“After six months of nothing happening on the Kindle front, Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos issued a press release calling the Kindle a ‘huge success’ and a ‘revolutionary’ device. Now, we’re not new to such hype, but the clincher here is he had no numbers, no sales figures and no revenue amounts to support his claim,” Prashanth Cherukuri writes for Seeking Alpha.
“It is very obvious that Amazon’s Kindle is a huge flop. In six months of traveling, I am yet to see a single person on any bus, train or plane with a Kindle in their hands. Contrast that with the iPod or iPhone or even the Sansa, where people can actually be seen using them everywhere,” Cherukuri writes.
“Even if we accept the fairy tale that Bezos is weaving and accept Kindle to be a resounding success, the difference to Amazon’s bottom line revenues will be 3%. JUST 3%,” Cherukuri writes.
Full article here.
[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “David” for the heads up.]
It doesn’t matter how good or bad the product is, the fact is that people don’t read anymore. Forty percent of the people in the U.S. read one book or less last year. The whole conception is flawed at the top because people don’t read anymore. – Apple CEO Steve Jobs remarking on Amazon’ Kindle, January 15, 2008
I’m one of the 60% that has read more than one book and I’ll be looking forward to downloading books onto my iPhone. I would never buy a Kindle, just as I would never buy a GPS. In fact I hope to never buy a single purpose gadget ever again. Whether this works out depends on how soon Apple can get a decent camera into the iPhone. If it takes more than 24 months, it’s a problem. By then I’ll be thinking about upgrading the iPhone 3G I’m about to buy.
Last weekend I was at the Long Beach airport and saw 5 people in a very small space with a Kindle. My Kindle made it 6! I was shocked to see that many in one place. I ride BART in the SF Bay Area and have only seen 1 other person besides myself with one.
I love the KINDLE and have read a lot of books off it since its release in Nov 2007!
I read all the time, on my iPhone. Even PDF formatted books…..
People who like books are generally fans of low tech. And they generally like the feel of dead pine trees in their hands.
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
@ericdano?
How to you store PDFs on the iPhone? Can it be done the same way on an iPod Touch?
I’m just curious. I’d like to carry some PDF books on mine.
i know it is popular with the over 60 set…..
While I disagree with Steve Jobs’ statement, as I read an average of 6-8 books a week, I will not buy a Kindle. I like books, and I would read on my iPhone.
the big problem with kindle is the need to be in an area with sprint coverage. with it the entire thing is almost useless.
To be fair, the Kindle is not a mass-market product. It doesn’t have to be to be a success, and Steve Jobs knows that. I mean, look at the iPhone. He set the success bar at 1% of the global cellphone market. If you set the bar for the Kindle at 1% of the US public, about 3 million, then who cares if 40% read less than 1 book a year. I mean, the Kindle isn’t just about books, it’s also magazines and newspapers.
Having said that, I read dozens of books in a year, and have no interest in getting a Kindle.
Steve Jobs is not always correct, so it would be nice if MDN could use their own brain cells more often.
Most people love reading, but most won’t get a Kindle. There, that was easy!
I’ve read a few thousand books, but would never consider getting a Kindle. Books are handy, durable, high res, and they smell good.
I emailed a pdf version of a book to my Yahoo account on my iPhone, and have been working through that. Works okay, but as Famous Grouse observed, when you can have a book handy as an add-on to an existing device, that is best.
Another device; no.
These press releases by Amazon about how they are SOLD OUT and showing huge palettes of them in their warehouse are are artificial to make it seem as though everyone’s got one.
The Kindle is a pretty impressive device. It’s not perfect, and it lacks the elegance of any Apple product, but it’s still a fine device and I really enjoy using it.
The fact that a new product is only 3% of Amazon’s bottom line does not make it a failure. Has the iPhone–which had a lot of hype and a six month head start–topped 3% or 5% of Apple’s bottom line? I suspect not, not least b/c it’s being accounted for on a subscription basis. But that does not make it a failure either.
Boy, I wish Apple would come out w/ a reading device!
“How to you store PDFs on the iPhone?”
Via email attachments. Just wait until 11 July for dozens of book readers for the iPhone/iTouch – and backlit in colour!
