“Apple computers have long been prized for being relatively virus-free. But as more people use Apple products, experts say the company is increasingly becoming a target for cyber pranksters and criminals writing viruses and other forms of malware,” Steve Hargreaves reports for CNN.
“The threat was highlighted earlier this week after a handful of the company’s iPods were shipped with the RavMonE.exe virus,” Hargreaves reports.
“According to Apple, the virus affected less than 1 percent of the video iPods available for purchase after September 12, 2006,” Hargreaves reports. “The problem is thought to have originated in the manufacturing process by another company that builds iPods for Apple and isn’t believed to be a direct attack on the widely popular iPod itself.”
MacDailyNews Take: See what happens when the mainstream media gets a hold of something and tries to report upon things which they do not understand? The virus originated on a typically porous Windows computer and was mistakenly placed up a very small batch (under 25 incidents reported) of iPods. It only negatively affects Windows computers, but, come on now, what doesn’t affect Windows computers negatively?
Hargreaves continues, “Moreover, experts say the iPod isn’t likely to become a Petri dish for cyber germs, as it’s not directly connected to the Internet and is easily wiped clean and reloaded. But they do believe viruses targeting Apple’s Macintosh personal computers are increasing.”
“Oliver Friedrichs, director of security response at Symantec, a leading anti-virus software vendor, said 72 vulnerabilities were discovered in the Mac’s OS X operating system in 2006, up from 19 in 2004,” Hargreaves reports. “And Symantec identified six threats of malicious code written for the Mac OS X operating system in the first half of 2006, versus zero in the second half of 2005 and two the year before that.:
“‘It doesn’t mean more bugs are being introduced,’ Friedrichs said. ‘But it means attackers are increasingly looking at it,'” Hargreaves reports.
“Friedrichs said of the 13,000 virus threats Symantec sends out a month, maybe a dozen are related to the Mac, with the majority intended for Microsoft’s Windows platform,” Hargreaves reports. “One reason Apple has so far been shielded from nasty code is because its market share is relatively small,'” Hargreaves reports. “Apple accounted for 3.3 percent of total U.S. computer sales in 2004, and for 4.3 percent in 2005, according to technology research firm International Data Corporation.”
MacDailyNews Note: IDC pegged it at 5.8 percent for third quarter 2006 just this week. See a trend?
“Experts say these low numbers, and the unlikelihood that Apple’s share will ever account for much higher than the low double digits, is one reason why the Mac will remain relatively safe. These days, they say, viruses are written more for money than fame,” Hargreaves reports. “But perhaps a bigger reason for Apple’s seemingly safe position is the stability of Mac OS X… Although experts give Microsoft credit for greatly improving the security of its Windows operating system over the last few years, most still say Apple has the Seattle software giant beat.”
Full article here.
[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “Paul K.” from Bowie, Maryland for the heads up.]
MacDailyNews Take: Yeah, most still say Apple has Microsoft beat when it comes to security. Current score: Microsoft Windows: 150,000 viruses, Apple Mac: 0. It’s like golf: lower scores are better (Mac OS X is Tiger Woods, Windows is a paraplegic kitten). Yeah, we’d say Apple has Microsoft beat by a bit.
And we’ll see just how unlikely it is that “Apple’s share will ever account for much higher than the low double digits” a few years from now. Some people simply cannot fathom or accept radical change or see beyond the ends of their noses.
Contact CNN.com: http://www.cnn.com/feedback/forms/form2a.html
(Web address of CNN article in question: http://www.cnn.com/2006/TECH/ptech/10/20/apple.virus/index.html)
Related MacDailyNews articles:
Apple profit rises 27%, Mac up 30%, iPod up 35%; stock jumps – October 19, 2006
IDC: Apple Mac attained 5.8% of U.S. market share in Q3 06 – October 18, 2006
Gartner: Apple Mac grabbed 6.1% of U.S. market share in Q3 06 – October 18, 2006
Microsoft upset with Apple for partially blaming Windows for iPod virus – October 19, 2006
Apple shipped Windows virus on small number of 5G video-capable iPods – October 17, 2006
McAfee: Microsoft ‘taking security risks’ with long-delayed, oft-pared-down Windows Vista – October 02, 2006
Why is Apple’s Mac OS X so much more secure than Microsoft’s Windows? – October 01, 2006
Apple Macs are far more secure than Windows PCs – September 26, 2006
Apple touts virus-free Macs – August 25, 2006
Oxymoron: Microsoft security – August 12, 2006
Symantec details more security holes in Microsoft’s Windows Vista – July 26, 2006
Symantec: Microsoft’s ‘improvements’ to Vista could cause instability, new security flaws – July 18, 2006
Symantec researcher: At this time, there are no file-infecting viruses that can infect Mac OS X – July 13, 2006
Sophos: Apple Mac OS X’s security record unscathed; Windows Vista malware just a matter of time – July 07, 2006
Sophos Security: Dump Windows, Get a Mac – July 05, 2006
What Microsoft has chopped from Windows Vista, and when – June 27, 2006
Microsoft botches another copy job: Windows Vista Flip3D vs. Apple Mac OS X Exposé – June 26, 2006
Apple: ‘Get a Mac. Say ‘Buh-Bye’ to viruses’ – June 01, 2006
Apple Macs and viruses: Fact vs. FUD – May 26, 2006
Unix expert: Mac OS X much more secure than Windows; recent Mac OS X security stories are media hype – May 03, 2006
Macs and viruses: the true story – May 02, 2006
FUD Alert: Viruses don’t catch up to the Mac – May 01, 2006
Spate of recent Mac security stories signal that Microsoft, others getting nervous – March 06, 2006
The Idiot’s Guide to Mac Viruses For Dummies 101 – February 24, 2006
Apple: ‘Leap-A’ not a virus; only accept files from vendors and Web sites that you know and trust – February 16, 2006
Mafiasoft: Microsoft to charge $50 per year for security service to protect Windows – February 07, 2006
Security company Sophos: Apple Mac the best route for security for the masses – December 06, 2005
Hackers already targeting viruses for Microsoft’s Windows Vista – August 04, 2005
16-percent of computer users are unaffected by viruses, malware because they use Apple Macs – June 15, 2005
CNN apparently shouldn’t try to write technical articles since their writers don’t understand technology.
