
“On April 12th, Apple announced that Mac OS X 10.5, Leopard, will be delayed from the original ‘Spring 2007’ ship date. Now it won’t ship until October,” John Martellaro writes for The Mac Observer.
“Considering that Apple had until June 21st (1806 UT) to ship Leopard, this is only a four month delay. In terms of OS releases, in general, this is no big deal some have said,” Martellaro writes.
“Well, yes it is,” Martellaro writes. “It’s actually a big deal because Apple had it within its power to avoid this setback.”
Martellaro writes, “Apple could have avoided this Leopard delay with good old fashioned management leadership. They could have allowed themselves to grow and mature a little. They could have empowered their key VPs to figure out what it would take to ship Mac OS X/Leopard on time, with excellence and exercise some authority. Unfortunately, many of Apple’s key VPs aren’t Lieutenant Generals. They’re Lieutenant Colonels.”
“Alas, Apple’s psychology and operating style is trapped in the $6B Valley of Death syndrome and not moving into a 21st century consumer electronics company that’s poised to move from $25B to, perhaps, $40B in just a few years,” Martellaro writes. “To get there in good shape, Apple will have to spend some money on something besides a half billion dollar new campus, forget the ghosts of the Michael Spindler and Gil Amelio eras, empower their VPs, and let their VPs become responsible for their own products, staff and OPEX.”
Full article – highly recommended – here.
[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “LinuxGuy and Mac Prodigal Son” for the heads up.]
Martellaro, as usual, makes a lot of sense. Obviously, Jobs knows what he’s doing, but nobody’s perfect. The bottom line is that the failure of Leopard to ship when promised is a failure. Perhaps it’s a minor failure, maybe just a one-time failure, but it’s a failure nonetheless.
Related articles:
Apple’s Mac OS X Leopard delay is a (somewhat) big deal – April 16, 2007
Apple buys 9 more acres in Cupertino – April 14, 2007
Apple’s latest Mac OS X Leopard build shows unified interface, buh-bye brushed-metal – April 14, 2007
eWeek’s Morgenstern: Apple’s Mac OS X Leopard delay is no big whoop – April 13, 2007
InformationWeek blows it again: reports second delay of Leopard this year due to Vista compatibility – April 13, 2007
Goldman Sachs, Merrill Lynch, Piper Jaffray: Use Apple’s Leopard delay as buying opportunity – April 13, 2007
Analysts unconcerned over Apple’s Mac OS X Leopard delay – April 13, 2007
Apple delays Mac OS X Leopard until October 2007, blames iPhone – April 12, 2007
Latest Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard build still accompanied by lengthy bug list – April 12, 2007
RUMOR: Apple to release Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard in June – April 02, 2007
Apple’s Mac OS X Leopard to feature ZFS? – March 29, 2007
Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard’s top secret ingredient: 3D everywhere, including new 3D Finder? – March 27, 2007
Apple to delay Leopard? Digitimes.com’s poor Apple rumor accuracy – March 23, 2007
Apple to postpone Mac OS X Leopard until October in order to support Windows Vista? – March 23, 2007
RUMOR: Some Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard ‘top secret’ features leak out – January 26, 2007
RUMOR: Apple Mac OS X Leopard to replace ‘Aqua’ with ‘Illuminous’ – December 11, 2006
Apple confirms ‘resolution independence’ and more coming in Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard – October 23, 2006
Cost of Apple’s second 50-acre Cupertino campus could top $500 million – April 25, 2006
Video: Steve Jobs meets Cupertino City Council – April 22, 2006
Transcript: Apple CEO Steve Jobs addresses the Cupertino City Council – April 20, 2006
Apple CEO Steve Jobs plans new 50-acre campus in California – April 19, 2006
Whilst there is always a case for the idea that management should have ensured that the company grew enough so it could cope with demand and keep to schedule. I would also argue that writing software (or doing anything else creative) isn’t something you can always put a specific timetable on, if it ends up taking longer than you might have estimated then you have two options: put more people on it or delay it. More haste less speed and too many cooks spoil the broth all have some relevance.
time will come……. just hold tight!
That damn George Bush…..
I certainly agree. It’s time to empower others besides Steve Jobs. Apple is growing at a phenomenal pace and it would be foolhardy to expect that everything would stay the same. The grooming process for Steve’s replacement should be underway already.
Jobs took the company from the edge of bankruptcy to the powerhouse it is today. He took Pixar from virtually nothing to a multi billion dollar company as well. He says he let Pixar’s people run Pixar. That means he knows how to delegate. I am sure he does not micro manage Apple.
Now some blogger who has never been a CEO of a major or even minor company is trying to criticize his leadership.
Bullshit.
I really don’t understand all the fuss… would people rather Leopard was released with bugs in June, or would they rather it was released in October with all the known bugs ironed out?
I just think people are being too fussy.
eh…yep…er….nope…
I think Apple’s leadership is better than ever. Better to be four months late with a great product than 4 months early with crap like some big software companies we know.
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
Yeah, we know that the leadership of Steve Jobs at Apple has just been one blunder after another so far right? You dipsh*t whiners have got to be kidding.
Big Al: You beat me to the punch.
and how long was longhorn/vista delayed??
t
“…empower their VPs, and let their VPs become responsible for their own products, staff and OPEX.”
Yeah, like Microsoft. Freaking brilliant idea.
