Does Apple’s iPhone security really ‘rival that of Microsoft’s Windows 95’ as Wired claims?

“Writing for Wired, Kim Zetter published an article that attempts to portray the iPhone as a security boondoggle on the order of Windows 95, due to fundamental mistake Apple made in designing it. Fortunately, Zetter is wrong, here’s why,” Daniel Eran Dilger writes for RoughlyDrafted.

“Zetter’s article revolves around the idea that because the iPhone runs all its internal applications as the same root user account, users are imperiled by potential crisis. How bad is it? Windows bad, at least according to Zetter’s headline,” Dilger writes.

“Zetter clearly does not understand the subject matter she presents, and should not be writing about it without first passing her copy to someone with security credentials. She also should have talked to more than just one source; in this case it was Dan Geer, who only seems to be an expert at being an expert,” Dilger writes. “What’s next, an article on global warming, interviewing science fictionalist Michael Crichton?”

Dilger dares Wired “to have Zetter rewrite the article after interviewing more than one source. Perhaps this would result in an informed, balanced piece rather than a simple regurgitation of the message one individual fed her as a story.”

“The entire premise of Zetter’s article is flawed; running services as root makes no difference to users, and does not expose them to special rings of evil. Apple has also released rapid patches for addressing vulnerabilities that have been found. Incidentally, they were found in large part because the iPhone is built using a lot of publicly scrutinized, mature code,” Dilger writes. “Windows isn’t; its a black hole of proprietary software that is only ‘open’ in the sense of Pandora’s Box. Which is why Windows–and not just Windows 95–most certainly does not rival the security of the iPhone, hypothetically or in practical terms.”

Much more in the full article here.

62 Comments

  1. @anthony007

    Nuff with the misogynist crapola also.

    If she was black would that mean that all black tech writers are also idiots?

    You are probably just a little kid, but just so you know there are a ton of female hackers and techies. For instance, Erica Sadun is (judging by the name) also a woman but she is one of the leading lights in the iPhone hacker community, which is kind of the bleeding edge of Apple tech know-how right now.

    No one with a mind as closed as yours could possibly be smart enough to call out even this idiotic columnist, let alone make any pronouncements about tech in general so maybe you should leave the commenting to people who know what they are talking about.

  2. Fact check here.

    If you go through Michael Crichton’s book: “State of Fear,” you will find that while it is not his best story ever, it does accurately portray Global Warming for what it is, A POLITICAL MOVEMENT.

    All Chrichton does is point out that every single piece of evidence for Global Warming has many more than ONE solitary explanation.

    What Global Warming does quite nicely is fit into the plans of those who seek to blame industrialized nations (read: The United States) for all their ills.

    People slaughtering each other in Dafur? Well it must be due to starvation which is of course due to Global Warming, which is of course because of the United States, which must somehow be the fault of George Bush.

    Chrichton effectively shows that we are being pushed in a direction by people who use our FEARS to manipulate us.

    In this sense, the article concerning the iPhone is more akin to the people who shout GLOBAL WARMING in the crowded global theatre, than it is Chrichton’s views.

  3. I don’t know anything about UNIX but if Steve says it’s OK for everyone to use the same ROOT account, it must be fine…..

    Mac Users don’t “tinker” with that OS stuff… We just believe everything Jobs says and remember, every Apple product is perfect!!!

  4. Y’see this is why I never read RoughlyDrafted. Not only are his articles just that, roughly drafted, but he continues to mix in political asides into his writing. The latter has the effect of making him look even more stupid than his low quality of writing does. And as far as Chrichton being an idiot, does Al Gore have any more scientific background? Chrichton, as an SF writer, has to know how science works. Do you really think Al knows as much? Just shut up Daniel.

    As far as Zeitgeist goes, why don’t you make your point right here?

    As far as Bush goes, is Edwards any better, ranting about how soon all young black males will be dead or in jail? How about Hillary, who acts as though the world will end if children are not insured by the government? How about Kerry, who seems to think it’s a horrible thing that we don’t play kissy-face with the Europeans? If Bush is so successful at playing on fears, then why do opinion polls put his job performance in the toilet? Something doesn’t add up, guys.

    What the real deal is here is that Bush presents more of the real world than you can handle. Now if you can’t handle Bush, I doubt you could ever handle a Reagan or a TR. You whining internet libtards couldn’t handle the real truth of knowing how many foreign nationals cross the border each year, how the police CAN’T protect you everywhere you go, how many mosques preach death to America in the U.S. alone, and on and on. Bush is a fear-monger only to the most cowardly. To those of us without blinders on, he’s too soft.

