Class-action suit filed against Microsoft over Surface tablet flop

“The law firm Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd has filed a class-action suit against Microsoft over what it claims was misleading information on the company’s Surface RT sales,” Mary Jo Foley reports for ZDNet.

“ posted about the suit on August 13, noting that it names as defendants Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer, former Chief Financial Officer Peter Klein, Corporate Vice President Frank Brod and Executive Vice President of Marketing Tami Reller,” Foley reports. “The case was filed in United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts on behalf of purchasers of Microsoft stock between April 18, 2013 and July 18, 2013.”

Foley reports, “The firm is claiming that Microsoft “issued materially false and misleading statements regarding the Company’s financial performance and its tablet computer, the Surface RT.” It is claiming that the company’s financial statements for the quarter ending March 31, 2-13 were ‘materially false and misleading’ and that Microsoft officials made misleading positive statements about the Surface RT during the ‘class period.'”

Read more in the full article here.

MacDailyNews Take: Roast ’em and toast em, bloodsucking sharks!

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Readers “Fred Mertz” and “Edward W.” for the heads up.]

Related articles:
Desperate Microsoft cuts Surface Pro tablet prices; could signal even more losses – August 6, 2013
Microsoft’s Surface sales figures are in, and they’re a total disaster – July 30, 2013
Microsoft earnings, sales badly miss expectations; $900 million inventory writedown on Surface tablet flop – July 18, 2013
Gartner: Apple to overtake Microsoft in total OS sales in 2015 – June 25, 2013
Apple Macintosh owns 45% of PC market profits – April 16, 2013
Steve Jobs’ revenge – April 12, 2013
Apple Macintosh on the rise as Windows PC market plummets – April 11, 2013
Gartner: PC Market posts 11.2 percent decline in Q113; Apple Mac sales up 7.4 percent in U.S. – April 10, 2013
IDC: PC shipments post the steepest decline ever in a single quarter, down 13.9% in Q113 – April 10, 2013


          1. This is a simple case of calling a spade a shovel. It was harsh as it was well deserved. Rorschach has a long history of using vulgar language in the most disrespectful way and needs to stop. He is disrespectful to us all and I did not use foul language or ‘potty talk’.

            1. I don’t know Rorschach, but the quote comes from the last line of Lou Reeds song – Last Great American Whale. His 1989 album, New York, is an amazing piece of social commentary on many aspects of the nations and city’s culture.

              Personally, I didn’t find the line/quote offensive in the least. It does trouble me, however, when people assert a moral high ground particularly in the absence of any sense of humour.

            2. 3l3 is the self appointed language police here. He hasn’t figured out we probably don’t have readers here that are still in grade school. That statement was not that vulgar.

            3. Agreed , it’s a given that 3I3c throws around his comments and thinks he speaks for more then himself, for the past many months if you have some time to waste, go back and look at all of his posts, they reflect the same narrow mindedness of this reply he just made and some are even worse.

              Most of us here just ignore his posts and have just chalked it up to Spam and worthless static.

  1. Oh this is classic! If you bought MS stock, you got what you deserved. Any good judge will kick this suit out, observing that the suckers who bought MS thinking that Surface had any real potential, as obviously dead from the neck up.

    1. Forward looking statements, unless you can prove gross, *intentional* misstatements (which is virtually impossible to prove), come under the “Safe Harbor” rules.

      Each investor is expected to take *all* projections with a huge grain of salt. If you gamble and lose then you gambled.

      Sure the Surface RT was/is a crap product. Did any investor actually expect Microsoft to say that? Never going to happen. When any company pitches a product they always say it’s going to sell very well.

      Should Apple have been hit with a class action suit for sales projections on some of its lesser selling projects? Should Apple have been sued for not selling enough Pippins? or MacTVs or Centris machines? Should there have been a class action suit because Apple had many unsold Lisas that ended up in a landfill?

      This lawsuit should thrown out in a heartbeat.

  2. I’m no M$ fan but this is a frivolous lawsuit.

    That being said follow the link over to the original article and read the comments from the M$ defenders, priceless.

  3. I remember the Windows where I used to work brag and needle me about how the Surface Tablet was an “iPad Killer” and how the Windows Phone was an “iPhone Killer.”

    They’re quiet these days.

  4. I can only imagine what SteveB will says when he first learned about the CAS…

    Notes to SteveB:
    Here we go again, MSFT naysayers and haters are coming out in full force and intend to destroy MSFT by filing shitty lawsuit.
    Pay no attention to them, SteveB!! You are the best CEO on the face of this Earth.

    “we” all want to see more of your great products such as Surface RT, Surface Pro, Microsoft Bob, Windows 95, Kin, and Zune.

    I will never able to afford to attend ANY concert if I don’t lining up the great new MSFT Store for the free concert ticket.

    I fully support your effort to sail Microsoft to where it deserver!!

    /s /s /s /s /s … 🙂

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.