Forget Icahn: Apple should take some advice from Ford

“Since Tim Cook took the helm at Apple in 2011, there’s been a steady flow of voices telling the CEO how he should be spending Apple’s money,” John-Erik Koslosky writes for The Motley Fool. “Chief among them has been billionaire investor Carl Icahn, who just won’t end his quest to convince Cook to cut a sweetheart deal to reward investors in the here and now.”

“Apple should ignore Icahn and all the others clamoring for preferred shares, a bigger buyback, a fatter dividend, a dirt cheap iPhone, or whatever the latest push is,” Koslosky writes. “Instead, Cook and company should look to Henry Ford, who had his fair share of clashes with inpatient, meddling investors.”

“In a crowded, competitive, and fast-evolving automobile market in the early 1900s — another time of tectonic cultural and technological shifting — Ford prevailed by staying true to his vision and resisting the forces that got in the way,” Koslosky writes. ” Apple can win by following the same path. Recent evidence backs this up.”

Read more in the full article here.

[Attribution: Next iPhone News. Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “Bernard Trllot” for the heads up.]

Related articles:
Apple urges shareholders vote against Icahn buyback proposal – December 27, 2013
CalPERS criticizes ‘Johnny come lately’ Icahn’s push for additional Apple buybacks – December 12, 2013
If Apple CEO Tim Cook were less polite, this is what he’d tell Carl Icahn – December 6, 2013
Carl Icahn chops Apple buyback demand – December 4, 2013
Icahn proposal calls for Apple buyback of ‘at least’ $50 billion – December 4, 2013
Carl Icahn files shareholder proposal with Apple for share buyback – December 4, 2013
Memo to Apple: Carl Icahn is right – November 23, 2013
Carl Icahn warns stock market could face ‘big drop,’ says does not want fight with Apple management – November 19, 2013
Carl Icahn reports stake in Apple now worth $2.05 billion
Carl Icahn: I had a ‘good conversation’ with Tim Cook; we both believe Apple is undervalued – November 11, 2013
Carl Icahn is 23rd in AAPL shareholders’ line with only 0.5% stake – October 24, 2013
Carl Icahn’s letter to Tim Cook asks Apple to commence immediate $150 billion buyback – October 24, 2013
Carl Icahn sends letter to Tim Cook, pressures Apple for a buyback – October 23, 2013
Activist investors like Carl Icahn destroying companies, costing jobs, says corporate attorney – October 9, 2013
Carl Icahn’s Apple buyback seen failing in bonds – October 7, 2013
Henry Blodget: Apple should tell Carl Icahn to ‘stuff it’; America should be incredibly proud of Apple – October 2, 2013
Apple should not bow to Carl Icahn – October 1, 2013
Carl Icahn says firm now has $2 billion in Apple shares; another meeting with Apple in 3 weeks – October 1, 2013
Carl Icahn demands $150 billion from Apple – October 1, 2013
Will Carl Icahn pick a fight with Apple? – October 1, 2013
Tim Cook to meet with Carl Icahn on Monday in New York City – September 26, 2013
Carl Icahn scoops up Apple stock on post-iPhone event plummet – September 13, 2013
Carl Icahn buys ‘quite a bit more’ Apple shares following unveiling of iPhone 5s and iPhone 5c – September 11, 2013
Carl Icahn’s ulterior motive: To get Apple to buy Nuance – September 3, 2013
Carl Icahn to dine, discuss buybacks with Apple CEO Cook in September – August 22, 2013
Icahn to meet with Apple CEO Tim Cook in September – August 22, 2013
How Carl Icahn will accelerate Apple’s ascent – August 14, 2013
Billionaire Carl Icahn says Apple shares could trade at $700 with increased buyback program – August 13, 2013
Carl Icahn spells the end of an era at Apple; this is the end for the Apple that you knew and loved – August 13, 2013
Carl Icahn reveals large Apple position, reportedly over $1 billion; wants to see Apple increase stock buybacks – August 13, 2013
Apple stock goes vertical: The Carl Icahn effect – August 13, 2013


  1. Henry Ford also understood the advantages of minimising choice when it comes to mass production.

    Sticking to your core values and principles is a good strategy for any company looking to the longer term. Speculators such as Icahn are not looking beyond where the next fast buck will come from.

