Site reports iPod nano screen failures

“Several iPod nano owners are reporting inexplicable screen failures within the first few days of owning the music player. The affected screens appear to be cracked, but owners cannot recall any events that would lead to such damage,” iPodNN.com reports.

The website, flawedmusicplayer.com has several emails from iPod nano users which state that no impact marks are visible on the cracked displays. Most users at flawedmusicplayer.com report leaving their Nano in a pocket for an extended period of time, and discovering a destroyed display when they remove the device to use it.

iPodNN reports, “iPod repair company iPodResQ reports a temporary price increase on its iPod nano screen replacement service due to ‘overwhelming demand.'”

Full article here.

Related articles:
Apple iPod nano takes a beating and keeps on beating – September 12, 2005

41 Comments

  1. I hope that this gets a fix from Apple soon in an updated model.

    Still for a colour screen that size I did wonder at the Nano’s release that being so small could also mean being more fragile.

    MW: ‘england’ as is the case in Canada and England they spell colour correctly with the letter ‘u’.

  2. Hmmm, I wonder what percentage we are talking here. If 10 people have a cracked screen and write in about it, it sounds like a lot. But if they have sold 100,000 players, that is ony .01 percent failure so the 99.99 percent of the time there is no problem.

    Until we get more info on failure rates it is still way too early to tell if this is going to be a real issue or not (remember when the mini first came out and there was the scare about the cable inside leading from the headphone jack being too rigid and resulting in distortion? That seems to have turned out to be a non-issue)

    In the mean time I think all of these will be covered under warranty.

  3. Flexible screens…arrrgh. That was too close for comfort. I was just on the verge of getting one (like tomorrow) for my wife’s birthday . It was a toss-up between the nano and the last of the minis. I think I’ll err on the conservative side and get a mini while there are still stocks. I’m just not interested in warranty issues for players with flexible screens.

  4. This damage is called “accidental damage” and is NOT covered by AppleCare. The odds of a spontaneous screen cracking to occur is the same as the window in your house suddenly cracking without any external influences. The LCD is sandwiched between 2 layers of glass. When this is cracked/broken, the crystal liquid within it oozes and that is what you see.

    Granted, Steve Jobs may have made a marketing error by demoing the device from his pocket. The nano is MUCH thinner than a cell phone and other such devices and it can be twisted or bent much easier, meaning that it requires extraordinary care.

    Regardless of its fragility, accidental damage is still not covered.

  5. I don’t have one, but doesn’t the slogan say, “1000 songs in your pocket.” It is one thing to have it sitting there while your cruisin’ the mall and another thing to be playing soccer while in your pocket.

  6. I’m happy to report that mine has not had such issues. Granted, I carry mine in the coin pocket of my Levi’s and never sit on it. These things are sturdy but they aren’t indestructible, people!

    1.5oz vs. 200lb backside… well, one of those is going to have to give and I assure you it probably won’t be the person’s butt. hehe ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

  7. I got my nano about a week ago. The first day I used it the text on the display was all screwed up. It was distorted and did not line up making it impossible to read. I took it to the apple store and they said I would have to just use the updater and reinstall the nano. Easy enough fix but then i have to go back through the hassle of putting pictures, music, and my on the go playlist back on. I still love it but it you think that bug would have been worked out…

  8. Why do Apple fans always assume its the customers fault? Apple has had a lot of quality problems the last 3 years. Things that Apple denied for quite a while. It wouldn’t surprise me if this wasn’t any different.

  9. I have not yet bought an iPod. This nano is exciting enough to tempt me to get one. However, I would like to boot from it via FireWire and store even more in it. AND, I will wait for a couple more releases to fix these unexpected problems. It seems that Apple should INCLUDE a case that protects the nano more than the current naked nano can.

    Sure, something that small is delicate. But, Apple should take into account that music players are not treated with kid gloves in the real world and build some degree of sturdiness or protection into them.

    In any case, this sounds more like a design flaw than accidental damage.

    Mike may be right that SJ made a marketing error demoing it from his pocket – unless he knew that its design will allow it to be carried there. Many people will correctly assume/interpret that from SJ’s demo, even if it is not correct that it will survive actually being carried there.

    Still, when Apple works out these early “issues” this nano is really nice.

  10. Let’s pretend I am a marketing employee at Microsoft or one of iPod’s competitors. The iPod Nano is frightening competition, and my company plays hard ball. Whatever are we going to do about this competitor that is set to blow away what is left of our profit and marketshare? Hm, I might just buy an iPod Nano (which my company pays for), break it (man that was tough), and run a FUD site with photos of my broken iPod Nano, and a fake interaction with Apple support guaranteed to spread bad feelings (only I get a fix, I’m so special and Apple doesn’t care about the rest of you). I get on a few Mac news sites (and hopefully soon on the general sites), and people are scared off from the iPod Nano. Mission accomplished.

    No, I don’t work for any of those companies and I never have (I’m unemployed actually). But Microsoft is known for dirty tricks and FUD spreading. Don’t believe just any old website you see, especially one that is anonymous and isn’t even reproducing their emails with Apple as proof. In this case, MDN already provided a link to a torture test story, and their iPod Nano took a whole lot more abuse before this kind of damage.

    The web site in the article could be legitimate, for all I know. I apologize if they are. I would be more comfortable with believing them if the author gave their name, more proof of how the player broke, and more documentation of their interaction with Apple.

  11. I think alot of these people in the “blogosphere”..whatever gay term you want to call it, don’t hold as much pull as they think they do. By and large, most ipod users don’t read blogs, or mac fan sites. Did the battery debacle slow down sales? No, not really. Dirty rumors aren’t gonna hurt apple, only a physical product that’s more appealing than the ipod could do that.

