“The Psystar story takes another twist as the company now vows to stand up against Goliath Apple promising to fight Apple’s end user license agreement that accompanies Mac OS X 10.5,” Travis Hudson reports for PC World.
“Psystar recently unveiled a $399 Mac Clone called the OpenMac, which has similar internal hardware as Apple’s $2000 Mac Pro. The kicker is that the Psystar computer runs on the Mac OS X. Psystar is now in clear violation of Apple’s EULA,” Hudson reports.
“Now Psystar has come out of the gates swinging as it plans on fighting Apple’s EULA by slinging around some antitrust law violations,” Hudson reports.
Full article here.
MacDailyNews Note: As of this article’s timestamp, Psystar continues to sell their “Open Computer” (née “OpenMac”) for US$399 (2.2GHz Intel Core 2 Duo E4500 Processor, 2GB of DDR2 667 memory, Integrated Intel GMA 950 Graphics, 20x DVD+/-R SATA drive that is Lightscribe-capable, 4 rear USB Ports) and their “OpenPro Computer” starting at US$999 for the base configuration (Intel Core 2 Duo 2.6GHz, GB of DDR2 RAM, GeForce 8600GT 512MB, 150GB 10,000RPM hard drive) via their website (which actually seems to work today).
We wondered what happens when Apple releases Mac OS X 10.5.3 and subsequent updates? From Psystar’s FAQ: It’s best to check the web for this information but when in doubt don’t update it. You may have to reinstall your OS X if it is a non-safe update.
Cringe, then shudder.
This is all a publicity stunt. Other outfits have tried this before and are today nowhere to be found.
They are about to lose all their money paying legal fees trying to fight Apple over selling unlicensed intellectual and trade property developed by and belonging to Apple Inc.
Checked out their site yesterday… the $399 is a lost leader. I priced out a base model at $799. I can get an iMac refurb for that.
MDN’s take is absolutely spot on. This is nothing more than an upstart company saying, “Here we are! Look at us! We’re the good guys!” They, too, will either become PC uglybox assemblers, or they will simply disappear into the ephemera of wannabe’s.
“which has similar internal hardware as Apple’s $2000 Mac Pro.”
??? Yeah right!
Sounds intriguing… sort of like for all the people who don’t want to go through all of the time and effort to hack their Dell to run os x.
Okay, whoever owns this “company” is either the biggest idiot on the planet or the most brilliant.
There’s no middle ground here.
In other words, it’s either the obvious (they have no right and will be shut down immediately) or they found some legal loophole that nobody ever saw coming.
I call bullshit on this unless you are the type of person that doesn’t want wheels when buying a car.
You have to pay to add stuff (at a cost to make it work) like the OS? How about a DVD-burner? Firewire? A reasonable graphics card?
Funny how the costs go up and at the end, it may not work with the next Leopard upgrade.
Oh yeah…I want one…..
will this site ever give balanced views on apple, im not saying what psystar is doing is right just that MDN should point out the positives of this situation as well as the negatives.
So i will add one or two
1)a product like this could bring OS X to the masses, the masses of people that want to try apple but dont feel they can afford to take the risk
2)it shows how badly overpriced apple hardware is
3)it may push apple into upgrading its mac mini line and show apple that if handled correctly it could be a soarway success
yes build em cheap stack em high is not the apple way you say, so what exactly have they done with the ipod line then??? they have products at every price point and to achieve mass market as apple must surely wish then they need to do the same with the mac. The ipod mini/nano story shows that apple can do this without damaging its brand.
Psystar will come and go like those before it. In the meantime enjoy the sensationalism!
More power to them. If that’s what it takes for Apple to get the message that we want more choices than the all-in-one iMac or the non-upgradeable mac mini. Give us a mini tower or allow us to buuild our own systems and ran OSX.
sounds like the ultimate gift for the mother-in-law you really love!!!
“Now Psystar has come out of the gates swinging…”
That’s a mixed metaphor isn’t it? Who comes out of a “gate” while “swinging”?
@macattack,
1) There is more risk with one of these than a true Mac. One of these might not work at all after the next update.
