
Apple today announced that it will not be selling NBC television shows for the upcoming television season on its online iTunes Store. The move follows NBC’s decision to not renew its agreement with iTunes after Apple declined to pay more than double the wholesale price for each NBC TV episode, which would have resulted in the retail price to consumers increasing to $4.99 per episode from the current $1.99. ABC, CBS, FOX and The CW, along with more than 50 cable networks, are signed up to sell TV shows from their upcoming season on iTunes at $1.99 per episode.
“We are disappointed to see NBC leave iTunes because we would not agree to their dramatic price increase,” said Eddy Cue, Apple’s vice president of iTunes, in the press release. “We hope they will change their minds and offer their TV shows to the tens of millions of iTunes customers.”
Apple’s agreement with NBC ends in December. Since NBC would withdraw their shows in the middle of the television season, Apple has decided to not offer NBC TV shows for the upcoming television season beginning in September. NBC supplied iTunes with three of its 10 best selling TV shows last season, accounting for 30 percent of iTunes TV show sales.
Source: http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2007/08/31itunes.html
So, this is totally off-topic, but, you know, there’s this cool website Torrents.to. It searches major torrent sites for stuff. You just type in a search term, say, oh, we don’t know, “heroes” or “office” or “earl” or any other random word, pick a torrent site to search and it returns results along with handy tabs across the top, so you can quickly conduct the same search on any major torrent site. It’s really pretty cool and works rather well. If you Google for “Mac BitTorrent Client,” a ton of results are returned, too.
Anyway, back to news that Apple’s iTunes Store is dropping NBC shows after NBC demands would have raised show prices to $4.99 per episode: it’s disappointing that we won’t be able to watch NBC TV shows anymore.
Contact NBC:
NBC Main Telephone Numbers: 212 315-9016 and 212-664-4444
Email: NBCUniSupport@nbcuni.com
Web Form: http://www.nbcuni.com/About_NBC_Universal/Contact_Us/
Jupiter Research anaylst Michael Gartenberg blogs, “Apple’s looking good here, championing users. NBC is making a mistake, $4.99 is way too high per episode… and this is the type of move that pushes users to look for other places to get the content (like in hi-def for free over BitTorrent). Legal paid content drives consumers to do the right thing, take it away and nature will abhor the vacuum it creates. Sometimes I think God put video content guys on the planet to make the music guys look progressive and visionary.”
MacDailyNews Note: Please see related article: NBC: Apple’s iTunes, iPod powering broadcast ratings for ‘The Office’ – January 17, 2006
Why the hell would anyone pay $4.99 for something they can DVR for free?
At $1.99 it’s and impulse purchase, at $4.99 people start thinking about it.
Whomever is in charge of the strategy at NBC is a moron.
NBC is gonna be kicking themselves for leaving itunes how stupid can they get.
I like it. Apple won’t be anybody’s bitch.
It’s a strong and powerful signal, and NBC will come around eventually.
Can’t wait for the new iPods next week . . .
Good move Apple
Also, if any other content providers go along with NBC in this direction, Apple should just screw them by enabling full DVR capability on the AppleTV with the ability to scrub out ads and the ability to upload to iTunes/iPods.
So basically what the Universal Media Group is telling consumers is that they want you to pirate their content, because they’re not going to give you any reasonable way to access it legally.
Greedy jerks. I think I’ll boycott broadcast NBC television in return for their consideration of their customers.
There are some not-so-subtle fighting words in Apple’s statement. They’re trying to get the public on their side by mentioning the price increase, and get NBC investors on their side by mentioning the tens-of-millions of iTunes users. I’ll bet Jobs personally wrote that statement. Now he’s gone to hardball. Play ball!
What is with these industry jackasses who continually want to cut open the goose that lays the golden eggs? Does not compute.
If you are planning to be, go f**k yourself and leave now… right now…
NBC is my favorite tv network, but if the F with Apple, they will loose as a TV viewer….
The barn door is open, most of the horses have left the stable, so let’s put up a sign charging 250% more for the few remaining nags.
Brilliant.
Aren’t they third in the ratings behind CBS and ABC? I can’t see how this is going to help that situation.
I also think this is really going to make their new fall shows that much more vulnerable and more difficult to develop a loyal audience. What are they going to do, go with the second best online distribution method. And that would be who?
Guess its torrents or bust…Honestly how do some of these people get put in charge of companies? Do they not understanding they basically just wrote off millions in revenues to their share holders? Anyway should be interesting to see how this plays out and who caves. My bet: Universal will try to quietly ‘re-join’ the iTunes store once they realize the millions they are losing out on. Of course, this is right after someone gets fired over it.
Pulling that crap for $1/Zune sold may work on Microsoft but the buck stops here Universal.
Greed!
Does anyone else think that $1.99 is still too much for a TV show? It is very rare that I ever consider paying that much for something that I will most likely watch once. $.99 is more on the mark for a television show. $4.99 for a TV show is outrageous!! Heck, I can buy movies at Target for less than that.
It will be sad to see Battlestar Galactica gone but there really wasn’t anything else from NBC that I would even have wanted to download anyway. Perhaps, they should worry about finding some quality programming for their networks rather than trying to rape the population for the very few shows that people might actually want to watch. They aren’t #1 anymore as the days of Friends, Frasier, and Seinfeld are gone. However, it is apparent that the arrogance of being #1 for so long still lingers
Bring it on!!!
I think NBC underestimated Apple.
Pulling the show in september was probably not expected by CNBC who thought they have till December to pressure Apple to raise prices.
