Apple locks forum discussion thread regarding iMac display issues

“Apple Support has locked a discussion thread about newly purchased iMacs exhibiting symptoms of problematic displays in what Tom’s Hardware is calling an act of censorship,” MacNN reports.

“The topic, titled ‘Bought new iMac 20″ Faded Screen,’ began on August 7th — the first day the new iMacs went on sale — and quickly became the primary place for new iMac owners to discuss their troubles of 20-inch and some 24-inch iMacs,” MacNN reports. “The discussion saw a slew of traffic in its early stages, which later soared to an average of 429 hits per day until Apple locked the topic to prevent further posts, according to the report.”

“From August 7th to November 18th the thread accrued more than 15,000 hits for an average of roughly 158 hits per day. That number rocketed up to 9,000 hits in just 21 days before Apple closed the thread,” MacNN reports. “What’s more, new posts about the gradient color issue in new iMacs are disappearing, with error messages taking their place in the forums. Apple has yet to reply to any of the posts regarding the issue in its Intel-based iMac Display support forum, and has not acknowledged the existence of any issue.”

Links included in MacNN’s article here.

98 Comments

  1. Petey,
    I just realized that my new eyeglasses are glossy. Does this mean I will be blind as a bat real soon? And what would happen if I used a glossy iMac wearing my glossy glasses? Would one negate the other and make it all good? Or would it multiply the effect and like “blow my head cleeean off”? Go ahead, make my day.

  2. I’m actually surprised MDN posted this. Where is their take? “There is no way this could be true. Apple always uses superior hardware. These users are all on drugs. Good for Apple for closing down the forum. Screw the complainers. If you don’t like Apple products–don’t buy them! And if you do buy them, don’t tell the truth about your experiences.”

    Just seems like MDN will excuse absolutely anything does.

  3. No offense guys, but bad hardware happens to ALL tech companies. There’s nothing new here, stop thinking Apple is the new Microsoft.

    BTW if Apple closed the thread, they at least know of the problem. Steve, give ’em a rebate or something..

  4. >>Any comments on the quality of the Apple Cinema Displays? More specifically the 30″ one. I’m feeling a gift from Mrs. Santa happening soon.

    The Apple Cinema Displays use S-IPS technology (I believe the panels themselves are actually made my LG Phillips) and have for a few years now. You take a little hit on response time and contrast ratio/brightness, but the color fidelity is much MUCH better. Specs such as contrast ratio/brightness can be misleading as some manufacturers like to pump up their numbers (like not giving a true ANSI reading, or using dynamic contrast ratio numbers). AFAIK S-IPS and S-PVA displays are the best in terms of true color fidelity.

    I have heard that the 24″ iMac uses an S-IPS display, but I can’t confirm that. Someone would have to disassemble one and get the part number off the the panel itself.

  5. Apple has a weird hang up regarding Hardware issues. As I’ve said here and on the Apple site (and have been censored at both places) they have a BIG issue with the Mac Mini Optical drives.

    It’s fixable (most people believe it’s a frimware issue) but it’s been two years and they still haven’t done anything about it.

    It’s strange, I’ve been a Mac user since the mid 80s and really…this is the first time I’ve seen Apple ignore such a big issue for so long.

  6. I just realized that my new eyeglasses are glossy. Does this mean I will be blind as a bat real soon? And what would happen if I used a glossy iMac wearing my glossy glasses? Would one negate the other and make it all good?

    Actually if the interior of the glasses are glossy it can cause reflections into the eye if light can get in from the sides. But this is minor.

    Staring into a 24″ mirror wouldn’t be a problem, because it reflects all the light, giving the eyes one clear image.

    Staring into a 24″ glossy iMac causes eyestrain because there are two or more images, the screen image and the slightly out of focus reflections…

    Now you know why it’s a major health concern.

