NY Times’ Pogue reviews RIM’s BlackBerry Storm: ‘I’ve got a better name for it: BlackBerry Dud’

Research in Motion has a new phone that’s “officially called the BlackBerry Storm,” David Pogue reports for The New York Times. “But I’ve got a better name for it: the BlackBerry Dud.”

The Storm’s “entire screen acts like a mouse button. Press hard enough, and it actually responds with a little plastic click… As a result, the Storm offers two degrees of touchiness. You can tap the screen lightly, or you can press firmly to register the palpable click,” Pogue reports. “It’s not a bad idea. In fact, it ought to make the on-screen keyboard feel more like actual keys… Unfortunately, RIM has completely botched the execution.”

“The Storm even muffs simple navigation tasks. When you open a menu, the commands are too close together; even if your finger seems to be squarely on the proper item, your click often winds up triggering something else in the list,” Pogue reports. “There’s no momentum to the scrolling, either, as on the iPhone… In short, trying to navigate this thing isn’t just an exercise in frustration — it’s a marathon of frustration.”

“Now, I wouldn’t come down this hard on some product — especially one that was so eagerly anticipated, customers lined up at dawn on the day of its release — without getting a second, third and fourth opinion. And I’m telling you, there wasn’t a soul who tried this machine who wasn’t appalled, baffled or both,” Pogue reports. “And that’s before they discovered that the Storm doesn’t have Wi-Fi.”

Pogue asks, “How did this thing ever reach the market? Didn’t anyone at RIM actually try it? Or was everyone involved just too terrified to pull the emergency brake on this train?”

There’s much more – highly recommended – in the full report of the train wreck, er… review of RIM’s BlackBerry Storm, headlined “Blackberry Storm Downgraded To A Depression,” here.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “Fred Mertz” for the heads up.]

MacDailyNews Take: Vista got better reviews.

57 Comments

  1. last sentence –

    “The company says that it’s hard at work on a bug-fix software update.”

    so they know it sucks today. too bad vz rushed rim as it is hurting both of them. better off delaying a few weeks, taking the heat, and delivering a decent product.

  2. So what do you do when when after sampling a delicious looking fruit you discover that it tastes like crap and smells like crap?

    Wait for a genetically engineered fruit of the same kind?

    Once bitten, twice shy! PTL Ball Silly, Pull The Plug!

  3. I love this from the article.
    “BlackBerry without a physical keyboard.

    Hello? Isn’t the thumb keyboard the defining feature of a BlackBerry? A BlackBerry without a keyboard is like an iPod without a scroll wheel. A Prius with terrible mileage. Cracker Jack without a prize inside.”

    Cracker Jack hasn’t had a real prize inside for years (and no a sticker doesn’t count), and the iPod touch doesn’t have a scroll wheel yet it is one of the best iPods ever!

  4. Actually, dude, the iphone was perfect when it came out. It blew the cell phone world apart.

    Remember, this is a product by an Industry Leader, to try to take back some of the losses they are suffering from customers choosing the iPhone.

    This isnt their first attempt at a cell phone. This is the Blackberry guys panicking like rookies.

    Had it too easy for way too long, eh RIM?

    How many other complacent and lazy companies can you name?

    Ford
    GM
    GE
    Chrysler
    Microsoft
    …….

  5. To all the naysayers out there, I just want to say that I love the Storm. And the G1 too. Never touched or seen either one, and, based on the reviews, wouldn’t dream of buying one, but I love them just the same. Competition will only drive the iPhone to get better. Heck, I’ll even pre-love the MS Zune-phone disaster-in-waiting, for the same reason!

  6. JD: Golly, the iPhone was just perfect when it first came out, too.

    No, but it got the essentials so right that people were willing to wait for improvements around the edges.

    From all appearances RIM fails miserably even at basic usability. And that is hard or impossible to remedy after the fact. Too bad they don’t seem to understand the difference.

  7. @ping

    Actually, I have a Storm. Its essentials are just fine, and RIM is going to make it better. I don’t know what device Pogue is going on about, but it’s not the Storm. Walt Mossberg agrees with me.

  8. Well JD most reviewers, at least those of note, do seem to know precisely what device he is going on about, and unfortunately for ‘Rimmers’ it IS the Storm. Don’t think they have been on the Apple coolaid eddie either. So just maybe that big sever centre over at RIM Towers is sending positive but very subjective messages to the gullable. Are they telling you to believe in crops circles too by any chance? Not sure either how it can actually improve that much with a limited operating system and only basic touch capability. There is only so far you can go with yesterdays technology I’m afraid.

  9. People who compare the iPhone situation to the Storm have got to be kidding.

    The iPhone was the first, it was the originator and spent its initial time in an empty field all by itself with nothing to compare.

    The Storm is arriving in a sea of iClones that are starting to get good. Some of them, like the Samsung Omnia on Verizon, are being released right alongside it this year. There’s virtually no comparison between the two introductions.

    Apple had plenty of room for error since everyone followed in their shoes. RIM doesn’t. Either you float above the iClones or sink with them.

  10. @spyinthesky

    Is Mossberg drinking the RIM koolaid too?

    What is it with you people that if Steve didn’t personally bless it, it’s evil of the most vile sort? Not everyone can use an iPhone, not everyone wants to. Get over yourselves, the iPhone is just an f-ing phone and it’s not perfect. The 3G dropped half its calls before Apple finally delivered software that made the thing work, and that was after the launch fiasco that left half of them bricks on day one. The original iPhone was, well, not so hot either until a few downloads later, let’s be honest.

