Hackers attack Microsoft Windows-based ATM network; steal PIN codes and net millions

“Hackers broke into Citibank’s network of ATMs inside 7-Eleven stores and stole customers’ PIN codes, according to recent court filings that revealed a disturbing security hole in the most sensitive part of a banking record,” Jordan Robertson reports for The Associated Press.

“The scam netted the alleged identity thieves millions of dollars. But more importantly for consumers, it indicates criminals were able to access PINs — the numeric passwords that theoretically are among the most closely guarded elements of banking transactions — by attacking the back-end computers responsible for approving the cash withdrawals,” Robertson reports.

“The case against three people in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York highlights a significant problem,” Robertson reports.

“Hackers are targeting the ATM system’s infrastructure, which is increasingly built on Microsoft Corp.’s Windows operating system and allows machines to be remotely diagnosed and repaired over the Internet,” Robertson reports.

“A critical issue in the investigation is how the hackers infiltrated the system, a question that still hasn’t been answered publicly,” Robertson reports. “All that’s known is they broke into the ATM network through a server at a third-party processor, which means they probably didn’t have to touch the ATMs at all to pull off the heist.”

Full article here.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “HMCIV” for the heads up.]

ATM IT Doofus #1: “Let’s make an ATM network based on the world’s most insecure OS, okay?” ATM IT Doofus #2: “Sounds like a plan!”

—   —   —

Peter explained, “Um, the 7-Eleven, right? You take a penny from the tray.”

Joanna asked, “From the crippled children?”

Peter replied, “No, that’s the jar. I’m talking about the tray, the pennies for everybody.”

Later…

Joanna, “You’re just this penny-stealing… wanna-be criminal… man.”

Peter, “Yeah, well, that may be. But at least I never slept with Lumbergh.”

41 Comments

  1. I think ATM companies should be legally required to disclose the operating system their machines are running. That way, I could be sure to avoid Microsoft-based ATMs like the plague.

    Of course, this would put Microsoft’s ATMs at an immediate disadvantage, as criminals would know which ones are the easiest targets.

    Why any security-conscious company would choose Microsoft to safeguard their data is completely beyond me. Microsoft have already proven their incompetence in this area several times over.

  2. If AYM machines used OS X, then they would be targeted just the same.

    Obviously this will be harder for them to exploit, but it would only take one security hole, and OS X has had its fair share of security holes. There is no denying that.

    *takes cover from the onslaught of insults*

  3. This should read “The case against three people and Microsoft in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York highlights a significant problem,”

    The Court should hold Microsoft for this problem, the Court should take every dollar in Microsoft’s account and close them down. If the software was done correct all this hacking would not be going on.

  4. But… but…
    1. Microsoft Windows is enterprise ready. (Even crackers can use it)
    2. Our IT people said Microsoft Windows was secure. (Nobody gets in until it is cracked)
    3. There are lots of apps running on Microsoft Windows. (Including hackers’ apps)
    4. Microsoft Windows is cheaper. ($319.95 a copy, plus several millions of dollars)

  5. @Dave

    “Apple is no different. It was super easy to hack the iPhone which is based on OSX”

    Actually there’s a big difference. In the case of the iPhone you have physical access to the device for an extended piece of time. It’s unrealistic to expect that you could make a device like that totally unhackable. In the end it’s just a piece of hardware and with enough time and access to the decive you could hack just about any piece of hardware or software.

    This case is about being able to hack some software from a distance over the net. From what I’ve heard no one has yet been able to hack an iPhone over a network.

  6. Actually I want my ATMs to use something non-commercial (or at least the old-school VMS systems they used to use). It’s ridiculous for them to put all this sensitive information on any popular commercial OS… in particular Windows, which has proven to be a sieve.

    You reap what you sow, but it seems clients of the banks will take the worst fall.

  7. JAYGEE,

    No insults, your point is valid, but what I don’t understand is that companies knowingly use MS which by all accounts has more security holes than any other OS.

    So, even though OS X could theoretically be hacked just as Windows can be it is a well-known fact that it is more difficult to do so than Windows, yet companies don’t seem to care.