It’s time for Apple to stop releasing its garbage (OSX) every year. They should take the time to make sure they get it right. Every 5 to 10 years should do it.
Jason D. O’Grady
http://www.powerpage.org
Here’s a hint Apple, don’t announce a timeline for release until the product is 100% ready for commercial sale. This would avoid those annoying negative blogs and consumer frustration. Of course, such honesty and integrity would require a sea change in corporate culture.
Software development isn’t a fixed process which can be precisely scheduled to complete in absolute time. Locating and fixing bugs is tedious, systematic and [unfortunately] often quite arbitrary.
Apple needs to spend a modest chunk of its new wealth on larger salaries and well-deserved bonuses for its own senior engineers and developers who actually create these great products.
Besides having a good name, “Jim” also makes good points. Any other company would probably have released Leopard with bugs in June and made up for it by October. Do we want that? No. I’d prefer a clean product release rather than a buggy one that gets followed up with a bunch of point releases to fix the issues.
I doubt that the author from The Mac Observer has ever been a software engineer, or a manager. If he had, he’d understand that his simple solution to the delay is not that simple. Sometimes perfecting a product takes time, not some manager standing over your head telling you to get it done.
My memory seems to be slipping today. Could someone please remind me what company John Martellaro runs?
Bloody back seat drivers!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”angry” style=”border:0;” />
I think that Jason is right. I’d rather wait until October and have something really hot than to get something sooner like an OS X version of Vista.
Much guessing and speculation. Companies are not run by one person making every decision and therefore he has no idea what Steve Jobs has given his VPs in respect to decision making authority.
Delays happen for a lot of reasons, lack of staff, can be one of them, but trained software engineers can not be hired and immediately speed things up as they need time to get up to speed and may actually delay the project further.
I would put this piece in the FUD category and by someone that has not worked in business much.
I think Apple should fire Steve Jobs. So we can hire him! Submit a resume, Steve.
Unfortunately I have to agree with Martellaro. OPEX? I wish I had some rather than crumbles: then I could do something.
My understanding based on reading other news reports here and elsewhere (so I may be totally wrong – lol), is that Leopard is done with the exception of some of the “top secret” items. Given what Windows users went through waiting for Longhorn/Vista where they not only waited for numerous time delays, but also alot of feature cutting as well. Since Tiger is already an excellent OS – I think that Apple is wise to delay the relase of Leopard to make sure all the features work, and avoid cutting any features simply to reach a set release date.
Big Al, Did you read his little bio at the bottom of the page??
As the planet warms, more software will be delayed.
I would put this piece in the FUD category and by someone that has not worked in business much.
He seems to know sufficiently enough to know that “Instead, each year, managers are asked to figure out ways to maintain or reduce their OPEX.”
MDN “office” . Incredible.
Who cares how late Leopard is, as long as it’s properly developed and works without major glitches right out of the box. Four months isn’t that long to achieve that.
How often can Microsoft say their OS manages to do that..?
If you give power to Veeps and then pressure them for results, guess what happens. You get bug ridden software (Vista) and poorly thought out products (Zune). In either case, the oOverseer did not have confidence in the ‘final’ product.
Is the release a failure, perhaps. But failures like that occur when you want to produce quality. I do not mind waiting (although I wish I didn’t have to). So easy to criticize the do-ers of this world.
Martellaro writes. “It’s actually a big deal because Apple had it within its power to avoid this setback.
“Apple could have avoided this Leopard delay with good old fashioned management leadership. They could have allowed themselves to grow and mature a little. They could have empowered their key VPs to figure out what it would take to ship Mac OS X/Leopard on time, with excellence and exercise some authority.
Who the FSCK is this guy?
First off there are a lot of things with Lepoard that the public is not informed about. There are a lot of things deeply inbedded in Lepoard that depend upon outside factors which is out of Apple’s control. These outside factors have changed which has influenced how and when Apple can release their next version of their OS.
For instance the hackers are chopping the hell out of AACS copy protection scheme designed to protect BlueRay DVD’s. The MIAA is pissed and if it can’t be made secure, we might never see BlueRay DVD movies on our computer screens. This will afffect Apple sales of Apple TV because no way in hell will the MIAA release HD content for iTMS unless the content can be made secure.
Anyone who has seen iTMS content on their HD screen can attest to the poor quality.
Another factor is the tons of third party software that wants a toehold on the new iPhone. Apple has to make sure this software works correctly and doesn’t cheapen the experience of a totally new approach to mobile computing.
So Apple is under pressure being the market innovator that’s a fact, somethings have been shuffled arround and delayed a bit, it’s no big deal.
Remmember Microsoft delayed their Vista for YEARS and Apple only delayed their UPGRADE for a few months, big difference
All of this talk of failures or reasons for delay on Leopard is a just a bunch of FUD! and MDN seems to feed off of it like a lot of beavers! Moving on!
John Martellaro seems to think that applying microsh*t management principles to Apple will work better. I happen to agree with most of the posts and call BULLSHIT as well. I don’t recall anything like this when mafiasoft delayed longhorn the first of many times. I think we don’t need to fix something that’s not broken. It may need some maintenance but I think SJ is in the best position to decide what maintenance is needed, if any.
MW=issue. As in I don’t think this is an issue.
His Steveness is a control freak.
Apple missed a chance to kill Vista.
You cuys who say “we dont care as long as it’s perfect and not buggy” are blinded apple fanboys.
