Samsung withdraws SEP claims ahead of second patent trial

“The second patent trial between Apple and Samsung, scheduled to start on March 31, took a dramatic turn late on Friday as the two companies filed a stipulation with the court dropping some of the claims and counter-claims to be debated in the second trial,” Electronista reports. “Samsung, perhaps fearing further investigations over its improper use of standards-essential patents (SEPs) as legal weapons and bargaining tools, has agreed to drop all SEP claims from the case, leaving it with only two claims on two patents, down from its original five.”

“In all of the legal matters between the two giant electronics firms, there are two types of patents in dispute: SEPs, which are a class of patents that are vital to create modern devices (for example, patents covering how 3G or LTE works), and non-SEPs — unique patents that others do not need to emulate in order to create working devices,” Electronista reports. “Apple has never resorted to litigation against companies infringing on its SEPs, preferring to negotiate agreements using the FRAND (Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory) principle, which means it will offer low-cost licenses to all competitors, even direct rivals like Samsung.”

“Under the deal filed late Friday, Apple has agreed to drop its counterclaims on those SEPs and FRAND counterclaims, reports patent analyst Florian Mueller, but Samsung is agreeing to dismiss its SEP claims without prejudice — meaning it could bring those matters up again in some future litigation. Samsung has been under investigation by the European Union over its abuse of FRAND guidelines, and was recently being investigated by the US Department of Justice, though the agency later strangely closed the investigation with a promise to continue ‘monitoring’ Samsung for FRAND abuse,” Electronista reports. “It may be that promise that moved Samsung to dispose of its SEP claims in the new trial, or perhaps it was influenced by a review of its track record in the US on such matters.”

Read more in the full article here.


  1. Samsung’s best team is it’s legal team who can find loopholes in the patent systems world wide such that all these patents disputes will be long enough to help their marketing team get as much market share as possible.

    Those patent judges in the systems who couldn’t care less about such manipulations of Samsung will keep wearing their high moral unprejudiced hat and hurt the “market” as long as the systems allow.

    Anyway. I won’t buy Samsung products anymore. Their products are so polluted. But then, one can’t deny the ultimate power of a government supported corporation (and vice versa) can be so worldwide influential. Korea and Samsung. Samsung Korea…

    1. Remember, everyone: Do not click the above link, which is to a Spanish spammer that redirects to another stupid link by a company that hopes to exploit the desperately under- and unemployed. Everyone in the food chain receives money for each click.

      Just click the one-star feedback, which amounts to a collective “suck me” for Jenny.

      1. It would appear that the author is quite capable of reinserting his or her comment no matter how many times it’s deleted. The wonder of WordPress. When I see the simplicity with which these ubiquitous publishing platforms are infiltrated by the nefarious, I worry about our propensity for trusting large chunks of our infrastructure to companies who can’t really be making enough money off of it to even give a damn (no insult meant to the community of developers working on WordPress). What does this portend for the future when we all plan to climb into the car and have it drive us somewhere?

  2. Well, that brightens my day. Hopefully Samsung will decide to stop abusing SEPs and FRAND.

    HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW! Like that’ll ever happen.

    It’s just a shame that Samsung is no longer tying its own noose on this particular issue. I would have loved for them to hang themselves by pursuing their SEPs all the way, just so the DOJ would be forced to actually do something about them. (Then again, like the DOJ would actually do that.)

  3. …but Samsung is agreeing to dismiss its SEP claims without prejudice — meaning it could bring those matters up again in some future litigation.

    The usual Samsung a-holiness. You’d think they’d get sick of their own stink. Pew! 😯

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.