WSJ; Apple rivals mostly need some design mojo

“Must the worlds of personal computers and of ‘post-PC’ products, such as music players and cellphones, remain as far apart as they now seem to be? I don’t think so, and in explaining why, I’d like to play peacemaker in a debate kicking around in these pages over the past few weeks,” Lee Gomes reports for The Wall Street Journal. “My colleague Walt Mossberg kicked it off two weeks ago in a column suggesting that the ‘component approach’ used to make Wintel PCs, with different companies responsible for different parts of the device, will never do for a new post-computer generation of music players or mobile phones. Users, he said, want an integrated, easy-to-use experience, like they get from Apple.”

“A few days later, Microsoft’s Bill Gates and Intel’s Paul Otellini responded with an op-ed piece saying their component model is alive and well, and will do just as well in the future as it has in the past. While the Microsoft-Intel team probably hasn’t risen to Apple’s design challenge as much as the two CEOs would like us to believe, I don’t think it’s unattainable for them. The differences between the two approaches have more to do with aesthetics than manufacturing processes. What Apple has, and what Wintel badly needs, is a design tyrant like Steve Jobs,” Gomes reports. “Apple has Mr. Jobs, who functions, in the words of one vendor trying to sell to Apple, as a ‘one-man focus group,’ a person with a legendary design sense who insists on getting what he wants. That is possible on the Wintel side, despite occasional claims to the contrary. Both Microsoft and Intel have long had programs in which they certify products as complying with the technical specs of their chips or operating systems. It would take only a bit of imagination to extend that idea to an entire product and the experience of using it.”

Full article here.
Gomes gets at least one thing right: Steve Jobs is the key. Unfortunately for the Windows PC platform, there is only one Steve Jobs. And, even if you could find a reasonable facsimile of Jobs, you still are stuck with too many cooks in the kitchen. Only Apple controls the whole widget. They design both the operating system and the hardware, that’s why it works so well. A beautiful iMac can run Windows, that doesn’t ease the user’s frustration. The ugliest Mac clones of yesteryear treated the user better than the nicest-looking Windows PCs on the planet. Pretty on the outside can’t hide ugly on the inside and vice versa. The same goes for digital media players (iPod) working with music jukeboxes (iTunes) and online media services (iTunes Store).

Gomes is dreaming if he thinks Microsoft and the box assemblers would put control of all hardware and software into the hands of one quality-obsessed perfectionist. That won’t happen, of course – which may be Gomes’ underlying point: only Apple can deliver the consistent look, fit, finish and user-experience exemplified by the Mac and iPod platforms. Microsoft, Dell, HP, Lenovo, Sony, Toshiba, Gateway, and all the rest simply have no chance of ever matching Apple’s integrated, easy-to-use experience.

Are you thinking about getting a Mac? Do it. You only live once, so stop wasting time.

Advertisements:
• Introducing the super-fast, blogging, podcasting, do-everything-out-of-the-box MacBook.  Starting at just $1099
• Get the new iMac with Intel Core Duo for as low as $31 A MONTH with Free shipping!
• Get the MacBook Pro with Intel Core Duo for as low as $47 A MONTH with Free Shipping!
• Apple’s new Mac mini. Intel Core, up to 4 times faster. Starting at just $599. Free shipping.
• iPod. 15,000 songs. 25,000 photos. 150 hours of video. The new iPod. 30GB and 60GB models start at just $299. Free shipping.
• Connect iPod to your television set with the iPod AV Cable. Just $19.
• iPod Radio Remote. Listen to FM radio on your iPod and control everything with a convenient wired remote. Just $49.

38 Comments

  1. It all seems to boil down to question of class. Before you can implement good design, you must be able to recognize it. It seems that the harder MS tries, the worse things look. Take a look at the Xbox 360. It looks cheesy.

  2. Of course Intel only sing the praises of the MS/other model since they sell so many chips to those manufacturers. As effectively a supplier of raw materials to both Apple and all the others it doesn’t make a jot of difference to them if the hardware and software for a machine are made by the same manufacturer or not. If apple got a majority marker share Intel would soon be singing their praises over the MS model since Apple try to push tech forward and use new technology.

  3. I sure ain’t just design that goes into Apple’s magic recipe of success.

    The ingredients are much more wide ranging and its secret is as likely to get out into the hands of a WSJ journalist as the Coca Cola recipe…

  4. Design can be functional, frill or a combination of both. Changing product colours is design but it doesn’t necessarily make the product ‘better’.

    When the original iMac came out (especially in multiple colours) many thought that a spash of colour was all that was necessary for the product to sell. It’s not.

    If a product stinks, changing the colour doesn’t change the fact that the product still sucks. Running XP on Mac hardware still means you’re using XP.

    MS has a lot invested in the XBOX – it’s their chance to control the entire widget. But i can’t wait to get my hands on the Wii =)

  5. Thorin –

    What he means is that Lexus, for example, does not make the LX470 from end to end. Components come from a variety of sources.

