American Idol, X-Factor’s Simon Cowell considers lawsuit against Apple re iTunes’ Leon Jackson snafu

“Simon Cowell is considering launching legal proceedings against iTunes after fans were prevented from downloading X-Factor winner Leon Jackson’s single.” Carl Stroud reports for The Sun.

“Demand melted the music firm’s servers shortly after When You Believe went on sale at midnight on Saturday,” Stroud reports. “The problem was only resolved some 15 hours later.”

“An insider at SonyBMG said: ‘Everybody here is up in arms. There’s been a monumental cock up. Simon is hugely disappointed about the situation and is considering launching legal proceedings. Everybody is really upset for Leon and don’t want technical malfunctions to mar his big week,'” Stroud reports. “A spokesperson for iTunes declined to comment.”

Full article here.

PR plant. ‘Tis no surprise that The Sun ran it immediately.

73 Comments

  1. Another Rotund Glutonous Bastard raises yet another cry of “foul most horrid!” meanwhile all the phone participants have been milked for all their worth to end up with crap in exchange.

    How do we know that itunes servers were melted down? Has Apple inc. issued a statement to that effect? Is that fat bastard implying that itunes servers are substandard?

    Or maybe, just maybe the so called market for X-factor crap has cottoned onto the scam he has been plying all these years & have voted with their wallets?

    He should be sued by Apple inc. A precedent is calling to be set here.

    Now if he were to Drink Camel’s Milk, the tuneless fart he emits would lace his palate with such a foul stench that he would think carefully in future before serving up X-Craptor again!!

  2. What can you expect from a paper owned by Rupert Murdoch, owner of News Corporation, mercenary sellout and appeaser of communist dictatorships?

    It amazes me that a man who pays so little tax on the massive profits of his companies (some people say it is as little as 6% on the global profits of the entire NewsCorp concern) is allowed to have so much influence on politics in the USA, UK and Australia. Back in the late-18th century, the American colonies protested on the principle of “no taxation without representation”. Murdoch has managed to turn this principle on its head so one man now has far more lobbying power than the trade union movement in any of the countries in which he operates.

    Still, there are a significant number of people who post here who swallow everything this dinosaur pumps out through Faux Noise as if it were the gospel truth, so they’ll presumably buy this piece of trivialised nonsense with the same enthusiasm.

  3. What if thousands of people turned up at physical stores and didn’t wait in line?

    The Sun is only fit for the recycling bin before it’s delivered to the newsagents. [F]ans were prevented from downloading, prevented is the wrong word here, very inflammatory language, they just had to wait a while for the queue to subside. That is if we take The Sun’s uncontested version as having some semblance of truth, which would make it atypical.

    Murdoch is firmly in the anti-Apple camp, those who wish to take control from the people (or I should say even more control), you can only vote for people who the corporations bankroll anyway.

    @ MCCFR

    Take a look back at the early history of the neo-cons, they were all radical socialist too. What they learned is that you can achieve totalitarianism through two means, govt taking over business didn’t work so they ‘switched sides’ and now they are trying the other way. Same with neo-labour in the UK.

    Murdoch is just after money and power, what was the James Bond movie based on him?

  4. You would never see a cock up like this at Zune Marketplace. Apple is a niche player and doesn’t understand the complexities of high demand mission critical server technology like Microsoft does.

    When you send that e-mail of a monkey peeing on himself to 50 of your coworkers how do you think it gets done? Right, an Exchange server efficiently distributes data with ease for your colleague’s enjoyment. That monkey got us through some tough times. I assume this same technology is in Zune Marketplace. It’s pretty snappy. Put another way, Microsoft doesn’t cock up.

    Your potential. Our passion.™

  5. “There’s been a monumental cock up.”

    Not even a tenth as monumental as SonyBMG rootkit. Yet nobody at SonyBMG was up in arms about that. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”raspberry” style=”border:0;” />

  6. I refuse to believe that anyone with a triple digit IQ could possibly care about anything related to “American Idol.” Please do feel free to mock the show’s contestants. Yes, some of them have expressive vocal chords and can sing on key. That seems to be the extent of their talent. The fact that millions of American sheeple love the show only proves my point. Pure, insipid pabulem.