At $1.99 it’s and impulse purchase, at $4.99 people start thinking about it.
Episodes of NOVA are $7.99, and I’m sure I’ve seen higher.
Seriously, that’s $120 a season for one show. You can buy the DVD of a show for $30. That’s just stupid on NBC’s part.
They should and probably will fire the moron that thought up that idea. Greedy idiots! $1.99 is an impulse buy. $3.99 or more for a t.v. show is just a great reason to fire up bit torrent.
It’s all about the money. In wonder if their stuff will show up at the Zune Store?
Sorry, I’m not paying $5 an episode for a TV show? The Office, for that much? It simply isn’t worth it. Next season they are planning on 30 episodes, so, that is $150 for a TV show? A TV SHOW?
Insane. Go Apple! Go!
Wow, let’s do some math here. My favorite NBC show is The Office. Season 3 of The Office had 25 episodes (21 half-hour plus 2 full-hour). On iTunes today, you can buy Season 3 for $34. When the DVD comes out on September 4, it should cost about $40 (Season 2 was $37). With NBC’s proposed pricing scheme, that would mean Season 4 would cost $124.75 on iTunes (given 25 episodes at $4.99 each). So let’s see here: $124.75 for low-quality, DRM-laden, no special-features iTunes episodes; or $40 for high-quality episodes with special features that can be ripped to my computer without DRM. Ummmm…good work NBC, you nailed that one. Thank you Apple, for at least attempting to protect the consumer.
NBC has decided they cannot make nearly as much via iTunes vs. selling ad space via traditional TV.
Thus, if the model to continue moving towards IPTV continues (and it will), and iTunes becomes the dominate player (likely), NBC will be showing TV via iTunes to home TV’s (via AppleTV) and start to lose their shirts in revenues.
The result is a quick fix by jacking up the price, but Apple isn’t going to play ball this way.
NBC may fall back to launching their own online store, which will be a horrific play.
Consumers want one main distributor to acquire their content, and iTunes is the best there is on the market today.
NBC is more than likely to be:
– Using this as a pricing tactic to force Apple’s hand and see what Apple is made of….
– Will be back by next fall, bending to the will of iTunes pricing.
@Grigori
I hope that you aren’t comparing the quality of an episode of Nova (which is, BTW, produced by a non-profit entity and shown on PBS that does not get ad revenues for broadcasts) with that of an NBC sitcom (more appropriately called “sh*tcom”)
Yeah, Apple is the greedy one, right?
Imagine an NBC conference room today…
“So, Dave, great idea pressuring Apple like that! We showed THEM we value our shows! I’m really impressed by how you made a stand and didn’t budge.”
“Thanks, boss!”
“So, what’s the plan now? How do we make up the lost revenue from iTunes sales? Make me a millionaire, kid!”
“Ummm… well… I thought we’d try raising our ad prices.”
“Hmm. That won’t work. We can bully our sellers, but not our advertisers.”
“Ok… how about… we make up the money by selling on OTHER digital media stores?”
“Such as…?”
“Errr well, I haven’t done the research yet, but… Err…”
“It’s going to be a busy Fall season, Dave.”
No, NBC makes more money per viewer on iTunes downloads than on ad sales. This is 100% a power play — NBC wanted more restrictive DRM (probably an expiration date on each download) and probably other crazy things. Apple refused those, and as a power play NBC said “ok, well then, we will have to charge you a lot more!” Unfortunately for NBC, Apple knows when to walk away from a deal.
I’m waiting for the DVDs to hit my rental store so I can get the shows for less than $1 each.
Bye Bye NBC and Kudos for Apple standing their ground
This would of course include all Sci Fi channel stuff including Battlestar, Stargate, Eureaka… etc.
Obviously some bean-counter at NBC thought the iTunes store was cutting into their DVD sales. Whatever. I never understood paying a premium for a low-res DRM file, when you could buy a DVD with all the bonus material, at half the cost.
Way to go NBC, you’re fighting piracy! At 2 1/2 time the price, piracy will disappear 2 1/2 times faster.
Damn, no Bionic Woman for me.
“I never understood paying a premium for a low-res DRM file, when you could buy a DVD with all the bonus material, at half the cost.”
I never understood waiting six months to watch a show.
I guess NBC doesn’t want people to buy their stuff. Even if Apple would have agreed, no one would buy it at $4.99.
They are just greedy bastards plain and simple. I am happy Apple told them no. NBC just negotiated themselves right out of some easy revenue. Greed is a powerful thing.
NBC/Universal must love to piss money down the drain. Nice move morons, you’ve now just lost over 75% of your paid downloads now….
Heroes Season 1 on DVD lists for $60. Excluding the value of any special features the cost per 23 episodes comes out to $2.60 per episode.
Amazon is selling it for $37. That is $1.61 per episode.
iTunes at $1.99 per episode is already more expensive than waiting for the DVD and buying it from Amazon (or elsewhere).
At $4.99 per episode, you would think that the DVD retails for $150 and sells at a discount for $99. Who in their right mind is going to pay that much for something they might watch once maybe twice.
Here’s the e-mail address for NBC Universal:
NBCUniSupport@nbcuni.com
Tell them how you feel but DO NOT make it polite or rational.
They wouldn’t understand.
(http://www.nbcuni.com/About_NBC_Universal/Contact_Us/)
Absolutely not; my Tuesday night viewing schedule has been set for decades. But I can’t imagine that many episodes of the show get sold at that price, particularly when DVDs with extras are available for just a bit more. Aside from the occasional “impluse purchase” (I had to purchase the last two episodes of Battlestar Galactica last season), paying much more than $2 per episode seems extreme.
