No iPad cannibalization in sight for Apple’s Mac sales

Apple Online Store“People have been wondering if and when the iPad is going to finally start cannibalizing Mac sales,” Bruce Upbin reports for Forbes. “It hasn’t happened yet.”

“In the year of the iPad’s release, Mac sales continue to break records,” Upbin reports. “Apple sold 3.89 million in the fourth quarter, up 27% over the prior year’s quarter, and 3.47 million in the third quarter, up 33% over the third quarter of 2009.”

Full article here.

31 Comments

  1. There are obviously people who own something like an iMac already and decided to get an iPad instead of a MacBook for their “mobile” computing. So yes, there has been some “cannibalization.”

    However, the growth in Mac sales has been so strong that any cannibalization effect has been negated and hidden. In fact, the iPad’s “halo” effect (to drive NEW Mac sales to first timers) is much greater.

    But it’s mostly irrelevant. Whether it’s a Mac or an iPad, it’s still an Apple product. And often, Apple gains BOTH an iPad AND Mac sale to the same customer, within a short period. The real losers are Apple’s competitors, who are losing more and more sales Apple (in every conceivable way).

  2. I don’t see the cannibalization in my own organization. We have purchased iPads and subsequently new iMacs and MacBook Pros. The iPad doesn’t do everything I do with the iMac or MacBook Pro. I seem them on a continuum.

    Base level: iPhone for quick mobile access to data
    Intermediate level: iPad for larger screen but still mobile access to data
    Higher level: MacBook Pro: Some mobility, full OS X accessibility

  3. @bon: “That’s because the iPad is second device. It can’t cannibalize Mac sales”

    People also buy Macs as secondary devices. So there’s no reason it can’t cannibalize Mac sales. For instance, instead of buying a MacBook, someone may decide to buy an iPad as a secondary device… I did. I have an iMac on my desk, and an iPad I use around the house.

  4. All Apple products are Trojan Horses. You buy one, then you buy another and another. It snowballs until you have all Apple products. So, Apple doesn’t care if you buy an iPad or a Macbook. In the end, they’ll get all your discretionary income.

  5. MacAir is perfect machine for my normal household internet and web work ….

    Where the iPad is used in my work, showing pics of work and other docs to potential and current customers ….

    iMac is work machine that does a lot of heavy lifting ….

    Wife uses a 13″ MacPro as she likes the larger screen …

    As for the iPad taking away form Mac sales, yes in some cases, but the halo effect is adding way way more ….

    And the iPad, unlike iMac and MacBooks, will get immediately passed down once a new generation comes out …. I know of at least 3 iPad owners that will pass down their iPads to their kids or grandkids – So at least 3 new iPads plus mine or 4 total will be purchased when the next generation comes out …. Now we do the same with our other Apple products but not as quickly – Even the iPodTouch we keep for a few generations before passing down … but not the iPad …

    iPad is such a huge hit for Apple and it has not even hit the mainstream user yet, give it a little more time to catch fire … It has only just begun ….

  6. It’s Trojan horse!,

    I showed my 1st gen iPhone to a lady friend when they 1st came out and showed her my iMac! I received a ” Christmas” email from her today and noticed she now has a @me.com addy and the email was sent from an iPad !

    I replied and asked her if she was all Mac now? Here is her reply

    “Yes I am all “Apple/Mac” now.  just got my IMac last month (that was last thing!).  I have 2 Iphones (3 & 4), Ipod, Ipad, MacBook, Apple TV and now the IMac!!  Only thing I guess I don’t have is an Ipod touch and I just use my old IPhone 3 for same purpose since I now have the Iphone 4!!”

  7. Quoting the source article:

    “A halfnymous blogger named Dario D. wrote this post “Apple’s Problem: Selling Macs” on December 12. Dario D. is so right and so wrong. He lays out a very compelling case, one that has been made time and again, why homo economicus should be avoiding Macs: They’re vastly overpriced when matched up spec-for-spec with their Windows 7 PC counterparts; PCs have closed the gap in ease of use; Mac marketing seduces people with low self-esteem.”

    Pure troll drivel, pulled right out of Dario D.’s deceitful rectum.

    Example 1: Not one professional study of the cost of Macs versus Windows PCs ever found PCs to be cheaper ‘when matched up spec-for-spec’ when the ACTUAL cost of each computer was considered. Shelf price + Total Cost of Ownership – Return On Investment = Actual Cost of anything. Macs win on Actual Cost every time and have done so for decades, as in for over 20 years. You won’t find a professional study that disagrees with this statement.

    Example 2: A bully, aka a troll, is a person attempting to over-compensate for extremely low self-esteem. So isn’t it interesting how Mac users don’t go around trolling PC users. It’s almost always PC users who troll the Mac users. Kind of makes you go ‘Hmm’.

    Another name for troll drivel: Propaganda

  8. Oh, I forgot the best part!

    Example 3: Dario D. is quoted as saying “PCs have closed the gap in ease of use.” No. Go check out any computer and take a look at the NAME of the boot drive. Does it have a name? Or is it merely labeled as “C:”? It couldn’t be easier to tell a Mac from a Windows PC. Nor could the LACK of ease of use of Windows be more glaring.
    (0_o)

    And ask yourself ‘Whatever happened to the A: and B: drives?’ DOS lives. You can’t wake up from this nightmare.

  9. Why waste time on obvious hit-whoring troll-fest opinion pieces. There are no facts, therefore it doesn’t rate as an actual article.

    The iPad is a satellite device… just like the moon orbiting the earth. Although in my house it’s more like a planet with multiple moons. Come to think of it, that’s why I name my MacBook Pro “Jupiter”.

    Or maybe the iPad is really more like a Star Trek shuttlecraft (Galileo?)… It always returns to the Enterprise.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.