  7. @ @MCCFR…

    Go climb a rope!

    If I want to take a pop at Murdoch, NewsCorp, News International and The Sun for steadily deprecating the level of intelligence in the media and the general population based on this story, I’m perfectly entitled to do so.

    Let’s remember Murdoch’s theory that regime change in Iraq was a good idea because it would lead to a $20 barrel of oil. The guy’s a fscking genius (not)!

    Let’s reflect in the fact that the three main partners in Iraq were the US, UK and Australia; now let’s correlate that to News Corps’ news/media interests. See the relationship?

  8. If it’s true that Apple’s servers couldn’t handle the load then that IS Apple’s fault. Can anyone here say they tried to download the song and couldn’t because the iTunes servers were down? I wasn’t downloading the night this happened ( I think it was December 20). Also, The Sun should have gotten a comment from Apple regarding this issue. That’s what’s really missing in this story. Finally, Sony would never miss an opportunity to poke Apple in the eye with a sharp stick.

  9. Is this relevant to anyone’s life? The general IQ of American seems to be plummeting every moment. I saw a television program about guys playing video game football. A television program about a video game. Will there be a program about people watching a program about video games? Sheeesh. Why have the reality checks been delayed in the mail?

  10. Is this relevant to anyone’s life? The general IQ of American seems to be plummeting every moment. I saw a television program about guys playing video game football. A television program about a video game. Will there be a program about people watching a program about video games? Sheeesh. Why have the reality checks been delayed in the mail?

  11. Is this relevant to anyone’s life? The general IQ of American seems to be plummeting every moment. I saw a television program about guys playing video game football. A television program about a video game. Will there be a program about people watching a program about video games? Sheeesh. Why have the reality checks been delayed in the mail?

  12. Is this relevant to anyone’s life? The general IQ of American seems to be plummeting every moment. I saw a television program about guys playing video game football. A television program about a video game. Will there be a program about people watching a program about video games? Sheeesh. Why have the reality checks been delayed in the mail?

  13. Is this relevant to anyone’s life? The general IQ of American seems to be plummeting every moment. I saw a television program about guys playing video game football. A television program about a video game. Will there be a program about people watching a program about video games? Sheeesh. Why have the reality checks been delayed in the mail?

  14. The only things gay Simon’s and drunk Paula’s little show have reliably produced are cheap entertainment and country music stars.

    While I do agree iTMS needed to address the problem much sooner, in a world where people camp outside stores for days to buy things, it’s not a big deal. If anyone was hurt here it was Apple.

    Whatever, let Simon sue. I’d love to see him take his condecending tone with any judge! Contempt of court, baby. Do we see another Paris-in-jail fiasco coming? ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

  15. Firstly, as much as I’d like to deny it, this is a story about the UK version of X-Factor which is Cowell ripping off the original Pop Idol/American Idol format.

    Secondly, I don’t understand how any “journalist” (or even someone who works for any of Murdoch’s tabloid “news” operations) would fail to see the minor flaw in SonyBMG’s “leak” which is that – despite being on sale for three days through iTunes – this karaoke cover version of a pretty saccharine song has sold less copies than the competition winner from the previous year sold in the first hour.

    This suggests any number of interpretations: how about people thought about buying it, then had an attack of taste and spent their money on something else. Or maybe, and I’m just pulling something out of the air here, it’s crap.

    So there is more than a slim possibility that Cowell and SonyBMG are trying to cover up the artist’s lack of credibility with the hip, digital download marketplace by blaming Apple and iTS.

  16. “Everybody is really upset for Leon and don’t want technical malfunctions to mar his big week”

    Is that someone at SonyBMG admitting that Leon’s song sucks and demand for his song is going tank after a week and his career is going absolutely nowhere like every other reality TV singing show winner?

  17. I have yet to see any corroboration from any source that Simon is contemplating action, neither have I seen anything to suggest that any single song would be capable of ‘melting’ the iTunes servers.