Ironic that Steve Jobs helmed the creation of the iPhone which turned me into an avid reader. I hate to sit at a desk and read from a computer screen and I wasn’t fond of books. The iPhone was the perfect compromise, always ready and right there in my pocket. After jumpstarting my interest with the many wonderful things I read daily using Safari over the past year, I’m now digesting all forms of print like never before. I swear this never would’ve happened if it wasn’t for the iPhone.
My cousin has both the Kindle and Sony reader (because he can). The Sony wins easily in user interface. I bought his old Sony so he could by a newer one (slightly better interface and contrast).
My only real complaint with it is that has Windows only software to purchase and download to the reader. Other than that, I am completely satisfied with the Sony.
If Steve Jobs says that nobody reads.. damn it.. then nobody reads… Don’t think about it.. just accept it as fact.
Fact is.. he is correct.. the majority of people don’t read. The majority of people are also stupid…. use windows.. and eat macdonalds… doesn’t mean health food, literacy… or even Macs (smaller market share) are flops.. just catered to a different type of person.
@Grifterus:
You can find books all over the place (out of copyright at guttenberg.org, for example). Then open in textEdit, print to pdf, and email that file to yourself.
Works pretty well. I grade literally thousands of pages for my screen writing class every semester, and the iPhone has made doing so MUCH easier and more convenient over the past year. Thanks, Apple!
Another way to put PDFs on the iPhone (other than e-mail, or waiting for the 2.0 software) is to use iPhoneView from Ecamm.
Ever since the iPod came out, I switched 90% of my reading from my eyes to my ears. I now probably listen to 4 audiobooks a month on my iPhone, primarily during my commute. I could never find that much time to read books if I had to actually read them with my eyes.
@bluegirl
While I disagree with Steve Jobs’ statement, as I read an average of 6-8 books a week
Steve Jobs didn’t say that YOU don’t read, he said, “Forty percent of the people in the U.S. read one book or less last year”
@Greg…
If you were in Long Beach, CA airport last weekend, your fellow travelers were likely attending the American Library Association annual conference and were publishers, editors, journalists and library staff. Agents and editors are using the Kindle and Sony reader for its ability to pack dozens of manuscripts for review into a small device. They are not the “readers” that the market needs to adopt eBooks. It’s like finding metric tools at a BMW garage.
When SJ says people don’t read anymore, he reveals that he hasn’t been to the beach or a park or a Barnes and Noble recently.
I love to read. I just don’t get the idea of reading from a skinny etch-a-sketch looking thingy.
And… what happens to it when I drop it in the sand?
Small world — I just got a Kindle yesterday. So far, I love it.
Yeah, it has an 80s Apple prototype look. And the buttons are a tad kludgy. And the screen isn’t backlit. Despite all that, it’s an interesting first-generation effort, primarily due to the easy Amazon integration via wireless.
As a pushing-50er, I can tell you that the ability to make any book into a large-print edition is a killer feature. You young punks will understand someday…
I’m happy with Kindle, and hopeful that Amazon sells enough of ’em to come out with a refined 2.0 version.
Unless Apple releases the oft-rumored Tablet Mac and it comes with…
Nah…never mind.
Jobs is wrong, people read, just not books.
If you are reading this post, you are probably like me. Reading posts, replying and reading news articles, etc… I take up my hours reading news, learning new information on new topics, technology or on politics – not books.
iPhone and the web w/Safari onboard is built for the new type of “informational” reading if you will – not for novels.
I haven’t read any non-medical books since I entered medical school in 1994. Sad.
And, I much prefer a book to online. I like holding a book in my hands and flipping through the pages. Now, back to The Red Book 2006!
Classic dumb comment. People DO read. They read less. Make it easier and they might read MORE. How is that idea flawed?
It’s like saying they shouldn’t make a phone because now people email more than they used to.
I love my Kindle and have to say I think I use it more than my iPod. That said, I also love and frequently use my Apple TV. I do think that if Apple came out with an iPhone that had an e-ink display for reading, my Kindle would probably be used less frequently.
And to a previous poster who stated the Kindle was nearly useless without access to the Sprint network, that’s simply untrue. I keep the wireless on my Kindle turned off most of the time, only using it when I’m looking for a new book.