  5. “Wow, this sure got off-topic, I expected more people to zing Wired for their gonzo-styled journalism. Instead we get rants on global warming….wtf?”

    so a sexist, a conservative and a bunch of Mac fans all walk into a thread……

  6. Reagan and Bush(es) were/are puppets of the ‘owning class’, unless you’re part of that, you are just fodder for their use. BTSOI, have you ever researched ‘false flag’ operations? Have you researched wealth accumulation rates over the past 30 or so years? The only candidates who are challenging the status quo are Paul, Gravel, and Kucinich. They have more than just the highest bidder in mind.

    In regards to this thread, I tried finding the original offending article at wired, no such luck, weird.

    Dan keep up the excellent work, I don’t mind the political jabs, they are usually very apropos to the subject at hand.

  7. @ shen – neither you nor Dilger can expect to make goofy political remarks in the context of a tech post and have people ignore it. If you put politics into your public writing, you are inviting people to comment. When they do, don’t get all whiny and start calling people names.

    And you shouldn’t, btw, assume the political makeup of mac users…

  8. Why is stating the obvious so offensive: The NFL and NBA are 90 percent black. So it’s obvious that blacks are better athletes than whites. However, noone dares state it because it’s not PC or it’s considered racist. I say, fuck that shit.

  9. If you guys could take your fingers off the trigger for a moment and read the friggin’ article, perhaps you’d see that the point being made isn’t about Crichton’s views on global warming, but how using one source for an article – particularly when that source is at odds with the majority, be they right or wrong – is shoddy journalism. It’d be just as bad if she’d written a glowing review of iPhone security using only one source.

  10. If you guys could take your fingers off the trigger for a moment and read the friggin’ article, perhaps you’d see that the point being made isn’t about Crichton’s views on global warming, but how using one source for an article – particularly when that source is at odds with the majority, be they right or wrong – is shoddy journalism. It’d be just as bad if she’d written a glowing review of iPhone security using only one source.

  11. If you guys could take your fingers off the trigger for a moment and read the friggin’ article, perhaps you’d see that the point being made isn’t about Crichton’s views on global warming, but how using one source for an article – particularly when that source is at odds with the majority, be they right or wrong – is shoddy journalism. It’d be just as bad if she’d written a glowing review of iPhone security using only one source.

  12. If you guys could take your fingers off the trigger for a moment and read the friggin’ article, perhaps you’d see that the point being made isn’t about Crichton’s views on global warming, but how using one source for an article – particularly when that source is at odds with the majority, be they right or wrong – is shoddy journalism. It’d be just as bad if she’d written a glowing review of iPhone security using only one source.

  13. If you guys could take your fingers off the trigger for a moment and read the friggin’ article, perhaps you’d see that the point being made isn’t about Crichton’s views on global warming, but how using one source for an article – particularly when that source is at odds with the majority, be they right or wrong – is shoddy journalism. It’d be just as bad if she’d written a glowing review of iPhone security using only one source.

  14. Excuse Me but…: If you go through Michael Crichton’s book: “State of Fear,” you will find that while it is not his best story ever, it does accurately portray Global Warming for what it is, A POLITICAL MOVEMENT.

    Oh, absolutely! The vastness of this conspiracy is only underscored by the fact that even mother nature is apparently in cahoots with the evil UN on this…!

  15. I am normally a fan of Dilger, but he has really blown it on this one.

    1. Yes, Zetter’s article is overblown. I’m especially unhappy with giving Vista a pass simply because it asks for permission. This is inappropriate because it asks for permission unnecessarily (as so hysterically satirized in the Apple commercial) – so often that people blindly give it just to shut it up. And not that it doesn’t ask for a password, it just warns you. Is this because it is running as root? Inquiring minds would like to know…

    This is as opposed to Mac OS X only asking when necessary, and constructing things so that this is only done rarely.

    However, as Zetter’s article says, correctly, the principle of least privilege is a well established best practice for security design. Dilger is wrong to criticize this.

    2. Yet Dilger is correct to say that Apple has turned off obvious security flawed technology that need wide access due to poor design like Active X (unlike, for example, Java applets).

    It appears that Dilger knows his argument is weak, and tries to support it through personal attacks – disappointing, and further weakening his case.

