PC World editor quits over Apple story

Apple Store“Colleagues at my former outlet, PC World magazine, have told me that Editor-in-Chief Harry McCracken quit abruptly today because the company’s new CEO, Colin Crawford, tried to kill a story about Apple and Steve Jobs,” Kim Zetter blogs for Wired.

“The piece, a whimsical article titled ‘Ten Things We Hate About Apple,’ was still in draft form when Crawford killed it. McCracken said no way and walked after Crawford refused to compromise. Apparently Crawford also told editors that product reviews in the magazine were too critical of vendors, especially ones who advertise in the magazine, and that they had to start being nicer to advertisers,” Zetter writes.

Zetter writes, “Crawford was former CEO of MacWorld and only started at PC World about a month ago. According to the PC World source, when Crawford was working for the Mac magazine, Steve Jobs would call him up any time he had a problem with a story the magazine was running about Apple.”

“The source didn’t know the specifics of what was in the story Crawford wanted to kill but said it was nothing new. ‘It was supposed to be light fare, just really innocuous stuff. The same kinds of things people have said about Apple before — things that teased Steve Jobs,’ he said,” Zetter writes.

“I reached McCracken on his cell who, from the sound of the background noise, seemed to be leaving the MacWorld party as we talked,” Zetter writes.

Zetter writes, “He didn’t want to discuss the details of why he resigned but said he quit ‘because of some fundamental disagreements with Colin.’ He emphasized that he wasn’t fired or forced out and holds no ill feelings toward the company… He said he actually resigned yesterday, but workers found out only about an hour ago. When asked what he’ll do now he said, ‘I’m going to blog and freelance at least for a while. I’ll probably write for PC World by the way. I want to make clear that I’m a huge admirer of what PC World does and I’m not leaving hoping that PC World will collapse with out me. I’m sure it won’t collapse without me.'”

Full article here.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “Twilightmoon” for the heads up.]
As Zetter writes, a “Ten Things We Hate About Apple” article certainly would be “nothing new.” Sheer boredom. Which is hopefully why Crawford killed the article. (For the record, we’d say the same if it was supposed to be “Ten Things We Love About Apple” — how many of these lame love/hate list articles do we need?) The rest of this blog report contains some stuff that may or may not be related to McCraken’s resignation from an anonymous source that may or may not have an ulterior motive to paint Crawford in a bad light. We also have McCracken’s take on the whole thing, which sounds a lot less conspiratorial than Zetter’s unnamed PC World source.

So, good luck in the future to whomever deserves it.

And, yes, we do still wish that Harry’s name was “Phil” instead.

68 Comments

  1. You’re right about the same boring articles over and over again. I quit buying all Mac mags after seeing the article ’20 ways to speed up your Mac’ for about the 50th time. It also didn’t help that their ‘Latest News’ features are full of stuff I had seen on MDN a month earlier. These guys have rested on their laurels for too long and have failed to compete with a faster and punchier online medium. ‘Ten things we hate about Apple’ just shows their total lack of creativity.

  2. On the name game, I was in the book store last night and saw George Tennet’s book, and got me to wondering….if he named his son Lou, and then Lou joined the military, he could be

    Lt. Lou Tennet

    Kinda like Major Major from Catch 22.

  3. So much speculation.

    Until and unless we see the article–unlikely–no one knows if it was killed because it might offend Apple or because it wasn’t up to snuff.

    It seems far more likely–but we don’t know–that it was simply an overdone concept than Apple would be horribly offended by it. There have been many list of reasons to hate Apple in the past.

  4. All credit to any editor who throws unimaginative articles in the bin. Magazines of all types are full of unoriginal stuff that we’ve seen before. If McCracken chooses to quit over such an inconsequential article, then there is either much more to the story than we’ve been told, or there is something profoundly wrong with his judgement.

    But what I find very alarming is Craword’s decree that reviewers should be less critical of manufacturers who advertise in his magazine. That’s a sure-fire way of making sure that no review can ever again be trusted. How can anybody trust a review that’s not impartial ?

    Magazines are becoming increasingly marginalised by the Internet. You can get news and opinion much more rapidly from the ‘net. The only two things that I think a magazine is still able to offer are impartial reviews and tutorials. Crawford has now eliminated one of those from PC World magazine. It’s now merely a vehicle for advertising and the advertisers call the shots.

  5. At University, used to have a math professor called Mrs. Assman. Always thought her surname was bit to, how should I put it, gender specific! ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  6. We have to be really careful here.

    For years, we’ve complained about the ‘bias’ shown by publications under the Ziff-Davies umbrella, including PC Magazine and ZDNet.

