’ with Napster – January 19, 2005
Cornell University wrestles with Napster’s exclusion of Mac and iPod-using students – September 08, 2004
Why are Cornell’s Mac students being forced to pay for useless Napster? – September 07, 2004
Napster schools to Mac-using students: bend over and take it – September 04, 2004
Funny, Calling it a hardware trap because you are stuck with an iPod – it wasn’t until recently that Napster could even be put on any player. These guys are really funny.
He says Apple boss Steve Jobs has ‘tricked people into buying a hardware trap’ as iTunes songs can only be taken away and played on an iPod.
Napster’s service is also a hardware trap; meaning it only works on a Windows PC since their site explicitly says the following…
PC only, Windows XP/2000, Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.1 or higher, Windows Media Player 7.1 or higher, Internet connectivity
Note: Windows XP and Windows Media Player 10 are required to use the Napster To Go™ service.
When are these myopic idiots going to wake up and realize that the war has already been lost?!? WMA-DRM is dead. Apple’s iTunes has already won this war. Video, Podcasting (or whatever else) are the next frontiers, but the battle for paid music downloads is all over but the shouting already. Like MDN says, why not go down to defeat with a little dignity since the game is already all but over and they’ve lost.
Mr. Duea is certainly acting in a manner consistent with an 8000lb gorilla sitting on top of him.
However, he is right – until FairPlay is licensed, if you use iTMS to buy music you are in a hardware trap. If you love your iPods as they are, then it isn’t a big deal. If you want competition which will drive Apple and others to offer better products, then right now the situation is confining.
If you like lossless music, well, there really isn’t much of an alternative for online downloads.
Funny, if you swapped Napster & Apple for Apple & Microsoft in any number of areas, some of the tunes would be a little different.
He’s just making excuses because Napster is going down. They don’t have a viable business model so he’s blaming Apple for not being “open.” Meaning, without the iPod, Napster can’t stay in business.
More FUD from “the other guys”. A hardware trap now, what else can these dumb people come up with. Oh yea I’m really trapped with my iPod.
I can use it on a PC and a Mac. Those other services and hardware don’t work on a Mac. I can listen to MP3’s, MP4’s, Apple Lossless, AIFF and so on. Yea it’s really trapping me, NOT!!! Those others have one sound they can listen to, WMF. Who’s trapping who here? Oh and Apple is not grabbing anyones arms and dragging them to the register and taking your wallet and forcing your credit card through that I know of.
FUD, FUD, FUD…
Now, correct me if i’m wrong. But wouldnt you be able to take the MP3 file that you donwloaded from iTMS from your iTunes folder on your computer an d drag it into anything else and it would play. And then you can even encode it into WMA and put it onto any MP3 player via their loading software?
I’ve never used the service for myself-on my Mac (I’ve done it for friends on their PCs) so Maybe I’m wrong……but if im right, then nobody should really complain about anything about incompatibility.
A hardware trap you say? Ok then, as a Mac user, why don’t you offer us a Mac compatible solution then Mr. Duea? It’s funny how you want to blame Apple for not being “open”, but it is <u>you</u> that have left me with no other choice but to use the iTunes/iPod solution as it’s the only one that works with a Mac. So it seems quite obvious to me that you have nobody to blame but yourselves then…
I buy an album or more a week from iTMS and I don’t even have an iPod currently. I listen to the music via my Mac and iTunes – hooked up to my stereo system.
So, how exactly am I locked into iPod?
Sorry for the reality intrusion, Napster weasel.
Mr. Duea paid $5,000,000 for the Napster name. I recommend that he sell the name to Microsoft, and distribute the funds to the shareholders.
some very funny stuff in this thread.
first comment for the hardware side: can you call this a business plan? “let’s copy what’s hot today because we are too lame to fingure out what will be hot tomorrow. then let’s bitch about what’s hot today because we could not make ours hot enough when we copied it to make any money, duh!”
second comment for the software side: can you call this a business plan? “let’s not compete head to head because that would be too embarrassing, but let’s sell subscriptions with the option to purchase. while we are lsing money, let’s lay low in hte weeds and jump at the next opportunity to copy something that might work better”
third comment for the ecosystem: can you call this a business plan? “let’s make sure we are able to keep our customers confused with 1000 options that require fulltime tech support people to make their walkman replacement play music. that’s how we measure progress-tech support jobs/customer. we won’t quite until the metric exceeds unity. we never liked those dang walkmen anyway-they didn’t need a computer.”