  7. Hoy Chow,

    I can understand peoples concern if a glossy monitor is used in an environment where any reflections cannot be eliminated, possibly such as a company setting with the ceiling covered in fluorescent tubes. In that case a non-reflective type would of course be preferable since even CRTs can be hard to use.
    But not all circumstances fit that description. I have a 19″ glossy LCD that is used in a typical home setting that only has any visible reflections when it is turned off. When used it creates no more eyestrain than my matte screened LCD.
    That being said, I do believe that we should have a choice, but it seems most manufacturers want glossy widescreens. I think if Apple had gone with all matte on the MacBook there would a lot less dissent than with the all glossy.
    I can’t help but think that they have a different motive for covering the iMac screen with a glass pane. They probably could have used a shiny coating more cheaply than glass. Is it just to protect the screen from a four year old with a crayon?
    Or is it a way to prepare for a touch screen? It doesn’t seem like it would be that hard for them to do. I don’t know why it would be needed or wanted, but Apple is pretty forward thinking. I guess we will see.
    Of course, with Macs being sold at other retailers such as Best Buy alongside other brands, it could possibly be at a visual disadvantage having a matte screen compared to a glossy. At least from the aspect of more vivid colors; it would depend on the setting. Kind of like how the TV makers have the brightness cranked up and the colors skewed to stand out.
    Anyway, I think Apple and all others should make their products with safety, comfort and usability first and foremost. It just makes sense.

  8. Another thought is:

    What if Apple made the iMac so you could use it like a Wacom tablet to draw on. It would have to be able to orient in a comfortable position to use; possibly a removable screen section. Could they make that part wireless? Along with touch functions, that could be fun to use. Just a thought. I sure wish I was privy to the ideas floating around Apple’s think tank.

  9. Rumors,

    That’s pretty funny. You might be a Winturd, but you’re a funny one.
    But I gotta admit, for the money, Dell does sell some decent monitors. I use them at work and would possibly buy one. Sounds like utter blasphemy, eh?

  10. I was recently called to check out a 24″ iMac aluminium which the owner said had “water” inside the screen. Of course it was just that condensation issue some of the brand-new 24″ iMacs have been having when first used out of the box. Lots of people have been writing about it on the Apple forums. So what? Just turn the machine on, set it to playing Chess with itself on advanced setting, let it get hot and get the fans going, whatever, the condensation will be gone before the day is done, never to return.

    I am not saying this screen quality brouhaha over on the forums is baseless, but as others above have said, if it’s a problem, send the machine in on AppleCare; they’ve all got one year of AC.

    Whenever I buy 1st gen Macs from Apple, I also always get the extended AC at the end of the first year, just to be safe. These 20″ owners should do the same.

  11. Hello dear customers: THIS IS A TRADING COMPANY DIAMOND ELECTRONICS LTD,WE HAVE BEEN TRADING ELECTRONICS ONLINE WORLDWIDE SINCE 1999…WE SELL PLASMA TV,DIGITAL CAMERAS,PROJECTORS,PLAY STATIONS,LAPTOPS,MOBILE PHONES AND IPODS,FOR MORE INFORMATION OR ENQUIERY,CONTACT US AT

    diamond_electronics_1@hotmail.com

    Apple iphones

    Apple iphone 4gb…$200usd
    Apple iphone 8gb…$300usd
    Apple iphone 16GB..$450usd

    NOKIA PHONES

    Nokia n97 ..$400usd
    Nokia n95 8gb..$350usd
    Nokia n95 …..$310usd
    Nokia n93 …..$250usd
    Nokia n93i…..$270usd
    Nokia n92 …..$220usd
    Nokia n91 …..$210usd
    Nokia n90 …..$200usd
    Nokia n80 …..$200usd
    Nokia n83 …..$225usd
    Nokia n77 …..$230usd
    Nokia n73 …..$220usd
    Nokia n71 for $200usd
    Nokia 8800 for $200usd
    Nokia sirocco Gold for $250usd
    Nokia 9300 for $190usd

    MOTOROLA PHONES

    Motorola v3 …$150usd
    Motorola v3i…$200usd
    Motorola v3x…$245usd

    SONY ERICSSON PHONES

    Sony ericsson w888i $250usd
    Sony ericsson w600i $145usd
    Sony ericsson w950i $260usd
    Sony ericsson w900i $180usd
    Sony ericcson p990i $180usd
    Sony ericsson p900i $160usd
    Sony ericsson p800i $170usd

    HTC PHONES

    HTC Advantage X7500 $300usd
    HTC P4350 for $250usd
    HTC TyTN for $200usd
    HTC P3300 for $210usd

    TOM TOMS

    TOM TOM GO 500. $170usd
    TOM TOM GO 910.$280usd
    TOM TOM GO 300..$200usd

    02 XDA

    02 xDA Exec-$280usd
    02 XDA Atom-$230usd
    02 XDA mini S- $250usd
    02 XDA II mini-$220usd

