“Even if Longhorn ships in mid-2006, it will be mid-2007 before we see it in real quantity, late-2008 before it has a significant installed base, and perhaps 2011 before XP finally fades away. That’s if Microsoft hits its marks from here on and customers actually want what Longhorn manages to deliver. Now factor in time for WinFS and the confusion when XP starts getting some Longhorn features, and it looks like the fun just won’t be stopping,” David Coursey writes for eWeek.
“Longhorn’s woes may open a door for Linux, a very tiny door, but Linux just isn’t a good choice for desktops. Instead, desktop Linux proponents should wake up and switch to the Mac OS,” Coursey writes. “People who use Mac OS X and think about such things consider it to be ‘Linux done right.’ Of course, it’s Unix, not Linux, but that’s a minor point. As Linux fragments, as it must, the distinction will become even more academic that it is already.”
Coursey writes, “Mac OS X has a better user interface than Windows, better security and is more stable. It’s all the operating system most users need. It doesn’t have the application support Windows enjoys, but there are many more excellent commercial OS X apps than there are Linux apps. If the desktop Linux people really cared about using a great operating system, they would stop trying to reinvent the wheel and rally around Mac OS X. It would be great if the contest were between two worthy operating systems, like Mac and XP/Longhorn. But Linux vs. Longhorn? You’ve got to be kidding.”
Full article here.
MacDailyNews Take: Mac OS X vs. Windows XP is not much of a contest today, as users of both understand. Mac OS X vs. ‘Longhorn’ is not a contest at all since Mac OS X is the only contender that actually exists, it wins by default. Even if the stripped-down, feature-shedding ‘Shorthorn’ debuted today, Mac OS X ‘Panther’ would wipe the floor with it. Microsoft has always followed Apple’s Mac with their me-too Windows OS and they’re falling behind more and more with their never-ending Longhorn fiasco. It is time for our Linux cousins to join forces with us and adopt quality hardware complete with advanced 64-bit G5s and Mac OS X. Mac OS X is everything (except totally free) that Linux wants to be, but will never achieve. With Mac OS X powered by passionate Mac users and former Linux users, Microsoft would feel some serious pressure. You have to wonder if the bloated Microsoft behemoth would even be able to make a timely and coherent move to defend its ill-gotten, monopoly-abused Windows turf.
moo…
Go Mac Go.
I couldn’t agree more. But in my opinion, those that aren’t using OS X are just simply missing out and that really is their loss, not mine.
If I recall, the linux distros that the average user would get aren’t free either, are they? I know Red Hat Linux comes at a cost and I’d guess plenty of others do to. I’m not into linux at all, so I’m only guessing.
get mac os x to run on Joe Blow’s custom-built beige box and I think apple could grab a chunk of the linux crowd. You can’t promote the use of an “open source” kernel when the graphical interface forces you into a proprietary hardware setup.
All the Apple dealerships here can’t get enough product to supply Mac users let alone Linux users too. They’ve even sold the display G5s in the closest dealership to me, and the only Macs in the shop are laptops.
I can understand the G5 delays, but why are there no eMacs either?
There are no eMacs left because there haven’t been any iMacs for months, so people in the market for Mac consumer desktops have felt the crunch.
Whilst in MS bashing mode check out this detailed review of XP SP2’s security enhancements.
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/09/02/winxpsp2_security_review/
so why aren’t hoardes of people switching to the Mac? I’ll tell you why. two things:
1) Apple doesn’t offer a cheaper “headless” Mac that would compete with the Dells of the world (yes, some people can’t afford an eMac)
2) Games, or lack thereof…
one of these things Apple can fix – today.
Gandalf: it is few threads below in MDN already
Linux isn’t totally free. Saying that is like only considering the initial hardware cost between an intel PC and a Mac PC.
Linux… yuk! Been there, done that. Linux in any flavor needs more attention than my last girlfriend.
Of course, Linux is a lot more stable than two girlfriends ago – she was like Windows: always on her period, never stable and apt to go berserko anytime at all with no warning.
Yup…. I’ll stick with Mac OSx and my NEW girlfriend… they both work, they’re always happy to see me and they remain happy to be turned on every day.
>You can’t promote the use of an “open source” kernel when the graphical interface forces you into a proprietary hardware setup.