The Kindle has been perpetually sold out – so SOMEONE has to be buying it…
I’m reading David Sedaris’ book currently. I read about 2 books a year, but I read a TON of articles on line and read WIRED and THE NEW YORKER religiously.
I have no desire to own a Kindle.
… the fact is that people don’t read anymore. Forty percent of the people in the U.S. read one book or less last year. —Steve Jobs
I’m as big a fan of Steve Jobs as anyone, but just because Steve says something doesn’t automatically make it true. This claim—that 40% of the people in the U.S. read one book or less last year—sounds preposterous on the face of it. Where is the authoritative reference to support this claim?
to be fair, the iPod…and MP3 players in general…have been out far, far longer than the Kindle. it’s not a good comparison.
Amazon just keeps the supply low to make it seem like a hot seller. Nobody’s buying that ugly piece of shit.
I heard Amazon’s going to rename it to the Dwindle.
kindle is a turd
Shame, shame, MDN. This site constantly draws attention to other sources’ dubious reliance upon statistical information; the MDN take is just lazy, and dare I say, presumptuous. One of the things I find disturbing about the information age is anything unearthed via Google or Wikipedia is taken as gospel.
I am acquainted with several authors who make handsome livings and enjoy plenty of sales. The Kindle is junk, and its lack of success is due to that fact, methinks.
Although there are several design flaws with the Kindle I have to say after buying one for my wife (who reads a book a day), and using it for a while I bought one for myself.
We both took ours on a recent 2 week trip up to Alaska and we loaded them up with books.
The wife actually needed more for the Alaska leg of the journey (she needs to slow down), so even tough we were in Canada with no Sprint coverage I just downloaded a bunch of new books on my MBP in the hotel and loaded them via USB.
We both had enough to read on the entire trip. She now loves the Kindle as much as she loves the TiVo. Can’t get her to love the Mac yet, but she likes it more than the PC.
What’s a book?
I really wish Apple would make one of these things. I would read more if I didn’t have lug big books around or take up shelf space with books I won’t read again and again. The Kindle is a cool idea, but I hate how it operates. From the demo on Amazon, I just can’t see myself using that button scheme at all. Apple probably has no interest in making such an item, but I constantly wish. I would get one for my mom, two sisters and myself. Right now we swap books via snail mail. The last person to read the book ends up with it on their shelf. Its usually me. 🙁
that’s BS, people still read, they just like books. I like reading books and sharing them with people. the kindle’s just lame, that’s all.
I would buy a Kindle in a heartbeat if more books were available, especially technical and programming books AND if it were a little less expensive, like 250. It wouldn’t replace books altogether, I can’t imagine Edward Tufte books in digital form, but for the vast majority of books I read I would happily trade paper and ink for 1’s and 0’s
I can’t use the Kindle to prop up an uneven coffee table or throw it across the room. Besides, can you highlight passages and scribble little notes on the margins of the pages?
And you thought the Zune was fugly!
Amazon’s Kludge a huge flop?
Well that’s just being nasty
The problem with Amazon’s Kludge, in all seriousness, is the propriety nature of their distribution model… give me standards based media format (not AZW) and a DRM free distribution system then I’m fine with things like the Kludge…
But to allow only reading on a Kludge, well thats rather kindley isn’t it?
from wikipedia:
Although it supports unprotected Mobipocket books (.MOBI, .PRC), plain text files, and HTML and Word documents, Kindle also uses its own proprietary, DRM-restricted format (AZW). It does not fully support the widely accepted Portable Document Format (PDF), but Amazon provides “experimental” conversion to the native AZW format.[11] Users may also convert PDF files to supported formats using third-party software.
Using the experimental web browser, it is possible to download books directly on the Kindle (.mobi, .prc and .txt). Hyperlinks in a Mobipocket file can be used to download e-books[12] but cannot be used to reference books stored in the Kindle’s memory.
The Kindle charges monthly for RSS subscription to select blogs, even though one may use the experimental web browser to navigate to and read blogs without cost.
I’ve seen as many Kindles in the wild as I have Zunes.
