Is AT&T charging separately for iPhone 3G SMS a mistake?

“So Apple called today, a little annoyed with my portrayal yesterday of AT&T’s iPhone pricing. The main difference on plans for the new iPhone versus the old are simple: The data plan is $10 more a month, mainly because the faster connection will mean higher data usage; And text messaging is charged separately,” Arik Hesseldahl blogs BusinessWeek.

“First there’s the data. IPhone users are traditionally heavy data users — mainly because of the iPhone’s excellent Web browser, no argument there. Faster pipes will mean even heavier usage, the thinking goes, and I’m inclined to agree on that point. AT&T spent a lot of money to build out its 3G network, and is entitled to make it back,” Hesseldahl writes.

“The other main difference this time around is that SMS text messaging has been pulled out as a separate billing item,” Hesseldahl writes. “Is this a mistake on AT&Ts part? I certainly think so. Charging fees for text messaging outside the usual data charges will only drive users to use instant messaging. There’s little doubt in my mind that Apple will bring an iChat client to the iPhone, hopefully sooner rather than later, and AOL has already demonstrated an instant messaging client that should debut soon. Plus there are other options, including Beejive’s Web-based application. Dear AT&T: This is a dumb idea, okay?

More in the full article here.

56 Comments

  1. “Is AT&T;charging separately for iPhone 3G SMS a mistake?”

    YES.

    Add on top of that the inability (still) to send picture messages.

    I really wish AT&T;/Apple would give people the option of activating 3G and then having the option to pay for it. There is no 3G service where I live or work and therefore NO sense in paying for something I’ll never use.

    The above reasons are why I will not buy an iPhone. Surely I’m not the only one who thinks along these lines.

  2. They did some research in the UK and its cheaper to get data from the Hubbell space telescope than to the same in SMS. The phone companies make an absolute fortune from ripping us off.

    Here’s hoping the EU commissioner screws them over again as she did for roaming rates.

  3. This is no different than if you had a Blackberry instead of the iPhone. We got spoiled with the “original” iPhone and the plan pricing. We need to just deal with the idea that AT&T;is going to treat this just like any other “smart” phone, and realize our “smart” phone is truly smart.

  4. Many have suggested that it’s not fair for AT&T to charge for 3G where coverage doesn’t exist. However, there’s no way for AT&T to prevent abuse here. Mobile phones are, well, mobile. You may live outside of 3G coverage, but work within a covered zone. You may, in your daily routine, frequently enter the zone and connect to 3G network. As there is no way for AT&T to configure their networks and phones to check/authenticate based on the account status, your phone will automatically connect to 3G wherever there is a signal, unless you turn off that 3G radio yourself.

    As for SMS special charge, that’s just a rip-off. There is absolutely no justification for this change.

  5. I swear, ATT is going to be the death of the iPhone in America if they keep this nickel and dime-ing crap . . .

    ATT has this HUGE opportunity to take more market share from Verizon, Sprint, T-Mobile, etc., but if they don’t have attractive plans, people are going to shy away . . .

    Apple needs to take more control over the issue, be an MVNO . . .

    Please refresh the iPod touch soon . . . please!!!

  6. MDN:

    The html ‘feature’ in your comments submission field that turns out AT&T into AT&T;is getting a bit tiresome. We seem to be discussing AT&T a lot these days and that semicolon messes it up. Is there any chance this could somehow be fixed (for example, exclude all html escape characters that begin with ‘&’)?

    As for other contributors here, if you wish to enter AT&T without that trailing semicolon, you may copy and paste this into your text:

    AT&T

    Let’s see if this comes out the way it’s supposed to…

  7. they fscking dont get it. People will pay a lot. No problem. But they want to nail down the cost. I said fscking nail it down. These chicken nickle and diming is sophomoric and plain dumb.

  8. @ M@c;

    Perhaps you should call AT&T;before you decide not to buy an iPhone. They have said before now that if the 3G network is NOT available in your billing zip code, you will NOT be billed the $30, but will be charged only for the EDGE that is available where you are.