2) How is Apple hardware badly overpriced when it is roughly the same price as comparable systems. Apple’s lack of low cost systems isn’t the same as what they do offer being overpriced.
3) It’s likely this will be crushed so quickly no information will be generated regarding demand. If Apple adjusts their stable at all in response to this, it is more likely they develop the missing mini-tower.
Yesterday, their address was 10645 SW 112th St, Miami, FL. Someone noted in their forum that the location is a residence. Suddenly, today their address is 10481 NW 28th St, Miami, FL, which is an industrial area.
Sounds like Psystar is a load of BS.
There is no doubt that these guys don’t have a leg to stand on…MDN is absolutely correct in their assessment…For PC World to claim that $399 is the true price of the computer (that doesn’t even include an OS), or that it’s similar to the Mac Pro’s hardware is embarrassing for a tech rag. People are trying to create hit traffic and portray Apple as the bad guy…De rigeur of late…Go to Psystar’s site and it’s full of jabs at Apple’s pricing…pathetic. Magic Word: “coming”…As in “OpenMac: NOT coming to a desk near you”.
you completely miss macattacks point, he is neither purporting the psystar computer nor decrying it, he is balancing up MDN’s biased journalism for them,
also name calling without explanation of why you think that is evidence of the dumbed down world we are living in
I speced out the OpenPro to about $1000 less than a comparable mac pro. But the mac pro has a xeon chip so you gotta add that extra cost to the OpenPro to match exactly… then there is no firewire…. lame, now I need to go out and buy a firewire card, Keyboard and mouse??? does it even come with one? If not … add that to the OpenPro cost. Firewire 800? nope.. add that too…iLife already on the mac… add that to the cost. So when it comes down to it…. They aren’t that far off at all and the mac pro looks a shit load better. To top it off as someone mentioned.. will it even work with the new leopard release??
sorry yes the poster above is quite correct, i am not for or against this system, i was actually making a point about the quality of the writing on this site, its one sided cult like to the point of propaganda.
Good journalism is about balance and reason. I made those remarks simply to try and engage the readers brains a little more than the article did.
” . . . come out of the gates swinging…”
I think it’s “come out of Gates swigging” and getting blind drunk afterwards because you can’t believe what you just did.
“similar internal hardware as Apple’s $2000 Mac Pro”
This is so off-base. Looking at the specs it appears closer to the Mini.
@Raymond:
My thoughts exactly: that’s like saying “a new Hyundai, with similar specs to a Ferrari…”
These guys need to be careful and research what they say before spewing stuff like this!
John
Wow, Psystar.com opens almost as fast as MDN…
Good journalism is NOT about balance. It is about truth and accuracy.
@ Jim:
It’s not ‘lost’ leader’ and its not that its just MISleading.
They are picking the wrong fight.
Their product is not worth investing in…
– no guaranty that would run future Mac OS releases
– cheap parts
– little chance that they will be around to support their product
– the few who really need to explore this option have already installed Mac OS X on their non-Apple boxes.
Macromancer:
It’s not and it’s just, as in “it is”.
I am willing to pay for a Mac to get a Mac.
Who’s with me?
http://www.psystar.com/contact.html
Check it out, they’re right next to the Miami Airport to make their quick getaway!!!!
But Psystar raises an interesting issue. I know that Apple says you aren’t allowed to run Leopard on non-Apple equipment. So Apple have a right not to support it. But company warranty is not government law.
Do I have the governmental legal right to try to put any OS on my Mac, given I purchased the copy of Leopard legally?
I know that Apple will threaten them, but may not sue since if Apple looses the case then much more will be at stake for Apple (and ironically MS).
There are no antitrust issues.
Antitrust law involves collusion between multiple companies to substantially control a market. Apple is a single company that can legally have complete control over their own product.
These morons must be getting the same legal advice SCO has been getting…
Not quite the same spec as the Mac Pro, but more evidence that Apple needs a lower-end tower. If these were sold exclusively outside of the US without an OS, they’d probably sell a lot of them.
Most people could get by just fine with 10.4.11 anyway.
“If these were sold exclusively outside of the US without an OS, they’d probably sell a lot of them.”