Take Heroes: the first season on DVD from Amazon costs $36.99US; on iTunes, $42.99. It makes little sense to make a purchase like this on a regular basis. Not that it makes NBC any less greedy.
How long before those Redmond jackels move in?
Anyone?
Beuller?
Stay tuned, MicroSoft will have an anouncement pertaining to marketplace before the holidays.
I wish Apple struck first.
All the other headlines are “NBC Dumps iTunes,” “NBC Pulls Content from iTunes.”
Hopefully this wasn’t too late. Guess Apple still held hope on further negotiations and NBC jumped the gun.
@theloniousMac
I don’t think all the SciFi shows are part of this stupidity. Battlestar is produced by NBC’s company, that’s why they can pull it. Other SciFi shows are produced by other production outfits that are unconnected to the GreedBoys at NBC.
On a more general note, I love anyone or any company that, when threatened, says FU and walks away. Why bother dealing with idiots. The old media companies don’t realize the world has changed. Their so-called entertainment is not longer the only show in town. Hell, there are better shows on FX than NBC.
Adios NBC, may your last good show, Seinfeld, live forever.
hmmm… USD 4.99 per episode?
that would bring them just in line with the price for every episodes that have recently become available in the UK.
Yep, we pay twice as much. As usual.
id like to be the fly on the wall in that meeting with the shareholders… well guys, we tried to get you some more money… instead they took away whatever money we would have made from at least the half the season.
i love you stevesy.
ps. i love nbc, its the only OTA channel i watch… office, earl, 30rock, heroes. cant get enough. i dont mind paying 30 bucks for a season pass.
mw: history. this guy is history
“Consumers want one main distributor to acquire their content, and iTunes is the best there is on the market today.”
Well, yes and no. Consumers ultimately want convenience–they don’t want to have to spend a big hunk of time searching for a show.
For example, this past season, you could purchase ‘Heroes’ from the iTunes Store or you could go watch it on NBC’s website for free (ad supported). Believe it or not, far more people did that than purchased it via iTunes. I’d be curious about the difference in revenue from tons of people watching with ads versus lots of people paying $1.99.
Meh… no worries. I’ll just go back to the old fashion way, the Bittorrent way. Kinda defeats the purpose eh NBC?
For me $1.99 is high. I would NEVER pay $4.99 for an episode of ANYTHING. I guess NBC hasn’t heard of supply and demand: NBC if your listening here you are:
– No supply = no demand. If you have nothing to sell on iTunes you will sell nothing… $0 income
– High price = low demand. If you sell high priced shows in iTunes you will sell very few shows… $4.99 (one sucker out there is sure to buy one, if only by mistake)
– Mid price = some demand. If you continue to sell your shows for $1.99 you will have some demand… $$$$$$
– Low price = LOTS of demand. If you sell them for less, more people will buy them. People will choose to purchase them through iTunes rather than steal them from torrents (better interface and user experience). People will purchase on impulse. More people will try different shows and get hooked, leading to more purchases… $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
There. Now NBC, fire whomever in your organization thinks holding out for $4.99 on iTunes is a good idea. Hire someone who passed high school economics and prepare to make $$$$$$. Otherwise, kiss me goodbye – at $4.99 even I might be tempted to get them from the torrents.
Nice blatant promotion of piracy from the editors of MDN!
Not that I disagree, I would torrent a series that I don’t even watch just to spite NBC before I pay $4.99 for a single episode. $4.99 would be fair for say, a bundle of three episodes.
They’ll be back. They always come back.
Apple just cut NBC’s juggler by pulling the plug on NBC now and not at X-Mas. Great move by Jobs. Ahhh, the media – when are you going to learn that you can’t control the masses anymore.
They’ll come crawling back, as money is their only God.
$4.99 for a 30-minute episode. Are the folks at NBC delusional?
NBC and Microsoft… look out for this combo. I agree with Bizarro Ballmer, above.
NBC and Microsoft are playing together on this one.
Move
Counter Move
My bet is with el Jobso.
Regarding the upcoming NBC show BitTorrent downloads: I’d just like to plug the excellent Visual Hub for video conversion. HandBrake is free and great, but I think Visual Hub’s “Encode for [ ] iPod [ ] Apple TV [ ] iPhone [ ] All” feature is worth the $23. (I don’t work there, just being a zealot.)
There have been rumors that Apple is going to start offering HD content and maybe movie rentals/subscriptions. If so, they are maybe better off giving up the TV shows (which as pointed out in the comments, are available for free and supported by ads on the networks own websites). This would free up bandwidth for more moview content at higher resoutions. I don’t think Apple gets much of that $1.99.
Here in Australia, we are always at least a year behind on broadcast – except Heros and now Californication (a if, this is class television) and a few others. But what I usually do is contact that great Amazon in th eclouds nd have the goodies shipped here. Yes, I know that Austraia ia rgion 4 nd th goo ole usofA is region 1 BUT the digital players here are for th most part region fre or they play everythng but region 7 & 8. Heeeh…
It is clear (MDN) tat NBC has a serious case of rectalcranialosis… which mean that the executives need to put a window in there fat overbloated stomachs to see the world.
What a bunch of phuqueheads!
And Heros was my favourite show.
Greedy ash-wholes.
Must have got their training from the ptrol companies!
@ critic
“Whomever” should only be used when it’s the object.