——-
What is “a proprietary hardware setup” ? AFAIK open source hardware doesn’t exist. Or maybe you were referring to building your own pc from available parts? surely you’re not suggesting that non geeks build their own boxen ?
As far as I’m concerned M$ is the enemy NOT Linux, I think that OS X and Linux compliment each other very well in their respective niches, but IMHO desktop computing isn’t a Linux niche YET !
I happen to believe that in the not too distant future, Linux will be the mainstream platform and windoze will wither and die. I also believe that this is good for the mac platform. There will always be a need for the Macintosh experience and enough people willing to pay a premium to get it.
As much as I love my Macs, they will never be the mainstream platform.
So I say – go Linux AND go Apple
Define hoardes. Million users more? What do you have in mind?
Windows base is essentially corporate users. No hordes there: very conservative and lots of drag. Hey, they for the most have still to adopt XP and you want them to move to OS X in few months? Get real.
Gamers: they are no computer users. IF a gamer has tens of titles also there they still are with older version of Windows for fear of breaking their gaming experience and you want hordes of switchers from there? Will not happen even if OS X had exactly the same titles available: what’s the point of changing machine and OS to get the same, that is, your favorite game working as before. So, cross them out.
Who remains? Home users and professionals in education and in fields where they have decisional power toward what platform to use.
Home users: for the most, judging from the one I know, they do not distinguish between Windows and Office. For the most they are surprised when they hear Office run on the Mac as well. It is something out of their understanding: “But… it is not Windows, how could that be possible”.
Professional, especially in educational and research fields. Oh my, let me tell you. Every one and their dogs are buying Powerbooks. You want hordes? What about seeing Windows platform be now the minority at workshops and meetings?
Yes, hordes buying OS X platforms are very real.
To get Linux users–and MANY others–Apple would need to release a low- to mid-range G5 tower (headless, with adequate expansion capability). It is unbelievably STUPID and SHORTSIGHTED that Apple refuses to do this.
And I LOVE Apple.
🙁
Most of Linux users are in institutions were discounted prices apply:
Dual G5 PowerMacs go from ~$1800 to ~$2700. Other discounts do apply. Apple is making a dent here.
Powerbooks? from ~$1400 to ~$2500. Prices are very much similar or better than other brands.
Once you get in there, you start to cripple in other segments. And Apple is getting in there, let me tell you.
“Professional, especially in educational and research fields. Oh my, let me tell you. Every one and their dogs are buying Powerbooks. You want hordes? What about seeing Windows platform be now the minority at workshops and meetings?”
Seahawk, I couldn’t agree more. These days, Windows users at scientific meetings have the body language of smokers: they know they should kick the bad habit, and they’re ashamed they haven’t done it yet.
As I said in other threads already: Apple is – in many cases – cheaper than other brands. They are aggressively discounting all models. In some cases even tax-free sales are possible which reduces the prices even more.
Amazing! David Coursey used to be a Winblows apologist before his Mac experiment. He bought an iMac G4 and the rest is history…
I don’t understand the constant call for a cheap, headless Mac. If you want a headless Mac, get an Xserve, If you want a cheap Mac, get an eMac.
It ain’t gonna happen folks and before someone brings up the other fantasy – OS X on intel/AMD that ain’t happening either.
hagar: totally. They even come forward and announce their next laptop will be a Powerbook for sure. Looks like sessions at the local AA gathering.
1) Apple doesn’t offer a cheaper “headless” Mac that would compete with the Dells of the world (yes, some people can’t afford an eMac)
Enough already with the “headless” Mac Crap. Here we have a a new iMac that, for all intents and purposes, is BODYLESS! And fer cripes sake, people who can spend $599 on a dell (before rebates) can sure as hell save up an extra $200 for an eMac. It can be done, has been done, and if they want quality for their money, SHOULD be done.
2) Games, or lack thereof…
There aren’t as many games as there are on the PC, but when it comes to the top rates games, 95% of them wind up on the Mac eventually. Usually within 3-6 months of their initial release. Besides, the Crappy games that come out for PC would never last long in the Mac market. Quality not quantity makes the biggest difference here. I will admit, there should be more developement of first run games for the Mac. I personally would never benefit from this as I just don’t play games anymore like I used to. I’m too busy working in iMovie, or Garageband to care.
so what IS the difference between Linux & Unix?