Like a certain unlocked cellphone (swap carrier for OS)? Hmmm.
im sorry arent truth and accuracy the same thing with regard to an article, i mean if it wasnt accurate it wouldnt be the truth right?
you can tell parts of a story that are true/accurate, but unless you give the whole balanced picture it isnt good journalism
“Most people could get by just fine with 10.4.11 anyway.”
Until 10.6 changes the world.
@brocktoon
sounds like you have been watching too much Fox news
i mean you could tell a story that a woman killed a man and that would be truthful and accurate but completely neglect to mention that it was inself defence, to be accurate you must tell the whole balanced story and good journalism often asks questions to engage its reader/viewer.
I have to agree with other posters that I would like to see more balanced views given by MDN, with more questions asked of apple, i have come away from this often feeling that I have been told what to think rather than make up my own mind. Opinion pieces are great but have to be a written a bit more from a neutral standpoint than we are getting.
Lot’s of new posters, probably all very close to Miami.
@Macromancer and Ampar… I stand corrected… it is just misleading
Unsupported hardware is bad for Apple because if customers buy this product and then find that it stops working when the next OS update comes out, who will get blamed by the press ? Apple or Psystar ?
Apple gets no financial benefit from the sale of these computers, but if they prove to be unreliable, users will say that their Mac doesn’t work properly. It’s a double negative for Apple as they lose a sale and also get the blame when it goes wrong.
While I agree that there is a market for a Mac midi tower, I don’t think that illicit clones are the solution. I’ve always felt that the way forward is for Apple to licence a few PC manufacturers to make Apple-approved computers to be sold as OS X-compatible computers, with strict controls over the exact hardware specification and the quality of the components.
Open mac is running a store bought version of OS X. It’s running on an EFI emulator so OS X thinks it’s a mac. Some extra kexts might have been added to the install to get audio working.
An apple update isn’t going to do anything bad to an open mac install. It’ll behave like a regular os x install on a real mac.
to fight ass-h&los;BRING IT ON SMALL FRY
seems like a publicity stunt if ever i heard one
I still want to know who’s behind Psystar. The fact that they’re vowing to “fight” strongly suggests to me that Psystar is a pawn in someone else’s game to damage Apple’s seemingly unstoppable Mac momentum – either directly (by forcing the issue and being able to sell PC clones that can run OS X), or indirectly (by bringing up the old “Macs are unnecessarily expensive” myth, as is already happening).
Contrary to MDN’s take, I don’t believe this is a “publicity stunt”. Somebody means business here, and it’ll be interesting to find out who that is.
Who can argue with jesus?
This “company” is obviously in it for the short term gain. They may indeed sell enough of these to make a huge profit. I’m guessing that is their “business plan”: sell and run.
What is the warranty? When it is found that they do not support these machines will they refund?
I feel for the people who buy these things; they should be informed that their new purchase will work minimally (that configuration is pretty weak) and for only a limited time.
To jesus et al:
I do believe that MDN can balance or not balance, but the final call belongs to MDN. MDN get their take because MDN belongs to MDN. This forum allows agreement or disagreement or, if you will, balance.
Thank you for your attention. That is all.
what a pointless post, contribute something valuable other than an insult, or at least if you are going to insult back it up with some reason
i agree that there could be loads of customer service issues with this that apple could be blamed for, however we should be talking about the points it does raise such as low cost way to entering the world of mac.
Apple has achieved it with the Ipod, why not the mac?
and i cant comment on america but here in Britain we do seem to pay a hefty premium for apple goods compared to similarly specced windows machines, i recently asked a friend what she was planning to upgrade her ageing desktop to, she said id like a mac but i cant afford it so im going to have to stick with windows. I think a lot of people are in the same position.
i dont think they were questioning the right of MDN to provide almost hysterical goebells like reporting, just the fact that it isnt good journalism
thank you, that is all
Personally, I think Apple’s EULA violates quite a bit of other laws/human rights. Imagine that Sony would sell music that plays anywhere and the EULA would only allow you to play it on Sony players.
It would be Sony’s good right to engineer their music downloads such that it is hard to play on another player, but that is not the same as “forbidding” something that is quite easy to do.
It looks like this world uses double standards for music and Software.