Is NBC Universal associaed with Universal Music? Seems to me that Universal is waging all out war on iTunes. It’ll be interesting to see if NBC Universal begins selling TV shows on their’s or other sites for $1.99 just to steel market share from ITS, same as Universal Music is trying to do with its DRM removal for everyone else except ITS.
4.99 per episode is not an arbitrary number. There is a significant pile of work and effort that lead up to that five dollar increase and now that NBC was kicked to the curb by Apple, it will be interesting to see what happens next.
I mean, what’s going to happen to that five dollar number and all the work and effort it represents?
Dollars to donuts you won’t here of this news from Leno or O’Brian for a late night laugh.
By the way, I negotiate for a living, and I can say without a doubt, that the party that can, and will, walk away from the table, has the upper-hand.
To hell with NBC. Paying $125 or so a season vs. $40 or so at the end is too much difference. Just DVR the show bubba. And I hope there isn’t an increase in stealing tv shows as a result – that’ll just increase the calls for DRM crap. To hell with NBC.
theloniousMac
Damn, no Bionic Woman for me.
Funniest line I ever heard was delivered to Sandra Bullock as Bionic Girl.
“So, you have come for more punnishment, eh, Bionic Girl?”
The gloves are off!! Way to go Apple! F*ck NBC and f*ck Universal…the greedy scum whores!
Note to NBC:
Say good night, Gracie. I hope your Plan B is kick-ass; otherwise, you just f*^ked up.
One of these days, you suits are gonna learn…Steve Jobs is the wrong guy to play hardball with. The leverage is with him. If you push him to the wall, he’s gonna exercise his leverage.
Apple represents the future; old media (i.e. NBC Universal) represents the past.
Get over yourselves.
Peace.
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”cool smile” style=”border:0;” />
Olmecmystic
Apple’s core business is selling computers. They are selling a lot of computers these days. If they can’t also sell “The Office,” so what? NBC is the big loser here.
I’d like to see how many NBC shows get downloaded between now and Dec. 31st off iTunes and compare that to the first 8 months of the year. $10 is much higher. Maybe that will convince NBC otherwise.
“Consumers want one main distributor to acquire their content, and iTunes is the best there is on the market today.’
‘Well, yes and no. Consumers ultimately want convenience–they don’t want to have to spend a big hunk of time searching for a show.
For example, this past season, you could purchase ‘Heroes’ from the iTunes Store or you could go watch it on NBC’s website for free (ad supported). Believe it or not, far more people did that than purchased it via iTunes. I’d be curious about the difference in revenue from tons of people watching with ads versus lots of people paying $1.99.'”
Why not keep both offerings?
NBC’s take: “Well, it will force people to watch on our site.”
Reality: Many people are happy to pay for the privilege of not having sit in front a computer screen for TV purposes, not watch ads, have the option to view content on their iPod on-the-go, etc.
As the MDN Take suggests, many of these people would be more prone to fire up BitTorrent than they would be to go the NBC site. They would both be “free” to the consumer, so it’s not the price. It’s more the convenience and the portability. “Don’t force me to do something,” says Joe Consumer. “Let me digest your content how/where I want to. I’d be happy to “pay” one way or another (dollars vs. ads), but give me good options. If I don’t like your solution, I might just go and, ahem, ‘acquire’ your content elsewhere, and completely cut you out of the loop.”
What happened to “the customer is always right?”
Just dropped NBC universal a line. I’d like to know how many of their shows that a serial in nature (i.e. Heroes) that 70% of the viewers miss the first few episodes and don’t bother. If it wasn’t for iTunes I wouldn’t be watching that show. And I bet a lot of you wouldn’t either. Any show I do watch on NBC I forward through the commercials anyways, so screw them.
me: audience, as in good bye
@critic
My thoughts exactly. I’ll happily pay $7.99 for an episode of NOVA (I didn’t even know it was on iTunes). For NBC crap? Never. Not even for “To Catch an iPod Thief” or whatever.
MW: down, which is where NBC/Universal is going.
Universal Music decides to offer non-drm music through everyone but Apple & NBC-Universal tries to hijack the price of video.
Things that make you go hmmmmm…
I hope things work out. I’d hate to miss my Heroes. If not, NBC can go f#@k themselves. Greedy bastards.
the very first poster here has it right on the money. I’ll “throw away” 2 dollars on a tv episode just to not have to bittorrent it or some other lame thing, but beyond 2$, forget it.
Let’s see….Season Passes to Battlestar Gallactica, The Office, Heroes, Stargate, miscellaneous other NBC shows…hmmm…that comes to around $175 of lost revenue. Way to go NBC!
OK, so how would $3.82 sound for a TV show? That’s what we have to pay for shows through the iTunes Store here in the UK.
What a ripoff!
@jhn
“Whomever” should only be used when it’s the object.”
I know. I realized as soon as I posted, but my laziness prevented me from posting a correction. I usually hold myself to high grammatical standards in my posts.
Actually, your average 1/2 hour broadcast TV show clocks in closer to 20 – 22 minutes. —
It just keeps gettin’ better!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”raspberry” style=”border:0;” />
mw : “police”
Kid: “Apple just cut NBC’s juggler…”
When did NBC hire a JUGGLER, and why would Apple CUT the poor guy? This puts a seriously morbid tone in the discussion.
Carnies be warned–you might be next!
OTOH, if NBC has been hiring circus acts, well, that does esplain a lot, Lucy.