I believe there is a good reason to have a headless mac. The people that are going to spend $599 on a Dell really dont care too much about computers. The want something that they can surf aol (otherwise known as the internet) or type a document. Because of this lack of interest, it also means they have a lack of knowledge about why windows sucks and why mac’s are better. So what they see is a price point, this one costs $599 and that one costs $799, so why should i pay $200 dollars more? And as for the bodyless imac, what do they care when they could get 2 dells for the price of one imac. Dont get me wrong, I love apple and what they do and I own 3 macs and I want to buy more. I just want to see apple grow and the way to do it infultrate families (which they have been trying to do via iLife) but most average families run on a budget and if apple can get past this budget issue then we can see mass families that grow up using a mac.
My 2 cents…
I used Linux for over 10 years — still do at work. But I use MacOSX at home since February. Two things made me switch:
(1) Tired of Linux’s inadequate support for hardware drivers everytime I upgraded.
(2) I had the money in hand.
It’s not that Macs cost too much, it’s that you need so much money up front, while Linux users tend to buy their machines a few hundred bucks at a time.
BTW, I bought my G5 headless.
Apple could put Linux on the desktop out of it’s misery tomorrow with a graphical interface for Darwin and good, fast emulators for OS X and Windows XP that worked on it.
Apple probably has this very thing in a deep dark dungeon on the Apple campus.
Linux Trolls, be good or they will release this OS and put you all in the Apple camp.
Windows is about as secure as this country will be if Kerry gets elected.
The “headless” iMac is a red herring that will never exist. Why? Apple got too badly burned in the days of a-Mac-for-every-niche, so many models with tiny variations in spec you never really knew what you had. When Steve returned he canned that whole way of thinking and now the philosophy is: concentrate on what works and don’t get distracted by trying to satisfy the minutiae.
99% of people in the market for a “consumer” level machine will change their whole system at on fell swoop. Even corporate buyers tend to work in this way. Only geeks and very small “mom-and-pop” businesses cherry-pick components and upgrade progressively. Apple sells a million iMacs a year, and there are a couple of thousand squeeky wheels going on about a “headless” iMac. Apple’s answer is inevitable. After all, it worked perfectly well for Henry Ford.
Hey Walt, drop dead!
Glick7,
Just be sure to watch the “upgrade” path from Girlfriend x.0 to Wife 1.0. Many features might become permanently disabled.
If things go wrong, load the “Shopping” application. Works for me.
Nobody said a headless Mac had to have 1001 variations. They could just come out with a couple versions. After all, they decided 5 versions of a music player were acceptable…
Yeah, I sure feel secure with GWB in office. We’re better off with two more wars and thousands more terrorists angry at us. Uh huh. Didja see the Bush twins interview the other day? “…we didn’t think about the repercussions.” Yeah, they really do take after their dad…
Liberal, take a chill pill — I realize that the Apple crowd tends to be more artsy fartsy and therefore “liberal”, but you have to admit that Kerry is a complete flake. Speaking as a “independent” voter who considers himself moderate in most things political and occassionally votes both Democrat and Republican, the thought of Kerry as President is pretty scarey. Had his votes in the senate been the majority vote (luckily this was rarely the case), our country might be significantly different place and undoubtedly the Soviet Union would still exist. He’s so to the “left” that I don’t want him choosing Supreme Court Justices. Why can’t the Democrats nominate someone moderate instead of a left-wing liberal flake?
Headless…
I don’t think it’ll happen any time soon, if ever.
I think it would be a good move for Apple, but they may simply be unwilling to release a low end machine that would be compromised by a shitty looking monitor.
It’ll keep getting mentioned because people really do want it. People can really see a market for it
A “blame America first” liberal wrote:
“Yeah, I sure feel secure with GWB in office. We’re better off with two more wars and thousands more terrorists angry at us.”
—–
Yes, I too harken for the days we had under Bill Clinton, when the terrorist loved us so much that they committed numerous acts of terrorism while planning what they would do to us on 911. They loved us then, but now, under Bush, they’re mad. I’d even bet that though they loved us when Clinton was President, the only reason they planned 911 is because they somehow knew that George Bush was going to be Presdent someday.
QUESTION: What do terrorists and liberals have in common?
ANSWER: Both groups dearly hope that John Kerry is the next President of the United States.
Sleep well folks.