Morons… Journo scum.
CNN – Name one successful Apple virus or attack?
Hmmm. what else don’t they really investigate, but report anyway?
Can MDN please add that animated emoticon of the face pounding itself on the ground? Because after reading this retarded CNN crap, I need that to express how I feel.
In other news, the crime rate went up because I thought about buying some crack next week. Or it may not seeing as I have never bought crack before. It is a possibility though
Apple not ‘Macs’ are getting more viruses because to break into the big markets they are opening their machines to WINDOWS OS.
How long before muppets on CNN start talking about windows viruses on Intel macs – and talk of this in terms of Mac OS.
Apparently tech writers for CNN are Gartner Group drop-outs.
And someone PLEASE explain to me how anyone makes money off writing viruses? Phishing scams yeah i can understand that but writing viruses?
“Experts say these low numbers, and the unlikelihood that Apple’s share will ever account for much higher than the low double digits, is one reason why the Mac will remain relatively safe. These days, they say, viruses are written more for money than fame.”
I think it’s exactly the opposite.
And also, if the Mac market share gets to the low double digits, then that would basically be DOUBLE what it is now. I like the sound of that. Glad to know they got something right in the article.
PLEASE SPAM CNN With your comments:
See what happens when the mainstream media gets a hold of something and tries to report upon things which they do not understand? The virus originated on a typically porous Windows computer and was mistakenly placed up a very small batch (under 25 incidents reported) of iPods. It only negatively affects Windows computers, but, come on now, what doesn’t affect Windows computers negatively?
http://www.cnn.com/feedback/dotcom/
Oh, Steve Hargreaves is a CNN Money staff writer. So what the hell is he doing writing this??
I don’t know what they’re talking about. What attacks? By who? Are they trying to make a big deal about the infected iPod that was infected with a Windows virus. What a bunch of crap!
“relatively virus-free”
0 = relatively nada… idiots
“But they do believe viruses targeting Apple’s Macintosh personal computers are increasing.”
Please, some body, explain what that this poor guy with no school means? ten year ago, there was no virus for Mac, ten years later, still no virus for mac, How is that “increasing”?
CNN – Computers, NO Nollij.
This is really bad reporting. Why some people are so reluctant to say anything unequivocally good about Mac OS X vs. Windows is beyond me. And I can smell a Windows-centrist a million miles away. They ALWAYS cite market share as the main reason or THE reason behind the dearth of OS X malware. They often will also say “relatively virus free” instead of just “virus free”. And why is it here that “One reason Macs have less viruses blah blah…”, then they talk about market share. It’s like one big backhanded compliment. The “experts” almost NEVER talk about the real-world tangible differences between OS X security and WIndows insecurity. You’d think both platforms have identical security implementation. Sheesh!
And then they limit the potential for more market share based on their own limitations, rather than actual foundational reasons. Nowadays its, “Mac OS X will probably not go above the low double digits in market share”. Not too long ago it was, “Mac OS X will probably never make it into double digit market share”. Before that, it was, “Macs will likely never move beyond 5% market share”. In 5 years it will be, “According to my expert calculations, OS X will probably never go above 15% market share”.
Everyone that makes these sorts of porgnostications should be made to give a public mea culpa when they turn out to be wrong.
The last time I looked, about 2 seconds ago, the Microsoft campus was still in Redmond, WA. I can actually see when I peek out of my cubicle and it is not in Seattle!
I wrote “porgnostications”. I live up to my name, though I confess to actually liking my new word.
MDN,
You are behind a little. There was an article released this summer by a security agency celebrating (sarcastically) the 200,000th Winblows virus.
“Friedrichs said of the 13,000 virus threats Symantec sends out a month…”
Why is Symantec sending out threats? Who are these 13,000 people that they are threatening?
Sounds veryou mafia-esque.
CNN a glittering example of why the “drive-by” media is losing it’s audience.
CNN lives to promote it’s own agenda!
CNN: Apple Mac attacks rare but rising
I have had my InteliMac since March and it has not attacked me once.
why do people pay attention to CNN? seriously
Powerbook Attack:
my battery is s–t and I have to buy a replacement. its hitting in the wallet pretty hard.
F—in’ powerbook.
I am really getting a clue right now, a raging clue and i think its pointing left.
You guys wanna follow my clue?
In spite of some obvious factual errors, I think they got some things right:
“But perhaps a bigger reason for Apple’s seemingly safe position is the stability of Mac OS X.”
“…… Variants of Unix power most of the servers on the Internet and the system has a reputation for security.”
“The Mac OS X has a higher security profile,” said Ray Wagner, a vice president at Gartner, a technology research firm. “It’s not generating anywhere near the same rate of problems, even on a per capita basis.”
