“YouTube’s plan to provide ‘every’ music video free is a ‘nail in the coffin’ of the paid-for online content business model and potentially threatens the dominant position of Apple’s iTunes, according to City analysts,” Mark Sweney reports for The Guardian.
“The video filesharing website, where 100m clips are watched every day, is in talks with Warner Music and EMI to offer music video downloads for free. Revenue will be provided by advertising,” Sweney reports.
“‘Any service that YouTube puts in place is, almost beyond reasonable doubt, not going to be iPod compatible,’ said Mark Mulligan, vice-president at JupiterResearch. ‘If they develop portability – and that should definitely be on the table – then Apple could be in the unusual space of playing catch up,’ he added. ‘If YouTube can convert its massive online popularity then it could provide a significant reason for people to buy non-iPod devices, at the moment Apple is still the best bet for portable music watching. Either way it is a nail in the coffin of paid-for services as the dominant online model versus ad-funded alternatives,'” Sweney reports.
Full article here.
What percentage of iTunes video sales are music videos anyway? We’d venture a guess that TV shows make up the bulk of Apple’s paid-for video content business, not music videos. JupiterResearch’s Mulligan vastly overestimates the power of YouTube and their music video plans. People have invested in the iPod ecosystem, they’re not going to dump it all just because YouTube offers iPod-incompatible music videos with ads.
Related article:
NPD: Apple retains huge lead with 75.6% share of U.S. music player market – August 17, 2006
Wouldn’t YouTube Want to attract those 50 million
users to their website and court Apple?
I hate to disagree with MDN, but I buy quite a few music videos from apple. I would think they do a great deal of business.
ABOUT TIME! This is great news… its silly to pay for music videos, just silly. Now YouTube… how about free TV programmes.
Music videos are nothing more than advertisements for the artist, the song, and the record company. They should be free in the first place. It was a crime for iTunes to charge anything, period. No one should have to pay for advertising content.
if YouTube comes out with a YouTube portable player that you can download ALL their content including free TV shows AND free music videos then MAYBE Apple will have to play catch up.
I hate to disagree with “random reader”, but I don’t buy quite a few music videos from Apple. I don’t think they do a great deal of business.
Don’t people agree that YouTube’s business model is flawed? Don’t they spend like a million dollars a day on bandwidth costs alone? I know advertising will help with revenue but I fail to see how YouTube could sustain the service for a long time.
Bah.
Music video downloads to youtube may be significant in terms of the sites survival (via ad revenue), but for Apple, it’s a small slice of the iTunes pie, and with movies, it will quickly become a minor portion of Apple’s iPod/iTunes revenue and profitability.
YouTube boasts horrible video quality… I wonder if these music video’s will push higher quality, and one must wonder what the sound quality will be like?…
With Zune coming out soon, perhaps a file encyption that does NOT include a Redmond solution is in th works. It should only be a matter of time until one can download the music video, and strip the audio from the file…
Again, perhaps significant to YouTube, but not for Apple, nor will this dent Apple’s dominance – no matter how much the record labels hope it does…
ABOUT TIME! This is great news… its silly to pay for music videos, just silly. Now YouTube… how about free TV programmes.
—————–
So, it’s not silly to pay 99 cents for a song, but it is silly to pay $1.99 for a song and a video? Just checking.
Allen
I don’t understand your point?… Pay $1.99 for a music video (which should be free anyway) or pay $7.99 for an entire album… or pay 99 cent per song if you prefer.
What in the world is all of this attempt and language of the DEATH of the iPod/iTunes.
I mean fo’ reals…..”the iPod killer” “nail in the iTunes coffin”
Sheesh…why so much of wringing of the hands, sitting on the edge to see the iPods/iTunes die???????
I find it funny that there are no “Windows killer” articles or anyone desiring to kill off windows (though it will happen w/ intel macs and osx soon).
YouTube is great for off-the-cuff stuff, but the quality of the video is at a level that free is the only price that’s right (not to mention that horrible sound sync issues). YouTube and iTunes are not direct competitors. They could give away music for free, too, but if it’s monoaural audio that sounds like a phonograph record made by Thomas Edison, it’s not exactly going to hurt iTunes.
You are all forgetting a very important point:
IF YOU GET THE MUSIC VIDEO FREE, YOU ALSO GET THE SONG FOR FREE. Nobody’s making you watch the screen while the video is playing.
If the videos like everything else on YouTube (crappy), I don’t think I would bother anyway.
If YouTube will be giving the videos away then why would they not be ipod compatible? They would purposely lose the iPod as a content platform just so they can use M$ DRM to protect files that…don’t cost anything…
Does that make any sense at all?