“Headless is OK”,
When you said that you feel more secure with GWB in office because “thousands more terrorists are angry at us”, didn’t you mean to say rather more accurately that you feel more secure with GWB in office because “thousands more terrorists are dead”?
It’s amazing hearing you Americans discuss politics. Liberal=artsy fartsy? and Kerry = Liberal?
man, you guys need to look around a bit.
Microsoft should be worried about Linux, not Mac. The developing countries of the world will not cough up the dollars for MS or Mac when a fully functional Linux desktop can be had for fraction (read: less than 10%) of the cost. Regardless of what any one individual here thinks, the majority of users need an email client, browser, office suite and a sprinkling of music, photo and drawing software and you can get that from Linux IN A VERY HIGH QUALITY for next to nothing (beyond the cost of a box). Not that that’s all Linux provides–just look at the security model and the number of Apache servers motoring the web! A key point of Linux, and the whole Open Source software scheme is to ‘free’ users from their dependency on commercial products and the companies that produce them and to collectively pool the resources of the computing world to yield the best software. So much for the soapbox – I’m thinking outside of it.
Just had a conversation with a co-worker here in my office…her husband is a Windows IT guru…hence at home, he’s got plenty of old and new computers – they have a network inside their house, etc. Here at the office we run macs – all running Panther. She was complaining that last night she tried to do something on “her” computer at home (a PC) and that it was broken. Seems all the computers had been infected and he was rebuilding them – AGAIN. Seems it happens all the time. She bemoaned that she can never use her computer at home because it’s always got something wrong with it. And her husband is a Windows IT guy remember. I then asked her the last time she had a problem here at the office – she quickly quipped never. The machines just run. And that’s the funny thing. Mac OS X computers just run. They don’t catche spyware or viruses. And you don’t need a dedicated IT guy (or husband) to constantly rebuild systems.
PC users just don’t get it. Those that do try Mac – never go back.
Australian said:
“It’s amazing hearing you Americans discuss politics. Liberal=artsy fartsy? and Kerry = Liberal?
man, you guys need to look around a bit.”
**********
Yes. Maybe one day we Americans will be as smart as everyone else in the world. Then, maybe our technological advances, our economic engine, our advances in medicine, and our military power will catch up with the rest of the world as well. Until then, I guess we’ll just have to settle for being stupid Americans.
On the other hand, you may just be selectively quoting a few people and conveniently asserting that they somehow are typical for what passes as politcal argumenatation here in the states. I bet Aussies are never guilty of glib statements.
Some liberal wrote: “Didja see the Bush twins interview the other day? “…we didn’t think about the repercussions.” Yeah, they really do take after their dad…”
______________________________
Hey, now that’s a good point. I mean, whoever heard of 21 year old college girls saying something ditzy.
What incredible insight these liberals have. Take a pentagram out of petty cash. Go ahead. You deserve it.
I do not understand this headless Mac concept. People who can pay $599 for a piece of crap Dell computer can afford a $799 eMac. They are just cheap scapes and want to feel like they got the best deal possible. What will they do with this headless Mac. Buy a cheapo monitor that is not nearly as good as the one included with the eMac. Maybe they will use a cheapo monitor that they already have from their old Intel system. For Apple to make money at they low end, they have to sell you the monitor too. You simply cannot beat the value of an eMac for the desktop at the low end. For a laptop, the ibook is a bargain. But a headless Mac for the low end? Someone justify this for me, please. I do not get it.
QUESTION: What do terrorists and liberals have in common?
ANSWER: Both groups dearly hope that John Kerry is the next President of the United States
_____
Uhm, Bush is the one keeping them well fed..
Mike wrote:
“Uhm, Bush is the one keeping them well fed.”
__________
Uhm, what the hell are ou talking about? Uhm…
Folks, stop comparing an eMac to a Pentium 4 equipped Dell. I’m a Mac user but come on. The eMac can’t compare to a Pentium 4 for performance at all. If they put a G5 in the eMac then yeah, start the comparisons.
And yes, I believe Apple needs a headless consumer model. Some people don’t want the built-in monitor. They may already have a monitor. See in the PC world, you can buy that $500 computer and then buy a $250 video card for it down the road.
What I can’t understand is why Apple insists on including a monitor but then puts such a crappy and outdated video card in their computers. I love the new iMac but a nvidia 5200? Please.