final comment that no one that is a ceo (other than steven p) understands: the ipod experience is about changing the way you listen to YOUR music. carry your library, whether it is 1000 songs or 20,000, with you so you can squeeze every available moment in your busy day to enjoy YOUR music. you could do that with your DAT walkman except playing the song you wanted out of 1,000 was a challenge. maybe if a ceo looked at competing from this perspective they might have half a chance in succeeding. access to YOUR music anytime, anywhere is a powerful potion. stevie understands that and god bless him for sharing that with the rest of us.
I am shocked. Thank goodness no one else does this. Like yahoo japan, they allow free streams of music now. Those great people. Apple is toast now *removes tongue from cheek*
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/2002447931_yahoojapan22.html
I’ll tell you what I’ve thought of a solution:
Mr. Duea would like Apple to stop hogging its own customers for iTMS, who are are currently generating around $30 million a year in profit for Apple.
So how about Napster and all of their ilk each pay a one-time license fee of $5 million and then 5% of their gross profits with a minimum of $1 million per year – after all, Apple is doing all of the software/hardware R&D, the least Mr. Duea and the rest of his WMA cronies could do is pay Apple for their work.
Now obviously the concept of Microsoft lackeys paying Apple for being their R&D function – as opposed to stealing it – is a wholly new idea so I don’t expect this to take off immediately, but I think its an idea worth exploring
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
That name has to be worth at least $5 now.
Talking about Napster gives me heartburn. I resent all these guys that don’t let Macs into their stores.
It makes me so mad in fact, that I simply visit even more individual iTunes Music Stores than ever before. To facilitate this, I created a Safari Bookmark folder containing all twenty iTMS store URLS just so I could quickly visit any iTMS without first having to both be in iTunes and on an iTMS homepage in order to be able to access the Store Chooser function. Here’s how.
Create a new folder in the Safari Bookmarks page (Safari>Bookmarks>Add Bookmark Folder). Drag out each of the iTMS icons one at a time from the Choose Store page in iTunes and drop them into the new folder on the Safari Bookmarks page. As you procede, change the “http” in each iTMS URL to “itms”. Rename each URL as you add it to reflect the correct name of the store to which that URL applies. Place the new folder full of iTMS bookmarks into the Safari Bookmarks Bar if you haven’t already done so. Done. You now have a dropdown menu in the Safari Bookmarks Bar for the home pages of all the individual iTunes Music Stores. Sweet.
If that’s too much work, here’s a URL for just the iTMS Store Chooser. Enter it into the Safari Address Bar but don’t activate it. Instead simply drag the URL’s blue globe icon from the Address Bar onto your desktop. Change the extension of the resultant desktop file from it’s default .inetloc to “.webloc”. Done. This creates a desktop web location bookmark which will always open iTunes to the iTMS Choose Store page. Drool over any iTMS, anytime, quickly and without the hassle of having to return to an iTMS homepage. Yum.
itms://phobos.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/com.apple.jingle.app.store.DirectAction/countrySelectorPage
Now … if they would only let us buy … heh.
HELP!
I’m caught in a HARDWARE TRAP and I can’t get out!
Really, I can’t… if I use the Dell on the next desk over my brain will implode.
Why, oh why did I ever lock myself into this stupid Mac that works all the time and doesn’t crash and doesn’t get viruses and TRAPS me into getting stuff DONE all day, and in style to boot? Oh, the humanity!
By the way, I also wonder where Oddyssey67 is, telling us all the good news about the trap Steve Jobs is setting for us next year with the new
“Apple iBro (Patent Pending)”
Of course, “i” for Intel
And “Bro” as in “Big Brother” – because your future will be controlled by iSteve with his Dr. Evil (TM) brand eDRM and future Macs will no longer carry the “Mac” nickname, they will be called affectionately “Little Box Of Horrors”. Just as soon as next year, iSteve’s evil genius minions will achieve their ultimate goals of delivering you less computer for your money, with all the eDRM you can eat! Mmm…
Maybe I’m paraphrasing his points; I’m not sure I got the exact wording. Hopefully the Odd-man will come in and tidy up his thoughts for us all.
