Forbes: Microsoft CEO Ballmer’s CES keynote a misfire

“After watching the opening keynote of the International Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas Wednesday night, I sat at a casino bar considering what I’d seen. When a friendly bartender asked me what I’d been up to, I explained I had just watched the CEO of Microsoft give a speech,” David M. Ewalt writes for Forbes.

“‘Bill Gates?’ he asked. ‘Wow,'” Ewalt writes. “It’s an easy mistake to make. Bill Gates gave the opening keynote at CES 12 times, including his swan song last year, after which he handed over the spot to long-time colleague–and CEO since 2000–Steve Ballmer.”

Ewalt writes, “In some ways, Ballmer didn’t have a lot to live up to. Gates may be a legend, but he’s got his intellect, not his stage presence, to thank for that.”

MacDailyNews Take: If by “intellect,” Ewalt means “total lack of ethics,” he’d be right.

Ewalt continues, “Those 12 CES keynotes were generally awkward affairs, tepid pitch-fests where the few bright points were jokes at Gates’ own expense, or when things went wrong. Gates never exhibited the whiz-bang showmanship of Apple CEO Steve Jobs, whose Macworld keynotes made fans swoon.”

“We might have anticipated a misfire even before [Ballmer’s] keynote started,” Ewalt reports. “As conference-goers filed into the room to take their seats, the loud music welcoming them included a song from The Ting Tings called ‘Shut Up And Let Me Go.’ It’s a ditty probably best known for its use in a widely broadcast TV commercial for Apple’s iPod and iTunes music store.”

Full article here.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “JES42” for the heads up.]

31 Comments

  1. windows 7. not so impressed by it. As a MAC user, we’ve been accustomed to these features for years now. But it’s amazing that they are turning their attention to the female consumers by letting that perky sales woman give part of the keynote and talk about how shopping will be easier on windows7 that you can now have side by side windows open. ooooooo wow.

    mdn magic word “problem” as in Windows 7 is just another problem for microsoft and those who buy it.

  2. Windows 7 – less press, less comments, and it will go away please. I hope people are not actually getting excited about winblows 7. They better watch their step because when Snow Leopard is released it will make Windows 7 look like it is standing still. There will be some killer apps to really take advantage of graphics CPU processing and the focus will switch back to Apple, and rightfully so. Microshaft is not innovating, just marketing and just trying to retain.

  3. Typical, biased fanboys…

    Windows 7 is a HUGE step up from Vista. It WORKS! Sure, it still is nowhere close to Mac OS X in terms of UI, user friendliness, features, or performance, but it is a significant leap for Microsoft. The fact that they got an OS to work for the first time is just great, and I applaud their success.

  4. Windows 7 is a HUGE step up from Vista. It WORKS! Sure, it still is nowhere close to Mac OS X in terms of UI, user friendliness, features, or performance, but it is a significant leap for Microsoft. The fact that they got an OS to work for the first time is just great, and I applaud their success.

    There is no consolation prize for answering your competitor’s product from eight years ago.

    I don’t know MS’s “success” should be applauded, as much as their realization that patience with them has ran out. Nobody’s gonna tolerate another round of empty promises, “adjusted” ship dates, and alpha-quality crapware. They HAVE to get this one right.

  5. @ Aaquib

    > Windows 7 is a HUGE step up from Vista. It WORKS!

    LOL. So low are the expectations for Windows 7 that the fact that it “works” is trumpeted in all CAPS with an exclamation point.

  6. How would anyone know yet when and if Windows 7 “works?” More examples of people blabbing about things they know nothing about. Gates retired as CEO; Steve sat out a keynote. Not quite the same thing.
    I remember some Mac “journalists” claiming at first glance that Vista looked “fresh..” then we all quickly found out what a mess it was. Windows 7 may be better, but there’s a much bigger problem, one that will persist- it’s still spray-painted DOS. Unlike Mac OS X, which is a completely different OS than Mac “Classic,” Windows is still Windows. And it requires annual subscriptions to the best and most anti-virus and spyware utilities you can afford.

  7. @Rickumus

    A $2800 laptop that improves upon and replaces another $2800 laptop that was sells quite well. It is rather brilliant. Especially since a lot of people have been quite anxious to see it ever since the incredible refresh made to the lesser MacBook models.

