Are 58% of iPod owners really thinking of a Zune switch?

“Recently ABI Research conducted a survey where it touted that some 58% of iPod users would consider a switch to a Zune within the next 12 months. The tagline has been passed around online,” Tobias Buckell reports for BloggingStocks.

“However, looking carefully at the study’s methodology, worries about the iPod’s marketshare diminishing drastically are set aside in favor of questions about the study itself. Dig this: the number was reached by showing participants a picture of the Zune media player and then ‘other competitive media players’ and being asked if they would pick the Zune,” Buckell writes.

Buckell writes, “The specific mention of an iPod is not in the language. Tell you what, show me a picture of a Zune next to a turd and I’ll be 100% likely to indicate a Zune preference, but it doesn’t mean I’m going to buy one. We’d like to see a little more detail about the survey in question before panicking just yet.”

Full article here.

Related articles:
Analysts: Microsoft Zune may end up being a flop – November 08, 2006
Enderle: Microsoft’s Zune could be very successful – November 07, 2006
Survey: 58% of iPod owners planning another MP3 player purchase will consider Microsoft’s Zune – November 01, 2006

34 Comments

  1. I believe that they asked if they would consider the Zune. When I go shopping, I “consider” a lot of options. You’d be unwise not to consider the options that are out there, either prior to shopping or during shopping. However, “considering” and “highly likely” are two very disparate ideas.

  2. Surveys cost money to conduct. That is why they have sponsors. They need someone to pay the bill. So fif the sponsor has an agenda, the surveyor will shape the survey to satisfy the sponsor’s agenda.

    In this case, MSFT (who I’m sure paid for the survey) wants to create an atmosphere among player users that the Zune is more desireable than the iPod. Hence a survey with wording/methodology that isn’t objective.

  3. Nothing “just yet” about it the potential threat.

    Just show me another company that has hardware/software/design/innovation and common sense galore that Apple has..? It has new products lined up like ducks waiting to be shot.

    ..no suggestions then. (Samsung..no, Sony..yesterday maybe, MS…absolutely not)

    iPod is safe. Very safe.

  4. Jim, Mr Ballmer just pulled Zune out of his ass, why would he put it back up there?

    A better suggestion would be to put it up the ass of Bill Gates or possibly the CEO of Creative.

    Still if you’re stuck on Ballmer doing an ingest, how about if he swallows it? Now that would have some scientific merit also, we’d all learn if Zune is toxic.

  5. I have 2 iPods and will be buying the iPhone/Widescreen Video if it’s anywhere near as cool as it looks like it will be.

    I am not considering a Zune at all.

    -c

    MW: ‘clearly’ (was ANYONE thinking clearly as Zune marketing meetings?)

  6. HIGHLY doubtful. But, the media also like a good fight and will do what they can to portray competition that people have to “stay tuned to.” Hence the perpetual term iPod killer. There has been no iPod killer. Not even an iPod stalker or crazy girlfriend.

    Zune will appeal to some. Fine. But no big deal, it’s not making iPod go anywhere. If anything, it will be interesting to see Apple really turn up the heat on product development. And watch Apple zig and zag while M$ chases behind screaming not to be left behind.

  7. ZUNE is an ugly product with an ugly name. All that money, and this is what Microsoft came up with? It’s as though Apple has hired all the good marketing people in the world and the rest hire “TURDS.” It never ceases to amaze me.

  8. The conclusion was not that 58% of iPod owners would buy a Zune. The conclsuion was: Of all the iPod owners asked that stated they were going to buy another mp3 player within the nexy year, 58% of THOSE people would consider a Zune. Not 58% of all the people surveyed.

    again, it’s not 58% of all the iPod owners asked, but merely 58% of the people who said they’d be interested in buying another mp3 player within the next year.

    Furthermore, let’s look at this:
    Methodology: data contained within this report is derived from a Web-based survey among a nationally-balanced and demographically-representative sample of 1,725 online consumers (age 18 and older). The consumer survey was conducted in October 2006. Respondents were provided a photo and description of the Microsoft Zune device before being asked about their likelihood to choose it over a competitive MP3 player.

    This completely assumes that people make electronics purchases based on what they read and see a picture of. Which anyone with half a brain knows is a complete falsehood. We these peope shown photos of other mp3 players? Were descriptions read to them? How were the descriptions worded? Were they asked if they’d choose any of the other devices by name, or was the choice “Zune or Other?”

  9. I saw another poll the other day that said Rick Santorum and Bob Casey were in a very close PA senate race.

    Casey won by a landslide.

    Mega-pollster John Zogby picked John Kerry to win in ’04 days before the election.

    i.e. Polls are BS.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.