    And this is not a plug at all for OS X, you can replace OS X with Linux, Unix, Wii OS, Playstation OS and the statement would still be accurate.

    Oh and to the one that said that the iPhone was so easy to hack, well yes, that appears to be true, but that required that people have actual access to the device and its components. Don’t know of many hackers that have an ATM lying around.

    That doesn’t meant they couldn’t get one and hack into it, I just don’t think it would be “super easy” as you state.

  8. Reminds me of an attack a few years ago targeting MS SQL Server that took down bank systems scattered worldwide. Folks in South Korea, where the systems were widely used, couldn’t get money out of their ATMs the whole weekend until the systems were sanitized.

    Why critical systems are running Windows is beyond me. I mean really, one is warned against doing that right on the box!

  9. what next…. putting autopilot sw on Windows? Next time terrorists will be able to hijack planes from the comfort of their homes…

    Today at my workplace I had to bring in my Mac because Windows XP running on VMWare was hosed (old legacy business application, in-house maintained, only Windows version existing).

    The tech guy discovered that some crucial files had been deleted by the anti-virus they had installed on XP. I did not know anti-virus programs had finally got that clever: they recognize Windows itself is a kind of a virus!

  10. Yeah! Diebold! They are infamous for the poor security of their voting machines. Anyone can rig an election with the things. So stoopid state governments like Maryland and Ohio buy them! And of course their resulting elections are fraught with fraud. Great.

    So here we have Windows, the world renowned #1 INSECURE operating system commercially available. It would even be hard to find a less secure OS anywhere! So let’s run our ATMs on Windows! Let’s take the single most sensitive part of our banking business structure and run it on the single most insecure operating system. Great.

    I for one would love to indicate with my financial accounts just how much I appreciate the thoughtfulness and technological intelligence of these banks. I’d love to say these banks get what the deserve. But the fact is that the customers are the ones who get hurt. The banks just clean up their mess and pass the cost of their moronic decisions on to their customers. Great.

  11. When will banks (or any big biz) take security seriously? Isn’t Citibank one of the biggest banks in the States? You’d think they’d make security of people’s $ a bigger priority.

    Didn’t a US Navy battleship run off of Windows NT years ago? That freaks me out.

  12. This article reminds me of when Bill Gates publicly stated how Vista was so good, he’d trust it to run the life support machines in hospitals and in the space shuttle…

    I wonder if they use Windows in the ICBM silos?

  13. For many years, ATMs (and, in NYC, MetroCard vending machines for the NY subway system) used to run OS/2. If you haven’t heard of it, this was IBM’s rock-solid desktop and server OS. Much better, more stable and secure than Windows NT (and subsequently, 2000). IBM officially abandoned development in 2001; yet many banks are still using it in their ATMs, especially in Europe. I have never ever seen an screen error message on an OS/2 ATM. In my neighbourhood, there are many banks with ATMs. Several have moved ATMs to Windows. How do I know? I oftentimes see a Windows error message on the screen (with ‘OK’ to continue).

    These people should better bring back the old OS/2. It just worked.

  14. Another Winblows Sucks Story:
    The computers at the 4 site clinic system that I work at were hosed last week by a virus that got into the server system and started chewing things up. Not good when you use an electronic medical record and not a paper chart in sight!

  15. If someone thinks OSX is just as vulnerable as Windows, consider that it isn’t just the OS we have to worry about. In my opinion, it’s the code hackers out there who grew up working with Windows, cut their teeth on Windows and the wide availability of exploitable flaws (especially in the hacker community) that pose a greater threat than the OS being used. By this I mean, as long as the enterprise (and we know Apple does nothing to push OSX in the enterprise) continues to use Windows, there will be individuals and criminal organizations that throw money at hackers to hijack windows OS’s. So as long as MS maintains the huge enterprise market share it has, it will be the OS with the biggest bulls-eye on it.

    I have many friends who are very sharp at coding for Windows who haven’t near the ability for OSX if at all… and funny thing is, they all have the same attitude, why target OSX when there are more Windows machines available to hijack?

