“The biggest unknown [with the Palm Pre] is price, which went unmentioned during the demo. My assumption is that Palm would try to take market share by coming in significantly lower than the $200 or so Apple wants for its iPhone,” Peter Kafka reports for AllThingsD.
Kafka reports, “But when I ran that theory by Palm CEO Ed Colligan, he looked at me liked I’d peed on his rug. ‘Why would we do that when we have a significantly better product,’ he asked, then walked away.”
Full article here.
MacDailyNews Take: More unwarranted hubris from a deluded man who for years has done nothing of note but pilot his company directly into the ground.
We’ve learned and struggled for a few years here figuring out how to make a decent phone. PC guys are not going to just figure this out. They’re not going to just walk in. – Ed Colligan, Palm CEO, November 16, 2006, laughing off the idea of Apple entering the smartphone market.
The more we see and hear from Palm, the more we believe they’re angling for a buyout.
Oh, by the way:
We’ve been pushing the state-of-the-art in every facet of design… We’ve been innovating like crazy for the last few years on this and we’ve filed for over 200 patents for all of the inventions in iPhone. And we intend to protect them. – Apple CEO Steve Jobs unveiling iPhone, January 9, 2007
Big Mistake Ed. 1, your product isn’t out yet……and needs some sort of momentum to get people to want to buy it. 2, no Apps or 3d games. 3, No real App store.
I could keep going, but if you priced it at $150 you could make some inroads in the market. BUT, you are on that crappy network……Sprint.
It will come out when the next generation iPhone comes out. It will be one year behind.
saw a news program this morning praising the new Palm Pre because it is easier for women with fingernails to use than the iPhone.
as a guy, I had no idea that the iPhone was tougher to use with fingernails.
but wouldn’t that be true with all touch screens?
I Love how these manufactures feel when they come outt with a new product and whole world will drop everything to get there product ? Apple changed everything in there world and still they think there better ? What a joke ? Let them first change the owrld and see how it feels, and I’ll keep my iphonee,,, thank you very much…
I believe that if the tables were turned and it was Apple bringing out the entry product with Palm being the strong incumbent, Apple might consider incentive pricing even with a great product like the iPhone. I don’t perceive Palm to have a strong hand at this point. In 2002 or 2003, perhaps, but not now.
Actually Sid, they didn’t “get” it until the iphone’s debut. So if AAPL was working on it for 3 years before that…
I’d say they are about 4 years behind now, and iphone v.3 wil be out when this vaporware distills out…
AAPL is at a dead run and lots and lots of other CEOs will be sad too.
there = their
What surprises me is the same guy that made that quote is still CEO of Palm.
“It will be one year behind.”
You really think the Pre will have caught up to 2 years ago iPhone model?
Have to see one but highly doubt it.
It’s going to be fun watching people typing on that keyboard in landscape mode….
“Ooops. we never thought of that.” said Ed Colligan
“as a guy, I had no idea that the iPhone was tougher to use with fingernails.”
My mom’s friend looked at an iPhone and ended up buying a BB because she said she could not type on the iPhone with long fingernails. I wasn’t there when she tested it but I guess it’s a problem.
Got nails? Fat fingers? iPod touch- and iPhone-compatible ‘Pogo Stylus’ works with newest models – MacDailyNews, September 17, 2008
I watched the QT of the Pre(sentation):
Rubinstein robotically reading from the numerous oversized teleprompters was classic!
Colligan is a SUPER creepier version of Ned Flanders! Who could work for that effing assclown?
Palm neglected to mention that they actually bought Handspring/Treo to “invent the smartphone”. A lie by omission.
All in all — Palm remains very 3rd rate. No chance of gaining traction in the market. An easy promise.
If you have problems using the iPhone on-screen keyboard because of long fingernails, there is a very easy solution.
Nail clippers.
This guy sounds like Apple back in the day. Apple’s product was SOOOOO much better than anything else that they couldn’t possibly face any competition from anybody else in the education and creative markets.
Then Dell stole Apple’s lunchbox for about 10 years and Adobe developed all their creative apps for Windows and left Apple out to dry.
BTW, what happened to Be, which Palm bought years ago?
Palm Pre looks like every other crappy ‘iPhone killer’.
Dont these people understand that they are COPYING the iPhone and that they are ALL chasing the iPhone?