Admit it, Apple made a mistake.
Even MDN can admit that.
Growing a company is one of the most difficult things to do.
Having an egoistic, only I can make decisions, who is involved with every tiny decision in products, such as theSteve is, can not work in the long run.
It may work in a small boutique shop with a small range of similar products, but not in rapidly growing and expanding business such as Apple hopes to be.
Wasn´t theSteve ousted before because he couldn´t grow Apple properly?
MDN: Martellaro, as usual, makes a lot of sense.
Oh, really? This armchair general makes it sound awfully easy how HE would have handled things. But where is HIS $80 billion valuation company? This is pure conjecture, with zero evidence to back it up.
Others have pointed out that software development often hits snags, even with good management. (This has been my experience as well.)
But beyond that, there’s no executive advice more brain-dead easy to give than “delegate more.” But, plenty of CEOs who delegate a lot more than Jobs are far less successful. And most observers have pointed out that Jobs’ attention to detail is one of Apple’s core strengths, to the point that there’s a lot of worry about replacing Jobs. Deciding to change Apple’s very successful recipe for management because of one little 4-month blip in the middle of a fabulous, multi-year growth spurt is a LOT tougher call than Martellaro makes it out to be. That’s not to say that some careful evolution isn’t worth looking at as Apple grows, but the old adage about not throwing out the baby with the bath water seems quite apropos.
Bah, this sounds like a columnist who has to pretend to write “profound” columns regularly to earn his paycheck. To paraphrase Jobs, some of the best decisions are the paths/products/advice we REFUSE to implement.
MW: “effects”–we should think carefully about the effects before tossing out a proven approach
Hmmm, it occurs to me that just maybe we should trust Steve Jobs. Apple learned long ago (Pirates of silicon valley) that you have to have politics with your business.
Apple is doing lots more with its people than HP and Microsoft. Its call “bloatware” and it drags down profit and makes it harder to do business.
JMHO.
en
The Leopard delay could be due to any number of reasons. It could well be delayed because of third-party hardware component suppliers not being ready. I’m thinking about the ‘top secret’ part of Leopard. Say it IS multi-touch to some degree – it will need monitors ready to ship IMMEDIATELY to make use of this ground-breaking feature… otherwise a revolutionary OS will go out the door – with all Apple’s fanfare on the future of computing – and no one will be able to use it. A bit like the Adobe UB lag, only a hundred times more damaging to Apple.
Creating the future doesn’t always work to normal guidelines for management or leadership practices…
Completely pathetic analysis in my opinion.
I hope Jobs and everyone at Apple are ignoring all this waffle.
I would rather wait for a good product, rather than have a neutered product like Vista. Does it look good? No. Has it been good for the stock? No.
Will it be best for users? Most likely, yes.
Apple may need to beef up its staffing instead of buying real estate. They are obviously spread a little thin with Apple TV, the iPhone, and Leopard. On top of that new Final Cut products, and other hardware business.
This has always been a lean company. They are expanding their product line to a degree that lean does not support such growth.
‘His Steveness is a control freak.’
Better than being an out of control freak.
Also, Al Gore, we all know that it is software that is CAUSING global warming-mainly from Microsoft……
1) SJ could have increased the head count to meet the artificial deadline and then lay them off after iPhones ship 4 month from now.
or
2) He could delay one of the product by 4 months and provide job security for his people.
What should he do?
Most CEOs in US have chosen Option 1 to keep Wall Street happy.
Shipping something before it is ready is a failure. Having the courage to slip a ship date knowing you will catch a lot of flack is leadership.
It’s quite possible that Apple made two decisions since Jan that made them favor the Leopard delay:
1. Open up the iPhone to more developers so as to have more software available upon release, thus requiring more support from OS engineers.
2. Spend more time to get Leopard more fully developed and debugged because Vista has turned out to be relatively insignificant competition (in other words, no big jump over XP).
I think Steve should stay the course.
Go watch your TV. Every sensible person has already figured out that Apple’s previous removal of Jobs was one of the most idiotic board actions in corporate history. If you can’t even figure that out, why should anyone listen to you?
Jake
I agree with Big Al. There’s a lot of pikers out there who couldn’t run a hot dog stand. Yet, these same people write articles knocking someone or some company.
John Martellaro sounds like my wife. Just because he has an opinion, it doesn’t make him accurate or right.
I have no complaints with Apple. Great hardware and software. Period.
Yes, I agree with the writer. Apple has failed. I want a half baked 10.5.0 release of Leopard so that I can find bugs in it and apply the quickly released 10.5.1 update, only to find that there are more bugs. I will then scream and yell at Apple for not releasing update 10.5.2 to fix the remaining bugs. Yes, I like Apple when they release a half baked OS and then advertise it as the best OS on the planet. Yes, Apple has failed here.
/sarcasm off/
Wiseguy…
This guy is someone that is correct in saying that this delay was not necessary with better management. This is a FACT. If the iPhone was going to require so much resourcing, then this should have been not only estimated, but also MANAGED so as to not delay Leopard.
By the way, Leopard is not “just an upgrade” as you suggest.
Apple has been touting that Leopard is very much a SIGNIFCANT OS release, with features and technolgy way beyond Tiger.
To turn your question around though… If Vista is such a MAJOR leap over XP, and Leopard is ONLY just a simple upgrade (as you have suggested, not me) then YEARS to delay a major release is more understandable than delaying an upgrade at all!!!!???