Or maybe I am looking at a revised version of the article
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”cool smile” style=”border:0;” />
What I wrote:
I’m sure you’re getting inundated with responses to this article. The statement that Apple Computers [sic] are “relatively virus-free” is incorrect. The Macintosh operating system, Mac OS X, is completely and 100% virus free. There are no known malicious, self-propagating viruses on the Mac. Furthermore, your article cites an issue with the iPod carrying a virus, however nowhere in the article do you mention that the virus was a Windows only virus and that it didn’t affect the Mac in any way. Instead you lead directly into some bogus report citing how attacks on the Mac are rising. This is completely misleading. An appropriate segue would be to talk about the hundreds of thousands of viruses plaguing the Windows operating system. You also fail to expand on the term “malicious code”. Six instances of malicious code written for the Mac OS doesn’t mean 6 viruses and it doesn’t mean that those pieces of code could ever do any harm on their own. Almost all were considered “proof-of-concept” and were meant to expose security risks, but they never had the ability to do what an actual virus does, and spread on its own. Finally, citing that the Mac’s market share, which is up to 5.8% of new sales, and doesn’t count installed user-base, is a reason it has enjoyed immunity to viral threats, that logic would lead me to believe that the Mac should be getting 5.8% of the 150,000+ viruses floating around on Windows. That equals roughly 9000 viruses. Currently, there are zero. You cite “experts” yet you don’t actually source them. I can do that and I’m not even a journalist. Watch! Experts agree that the best remedy for a broken hard drive is to cram peanut butter into the CD drive and light on fire. That’s what the “experts” say so it must be true. This “report” is pretty appalling.
What hacker out there wouldn’t want to be known as the FIRST to develop and spread a massive virus to the Mac community?
That would achieve a lot more fame and recognition than any Windows virus since even thirteen year olds can develop Windows viruses. I bet Apple would even hire this person.
bilbo faggins, that was a terrific reply. Of course, they’ll probably just write you off as a Mac cultist or some such nonsense. Good try though. Too bad there’s not a law that makes “journalists” have to get their facts straight, or else provide a correction with the same prominence as the original story, or else allow for a response by someone that actually knows what they’re talking about.
It didn’t metion that there are ZERO operating system viruses for Mac OS X. It downplayed Macs as being “relatively” secure against viruses because of small marketshare and because of the “stability” of the OS (?!?).
It’s simply an idiotic article.
And while I’m buzzing about all this, I’m sick and tired, yes, both SICK and TIRED, of seeing thess so-called “computer experts” come on some newscast, be it cable or local, and talk about ways to compute in a more secure environments WITHOUT EVER MENTIONING MAC OS X AS A SOLUTION!!!
They talk about Symantec this, McAfee that, this or that malware sniffer, blah blah blah, and never mention the one…only…true…best…solution……..which is to just get a friggin Mac.
People are stupid.
Stop spreading lies MacDailyNews.
MDN often claims that OS X has zero viruses. A claim even Apple has not made.
Facts:
1. The current Apple Virus commercial doesn’t claim zero viruses. In the commercial, PC simply states, “Last year alone there were 114,000 viruses for PCs.” Mac replies, “PC’s not Macs.” This says nothing because it is vague and because in fact there were not 114,000 viruses for Macs last year. Also, the 114,000 specific viruses that affected PCs did not affect Macs. Apple makes no claim that Macs has zero viruses.
2. On the Get a Mac:Viruses page Apple says, “By the end of 2005, there were 114,000 known viruses for PCs. In March 2006 alone, there were 850 new threats detected against Windows. Zero for Mac.” Apple only makes one claim – in March 2006 there were zero new threats detected against the Mac.
3. Apple’s security source of choice, Sophos, says that there has been a virus for OS X. Apple uses Sophos as their reference for zero viruses in March 2006. Yet MDN ignores that Sophos reported OSX/Leap-A as a virus in February 2006.
As a footnote Apple says, “Numbers from Sophos, a world leader in integrated threat management solutions, developing protection against viruses, spyware, spam and policy abuse for business, education and government.”
Oddly, a Sophos article, says, “it is correct to call OSX/Leap-A a virus or a worm. It is not correct to call OSX/Leap-A a Trojan horse.” See link subsection: Is Leap-A a virus or a Trojan?
How can MDN argue with one of Apple’s respected sources for security information? Easy, MDN ignores any data that refutes their claims. In the end, I recommend Macs and my wife and I use Macs because OS X and it’s security is amazing compared to Windows, but MDN is wrong.
CNN came to prominence in Europe after it’s coverage during the first Gulf War. Many of you will recall that it was triggered when Iraq invaded Kuwait.
I was in France and Spain as the tensions were rising in the middle east prior to Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait and naturally we turned to any English language news reports to find out what was happening.
The day that Kuwait was invaded, we were astonished to see that CNN ran that as the second biggest story of the day. Their major story on their world news network was that an industrial dispute in Pittsburgh was about to end. Few outside of the US even knew that there had been an industrial dispute in the first place. I can remember people standing and staring at the screen in disbelief, wondering why they weren’t talking about Kuwait.
It was incredible to see for ourselves just how little they understood of world affairs or what the really big story might be. It’s hardly surprising that they don’t understand Macs, viruses or accurate statistics.
Did i say this already? Im getting a BIG CLUE
Oh an awfully big clue right now, and its pointing that way ->
AttackOnMac,
The Sophos virus in question was made by anti-virus researchers as a proof of concept and never released in the wild.
Even if it had been released in the wild, it was unable to self replicate.
No Mac owner using OS X, outside of a research lab, has ever been infected by a piece of Mac malware. That is why we all claim zero Mac viruses in the wild.
CNN, like the BBc can’t tell the difference between being neutral and being objective.
They try to make everything fair and neutral, they don’t really know how to be objective because they aren’t sure of their facts.
There’s a world of difference between the two..
The difference between ZERO and ONE is HUGE. ZERO means that it hasn’t been done, ever. ONE (or any small number) still means that Mac OS X is “relatively safe” from viruses, but it is possible.
Mac OS X has had ZERO viruses. That is HUGE. ZERO means “safety through obscurity” holds no water.