At some point, we are going to be hearing from Apples lawyers about patent infringement from a number of these ‘innovative’ companies.
Then there are the dumb-ass reviewers; I read one guy in the UK say that Apple has an advantage over the Pre because they have an App Store with a ‘few hundred apps’.
Where do they find these dopes?
The name: Has anyone noticed that this is a really BAD name? WTF is a ‘pre’?
Did Colligan and Rubinstein forget some letters?
Should it actually be the Previa…no, thats a car.
Maybe the Predictor? No , I think thats a pregnancy tester…
Maybe its actually called the Prefix?
Perhaps Windows next piece of crap will be called the Suf? (As in Suffix)
Where do they find these not-too-bright people at these not-very-good companies?
I think it must be called Pre because it was designed to be Pre-iPhone. Hahahahaha. Get it?
What does the Palm pee bring to the table that the iPhone, blackberry whatever or Android doesn’t?
Absolutely nothing.
Long finger nails cause problems with iPhone?
I guess Apple wasn’t marketing the touch screens to hookers and strippers.
Here’s something I don’t get.
Back when the iPhone was first released, the only applications that 3rd party devs could write were web-apps. Everyone groused and bitched and moaned at such a limited platform, ultimately cheering when the iPhone SDK was launched. In fact, this launch gave the iPhone it’s second wind, and had it not happened the iPhone would probably have sold 30-40% fewer units than they have since said launch.
So, here we go with the Pre phone. A device that only supports web-apps. The difference here is that is not going to change. I mean the OS is called WebOS for crying out loud! So where are all the naysayers who called out Apple, were is all the grousing over the limited potential.
Just goes to show you that Apple is held to a higher standard than the rest of the tech sector, even when entering virgin territory.
You really want to brag about landscape typing, Macaday? Apple sure hasn’t taken advantage of the iPhone’s usefulness when held in a landscape orientation.
‘Ed Colligan, he looked at me liked I’d peed on his rug.’ ROFLMAO
Ed Colligan = pure 100% jackass meat – no fillers
Palm is as delusional as ever. While the phone looks somewhat nice, it’s still a Palm. Enough said.
nekogami
I actually have a lot of friends who have longer fingernails, and they’re not hookers or strippers. In fact, most “fashionable” women will have their nails done most of the time.
Palm…what a pathetic bunch of whiners.
They dominated and defined the PDA market and could have done the same with smartphones…if anyone there had a clue.
The fingernails problem is cause, like most touchscreens they rely on the small electrical charge in your skin, that’s why you cant use it with gloves or a stylus etc. And before anyone says it, I know there are styli and gloves out there for iPhones, but thats the point, they are FOR iPhones, normal ones wont work.
IMO, the Palm people (like CEO Colligan) are damn cocky and arrogant with their dissing of the competition (especially the iPhone) considering they have stolen… oops, “borrowed” so much from the iPhone.
It should be relatively easy to “top” existing devices (apparently not by the failed wannabes out there) when you can see what their positives and negatives are but it’s shameful to see so many so-called ‘iPhone killers” sponge off the work and R&D;of others (ie, Apple) in such a parasitic manner then have the nerve and gall to brag about how great and supposedly superior their “new” product is.
…
If this device is not even on the market yet, all of this talk about price and quality by the CEO is PREmature and PREtentious. And who came up with that name? People will just say it’s a PREdictable iPhone PREtender.
“‘Why would we do that when we have a significantly better product,’ he asked, then walked away.”
Why indeed. It never ceases to amaze me how many people think profits come from volume/market share. The holy grail is profits first, then share because your product is superior.
Colligan responded to the idiot’s question just as he should have, with disdain.
Everybody dismissing Palm’s Pre today, sound just like everybody that dismissed the iPhone 2 years ago. Today all those naysayers look like fools. Two years from now all of today’s “Pre” naysayers are going to look like fools, especially MDN because they can’t report without doing so through Apple colored glasses.
I will say one thing for Palm… there not connected at the hip to AT&T;… and that’s worth something of late!
No one has yet mentioned the one seeming advantage of the Palm — multiple apps open at once.
Not sure what this will do to the security of the device, but being able to cut and paste between apps (or, frankly, to be able to cut and paste) is certainly a plus.
(BTW – very happy iPhone v1.0 owner…)
If Palm is going to pull this off (if) they can’t go low end.