  9. re: rahrens –

    I could see how this might lead to a lot of potential abuse; find a relative or a friend who lives not far from you, but is out of 3G coverage, sign up with that home address, get that $30 down to $20 and take your phone anywhere. I have a hard time believing that AT&T would actually make this kind of exception. Let’s see…

  10. More than 7 billion SMS a day and counting.

    Until they are picked up, somebody has to store them. So until storage is free, I would gather that if you like to text message, you have to help pay for it.

  11. Yes, if AT&T;insists on continuing to charge for text messages it must give us a way to BLOCK all incoming messages with an auto reply to the sender stating as such. charging 20¢ for something that actually costs the company $0.0001 per message should prove to create more bad-will toward the company than the greedy little profits that they might see…

    This reason, and this reason alone, lead me to yearn the day when AT&T;doesn’t have a monopoly on the iPhone in the US. Screw you AT&T;.

  12. The answer to the article’s title question: HELL YES!

    In fact, I, for one, will not be upgrading to a new iPhone precisely due to this crap extra $5/month charge. People text me (I rarely text back, but unfortunately ATT doesn’t give a crap if I have no control over getting text messages) so I’d have to pay the extra tariff for a few BYTES of data being sent over their lines.

    An absolute rip-off and I won’t be upgrading now. Thanks a bunch, you idiots: you lost a sale with that attitude.

  13. While i understand the need to charge more for 3G data for iPhone 2.0; the frustrating part is the small geographic footprint for the 3G network. Adding greater frustration – there are no more iPhone 1.0’s (at least new) to be had. So many will pay $10 more per month to use a network that they can only access when traveling into a 3G serviced area.

    Now toss a slap on the face with the text messaging BS. Last month, I sent 43 text messages – between my wife and work. I didn’t come near 200 SMS messages. I mostly use SMS between other iPhone users – oddly enough.

    The change to SMS pricing will have me sitting on the sidelines a little longer. (1) No access to 3G in my area, and (2) no included SMS messages = $15 more for less.

    Oh, and now the inconvenience of having to step into an AT & T store for activation. I have a hard time believing that this launch will be as successful as last years. Apple is selling it’s soul for this sole provider contract between it and AT & T.

  14. For those of you who don’t understand the frustration of people who don’t live in a 3G serviced area… look at a 3G service map. Living in the midwest… there are population centers, significant ones at that – where one would need to travel 2 to 6 hours by car to access a 3g network.

    There should be a software switch or setting available at activation that can either enable or disable the 3G antennae,

    Maybe Apple should have kept 2 different models (beyond memory) available for consumers.

  15. The network effect of one hundred text messages is negligible to the extreme compared with a 30 second phone call or one view of a Facebook page.

    All text messaging (sending and receiving) should therefore be free even internationally, but set data limits (if you must).

  16. Predrag –

    Of course they could deny 3G service to people who aren’t paying for it. Separate network, and your device/PIN is either authorized or not authorized to use it. The same way it determines whether you can make a phone call or use data in the first place, silly.

    Agreed, 3G (and the accompanying price) should be an account option.

    SMS isn’t going anywhere until you stop wanting to communicate with non-iPhone people.

  17. Does anyone know the contact emails/phone numbers for AT&T;and Apple? I’m pissed at this SMS silliness (a bit annoyed at paying for 3G too when the closest is 4+ hours away) and I’d love for the vocal Apple crowd to turn their wrath on these two companies and in the hope that they’ll pull their head out and at least put the SMS back into the plans. I’d also like a 200 SMS minutes option on the Family plan. Only having the $30 option is too restrictive. I want to get an iPhone, but they’ve priced it so high that I can’t afford the ridiculous monthly payments. Anyone who can provide email or phone numbers to reach these companies would be my hero right now.

  18. @3Gnetwork,

    Since the iPhone 3G will automatically search for Wifi, then 3G, then EDGE, why would you need to switch 3G off, unless you were trying to save battery life? If you are in a car, can’t you get yourself a $10 iPod car charger, and not have to worry about battery life?

  19. @thethirdshoe

    AT&T;price plan for the iPhone is not different that what all the other carriers charge for their premium cell phone/services. In fact, it is cheaper in some cases, particularly when you consider what you can do, will be able to do in the near future and how easy it is to do it.

    Amazing how many dumped Apple because 3G was taking too long. Did everybody expect that the new highway was going for nothing?