At what percentage of US marketshare will these so-called “experts” stop repeating the “safety through obscurity” myth. Maybe when Apple’s Mac market share reaches 20% in the US. It’ll probably be close to 10% in 2007. And since Macs have longer useful lives than Windows PCs and enjoy an extremely active used/refurbished market, that 10% probably means a 15% or more “user share.”
Morons notified.
hows that saying go?; “If its not the mainstream media, its probably the truth getting out.”
MDN Stop Lying about Zero Viruses on Mac. It might be now Zero Viruses. You cant ignore the History ok.
OS X ‘Leap-A’ it was discovered this year
http://www.sophos.com/pressoffice/news/articles/2006/02/macosxleap.html
So i can say 114,000 on PC and Mac Os Tiger 1. Which tells us Mac Os X Still more secure then Windows. In history it had a virus or worm ok.
My e-mail:
FYI: the virus that shipped on the iPod was a Windows virus. There is still not one single viable virus for the Mac. Not one. Making it more than “relatively” virus-free.
There are a couple of trojans out there, but they require the user to install them manually.
Oh, and the whole “security through obscurity” thing is a myth that’s been debunked many, many times.
OSX is based on a UNIX kernel that’s been around for decades and has been proved incredibly secure over time.
OSX, because it is so highly secure, is the number-one target of malicious code writers out there. The hacker who writes the first viable OSX virus will be a legend. I say “will be,” because it hasn’t happened yet.
And by the way, as we know, there are millions of Macs out there without a single virus, yet when MS Vista was released to fewer than 10,000 developers, the first Vista virus appeared. Obscure? Yes. Secure? Not on your life.
My Mac has been hooked up to a broadband connection 24/7 for four years without virus protection. In that time, I have had not one incidence of malware of any kind – let alone a virus. Could a PC user say the same thing? I think not.
A little research next time would be advised.
“Leap-A” was a trojan, yes? Not a virus. It required the admin to type in his or her password. That’s like complaining that your car was stolen when you left it running.
I met 2 Virus or Worms on Mac at
http://www.sophos.com/pressoffice/news/articles/2006/02/inqtana.html
So i can say 114,000 on PC and Mac Os Tiger 2 in History.
AttackOnMac:
I responded to your comment previously on another thread. If you go to the site, you will find not one, but two examploes of viruses described. One of the viruses was written to exploit a vulnerability that had been fixed about 6 months previously, whereas the other was demonstrated in a lab environment. I am writing this from memory, but my recollection was that the “viruses” never propagated in the wild and could only propagate in the lab under specific conditions, which may have required user assistance. After reading MDN’s comments, your comments and the articles on the site to which you referred, I recall being unimpressed with your assessment as well as the assessment of the antivirus company responsible for the site which went out of its way to define a non-event as a virus. Was this done out of self-interest, perhaps?
If the vast majority of Mac users do not use antivirus software, is it really a small target compared to the antivirus clad Windows operating system?
“As they increase their market share, there will be more of a concentrated effort to write malicious code for the platform,”
As more malicious code writers find that is’s pointless to try to hack Apple’s time-tested, bulletproof OS X, the threat of a concentrated effort to write malicious code for the platform will DECREASE.
Provided it’s stealthy enough and doesn’t do anything obviously malicious, Mac users wouldn’t know whether they had malware or not.
Therefore it’s safe to assume all Macs in the world are already under Redmond’s control.
AttackOnMac and Jatt,
Read the related articles that MDN has provided before posting. You both sound like fools.
Apple Mac attacks rare (non-existant) but rising (all haters wish they could execute one)
They both ARE fools, they used google to find osx viruses, but didnt actualy research either one to realize that not only were they patched before they were released, but they did not self replicate, not to mention they are not detrimental.
you guys are grasping at straws that dont exist… why dont you get off our thread; dont you have a windows 98 box to defrag. gtfo
I knew that Os X was patched. I was just saying it was History. I use both Linux and Windows Vista Rc2 to try it out in beta. Vista is a Memory Hog. Sorry if i said bad. Iam just a Nice Guy. Bye Take Care
Totally irresponsible reporting.
The problem is that none of these clowns (or their sponsors) read forums like this one, so one gets to let off a little steam here but, in the end, MDN is preaching to the choir.
What a bloody crock o’ shit!
SHUT UP!! JUST SHUT UP!!!
Mac’s are still, STILL!!!, vunerable to the metadata file exploit.
http://secunia.com/mac_os_x_command_execution_vulnerability_test/
So the low market share of Mac OS X is shielding us from further exploitation.
Mostly because poor countries where they can only afford cheap PC’s with a pirate version of Windows drive the exploit for profit market.
The poor can’t afford a Mac to hack!!!
The new and improved Redmond devil!!
Cheez be nice. I didnt say anything bad about macs. All i said its history of 2 worms in Mac. Its not true anymore since it was patched. Bye take care.
Rapid Dog even Posted a new Worm it seems its unpatched still on OsX. See i didnt say Shut Up Shut Up as rude way. So be Nice People. Have i said Mean words in this site to People i guess not. Bye take care.
Jatt = Twatt.
These kind of clueless morons will be writing half arsed stories for CNN next.
Uh too late.
Whats up with these slang Languages. Twatt or moron. I dont tease people. Why cant you people be nice. Bye take care
Jatt,
Do you know how foolish you look here defending Windows security record vs. the Mac?
Maybe you could also make an argument that the Yugo is just as good a car as a BMW when it comes to safety or driveability.
“Why cant you people be nice.”
Because you’re a cock.
Bye take care
Well i dont Defend Windows Anymore. Let it be Insecure. I still can defend myself by having hardware firewall on and free anti-virus like AVG. And dont go to warez sites or check e-mails that contain viruses that say download this file or similiar. I know Os X is more Secure with Having No Viruses or Spyware then Windows. When did i start arguement again. I know i did before. I am sorry for it. If i overeacted before. At least i didnt tease people. Bye Take Care.