Famous last words!
Still, it does look a fairly well rounded product and puts a little pressure on the iPhone to stay ahead, and oh yeah add: spotlight search, copy & past, having multiple apps open, iChat etc
Suppose we will have to wait until June again!
“Why would we do that when we have a significantly better product?”
Because you may want to sell a few?
My fiancee has long nails and has no trouble at all typing on her iPhone. She can “tick-tick-tick” out a message way faster than I can.
I want to see his face when Pre comes out and at the same time Apple introduces new iPhone na OS 3.0
Oh crap, another 2 years of innovating ahead of us, start your copiers palm people.
Didnt Palm hire John Rubinstein who used to work at Apple? I guess he kicked some butt internally, because Palms webOS looks like it has some smart things.
Many comments sounds like you didnt see Palms video of the presentation. I would strongly go see it. http://www.palm.com/us/products/phones/pre/palm-pre-ces.html
I do not think it is an iPhone killer, because it will take alot of better phone models, and for Apple to stop innovating before the iPhone will die. I dont think Palm intented to make an iPhone killer, i think it is only Microsoft that wants to destroy Apple. I think Palm wants to make great mobile products, and i think the smartphone market is growing and big enough to allow Apple, Palm, and other competitors to live side by side.
While it looks like Palm copied the iPhone, it may very well be that both Palm and Apple copied someone elses HCI research into how to interact with small screens, or interaction by hand.
Remember that it wasnt apple that invented the computer mouse, nor did apple invent touch screens.
I think the Palm webOS seems like a good product, and i fully expect Apple to learn from it and make improvements.
well said Jon….a gem of a comment in a sea of garabage from whiny, crying, fanboys. In short, WebOS looks to be a step ahead of everything on the market (yes, even the mighty iphone). Whether it sells well, will be an entirely different story. Apple makes pretty good products, but their best strength is that they have the best marketing in the business.
@ whistler
Wake up!! I see no whining (other than that snotty little comment from the Palm CEO). Apple has good marketing BECAUSE they have good products and the quality sells itself…..others HAVE to rely on marketing to hopefully disguise the mediocrity of their wanna-be’s. Methinks thou be a troll….begone troll!
Those who laughed at the name Wii are probably the same ones that are laughing at the name Pre.
Will the Pre have the same success as the Wii? I doubt, but I think it has a fine chance of existing in the smartphone ecosystem and stimulating other players to keep on improving.
Rock on Palm! I hope the phone lives up to what was shown.
And hopefully not tied to one carrier.
There’s good and bad in the Pre, but there is also in the iPhone. Choice is good. This one looks like is has a better chance of succeeding in the market than most if not all of the other players.
Greg
So because the name rhymes, you contemplate whether the Pre will dominate the market in the same way the Nintendo Wii has?
Based on that alone, I’m ready to vote: you’re a fucking idiot.
Strangest thing in the world happened today:
The Palm Pre won Best of Show at CES…without really BEING at the show. They did a press conference at the Venetian, and Palm had a little shin-dig in one of the meeting rooms at CES, but the Pre was NEVER ON DISPLAY!
Trust me, I tried to find the stupid thing. It was nowhere to be found. My conclusion? VAPORWARE! They don’t really have a working product right now, or they’d have had it on display. So, Palm’s crap.
It would be great for the WebOS loaded Pre to take sales from the WinMo crap that Palm currently sells.
“no Apps or 3d games.”
True. And it’s very upsetting that the Palm Pre won’t be able to make fart noises.
“No real App store.”
The jury’s out on this one, but I somewhat agree. It’s interesting that they’re using HTML5/JavaScript for the development environment (a la the first generation of iPhone) but it sounds like you’ll be able to download these things into “apps.”
It’s an interesting idea, but I’m not real big on it. And I have my doubts about how well I’ll be able to take advantage of the hardware.
But, then, I’m a Mac developer who had no interest in the iPhone until they came out with an SDK.
“BUT, you are on that crappy network……Sprint.”
Versus being on that crappy network…AT&T?
Palm is yet another stock to eventually short/option put. Make sure to keep your option windows long.
I would not be surprised if Microsoft buys Palm…
Say what you want but if look at any of the numerous photos of the device and read what people have to say who have actually used it, it sounds like it could be an excellent smartphone with a very well designed UI (although it looks like it must be infringing on some of Apple’s patents).
