Weisel: Apple’s Intel transition ‘proving difficult’ – soft demand, lack of supply for MacBook Pro

“Shares of Apple Computer dipped almost 2% to $66.37 in midday action on Monday. Thomas Weisel issued a research note saying the company’s transition to using Intel chips in its computers is ‘proving difficult.’ The firm said its checks with Apple specialist resellers across the U.S. found there is soft demand for Macs and a lack of supply for the Intel-based notebook products. 65% of the resellers expect the transition to have a negative impact on Apple’s current quarter, Weisel told clients,” Michael Baron reports for MarketWatch.

Full article here.

Advertisements:
• Apple’s brand new iPod Hi-Fi speaker system. Home stereo. Reinvented. Available now for $349 with free shipping.
• Apple’s new Mac mini. Intel Core, up to 4 times faster. Starting at just $599. Free shipping.
• MacBook Pro. The first Mac notebook built upon Intel Core Duo with iLife ’06, Front Row and built-in iSight. Starting at $1999. Free shipping.
• iMac. Twice as amazing — Intel Core Duo, iLife ’06, Front Row media experience, Apple Remote, built-in iSight. Starting at $1299. Free shipping.
• iPod Radio Remote. Listen to FM radio on your iPod and control everything with a convenient wired remote. Just $49.
• iPod. 15,000 songs. 25,000 photos. 150 hours of video. The new iPod. 30GB and 60GB models start at just $299. Free shipping.
• Connect iPod to your television set with the iPod AV Cable. Just $19.

Related MacDailyNews articles:
Boston Herald: Apple MacBook Pro ‘contender for best notebook on market, comes with a superior OS’ – March 06, 2006
Time Magazine’s Gadget of the Week: Apple MacBook Pro – March 06, 2006
PC Magazine review gives Apple MacBook Pro 4 out of 5 stars – March 03, 2006
Ars Technica: Apple MacBook Pro ‘an extremely solid machine, an important step forward’ – March 02, 2006
Mossberg: Apple’s MacBook Pro gives users a ‘much better OS with vastly better built-in software’ – March 02, 2006
New York Times’ Pogue: Apples MacBook Pro a ‘beautifully engineered, forward-thinking laptop’ – March 01, 2006
Apple MacBook Pro a ‘drop-dead gorgeous laptop’ – February 27, 2006
Macworld posts Apple MacBook Pro 2.0GHz first lab tests – February 22, 2006
Apple PowerBook G4 1.5GHz vs. MacBook Pro 2.0Ghz Adobe Photoshop benchmarks – February 22, 2006
Apple begins shipping MacBook Pro notebook computers with faster 2.16 GHz Intel Core Duo processors – February 14, 2006
Adobe: no native Intel Mac support until 2007; Photoshop could be 14 months away – February 01, 2006
Computerworld: Apple’s MacBook Pro ‘fast, really fast – looks like a real winner’ – January 28, 2006
Analyst: Apple seeing strong sales of iMac Core Duo, MacBook Pro, 5th generation iPod – January 25, 2006
Apple: expect MacBook Pro shortages – January 19, 2006
Use the ExpressCard slot to add FireWire 800 to Apple’s new MacBook Pro – January 15, 2006
Apple MacBook Pro, ExpressCard and EVDO – January 14, 2006
Apple introduces MacBook Pro; up to four times faster than PowerBook G4 – January 10, 2006

43 Comments

  1. <b> iTease: How Apple Can Make Converts<b>

    Lets face it, the overwhelming success of Apple’s iPod is undoubtedly the integration of hardware and software. When Apple made iTunes for Windows, it was an absolute brilliant move and cemented the success of the entire iPod/iTunes experience. What would those numbers look like if Apple’s market for ITMS and the iPod were limited to MAC owners only?