It was nice to see MDN acknowledge that this is a FAILURE on Apple’s part.
MDN and this Author at The Mac Observer are doing the RIGHT thing by taking Apple to task over this.
If Apple is to become the Microsoft beater you fan(atic) boys aspire to, then it HAS TO become better at managing these sorts of projects, and it CERTAINLY needs to recognise that in the CONSUMER electronics and media business (unlike the PC hardware and software business) delays are NOT an option.
Apple was right to make sure iPhone is out at all costs, in the mobile phone game a few months makes a HUGE difference to the “newness” of you feature set.
However, if they had managed BOTH these projects resourcing appropriately (or at least BETTER) they SHOULD have been anticipating these things, and not promising dates that couldn’t be achieved.
my 2 cents.
Luke
Let me get this straight. More management would have fixed this? Umm…yeah. Right.
Why are their so many posters here at MDN comparing Micorsoft and Apple?
Why does a late delivery of a product by Microsoft give Apple the right to be late in delivery???
What does the delay of an Apple product have to do with Microsoft?
I don´t own a Windows computer. Do you all??? Why are you all obsessed with Microsoft?
Does Ford compare itself to Porsche when it fails or succeeds?
Does Pepsi users whine about Coca-Cola´s late arriving new soda?
Quit the Microsoft vs. Apple comparisons already!!!
Me thinks the tech writers want Apple to release buggy software so that they can bring out the “See, Apple writes crappy OS software, just like Microsoft” cannard. Yes, they want Apple to fail so that Microsoft can compare favorably. Steve is not having any of that, believe me now, listen to me later.
Yet another blogger who thinks he can run Apple better than Apple can. There is a reason these people are lowly, insignificant bloggers and not visionary CEOs of multi-billion dollar companies.
This guy’s arguments have no basis in fact. He is commenting on that which he does not know because only Apple knows what goes on inside of Apple. I’d rather Apple admit that Leopard isn’t ready and delay it then ship it and “pull a Vista” on us all.
To the Mac dudes and dudettes that have been with OS X since it’s intro back in mar ’01. How many times have we gone through this process of getting the latest and greatest release, only to find that there are parts of the OS that are still not complete. I am glad that Apple is late here. It will save all of the users the hassles that come with being an early adopter of new technology. I say that the tech writers should quit over-reacting to this because they will probably be made to look like fools in the end by his Steveness.
Kudos to Apple for having the balls to get it right rather than releasing a piece of shite.
MDN must be desparate for stories to put this up. Probably why I come here so rarely, craptacular headlines like this that deserve no reading.
The real story here, and the one that Apple couldn’t really say in a press release is that the competitive threat from Vista is so amazingly small, that Apple didn’t NEED to hit the spring 2007 date.
Yes, I would like Apple to never miss a date. They’ve become so dependable that it is indeed a bit disappointing that June won’t be hit. I was getting excited about Leopard, too. However, if Apple was not seeing the market share growth numbers continue after Vista was released, then they would have figured out a way to still get this done.
The other logic here has nothing to do with development schedules. It has to do with market concentration. Steve is very good at making sure that folks can FOCUS on a new marketing message.
So, AppleTV gets limelight for 2-3 months, then iPhone 2-3 months. The problem was that between AppleTV and iPhone, two products dependent on the FCC process, there was no open window of time for the market to FOCUS on Leopard. Now, when Leopard comes out, it will dominate the holiday buying season for Apple (no coupons like Vista either).
Finally, I fully expect Leopard to be the first of a new breed of OS, an OS ecosystem and not just another desktop OS release. I would suspect that the top-secret features have something to do with desktop, notebook, AppleTV and iPhone, and since not all of these platforms are in the market yet, the “top-secret” stuff wouldn’t have made sense without them….
There is always a bigger picture with Steve!!
Overcoming our failures in life is what makes us better. We can’t improve unless we face actual failure.
I personnally think that postphoning Leopard is a good idea. Why? So that it won’t compete with iPhone. They should launch iPhone successfully, then after all the hub-bub dies down, launch Leopard before the holidays. Nice combo if you ask me.
Right enough, but perhaps a litle harsh.
After all, this is leading edge science, not chocolate drops
Sometimes things just do run late, not through incompetence but because of unexpected and – importantly – unquantifiable problems on the way.
No excuses you understand, just a little understanding. I too want Leopard and Time machine!
And of clourse, an iPhone
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />
I’ll just add myself to the list of people who think all these whiners should just shut up. It will be ready when it’s ready. You may want it now, but you’ll just have to wait. Get over it.
Could be Apple knows more about what’s going into Leopard than he does.
He might be right, but he shouldn’t be so quick to judge until it’s released.
This guy needs to read the Mythical Man Month.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Mythical_Man-Month
The simple fact is programmers were switched from leopard to the iphone
2 big products at once, simply a one off
though one which could have been avoided
Oh nice. More business advice from someone whose management experience is probably limited to the morning shift at the local arby’s. Why is everyone blowing this way out of proportion? Yea it sucks.. but this is software.. for a project this large, you don’t even need a good reason to be 4 months late.
I don’t know if the iPhone is the real reason. For all we know, they chose 4 months to give people a “breathing period” so they don’t have to decide if they want to shell out $500 for the iPhone or $130 for the OS upgrade. Whatever the reason I wish people would take a deep breath and relax. It will be okay.