Morning sarcasm provided by the Magic Word “Class”. You just can’t make this stuff up.
That Napster dude is nothing but a crybaby and a big fat hypocrite. Napster’s service is NOT cross-platform, the moment you miss a payment you lose your music, and it does NOT PlayForSure. Doesn’t he know that people pick the hardware first and use the software to run it. They don’t pick their music store and then look for a player. HE IS AN IDIOT!
With iTunes, you buy a track and play it. Simple.
Sounds like Darren Waters and his editors at the BBC need some friendly emails to tell them to start printing the truth.
“iTunes songs can only be taken away and played on an iPod.”
Right. Then the Audio CD I just burned does what?
“…as iTunes songs can only be taken away and played on an iPod.”
Ummm… that has to be one of the most misleading statements ever.
Yes, perhaps the ipod is the only player supporting playback of AAC files. Let’s see though, you have an AAC file downloaded into iTunes that you want on some other player. I’m pretty sure every mp3 player supports playing mp3 files so why don’t you just convert the song directly to mp3 in iTunes?
It’s not like it’s difficult…control-click (or right-click for you PC users) on the song and choose “convert selection to mp3” (assuming you have mp3 chosen as the default format for importing in itunes prefs)
Voila! your song is in mp3 format. Only playable on an iPod??? I think not. Are people so ignorant that they can’t figure this out?
Oh yeah…WMAs blow!
You can’t blame the guy for being upset that Apple avoided the real hardware trap by not licensing Windows Media from an actual monopoly. How is he supposed to compete?
I wonder if it would be sensible in the not too distant future for Apple to actually start offering Fairplay licences to other operators presuming of course that such an action would not lead to serious usability, compatibility and security issues.
In all seriousness it would call these companies bluff and what is the danger here now? The opposition having invested so much in Microsoft’s brown stuff are niether likely to actually offer it an any large scale way and are hardly financially able to do so even if they did wish to . The cost and complexity of actuallyoffering both WMA and AAC with little hope of actually making an impact in the latter would also make them even less competitive I suspect. And the likely handbags at 10yds between the confused download stores and music player makers as to what they should do in such a new situation would be a sight to be savour I suspect.
For Apple though it would give them plenty of good marketing and moral kudos and good publicity, make the iPod/iTunes combination by far the most open offering meaning comments like those above sound even more dum and laughable. Equally it could actually encourage a few specialist distributors to set up and offer specialist services to support iPods that Apple really can’t be bothered with or have the resouces or inclination to cover, so widening the content net yet further. Seems win win at this stage especially as the iPod expands into new areas. After all a videopod would probably be in such a position from the off as MPEG4 is pretty much likely to be the majority standard and certainly far less unique than AAC amongst media companies generally.
The real FUD here is that Duea says you need an iPod to play an iTMS-purchased track. It’s a subtle lie that is perpetuated by the iPod challengers and haters.
You can play it on a PC or Mac. No mp3 player or iPod required.
Mr. Duea is certainly acting in a manner consistent with an 8000lb gorilla sitting on top of him.
“However, he is right – until FairPlay is licensed, if you use iTMS to buy music you are in a hardware trap. If you love your iPods as they are, then it isn’t a big deal. If you want competition which will drive Apple and others to offer better products, then right now the situation is confining.
If you like lossless music, well, there really isn’t much of an alternative for online downloads.
Funny, if you swapped Napster & Apple for Apple & Microsoft in any number of areas, some of the tunes would be a little different.”
———————————————————-
Nonsense, all of these products are out there. Why are consumers not choosing “Play for sure”? Apple is not stopping anyone from buying a dell digital jukebox or downloading music from any site they wish to download from. Apple may license in the future (who knows), but I’ll bet if they do they will not allow WMA to be a part of the scenario. That would be just plain dumb. MS has set the tone for how the industry competes. Not Apple. Apple offers a cross platform solution. You don’t like it don’t buy it. There are plenty of other options. In fact if you are a PC user you have more options than Mac users. Go buy an MP3 player from Creative & get on with your life. Simple. The truth is that Apple offers the best solution. It has everything & more in the music dept. What do these other companies offer for music purchase & usability that Apple doesn’t? Nothing compelling apparently. No ones choice is being taken away. The majority of people buy CDs & put there own music on their MP3 player of choice.