So a leftist rag, the Guardian tauts free downloads. Oh yeah, that will go down big with the content owners. It’s all too clear to the Marxist brain that free always works. It works great for land in Zimbabwe, doesn’t it? If you don’t have to eat, that is. Punish producers and kill production.
Free works in the Linux world, because many of the contributors build reputations, which get them great jobs. Many get as good as they give. And companies like IBM love Linux, because IBM makes billions from managing corporate IT shops and also works to stop Microsoft’s domination.
Yes, some upcoming performing artists may put stuff out for free, but once they get well known, they will search out ways to be paid – and it’s bye bye YouTube.
This will entice teenagers who wouldn’t have bought the music videos anyway, but the diehard music fans who want their favorite artist videos aren’t going to want a commercial slapped at the beginning of their music video. They’ll buy the commercial free video instead.
Giving away music for free does not sound like a great business model to me. Do they mean streamng videos for free perhaps?
Something ain’t right here.
I already know how to extract YouTube videos to my desktop. I now just want to know when some innovative programmer is going create converter software to allow me to convert Flash video to QuickTime. Or to have Apple throw the switch in iTunes to handle FLV and SWF files.
LinuxGuy and Mac Prodigal Son
First you say this:
It’s all too clear to the Marxist brain that free always works.
THEN you say this:
Free works in the Linux world
So the Linux world is full of Marxist brains?
Pull your neocon brain out of your ass. Then you might see that this is not a political discussion.
No, you probably won’t want to see that. You’re likely more comfortable with your brain *right* where it is… in your rectum.
Have a nice life, jerkoff.
Isn’t You Tube Content just a variant of Flash Video? If it comes in your computer it can be captured and transcoded. It’s that simple (or complex).
Enough f#@king ads, I’ve prefer to record the few shows I watch on the tube now so I can ffwd through the ads.
NOTHING IS FREE.
Buy the song, get the music video for free if it exists… sell more video enabled iPods. a music video for the same price of a TV show is dumb.
Am I missing something here….? Exactly why should music videos be free? If I’m not mistaken music videos need Art Directors, Sound technicians, continuity, choreography, lighting, blah, blah, blah. Don’t these people count all of a sudden… or do you people believe that fairies and pixie dust produces music videos?
Last time I checked, these people deserve to be paid for their work too. If a video is a marketing tool to promote the label’s music, then what is the music track itself if not a marketing tool for the artist?
Getting something for free means someone, somewhere didn’t get paid for their work. That’s wrong, anyway you slice it!
The quality of the video (and often the sound) on YouTube is sucktacular at best the vast majority of the time. That’s going to effect people’s purchasing decisions.
Well – if YouTube can offer videos for free why can’t Apple?
I was always under the impression that Apple was selling content because the record companies wouldn’t let them give it away for free?
Sure Apple would likes to make a buck – who doesn’t. But since when do the record labels allow one company to give their content away for free???
I wouldn’t mind if google did this since they offer a convenient way to download videos as ipod compatible right on the page, or maybe youtube should add that. I know you can get software to extract the videos and convert them but I can’t be bothered with that.
Television networks currently allow free downloading of the same tv shows that iTMS sells, and that hasn’t impacted sales. I don’t think youtube music videos will either.
YouTube has never allowed you to easily download videos off their website and I doubt they will start now. You can download them, but those ways are considered hacks. Plus, their site is slow as balls!
Allen
If you’re thinking of, for instance, MSN showing “Arrested Development,” then you’rte totally wrong.
1. MSN is streaming the shows… those aren’t direct downloads.
2. MSN is inserting commercials… so it isn’t “free.”
Got any examples of your assertion? How can others legally give away the same things iTMS sells?
The media and a lot of people believe this is an either or option. I don’t think it is. Ad supported media is one model, paid ad-free media is another. From a technology perspective, streaming is one option and download/play later is another. TV didn’t kill Radio, and the Internet didn’t kill either of those. They all co-exist even though their usage patterns may have shifted.
The one thing that people aren’t thinking about is that this can be a killer app for web/video enabled cell phones. It doesn’t mean it would be an iPod killer and take away from iPod sales. If and when the iPhone comes out, YouTube and iTunes could compliment each other in this regard. Ideally, I would be able to watch free ad-supported streamed music videos while waiting in line somewhere, watch an ad-free paid for downloaded tv show for longer waits, listen to a paid for ad-free playlist while commuting/walking, then text or make some phone calls whenever I wanted.
Mac Yak,
ABC, FOX and others all offer free tv shows… Of course there are commercials. But youtube will most definitely have commercials as well.
It clearly says in the article that “Revenue will be payed for by advertising.”