TT
Global warming is actually caused primarily by Rush Limbaugh opening his mouth.
Sure Apple needs to expand. And those apparently useless campuses that Apple are building are going to be housing more engineers so that Apple can meet their goals in the future.
Apple started this expansion a year or two ago with buying more land in Cupertino and re-developing it.
This stuff takes time to put together. Plus Apple don’t necessarily want to hire people who suck at their job simply to put more hands on the job. They need dedicated people who will bust their arse for the man.
I absolutely disagree with the majority of the posts on this page. Of course none of us know exactly what is going on with Leopard, but on the face of it the decision to delay and to delay for four months, is in all probability not only the right decision, but an example of strong and good management.
This is an example of basic sound management. Projects often do not run smoothly. This is a fact of life in every field of business. And the reason(s) can be one of many. The key to good management is how you respond. The biggest mistake is to panic and shout. To throw (often the wrong) resources and to demand that problems are solved quickly. The result? Usually more delay, more wasted money and often disaster.
The right way is to calmly identify the problems and what needs to be done. make sure the right people (not necessarily different or more people) are working on the project; and then, crucially, give them a realistic time frame to work within.
I think that this is the approach Apple is taking, and more power to them.
Isn’t that the kind of setup that Microsoft has? And how has that been working for them?
He does seem to be allowing ‘management’ some sort of credit it, oh, so often, does not deserve. Indeed, the elevation of ‘managers’ to something other than paper-pushing status is a symptom of the decline of the real ability to do business. More managers is practically always a sign of ossification, stagnation, and hubris on the part of a company. More organization, perhaps. More managers? No.
Wait a minute, isn’t this Bill Clinton’s fault?
One word to fix the Apple management problem: cloning.
Alas, we will never know how to look at this until Daniel Eran blogs on it.
semi-serious, stop it.
1. Releasing a product on time but filled with bugs and postponing a product release with less bugs are not the only two options, so people should stop acting like those are the only two scenarios.
2. You don’t need to have certain qualifications in order to recognize problems or make criticisms. If that were the case, then none of us would be qualified to criticize anything about the government or even Microsoft, which I know plenty of people here do, even though they don’t run billion dollar companies.
I agree that this is an example of good management. Delaying a product because what you have is not ready for prime time is a good decision. Sometimes, unanticipated issues arise. UN-ANTICIPATABLE, as well. When M$ delayed Vista because what they had was inadequate, that was a good management decision. Unfortunately for them, it followed a management failure to recognize the major limitations of their vision until it was too late.
Apple is not in that position now. Apple’s vision is enormous and achievable, but not without some extra effort.
Did anyone actually read the article? It actually makes some good points, which MDN recognizes. For example:
“First, Apple hates to increase what’s called operating expenses, “OPEX”. You’ll hear Tim Cook talk about this at Earnings Calls. It’s a Silicon Valley obsession that as OPEX goes down, profits go up. Wall Street loves this. Investors love it. CFOs love it.
The effect is that it’s virtually impossible for an Apple manager to significantly increase their staffing based on their own judgment. Instead, each year, managers are asked to figure out ways to maintain or reduce their OPEX.
As a result, when a product comes along, like the iPhone, that’s based on Mac OS X, human resources remain constant while the demands of coding and QA grow and grow.”
Steve may have mellowed a bit, but, he has not changed. He will quit being the El Commandante when they pry Apple from his cold dead hands.
Lieutenant Colonels and Lieutenant Generals. Hooy! Not going to happen. I am glad for it.
The world is full of well managed mediocrity. There is so little quirky greatness. I savor it.
Waiting is such sweet agony.
One of the side effects of being perfect is that anything less than “perfect” every time out appears to be a failure. Apple has been as perfect as it is possible to be in the last few years. So if it says the Sun will rise from the South tomorrow, and it doesn’t happen until two days later, the lapse is painted as a major failure! While Martellaro brings up some valid points regarding Apple’s future, there is no reason to believe Apple is suddenly fallible just because of a few months’ delay in releasing the next OS.
Complete and utter bullshit. The company that grew from a $6B to a $20B did so with the philosophy management he attacks.
Writing software is a tricky thing, don’t fool yourself that throwing more manpower would have solved this. Last time I checked, Apple had 11,000 employees, that has grown to 18,000 by now. It’s not a management problem. There’s a price to pay for the awesome softwrae that Mac OS X is. It’s a 4 month delay, get over it.
Make no mistake: that 3 hour WWDC keynote will be HISTORIC.
As VISTA is obviously a failure, why hurry with 10.5? As that pressure is gone, I prefer to see it well or better done for fall. And as the iPhone could hit like the iPod has done – well there’s a lot of potential switchers out there.
Yes on MDN’s take. Its still a relatively minor failure in the broader scheme of things, but the market’s tolerance and the consumer’s tolerance are now officially pushed to the edge, and I think that Apple has used up it’s “Brownie Points” for the year. Apple needs to be much more cautious from here on out about its pre-announcement timing. I would even suggest that they stop pre-announcing entirely for this year, and only announce releases as they’re completed and ready for market.
Apple’s got a potentially hazardous little cycle going early on this year, and it goes something like:
1) Long drawn out rumor of new device or software.
2) An official pre-release announcement.
3) Wall Street gives Apple lots of positive press.
4) We wait.
5) When release is imminent Apple announces a delay.