    The problem is, Apple does not do this either. Apple contracts with a variety of companies to make it’s products.

    The winning part is that Apple is so anal about the finished product (Apple + Anal = Mac?) that the user is insured a seamless (as possible) end product. Windows and Intel and the dull box makers are just Frankensteining the whole thing together.

  6. AG Penny and Harry:

    Oh OK, I agree wholeheartedly. Thanks.

    BTW that reminds me of my dismal failure in trying to convince my wife of how I should buy a new Infiniti G35 coupe. She just doesn’t get it. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

  7. So here we are again, listening to “industry analysts” tell us that the only real difference between Apple and MS and everybody else is aesthetics – what hogwash.

    As to user experience? Yes, I’ll go along with you there, as long as it isn’t the amazingly over-simplified “user experience” this article implies – That the way the pc experience feels, along with its looks is all that makes the difference. In the real world these things make a quantifiable difference, but they are by no means the difference that keeps users using in the long run. I’m sorry, but what keeps Macintosh users going for the Mac product line over a lifetime, (and what makes Mac users angry about not having the option of using Macs in the workplace) is, among other things, the actual and real quality of the hardware and software from a purely mechanical, pragmatic, and money-saving standpoint.

    Design gets new users wanting to try Macs, but the hardware and software operational characteristics are what keep people loyal to the product line – among other things.

  8. EVERY original personal computer was better designed than the current PCs: Commodore Pet, Vic 20/64, Sinclair ZX2000, Apple II, Hitachi Peach, Atari, Lisa – even the TRS-80!

    The only saving grace today is people hide the CPU under the desk and you only look at the monitor.

  9. But now that I think about it, I think he’s right.

    Design would help a lot. Think about Windows users. They are using dull boxes coupled with a festering OS. If you spruce up that dull box, it will fare well with the Windows community (afterall they don’t seem to mind the crap they are using and are still dealing with Stockholm Syndrom). Obviously Mac users know better. As represented in some previous posts the pretty shell will not fool us.

    A dull box turned pretty is still a wolf in sheeps clothing.

  10. Steve Jobs said it best: “The trouble with Microsoft is they have no taste. They have no taste and I don’t mean that in a small way, I mean that in a big way. In the sense that they don’t think of original ideas, and they don’t bring much culture into their products.”

  11. In order to get the design mojo you need someone at the top that truly believes in the power of good design, not someone who gives lip service to it. Apple has that, most other companies don’t.

    Usually what happens is a company hires some great creative talent, they produce some great designs, and by the time it filters up through all of the marketing people and bean counters who think they can be a good designer too, the design is a giant piece of poo.

    I’ve seen it. It happens.

  12. “EVERY original personal computer was better designed than the current PCs: Commodore Pet, Vic 20/64, Sinclair ZX2000, Apple II, Hitachi Peach, Atari, Lisa – even the TRS-80!”

    Don’t forget the TI-99, the brushed stainless steel look was so suave.

  13. furthermore, don’t confuse design with what most ignorant people think it is, a pretty box. Design is about function as well as form. Apple knows this and blends the two superbly.

    It’s been 9 years since the PC design revolution started at Apple with the first iMac. At the time Bill Gates joked about how long it will take the PC industry to catch up to doing multi-colored PC’s. Well, all that showed was that he didn’t get it, and 9 years later the PC industry still hasn’t caught on.

    Unless you call those P.O.Ses that Dell makes good design.

  14. Hmmm, interesting comments. Let me throw one into the sink. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
    Its how it works. . . . in my hands. . . . with my knowledge . . . . at my schedule. PS dosent hurt if it looks good, works for me. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

    If it works for me, then its great. If I have to become a nerd just to make it work (like Gates and many PC users) then thats fine . . . . if I am a nerd.

    PS. Many non-iPod units work just fine. Plug then into you PC with iTunes and you can down load your music, your online music, etc just fine. Its when the third party companies get really greedy that they suffer. I bought a VR3 (creative ripoff?? ) mp3 player and I love it. It cost 19 $, has 128 meg of memory and shows me the name of the song I am playing. It also acts as a voice recorder (if I could only figure out how to make it work 🙁 ) but that is just it. Third party items work fine . . . . . in their place. JMHO

    N.

  15. just for the record, some of us know that this Life isn’t a one shot kinda thing, (reincarnation is real), but in the end/beginning all we have is the Present, might as well as fill with it with quality,.. i.e., an Apple product, and/or nice company when you can.

  16. “Windows and Intel and the dull box makers are just Frankensteining the whole thing together.”

    Exactly. If you are old enough to remember, this is what Detroit was doing in the 70’s and 80’s. It took them until late nineties to start to get it right. M$ may not have that long, as the computer industry can change in a nanosecond compared to something like the auto industry.

