“Wal-Mart’s announcement it will offer downloads of ‘Superman Returns’ over the Internet applies only to Windows users. PCs and portable devices using Windows Media Player will be able to play the copy protected programming, but the retailer explained in an FAQ on the Wal-Mart Web site, ‘These videos are not compatible with Apple iPods,'” Frank Barnako blogs for MarketWatch.
“After you buy the DVD at list-minus-the discount, the price to download the movie file to your PC or ‘Plays for Sure’ and Zune player is less than full retail,” Barnako reports. “An extra $3.97 gets files for both your portable players and the PC, less if you want to watch the movie on just your player or laptop/PC.”
Full article here.
From Wal-Mart’s press release:
With the purchase of the Superman Returns physical DVD, customers can choose from three video download format options — $1.97 for portable devices, $2.97 for PCs/laptops, and $3.97 for both portable players and PC/laptops… Using the video download “feature sticker” on the cover of the Superman Returns physical DVD, customers access http://www.walmart.com/superman , enter the promotional code, and select their desired download format… In the coming months, Wal-Mart will test additional DVD bundles.
From Wal-Mart’s FAQ:
We currently support Microsoft Windows XP (no Macintosh or Linux). We only support Microsoft Windows Media Player version 10 or higher. The Portable format is optimized for on-the-go viewing using “PlayForSure” portable video players. If played on a PC, the image quality will not be as good as the higher resolution Standard format. These videos are not compatible with Apple iPods. Portable format videos are encoded at a 320 x 240 resolution with an average bit rate of 500 kbps. Standard format videos are encoded at a 640 x 480 resolution with an average bit rate of 1,500 kbps.
How many extra $3.97 downloads does Wal-Mart expect to sell by offering content limited to only ‘Plays for Sure’ also-ran players? According to Wal-Mart’s FAQ, Barnako is wrong, Zune is not supported as it does not support “PlayForSure.”
Related articles:
Report: Apple and Wal-Mart in discussions over iTunes Store alliance – September 29, 2006
Wal-Mart: we’re not fighting iTunes Store movie downloads – September 23, 2006
Wal-Mart threatens retaliation against Hollywood studios if they sell movies via Apple’s iTunes – September 22, 2006
Wal-Mart loses ‘philosophical argument’ with Apple CEO Steve Jobs, gains top-selling iPod – November 29, 2005
…and this is why! Siding with the tyrants!
So what’s the resolution of the $2.97 PC-version?
If you’re buying the DVD, why would you need another version for your PC/laptop? Couldn’t you just watch the DVD on your computer if you wanted to? People don’t want two copies of the same thing, one on disc and one on their hard drives. The advantage of downloads is eliminating the in-store experience and the physical medium altogether. The DVD plus a version formatted for a portable video player are all you need.
If you bought the DVD, why do you need to buy the “download” version? Just rip it yourself.
Wal-Martians…
I went to a Wal-Mart last year in search of a particular product. The parking lot was strewn with shopping carts just abandoned anywhere they ceased being useful, making driving through the lot difficult at best. The place smelled bad, with soul sucking lighting, and
preternaturally smiling octogenarians greeting people while wearing 20 pounds of swag.
It’s literally sickening that this is what free enterprise and capitalism run amok has come to mean in America. Even their TV spots suck ass.
Besides, if you actually bought the disc, why not rip it (using any number of FREE pieces of software!) to whatever format and quality you want??? Stooopid.
From John: ” … So Walmart you wasted a lot of money and time as no one will buy this crap unless they are very stupid.”
You are correct – but there are a bunch of “stupid” people out there. That’s why MicroShaft and Wally World are so wealthy!
Ripping the DVD works MUCH better for me. I can rip it at 720 AND at a higher bitrate, for the big cost of $0. This ofcourse would only be for portable devises… like the iPod. As someone else pointed out, if you already have the DVD, why would your download another, much lesser quality to watch on your PC? Just watch the freakin’ DVD.
Good job Wal-mart. Sounds like your learning a few things about ‘innovation’ from good ol’ Microsoft.