TheNewMacDude:
I know your a nice guy. And thanks for not calling names. As i said i dont defend windows anymore. I appreciate it your kindness. I might go to Linux again. Good luck in future.
Juvenile
Asshat
Talks
Trash
LOL again teasing. Iam not Juvenile and i dont talk trash. Iam just a Kind Person. It might be trash to you. Bye take care.
Jatt:
If you abhor the insults you receive here either go away or grow up. You’re inciting people behaving like an insincere cretin. Of course, you may be an attention-seeking imbecile with psychological defects.
Jatt, how do you enter your posts with your head stuck up your ass?
Jatt, how can you read the posts with your head stuck up your ass? Do you have text-to-speech software? If so, what is it?
Ok Huh? I dont have Defects and i dont seek Attention. It might look like it. Insult me all you want. Since you people dont have respect for me. Like i have done something bad. And i dont say anything about macs Suck. When did i say bad thing to you Huh? or anyone. Bye take care
Calling People Names or teasing is Not Right.
Stop beating me….
Joe wrote:
“I am really getting a clue right now, a raging clue and i think its pointing left.
You guys wanna follow my clue?”
That was a GREAT episode!!!
“Mud Monkey!” LOL!!!!!
I dont have Defects and i dont seek Attention. It might look like it.
Yes, Jatt, it does look like you’re an attention-seeking imbecile with psychological defects, in spite of your protestations to the contrary.
Defending Windows was Before argument. When did i start Defending Windows again argument again. I already said i dont defend Windows anymore and sorry if i was overeacting before. You guys insulting me over Windows. I dont insult you people because your using Macs. Bye take care.
Rabid Dog,
My Mac is only vulnerable to the meta data issue if three things happen:
1) I download something I’m not sure about.
2) I approve the download in my browser.
3) I manually open the file from the Finder.
Hardly a concern. Dufus.
Jatt,
You need to get familiar with the community at MDN. We’re a very outspoken, pro-Apple group, and MDN staff feed us. Anybody who’s not on our side hears about it.
Take it with a chuckle.
Ok no problem coolfactor. Bye take care
OK, Jatt, I believe you are sincere in your posts and for that reason I am now going to use your phrase “Bye Take Care” as my nic. I just think you are woefully uninformed about Macs and cutting edge computing technology but you’re a nice guy.
It is official now. I am no longer “thenewMacDude”, (which I used because there once a was a dufus with the nic “MacDude”). From here on out.
BEHOLD!!!!!
ByeTakeCare
Jatt, I would recommend reading the many links that are provided by MDN here to increase your knowledge about Apple and the Mac. There is a wealth of info that would help you immensely. Really.
Big Al,
I cannot find any information that researchers created OSX/Leap-A. In fact, the virus was released on MacRumors.com and is disguised as screen shots from OS X Leopard.
Symantec describes OSX/Leap-A as a worm and provides information on how infects and spreads via iChat.
McAfee describes OSX/Leap as a virus/worm and <a >reports</a> that “Applications may fail to run correctly, as the hook installed by the worm fails to correctly return control to the hooked process due to incorrectly written code.”
macca,
The default account created on starting a Mac for the first time is an Admin account. I personally create my first account for admin only, then create a new standard user for daily computing. Can you delete/rename a file from your Applications folder without a password? If so, you are already admin, no password required.
AttackOnMacNot,
Please show me where Leap-A was a lab experiment or a previously fixed vulnerability. The Leap-A virus was in the wild as OS-X Leopard photos released on MacRumors and initially a few users did get infected. User assistance was only required if the user did not use the default OS X admin account, most users do. I am not swayed that an MDN reader disagrees with three security companies. Nor am I impressed that you consider an unwanted file with unwanted results that made it’s way onto Macs a non-event. While I feel that my choice in an Apple Mac provides security measures that will always protect me, a knowledgeable computer user, I also do not claim that the Mac is immaculate.
Michael,
I am not sure what you are referring to. I am referring to MDN’s comment, “Yeah, most still say Apple has Microsoft beat when it comes to security. Current score: Microsoft Windows: 150,000 viruses, Apple Mac: 0.” Mac OS X is not a zero. I also notice MDN added a link to Apple’s virus page. Apple’s virus page does not claim zero OS X viruses. It makes three statements regarding the number of viruses and Mac health.
1. “114,000 viruses? Not on a Mac.” – True, there is only 1.
2. “In March 2006 alone, there were 850 new threats detected against Windows. Zero for Mac.” – True, OSX/Leap-A was released in February 2006, nor March.
3a. “While no computer connected to the Internet will ever be 100% immune from attack…” – True, has MDN read this statement?
3b. “…Mac OS X has helped the Mac keep its clean bill of health” –True, the Mac currently has a clean bill of health.
3c. “…a superior UNIX foundation and security features that go above and beyond the norm for PCs.” –True, and this is why I only own and recommend Macs.
“Today, the number of viruses actively attacking OS X users is…NONE!” — ClamXav website.
This statement was on the website before, during, and after Oompa-Loompa/Leap-A. This (whatever you wish to call it) was so dysfunctional, it took 12 hours for <b>real experts</a> to debug it just to make it work. In fact, it took the experts even longer to get a copy of the (whatever you want to call it).
Besides chalking up an article like this to a lack of research, sheer ignorance, or yellow journalism, the truth is Misery Loves Company… stolid Windows users can’t wait for Mac OS X to get a real virus. They shouldn’t hold their breath.
The Communist News Network. No wonder.