Come on Apple, make a pizza box or cube with a video card that can be replaced by the user.
Finally, I cannot keep out of this.
Reggie: I agree with you. Kerry’s no more a liberal than GWB a contender for the Nobel Peace Prize. He has no ideology whatsoever from what I have heard him saying publicly. There are people saying that anyone would be better than Little Bush, and they may have a point. But in my view, Kerry still has to define himself as a credible alternative on most important issues.
BTW: why is “liberal” always used as a derogatory word? Liberal means seeking individual freedom and rights. The opposite of liberal is oppressive. Look at your constitution, folks! The people who founded the US of A had a decidedly liberal attitude.
Just my two cents from across the pool.
I think a headless Mac would be a good idea. Even if it was just a G4 in a plain white box it would give users a chance to try out a Mac for 500 dollars (or even 600 dollars). Once you get them hooked they will be looking for a higher end unit pretty quickly and the market share gained would incent more company’s to produce even more software for the Mac.
hagar57,
You’re talking about one of many dictionary definitions of the word “liberal”. Like it or not, it has a different modern usage and talks about an entirely different kind of person that believes some very specific things and tries to implement those things in some very specific ways.
Modern day liberals are weak-kneed, limp-wristed pacifists. They are tax raisers, bleeding hearts, hyper-regulating socialists, they enable and even advocate infanticide, and they believe in the redistribution of income. When they don’t get their way at the ballot box ( which is very often) they try and often succeed to subvert the democratic will of the people through a judicial activist court friendly to their position.
I hope that answers your question of why the word “liberal” is used pejoratively.
As for John Kerry: Yes, he is a liberal, and a quite severe one at that. This is common knowledge, and if you’re not engaged enough to know this very simple fact, then perhaps you should be.
Anyway, it doesn’t matter, because Kerry is going down big time, and he’s going to lose big time. It’s fun to watch liberals implode over it.
Life is good.
It doesn’t even need to be headless.
How difficult is it REALLY to make the vid-card upgradable?
They’re using an aftermarket nvideo card… so why not add versatility… to extend the life of the machine… unless they don’t want it to be extended.
That card won’t run apps very well a few years from now.
make it entry level… and upgradeable
hagar57 wrote:
“Kerry’s no more a liberal than GWB a contender for the Nobel Peace Prize”
_____
Yassar Arafat, head of the PLO which is, and has been for decades, a terrorist organization, won the Nobel Peace Prize.
Jimmy Carter, self-righteous appeaser on whose shoulder’s (along with Bill Clinton’s) rests the cause and blame for the North Korean’s acquiring nukes, won the Nobel Peace Prize.
Facts are a very tough thing for the naive among us to confront.
It is amazing how quickly something turns from an Apple discussion to GWB and Kerry discussion. but i was so disturbed by what i read so…
Quote:
Modern day liberals are weak-kneed, limp-wristed pacifists. They are tax raisers, bleeding hearts, hyper-regulating socialists, they enable and even advocate infanticide, and they believe in the redistribution of income.
Why so much hatred? People believe in different things and are allowed to voice their beliefs which is what makes America so great, but the way you talk shows nothing but hate. I was for the afgan war (Which I still support), I was for the iraq war ( even though I was wrong to support it as I believed Bush & Co.)I am not weak-kneed nor a pacifist. As for hyper-regulating, Bush is trying to get an amendment to the constitution to ban homosexual marriages. Not only does this go against the basic beliefs of the Republican party ( States rights over big government) but it is hyper-regulation because you are telling me who I can marry because of YOUR religious belief. I remember reading something about separation of church and state, but I guess Bush missed that in his cliff notes of the constitution. Same thing for infanticide, that is based on YOUR religious beliefs and I hate to break it to you, but not everyone in the US has a religion or even shares yours. If your faith can’t keep you from having an abortion, then maybe your faith isn’t strong enough. As for your points about raising taxes, redistribution of wealth, bleeding heart, i believe the point of government is to help people of all kinds live safely and prosper. Sometimes when you are down on your luck, you need a helping hand. Ever heard this, Bring Us Your Poor, Your Tired, Your Huddled Masses? Government is supposed to help, not be a free-for-all for connected, rich people. Most of that great tax “cut” went to the top 1% of the country and just so you know, even bush’s dad, GHWB, said that trickle down economics does not work.