Before you jump to conclusions, please note that I own and use both an iPhone and a Mac and have used Apple products continuously since the Apple II and enjoy them very much. Most of you, including MDN, could stand to be a lot more open minded.
Um, Joe? No one’s used it. It wasn’t at CES, where it was announced, so the only people who have “used it” are Palm and Sprint employees and executives, and personally, I don’t think the stupid thing exists at this point, so I don’t think ANYONE has used it.
PS, pictures don’t mean crap.
I looked at the presentation video, and it looks like a much better phone than Android. But Rubenstein really did copy a lot of iPhone UI conventiontions, like the little bounce when you’re at the end of a scroll, the scrolling with momentum, and the two-finger zooming gesture. I can’t help but think that Jobs is most displeased that Rubenstein took these nice little things that make the great iPhone UI to Palm.
That rug really tied the room together.
Children, please pay attention now!
Some posters confuse ‘there’ and ‘their’, but even more confuse ‘they’re’ and ‘there’.
It’s quite simple really.
*’Their’ is the plural possesive as in: it’s their car, it’s their choice.
*’They’re’ is, of course, the abbreviation of ‘they are”
*And ‘there’ is used for all the rest – it’s used as a pronoun, adverb, adjective, and noun.
Now you can all run along!
But before you go, memorize this sentence:-
They’re happy they’re not there, because their enemies are there.
ATTENTION ALL MORONS,
Poor Ed, He still doesn’t realize that the reason Apple can charge premium prices is because they have one of the strongest ( if not the strongest ) brands on the planet, and they deliver products people want. Palm does not have a platform, they have some phones and a web based operating system.
Now onto patents, Apple has only applied for over 200 patents in the iPhone, Does not mean they have been given those patents. Be assured though that as soon as they have been given these patents they will be cashing checks left and right, or there will be a rapture of “smart phones”. Sorry about the mythological reference there.
Palm could still implement a landscape virtual keyboard if it wanted to and claim that the Palm represents the best of both worlds. More of a reason to buy a Pre than an iPhone. This prototype Pre has plenty to offer, such as copy/paste, L.E.D. flash, higher camera pixel count, background applications, etc. But it is just a prototype. The production model won’t be out for several months and will most likely run into the iPhone 3.0 with updated hardware and Snow Leopard Mobile. Apple won’t be standing still. No handset company will. Palm wll have to gamble everything on this Pre so they better not make any mistakes or Palm is a goner as a company. Apple can throw whatever it takes with its abundant cash reserves at Palm or any other company. Between Google’s Android and Palm NewOS, I think Android has a definite support advantage.
The Pre is for people who have already ruled out iPhone for whatever reason. There will be no material volume of people asking “Pre or iPhone?” That said…
The Pre @ $99 will destroy RIM, the Pre @ $199 will destroy Palm
Only one thing needs to be said about the “Pre”:
IT’S VAPORWARE! V-A-P-0-R-W-A-R-E! IT DOESN’T EXIST! IT’S A HOPE, A PROMISE, A DREAM, A PHANTOM, A WISP, AN ILLUSION, A POTEMKIN VILLAGE, A GHOST. NOTHING MORE!
Let’s all wait until the unit falls into the hands of actual, real-world customers (and Sprint’s less-than-awesome network) before praising or condemning it.* THEN we’ll find out if Palm can right itself in some very deep financial waters.
* And when will this be? Six months? More?
@Crabs
You are mistaken. Check out this link: http://www.engadget.com/2009/01/08/palm-pre-first-hands-on-with-live-updates/ and this one: http://i.gizmodo.com/5126702/palm-pre-preview-simply-amazing
Well, I guess I stand (somewhat) corrected. It still wasn’t anywhere on display at CES, because neither Sprint nor Palm had a booth. And since it makes no sense to announce a phone at CES, but not display it for all the industry folk there, I’m still saying it’s, to a lesser degree, vaporware.
Since Palm hired away much of the iPod/iPhone design team, this phone could actually give Apple a run for their money. They have the knowledge to avoid the mistakes of another copy-cat.
This is why I am ashamed to take my MBP out in public. Someone dares to release a product in the same category as Apple… cue the FanBoy BS….
This thing isn’t even out yet. It is possible that Apple won’t own this segment forever… but ultimately… there are a lot more important things to rant about at this point in history!