And “other” can legally give away anything they want if they own the rights to the content. That’s the difference, ABC and FOX own their content, Apple/iTunes does not.
Woops, I meant “Revenue will be PROVIDED by advertising… Typo.
Allen
You mean the way TV shows flow into your home totally free… like via ‘basic cable” or “satellite”? Explain how those are free.
Also tell us about the “free” ways of ripping the signal into a file on your desktop. And explain you free you are to execute that action.
Then you can apologize to the class for wasting everyone’s time.
Majik Wurd: “numbers” … how appropriate…
And explain you free you are to execute that action.
It should read:
And explain how free you are to execute that action.
Sorry for the typo, class…
Mac Yak,
I didn’t say basic cable or satellite were free, I said shows on most of the major networks sites were free… And they are…
Secondly, there are a myriad of applications that will rip the signal to a file on your desktop if you choose. Of course it is illegal, but so is ripping a dvd into iTunes for your iPod, or burning a copy of a cd that you own for your own personal use. It doesn’t mean it’s not done everyday.
“I now just want to know when some innovative programmer is going create converter software to allow me to convert Flash video to QuickTime. Or to have Apple throw the switch in iTunes to handle FLV and SWF files.”
It’s there… Called iSquint. Check versiontracker.
People will buy videos that don’t feature advertising slapped on the front of them.
http://getkickedoffaplanewearingthis.blogspot.com/
What YouTube lacks in revenues, they will make up in VOLUME!!
iTunes is doomed!
MW: plan, as in, “What moron came up with this plan?”
I didn’t say basic cable or satellite were free, I said shows on most of the major networks sites were free… And they are…
Exactly. And yet, people still gladly pay $1.99 for the same show at iTMS. Why? Because people don’t want commercials, and they want to be able to take the content with them on their iPod. Until someone figures out a way for people to do this for free, iTMS will dominate.
Here’s a piece of freeware – that promisses to do the “Youtube 2 iPod conversion”. Havent tried it though….: http://djodjodesign.free.fr/index2.html
Windows users can watch music videos for free at Yahoo, MTV and VH1.
There is a freeware named PodTube that grabs and converts YouTube videos into iPod compatible format in a single step
“What YouTube lacks in revenues, they will make up in VOLUME!!”
brilliant sarcasm!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />
1 million x ZERO..
wahoo!
well done
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />
>”YouTube’s plan to provide ‘every’ music video free is a ‘nail in the coffin’ of the paid-for online content
“nail in the coffin” Isn’t it necessary to be in a dire situation (like be “in the coffin”) before you can put a “nail in the coffin.” What a stupid bit of analysis. iTunes will be #1 as long as iPod is #1. As long as iTunes works seamlessly with the iPod, and iPod is king, YouTube does not have a chance. And what’s the one piece missing from the YouTube “business model”… that’s right, a portable music player.
Also, they are going to release every “music video” for free? Most of the songs I bought from iTMS will never be released as a music video. My collection has much more than rap songs and pop tunes.
I can’t believe MDN actually used the word ‘ecosystem’… that’s such a msft word!
Using PodTube (Freeware), you can download YouTube’s Flash videos and import them to iTunes. No sweat. But they are lousy quality!
Oops, sorry, PodTube has been mentioned already. My bad.
YouTube has always given me pitiful video quality. It is jerky, stops and starts, and the resolution isn’t that great even if you can overlook all that. Maybe it’s better if you have a T1, but even at 300+/128 DSL, YouTube just bites. YouTube is great for those quick clips of TV news, or “Don’t pass out first” videos, and so on. But music videos with ads? Yuck. If I wanted ads, I’d watch TV. As for this cutting into iTunes’ revenue model — oh, right! Like people will suddenly stop paying for videos if they can get free things with ads! Why, whatever was Apple thinking, selling TV shows then? Idiots! An ad is never free — it taxes you mentally. The question is whether people will pay money for ads to go away, and the answer is “yes.” Cable TV answered that question years ago.
The $1.99 pricetag was the nail in the coffin for video sales to me. I’d be happy is there wwas a place to just watch the rare video I actually want to see. MTV, VH1, etc. all have video that is not mac-compatible. No great loss either way.
Transmission gets ’em…
Why are music videos still even made? No station plays them anymore. Any videos that I have gotten free with the purchase of an album on itunes are watched twice at most. It’s a dead format. For those of you thinking that they are still relevant please answer the following question. Why did MTV & VH1 give up on showing music videos years ago? Think about it.
Veoh.com is like YouTube, but it is integrated with the iPod and Front Row.
Not as many videos as YouTube, but better stuff IMHO.
Robert