
Apple’s first dedicated smart home display, the $299 HomeView, has been on sale for only a few days, and early post-launch feedback is already mixed. While reviewers consistently praise its premium design and integration with the Apple ecosystem, several recent assessments — including a hands-on published today by iPhone in Canada and a November 14 analysis from The Mac Observer — highlight frustrations with Siri AI reliability, heavy reliance on an iPhone, and limited independent functionality.
The HomeView features a 7-inch square Liquid Retina display (1088 × 1088 resolution, up to 500 nits) mounted on a compact speaker base via a tilting hinge. It supports facial recognition for up to six household members, switches personalized profiles (calendars, messages, reminders), acts as a HomeKit/Matter controller, handles FaceTime with Center Stage, and includes cooking assistance and customizable “faces” (including Snoopy animations). It runs on an A18 chip and requires an iPhone or iPad for setup and many personal features. Wall-mount options cost extra.
Gary Ng of iPhone in Canada, who bought the device with his own money in Canada (where it lists around $429 before tax), published a critical review today. He liked the compact design and the ability to display album art while playing music, but described setup as frustrating (including a lengthy mandatory update before full use) and Siri AI as “an absolute disaster.” He reported slow responses, frequent failures to reach his nearby iPhone, calendar queries that merely read entries without context, and moments when the device deferred to his phone instead of responding. Ng concluded he would rather return it and put the money toward a discounted iPad that can do more.
The Mac Observer’s Nov. 14 roundup echoed broader early-review themes. It cited Joanna Stern (The New Things) noting she nearly cried from frustration with Siri after a week of testing, and Jennifer Pattison Tuohy of The Verge describing Siri AI as slow enough that “if [it] were a human personal assistant, I’d fire her.” Other points included basic failures (timers, Safari), privacy concerns (one reviewer could briefly see a family member’s messages on the shared display), limited third-party apps (mostly CarPlay-style), the absence of physical mute buttons for the camera/mic, and the device’s overall dependence on a nearby iPhone for full personal features. The piece questioned Apple’s decision to ship beta Siri AI at a $299 premium (with potential future usage fees).
Major November 12th reviews from outlets such as The Verge (score 7/10), Engadget (8.4/10), CNET (8.0), ZDNet (4.5/5), Forbes, PCMag (4.0/Excellent), and 9to5Mac were more balanced. They highlighted the device’s elegant hardware, strong sound for its size, effective smart-home controls, family personalization, and usefulness as a kitchen companion or photo frame — especially for all-Apple households. Several noted it outperforms similarly priced Echo Show or Nest Hub models in polish and ecosystem integration, though it is more expensive and less flexible for mixed or Android households. Common caveats included Siri’s remaining shortcomings versus Alexa+ or Gemini, the square screen’s awkwardness for video, and the premium price.
Apple launched the HomeView on November 13th as part of its broader “Home Collection.” Early real-world and post-launch feedback suggests the hardware is a strong first-generation effort that many Apple users will appreciate, but software maturity — particularly Siri AI — remains the key variable for long-term satisfaction. For households deeply invested in Apple’s ecosystem, it can serve as a polished shared hub; others may prefer waiting for software refinements or sticking with more mature alternatives from Amazon or Google.
MacDailyNews Take: Siri AI is in beta, but it has already been receiving regular iterative improvements in capabilities and performance areas since its initial launch. Properly updated HomeView units – to the most recent software – show the promise of Siri AI, even though it’s still in beta development.
Please help support MacDailyNews — and enjoy subscriber-only articles, comments, chat, and more — by subscribing to our Substack: macdailynews.substack.com. Thank you!
Support MacDailyNews at no extra cost to you by using this link to shop at Amazon.
Like 🙂 or dislike 🙁 this post below!