“With the purchase of the Superman Returns physical DVD, customers can choose from three video download format options — $1.97 for portable devices, $2.97 for PCs/laptops, and $3.97 for both portable players and PC/laptops…”
Why would anyone with a smidgen of intelligence purchase a download after having the original film on DVD? That’s like paying twice for the same product, except that the downloaded version sold by Wal-Mart is of inferior quality! Seems that Wal-Mart made a similar deal with the film studios as Microsoft did with the music industry. This is what happens when you have no leverage in the market, you acquiesce.
It’s no wonder that Wal-Mart only offer this service to Windows and non-iPod users. Mac and iPod users are far too savvy to fall for this crap.
And, please, let’s not forget that the Wal-Mart downloading experience is likely to be as frustrating as a visit to the DMV.
PlayForSure is dead.
Long live SquirtsForSure.
Who knew; they could make their online experience just as crappy as their in store one.
Well, it looks like we have a consensus. Wal-Mart’s strategy is a perfect tool to identify the mentally deficient members of society. I would expect that the Wal-Mart buyers database would be strikingly similar to Microsoft’s Zune owners database. What a shame to find your name on both lists.
It just goes to show the average intelligence of a Walmart executive – too pig ignorant to recognise that this strategy deliberately excludes 75% of the market.
Way to go. If you have Walmart shares then go to the next AGM and challenge the commercial validity of this decision. Then buy your movies from iTunes.
Cheers
f Walmart.
1) Join Netflix
2) Order movie
3) Rip it to hard drive with Mac The Ripper
Done. Easy. Free.
I hold nothing against Wal-Mart.
And I sure wouldn’t put down the people who shop there. Aren’t these the same downtrodden so many of you were offering to “save” a few weeks ago? Are you now better than them? Curious.
This in fact will turn out to be good for Apple, just as the Zune and Creative attempts. The more who jump in and fail now, the better Apple will look in their endeavor.
Odd that for the Apple model to really succeed, as iTunes has, others must fail. That is free enterprise. That is also Wal Mart. Choke on it.
This was a poor execution on the part of Walmart. I imagine that they are low pricing Zune players at $139.00
With the thought of tying it into their movie download service.
Ha! who would have thought that Zune wouldn’t work with play for sure Microsoft product?
Expect to see Zune’s on sale at Wal mart for $99 after xmas….. $75.00 by Easter.
Think again TowerTone
http://www.walmartmovie.com/
I see from the tone of the above posts that what the music exec said was true: “90% of iPod users practice content piracy”. Typical of Apple.
Tower Tone:
I can find no chunky peanut butter in its own oil locally less expensive than what I find at Wal-Mart. However, anyone who buys the same product twice isn’t a savvy consumer. Believe me, not everyone who patronizes Wal-Mart is going to succumb to this scam.
Do you honestly think that someone who falls for Wal-Mart’s shakedown is going to exercise critical thinking when it comes to making an informative computer purchase? Besides, most of the negative comments are disparaging Wal-Mart’s business tactics, and not every person who shop at Wal-Mart. Got it?
JustMe,
Since the PC is the dominant platform and used in the practice of downloading songs illegally…that must mean that most PC users who download music (whether they have an ipod or not) practice content piracy. So…what exactly is your point? Is it the tool we should blame? Is it the technology that is at fault? Is it evil PC users?
Sorry, pr
that was shockingly crappy.
I could easily make a slanted movie like that concerning Apple, religeon, Hollywood, or Democrats.
My small hometown went through many changes on the downtown square way before Wal-Mart was around. Sh!t happens. Good luck getting milk delivered to your door.
I don’t own a video iPod, but I know a few people that do. Why, if you buy the physical DVD first anyway, wouldn’t you just rip it to an iPod compatible program? Doesn’t Handbrake do this? Of course, I have heard that this is and isn’t legal and all kinds of other stuff. But why can Walmart of all people make this legal? I’m confused as to why you’re paying twice for the same product. It sounds like a scam to me. It’s like they will sell you the printer, and then for a fee, they will print your documents for you.
Barnako may be right because even though it does not play on the not-PlaysforSure Zune player, maybe it does play using the Zune software on the PC, since Zune is based on WMP 11.
Can some PC person with Zune software check that?