Steve Jobs is right, people don’t read anymore, mainly due to those who read can’t comprehend the concepts. People like bluegirl and others think broad, generalized, statistical data, applies to them solely, and if it doesn’t, it can’t be right. Extrapolate, people, extrapolate. Understanding concepts and context is vital. Books provide entertainment and education, if most people aren’t entertained or educated by them, they become irrelevant, and reality tv shows prove people like low brow amusement masquerading as both.
Why are reality shows so popular? The less informed would say because people love them, the more educated would say, because they cost little to produce, it’s a financial goldmine, so the execs pander to the public. It depends on what you know, and people who don’t read and comprehend, don’t know much.
Take my word, Steve Jobs is way smarter than his detractors, he doesn’t need your advice.
pan·der (pndr)
intr.v. pan·dered, pan·der·ing, pan·ders
1. To act as a go-between or liaison in sexual intrigues; function as a procurer.
2. To cater to the lower tastes and desires of others or exploit their weaknesses
Yes, People don’t read anymore. As soon I start reading one post I skip to the next one before I finish. Then jump to the next tab for the latest tech news… What?
Whats a Kindle? Isn’t that what you need to start a fire with?
Steve Jobs is an idiot sometimes. Yes, I said that. Possibly uneducated idiots do not read anymore, but I do a lot of reading because I like to keep up with what is going on in this world.
I purchased a Kindle and absolutely love it. So far, I have purchased 23 books in the last two months. I could never afford that many physical books, and I have no more room for physical books in my home.
One bestseller was $27.95 at the local bookstore – Kindle price $9.99. Hmmm… Which one shall I buy?
The first iteration of the Kindle is not perfect, but it is better than all of the other eBook readers out there IMHO. In two years, Amazon will bring a color version out and I am sure it will be even better.
I’m looking forward to buying my dad one for Christmas.
As for me, I am reading “A Man Called Intrepid” dead tree version while I kill time in the hospitol.
Oh, and “I got your huge flop hangin’, so kindle that…..”
That’s funny, because I just got a Kindle today. I’m not sure what MDN’s stake is in trashing Kindle–maybe it’s to boisterously verify Job’s statement.
As a student who will be traveling around a lot, you can bet your ass that just like I want an iPod to carry all my music, I’ll be wanting a Kindle to carry all of my books and readings. It’s a no brainer. As for books–dude–Harry Potter, anyone? Time, Newsweek, the WSJ?
This article is unsubstantiated Dvorak-esque flamebait if I ever saw it. Shame on you, MDN.
They can have my Kindle when they pry it from my cold, dead, hands.
I used to do as little “book” reading as possible, until I got my Kindle, that is. Now I take it everywhere, and read several books a month.
MDN says people don’t read anymore – true. MDN concludes that is why the Kindle is a flop – less true. Or at least it does not provide a singular explanation. The other main reason it isn’t doing well is because there are several really nice eBooks shops online and the Kindle is a proprietary device for drm-ed books, (understanding that it will read other formats as long as they are not drm-ed). It only works with Amazon books if the books are drm-ed.
Let’s say it all together again ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls – No more proprietary ereaders – PLEASE. eReader.com provides eReader software for ALL platforms including hand held devices, and they assure me that an iPhone/iPod Touch eReader is in the works, and they have a very respectable [read large] selection of ebooks.
I still think the absolute nicest looking device, in a reader friendly way, is made by Sony – But of course, it’s proprietary to one single web site – give me a freaking break!
Rant over… For now
I “read” printed books far less than I used to. But I consume books far more than ever by using Audible.com and my iPhone. I probably get through close to 40 books a year now. Who has time to sit and read anymore? I can listen to books while driving, walking, running, going to sleep in a dark room, doing odd jobs around the house and in the yard. Audible.com is great!
I’d rather read a REAL book. I’m nuts that way…..
Despite it’s name, the Kindle makes my job more difficult. The paper books burn so much better.
The problem with the kindle is that there’s a reason that people that read books, newspapers and magazines like books, newspapers and magazines. When I read a book–and I usually have at least one in my bag–I read a real book—pages bound together with glue or string. The text is much more readable than any ebook, I don’t have to be careful what pocket I put a book in or where I lay it because no screen is going to get crushed. Flipping through the pages of a book is much easier than going to a page on an ebook. If I don’t know exactly where I’m looking for but know generally where in the book it is I can find it much easier on paper than with an ebook. A book’s batteries never run out. Etc.
