Düsseldorf court denies preliminary injunction against Galaxy Tab 10.1N: Design-around pays off for Samsung

“The Düsseldorf Regional Court has denied Apple’s motion for a preliminary injunction against the Galaxy Tab 10.1N, a modified version of the Galaxy Tab 10.1 banned by the same court in August 2011,” Florian Mueller reports for FOSS Patents.

“The court determined that the 10.1N is reasonably distinct from Apple’s products and, therefore, does not constitute an infringement of Apple’s Community design (the EU equivalent of a U.S. design patent) or the German law against unfair competition,” Mueller reports. “The appeals court had held the original Galaxy Tab 10.1 to violate competition law. But it appears that Samsung’s designaround (modifications of product design in order to steer clear of further violation) has done the job.”

Mueller reports, “It’s important to understand that today’s decision is merely the denial of a preliminary injunction. In parallel to all those efforts to have different Samsung tablets banned as a result of fast-track proceedings, Apple continues to assert four different design-related rights against ten Samsung smartphones and five Samsung tablets, including the ones against which Apple sought preliminary injunctions. That case will take more time to be resolved (I guess we’re talking about a year or more just for the regional court, plus a possible appeals proceeding before a higher regional court).”

Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 vs. 10.1N iPad wannabe

Read more in the full article here.

8 Comments

  1. That may be great for legal reasons but it still wouldn’t make me want to buy it, “🎵some people drink Pepsi some people drink coke the wacky morning dj says democracy’s a joke…🎵”

    Spoken by cake©, building a religion

  2. That’s ridiculous! Can’t wait for the day when Apple cancells all orders of any part or service they get from Samsung. I’ll bask in samsung’s misstep and misfortune.

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.