6) Wall Street says its not worried.
7) We wait, and hope.
This harkens back to the early and middle 90’s when Apple was becoming infamous for announcing new product and then not being able to deliver on time or in quantity.
Look, small set backs are not the make-or-break scenarious that they would have been even a few years ago for Apple, but the patience of the market place has already been worn thin in the tech sector as it is, and if huge companies like MS have to pay the piper for long and repeated wait times, then you can be sure it will be potentially worse for still-up-and-comings like Apple. The iPhone is going to rock, Leopard is going to rock, but lets not allow hasty announcements to blow the wind out of the sails – please.
For those who insist that “APPLE FAILED!” because they missed their deadline by four months, how many of you actually work in the software business? Please, a show of hands. Here’s a little something about me — I do. I’ve personally seen schedules slip by years, and you know what? The way most software houses run is that they set a date, work on the full feature set up to the mid-point, and then start cutting features to meet the date. (Yes, this happens even with detailed schedules). The result? BAD PRODUCTS. Apple has put quality first instead of schedule first. Doing this means they’ll take flak from the sea of ignorant armchair estimators (who know everything), but whose opinion really counts for squat. I’m talking to most of you.
Software engineering is an imperfect science. Scheduling it is even more of an imperfect science. I don’t care what kind of predictive genius you are — things come up that no-one can anticipate, especially when you are on the cutting edge. Are you honestly saying that you have a way to anticipate and accurately estimate the impact of unknowns? Again, if you do, you need to set up a psychic hotline fast and make some real dough, instead of wasting time touting your intelligence on MDN.
This article and MDN’s take are right on. The delay is a blunder, the magnitude of which will not be realized until later this year. It was Apple’s golden opportunity to checkmate Microsoft with a vastly superior OS that will set the bar to an unattainable height. The oppotunity is mostly gone. It’s all about timing, and Apple’s OSX GARFIELD (aka Leopard) let everyone down. Check that, Apple’s leadership, or lack thereof, let everyone down. Anyone touting the OS delay or justifying Apple’s decision to pull resources from Leopard to the iPhone as good things is a blind optimist. This was a leadership debacle of the highest order. Nuff said!
Keeping that same military scenario. Battle is a fluid situation. It’s not expected to work totally as planned. Your opposing troops might not be where your spies and other intelligence have predicted, and it’s how you manipulate your troops into position for that situation that wins the battle, not being lucky to be in the right place at the right time. Apple is doing the best that they can with what they’ve got to work with, and the battle is not over yet.
I don’t see how this is a ‘major blunder’. If it finally comes out in October, Vista will be nothing if not more detested.
Now might have been better, but Oct. isn’t too late.
It’s not Microshaft or M$ or even Micro$oft, it’s Micros**t
Micros**t Micros**t Micros**t
Everyone remember that.
actually, Apple could make that a saying
Vista gets detested,
Leopard gets retested.
So, let’s be realistic…. Apple is no longer a company that can be controlled and run by a single person. It is high time that all VP’s, Directors and Managers be given additional authority and accountability for their areas of expertise. Apple will not be able to make the jump to hyperspace without a full crew. Steve is a great CEO, but he needs help from the chosen people who occupy the big $$$ positions. It’s time to let the company spread it’s wings and soar.
Based on results, Apple has nothing to be apologetic about. Apple’s software and design engineers are operating 20 years ahead of the curve. The complexity of what they have accomplished ought to be appreciated. Instead we continue to see this type of FUD from a bunch of loser, backseat drivers, whose $$$pockets are fed in obscene/obscure ways by Microshxt.
I’m as disappointed as anyone, but I want a bug-free OS that I can count on. But I do demand to see all the secret features…the people waiting are owed that and now the new OS need something to hype about featurewise to smoke over being a little late. With however many billion in cash reserve, I don’t like the mobile backpack of excuses blaming resources being called elsewhere. Don’t make excuses, just say we are late and want to get it right. The iPhone is not a good excuse, as one is computer hardware and one is consumer electronics.
Bottom line…I really need to be impressed at this 3 hour keynote for my wallet to vibrate.
“the sky is falling” Chicken Little, 1934
I’m just amazed because I don’t think I’ve ever heard MDN agree with criticism of Apple before! I was expecting MDN to issue some uber-sarcastic criticism of Martellaro.
But maybe our MDN is growing up…
Maybe there is some strategy in this. Has anyone thought of that?
“Shipping something before it is ready is a failure. Having the courage to slip a ship date knowing you will catch a lot of flack is leadership.”
Making sure that measures and resources are in place to prevent a delay is good leadership. I’m not saying that Steve isn’t a great leader, but Apple dropped the ball this time. When the marketplace and millions of people are watching your moves every day, you better understand your team, your load, and your deadlines. If you foresee a strain in any of those, then you MUST put in place solutions to resolve them. Pointing to another company’s failure does not make your own failure any better (two wrongs make a right?). This doesn’t mean that Steve Jobs should be fired but somewhere in the leadership totem pole someone wasn’t proactive in allocating and managing resources/time.