What if software vendors would prohibit running Windows executables under Wine?
What if the entire software industry would issue such restrictive EULA’s?
What would come of such excellent products such as VMware?
In a time of virtualization, it also sounds inappropriate to prevent people to run software on whatever processor, emulator, than one cares to choose. The distinction between hardware/firmware/emulation/virtualization is getting more and more blurry.
If M$ wants to prohibit running Windows under virtualization, everybody hollers this can’t be done. Apparently Apple can do this without much controversy.
In my opinion, Apple is welcome continue to make it difficult for others to run their OS, but it should strike the restriction in their EULA.
Goebbels-like reporting… Really. Really?
That is all.
Pystar is just another leech trying to profit off another open source project. If you really want one of these clone boxes, go to osx86project.org. Download the install instructions and hardware compatibility lists. Buy your choice of quality parts from a reputable known source. Then donate some funds to the project to ensure your box will still work in the future.
Apple is too expensive! My trusty G5 died a few months ago and I decided to get a Mac Pro but on my way there I stopped in at Best Buy. After looking around I decided to buy an HP Quad Core and a Hp 17″ Intel Core 2 Notebook all for 2100 bucks. Installed Mac OS 10.5.2 and 2 months later not one single crash or bump. And I saved about 600 dollars. But what these people are doing is wrong. If you want to build a mac build it yourself. Installing 10.5.x is not easy and basic computer skills wont get you through the install and setup process.
Apple are not anti-competitive; competition usually implies there are two or more competing products, and last time I checked there were plenty of other people making computers and software. Microsoft hasn’t released a special ‘Mac Edition’ of Windows.
Whether you agree with it or not (or like it or not!), Apple, or anyone else for that matter, has the right to defend their property and set the terms for its use, as well as determine the price for its offerings.
If it’s really that irksome to anyone (sucks that your HD-DVD player won’t play Blue Ray discs, huh?), than take the competitive initiative yourself and develop an OS of your own you think is as good or better.
“Apple grossly overcharges for its hardware, stating the computers have a markup of 80 percent.”
R&D;isn’t free. Unless you copy it from someone else -as in the case of Microsoft.
Without Apple – what would computers be like? No mouse. Mono color screens, USB would still be a mystery as to why it’s there, Linotype machines in the print industry, video still on tape, audio still on tape, no iPhone.
On the plus side – there would be no Windows either.
There is your 80% markup. STFU – and pay up thief.
publicity stunt? Let’s see… on day one you blatantly violate Apple’s trademark and get a round of press.
You get people to say things like “a fraction of the cost” when in fact, that is only the case if you completely pirate OSX (which is what they are REALLY encouraging you to do.).
Day two you have a different name and a different config… (well duh its PC hardware there is a plethora of components that all kinda sorta work together)
====
Hopefully they will just go away.
Because as I’ve said before, the Mac OS and Apple gear is a product of a certain business model. Change the business model and you will change the experience.
If you want the product of free software without IP restrictions, you’ll get linux. If you want an OS designed for commodity hardware, you’ll get Windows. Microsoft and Apple are both populated by smart people, they both hire the best designers that money can buy (though MS didn’t use to), they’re both greedy and trying to make as much cash as possible (just like me).
There are two HUGE differences between the companies:
– Microsoft has close to a monopoly and can take its customers for granted. It does not have to Think Different.
– The business model.
Leopard is simple because Apple doesn’t have to lock it up (because they know they’ll get paid for the hardware), have different price points (because they can do that with the hardware). Upgrading to it generally works (generally with Windows you want to buy new hardware when you upgrade).
Apple can also spend an extra $50 here and there for good design because there isn’t a Dell who will pinch every penny possible and take 70% share (you might spend the extra money for design, but your school and/or boss won’t).
Change the business model and you’ll change the Mac.
If you want commodity hardware, please, just use a commodity OS. Contrary to MDN, they’re not that bad. The mac is a yes or no question. Not, as my 7 year old would say, “Yes, but…”
You can go your whole life with Apple free computing and technology. Just say no to apple and move on. Don’t try to make Apple into MS.
Change the business model and you’ll change the Mac.