Mac Z
Well, I said I hold nothing against Wal-Mart or its shoppers. And of course, a company that size is gonna screw up a lot. And if a few post disparage the shoppers, I’ll address them. Got it?
Can they sell downloads to an iPod? No. So they try the next best thing. If it doesn’t work, they throw in the towel. (Ballmer style)
It’s just business.
BTW, I shop Target.
Try reading the reviews from EVERY media outlet you can name. All positive, all pointing out the fact that WalMart has NOT been good for America. The interviews with
real, smalltown people tell the story the best.
Saying that you “can make a slanted movie” is not the same as actually making one.
It takes facts, and research into the real truth of a matter to make a film, and criticizing a film you haven’t even seen suggests that you enjoy giving your money to gigantic corporations at the expense of the small town merchant.
It’s always amazing to me that people who support states rights, smaller government, less regulation and more freedom think the idea of one corporation (who owe only more growth to the stockholders) controlling everything is a good idea. It’s the very antithesis of competition and the American Way because big money can control factors that go beyond just delivering a better price or product. WalMart is ANTI-Competitive and AGAINST smaller merchants making a living. Figure it out.
Just Me:
And you think that PC users have no access to ripping software or are inherently more criminal than the typical Mac user? Considering the repeated statistic that PC users make up more than 84% of computer users, it is logical that PC users should make up the bulk of thieves since PC users have access to the same or similar ripping software as Mac users and PC users make up the vast majority of computer users.
So what that iPod is the device of choice of Mac and PC users for storing music? Apple is not responsible for what files users store on their iPods any more than General Motors is responsible for bank robbers using a Chevy as a getaway vehicle.
Any individual user is permitted to make a single copy of digital tunes or a film for posterity and family or individual use only and not for profit.
Lastly, I have no music that I didn’t pay for. So, take your unsubstantiated personal opinion and shove it. You owe me and other honest iPod users an apology.
To be fair to retailers other than Apple, how exactly do you expect their downloads to be compatible with iPods? Of course, that aside, if they can’t have them work with the best player they should ensure that their service is so good and works so well with other devices that people are willing to use it instead. Unfortunately none of these sort of companies seems to have any intention of even attempting to put something of true quality together. Unsurprisingly, they fail.
WalMart has always sucked. I’m very glad I’m not alone in not ever walking into one of their slave factories. And now it’s official- they want us all to be clones.
“….1) Join Netflix
2) Order movie
3) Rip it to hard drive with Mac The Ripper
Done. Easy. Free…..”
Or…
Rent the movie wherever..
Grab and use .. this
and now you own it …
Skip the middleman !
(in this case .. Wall Mart)
I have a feeling that soon the Zune will get a firmware update that will make it Plays for Sure compatible.
Once that is done Microsoft can abandon the Zune platform without the class action lawsuits.
I love it when people get all sanctimonious about Wal*Mart, defending the pure, limitless capitalism of the whole idea. This is free enterprise at it’s most ultimate expression, and so on. And it’s true.
That does not mean it’s a good thing, any more than any other shit-seller, quality be damned, race-to-the bottom, fast food culture business in the US. Like fucking Dell. Make all the money you can!!! But try not to think about sustainability or quality in the whole endeavor.
Try not to think about the time people actually spend using your products, just get ’em out the door on a .3% margin.
Our homes are now filled with 20 dollar DVD players that last 6 months. Where oh where will they go when they crap out? Will Wal*Mart recycle them? No, but hot damn! I just got a computer for 150 bucks!!! WOOT!
So this is what America is all about, it’s about being Dell, not Apple.
It’s not about art or culture or the things that make us human.
It’s about getting the best deal and shitting the waste all over the world.
Go us.
-c
MW: ‘rest’ (now, Microsoft. You’re in for a big fight)
To be fair, I have never seen a Walmart employee in chains. In fact, I have it on good authority that they all applied for the jobs they got at Walmart.
Those employees that didn’t like the wages, left to find better paying jobs.
The Walmarts in my home town all pay over twice the minimum wage. What are you bitching about?
Big Al
Calgary AB CA
People who hate Wal-Mart who aren’t socialists, communists, or other fans of “government knows best” are really people-haters. They hate the fact that other people like Wal-Mart, shop at Wal-Mart, and don’t think like they (the self-proclaimed elites do). Word to all y’all — no-one cares. No-one cares what you think, what you and your powerless internet haters have declared as “good” or “pure”, ok?