    Considering that the top Nokia’s retail for over $700 dollars a piece, getting an iPhone at a third to half the price seems like one hell of a bargain.

    Some interesting facts:

    Over 7 billion text messages a day now.

    In the third quarter of 2007, AT&T;customers sent 24 billion text messages.

    Verizon had nearly 45 billion text messages exchanged during the fourth quarter of 2007, which is 250% more than for the same quarter the year before. Verizon had almost a billion picture and video messages transferred in the fourth quarter of 2007, more than double the amount of that period in 2006. And they don’t have the iPhone.

    Note that the carriers will store text messages up to a couple of weeks. And if the usage continues at the current growth rate, which is probably understated, storage costs, maintenance, service and security are going to be astronomical.

    Sure, other carriers are waiting with bated breathe to get the iPhone. But don’t expect it will be any cheaper.

  20. @jtc

    Boy, ignorance is bliss.

    Text messages are stored by the carriers until they are picked up.

    To the question, “But how long are text messages stored by phone companies?

    Sprint typically can retrieve text messages within a 14-day window in the event a phone is turned off or otherwise unavailable,” Dave DeVries, Sprint spokesperson, said.

    “Text messages are stored…for up to 72 hours until delivery to the wireless device is successful,” Meghan Roskopf, AT&T;media contact, said.

    “If the message cannot be delivered, the text message is removed from our system and cannot be accessed or retrieved,” Roskopf added.

  21. With SMS size limited to 160 characters, even at 24 billion messages per quarter, storage should be somewhat trivial for an enterprise the size of AT&T;. The majority of those messages will be delivered immediately rather than being stored for future delivery.

  22. If i’m doing the maths right:

    SMS has a maximum per message of 160 7-bit characters, so 160 * 7 = 1120 bits per message, divide by 8 to get bytes = 140bytes per SMS message. Maybe there’s overhead (sender, recipient, other bits) and maybe everyone doesn’t use the full message length, so figure it’s may in reality be a little bit larger/smaller per SMS message.

    A gigabyte of storage is around 1 billion bytes, depending on the definition of gigabyte you are using. So if we divide that 1 billion bytes by 140 bytes per message, we get something around 7 million SMSs stored per gigabyte. Pretty sure even desktop-class storage could handle this.

    So, I’m pretty sure we’re not paying for their SMS message storage costs. Infrastructure, maybe… somewhat…

  23. DanielM, defending 20 cents a SMS from the storage angle is laughable. It’s obvious you have no clue how much space a SMS takes up or how cheap storage is. 24 billion, ooohhh, such a big number. 1 terabyte drives go for under $200 now. 1 terabyte is 1,000,000,000,000 bytes. Do I need to keep doing the math for you, or can you figure out how idiotic your argument is now?

    I love my iPhone and I’ll upgrade to 3G as soon as it’s out, but your blind fanboy defense of a moronic ploy to milk consumers of their money is just way over the top.

  24. For further fun, by rough estimates (rounding off a lot), 1 gigabyte is about 426 copies of Tolstoy’s War and Peace (thats a lot of SMS).
    (That’s rounding off +rough math + using the project gutenberg plaintext of War & Peace.)

  25. This thread amazes me. Everyone bitching about AT&T;charging 0.20/SMS (without some kind of text messaging plan).

    This is nothing new. If you didn’t have a text messaging plan for any phone, you paid through the nose for texting. In the very recent past you couldn’t get an unlimited texting plan, which is why so many parents wound up with $500 phone bills from their teenager’s texting habits.

    AT&T;is in the business of making money, and the way you make money is you charge for services people want. Supply and demand. Texting is in demand, so AT&T;wants to charge for it.

    Also, the costs to AT&T;are not simply the storage costs of the messages. AT&T;(and any other carrier) has to pay for their network one way or the other, has to pay for routing your SMS from the sender to you, has to pay for air time or using another carrier’s towers if you’re roaming, customer service support, etc.

    If you don’t like the plan, feel free to let AT&T;know about your dislike and don’t buy an iPhone. But to think that you were going to get everything cheap is silly.

  26. Yeah. AT&T;is nickel & diming folks, in typical phone company fashion.

    This is what happens when Apple lets them run the show in exchange for huge up-front subsidies. Frankly, I liked it better when you paid Apple what the phone was worth, and AT&T;basically sat down and shut up.