    So here is a way for Apple to make converts from the PC/Windows platform. Let’s call it iTease, an altered version of the entire iLife suite made specifically for Windows users. With a built in limitation (either timed-out after a specific amount of time, or limited in it’s ability perform fully) a Window’s user would get a first-hand OS-X/Apple experience albeit somewhat bastardized my running atop Windows.

    Jobs & Company could pull off a real marketing winner. iPod and ITMS for Windows users already have already given a taste to the seamless, user friendly and elegant software experience we are all accustomed to. To tease them even further into the world of MAC could very well be the experience that throws them over the edge.

  2. This isn’t news. Apple already said in January they expect slower mac sales this quarter – that’s why they lowered their guidance. Nothing new to report here. iMacs, Pro desktops and Powerbooks (yes, seriously) are all selling like hot cakes. Powerbooks are holding up well because there are a lot of pros who need to ensure 100% compatibility with their pro apps who need a laptop.
    As far as I can tell the only slowdown was in mac mini sales as buyers waited for the intel version (now out) and in fulfilment of MacBook Pro orders – something which is already taking place now that they’re shipping.

    Thomas Weisel need to go back to school. The slowdown was both aniticipated, and has already been responsible for a 20% decline in Apple’s share price. Everyone expects a slowdown – there’s nothing to report.

    Now why didn’t they look at Q3 instead, and try to work out how much the availability of the MacBook Pro, the new mini, and new iMac and the possibility of a new iBook will positively impact sales for that quarter? THAT would have been interesting.

  3. You can either listen to these Weisels or observe reality.

    Mac sales growth is still running 2.5X that of the industry.

    If someone tries to beat down a stock so they can buy it and profit from the “natural” price increase, don’t be a sucker.

  4. BTW, I do a lot of traveling for my job (last 2 weeks, 8 cities in 3 countries).

    Everywhere I go, I usually pass by the local Apple Store if time permits. And judging from the crowds (no exaggeration), Mac, iPod and accessories sales are doing very, very well.

    So much for the anals.

    ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”cool smirk” style=”border:0;” />

  5. This should not be surprising to anyone. No one wants to buy the old extremely slow computers at high prices. Apple is already sky high on pricing, why purchase equipment from two years ago at full retail?

    It is funny that one of the reasons Apple went to Intel to get around supply problems caused by Motorola (now Freescale) and IBM. Now we see the same problem all over again. Perhaps this is an Apple problem and not a chip manufacturer problem?

  6. Soft demand = lack of supply.

    This is not surprising. Until all the pro apps are out it will remain soft. Remember, most mac users work in the graphics and video fields, neither of which have UBs ready.

  7. Apple is shipping systems in quantity now. I think the suppy problem is quickly coming to a close. By month end they’ll be caught up on the MacBook Pro. Then we’ll see the real numbers.

    Let Apple stock drop. Maybe I’ll get a chance to invest before it jumps up again. Apple is outperforming the industy by every important measure: Increasing market share, profit margins, percieved quality, interest, consumer demand, inventory, and more.

  8. APPLE stock still has more DOWN to go. Perhaps under $60 soon.
    GOOGLE is also headed south, perhaps $330 soon.

    EARTHLINK stock is likely to go higher soon, perhaps $11, $12 or $13
    ANSWERS.COM stock seems to have hit the bottom same as well, and is likely to close above $11 this week.

  9. Because APPLE is a good company however it is not worth $55billion. They cant make profit on the high quality hardware they sell at such low prices.

    When steve jobs releases a $349 speaker and a $99 ipod case, you know they are desprete for profits. and its a hint that they are unable to make any profits.

    Eventho Sony is valued at $6billion, it still has more down to go, and if SONY is $6billion, why should Apple be $55billion, its simply a hype and Bubble just like Sirius Radio.

    Google , again, these guys ‘plan on becoming a 100 billion dollar company, they are not even worth 100billion, 100’s of new advertising companies are popping up here and there and copying google’s ADSENSE and ADWORDS services ( which is the core of google’s money source), Google is also a bubble even after being down $100.