  16. I agree. MDN, your takes sucks. If 90%+ of the world used an OS worth hacking into, they would be doing it to whatever it is.

    So as you cheer for increased market share, cheer for increased hacking and viruses as well…

  17. not to be the party popper here, but I have been looking into this all day now, and there seems to be no proof yet that windows had any part in the break in. They are just not releasing the data. The only ones saying it is a windows hole are pundits, and they have yet to show any facts.

    Don’t get me wrong, building a “secure” system on windows is an oxymoron, but it might yet turn out that they got in another way.

    Kinda like when the cops show up after a break in and note that the doors where not locked. OK, but the crooks may have not known, and instead come in the open window……

  18. I wonder if Apple would be willing to license OSX for atms?

    Not likely, and there’s not much point to it. Anyone who wants to write a secure ATM application has any number of decent choices, from vendors who specialize in embedded operating systems.

    Basing an ATM on windows is sheer laziness.

    -jcr

  19. The ‘increased marketshare means you’ll get picked on, too!’ mantra isn’t actually true. The reason being that OS X is built from the ground up with security in mind, whereas Windows is a patchwork of ‘good enough’ fixes. The other factor? Only the user can explicitly authorize changes on an OS X system, and possibly won’t even have the permission to alter the system root itself.

    On Windows, going by my experience on XP, routinely altered the system whether installing software, or downloading stuff from the ‘Net. Windows allowed anyone open door access into my computer, even with the supposedly firewall features and what have you working!

    Why yes, sure, there will be hackers who try to break into OS X if only for the challenge, but they actually have to hoodwink the USER first! And yes I know AirPort and Safari, and even Quicktime have been ‘broken into’ – but, none of those hacks altered the registry, or even took control of the system.

    And not only that, but barely days after those exploits? Apple patched them up!

  20. There goes a few more morons spouting off about the market share myth again. Hackers target Windows because its easy. Criminals are lazy. They go after the low hanging fruit, and that fruit is not Apple. As long as there are profitable ways to exploit Windows, why bother with trying to hack Unix-based Mac OS X.

    Even if Apple’s OS market share grew to 50%, hackers will still target Windows. BECAUSE WINDOWS IS EASY and MAC OS X IS HARD

  21. Andy sez: “… And yes I know AirPort and Safari, and even Quicktime have been ‘broken into’ – but, none of those hacks altered the registry, or even took control of the system.”

    Indeed. But one correction: Mac OS X does not have, in fact no version of UNIX has, a ‘registry’. That bad idea is entirely Microsoft’s responsibility.

    My very favorite quote from Bill Gates is:

    “Nowadays, security guys break the Mac every single day. Every single day, they come out with a total exploit, your machine can be taken over totally. I dare anybody to do that once a month on the Windows machine.”
    — Bill Gates talking to NewsWeek magazine January 2007

    In fact the exact opposite is the case. No Mac has ever been zombied. (Please don’t bother quoting lies to the contrary). Meanwhile Windows boxes are zombied hundreds if not thousands of times a day. What wacky thing will Big Brother Bill say next?! Thus Bill Gates is retiring.

    Nonetheless there have been plenty of vulnerabilities found in Mac OS X and related technologies. The most insecure Apple technology has turned out to be QuickTime. But Apple have been diligent repairing it.

    There are yearly attempts to crack Macs as well as PCs at various white and black hat meetings and conventions. The Mac has been broken into twice at such events. But never was it possible to take over the operating system. And both successful break-ins required the ASSISTANCE of someone with a user account on the Mac. These break-ins were of course not credible indictments of Mac security. One unconfirmed other break-in occurred, or so the tale is told, using a third party WiFi card with drivers installed in a PCMCIA slot on a Mac OS X PowerBook. Controversy remains as to whether this actually happened. But the general consensus is that it did; however, the security fault is blamed on the third party software driver. Nonetheless, security vulnerabilities were found and patched in Apple’s own Airport driver. Again, no take over of the Mac was found to be possible.

  22. macbones sez: “I wonder if Apple would be willing to license OSX for atms?”