  27. Since my specialty is statistical inference, I don’t know if 20 cents is enough, too much or extremely usury. My position was to point out, not only the absolute number of text messages being generated, but the significant growth that is now being observed.

    More important to the space needed of such, is the cost of maintaining such, transferring such, securing such and track such.

    (I did error though, the 7 billion SMS a day was in reference to the state measured over 6 months ago. Current estimates could well be over twice that number.)

    Obvious to a carrier, picking up a phone and calling somebody is a lot less encumbering on them than taking a message and holding it under guard until it is picked up.

    It should be noted that text messaging was NEVER free. Unfortunately, it was never fully described or tabled either. Its low usage didn’t require it. It wasn’t an issue until now that the explosive use of SMS has brought it to the forefront, both for the carrier that has to supply and service it, as well as the user who wants to make use of it.

    Now the following can only be surmised. It is no doubt a fact that AT&T;’s sudden rise in SMS usage is in part due to iPhone. If true, the current third to half a billion a day that AT&T;is approaching was never projected. Now one can only imagine what the effect of the new iPhone will have on the usage and thus the services that will be required to handle it in the near future.

    But it really doesn’t matter. Whatever the cost is, the user, by choice, will have to pick up the tab. Like every other company, cell carriers survive by charging enough to cover costs, investing enough to survive in the future and adding enough to make a profit. Otherwise you have a great vehicle and no road to drive it on.

    Altruism is not part of a stockholder’s vocabulary.

    P.S. Equally important to appreciate; it is not the size of the message, but the frequency going out and in. So lets face it. You are going to get screwed one way or another.

  28. Current iPhone plans are all “unlimited data”, but are differentiated by the number of text messages included: $20 for unlimited data + 200 txts, $30 for unlimited data + 1500 txts, and $40 for unlimited data with unlimited txts. So, even though there is unlimited data, and even though txt messaging is included, it can be thought of as split into 3 cost plans. So whether there is an increase in price depends on what the monthly value or charge for unlimited data on the EDGE network. If you think it is $15, then there is really not change in the cost for text messaging. If you think EDGE was $20 a month, then, sure, you will be paying $5 a month extra for an equivalent text messaging plan.

    The new thing here is that no text messages are included in the baseline plan. But it is not clear whether or not you are actually paying more for month for an equivalent text messaging plan.

  29. Also, the article claim:

    “One other thing that’s different, and actually better: AT&T;is waiving the fees associated with upgrading from an old iPhone to a new one. If you have a first-generation iPhone and still have 23 months to go on your existing contract, you don’t have to pay the usual fees associated with the upgrade. That is better, and I’m told that this is the first time that AT&T;has ever done something like this.”

    This is at odds with the AT&T;website, which says:
    What will I pay for iPhone 3G?
    “If you are upgrade ELIGIBLE and your account is in good standing, you will pay $199 for 8GB (black) and $299 for 16GB (black or white). Two-year contract required.

    You have the option to purchase an early upgrade priced at $399 for 8GB (black) or $499 for 16GB (black or white). Two-year contract required. Coming soon, AT&T;will offer a no-commitment option of $599 for 8GB and $699 for 16GB.

    Check upgrade eligibility

    Will I pay an upgrade fee?
    Yes. You will pay an $18 upgrade fee.”

  30. I’m somewhat confused on this issue?

    If you live in an area where 3G service isn’t available, will you be able to have the downgraded $20.00 EDGE-only data plan or still have to pay $30.00 a month?

    I’m thinking that they could bypass abuse of this issue (purchasing an iPhone in an non-3G zipcode and then using it in a 3G area) by deactivating 3G capabilities to your wireless account whether that’s done over the network or by a special software block on your iPhone from initial activation.

  31. @DanielM…

    Sorry… you are wrong. SMS charges have nothing to do with being able to “survive by charging enough to cover costs, investing enough to survive in the future and adding enough to make a profit.”

    SMS charges, after all infrastructure and communication charges are estimated to be 90-95% profit.

    It is calculated to be the most expensive bandwidth on the planet.

    It utilizes the control channel that mobile phones have with the tower. This is the same channel that the phone listens for calls on. It is a very lightweight always on network connection with the tower. It sends 140kb bursts a couple of times checking for calls.