An average 1 hour show would be 40 min, or 2/3 of a full hour.
magic word: “hour”
3rd Kidney…
Because of US law (FCC regulations regarding ownership of TV networks by foreign-owned entities, which – for the sake of information – is why Murdoch gave up the country of his birth to become a US citizen), NBC Universal is majority-owned (80%)by GE and minority-owned (20%) by Vivendi who are the controlling owners of UMG (Universal Music Group).
Sadly, having a financial fist fight with GE is out of Apple’s league at the moment; however, as I’ve previously stated with regards to UMG, Vivendi is another matter – it is worth a mere $47 billion in comparison to AAPL’s pending $120 billion with UMG in many ways a millstone around Vivendi’s neck.
I believe I’m correct when I say that Vivendi have been searching for a buyer for UMG for some while: it originally wanted to sell UMG as part of the former Vivendi-Universal Entertainment (VUE), except there were no takers and GE only wanted the filmed entertainment (Universal Studios) to wed to NBC plus the theme parks.
Part of the reason UMG is seen as a poison chalice is the erosion of the music market, initially by piracy and now track-by-track downloads; quite frankly, many unimaginative investors don’t want a business in a state of flux (see how I avoided using the term “paradigm shift”)
Personally, I would enter into a partnership with a private-equity group (51% Apple, 49% the PEG with two-thirds Apple money) to make Vivendi a decent offer for UMG and take control of the world’s largest music company, sweat the assets (music, music video and sheet publishing [why does no one see the value of selling MIDI data??]) and then refloat it as a music company made fit for the 21st Century. Apple could leave day to day management to the PEG with Eddy Cue occasionally showing up to remind everyone that Apple holds the purse strings.
Isn’t there like some cable channel “MSNBC”?
I wonder….
From the AP story
“Rather than cut off NBC programs in the middle of the season, Apple decided to stop before the new fall episodes premiere next month, he said.
That would be a blow to fourth-place NBC, which could use the buzz provided by Internet sales for its programming – not to mention the money.”
SJ always laughs last!!
NBC seem to think that people put a premium on every TV show they watch and that the premium is far higher when watching at lower quality on the internet. Most of the TV I watch I enjoy but if I had to pay for it I wouldn’t. If a particular show becomes unavailable to me then I’ll just watch something else – there are quite a few TV channels around – or I’ll watch nothing.
The shows I buy on DVD are ones I want to watch again, ones want to own, invariably now I wait for them to come down in price so I can buy all the ones I want without breaking the bank. I pay for subscription satellite TV as it is, I’m not paying ridiculous prices for individual shows.
$4.99 an episode on iTunes, or indeed any format is just insane.
So a 1/2 hour sitcom (22 minutes actual time) at $4.99 would come out to nearly $0.23 / minute. Wow, that had better be one good show!
If NBC had two brain cells to knock together they would bittorrent their shows after they air, with ads included. Make a nice torrent client–hell, all the networks make on together–and viewer combo. Give the shows away for the advertising, and most of the bandwidth expense would be bourne by the consumer.
But no, they wouldn’t do that because they want a rent model, not a buy model.
I’ve never had any desire to watch a network stream because I watch on the train using my iPod, not at home.
To: TheConfuzed1
“By the way, I negotiate for a living, and I can say without a doubt, that the party that can, and will, walk away from the table, has the upper-hand.”
Doesn’t Apple have the upper hand by not distributing any of their new content even though their contract is good until December, at least for the time being? I know that they could leave at the end of their contract and could hurt Apple (maybe, but I doubt it), but Apple is hurting them now by not offering new shows and episodes. I think that Apple has the slight upper hand on this right now. I hope things work out and we, the customers, win out in the end.
the moron in NBC is Zucker (sucker) he is dumbest c.e.o. he reminded steve ballmer
I thought Dunder-Mifflin’s business plan was a mess. I can’t wait to critique NBC’s iTunes blunder in my next business management class. Maybe I’ll bring Michael; it might make him feel better (he’s still a little touchy about me getting the Corporate job).
MDW: pattern, as in there’s always a pattern in madness.
@R2: “I wish Apple struck first.”
Dude, they did. What do you think just happened here? NBC stated they would not renew their contract AFTER DECEMBER. They thought they would have 3 months of sales of their new season, 4 months for Apple to sweat and possibly cave in to their demands- then pull the plug in mid-season if Apple didn’t cave.
Instead, they get 4 months sales of their “reruns”, otherwise they get jack sh*t.
Apple very publicly called their bluff, and kicked their asses to the curb 3 months in advance.
Safe to say the ball’s in NBC’s court now. They stand to lose a hell of a lot more than Apple does- think of the tiny % Apple gets from these sales…
jeff zucker (sucker) is moron. He is steve ballmer of NBC. no vision
http://www.nbcunidigital.com/
NBC/Universal Digital is in charge of the iTunes arrangement. If you want to reach the people that pressed for the price increase contact the corporate sales agents.
If memory serves me, MSNBC was a 50/50 partnership between NBC and Microsoft, NBC purchased a portion of the M$ share back in 2005, but M$ still has some where around 20% of NBC stock. NBC I think is part of the NBC Universal family of companies, if so Steve has just stomped on Mr. Bills crank big time. The whole damed thing reeks of Microsoft’s tactics. Hope Apple burns their asses big time.
What Apple should do to scare NBC is to buy Tivo, which market cap is 586 millions dollars, Apple Market cap is 119 billions, so there is enough money to take over Tivo…. I hope Apple has some bad guys inside…..
Dear NBC,
I don’t watch any of your television shows at the moment. Not because of some judgement on the quality, but because I just don’t watch much TV any more aside from educational and historic programing.