    It is certainly possible. But Darwin, the CLI core of Mac OS X, is Open Source. Anyone can use it for free in any computer device. It is hardware platform independent with relatively minor tweaks to the OS kernel. You have to DIY the GUI however. Apple won’t ever by licensing that. (And this is not the make fruitless arguments to the contrary).

    The most secure operating systems available are well known to be OpenBSD and FreeBSD (upon which Darwin and Mac OS X are based). They are also Open Source and have free GUIs available.

    But these days there has been a lot more experience using Linux for such purposes, and it also has free GUIs. Linux has a very good security record. (No, not better than BSD UNIX, including Mac OS X. Sorry).

  23. Lecture ahead. Run for cover.

    “Security By Obscurity” is a theory that has some merit, obviously. If you have a lower market share then your product is a smaller target, so why bother.

    HOWEVER, this theory has been outrageously exaggerated relative to Mac OS X to the point of utter hilarity. I only laugh these days at the poor fools who attempt it. Blasting it to smithereens is so incredibly easy. I used to perform for the clowns with irrefutable math that showed if you even include all the Proof of Concept malware for Mac OS X as well as all the old Mac OS malware known to exist that you would find there is well over 150x more malware on a per user basis for Windows than for Mac. But why bother? Here is the mickey mouse version anyone can understand, if they dare:

    Have you passed third grade math? Good. Then try this:

    1) Count up the number of in-the-wild malware known to exist for Mac OS X. That would be one, as in 1, as in the loneliest number that you ever heard, etc. (No, all the others were all Proof of Concept malware folks. You can’t catch them. You can’t even dig around for them on the net. Only the professional malware investigators have them. OK? So settle down).

    2) Count up the number of in-the-wild malware known to exist for Windows. These days there is never any consensus because the number is beyond human comprehension. Apple had an ad years ago that said there were 114,000. That was very conservative then, and is incredibly conservative now.

    3) Divide the number of Windows malware by the number of Mac OS X malware. That’s 114,000, to be incredibly conservative, divided by 1.

    4) What you get is the ratio of malware for Windows versus malware for Mac OS X. That number in our example is 114,000 to 1.

    If you want, you can go on to calculate your own ratio of the number of malware for each platform on a per user basis. Being conservative, Macs currently have 3-4% of the entire computer user base in the world. (Note this does not equal the current sales market share, which is around 12-14% depending upon who collected the data). Windows boxes these days have maybe 92% of the computer user base. Go do the rest of the math yourself.

    But do you care? No. What you get is yet another whopping huge number of malware, per computer user, for Windows versus Mac OS X.

    Thus, no matter which way you count, no matter what obfuscation you use to hide the facts, Windows has a shockingly higher number of malware, per computer user, than Mac. If in fact, the Security By Obscurity myth were true, you should get a ratio drastically closer to 1:1 malware on a per user basis.

    Why is there so much more malware for Windows? I used to wonder. But these days I blame it on:
    (1) Sheer security incompetence at Microsoft
    (2) A viciously high rate of hatred toward Microsoft and Windows by its users to the point where they delight in finding ways to break them. This is called sadism. Meanwhile, I personally consider people who voluntarily use Windows, knowing its faults, to be masochists. This is not a healthy picture.

    And Mac users? They’re too happy and productive to bother even attempting to write malware. And yes folks, some of the most brilliant coders on the planet write for Mac. They are just as capable as Windows coders at creating malware. So forget about that lame argument. Only professional and high brow computer security experts in the Mac community have made any effort to write Mac malware. And in each case, apart from the writer of the ‘Porno Trojan’ for Mac OS X, their malware was only written to prove a vulnerability, not to exploit it. Their malware was never malicious and never released into the wild. None of it in fact, including the ‘Porno Trojan’, is even capable of self-replication in the wild.

    Are you getting the clue yet? Nice, intelligent Mac users using a secure OS. Vicious and spiteful Windows users using the OS renowned for decades for its dangerous security holes. Hmm.

    Security By Obscurity?
    HAHAHAHA!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.