  10. when you go to Costco and buy an ice cream or a slice of pizza on your way out, it costs you only $1 or $2, they can afford to sell at such low prices because they dont need to make profit on those.

    when Steve Jobs comes up with $99 ipod case and $350 speaker, you know something is wrong… its not the same story as costco. he is in need of profits to not dissapoint the walstreet. and its not going to work.

    All ipod owners arent necessarly APPLE-FANATICS, they wont buy it.

  11. There can be a supply deficit for the MacBook Pro and still be an overall softness in demand for other Apple products (particularly the Macs).

    The short-term issues are related to the economy as a whole, the quarter (many of us have taxes to write checks for soon) and, at least to some extent, the ongoing Intel transition.

    1. The fact is that there are still undefined product segments (future Pro desktop models, MacBooks, and the rest of the MacBook Pro line). I for one wouldn’t buy too quickly until I know what those options will include.

    2. Furthermore, the delay in certain software transitions (most notably Photoshop, but others as well) makes those with even barely adequate older models prefer to wait rather than leap forward into worse performance than they currently have (even if that is a short-term issue).

    3. For all the positive reviews out there on the MBP and the other shipping Intel Macs, there are enough criticisms circulating (partly related to Rosetta, but also to some reliability issues) that some people are waiting until the dust settles first.

    If this turns out to be a soft period, it’s still a necessary transition, and not unexpected. Once things settle down and the full product line is reestablished, Apple should be able to move forward with renewed momentum, and they have the music store and iPod line to help carry them through (as long as the iPod popularity and development remain strong).

  12. And one more thing – in response to those comments about supply and demand, MacBook Pros may be in such short supply (due to low production rates) that they are scarce even though demand is low.

  13. Stocks “Eventho Sony is valued at $6billion, it still has more down to go, and if SONY is $6billion, why should Apple be $55billion, its simply a hype and Bubble just like Sirius Radio.”

    At time of writing, the NASDAQ shows SNE to be worth $46.6bn. Where do you get $6bn from?

  14. NOrm: Simple – There is little or no hardware available and what little there is available there is little demand for it.

    Tip: Intel just announced that their sales are hurting and will continue hurting. That means they aren´t selling chips; ergo Apple isn´t selling computers. And/or Intel has production problems.

    And AMD is now beating INtel´s butt with faster chips.

  15. Stocks,

    You are wrong. Check your source. Sony is worth $46 Billion.

    Apple is worth more than Sony because it has a lot of potential future upside. Apple is probably slightly overvalued.

    Sony is valued where it is based on current malaise and a bleak future outlook, including being later with their next gen Gaming Console, getting the pants beat off of them in digital music, and having their years old conglomerate digital lifestyle environment not growing to fruition (despite putting memory sticks and readers on everything)

    Do you research.

  16. soft demand for Macs and a lack of supply for the Intel-based notebook products– Yeah Right!
    How about HUGE supply, because noone is buying the stuff—-or
    No supplies because the stuff is selling out.

  17. The Great Apple Comeback is over, they blitzed the world with a new device (to most) the iPod, but they are not making much headwind selling more Mac’s because the world is Windows and Vista is right around the corner.

    Vista promises

    1: Better security (yea right?)

    2: Better looks (it is nicer)

    3: The most software (everyone codes for Windows)

    I have predicted a eventual slowdown in Mac market share advances once Vista rolls it’s ugly head.

    Why? Because once security and looks are no longer a problem on Windows, it comes down to who has the most software and compatability.

    Microsoft is retaliating guys and gals.

  18. Stocks: When steve jobs releases a $349 speaker and a $99 ipod case, you know they are desprete for profits. and its a hint that they are unable to make any profits.