    Very wisely, Tim Cook has very clearly signalled that Icahn cannot expect any movement with regard to his further ambitions for Apple’s money, so Icahn can stay on board knowing what the deal is, or he can sell his shares and speculate elsewhere.

  2. Apple should take advice from no one! All of these anal cysts want to do is screw over AAPL just so they could lower their stock. I bet they are also lying about it on purpose. Apple should just do what they do best and ignore these hit trolls.

  3. Yeah, but isn’t MDN always pulling out the fact that Ford lost it’s lead to Chevrolet in the 30s when it was super dominant and resistant to changing the color offerings of their Model T, when Chevy offered a more advanced car with color choices. Then and only then did Ford produce the Model A also with color choices, but it was too late and the tide had already turned to Chevy… And, Ford is still playing catch-up today (according to MDN) because of that mistake.

    So, if this is so, according to MDN. I’d read this article with a grain of salt. Apple is doing fine, and “yes” investors will try to meddle, but having a forward vision and not resisting change is also good policy, IMHO.

    1. …and of course, the irony in this observation is to look at what colors are available to buy on an automobile today (especially off-the-lot): you can have “any color” you want, so long as it is Black, White, or Grey 😉

    2. This note is for Mtnmnn: OK, so for a while, GM seemed to have “overtaken” Ford in the US. Ford still had formidable presence in the UK and elsewhere, even then. AND, in case you failed to notice, FORD was the only US car manufacturer — the ONLY one! — that never went bankrupt and/or required a humungous Federal “bailout” in order to stay in business. And some US car companies, like American Motors, simply don’t exist anymore. Let me ask you this: back in 2009, which stock would you have preferred to own — GM or Ford???

  4. As a publicly traded company Apple has some responsibilities to its shareholders. Returning value is one of them.

    Sitting forever on an increasingly large (unprecedented large) mind boggling enormous pile of cash is doing no one any good and is attracting pests (like Icahn and Einhorn).

    Yeah, Apple stick to your vision but what exactly is the vision associated with “cash mountain”?

    1. One would think Apple has more than enough emergency cash for most situations, but maybe they’re thinking the entire world economy will crash or something. Besides with most of that cash locked overseas maybe they’re waiting for a cash repatriation tax holiday. I don’t know why they don’t just create some overseas businesses and make more money than just keeping it locked up in a low-interest bank account. All I know is Apple should be using it to expand into new markets now that their hardware business is completely capped by the flood of cheap Android devices and now the growing flood of cheap Chromebooks. There soon won’t be anywhere Apple’s business can grow.

      It’s true that us common folks don’t know exactly what the enormous mountain of cash is being held for, so we’re only left to speculate like the majority of the investors out there who have lost interest in Apple’s vague vision.

      1. I have no doubt of two things:

        1) The US Senate is so diabolically stupid that they refuse to take down the barrier THEY maintain against bringing foreign earnings into the USA. It’s a ~34% tax rate. Compare that to the normal internal corporate tax rate (of max ~28%) and you’ll notice the inherent insanity. Get lost Carl Levin, dolt.

        2) No way no how is Apple ever going to get into the same position they were in at the end of 1996 with $1 Billion in unwanted Mac Performas rotting in warehouses, which triggered off one of the worst press-oppression eras in their existence. It wasn’t that Macs were remotely bad. It was that the press decided to DESTROY Apple for what is admittedly the single stupidest marketing moron move in their existence, the single worst in my personal experience.

        IF Apple every falls down another rabbit hole, they are NOT going to get caught without wads of cash to get them back to life again, no matter how much HATE is thrown at them by anyone. Apple’s future is to survive AND stick to their principles of creativity. That’s going to be the case no matter how many dickheaded stock manipulators and total ingrates rant and rave at Apple. Hurray!

  5. So, Apple needs help from Ford now, eh? What evidence do you have to support that Apple cannot do tremendously well with the current board and management? Lets look at the data shall we?! Stock analysts (day traders in for the quick buck) are the ones causing all the hype to spin the stock for their own interests… which by the way, is also why Icahn wants some rules changed.

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.