Lastly, based on you limp-wristed comment, I am heterosexual and having the beliefs that I do has no correlation to sexual orientation.
To conclude, I don’t hate you, i just disagree and I would never slam you personally for you beliefs as I realize that this a free country and you are entitled to your opinions. At least we agree on something… Apple makes a damn fine computer.
JO wrote:
…As for hyper-regulating, Bush is trying to get an amendment to the constitution to ban homosexual marriages. Not only does this go against the basic beliefs of the Republican party ( States rights over big government) but it is hyper-regulation because you are telling me who I can marry because of YOUR religious belief.
———-
No, in this case it actually reinforces states rights, and it is hardly hyper-regulation, in that it merely maintains the legitimate traditional and majority-approved status quo that is currently under attack by a small group of sexual degenerates.
Look, our hand has been forced, and if you don’t like that an amendment is going to settle the issue, you have only the liberal subversion of the democratic process to blame.
States, even liberal ones like California and Massachusetts, have at the polls voted to uphold that marriage is to be what it has been: Between one man and one woman. Do you understand that? The voters have already decided.
But democracy is not good enough for liberals when it interferes with their agenda. So, they circumvented the will of the people by having liberal activist judges override democratically enacted measures. In the liberal world, anything they don’t like is declared “unconstitutional”. But in fact, if you ever bother to read the constitution you will nowhere find any “right” to gay marriage. It’s just not in there.
So it comes down to the matter of whose values will prevail. We can’t always get our way, and though there are sometimes absolute rights, there are very few of them. One guy in an apartment building that wants to blast his stereo at 3 in the morning does not get to claim “opression!” when everyone else in the building tells him he can’t do that. Or is the majority somehow inexplicably obliged to be so self-sacrificing and accomodating as to let him do whatever he pleases.
When you have gays, which are a tiny and very whiny vocal minority enlisting the help of activist judges in pursuit of their agenda, an agenda that goes against the grain of the democratically affirmed vast majority, THAT, sir, is oppression.
JO wrote:
I remember reading something about separation of church and state.
———-
Really? That’s funny, because my copy of the constitution doesn’t say anything about “separation of church and state”. The only time my copy of the constitution gets into any religious matters is when it places a restriction on CONGRESS, not to establish a religion OR prevent the free exercise thereof.
Those last five words, not favorites of the ACLU, would seem to indicate that voters, as individuals, may vote according TO their religious beliefs if they so desire and are in no way obliged to leave them at home when they go to the voting booth.
In other words, just because YOUR value system is not Christian or traditionally American doesn’t mean that YOUR values get to prevail. Again, I say to you, it’s a democratic process. The voters decided – NOT George Bush – the VOTERS – and we’re not going to allow that liberal activist judges overthrow the will of the people on this matter.
As gays so often love to say: Deal with it!
JO wrote:
“I hate to break it to you, but not everyone in the US has a religion or even shares yours.”
———-
Jo,
I hate to break it to you, but you’re outnumbered.
JO wrote:
“Sometimes when you are down on your luck, you need a helping hand. Ever heard this, Bring Us Your Poor, Your Tired, Your Huddled Masses?”
Helping hand? That’s what charities are for. But don’t be generous with MY money. Be generous with your own. MY money, is STILL my money, and those that did not earn it are not entitled to it. If I want to give to chairitable causes, I’ll certainly avail myself of that opportunity, but it will be IF, WHEN, and HOW I so choose, and shall remain my business, an no one else’s, in that, again, it is MY MONEY!
As for the “Bring Us Your Poor, Your Tired, Your Huddled Masses” statement, that is nowhere in the constitution, so I can’t imagine what it has to do with anything. But I certainly don’t think it was ever intended as an advocate statement endorsing redistribution of wealth.
You want money? Earn it!
Two men, one a conservative, the other a liberal, were walking down the street together when they came upon a hungry beggar. The conservative man reached into his pocket and gave the beggar a five dollar bill. The liberal scoffed at the conservative with righteous indignation saying: “How stingy and greedy you are. Five dollars? How long is that supposed to last this poor beggar. I can be far more generous than that.” Then he reached into the conservative man’s pocket, pulled out a twenty, and with a self-satisfied grin gave it to the beggar.
Welcome to the welfare state.