    Sounds like typical ‘Sun’ newspaper cr@p to me.

  18. “Everybody is really upset for Leon and don’t want technical malfunctions to mar his big week.”

    What a LOAD. Simon cares only about ONE thing: money in Simon’s pocket. He lost out on some revenue from would-be customers who would have only made a spur-of-the-moment purchase. Now he’s contemplating suing to further line his pockets. What an asshole.

  19. Simon Cowell S@#KS monumental COCK, and so do his stupid shows. This is a case he’ll never win – I’m POSITIVE Apple put a clause in their contracts with artists and record companies that protects Apple from this sort of thing.

    American Idol is one of the most sorry-ass excuses for televised entertainment in history.

  20. So Simon Cowells’s latest puppet has not sold as many songs as he wanted… Big deal!

    I’m sure that he don’t need the money.

    Besides, Leon will only have career for 6 months anyway until Simon drops the singer for some other talentless drone that can be manipulated to Simon’s profit and personal bank account.

    I say bring it on!

    Apple will eat that selfish asshole for breakfast.

  21. American Idol is one of the most sorry-ass excuses for televised entertainment in history.

    At least Paula’s still hot, even if she’s drunk/wasted/insane/whatever.

    Anyway, forget Idol. YouTube for “The Gong Show” sometime. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

  22. There is a hint of poetic justice in this.

    ‘X-Factor’ is the UK equivalent of ‘American Idol’, where various acts perform each week to win through to the next round and be crowned the eventual winner, with a £1,000,000 recording contract and the chance to release a festive song which normally gets to the Christmas #1 music chart position. Obviously, each time the public phone to vote for an act, Simon Cowell’s company get a large portion of the call charges.

    In the Grand Final last week, the two remaining acts, Leon Jackson and Rhydian Roberts (the favourite to win), were voted on by the public, but after the show there were accusations of vote rigging as people voting for Rhydian couldn’t get through on the phone lines as they were continually ‘busy’. While apparently Leon’s supporters had no problems voting for him.

    Now, if people can’t download Leon Jackson’s song and get it to the prestigious Christmas #1 Chart position because Apples servers are overloaded (and prevent Cowell from making more money), isn’t that some sort of justice?

  23. @offkey,

    Re: Paula Abdul, I must agree, she is still one of the sexiest women on the face of the planet, even if drunk, nuts, or whatever.

    Unfortunately everything else on American Idol negates that. It is painful to watch. Unfortunately (at least here in the US) that’s about all the fare there is to watch this season considering the writers’ strike. So I’ll be watching reruns of crap that I never wanted to watch anyway before I’ll ever watch a new or repeat episode of Idol.

  24. @Bartsimpsonhead

    ‘American Idol’ is the US equivalent of ‘Pop Idol’, which was developed in UK by Simon Fuller (producer of Spice Girls). ‘X-Factor’ was Simon Cowell’s copy-cat show that originally saw him sued by Fuller for breach of contract and breach of copyright; Cowell was a judge on the original first season of ‘Pop Idol’ in 2001 and the first season of ‘American Idol’ in 2002.

  25. Ferf,

    Just say no! Turn that darn boob tube off and do something constructive. Go to the library and read a classic novel. Take a night class and further your education. Or learn a new skill or hobby like embroidery or pottery. Get into exercise and develop that buff, rock hard, manly physique that all the chicks go for. The possibilities are freakin’ mind boggling and endless! Whataya say, buddy?

    The above comments are something you might hear from one of those liberal, left wing, tofu munching West Coast nut jobs.
    Avoid them like the plague.

    Instead, kick back in your LazyBoy, open a bag of chips, pop the tab on a cool brewski and flip those channels! It’s what I do. It’s the American way of life! Enjoy.

  26. The biggest – stinkin’ pieces of sorry-as there is…

    If you COULDN’T get it from iTunes… HOW about from SONY?

    Any word on that…

    THIS is a Sony jab at Apple…

    IT NEVER HAPPENED.