But in light of your move to pressure Apple into increasing iTunes pricing for your shows to 4.99, and Apple’s subsequent move to drop your shows, I’m thinking about downloading your shows on pier-to-peir networks. Just to make a point. Maybe I’ll finally start watching the US version of The Office. I loved the BBC series and I understand it’s quite funny. Heroes is also very well-regarded so I may watch that, too. Do you have any other suggestions? I’m all ears.
Congratulations. You have created a criminal.
-c
NBC=Greed
Now, how to I deprive NBC of potential revenue for their greedy practices…
Step 1. Get a computer. Check.
Step 2. Get broadband internet access. Check.
Step 3. Install Bit-Torrent client. Check.
Step 4. Download anything I freekin’ want to watch. Check.
Step 5. Cancel cable. Check.
A funny thing just happened. I’m independant. I wonder how long it will take NBC/Comcast to realize it?
Oh Gods! I loves me some bit-torrent!
NBC = General Electric, since GE bought them years ago
Dave Letterman put it best
“We know all about making refrigerators, so let’s run a TV network”
BC
Seriously, MDN. Once in a while your takes are simply PERFECT. This is one of those times
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
F*ck NBC. If they can’t make it easy for me to get my shows, I’ll find another easy way to get them.
Chrissy-
It’s peer , not pier.
Other than that, good job.
No wonder Apple are doing so well. Management is smart enough to stick to what they know will work (what consumers would actually be prepared to pay) rather than just sucking up to the greedy media companies like Microsoft in the hope of lining their own pockets at the same time. There is still other content out there which will sell Apple TV, iPod, and Macs.
It is the same with all the complaints you hear that Apple won’t build a loss leader Mac so big business can buy them. Just leave the other manufacturers throwing their profits away trying to under cut each other and concentrate on those who will pay for a decent solution leaving the funds to actually innovate and improve.
“Congratulations. You have created a criminal.”
Don’t you mean encouraged?
(j/k)
Sorry, imagine Dave using his “dumb guy” voice
Interesting that Apple stock price is still up today.
I can’t remember the last time I watched anything on NBC. There must have been SOMETHING since cheers!
Just because no one seems to have mentioned it, NBC did not necessarily want $4.99 per show. It’s more likely that since they were in bargaining, they expected to settle for less. Since Apple wants $1.99 and NBC wants $4.99, it’s possible that NBC somehow thought that they would end up charging $3.50.
That being said, I personally agree with “NBC is nuts” who said that $1.99 is still too much for a TV show.
Apple has not got clean hands here in that they also charge huge prices to UK customers for no other reason than Geography, and they also charge too much when it comes right down to it.
I am starting to think that some kind of graduated pricing makes sense despite what the great Steve-o sez. $0.99 for a single song is far too much when it’s a 30 year old pop album, yet too little for those who just “must have” the latest song.
If I was a recording artist and I came out with a dynamite album that was wildly popular planet-wide, I would be miffed at being paid the same price as the corporation that owns the rights to “Benny Hill Sings Cowboy Songs” (or any other obscure junk you can think of. In the first case an original living artist is being poorly compensated, in the second case some faceless corporation that shouldn’t even have the right to the revenue is getting the same money.
Watch for Jobs & Co.™ to add several additional/new ABC & CBS TV shows to the iTunes library — in your face, NBC.
Niffy
Just thought of another angle on this thing…
If a TV show is about 20 minutes of content and the price was to be five bucks, then that’s a dollar for every five minutes.
How many folks would like a Television set that (aside from the cost of the set), needs to have a dollar coin put in a slot on top every five minutes while you watch it?
Certainly seems ludicrous that way.
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />
This just shows you how insane the rates are for advertising. All the networks are going to be hurting in the future because the advertising budgets will be slashed. Television is dying. The networks just don’t know it.
Wow! $4.99 per episode of any TV show I can watch for watch for free over the air. Wait! Since I already have a Series 2 Tivo DVR, maybe I’ll record the NBC shows I can’t get from NBC on iTunes anymore, and then use TivoDecodeManager (free shareware) to transfer the shows at 720 x 1020 standard definition to my Mac, then watch the shows using Quicktime at my convenience, any time or any place I like. The overall picture quality might not be as good as what I could get through iTunes, and I’d have to manually fast forward through the commercials, but I’d have a copy of the show forever! I think Jim will get a kick out of this!
Let us all celebrate the event of one less swarm of stupid TV network execs on iTunes by adjusting our mac desktop to a jolly little desktop image I conjured at short notice:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/sigalakos/1287073309/
I agree with MDN’s take. Torrents make it so easy for us.
What’s all this about having a choice between waiting for the DVD or iTunes downloads? Hasn’t anyone heard of Miro, formerly DemocracyTV? Just search for the link for your favorite TV show at TvRss, plug it into Miro, and the latest episodes are downloaded automatically, along with any older ones you want. Or get the best and easiest bit torrent/rss torrent app for Mac I’ve ever seen, XTorrent. Or there’s always EyeTv, no downloading required, just personal use recording. So many options!
Uh Jeremy, ya might wanna check yer math.
Very nice! Of course, I guess NBC could show their peacock eating an apple – do they still use the peacock? Not the brightest bird in the world, so it’s an apt choice.
Like all the dumb moves NBC has made over the last few years, they will one day regret this. Apple’s stance on this shows that they will not allow their customers to be taken advantage of.