    An SMS merely adds a minimal amount of extra noise over this signal… which means that essentially, infrastructure wise, SMS is more or less free for these companies. There is no connection penalty, very little in the way of bandwidth penalty and essentially no storage issues… as most messages are delivered more or less instantaneously.

    Besides… even if every message was stored, it’s not a problem with affordability.

    It’s a major source of revenue and a huge cash cow.

    Prices are out of whack. I can see full emails perhaps costing 10 cents a piece… but SMS shouldn’t be any more than a penny per message. This is the cost of one of these messages in Japan. 1yen.

  32. I agree with you. The extra 15 was a deal breaker for me. Had the left the 200 sms as included I could see the extra $10 but I’m not bending over twice. AT@T should be happy to unlock your 1st gen when you upgrade to the 3G but instead told us to f** yourselves basically. Which I why I won’t be upgrading to 2.0 until I know it can be unlocked. The whole iphone experience has really tarnished my once pristine view of apple in my eyes. I’m sad to say it.

  33. I’ll stick with my first gen for the foreseeable future; why pay for a phone to get ripped off texting ? Is 3G really that necessary to me ? I think not. So what if I have to wait a few more seconds for a page to load ? And I have GPS in my car, so I don’t need it on my phone.

  34. Lots of people don’t know it yet, including AT&T;.

    I’ve used SMS about 4 times since I got my iPhone. Email is better for longer messages and attachments, and chatting is better (free) for everything else. It’s baffling that the cell carriers think that SMS is worth a premium.

  35. If I want something to disappear, I tax it or raise the price. Perhaps SMS is the red-headed step-child in AT&T;that they’re trying to ship off to Aunt Peterson’s?

    No offense, red-headed step-children. Love ya’, mean it.

  36. SMS?
    Pictures in SMS?

    Let’s see-I have mobile broadband and a connection to the internet.
    Now if someone would only build some kind of intertube webby thing where I could upload pictures to a publicly viewable thingy or engage in real time back and forth conversation through typing.

    Quick-someone invent flickr and AIM.

  37. The inclusion of SMS but exclusion of IM is the primary reason I did not buy the first iPhone. I don’t “text” but I do IM. I will be waiting for the App Store to have an IM client (Google Talk preferrably, AIM second) before I buy an iPhone. Even my stupid, idiotic, crappy Crackberry has both Google Talk and AIM.

    And if they come out with IM, i’m still not going to do any “texting” and won’t be paying $5/month. Previously, I would’ve considered trying it out since 200 messages a month were included, but I certainly will not now.

    I hope Arik Hesseldahl (from the article) continues to press the point.

  38. It sounds like you guys are getting a real bum deal over there. Over here on o2 we get unlimited free data on the iPhone packages and we also get “the cloud” free which is a network of wi-fi hotspots in public places around the UK. On top of that I get 600 minutes and 500 texts per month for £35 ($70) which is pretty good. Unless you tell me that your calls are loads cheaper than that.

    I think they hit us hard on roaming when abroad though. Not been away since I got my iPhone but I’ll take a look at the roaming tariffs when I do.

    Good luck with getting AT&T;to change their pricing policies.
    ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

  39. The reason I went with Sprint Instinct Touch screen phone is because UNLIMITED Text messaging is included. So with 2 lines, it saves a ton of money over EXPENSIVE AT&T;ripoff plan.

    Think about it, text messages take tiny amount of data but AT&T;charges enormous amount of money for them because they can!

    No they can’t. Go with Sprint Instinct.

    You also get UNLIMITED TV channels (live and on-demand) and Radio and turn-by-turn voice GPS Navigation with real street names announced. And it also has a camcorder that iPhone 3G doesn’t! The browser on iPhone is better however.

    But over $30 per month EXTRA for text messaging for 2 lines on AT&T;? That’s a ripoff right there! Not for me! And I can get my work push-email (Outlook/Exchange) for FREE with Sprint. Apple would charge $100 per year for the service. Those fees add-up quickly with iPhone 3G!

    Bottom Line:
    ——————-
    iPhone 3G = Great but AT&T;= Rip-off

    So I got me 2 Sprint Instinct phones. They are pretty good and very close to iPhone!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.