    Apple has almost always designed products that are high-end and high(er) priced, aimed at consumers with above average everything, so this is nothing new. Heck, when the iPod was introduced, more than a few pundits loudly predicted a rapid, dismal failure for the “overpriced” gadget.
    Apple is only trying to increase it’s profits. Expensive speakers and ipod cases are not a sign that Apple is “unable to make any profits”. Besides, if Apple was hurting for profits, those two products certainly would not “save the company”.

  19. Phew!! Didn’t force a 30″ screen requirement to read the thread.

    MacDude

    Apple still has time yet. Vista may launch this year, but won’t get momentum for another year to eighteen months after that.

    Exactly as Windows 2000 and XP did.

  20. As a finance guy with various professional designations and registrations, I feel morally compelled to warn everyone NOT to take what “Stocks” is dribbling as prudent financial or investment advice.

    What he is charging for the advise is all it’s worth.

    ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”shut eye” style=”border:0;” />

  21. Hehe. Hi there MacDude.
    Yeah, Microsoft’s really determined to increase security and looks. Yeah.
    Have you seen the Aero Glass theme on the latest screenshots of the latest beta? It looks WORSE than XP. The transparencies are pointless and hinder the look of the whole thing, and the color is way too bold. That’s why Apple uses soft blue and gray, because they’re colors that are “ambient”. However, Windows uses either blue still or I’ve even seen it use solid green (ick), which is distracting to the eye when trying to focus on a window.
    The security is probably Windows Defender and the same “security updates” they did with XP, which never fixed a thing. The problem’s the framework, and so without DRASTICALLY changing that, the “security updates” will probably just protect you from being stupid and pop up one billion messages when you try to download a file to discourage you to. If MS keeps trying to focus on putting a million firewalls and whatever on the system, not only will it make no difference because virus writers are smart enough to work around these things, it’ll also make the system even more clunky than before. Huh.

    Hey, I think I finally figured out why MS has waited to release Vista for so long – they’re waiting for all the virus writers die to say they have a “secure” platform. Heh.

  22. Oops, it should read:

    “they’re waiting for all the virus writers to die”

    Cause, you know, I don’t let these things go uncorrected, unlike someone we know..
    I’m looking at you, Mr. “they blitzed the world with a new device the iPod”.

  23. “Because once security and looks are no longer a problem on Windows…”

    I hope no one is holding their breath for this. Considering the originally announced feature set of Longhor…opps, I mean Vista, the innumerable announcements since then of feature set reductions, what the proposed feature set is currently stated to be, and what Vista will actually ship with, forgive us Macusers for saying PC users probably counting chickens before they’re hatched.

    “…it comes down to who has the most software and compatability.”

    That’s true now, sort of, and it isn’t slowing the increase in Mac marketshare at all.

    However, I do think the phrase, “Vista’s ugly head” is probably an accurate assessment. As they say, “Beauty is skin deep, but ugly is to the bone.” Or, in the case of Vista, to the core…of it’s code.

  24. If SNE (SONY) is valued at $46billion, then how come on etrade it shows 6.7billion, and why does the stock price move so high and low on such low trading volume?

    By the way, SONY almost always hits bottoms between july and november.

  25. Why buy a PowerPC now that Intel chipped macs are the future?

    Why buy an Apple Intel Mac when it won´t run pro products without taking a Rosetta hit?

    Answer: Wait, wait, wait.
    So PowerPC macs aren´t selling and Mactels aren´t moving as fast as they would if the pro software was available.

    It´s not the best of times for Apple. And if iPod sales soften….gulp! My Apple stock ain´t gonna´ like it.

  26. “If SNE (SONY) is valued at $46billion, then how come on etrade it shows 6.7billion, and why does the stock price move so high and low on such low trading volume? “

    Interesting… etrade shows $6.7b in the detailed quote, but it shows $45.4b in Company Snapshot. I think you have found a bug in etrade’s computer program.

    Since number of shares out is 996.519M, market cap of $45.4b is the right number.