    I-MATE PHONES

    i-mate Ultimate 9150 for $280usd
    i-mate Ultimate 8150 for $260usd
    i-mate Ultimate 5150 for $200usd

    i-mate JASJAM for $230usd
    i-mate JASJAR for $200usd
    i-mate PDAL for $240usd

    ETEN PHONES

    ETEN glofiish M700 $300usd
    ETEN G500 for …..$200usd
    ETEN G550+ for ….$210usd
    ETEN M600+ for ….$230usd

    SIDE KICKS PHONES

    Sick kick for $150usd
    Side kick 2 for $160usd
    Side kick 3 for $200usd

    PALM TREO PHONES

    Treo 680 for $200usd
    Treo 600 for $160usd
    Treo 750 for $250usd

    SAMSUNG PHONES

    Samsung U300 $190usd
    Samsung U600 $200usd
    Samsung U700 $250usd
    Samsung p110 $240usd
    Samsung Z540 $250usd

    BLACK BERRY PHONES

    blackberry 8700c $200usd
    blackberry 8700r $200usd
    blackberry 7290 $210usd
    blackberry 8700f $230usd

    LAPTOPS

    SONY VAIO B100B08 60GB $350usd
    SONY VAIO B100B08 60GB $500usd
    SONY VAIO FS295VP 80GB $450usd
    SONY VAIO FS215Z 100GB $450usd
    SONY VAIO A217S? 100GB $400usd

    PLAYSTATION GAMES

    play station I…………..$85usd
    play station II………….$140usd
    play station III…………$250usd

    XBOX GAMES

    Xbox 360 ……………….$250usd
    Xbox 360 Platinum System….$200usd

    VIDEO GAMES

    SONY PSP GAMES
    Sony PSP Tony Hawk’s Underground 2 Remix ValuePack $200usd
    Sony PSP Limited Edition(White) 20 Games+Car Kit Etc $250usd
    Sony PSP Super Pack” – 5 Games With ExtraAccessories$190usd
    Spider Man Movie, UMD Sampler $160usd $200usd

    LAPTOPS

    SONY VAIO B100B08 60GB $350usd
    SONY VAIO B100B08 60GB $500usd
    SONY VAIO FS295VP 80GB $450usd
    SONY VAIO T370P/L 60GB $330usd
    SONY VAIO A215Z 60GB $550usd
    SONY VAIO A397XP? 80GB $400usd

    CAMCORDERS AND CAMERAS

    Canon EOS 400D + kit lens 18-55mm f/4.5-5.6 ……..$520usd
    Canon EF 28-135mm f/3.5-5.6 IS USM (lens) ……….$600usd
    EIKI LC-XT3 XGA THEATER PROJECTOR 10,000 lumens….$2500us
    Canon EOS-5D (Body Only), 12.8 Megapixel, SLR, Digital Camera -$2000
    Canon EOS-1DS Mark III, Megapixel SLR Digital Camera–$1600
    Canon EOS-1DS Mark II, 16.7 Megapixel SLR Digital Camera–$1300

    DIAMOND ELECTRONICS LTD.

    Email–
    diamond_electronics_1@hotmail.com

    customers care service line– +447045752568

    We ship to your doorstep in 48 to 72 hours time and we make sure package gets to you very safe.
    We promise to sarve you better

  12. Kimselect Stores is a registered and legitimate company that offer the whole world access to buyer Electronic product at affordable prices. Our product are 1st factory condition with 2years factory waranty in brand new original box with complete accessories . We operate a 100% return policy guarantee . Our aim and objective is to make our customers a happy buyer. We allow 15% on the purchase of minimium order of 5units and 1 mobile phones free as you buy up to 5units . We sell in Unit and also sell in Bulk. Do contact us via email for more enquries.

    Email : kimselect@rediff.com

  13. Designed to lowest 3!.
    I am from South and too poorly know English, give true I wrote the following sentence: “Com offers you cheap airlines tickets where you can find best travel deals with heavy discount, buy discount air tickets in india.”

    Waiting for a reply :o, Nokomis.

  14. Good evening. Only dull people are brilliant at breakfast.
    I am from Saudi and learning to write in English, please tell me right I wrote the following sentence: “Cheap air flights low cost airline tickets ponta delgada cheap airline tickets round trip last minute airline tickets online cheap air flights jorhat.”

    Thank 😎 Joanna.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.