@vanfruniken – I agree 100% with you – I own apple products and love their design philosophy. But if apple ever becomes a contender with MS in terms of Mac’s penetration into the PC market they are going to have to deal with the clone issue. Either voluntarily or forced to distribute their OS because of a court ruling. I think it would be wise of apple to address this issue now – shutting down company after company in the courts eyes may and probably is the behavior of a monopoly.
I love my macs and apple products – and will be loyal to the brand. But remember they are only a company and they care about one thing and that is maximizing profit.
I am the minister of apple enlightenment and propaganda, you will buy my apple itoilet, its just like a normal toilet but slightly easier to use, for this priviledge you will of course pay over the odds without question, anyone who disobeys this direct order will be labelled with the tag moron or windows sufferer.
Also we will continue our ethnic cleansing by ensuring that apple products are beyond the financial reach of the working class, sneering at those unfortunate enough not to be able to afford apple products must be undertaken at every opportunity.
You will also continue to blindly agree with everything apple or MDN say or do, you have no mind of your own, one state one apple
Heil Jobs!
That is all
The $399 price doesn’t even include Leopard! It also doesn’t include a boatload of other things that make a Mac a Mac.
This thing is not a very good deal, certainly nowhere near the deal Psystar would have you believe:
[url=”http://thesmallwave.com/2008/04/14/psystar-mac-clone-not-the-deal-they-make-it-out-to-be/
“]Psystar Mac Clone Not the Deal They Make it Out to Be.[/url]
@Dr Job-ells
Too funny –
‘If you want the product of free software without IP restrictions, you’ll get linux. If you want an OS designed for commodity hardware, you’ll get Windows. Microsoft and Apple are both populated by smart people, they both hire the best designers that money can buy (though MS didn’t use to), they’re both greedy and trying to make as much cash as possible (just like me).’
Bingo! You don’t have to like it, but it is what it is. Nobody’s twisting your arm. If you don’t want to buy a Mac, then don’t.
It’s obvious. Jean-Louis Gassée’s bankrolling it and Psystar’s shysters. He’s getting even with Jobs for not buying Be.
Since when is “Integrated Intel GMA 950 Graphics” and “Intel Core 2 Duo” similar in any way to a Mac Pro with 4 or 8 cores. Nice reporting…
@James – I agree with what your saying BUT if apple ever gets to the same level of penetration as MS they may look at apple’s aggressive behavior to clone manufactures as being monopolistic. I think the clones will come and go because they don’t have the same hardware and software integration. Personally I think apple legal department should not perform any actions and just let them fall flat on their face.
To Jim – TIV:
“Macromancer and Ampar… I stand corrected… it is just misleading.
Now I’m just confused!
@van Fruitcake
“Personally, I think Apple’s EULA violates quite a bit of other laws/human rights. Imagine that Sony would sell music that plays anywhere and the EULA would only allow you to play it on Sony players.”
Human rights! Last I knew those were concerned with more serious matters:
http://www.iep.utm.edu/h/hum-rts.htm
And if the term is now to mean something else; then whatever it now means must be pretty trivial.
Has the EULA been tested in law — which is what I suppose you mean by the weaselly phrase “violates … law”? No, it hasn’t, and we’ll see what the outcome is if and when it is.
Sony for your information has tried to control what music you can play how and where. Their method was called ATRAC. They also tried to limited what you could play how and where by means of a rootkit:
http://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en-us&q=sony+rootkit&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8
That’s something neither Apple nor any other reputable company has done.
How do you not know this? Have you been living under s stone?
Now Mr von Fruitcake, before you tell me I can put Microsoft’s software where I like, think about this one: it _suits_ MS that I can. Moreover, it suits them that it is difficult for me use anything other than their software. That’s not offering it to me: it’s forcing it down my throat whether I want it or not.
And when Microsoft makes the hardware the boot is on the other foot. I can assure you Mr von Fruitcake that you won’t be running software of your choice on your Zune or on your XBox 360.
“similar in hardware to the MacPro”
Uh, nope. Not even remotely. Closer to the MacBook.
Nor, of course, will you be running the Zune software on some other portable player. Heck, they don’t even play the same formats. PlaysForSure — no it DOESN’T.