    3. Lets give an analogy: imagine that you have a factory with highly sensitive areas, medium sensitive areas and public (low) sensitive areas.

    Running as root means that when any hole (an unlocked door, an unlocked air conditioning vent) is found you get access to everything simply because, in this analogy, there are no additional security checks. This is very bad.

    The appropriate solution is to run with the least access possible to do what you need, and ramp up only as needed, and only for as long as needed. And, if you don’t have the authority to ramp up, you don’t get access.

    This means that all medium security areas are surrounded by locked doors, and only a medium or greater security badge will get you in.

    However, if you want to get into the really sensitive, high security stuff, you will need to go through another, additional locked door, and this door will only open if you have high security clearance.

    If you went through an unlocked door on the outside, you would only get into the medium security areas, not the high security areas, and this is the point.

    4. I have no special knowledge, but I am certain that Jobs knows this. I am also certain that this situation will be fixed when the iPhone Software Development Kit is released.

    After all, we’re talking about an industrial strength, high security operating system on the iPhone – Unix, in its OS X flavour.

    The fact that all applications run as root on the iPhone is simply a temporary bug, and was done to reduce development effort.

    5. It would be interesting, and only fair, to analyze all other phones – how many of them run as root? I’m sure most if not all of them do.

    But this doesn’t mean its a good idea. And, Apple, especially, who tries harder with design, has to do better and should have done better. But, I am sure, will do better very soon, with the next rev.

    MDN magic word is uncanny as it often is:

    soon, as in this will soon be fixed

  16. “@ shen – neither you nor Dilger can expect to make goofy political remarks in the context of a tech post and have people ignore it.”

    umm, i didn’t, i made fun of the people who first did. try reading sometime.

    “If you put politics into your public writing, you are inviting people to comment.”

    yeah, see again, i was the one commenting. if you think that making fun of Micheal “quatum foam” Crit is “bringing politics into your writing” then you need more help than i get you over the net….

    ” When they do, don’t get all whiny and start calling people names. “

    third time is the charm, you will notice that i only pointed out that “busting” was fear mongering. that isn’t name calling, that is reality. read his post.

    MW: “before” as in before you post you should actually see if you understood what you are responding to. you failed that one….

  17. regarding global warming:

    Hate to bust anybody’s bubble, but there are a couple of scientific facts that people need to digest:

    1. As of 2005, the 10 hottest years since the human race has been tracking it, have all occurred in the past 14 years.

    2. A skeptic took Gore’s documentary to court in the U.K., which is good – lets really be sure here.

    Several facts were criticized as excessive/alarmist/not based on science/the science has changed, but not the 10 hottest years one, and this is the big one.

    So can we all accept that the planet is getting hotter please?

    3. There is more: there is a massive scientific consensus (not 100% unanimous, but a massive majority) agreeing that the post industrial age human activity is very likely responsible.

    Of course this can never be proven conclusively, but few things can.

    4. We all need to think for a minute: coal and oil took millions of years to form. We’re burning it off in decades/centuries, releasing a massive amount of carbon dioxide, in a highly unnatural way, and extremely suddenly, relative to the time it took to form.

    It isn’t rocket science to figure out that this is going to increase the carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, slowly but surely. And carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas, and traps heat, causing the planet to slowly heat up.

    5. Obviously this is major badness.

    Obviously industrialized countries are responsible.

    Obviously we need to fix this on an urgent basis.

    And, no, I’m not doing my part, and I love V8 cars. But obviously, I, and all responsible humans need to get moving.

    6. Science is not a political movement. And we need to quit arguing and get moving.

  18. Mac Users don’t “tinker” with that OS stuff…

    But hackers do.

    Way back when OS X launched, it was firmly established that THE cardinal sin with a Unix-based OS is to run everyday users as root (allowing remote root login is the second grave sin).

    Why on earth would Apple risk a proven security record with the iPhone? Is it because we’d have to give permission when Apple does one of their quiet automatic updates? Wouldn’t you want such a high-profile, fully-networked device to be as secure as possible?

    The original article is laughable in that even root with OS X is more secure than Windows ever will be. But why would Apple want to take any unnecessary risks?

  19. Just an observation, so no hard evidence here, but I’ve noticed that as women get older they seem often to get… extremely wise, sensitive and discerning. And as men grow older they seem often to get… sexually inappropriate, pompous, narrow-minded and somehow just plain kooky.