Visit http://www.riche.tv
You know what? Appe sell Friday Night Lights for $40. While Best Buy sells it for $25 and on sell for this week at $20. How much is NBC want? Sh1t! How much is their cut on $25 vs. $40. Sound like greed to me. NBC does not have to pay for hosting, bandwidth, credit card transactions. All I have to say is F* em!
Don’t flame or slaughter me, but wasn’t office about to be canceled before it became in demand at iTunes? Didn’t iTunes help in a very large part to keep it on the air and make it a success?
So what if NBC walks. Apples top 30% of sales might just be made up be someone discovering a sleeper hit on one of the networks still on iTunes. When that happens, THAT network, not NBC will be reaping the ratings and extra revenue.
Oh yeah, and on the subject of NBC, out of the “Big 3” They are neither #1. or #2…….. Doesn’t exactly put them into a strong bargining position
It’s called renting the season for $10 bucks at your local rental store and a free program called Handbrake. That’s about .42 cents an episode.
I’m glad Apple announced the reason why NBC was not renewing the contract, especially after NBC first announced the impasse and made it sound like NBC wanted to renew, but Apple was being unreasonable.
$4.99 for an episode of a show is ridiculous. DVR it or wait for the DVD box set.
GET YOUR FREE NBC SHOWS!!
COMPLETE SEASONS ON DVD
ENTIRE NBC CONTENT ON BLUERAY OR HD-DVD
Step RIGHT UP!!
Muhahahahahhllallala
NBC screwed up, I’m a new pirate now!!
@NBC is nuts
“Does anyone else think that $1.99 is still too much for a TV show? It is very rare that I ever consider paying that much for something that I will most likely watch once.”
People drink Starbucks rip-off drinks all the time, and that’s truly single-use. How much does one of those drinks cost every day, or twice a day for that matter?
@Grigori – “Episodes of NOVA are $7.99…”
That’s the reason I just couldn’t bring myself to buy any of their stuff. I mean, I love NOVA and all, but $7.99 for that one hour show…I prefer to get it on my Tivo and copy to my Mac if I want to save it. I would perhaps pay $4.99, seeing as it’s a “special” kind of program. I think whomever is in control of selling NOVA at $7.99 is losing out on a lot of potential sales simply because the price is too high (i.e. they would have sold more in quantity at $4.99 with smaller margins than they have done selling at $7.99). I will, for instance, buy the National Geographic shows, since I think they are quite reasonable.
Just to help search engine results and to counterbalance junk headlines like the ones R2 showed, here is the counter-headline:
“iTunes Store Dumps NBC”
“Apple Cuts Off Sales of NBC Programs On The iTunes Store”
“Apple Tells NBC To Take A Hike”
“iTunes Closes Its Door To NBC”
and finally,
“iTunes Fights For The Consumer, Says No To NBC”
We TiVo owners can transfer any show we want to the Mac & convert it for the iPod. Not as fast as an iTunes download over broadband, but it’s free and makes it more fun to do considering NBCs greed.
>> @NBC is nuts
“Does anyone else think that $1.99 is still too much for a TV show? It is very rare that I ever consider paying that much for something that I will most likely watch once.”
I think a buck would hit the sweet spot. $1.99 is an early-adopters price – good if you are happy to pay it (I’m not). So what does that make $4.99? An incentive to use BitTorrent and pay $nada.
> People drink Starbucks rip-off drinks all the time, and that’s truly single-use. How much does one of those drinks cost every day, or twice a day for that matter?
Rent is a big part of the equation. If you drink it there it’s probably fair, but if you take your Starbucks coffee elsewhere then you’re paying too much for a mediocre product.
“Now, how to I deprive NBC of potential revenue for their greedy practices…
Step 1. Get a computer. Check.
Step 2. Get broadband internet access. Check.
Step 3. Install Bit-Torrent client. Check.
Step 4. Download anything I freekin’ want to watch. Check.
Step 5. Cancel cable. Check.”
I hate how maych BMW charges for cars:
Step 1. Find BMW in parking lot at local mall. Check.
Step 2 . Break in. Check.
Step 3. Hotwire. Check.
I wonder how long it will take BMW and the local police to notice?
A funny thing just happened. I’m independant. I wonder how long it will take NBC/Comcast to realize it?
Oh Gods! I loves me some bit-torrent!
They should fire the NBC guy who made this decision. At least Apple understands what a consumer wants. $4.99? You gotta be kidding me – this is why there’re software pirates – ‘cos of stupid greedy corporations like NBC. Kudos to Apple for sticking up for the consumer though this will mean I won’t get to watch my most favourite show in the world – Heroes. Damn you NBC!
It’s not about prices, but control
The reason why movie theater prices are all the same. Price sends a signal. This is why Apple charges all one price and for good reasons. Imagine a price war on iTMS? With the more wealtheir studios shutting out the poorer ones?
The answer is that pricing sends a signal. People have come to believe that “you get what you pay for.” If you lowered the price of a movie, people would immediately infer from the low price that it’s a crappy movie and they wouldn’t go see it. If you had different prices for movies, the $4 movies would have a lot less customers than they get anyway. The entertainment industry has to maintain a straight face and tell you that Gigli or Battlefield Earth are every bit as valuable as Wedding Crashers or Star Wars or nobody will go see them.
Now, the reason the music recording industry wants different prices has nothing to do with making a premium on the best songs. What they really want is a system they can manipulate to send signals about what songs are worth, and thus what songs you should buy. I assure you that when really bad songs come out, as long as they’re new and the recording industry wants to promote those songs, they’ll charge the full $2.49 or whatever it is to send a fake signal that the songs are better than they really are. It’s the same reason we’ve had to put up with crappy radio for the last few decades: the music industry promotes what they want to promote, whether it’s good or bad, and the main reason they want to promote something is because that’s a bargaining chip they can use in their negotiations with artists.