  17. In Time magazine, Jobs was qouted as saying (paraphrasing here), “you know how you see a prototype car at a show, and then when it actually comes out, it sucks? That’s becuase the designers send the design to the engineeers, who say ‘oh no, we can’t do these 35 things – not possible. Then the manaufacturing team gets the design and says ‘ oh no, we can’t do these 35 things”. So the design is now so comprimised that it doesn’t look at all like the cool concept car you first saw. That’s what happened with the first iMac. We were told no. But we stuck to our design intent and told them to find a way to make it happen. Some people left, and some were pushed out the door, but the ones that remained understood what we wanted, and we continue to attract those type of people.”
    I think the design tyrant title is probably pretty close to the truth, and when you have an uncanny eye for what people want, and what to leave in as you drive towards simplicity, that’s the secret sauce.

  18. Apple’s legendary design powered by The Steve Inside® is only part of the story of Apple’s success. Here are a couple other key contributors:

    a. The existence of M$: without a stinking cesspool, how would one know they’re clean?

    b. Darwin: Mac OS X’s plumbing, based on FreeBSD Unix, is solid and Open Source. Collaboration and peer review keeps it solid and very functional. Winblows is closed, proprietary and sucks. Further, Apple gets to put their effort into the UI: Core Image, etc.

    c. Less market share: That’s right, having far less market share than Windblows helps Apple to by giving it the freedom to be innovative without worrying about backwards compatibility to crap. If M$ really made a new, (gasp) innovative OS, they would have to sever the ties to the Windblows past – eliminating the “market share” advantage.

    d. There’s more, but I’m tired of thinking. So I’m going to go play Doom on my peecee ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”LOL” style=”border:0;” />

  19. Gomes: “It would take only a bit of imagination . . . “

    Yaah, right. That little “bit” of imaginatioon that they’re lacking is about as huge as the chromosomal differences between humans and chimpanzees: Sure, they’re “98%” there, but that little “bit” of 2% extra to being human is HUGE!

    Actually, now that I tihnk about it, after studying the Ballmer species in its native habitat, maybe, just maybe, they’re closer than we think at Microsoft.

    TO CHIMPS!!!

    Result: They’ll NEVER catch Apple.

  20. Even the folks at the WSJ don’t fundamentally get it. Apple’s been on a roll for quite some time now, and it’s not gimmickry that keeps them going. It’s not something easy, or else that easy thing would have been tried and done by now. Don’t they think that M$ wants to get Vista out the door? Don’t they think that Creative wants to beat the iPod? Don’t they think that Dell wants to keep increasing profits? Well, if it were easy to fix these trends, that would have been tried by now. One of the things these companies are all missing is passion and another is ingenuity. That is why small businesses succeed and why large ones collapse under their own bureaucratic weight.

  21. “Let’s not forget who invented the beige box in the first place….”

    That is true, but it was a sign of the times. That term is used now in

    reference to a portion of the market that has stagnated in many ways.

  22. Yup that’s where they get there story wrong alright. PC’s and Mac’s are built the same but Apple has the advantage of integrating the software and the hardware to work as one. PC vendors and Microsoft can’t do this, ever. That’s where an inovative person would be as useful as Steve Balmer has been.

  23. While Apple do design a lick-worthy box, at the end of the day, it is just still a box.

    I work in the PeeCee industry and the reason I use a Mac at home is the lack of work in maintaining it, the ‘just-works’ nature, coz its something different to the OS’s I have to deal with at work, and finally (as well as mainly) because of the OS and applications that run on the OS.

    Frankly, the Apple hardware, to me, is the most limiting and annoying part of the equation. They lack the flexibility and upgradability I am used to in the PeeCee world. I use Mac’s in spite of the hardware, not because of it!!

    My PC’s are all like Granddads Axe, 3 heads and 5 handles later. I dont buy a new PC, I buy with an eye to best price/performance ratio at the time and then upgrade bits as needed. GPU’s are my most upgraded item in my PC’s, with the processor/ram after that, new HDD’s as required, and the display last. This usually occurs over about a 3-4 year cycle.

    To achieve a modicom of that flexibility (and run the highend apps like Aperture / Motion at all) you either buy a iMac and accept you will replace EVERYTHING in 2 years, or else you have to have buy a tower Mac at a crippling inital price. Then to upgrade GPU’s is an exercise in frustration, with little choice (just ask dualcore G5 owners with GF6600’s) and costs of at least 1/3rd more than a comparable PC GPU.

  24. MacMania said:
    “a. The existence of M$: without a stinking cesspool, how would one know they’re clean?”

    Easy. I fell in love with System 6, especially the bundled HyperCard, well before I used a Windows machine. Quality and ease-of-use stand on their own two feet. They don’t need a prop.

  25. Steve Jobs will never be gone. When he dies, he will be placed alongside the cryogenically-protected body of Walt Disney, for future defrosting – and for the future glory of Apple and the Disney Company.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.