The only real advantage of an ebook reader is that no physical storage of large amounts of printed materials is needed. On the other hand, I download a lot of free ebooks but I never read them for the very reasons listed above. So my ebook library only takes up a sliver of disk space but that isn’t much of an advantage because I never really use them.
If they really want to sell Kindle, they should port it to the iPhone, sell it in the Apple app store, kill off the hardware, and go software only.
I work in a hotel and I have yet to see one Kindle. I have seen dozens of MacBook Airs, tons more Macs than just a few years ago and a billion iPods. I think people do read because I see lots of people bringing books and many more bringing magazines. But Kindles? Nary a one.
Speaking of books: anyone read anything good lately?
My company got together and bought our boss a Kindle for Christmas this past year. He’s a guy who “has everything,” travels all the time, and loves to read books and magazines, etc. He loved it. No more lugging books around.
Now if only I could get him to lose the Blackberry and replace it with an iPhone…
Amazon’s bottom line is HUGE, given their success and the number of products they sell. Even if the Kindle adds just another 3%, that is still a huge number. That’s why we need to see some sales data, because I don’t believe it comes anywhere near 3%.
I would DEFINITELY buy an e-ink reader if it was from Apple and did not have DRM (or allowed me to read my PDFs and TXT files).
None of the current ones do this easily, and the Kindle has full DRM. I can’t even read my own PDFs or TXT without having to let Amazon see what I put on it.
iCon
so far is the Sony reader.
However, like everything they do, Sony tries to “make life easier” for the end user with their shit software. If they tried less hard, they would make better products. They just don’t understand. Look at the Clie and the Vaio!
Personally, I wouldn’t have much use for a Kindle, since I like to read ‘real’ tangible paper books, but the concept is unique, I suppose. I suspect Amazon were riding on the expectation that their brandname would be enough to ignite some movement toward adopting the device.
‘They’ have been saying for years how the classic paper book is as dead as Betamax in our technological culture, but time has proven that false. Afterall, the Kindle was only a US product(?), so it could hardly alter the way into which the world wanted to read.
Unless there’s a massive bookburning being planned, I’m not sure an electronic reading device would be too widely sought. There’s something more special about holding a leatherbound classic than say, reading it on a small plastic device with a highly contrasted screen.
I read approximately one book per week.
About 7 years ago I decided to read all the classic fiction books that I had never read; then I started reading paperback fiction novels.
There are many great, fun, entertianing and thought provoking books to read.
I got into the habit of reading one or two hours before going to bed (instead of TV or computer surfing).
Book reading is one thing I cannot recommend enough. It is like heavy weight lifting and fast aerobic excercise for the brain.
“It doesn’t matter how good or bad the product is, the fact is that people don’t read anymore. Forty percent of the people in the U.S. read one book or less last year. The whole conception is flawed at the top because people don’t read anymore. – Apple CEO Steve Jobs remarking on Amazon’ Kindle, January 15, 2008”
Anymore? Mass literacy is a phenomena of the last century or so. Even in the 20th century, when did the masses ever read more than a book a year?
@numlock
It’s more likely that they didn’t really read at all, beyond a basic ability to read and write. Afterall, 100 years ago, people were considerably more active than we are today. They walked, rode, played sports, did hard physical labor…
There probably just wasn’t any time in the day to sit and read.
The office bound culture we have today is a creation of the 1940s, you know.
As for me, I never liked reading paper books, let alone electronic ones. I do still enjoy reading stone tablets. The roughness, the wieght, and the smell of stone when it gets wet is absolutely devine.
@Pete,
And best of all no DRM.
I know one person with one, it was given to him as a gift and he never uses. Contrast that to 5 of my circle of friends with iphones/ipod touches.
Kindle is a single use proprietary device; how anyone thought that would work is beyond me.
If someone actually designed a digital book that looked like a nice leather bound novel with touch navigation and a nice crisp reading screen instead of the quasi weird looking Speak n Spell that the Kindle is, people might actually be inclined to buy it.
Kindle a big stinkin’ flop, just like Newton.
