Nokia N91 vs. Apple iPod

“Nokia AB, the world’s foremost mobile phone maker has introduced the most superior mixture of wireless phone and MP3 player devices (Nokia N91) that participates against Apple Computer’s iPod,” Karandeep Singh Dhillon writes for Moneyplans.net.

“Its 4GB internal hard drive that easily holds 3,000 songs is the unique feature of Nokia91. Previously electronic goods giant Samsung, introduced a 2GB internal hard drive phone that only exists in Korea. Nokia’s N91 doubles its capacity and available globally,” Dhillon writes.

MacDailyNews Take: It must be really unique, because 4GB at a decent bit rate will actually hold about 1,000 songs.

Dhillon writes, “There is also an increase of about 3.5-millileter in the headphone jack that makes it more friendly with a wide array of high-end audio headsets. Its incorporated Wi-Fi connection allows users to wirelessly haul and drop music files from a PC. The N91 also boasts an audio output port for hooking up external speakers or stereo systems. It has a sleek, futuristic look, with music control buttons… The U.S. retail price depends on how carriers make it available to subscribers, but the European price reportedly reaches about 700 euros ($900).”

Full article here.

MacDailyNews Take: Would you rather have a 4GB iPod mini and a cellphone to carry around or a 4GB iPod mini that also offered a built-in cellphone? Yes, the Nokia N91 is too expensive. Yes, it doesn’t really hold 3,000 songs unless you like your songs to sound a bit worse than AM radio quality. Yes, this model isn’t the exact cellphone/music player model that will hurt Apple’s iPod, but it is the first to offer something that Apple does not: it makes phone calls and it eliminates the need to carry two devices where one would suffice. If the Nokia N91 used a Click Wheel (Apple patent pending), worked with AAC/FairPlay (iTunes Music Store), offered software/user interface designed in Cupertino, and was priced like an iPod mini (even if that meant signing up for a year plan with a carrier), we’d get it instead of an iPod any day of the week. Apple are you listening?

Note: Nokia to use Microsoft’s music formats on its handsets.

Related MacDailyNews articles:
Will cellphones eat Apple’s iPod or vice versa? – May 09, 2005
Bona fide Apple iPod killer? Nokia’s 4GB mobile ‘jukebox’ phone due by Christmas – April 28, 2005
Can mobile phones and telecoms kill Apple’s golden iPod+iTunes combo? – April 26, 2005
Motorola CEO Zander: Apple iTunes phone due ‘in the next few months’ – April 20, 2005
RUMOR: Apple’s iTunes Mobile 1.0 to be ready by June – April 20, 2005
Verizon, Sprint, other wireless companies balk at carrying Apple’s and Motorola’s ‘iPod phone’ – April 19, 2005
Motorola to unveil iRadio – PC to Mobile to Car Stereo service – April 18, 2005
Will Motorola’s Apple iTunes phone make it to market? – March 28, 2005
BusinessWeek: What’s going on with the Motorola Apple iTunes mobile phone? – March 24, 2005
So who’s really delaying the Motorola iTunes phone anyway? – March 21, 2005
Motorola exec: Apple iTunes phone debut delayed by Steve Jobs; phones will launch in 2005 – March 16, 2005
Motorola’s Apple iTunes phone in trouble? – March 14, 2005
Motorola says iTunes phone unveiling delay not caused by dispute with carriers – March 10, 2005
Motorola says it’s working on more iTunes phones, some models ‘can store eight hours of music’ – March 10, 2005
Motorola indefinitely postpones Apple iTunes phone unveiling – March 10, 2005
Motorola’s ‘ROKR’ Apple iTunes mobile phone to be unveiled this Thursday – March 06, 2005
Motorola’s yet-to-be-unveiled ‘ROKR’ phone will be first Apple iTunes phone – February 16, 2005
Nokia to use Microsoft’s music formats on its handsets – February 15, 2005
Motorola E1060 not, repeat not, the iTunes phone – February 16, 2005
Motorola executive previews iTunes Phone at CES, syncs to iTunes like an Apple iPod – January 06, 2005
Apple’ prodigious hardware and software design skills may help Motorola create iPod phone – December 28, 2004
Apple, Motorola iTunes on cell phones a harmonious deal that benefits both companies – August 05, 2004
Motorola posts Steve Jobs’ Apple iTunes announcement video – July 28, 2004
Apple, Motorola iTunes deal not exclusive, debuts Apple’s licensing of FairPlay DRM – July 27, 2004
Motorola and Apple to bring iTunes Music Player to Motorola’s next-gen mobile phones – July 26, 2004

39 Comments

  1. Re malingerer’s:

    “The likelyhood that Apple’s defined product solution will be implemented on any carriers platform is almost nil. Fact is, carriers dwarf Apple in size and amount of subscribers, both nationally and globally. “

    Can anyone spell cartel? Monopolistic practice? Barriers to competition?

    I’m no lawyer, but….COURT-CASE, ANYONE?

  2. Ditto on “one guy’s” comment. Norway has nothing to do with Nokia.

    It is like saying that Microsoft is a German company. Ludicrous.

    The better and correct expression for the Finnish company is always “Nokia Oy”.
    It’s easy to remember, like TNT! Oy! Oy! Oy!

  3. MDN you are hung up on the number of songs the phone holds.
    What´s an Apple shuttle hold – 500?
    the future is all in one.
    People don´t want to carry all these gadgets around.

  4. No matter “One guy from Finland”, the market in Sweden is obviously bigger. Though it would be good for Apple/Motorola to give Nokia a run for its money!

    MW is every as in “every-one” can benefit from an iPhone implemented properly. The Telecom industry needs to have its ass kicked big time … ridiculous to consider how much money is wasted on silly things suchj as ring tones and logos, not to mention the ridiculous call charges. I expect WiFi-Max to give mobile operators a run for their money (literally!)

  5. >MDN wrote: Would you rather have a 4GB iPod mini and a cellphone to carry around or a 4GB iPod mini that also offered a built-in cellphone?

    I’d rather have the 4GB phone – preferably one that’s not locked into iTMS.

  6. >MDN wrote: Would you rather have a 4GB iPod mini and a cellphone to carry around or a 4GB iPod mini that also offered a built-in cellphone?

    I’d rather have the 4GB phone – preferably one that’s not locked into iTMS.

  7. >MDN wrote: Would you rather have a 4GB iPod mini and a cellphone to carry around or a 4GB iPod mini that also offered a built-in cellphone?

    I’d rather have the 4GB phone – preferably one that’s not locked into iTMS.

  8. If the price tag they’re throwing around is right, this won’t be the killer. But if it gets even as much hype & attention as the Moto Razr, it’ll open the door for a cheaper version that *will* be the killer.

    Looks pretty slick.

    I’d like the clickwheel on my iPod to work like a rotary dial wheel.

  9. THIS JUST IN!:

    Nokia shot itself in foot, and is chasing its tail.

    Now to just flush them down the drain..

    Nokia had potential, but all of their phones have sucked big time in the last 5 years

  10. Ditching the keypad for a scroll wheel is just the kind of bold simplification Apple would be likely to do (like axing the display for the shuffle). Most people make calls via their stored contacts, so if an Apple phone synchs with Address Book, you’d rarely need a keypad to enter a number anyway. The bigger problem would be how to enable text messaging if there’s no keypad. Maybe the screen could be touch sensitive and use a stylus a la Palm Pilot? If so, you could activate a numeric keypad for dialing and a QWERTY keypad for messages no problem. Text messaging is overdue for some Apple-style simplification.

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.