There’s only one source for Fair & Balanced, hard-hitting American journalism.
http://www.foxnews.com/
RMN
Iam just a Kind Person. It might be trash to you.
Your personal demeanor has nothing to do with how you think neither does it defend the nonsense that you post.
I have had discussions with Jatt in other threads. At first, I reacted a bit like the less rabid of the responders. I then decided he was genuine and apologised. Give him a break. Perhaps he stated something out of ignorance. The best way to encourage people to try or to continue to use the Mac is to discuss issues with them politely. That does not mean that you have to be any less enthusiastic about your choice of platform. Just try to be civil.
Many people read these discussions who are considering purchasing a Mac. How will your rants make them feel? Cult of Mac almost sounds too polite. Perhaps rabid Nazi hoarde would be more appropriate. (My apologies to rabid Nazis who resent the association.)
The factory that got those ipods infected was presumebly Foxconn, they use Windows, see the second last paragraph here:
http://www.businessweek.com/technology/content/oct2006/tc20061018_006862_page_2.htm
Larger exposure does bring more chances of something going wrong, battery problems, discolouring etc, but then again this worm thingy did come from Windows.
MoreAttackOnMac:
The following is a quote from a Sophos article in which they use the term virus and worm interchangeably. The article was posted on 18 February under the title “Second Mac OS X worm spreads via Bluetooth vulnerability”. http://www.sophos.com/pressoffice/news/articles/2006/02/inqtana.html
“The Inqtana worm exploits a vulnerability (known as CAN-2005-1333) to spread itself to other vulnerable Mac OS X computers. However, Apple released a patch against the vulnerability in mid 2005, meaning the worm is highly unlikely to spread successfully.”
You suggest my word is not as valid as that of a security company. I am simply reading their own words and qualifications and coming to the conclusion that they are being sensationalist in their choice of phrasing. The title says the worm “spreads”, but the text says “unlikely to spread” and indicates the problem was patched ~7 months previously.
Explain to me how MDN is lying.
I just noted that you asked about the other virus. I will look it up as my first comment was from memory as I stated above.
This from Cluly, a senior technology consultant for Sophos:
“The Leap-A worm isn’t in itself a significant threat”. This was posted under the title “79% believe Mac will be targeted more often in wake of Leap-A Mac OS X worm”. The 79% figure came from a poll on their own website and was a response to their initially alarmist articles. Sorry, but is sounds like “yellow journalism” to me.
Do I think Macs will be attacked in future? Yes. Do I run antivirus software on my Macs? No. I perceive the threat of viruses to be low and the disadvantages of using the software to outweigh the risks.
To Huh?
If TheNewMacDude can be nice. Why cant you be Huh? I even said to you sorry over Windows Arguement. And why you have to be harsh. I have not said a single word to you bad Huh? Just because i dont tease people. Its your choice if you want to be nice or not.
Quate from TheNewMacDude
OK, Jatt, I believe you are sincere in your posts and for that reason I am now going to use your phrase “Bye Take Care” as my nic. I just think you are woefully uninformed about Macs and cutting edge computing technology but you’re a nice guy.
It is official now. I am no longer “thenewMacDude”, (which I used because there once a was a dufus with the nic “MacDude”). From here on out.
BEHOLD!!!!!
ByeTakeCare
And from be Polite Person:
I have had discussions with Jatt in other threads. At first, I reacted a bit like the less rabid of the responders. I then decided he was genuine and apologised. Give him a break. Perhaps he stated something out of ignorance. The best way to encourage people to try or to continue to use the Mac is to discuss issues with them politely. That does not mean that you have to be any less enthusiastic about your choice of platform. Just try to be civil.
Bye Take care
Yea I see a big rise in attacks. Let’s see 0 viruses yesterday and still 0 today. Some trend.

” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”LOL” style=”border:0;” />
This is the kind of trend that Microsoft can only dream of.
MoreAttackOnMacNot,
I agree with the fact that most negative Mac news is sensational. Most negative headlines read just as the example that you provided or like the famous “Hijacking a Macbook in 60 Seconds or Less.”
I also agree that most Security, more specifically antivirus companies are self-serving as you suggest.
Most importantly I agree with your conclusion, “Do I think Macs will be attacked in future? Yes. Do I run antivirus software on my Macs? No. I perceive the threat of viruses to be low and the disadvantages of using the software to outweigh the risks.” And I’ll add – Do I think OS X security will ever be as bad as Windows security? No. Do I think Mac OS X security will be a major concern? No. Notice that I claim OS X is secure, not Macs. Now that Macs can run windows, will Macs with Windows ever really be secure?
My problem is still my initial complaint – MDN spreads the false claim that OS X has zero viruses.
Your 12:41am statement almost makes it sound as if you agree that OSX/Leap-A was a virus/worm and not a trojan/social-engineering. If you still believe OSX/Leap-A was not a virus/worm I continue my case in my next comment.
MDN uses the argument that OSX/Leap-A is not a virus because it does not spread and because ]http://macdailynews.com/index.php/weblog/comments/8616/”] Sophos themselves do not classify Leap-A as a “virus.”[/url]
Well… Apple provides this statement, “A malicious application named Leap.A that attempts to propagate using iChat has been detected.” Security researchers have shown that it can propagate.
And Sophos has changed it’s classification.
More for those in denial…
OSX/Leap-A was, as previously stated, released in the wild on MacRumors.com and was disguised as screen shots from OS X Leopard. Any virus has to be introduced somewhere. OSX/Leap-A infects much like any virus, for example W32/MyDoom-A.
1a. W32/MyDoom-A spreads via an attachment to email contacts.
1b. OSX/Leap-A spreads via file transfer to iChat contacts.
2a. W32/MyDoom-A activates when the infected attachment is launched.