  27. Queezzie, do you even own Apple stock? I doubt it, seeing as all I see you do here is comment on everything and say something negative and then flame everybody who disagrees with you. One who is that negative on Apple doesn’t seem like a potential shareholder to me.
    If you really do own their stock, shouldn’t you kind of think about the fact that everything negative you say about Apple, if true, has a possibility of bringing the stock down?
    You’re the only person I’ve ever seen who would bash a company endlessly and then put your money into it and have faith in it. According to your portfolio, you hope they do good, and then say everything they do is bad.
    Contradictions aren’t healthy for brains.

  28. Freeze: Not being a shareholder is probably a strength when it comes to this topic. For he past few months, all I here from the shareholders are platitudes and overly optimistic assessments (“the future looks bright!”), when there are actually real reasons to be concerned. It seems the desire to keep the AAPL price rising is keeping some people from donning their thinking caps.

    For instance, Intel is currently losing market share big time to AMD on the PC side, in almost all markets. Yes, servers & desktops, but even in laptops they’re gaining a lot of momentum. I’ve seen more than a few ‘shootouts’ showing the Turion equal to (power efficiency) or better than (outright performance) Intel’s Yonah. PC people at all levels are looking for ‘AMD Inside’, b/c their products are head and shoulders above what Intel currently sells, or are planning on selling in the future (I’m talking roadmap comparisons here). People are noticing, and they’re spending their money accordingly. How does this affect Apple? I can only surmise, but since Jobs has tied the company to Intel exclusively you can be sure that any ‘halo effect’ is pretty dim.

    Next are Apple’s new Macintel products themselves. Simply put, they aren’t as good as most people expected, and in some cases aren’t even products that people are clamoring for. Rumors of Apple-branded DVRs, Tablets, and hopped-up iPods are out there for a reason folks – PEOPLE WANT THEM. And yet apple rolls out tepid upgrades to existing products in he face of this … um, stu-pid. And this recent rash of ‘feel good’ reviews notwithstanding, under a non-rose colored light the MacBook Pro is a decontented, hot, decent performing dual core laptop … that just happens to look good and have a stable, virus-free OS. In performance areas where having the extra core can be leveraged, it does well. In anything else, it’s about the same as the old PPC version. And it certainly isn’t so good as to make everyone swallow Job’s line that he didn’t know how to build great products with anything but Intel. Again, people are noticing – the hype is not matching reality.

    I see it a lot. I just helped a couple of medical researchers slog through some Mac purchases. They initially figured they’d go Macintel, but once they investigated all the pluses and minuses they just weren’t impressed with MacBook, iMac Core Duo, OR the Macintel Mini. They went PPC Mac all the way (laptops & desktop). Some of their decision was Rosetta-based (they had software that wasn’t likely to be UB anytime soon, and couldn’t afford to take a performance hit), some was they were impressed with the best PPC Apple offered (the Quad) and could find nothing else in it’s price range that performed as well. Also, MBP just dropped too many pro-level features that they’d come to depend on. Finally, those that were informed on such things just didn’t like Intel – the consensus was that they couldn’t understand, if Apple HAD to go to x86, why not Athlon/Opteron??

    So there you have it. Non-scientific I admit, but if my recent experience is any indication at all, Apple is in for a rough ride. And it will be made all the rougher by Intel’s high prices for it’s CPUs and lack of part availability.

    I think Stocks makes an excellent point regarding the iPod accessories and their sky-high pricing – if Apple wasn’t expecting to have some bad news for the shareholders in the next quarter, there’s no way they’d be charging so much for these items. They’re need to boost profits is evident, and they’re pulling out any stop they can think of to make it happen, counting on brand loyalty and ‘buzz’ to lay the smoke while they do so.

    Yeah – I’m a curmugeon, a troll, an un-believer … I’ve been flamed it all. But, I think, in this case I – and all the others trying to warn the herd animals – also just happen to be right. In a big, big way. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”cool smile” style=”border:0;” />

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.