    I WAS DOWNLOADING SEVEN SONGS THAT NIGHT

    no problem.

    BTW none of the songs were X-FuKtors.

    DONNY DEVITO

  27. @MCCFR

    “What can you expect from a paper owned by Rupert Murdoch, owner of News Corporation, mercenary sellout and appeaser of communist dictatorships?”

    and

    “Let’s reflect in the fact that the three main partners in Iraq were the US, UK and Australia; now let’s correlate that to News Corps’ news/media interests. See the relationship?”

    Those are your quotes. Lets ‘correlate’… seems to mean that USA, UK and Australia are run by Communist Dictators. Hmmm.

    Thanks for the great wisdom and insight.

  28. So I’ll be watching…crap that I never wanted to watch anyway

    And soon, we’ll be able to thank MS for that:
    http://macdailynews.com/index.php/weblog/comments/15863/

    Sad is when one has hundreds of channels to watch, and only a couple of decent shows worth watching.

    Let’s look at the situation here:
    – TV sucks.
    – Jobs is “in” with Disney, Pixar, and Hollywood.
    – AppleTV needs content.
    – Jobs has a knack for showing his competitors how bad they suck.

    Is the answer all but screaming for itself or what?

  29. I am disappointed because I could not call in on the phone, So I think i am going to look into suing SIMON’s production. What About That… It is a two way street Simon, your equipment failed(out dated Microsoft crap telephony) . If you plan on suing Apple for the same reasons, then don’t be surprised if you get suing tooo.

    This suing crap has got to stop, for any little thing these big goofs throw up the SUING flag. GET A CLUE Simon. Your time in the spot light is limited, not to mention your show sucked and was stupid.. I watched it 5 times and never watched it again…

    Go ahead an try to get to Apple, I would love to see you fall on you face, and I agree, become another Speers…. Can you say BROKE (financially)

    GO APPLE

  30. Poo…

    I didn’t say or write that. But because you’re probably a member of the Faux Noise fan club, it suits you to conflate the two issues.

    It’s the same as saying Prescott Bush was a Nazi sympathiser because he helped to launder money for the Thyssen family before the full-blown outbreak of WWII. He wasn’t, but he was an opportunist who made money working to enable “financial solutions” for a supporter of the Nazi party.

    Murdoch is the same: a man who’ll criticise watered-down social democracy in the EU (where it works for the public good) because (for the most part) he’s never been able to convince mainstream Europe of the validity of his opinions, but prevents any criticism of a totalitarian Communist regime in the PRC through his media empire because it might jeopardise his interests in Star TV.

    I think my point about Murdoch is that he’s a man of principles until there’s a solid commercial reason to forget those same principles, whether that reason is one that will benefit or damage News Corporation; personally, I prefer my news broadcasters to either take a consistent editorial position or to take no editorial position as opposed to changing them to suit their commercial objectives. If you take a different position, then that’s your business.

  31. The main reason Simon and X-Factor are so upset is because they know that any sales for this guy is only going to be in the first 15 hours since the short-attention-spanners that the television-music-marketing caters too are going to completely forget about this guy by the next day… They’ll try and download right after the show, get an error message and tell themselves, “I’ll just try to download it tomorrow”. Then the next day they’ll wake up and say, “What was I going to do today, hmmmm.. Oh well… Oh! look at the new show on TV… America’s Top Janitor! Let’s watch that!”

    That’s why they’re so upset, because they’re not selling music, they’re selling a product with an extremely short shelf life.

  32. Truth,

    That sounds about right. Those kind of viewers leap from one shiny (or noisy) bauble to the next. Their id bounces around inside their skull like a ping-pong ball; until it slips through one of the holes.

    P.S.

    I’ve looked and looked, but I canNOT find ‘America’s Top Janitor’ in the TV Guide. Any idea what channel and time?

  33. This is a really embarrassing PR stunt. The guy is a very average baritone making the unfortunate decision to release a Mariah Carey song as his first single. The Cowell press release is a desperate attempt to get first week sales up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.