2b. OSX/Leap-A activates when the infected file is launched.
By most virus definitions, the virus:
1. Must be self-replicating.
OSX/Leap-A copies /tmp/apphook to the following folder: ~/Library/InputManagers/apphook/apphook.bundle/Contents/MacOS so that it runs every time an application starts. It then uses Spotlight to search for the four most recently used applications this month, which do not require root permissions. Then it searches these files for the extended attribute oompa. If it does not find this attribute, it will infect the selected files. Finally it infects the selected files by copying the contents of the data fork to the resource fork of the selected file, and then copying itself to the data fork of the selected file.
2. Must infect without the permission or knowledge of the user.
OSX/Leap-A does this when it uses Spotlight to search for the four most recently used applications this month, which do not require root permissions.
3. Must execute itself.
OSX/Leap-A does this when it infects the selected files by copying the contents of the data fork to the resource fork of the selected file, and then copying itself to the data fork of the selected file.
A quick point, a trojan does not spread or self-replicate.
(Information from Symantec)
at Microsoft. Have you noticed how the article ends?
“As we’ve made improvements to the security of Microsoft software and services, we’ve seen cyber criminals shift their focus to other platforms and applications,” said Stephen Toulouse, Microsoft’s security program manager.
Who have seen this shift? This is a clear profit from yellow journalism and turn it to own advantage. Can anyone honestly state the above with straight face.
One certainly need MS training to be able to do that. Well, after all, it is years they are telling their customers they NEED Windows.
MANTM, you are really stretching, either to keep kicking a dead-beaten horse or because you have wrong info, did not understood them, or lacking correct ones.
OSX/Leap-A does (did) not work as you say. Maybe it was it’s intention to work as you describe, but it was not working that way. At best Leap-A showed a p
roof of concept and not so well written code. Moreover, you are adulterating the meaning of it. All the 1-2-3 above are NOT checked OK for Leap-A. For your own definition of it Leap-A was NOT a virus: it never did ANY of the above. Moreover, it was not an executable that is actually the actual signature of a virus that does 1-2-3 because it INSTALLS itself in the victim and RUNS with admin/root privileges in order to do 1-2-3.
With OSX/Leap-A you could not be infected by this unless you do all of the following:
1) Are somehow sent (via email, iChat, etc.) or download the “latestpics.tgz” file
2) Double-click on the file to decompress it
3) Double-click on the resulting file to “open” it
…and then for non-Admin users, it fails to infect most applications. If you were not using iChat there is no show to see. Not only that: even with using iChat it was only capable to infect Bonjour contacts WHEN contacted. So again, no virus: it needed an particular condition and active collaboration from user.
Thence, this is not a virus and MDN is right.
By definitions above, is Leap-A a traditional virus? NOPE
It doesn’t propagate externally, so no, it’s not a true Virus, as it does not attach itself to another file. It is what it is; disguised.
It’s not a Worm because it must travel computer to computer by using human intervention, right? Worms are automated.
What’s left? Trojan Horse. In this case, Leap-A does not infect other files, and, only because it’s poorly done, doesn’t have the ability to self-replicate.
At best it was a Trojan Horse and it proved not to be really working at that either.
You are really taking your info from Symantec? LOL, they have been screaming “VIRUS FOR OS X, YOU HEARD IT HERE FIRST” from day one trying to beat the competition and really falling flat on their face every time. Now they scream “OS X VIRUS” when a Mac user sneezes.
AND, if you really want Symantec opinion, I could give you the email of one (at least they have one) serious security engineer there and HE does not dare to call Leap-A a virus! but he cannot share his opinion out of an internal mailing list called [Focus-Apple] where his views do not always match the official stance of his employer.
‘Nuff said and said too much.
MDN always amazes me: magic word “serious”
More attack, you are delusional. Leap-A NEEDED USER INTERVENTION!
A virus on Windows that propagates via email, effective virus, do not need the user to intervene: it is enough to open the email and the attachement and then BINGO. Nothing else is required. The virus installs, take command of Outlook, replicate itself, sends ITSELF forged email with a copy of itself to victim contacts and recreate the very same conditions on other Windows users PCs. The users only triggers the cascade of events.
Leap-A never had this ability because THERE ARE AS OF TODAY ZERO VIRUS FOR OS X.
Leap-A needed user intervention at EVERY STEP it was miserable: the 3 Mac users (three) that reported being infected (Symantec reported at the times “0-10” ROFLMAO, could they be more blue in their face so hard they were trying?) admitted they really wanted to help the poor guy with crutches.
By the way, Leap-A was by far the VERY BEST attempt. By a mile. HAHHHAHHAHHHAH. If this is what best can be done…
Mac OS X *is* Unix. The ecosystem is done so you NEED user intervention period, unless the malware achieves a privilege escalation and get root privileges which is the concern of all Unix systems, not virus and worms.
NOT ONLY THAT, you have not done your homework, do you? Symantec itself calls it a WORM:
<i>Discovered: February 16, 2006
Updated: March 14, 2006 01:58:22 PM ZE9
Also Known As: CME-4, OSX/Leap.A [Computer Associates], Leap.A [F-Secure], IM-Worm.OSX.Leap.a [Kaspersky Lab], OSX/Leap [McAfee], OSX/Leap-A [Sophos], OSX_LEAP.A [Trend Micro]
Type: Worm
Systems Affected: Macintosh OS X
OSX.Leap.A is a worm that targets installs of Macintosh OS X and spreads via iChat Instant Messenger program.
Note: It infects files on the Macintosh OS X version 10.4. The worm will execute on Intel Macs, but cannot spread to other systems from these machines.<i>
Are you actually a TROLL or what?