    Sure there are exceptions either way, but honestly, I think that more men would be better off if they took a few pages from the women’s playbook and sought to put them into action.

    I’m just saying…

  20. That Eran is a complete moron.

    The basis of his argument seems to be It’s not bad to run as root with total system access because most malware doesn’t have to.

    Give me a break. Any OS which compartmentalizes security and runs each process with no more rights than it needs to do the job is better than one which runs every single app with full privileges.

  21. @ Fatty Arbuckle,

    Which kind of supports poor Anthony as Chrissy used to be a he…and some narrow minded sorts would argue still is.

    So is she the brightest commenter here because she is now a she or because under the she really is a he?

    It bottles the mind.

  22. Let’s just say global warming is purely political. Does it hurt the planet to actually do something about pollution and CO2 emissions ? How about we develop new technologies to get our energy from clean, reusable sources ? Plenty of jobs to create and we would not be dependant on some Middle East oil exporting countries. Public health alone in some densely-populated countries / regions / cities would improve. So not matter how one sees global warming, turning to clean energy is profitable to everyone. Oil companies should understand this and invest so they move on with the inevitable trend and yet keep making some profit…

  23. Bush is an idiot, Busting. A pompous, self centered out-of-touch wanna be aristocrat who has poisoned the well of political discourse for the foreseeable future. The fact that anyone still defends the decision to go into Iraq, or the concurrent attacks on personal freedoms, with hyperbolic diatribes about “libtards” is proof enough. And let’s not forget the current institutionalization of grief that prevents any American from actually learning anything from the WTC attacks. Exactly how can Bush present the “real” world when he himself is completely disconnected from same?

  24. In response to:

    <quote>
    Talk about playing on our fears…I dare you to take a full look at the following… http://www.zeitgeistmovie.com/ …speaking of Bush (et al) and “playing” on our fears, he and his movement are the worst.
    <quote>

    I watched it and although it seems to want to be believable, I cannot find any links to its’ authenticity.
    My searches found nothing tangible as to back up its findings.
    Can you provide some links or something?

    Please do. I cannot find anything.

  25. No, I don’t mean that I believe this will be a disaster. I mean that it is likely to be a good thing for many more people than it harms, and good for humanity as a whole. Sure, any change causes hardship for SOMEBODY, but aren’t we as liberals supposed to be in favor of “change” (well, most of the time). The planet will only be a little warmer (and never get as warm as at some periods in its past), according to the scientific consensus at the UN’s climate change panel. And most who have looked at this objectively find that this is likely to be a benefit. To take just a couple of examples, mortality rates will decline due to cold, and the growing season will expand in many parts of the world.
    So, again, we should all be pro-Global Warming!
    P.S. The polar bears are doing great and have been increasing the last 20 years.

  26. Holy crap macfanatics are still getting their panties up in a bunch about…well nothing.

    God forbid anyone says anything bad about your MACS. Anything to even HINT that your CPU is in any way shape or form inferior to Intel’s or AMD’s. You would sooner hang anyone that said they were slower…..errr…. hey! Correct me if I’m wrong but are the latest Mac’s running INTEL???

    OH BOY do any of you macfans remember all the flame wars you started over how superior the Moto’s were to anything Intel had? God I got sick and tired of your warped logic to explain away the obvious. Suddenly Macs are on Intel and you guys are forced to deal with reality. Ditto when the os moved to a BSD base in OS X.

    Don’t get me wrong, I think Apple is an incredible innovator in both UI and hardward design. When OS X came out I immediately went out and bought a powerbook so I can play with it. But I hate these closed minded fanatics (Apple, microsoft, whoever) that can not accept even legitimate criticism.

    Oh by the way “State of Fear” was the biggest pile of crap I’ve read in a long time. Anyone that use that book to bolster their arguments are total idiots. He cherry picked his data ignoring all other data. One example that of the drivel i can remember is when he writes about one monitoring station where they recorded increased temps. Oh boy what a brilliant guy. Scientist have known about micro-climates for many years. No one expects the temperature to decrease the same about everywhere at the same time. That’s just not the way things happen in a complex system. But then again Crichton seems to have problems understanding complex things.

  27. MacFags can’t be bothered with “facts” and “research.”

    Whatever Holy St. Steve says is truth and those evil reporters with their well sourced articles pointing out obvious flaws in the iPhone must be silenced.

    Fuck you and your iPhone, mysoginist bastards.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.