Apple charges what it does to make sure iTMS is a success to sell iPods. That all content makers are represented equally. That the customer has a consistant experience instead of price wars, conspiracies to fix prices and other nasties of the free market economy.
The entertainment industry has to maintain a straight face and tell you that Gigli or Battlefield Earth are every bit as valuable as Wedding Crashers or Star Wars or nobody will go see them.
Notice the quote says “the entertainment industry”. NBC knows exactly whats going on and why they can’t be charging a fortune for their TV shows when everyone else doesn’t.
Apple left the door open a little, that if all the content providers agreed to a price increase, as long as it was uniform and consistant, then Apple would be open to that.
NBC chose to bail out. They tried to do Apple some damage because they are going to be competitiors, but Apple backslapped their silly ass.
Same fscktards that killed the Black Donnellys for no good damn reason. The only decent thing I’ve seen on network tv in ages. Now I remember why I don’t watch tv…
“Why make billions when we can make…millions!”
this just goes to show that the ppl at nbc are out of touch with reality and dont understand the market at all. they are either really old or really young or really stupid. i personally dont watch tv so if i watch a tv show it comes from itunes and i would be willing to bet im not a minority with the up and coming young ppl who are gobbling up macbooks in droves. i dont steal content and dont encourage anyone else to either. i think ppl work hard for their money and im not gonna cheat em outta it, but ill be damned if i pay 5 bucks for a lame ass tv show from a non cable network. if im payin five bux there better be some titty in it or somethin
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />.
@?what? – I like that, LOL!
if im payin five bux there better be some titty in it or somethin
@ goose: “What Apple should do to scare NBC is to buy Tivo, which market cap is 586 millions dollars, Apple Market cap is 119 billions, so there is enough money to take over Tivo….”
NO. What Apple should do – what they should have done from the beginning – is make AppleTV WITH A DVR. And a DVD player. what better way to put the fear of the Almighty Dollar into these idiots? It’s certainly a lot cheaper than buying TiVo. Besides, who needs their idiotic monthly fees?
Personally, I hope this is a wake up call for Steve Jobs. He really needs to stop pretending that this situation is ever going to get better. He’s been pinning a large share of the company’s future on remaking the success of the iPod/audio paradigm in video, and it just ain’t going to happen the way he’s been playing it. The hollywood studios are just too paranoid of Apple’s success – and power – at the expense of the record companies. It doesn’t matter that he’s practically saved the music industry from financial oblivion (or at least delayed it). The CEOs of these video/movie companies would rather have the ship they sail hit the shoals than give up that kind of control to one man/one company – even if it is in their shareholder’s best interests.
Jobs has been pussy-footing around this fact for too long. As a studio exec himself, he’s been ‘self-indentifying’ with them way too much. What’s good for Apple should be his focus. And what’s best for his Apple customers – not for his country-club cohorts – is what’s good for his company.
I’ve said it countless times before here, and I’m going to say it again: The iPod/iTunes system works BECAUSE the system allows you to record and/or rip your own audio and do what you want with it. The record companies don’t dare leave iTunes now because they know that people will have absolutely no incentive to buy from them otherwise – the hardware and technology Apple provides makes it easy to make them irrelevant if they try to gouge their customers.
The same thing – and ONLY the same thing – will work with video. Only when companies like NBC/Universal come to fear an AppleTV DVR, with all the software polish that only Apple can bring to bear, as well as a built in DVD player that makes ripping a snap (even if Apple doesn’t provide the software for that themselves), will they begin to negotiate with Jobs in good faith. They will do so for the same reason the record companies do now; to do otherwise is to accelerate the coming of the day when they can’t make money on selling movies or TV shows any longer.
C’mon Jobs. What more is it gonna take? How much more do you need to see? Leave the DRM shit behind. Don’t screw us over like that. Forget about tying your customers to iTunes first & foremost. If you give them the easiest way ever seen, to record their own pre-owned or already freely obtained content, then – just as with audio & the iPod – everything ‘video’ will fall into place.
All you have to do is JUST DO IT
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”cool mad” style=”border:0;” />
What a bunch of tools at NBC. If it wasn’t for iTunes, I never would have started watching The Office, which is easily the best show on TV right now (despite the fact it’s on NBC). I just don’t watch the big networks on broadcast TV anymore…if it wasn’t for iTunes, I wouldn’t be watching The Office and I’m pretty sure I’m not the only one.
I agree … $5 bucks is too much for an episode of TV programming…
On another note, does any one know of any links, hacks, info about downloading DVR content from a DirectTV set-top-box to an Apple Mac OSX? I’ve gotta get my Hero’s episodes on my iPhone! Thanks in advance.
“I wouldn’t be watching The Office”
I wouldn’t be watching the office for free. It’s about the lamest show out there.
Or I could DVR any of their shows for free. Or, wild concept here, watch it when it airs and go for pee breaks when the commercials come on. Also free, plus I cleanse my bladder.
Networks are dinosaurs anyway. Another five to ten years NBC, CBS, ABC, and that butt-ugly whore called Fox will all be museum relics.
@This is how business is done!!!
If you are planning to be, go f**k yourself and leave now… right now…
NBC is my favorite tv network, but if the F with Apple, they will loose as a TV viewer….
Huh?