Amazon has more to worry about that the Kindle. They’re loosing partners left and right. There’s an article in today’s IBD about it. Target (TGT), Toy ‘R Us, and others needed them to build and run their web sites but have now found that Amazon’s poor practices are costing them money. They left. Borders also. It will be interesting to see how the stock (AMZN) reacts to all it.
Job’s is right. To few peeps reed or care to. Thats why comment’s hear and on millions of other sights reed like this one, blame education and politishuns.
Ignorance means power — for the politishuns. It will only get worse.
I’ve had a Kindle since the beginning. I travel extensively and read voraciously. It is rare for me to have less than 4 or 5 different books, magazines, newspapers open simultaneously. The Kindle has solved all kinds of problems for me. I carry much of my research library, nearly all of my fun reading, and receive daily subscriptions to the NY Times, WSJ, and LA Times. This is all on a device that takes up as much space as a large paperback book. I can’t carry all this with me when I travel; I hate reading extensively on a computer screen. I wouldn’t even consider reading this kind of material on my iPhone.
Is the Kindle perfect? Heck no. It doesn’t have backlighting. the whole look and feel is clunky and it turns pages slowly. But these aren’t showstoppers for me. I’m sure that in due course, there will be a 2nd generation Kindle that addresses some of these features.
Finally, the Kindle gives you access to wireless cellular networks for no monthly charge so I *can* go on line and check email or read some blogs. No color, but who cares.
The device is to expensive for what it is-an ebook reader.
It has a clumsy interface, not well designed look.
It is black and white only.
The media to put on it is to expensive.
The DRM on it is intrusive.
I have heard the display is crisp, the sprint ev-do connection is awesome and the web browsing is ok.
Drop the price, redesign the button layout, lower the price of the media, loosen the DRM , add color and I would possibly consider thinking about maybe purchasing one.
If people didn’t read Apple wouldn’t have a web site. Nor would anyone else.
I have a Kindle and an iPhone. The iPhone is by far the best cell phone I’ve ever used and a great tool for surfing the web and email (hope for even better with Exchange in 2.0).
The Kindle may not be as elegant but I like the interface and the ability to keep work related articles and magazines (from pdfs) with my favorite books (work and pleasure). Plus the ability to search all of those plus the WSJ/LaTimes is a great advantage. The battery life is awesome and the Sprint coverage (I travel a lot) has been excellent. I’ve been a lite reader but find myself reading more now that I have the Kindle. I only wish that it wasn’t so ugly in it’s design.
Kindle a big stinkin’ flop, just like Newton.
…. and Lisa.
…. and 20th anniversary Mac.
…. and MBA.
…. and full independent resolution.
… and hockey puck mouse.
… and (insert next Apple disaster).
What makes the Kindle a flop? By what measure? Is there actual data that the Kindle isn’t selling well or has been unprofitable? Just curious about the confidence of the pronouncements and if there is actual data to confirm them…I honestly don’t know…just curious…
kpwcaw,
Fanbois growl, “Data? Data? We don’t need no stinkin’ data!”
The great thing about fanboism is that reality doesn’t matter, statistics are purposeless, and numbers don’t count. These cretins cannot provide a shred of hard evidence for every pinheaded post they write.
Oh Oh I’ve got one AppleTV is also a flop.
The pippen didn’t go so well either.
Read the comments/reviews of people who actually own or have tried using a Kindle and then read the reviews of people who have not. You’ll notice that almost every Kindle owner loves the device.
Why i love mine:
– Free wireless download of books and sample books
– Ability to search my entire Kindle database with keywords
– Easy to read screen
– Compact lightweight – I used to carry 3-4 lbs of books with me
– Wall Street journal delivered electronically to me every morning
My advice, try it first then post your opinion.
John: I concur with you… I love mine and am very happy with it (for reasons stated in my above posts)…
I wonder what it is about the device that the people that don’t own one don’t like it a priori. Amazon should figure this out and try to solve the problem. Whatever their reasons it is not good for sales to have people dislike the device before they’ve even used one.
Kindle looks like a gadget of 19th century. Large space is occupied by its buttons.These should be replaced by a good touch screen .I find any phone supporting pdf enough to beat this device.