You know, it’s probably smart to spread out your income growth opportunities.
iMaki said
“This article and MDN’s take are right on. The delay is a blunder, the magnitude of which will not be realized until later this year. It was Apple’s golden opportunity to checkmate Microsoft with a vastly superior OS that will set the bar to an unattainable height. The oppotunity is mostly gone. It’s all about timing, and Apple’s OSX GARFIELD (aka Leopard) let everyone down. Check that, Apple’s leadership, or lack thereof, let everyone down. Anyone touting the OS delay or justifying Apple’s decision to pull resources from Leopard to the iPhone as good things is a blind optimist. This was a leadership debacle of the highest order. Nuff said!”
Whatever…. Why does every Apple critic want to classify this slight delay as a failure? Copeland, Pink, and Taligent were failures. Those efforts never saw the light of day. What about Vista? a 5 year delay, and when it finally showed up most to all of the ‘major features’ were MIA, security was a joke, it has been panned as a ‘must skip’ upgrade.
Leopard, when it ships, will be the right OS at the right time. Its feature set will be complete. It will not have to share the spotlight with the TV, or iPhone. Frustration with MessySoft Vista will be at an all time high, with people willing to put down $$$ for Apple products and Leopard at the beginning of the critical Holiday Consumer Retail Spending Season.
Not only will Leopard not have to share the spotlight with TV and iPhone, it will capitalize on their success, and that of the 6G widescreen/touchscreen Video iPod if such a beast actually shows up this fall for back to school.
Regarding Apples’ chance to checkmate Vista with a vastly superior OS being gone, maybe you should check again. As Mossberg and others have already pointed out, the Vastly Superior to Vista OS X 10.4 Tiger is ALREADY HERE! It has been for like 18 months before Vista hit PC builders.
MW soon… as in “Oct is soon enough”
Everybody knows how Apple should be run. Where were they with their assh…ur…opinions when Apple was on the brink?
Hey TowerTone, how’s Iraq going for ya?
iMaki writes, “This article and MDN’s take are right on. The delay is a blunder, the magnitude of which will not be realized until later this year. It was Apple’s golden opportunity to checkmate Microsoft with a vastly superior OS that will set the bar to an unattainable height. The oppotunity is mostly gone. “
sigh…
1) The opportunity is NOT gone. Most of the people who are thinking of migrating to Vista are waiting for the inevitable Service Pack 1.
2) It surprises me how personally people are taking a business decision. Apple does not know you personally (at least in most cases). This was a business decision. We may not like it. Apple probably does not like it. But like any good management team, they examined the choices and made a difficult one. Further, they announced it 3 months before the revised release date.
3) Management is the balancing of resources.
Could Apple have hired more engineers? Yes.
Would it have avoided this situation? Maybe.
Would it have decreased Apple profit margins? Yes.
Remember Apple is a business and needs to make money. And bringing additional engineers onto the team late in the game may have resulted in little additional productivity.
the other Mark: “Remember Apple is a business and needs to make money. And bringing additional engineers onto the team late in the game may have resulted in little additional productivity.”
– Obviously you did not read the article. Go back and read the article and then you can comment on it.
Failure – too strong, blunder – too strong, oversight, maybe about right.
The article seems to be written from a conventional business point of view, that point of view that produces crappy Microsoft software, crappy Dell computers, autos that use polluting fuel, food that is full of poisons and has decreasing essential requirements and the massive list of most products produced by conventional business. All these products cost far more in the medium to long term than good quality products but the bean counters want more beans now and can’t see that more beans now is less in the future.
Apple does very well in a marketplace and total environment obsessed with cheap shit by striving to make as good as they can that will be acceptable to enough people to keep the everyone (customers, employees, investors) happy. No one gets it right 100% of the time, the mistake was announcing the date rather than missing it.
When talking about control freaks it is The Street that is prime candidate. They were asking for more forward visibility on new products, they get it and they throw a strop when things don’t pan out as predicted, that’s the nature of prediction folks.
It’s a blip, move on already, no one is harmed by this delay.
He makes zero sense. None at all. One four-month delay does not a management collapse make, and his inferring that it does is ludicrous.
In fact, the decision to get iPhone out the door and delay Leopard in the process is what a kick-ass management team would do. Microsoft and most other companies would have thrown temps at the issue and either shipped crap or delayed them both.
A smart management team knows that you do not staff for peaks. It would be stupid to hire 250 more developers and try to throw them at the problem (mythical man-month and all that), so you make the hard decisions and move forward. It’s a shame that actually seeing good management in action blinded him to the process.
Yes, Leopard being delayed is a failure. No question about that. But this article is the height of knee-jerk reaction. Sheesh.
G-Spank-
Mind your manners.
Al Gore-
If the left wouldn’t give him so much to complain about, maybe he could….
Global Warming is clearly a myth. The ice caps are not melting. Everything is fine. Let’s watch Survivor.
Interesting point about Apple still being stuck in a “lean times” mentality.
But considering other people are worried the company is become too bloated and unfocused, the question is who do we believe? Does this guy have any real information to support his argument, or is he just speculating?
MW: faith. heh
See, the problem is this is a Catch 22 situation.
1: Empower VPs and the mediocrity seeps in. Choices are made that are not quite right. And quite right isn’t enough. For staffing choices and development teams, sure, go for it. But remember, once the rush is over, what do you do with the excess personnel? Oh yeah, develop new products!
What a great idea!
2: Don’t empower them, and Apple never quite makes it to the big time.
See, the problem is this is a Catch 22 situation.
1: Empower VPs and the mediocrity seeps in. Choices are made that are not quite right. And quite right isn’t enough. For staffing choices and development teams, sure, go for it. But remember, once the rush is over, what do you do with the excess personnel? Oh yeah, develop new products!