    However, on the basis that two wrongs don’t make a right, it certainly doesn’t bode well for the integrity of an independent media if the editors of IDG media channels can simply be “nobbled” by the CEO of any advertiser (Adobe, Apple, Microsoft, whoever) who doesn’t like what’s being written about them, their company or their products and services.

    In any case, CEOs should be CEOs and leave editors to do their job in peace so long as they don’t break the rules of journalistic ethics and bring the name of the parent company into disrepute; if this story is true, that doesn’t seem to be the case at IDG and someone – preferably the non-exec board – should take Crawford to one side and remind him what he’s supposed to do between 9 and 5 every day.

  7. true story:

    years ago i had a job with a guy who also worked as a minister. nice fella, great sense of humor. his name was Richard Rashe. he insisted that everyone call him “Dick”. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”gulp” style=”border:0;” />

    i guess he figured that everyone was gonna go there anyway so he just beat ’em to the punch! ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”LOL” style=”border:0;” />

  8. Some people believe everything they read…

    The only one on record in this piece is McCracken and he spoke in glowing terms about the magazine and if Zetter hadn’t been able to contact him, we wouldn’t be reading this story.

    McCracken resigned because Crawford TRIED to kill his story? No, Crawford killed two birds with one stone.

    Are anonymous PC World sources in this piece even credible?

  9. Never underestimate the power of advertisers and what they’re capable of doing in defense of their most precious asset: the brand.

    I’ve expressed my “misgivings” about Apple a few times online in the past and have even received phone calls from Cupertino as a result.

    Of course, they’ve never called to say “thank you” for the times I’ve openly expressed my support and endorsement of their company and products. And those far outnumber the “misgivings.”

    In this journalist’s case: “You never know whom you really work for.”

  10. Don’t give Apple too much credit-or hit PC World too hard on this item. It wasn’t that long ago that Apple tried to put a particular rumors site out of business for publishing advanced product information. I can’t remember which one, but it was the talk of this site for awhile. Also, Apple seems, at times, to sue at the drop of a hat anyone that takes exception to its grand plans. Apple’s legal staff can definately be “Richards” at times.

  11. @clyde
    How you guys get worked up and worried over ChrissyOne just because the name implies a female. You don’t know how many others posting here are female but don’t advertise it in a nickname…. ; )

  12. This sort of behavior — where business executives meddle in editorial matters — is one of the reasons why traditional media is in a death spiral and this is NOT a good thing.

    If consumers are to be served well by the media, it must be independent to provide a checks and balances system for society, government and business, and there must be a wall between editorial and advertising content. Undoubtedly, this unwarranted interference is why the editor resigned, and rightly so. The story may have been a dumb story, but the CEO is way out of line. This problem will only get worse as formerly independent media outlets are gobbled up by corporations that own multiple businesses.

  13. Seymore Butts could not be reached for comment. In other news, Hue Jass and Hue jardon were singled out and mocked for their name.

    Ex Editor-in-Chief Harry McCracken should be thankful. While the advertisers pay the bills, nothing keeps people buying your rag than a truthful review. Look at the auto-mags. Ever see a bad thing written about American cars? NEVER. And they are a trash product.

    thanks,
    Harden Thicke

  14. “‘It was supposed to be light fare, just really innocuous stuff. The same kinds of things people have said about Apple before — things that teased Steve Jobs,’ he said,” Zetter writes.

    In other words, the same bulls**t that Mac users have heard over and over again since the beginning of time. We are sick to death of this “innocuous stuff”. Huzzah to Crawford for saying “enough is enough”.

    (I also agree that McCracken likely did not quit over this. Anyone who would quit over a silly list article is an idiot who has no business being in the magazine industry.)

  15. Come on folks, if you really think youre getting journalistic integrity from a magazine about PCs or automobiles, I’ve got a lightly used bridge in Brooklyn that I like to sell to you.

    Well, if you want to be that cynical, why should any WinDell user believe any of the pro-Apple articles in any of the PC/IT magazines or the columns by Mossberg, Pogue or whomever.

    And why do we bother reading MDN’s compendium of those articles?

  16. There used to be a Minister for Gaming and Racing in New South Wales whose name was – wait for it – Richard Face.

    The question has been asked, many times before, “Just what were his parents thinking?”

  17. Good morning. The problem is never how to get new, innovative thoughts into your mind, but how to get old ones out. Every mind is a building filled with archaic furniture. Clean out a corner of your mind and creativity will instantly fill it.
    I am from Sweden and know bad English, give please true I wrote the following sentence: “Welcome to the alcohol treatment tag page at technorati.The reason people relapse google – alcohol treatment news.”

    With best wishes 8), Henry.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.