If anyone’s still reading the comments, I’ve got a question. A really good one.
If it were truly as easy and legal to make a Mac clone as “Psystar” claims, why did it take a mysterious upstart company to finally try it? Surely Dell could throw the same components in a box and make the same thing, right? So what’s stopping them?
Either it just never occurred to Dell or HP to throw together a Mac clone, or Psystar is full of sh*t. My money’s on the latter.
——RM
@ ihatewindows…. You installed Mac OS 10.5.2 on a HP Quad Core and a Hp 17″ Intel Core 2 Notebook??? …interesting.
An unusual amount of idiots posting comments today. Apple produces quality products. I hate paying a high price but I understand quality. Put the same materials in a PC and guess what…you have the SAME PRICE!!!
I think I might pirate ‘Tired of Retards’ moniker for once….
@LordRobin…it may have occured to them but even if it was doable, would you want the hassle of having an OS upgrade potentially not working with your hardware?
A customer relations horror story…..
Buster, whats wrong with my install?
Psystar changed their website so that the pages for the two flavors of the fraud clone do not say ‘OpenMac’. However, they were too dopey to realize that it still says ‘OpenMac’ on their picture files. Darn. That’s a trademark violation. Go directly to jail…
These guys don’t have a leg to stand on. Apple’s EULA for Leopard is explicit and simple. Anti-trust? Huh? Not applicable.
Now if they had started a suit against Apple BEFORE they broke the law, then fine. Maybe they’d be making some statement about operating systems being cross-platform, much as that would be a waste of time. But NOOOOO, instead they flagrantly broke the law, illegally calling their boxes ‘Macs’ and illegally installing Leopard on them. Very bad. This puts them 100% on the defensive, which means their counter suit will most likely be thrown out of court while Apple’s suit pummels them into oblivion.
Recall that Apple won all their lawsuits over industrial design plagiarism. (There were at least two iMac fakes that made a brief appearance). This case is a ‘real’ (vs Bush / Tenet) SLAM DUNK.
Dr Job-ells sez: “You will also continue to blindly agree with everything apple or MDN say or do, you have no mind of your own, one state one apple.”
HAHAHAHA! Yes, you caught the flavor of the consummate anti-Mac tard-troll perfectly. Well done.
Me: I never buy anything but quality. I don’t waste my money. I don’t care whose brand name is on it. So sorry that currently the brand name is ‘Apple.’ That will change one day once someone creates something better, and I’ll be there…
FINALLY someone is asking questions about Psystar instead of just assuming this is real.
http://blogs.guardian.co.uk/technology/2008/04/15/so_exactly_who_or_what_is_psystar_we_dig_a_little.html
I feel some of the Dr Job-ells post may of been lost on you. Whilst that post wasnt mine I see the points it was making
1) some people would buy a turd if it had an apple logo on it and MDN would still sell it was the most ground breaking turd that there ever was, and a number of apple fan boi’s would swear on their nans lives how wonderful the said turd was and that its going to revelutionise the whole turd industry.
2) that similarly specced machines are cheaper in the pc world, i bought my sony vaio and macbook at the same time and for the same price and the vaio has its own Nvidea graphics card and twice the amount of RAM
3) that MDN and a growing number of fan boi’s refuse to look at anything apple in a balanced way, almost like they have been brainwashed ala goebbels
4) that the less well off in society are excluded from the mac world
You say you buy apple because you only buy quality, fair enough, but why should the poorer members of society not be able to access the mac, we all agree the mac as a system is a class above windows, why should there be some social divide with regards to have and have nots. To make matters worse people that often cant afford to buy macs have to buy windows and then take criticism from sites like MDN labelling them morons.
Fell yourself lucky you can afford to buy into the Mac world
*feel yourself lucky
hi i’m david currie, you may know me from such infomercials such as “I’m a smug arrogant tit” and “i look down my nose at poor people”……..thanks for your time
whats the only thing worse than being david currie, being an egg, you only get laid once, smashed once and the only thing to have sat on your face is your mom
now im the consumate anti-currie tard troll
and i like it……..uh huh
@ HolyMackerel
Yes it is illegal when you do it commercially.