Wal-Mart is a business. Other businesses take on Wal-Mart and win because Wal-Mart is fallable. Don’t peddle this “you are zombies; you’re forced to shop at Wal-Mart, but I have the superior intellect and can resist their ads” bull. I’m sick of the self-coronated keyboard cowards proclaiming that because I don’t think like them, I don’t deserve a choice in consumer goods. I shop wherever I want, bigot.
My friend worked at Wal-Mart. He got no benefits and little health care.
Let me explain a little more about why Wal-mart doesn’t scare me.
My grandfather warned me in 1977, before Wal Maart was within 40 miles of our home, that they would at some point be this powerful. He himself did very well with a 7th grade education, and knew business. He also understood it wasn’t the company, but the business model, that makes them successful.
Now guess what? Sears used to be feared, as did K Mart, Gibson, Howard’s, T,G&Y, and others. Malls with nice Apple stores in them wreak havoc on older downtowns. This is a cycle that businesses have gone through for over a hundred years, actually since the industrial age started. Now that things are different since you were a kid doesn’t mean they were like that when your parents or grandparents were young. You can’t stop change.
However, when growth finally hits a wall, when others adapt to your model OR BETTER IT, new companies or adaptive older ones will step in. Target already fills a niche a little above Wal-Mart, and K-Mart/Sears are getting leaner to compete. Dollar General and Family Dollar are taking over the smaller markets.
At some point, Wal-Mart will begin to collapse on itself (like Dell), a victim of its own growth. Meanwhile, they gave everyone a wake up call, just like Toyota did to the automotive industry.
So if you don’t like Wal-Mart, don’t shop there. I don’t. But if you don’t like foreign made products using cheap labor, then why are you using a Mac?
If the Target management is on the ball, they will talk to Apple to strike up a deal and stick it to WalMart. WalMart will eventually come crawling to Apple to make the same deal.
You people are right about buying the DVD and ripping it for free… but most PC users that I know wouldn’t know how rip it themselves. They’d rather buy it than learn how to do it themselves.
… $1.97 for portable devices, $2.97 for PCs/laptops, and $3.97 for both portable players and PC/laptops…
I can imagine someone burning the midnight oil trying to come up with the plan.
Hear, hear TowerTone!
A voice of reason! I remember when Sears & Roebuck was the most feared retailer in the world. No one could touch Sears. (in some categories this is still the case as Sears still sells 40+% of all appliances sold in America, but I digress)….
Sears almost single-handedly created the ‘suburbs’ by moving out of downtown retail areas and building shopping malls off of freeways in the middle of nowhere…. and the people followed…
Now Sears is a mere shadow of its former self. However, WalMart’s sales are stalling and eventually they may suffer the same fate…
Capitalism may seem at times cold, but it truly provides the most efficient outcome (in spite of all the scare mongering videos) for both business and consumers.
Can some PC person with Zune software check that?
Now, you are in for a LOOOOOOONNNNNGGG wait buddy. The couple hundreds in the world who wasted their money on it are still trying to install the software.
Working for a small town newspaper I can tell you that WalMart is not only killing the small business community..it’s killing small town newspapers. But there is light at the end of the tunnel.
http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/W/WAL_MART_SUPERCENTER_BAN?SITE=7219&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2006-11-29-00-29-46
For those of you who think that it will all work out for the best… try thinking that as your income goes away, your job disappears and you are eventually rendered homeless. Yeah…capitalism works but not always in the best interest of the people.
pr
I hear they are killing small animals, too.
As for your link, check with Chicago(I think) to see how well that is working. The city is ringed with Wal-Marts, they are packed, Chicago gets no revenue, and the poor have to travel that much further to save.
By the way, it is the internet that is killing your newspaper. Let’s boycot it!!! (I know, ad revenues)
They may be falling sooner than expected. Slowly. Or it could be spun to say the economy is failing. Or people are putting off shopping, or…
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/11/30/business/30walmart.html?ei=5065&en=f1870d1d912b4052&ex=1165554000&partner=MYWAY&pagewanted=print