Here, I help you a bit more. It is clear you are not that capable of searching the net:
http://www.symantec.com/security_response/writeup.jsp?docid=2006-021614-4006-99
Leap-A ? What a joke!
WOW, it is worst than I thought. YOU HAD the same Symantec link and still trying to call Leap-A a virus? You even provided at the end of your nonsensical post a proof(?) of your gibberish which actually says YOU ARE WRONG?!
AHAHHEUHAHHAOEHUHHAHUHA
What a tool!
“Friedrichs said of the 13,000 virus threats Symantec sends out a month, maybe a dozen are related to the Mac, with the majority intended for Microsoft’s Windows platform.”
Feudian slip???
Confirmation of the rumors?
This is so fun.
Mac OS X users: there are zero viruses for Mac OS X.
Trolls: Nuh uh! Here’s some software that requires user intervention to install, and under certain circumstances, if another Mac user installed the program too, it would have spread, like a virus!
Mac OS X users: *sigh*
It’s like there’s this mountain of poop on the Windows side, and people are struggling to find a speck of dust on the Mac OS X side… AH-HA! I FOUND ONE! oh, wait, never mind. damnit.
Nick, BINGO. If the MS lovers have to dig and dig to try and come up with something, I say, that is the case right there.
I would buy an anti-virus package if I felt that it could do something for me. Right now, I cannot see anything that they can really do. No active viruses but they want $50 a year from me for——– what????
Now for PCs, I say sure, its needed.
So, “CAN’T EVERYONE JUST GET ALONG??”
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
N.
Nick is right on. Windows fans…..get informed…..read MDN and it’s knowledgeable community. We can lead you to the promise land!!!!
Hey, Hardly Boys
Have your clues been pointing towards Jatt? OK, buy bi.
Oh there another Troll by AttackonMac on Viruses. Well i was insulted over Windows Argument only. Which i dont argue anymore. And i use Ipod not Zune and free anti-virus by AVG. I had enough insult by this dude Huh? over Windows XP. Bye Take care.
I will see if a Mac will fit my Needs. I might buy MacPro in future ok. Since you can upgrade parts like video, ram, hard drive Yourself in MacPro for $2499 but its still expensive. Bye take care.
Ok people i guess you think iam Nonsense when i said vista Reliablity is Good before. Proof at
Uptime for 9 days even its in Beta Rc2 ok. Trust me people. I dont Lie or make up stuff. And iam not defending Windows over Macs. Just showing its Reliable in Vista Rc2.
Bye take care all people. Even though some were nice and some were teasing me in this thread. Bye take care again.
This CNN article smells like Symantec had their greasy fingers on it. Also sounds like they’re attempting a “power of suggestion” and hypnotizing virus writers to give it their best shot. Nice.
Jatt, I understand for you coming from Windows world an uptime of 9 days must seem a lot. If my Mac had uptime of few WEEKS I would scream WHAT THE HECK IS WRONG WITH MY MAC?
9 days? You seriously call that *reliable*. Wow, worst than I thought how miserable the life on Windows side must be.
If you take care of it. Then it can run for more then 9 days. 9 days is Not Lot to me. I was just showing vista rc2 reliablity so far. Hardware has a role in it to. I do understand 95,98 and Worst Windows Me had issues for no reason. I did try Windows Me for 2 to 4 mins then never again Windows Me. I Call Reliablity if a something that can run for Months like Linux has great Reliablity in years. No Question Asked about Linux. Bye take care.
See any Platform can have issues like http://macdailynews.com/index.php/weblog/comments/11371/ shut down unexpected. Maybe due to the Hardware not working properly. You just want to get High Quality Brand Parts. Dont get Junk Generic Parts like $20 motherboard or IBM Deathstar hard drive. which will suck ok. Buy like Seagate Serial Ata hard drive or Western Digital. Bye take care.
Jatt, indeed but do not mix hardware problems with OS problems. The same PC with Windows is a joke, crashes, blue screen of death, uptime of days. Put Linux on the same machine and you forget what a reboot is. Same goes with Mac OS X. In 5 years I only had 4 crashes and all of them on OS X before Panther. Since Panther the only time I reboot the Mac is for a major update of when I get a new version of OS X, like Tiger.
If no other updates of Tiger are on the horizon (Leopard is undergoing Unix certification, hence it’s development must be very advanced), I will reboot in January with Leopard.
This is what I call reliable: it just works. Weeks after weeks after months. And no secure issues either, just keep the OS updated. No need to waste CPU cycles on AVs, Bot scanners, etc.
Apple usually goes with higher quality components as well. And it controls the entire process to make the computers. It is not a cheapo assembler like what you get from most PC makers. And this builds on the reliability. If you look at the computer satisfaction survey, Apple is first in every single feature, sometimes sharing the 1st place with a PC maker here or another PC maker there. It shows consistency which comes with reliability. No other PC makers in the industry can even come close.
Cheers
OK thanks LOL cheers you to. Bye take care have a nice day.
My Windows desktop has been running since 8/31/2006, and even then was probably only rebooted to complete install of some new software.
The myth of Windows Unreliability is just that, a myth.
Hey Myth,
My antivirus antispyware program on my macs have never even been installed for 18 months and running now. My initial purchase date. Same with Ad Aware, Spybot, Windows defender, Norton, McAfee, Panda Anti virus, etc etc etc etc.
Also, whenever & for whatever reason you reboot, that’s a reboot.
Ignore the bozos (idiomatic), though its all grist for the mill (idiomatic) when learning conversational English.
Don’t bother with “Bye Take Care.” Really. Writing it once is more than enough on a forum such as this. Many of the frequenters here who inhabit the cultural milieu that this reply forum represents consider politeness a weakness and anyone who does not respond as they do not worth the bother, other than as a target.
CNN is no longer relevant. Nobody listens to CNN.