    @bildad

    I actually kind of miss them and their simplicity sometimes. 7 was especially great in its day.

  8. I know Windows 7 is still a while from being available but it could be decent, it’s certainly the right approach and MS have obviously learnt from the Vista’s relative-fiasco.
    It could be a big draw for XP users to upgrade/renew and it is likely to have the most intense launch advertising ever in history.

    All the more reason then for Apple to not sit back and push forward.
    I just wish that Apple would drop the stupid I’m a Mac ads and show people what Mac OS X and iLife is really like – you can bet that MS will advertise all those features that Mac users are familiar with to much acclaim, “wow’s” and “oows”!

  9. The high point of Ballmer’s career was that expo where the stiff pranced around the stage like a drunken guerilla, screaming as though he’d just been castrated without an anesthetic, armpit stains revolting the entire world, all in a transparent attempt to cut loose, attempt to be cool and fire up the attendees. It’s been all downhill from there…

  10. @Gosh

    Personally, I think Apple don’t need to advertise OS X and iLife (et al) as TV commercials. Remember Phil’s remarks at the keynote? Several million people visit Apple Stores day by day, where they are exposed to OS X, iLife, iWork (…) and can experience it first hand.

    Plus, Apple’s own website is filled with demos and tutorials of their products.

    I suspect, afterall, the ‘I’m a Mac’ ads as designed to pique interest, not sell a product. In other words, for the viewer’s own curiosity to guide them to the local Apple Store or the company website.

    There’s no need to worry about people not being exposed to the Mac experience. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

    As for Ballmer, why is that a surprise? I was feeling charitable, so I sat down to watch the CES keynote, and, honestly, had to close the browser window after five minutes. MS have a long, long, long way to go…

  11. It Works!???
    So, Microsoft having stupendous resources to build windows 7, and finally creating an OS that works, is a defining moment? Is that like congratulating a chef for making food that actually tastes good? I don’t despise Windows – I’m happy for the people who use the wretched beast, it puts me me higher on the ladder. As my friend says ” if it wasn’t for the losers, you wouldn’t know who was cool” lol

  12. After Microsoft dazzles their users with promises of fantasy features, pours billions of dollars into Marketing and Development (there’s no such thing as R&D;at Microsoft), then chops them out when they’re unworkable, they simply slap a new face on the same wretched structure, market the hell out of the few keen, wicked and neat-o features that remain and sit back counting their cash as the sheep and cows line up to buy.

    Vista was little more a new skin for XP.
    Windows 7 is another re-skinning job for Vista.

    BTW, System 7 was a great OS. It was 32-bit YEARS before DOS (the then competition) or Windows were.

    I just don’t get the people who attempt to continue the myth of how terrible System 7, Mac OS 8 or 9 supposedly were. Did any of these people actually USE them? Did any of them attempt to use he competition of the time? OS 8.6 was fantastic. It was probably the peak of the “Classic” Mac OS in many ways.

    Yes, OS 9 was a bit creaky, but it was still fast and stable, as long as you avoided loading too many System Extensions… unlike me. ;^)

  13. @Andy

    Well yes herding ever greater numbers into the Apple stores and Apple.com is working but I just think more positive advertising would increase that.

    Still too many people say ‘Mac’s don’t have right click’, even some moderately intelligent Mac users? And I really get annoyed with the way Mac’s are presented, or rather not presented, in the stores. All should have Garageband running or a video of that or other iLife apps. I hate to see kids greeted by an empty desktop and tapping away at the keyboard until they get frustrated.

    I’m still puzzled by the way Safari is so totally under-sold, just as under-stated as it’s interface. Compare that to Firefox which just can’t wait to show you what’s new or how-to, just as soon as it’s downloaded.

  14. despite owning an apple, I don’t consider myself a fanboi. I must admit I do find it humorous, in that taking pity on a zealot kind of way, how, rather like uber religious people, you can’t tell fanbois anything, nor nothing you can say will ever get them to shift from their position one iota. It’s like they have surrounded themselves with this self-reinforcing delusion, coupled with an unflinching faith in their faultless god- steve in this case: not the making steve, but the marketing steve- and all richly shrouded with smug to be sure, and casting aspersions on the mere plebs below because it makes them feel superior. Not that they ever contributed one bit to the making of the all mighty’s Steve’s products. It’s quite fun to see…in a Flanders’ sort of way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.