  12. Most users at flawedmusicplayer.com report leaving their Nano in a pocket for an extended period of time, and discovering a destroyed display when they remove the device to use it.

    WELL DUH!!!

    I have a Nano and I’ve dropped it a few times already, placed a drink on it at a bar and some other things.

    This little device is TOUGH but if fools are sitting on it, bending over with one in their pockets, rubbing up against change and keys, of fsking course it’s going to break.

  13. ARSTechnica broke the display with a drop from 9 feet, long before they destroyed the unit with the car. Some people also referenced that test on the flawedmusic site, making the same mistake. Or maybe it is just one stupid person.

    It is easy to believe that a back pocket is a bad place for this device, and that a couple thin pieces of glass might not be able to stand up to what some might call normal use. It also could be a manufacturing problem on some units, with tolerances be as close as they have to be. Taking time off from apologizing for Jobs might make things clearer, but how would Steve feel without a few thousand noses up his butt?

  14. “I only had the Nano in my shirt pocket…while mountain climbing…up Mt. Everest…in sub-zero tempertures…and it cracked…I’ll think I’ll sue Apple for a replacement.

    After all it was only in my shirt pocket, what harm could that do?

  15. Garfunkle said:
    “ARSTechnica broke the display with a drop from 9 feet, long before they destroyed the unit with the car. Some people also referenced that test on the flawedmusic site, making the same mistake. Or maybe it is just one stupid person.”

    You’re right, the display did malfunction after a drop from 9 feet, prior to them running it over with the car. You neglected to mention, however, that prior to the 9 foot drop, the nano had been purposely dropped out of a moving car twice, once at 30mph and once at 50, after which the display still worked perfectly fine.

  16. You know, it took me three iPod minis to get one that worked right. First one wouldn’t load the songs from iTunes, second one had the crackly sound problem after about a month. Happily both were replaced free and #3 has worked over a year with no problems at all. But the fact is, when these things roll off the assembly line at first, they’re still working the bugs out. Thankfully, Apple seems to recognize this and take things back for replacement without much fuss. Not like the time I got a Sony DirecTV box that was dead out of the box– but because it had been initialized, they wanted me to send it back with the card and they’d send me a new one in about 3 weeks. Fortunately the store (Abt in Chicago) said “That’s bull” and gave me a new one anyway. And don’t even talk about Dell customer service….

    MW: image. As in, the DJ Ditty lowered my image of Dell even further than I imagined it could go.

  17. DudeMac
    “Apple needs to fix this, don’t let those iPod nano fans down.”

    Yes they should make it thicker with rounded corners, they should also make the screen smaller so it is more difficult to break.

    The same thing happened with the Pentax Optio ‘S’ series when they first came out. As a result cases were more strongly recommended at time of purchase, the camera was redesigned and the problem all but went away. Interestingly most of the victims of the cracked screen on that camera were guys and could most likely be attributed to the ‘pocket size’ of the unit.
    Additionally users will often return something for replacement and lie. (Nope, haven’t dropped it, didn’t get it wet and it never left my sight) Later on it turns out it is water damaged and if it has been replaced the store has to bear the cost. It’s no wonder some stores give you a hard time when you return something as faulty.

  18. “Let’s pretend I am a marketing employee at Microsoft or one of iPod’s competitors. The iPod Nano is frightening competition, and my company plays hard ball. Whatever are we going to do about this competitor that is set to blow away what is left of our profit and marketshare? Hm, I might just buy an iPod Nano (which my company pays for), break it (man that was tough), and run a FUD site with photos of my broken iPod Nano, and a fake interaction with Apple support guaranteed to spread bad feelings (only I get a fix, I’m so special and Apple doesn’t care about the rest of you). I get on a few Mac news sites (and hopefully soon on the general sites), and people are scared off from the iPod Nano. Mission accomplished.

    No, I don’t work for any of those companies and I never have (I’m unemployed actually). But Microsoft is known for dirty tricks and FUD spreading. Don’t believe just any old website you see, especially one that is anonymous and isn’t even reproducing their emails with Apple as proof. In this case, MDN already provided a link to a torture test story, and their iPod Nano took a whole lot more abuse before this kind of damage.

    The web site in the article could be legitimate, for all I know. I apologize if they are. I would be more comfortable with believing them if the author gave their name, more proof of how the player broke, and more documentation of their interaction with Apple.”

    For starters domain name registrations are public. How do you think the BBC called me this morning? Also several publications mention me by name. Oh and I don’t work for Microsoft, and if you actually took a moment to read my site you would know i am very pro Apple. Apple markets this product to go in a pocket. Saying putting it in a pocket makes anyone who does so an idiot is inane. I have posted my interactions with Apple and I am not hiding behind some curtain. People need to look more deeply then the cover of a book before the lash out judgemental nonsense. Let’s remember how everyone treated the ibook logic board problem people and the ipod battery people. Where are they today? Oh yeah, they have new logic boards and batteries because Apple admitted their mistake. Before jumping on a bandwagon that “this guy is just some idiot” remeber that someday, you might just have to put your foot in your mouth. And to clear one thing up, all of the money and time spent on this comes from me. I have legal counsel (no it is not to sue but to make sure I am not sued) that I pay for, I pay for the web hosting, and that web hosting is giving people like you the right to have your have your opinion known as well. Before we dismiss someone as just being some fat ass stupid moron let’s take a moment to actually read and try to comprehend before making judgemnts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.