Cheers!
if this computer was released in europe, apple might not win the case, european law i believe would make that element of the EULA unenforceable as my understanding of the law there goes. Once purchased the software may be used in any way the conumer so desires as long as its not pirated.
@david currie
you forgot….you come in a box with 11 other guys!!!
@ihatewindows…Didn’t say something was wrong, I was interested in how you did it…i.e. got Leopard to run on a PeeCee.
@what if they did it in europe
WTO would have supported Apple and in fact it would have been taken down sooner.
@ vanfruniken
Except you’re missing the most important point: Apple Macs are all about the combination of both hardware and software – it’s the whole package.
This is completely different from any other vendor on the consumer market.
How you a complex operating system can be likened to “music downloads” is such an over-simplification only a moron would buy into, and i had to read your analogy several times to make sure you didn’t mean something else. Pure idiocy.
As for your “virtualisation” argument – how the heck can you compare Windows (a software only product) with Mac (the combination of software and hardware). Only the synaptically challenged amongst us would fail to see the difference here.
Just because Microsoft has chosen a software-only approach in order to expand rapidly market-wise (they were only too happy for their OS to be pirated as it assured widespread uptake), it does not mean we should expect Apple Inc to do the same with the Mac, which many feel offers a better experience precisely because of the hardware/software integration.
the same WTO that are hammering china so hard for copywrite violation, lol
or the same european union that love to hammer big business where they feel it will benefit the end consumer, on that note it wont be long before the EU grabs apple by the balls for making Europe pay more than america for apple products. In the UK the iphone 16gb is $650.
The end solution will be something like the iphone in france, a version of os x will be sold for psystar style machines at a slightly more expensive price that reflects apple r and d adequately. Yes i know I havent fine tuned this business model exactly but you get the gist of what will eventually happen.
Even if Pystar could legally sell these machines, they couldn’t make any money and would close their doors in a couple of months. A Mac OS X license is $129, and if they get it for less, they’re either using educational versions or family pack versions, which are also violations of the EULA.
Based on $129 for Mac OS X, that only leaves $270 for components. No way they build decent PCs for that price and actually pay people to put them together, let alone pay for their website, etc.
I ran the numbers…
A Psytar clone could save me all of $18 over a mini!
Gosh, that’s really compelling there.
Details are here:
http://photo-hh.blogspot.com/2008/04/psystar-mac-clone-could-save-me-all-of.html
@ vanfruniken
“What if software vendors would prohibit running Windows executables under Wine?
What if the entire software industry would issue such restrictive EULA’s?”
I believe MS and the other software companies wouldn’t give a hoot what kind of hardware people run their software on. And with good reason – they are SOFTWARE companies. Bottom line, they make practically all their money from it.
Apple is much more a HARDWARE company. Their main source of income is the hardware they produce. You think the price of retail Mac OS X (or even iLife) reflects the amount of time and effort put into building it? Why do you think MS charges hundreds more for Windows compared to Mac OS X?
So yes, it’d be nice to have more options and lower prices when it comes to Macs. But no, this “we’re fighting the big bully for everyone” kind of crap is definitely not the way to go. Besides, Phystar’s machines are definitely not worth it, just dig a little deeper and you’ll see.
Most of us live in free countries, right? So make your choice. Like it, buy it. If not, don’t.
@ bizlaw
$399.00 does not include the OS
they charge $155.00 for mac OS X
macattack, if there’s a Mac price premium it’s for the software value-add, which is unique to the Mac. As stated above, Apple has to fund its OS X and iApp R&D;somehow.
I believe any company has the right to sell a PC with OS X installed on it. Provided they use a retail copy of OS X. EULA’s are not enforceable especially when you can’t read them until you have already opened the box.
Apple can go after them for trademark infringement though. They would have a case against “OpenMac”.
i think the argument here is not for or against psystar, its for and against an affordable mac, the mini is the neglected child of the apple family
@ MacDaddy “Yes it is illegal when you do it commercially.”
But what if it was Amazon selling both Leopard and an OS-less Psystar on their site, even as a bundle. You could choose to buy the Psystar and Windows, or the Psystar and Leopard.
I don’t think this would be illegal, but would still be unwarranted.