What a great idea!
2: Don’t empower them, and Apple never quite makes it to the big time.
See, the problem is this is a Catch 22 situation.
1: Empower VPs and the mediocrity seeps in. Choices are made that are not quite right. And quite right isn’t enough. For staffing choices and development teams, sure, go for it. But remember, once the rush is over, what do you do with the excess personnel? Oh yeah, develop new products!
What a great idea!
2: Don’t empower them, and Apple never quite makes it to the big time.
See, the problem is this is a Catch 22 situation.
1: Empower VPs and the mediocrity seeps in. Choices are made that are not quite right. And quite right isn’t enough. For staffing choices and development teams, sure, go for it. But remember, once the rush is over, what do you do with the excess personnel? Oh yeah, develop new products!
What a great idea!
2: Don’t empower them, and Apple never quite makes it to the big time.
“See, the problem is this is a Catch 22 situation. “
What you describe is not a Catch-22.
The maturity level of MDN comes into question once again. The implied certainty and absoluteness about something being a failure. MDN, get a little older and wiser, and you’ll see what I mean.
Remember Apple steve left and before he came back. There are only so many people who can run a business the right way, just because a bunch of people have MBA’s doesn’t mean they can make billion dollar companies or run them after the builder has left. So just throwing a project to a VP and giving them a huge budget doesn’t mean good things arrive. Steve Jobs is one of few and we are lucky to have him. If some things end up a little behind it’s better than screwed up.
Fake Steve summed up the article pretty well:
http://fakesteve.blogspot.com/2007/04/everybodys-expert.html
Did you all read this Apple’s Statement at Apple’s Hot News page?
http://www.apple.com/hotnews/
Apple Statement
iPhone has already passed several of its required certification tests and is on schedule to ship in late June as planned. We can’t wait until customers get their hands (and fingers) on it and experience what a revolutionary and magical product it is. However, iPhone contains the most sophisticated software ever shipped on a mobile device, and finishing it on time has not come without a price — we had to borrow some key software engineering and QA resources from our Mac OS X team, and as a result we will not be able to release Leopard at our Worldwide Developers Conference in early June as planned. While Leopard’s features will be complete by then, we cannot deliver the quality release that we and our customers expect from us. We now plan to show our developers a near final version of Leopard at the conference, give them a beta copy to take home so they can do their final testing, and ship Leopard in October. We think it will be well worth the wait. Life often presents tradeoffs, and in this case we’re sure we’ve made the right ones. [Apr 12, 2007]
First bold sentence is the key to the reason for Leopard release delay. so without QA resource then Final release can’t be tested in time for release at WWDC.
Second bold sentence tells us that developers who show up at WWDC will get their hands on Leopard in near final quality and that there will be 3 hours of Keynotes meaning we will know everything about Leopard including secrets that Jobs has been holding back. That’s good news.
Third bold sentence says that Apple feels that they made right decision which I agree with instead of this stupid article which the author didn’t think about QA. And I think iPhone is important that it has to be released this June than October because of exclusive agreement with Cingualr (AT&T). And also, we get to get a more cleaner final quality of Leopard this October instead.
All humans must be perfect …. must never make mistakes …. must hang imperfect humans ….
When Steve Jobs rejoined Apple, the first thing he did was toss people who think like this. They are wholly negative, can only see and nitpick for failures, even in the midst of the biggest roaring comback of the decade. Theirs are the minds that populate MediocreSoft.
Maybe, just maybe, Steve Jobs and company are a lot smarter that this anal prig, no matter how well this self-annointed judge seems to make his boneheaded case. Apple’s stock numbers prove it beyond doubt.
Just means delayed cash flow … how many are like myself that will refuse to by a soon to be out dated product.
I’ve been itching to replace my old Power Mac, but I got burned on that last time. Got this thing 2 months before 802.11g, and the darn new airport card won’t fit in it. Obsolete before it got out of the box.
I am NOT going to buy a new $2000+ computer, and then pony up more $$ just a couple months later for the new OS.
I might consider it if it was garanteed that I’d get the upgrade when it was released. (and not pay even even the obsurd fee that the 801.11n upgrade was charging)
The guy is a moron – so he knows what to do to make Apple successful…. gosh, if only Steve Jobs could pick his brain!
I am a huge Mac fan and think they should decide to stay with Apple, but this article is significantly slanted.
In a school district as opposed to the corporate world where there is a significant lack of funding, the decision often does come down to the bottom line. Even with all the anti-virus and spyware software and all of the multi-media authoring software they will need to purchase to be comparable with iLife software and all of training required to switch to a different operating system and all of the financing, Dell still has a lower TCO.
Due to Apple’s delayed release of Leopord operating system until October, it will probably cost Hays School District nearly $150,000 extra dollars to go Apple because they will have to purchase the Apple Maintenance Program on all the laptops to get the Leopard operating system; Plus an additional fee to upgrade to iLife 07 when it is released.
Also weighting on the technology director’s mind must be the exponential logic board failure that Hays has reportedly experienced over the last 3 years with the Apple iBook.
I think the student opinion in the decision should be valued. Thanks Derek for the link.
http://www.hayshighguidon.com/MacPC/Mac_PCOpinion.html
Oops! That comment is related to this article:
http://www.macdailynews.com/index.php/weblog/comments/13327/