Scott, I really dont want to take the time to debunk everything you just wrote as I don’t have the time as I am too busy creating tax dollars to pay for all my wasteful social services, plus this is a mac forum and not a politcal debate forum. But, i have enough time to give you a quick history lesson. You are right, seperation of church and state is not found in the constitution, but notice how i said cliff notes. I am sure you know what those are, they break down the topic into bite-size concepts, something that we know the current president likes as he is not an avid reader. Nevertheless, It was a concept that the founding fathers believed in. Thomas Jefferson wrote in 1802 that the Constitution created a “wall of separation between church and state.” Seeing he was one of the founding fathers and a president, I just might take his word about what the constitution meant over yours. Sorry.
Lastly, “sexual degenerates”? Sad… really sad. I remeber a time that people had similar disturbing beliefs about african americans (animals, less than human, etc.) but look at us now, we have african americans holding prominate positions in the white house. Luckily, people can grow. I hope in your lifetime, you do too.
This will be my last post about this topic… on with the apple based discussions!
JO wrote:
“Scott, I really dont want to take the time to debunk everything you just wrote…”
———-
That’s because you CAN’T debunk anything I wrote.
JO wrote:
“But, i have enough time to give you a quick history lesson. You are right, seperation of church and state is not found in the constitution, but notice how i said cliff notes. I am sure you know what those are, they break down the topic into bite-size concepts, something that we know the current president likes as he is not an avid reader. Nevertheless, It was a concept that the founding fathers believed in. Thomas Jefferson wrote in 1802 that the Constitution created a “wall of separation between church and state.” Seeing he was one of the founding fathers and a president, I just might take his word about what the constitution meant over yours. Sorry.”
———-
1) Yes, I noticed how you said “Cliff Notes” (and I know you think it was quite cute and clever), but I rightfully ignored it, in that it is an arrogant slam at the President of the United States that is based on the very very tired and time-worn contrary to the facts “Bush is stupid” mantra that is a favorite of the gutless and clueless wonders of the world such as yourself.
2) What are your qualifications for giving me a history lesson?
3) You actually DIDN’T give me a history lesson. All that you did was provide ONE out of context quote from Thomas Jefferson. If this is what you think makes for a history lesson, then I think we have some insight into your insufferable ignorance. And since Thomas Jefferson was a slave holder, he had to at least be getting SOMETHING wrong.
4) Additionally, we don’t run this country according to quotes, but according to the actual constitution (well, at least we ideally anyway).
JO then wrote:
Lastly, “sexual degenerates”? Sad… really sad. I remeber a time that people had similar disturbing beliefs about african americans (animals, less than human, etc.) but look at us now, we have african americans holding prominate positions in the white house. Luckily, people can grow. I hope in your lifetime, you do too.
This will be my last post about this topic… on with the apple based discussions!
———-
1) Would you care to provide any quotations from Thomas Jefferson or any of the other framers that specifically support gay marriage as a constitutional right?
2) I suppose I’m supposed to think that comparing the act of sodomy to the natural races of man is somehow novel. I’m afraid I can’t do that, in that I have heard this same fallacious and insulting analogy about 68,529 times by now.
3) I wonder if you’ve ever been confronted by the many many black Americans that are thoroughly offended and disgusted at people like you that liken their struggle to the whiny malcontents of the gay agenda crowd. Your attention please: The fallacious analogy does not work because one group is a natural RACE OF MANKIND, and the other group of their own free will and volition according to the perversions of their hearts engages in unnatural acts…SODOMY!
4) You should probably cool it with the unsolicited lectures against bigotry, in that you yourself have displayed here some very apparent anti-Christian bigotry. (Yes, yes, I know, anti-Christian bigotry is the acceptable fashion of the day.) Neverthess, to your list of outstanding qualitites such as arrogance and ignorance, we can now add hypocrisy.
5) I agree with your last sentence. Now that you’ve lost every single argument you’ve put before me, it’s probably best for you to move on.
Finally realizing he’s in over his head, JO has been rendered speechless. One more liberal bites the dust. My work is done here.
Scott
P.S. Come November, Kerry’s going to have his ass handed to him in a big way by the electorate. And good riddance. He and his kind are the slimiest creatures.
Kerry thinks that you can appease satan/islam/terrorists, Bush knows you can’t. The world will come to know.