    My G4 PowerBook went back with the display problem that most of them had. My white G4 MacBook was replaced because the WiFi stopped working, the way a huge percentage of them did. Now I have a new aluminum MacBook with no FireWire and a clicky trackpad that reminds me a whole lot of my Storm. And don’t even get me started on the mess that is Mobile Me, the dumbest name for a product in the history of computing except for, perhaps, Lisa.

    Please don’t pretend it’s all good here in the orchard, it ain’t so.

  11. Like the Obamatards, the RIMtards are having a collective meltdown as they are confronted with the fact that the blank slate upon which they have projected all of their hopes and dreams turns out to be a run-of-the-mill, or worse, product.

    As Obama packs his staff with has-beens and never-weres from previous administrations, signifying zero change whatsoever, the Obamatards are disillusioned, just as the RIMtards are with the “Storm.”

    Some ‘tards cast their votes for an empty vessel they can fill with all their hopes and dreams – for convenient one-stop smashing – blindly chasing the foolish, very Liberal fantasy of “change.” Voting for change undefined is lunacy.

    Some ‘tards cling to their antiquated CrackBerry devices, watching their beloved get obliterated by iPhone’s vast superiority, and project upon Storm’s rickety, poorly-executed, limited click-screen all sorts of similar fantasies.

    Some “double ‘tards” even did both: Voted for Obama and lined up to buy a Storm sight unseen, too. Fools.

    Welcome to reality.

    At least the RIMtards only blew their money on a piece of antiquated junk disguised as the future instead of voting one into the U.S. Presidency.

  12. @ everyone

    Tried searching on Google and every other thing, cookies turned on etc. but this article is just NOT available without the log on.

    I just don’t know what newspaper companies think they are doing in this day and age with these stupid log-on requirements. They do no good and just stop people from using their sites.

  13. I really want the Storm to succeed, mainly because I’m stuck on Verizon due to the free IN calling. It looks like it has potential. If it wasn’t for IN calling, I’d be on an iPhone now.

    I played with a Storm in the store for a bit, and it wasn’t too bad, just a bit sluggish on repainting the screen and flipping. I’m hoping they can fix that with some software tuning.

    Doesn’t matter right now, anyhow. I won’t buy it until they can support syncing to Mac, for which RIM says they’re trying to get something out early next year.

    Samsung is releasing a touchscreen but… no… *sob*… I just won’t do another Windows Mobile device 🙁

  14. Winston reappears!!!

    I bet you are just as glad as I am that the Haunted House is finally over!

    Now, if they could just pick up the trash on the eastern side of ESP where I live. Walking my dog is a nightmare. All she does is try to eat trash – and I don’t mean Paris Hilton.

    Well, time to take Molly out for a walk and battle the trash.

  15. My favorite part…

    “But wait, there’s less. Both of my review Storms had more bugs than a summer picnic. Freezes, abrupt reboots, nonresponsive controls, cosmetic glitches.”

    “… (And goodness knows, it’s easy to start up. Just enter a Gmail address …) “

  16. Happy Thanksgiving to MDN readers.

    I have to say Pogue is known as being very Pro-Apple (isn’t he friends with Jobs?) and it’s amusing these reviews and feedback are after a short time or a few minutes of using the Storm. Why don’t you actually use the device for a couple weeks and get used to it.

    RIM will address the issues with Storm (as did Apple with the numerous updates iPhone has had) so at the end of the day both devices will still sell a boatload. Storm will make sales just by the fact it’s on Verizon Wireless which last I looked was still the #1 rated carrier in the States.

    Most of Pogues review as well a number of other reviews are doing a disservice and either reviewing it as a standard Blackberry or how it’s different then iPhone. I wish people who review things do so on their own merit and while yes recognize the strengths of competing devices judge the device on it’s own.

    Most of the issues can be addressed with a software update. This market is so huge it will come down to personal preference and for now at least Blackberry provides options for users. Apple is one form factor, one carrier.

  17. @Superior Being

    Great analogy. Especially regarding Obama and RIM. The dissent is gradually beginning. The “Elite Media” is beginning to scratch their collective heads as if they never saw his sophomoric arrogance.

  18. At the moment I use a combination – the Blackberry Bold for work email / applications. A edge iPhone (jailbroken) for nights / weekends for music / web / games.

    I also have various HTC WM models and a new Palm as users still order them and I have to support them.

  19. macca: what genius greenlit this thing without wifi? i mean, seriously – isn’t that pretty much a deal-breaker? until we have wi-max or some other truly 3g wide-area network, it’s just got to have wifi.

    RIM has left the Storm to the network providers for branding and feature specification. And the providers just don’t want WiFi in there, so RIM left it out.

    Apple precluded such provider interference right from the start, which made the iPhone a very different beast. But especially as long as manufacturers keep kowtowing to the providers, the results will be the mediocrity we know.

  20. Denny: The “Elite Media” is beginning to scratch their collective heads as if they never saw his sophomoric arrogance.

    The word you were apparently looking for is competence. But I can understand that by now you’re having a hard time recognizing it on sight…! ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  21. @ping,

    Yeah, like who would ever want an expert in Constitutional law running the country?

    After 8 long years of Cheney-Bush doing their best to turn the Constitution into a piece of used toilet paper, it feels great to have grown-ups back in charge.

  22. as i often say “there is no competition” for the schmucks who say “competition is good” without understanding the true intrinsic nature of what it takes to be a competitor. Nikon and Canon are real competitors, and Nikon mopped the floor with Canon’s ass this time. I have the D700 – fscking amazing!! Why? Nikon had a coup and got rid of old, outdated management execs. They bought in more progressive people, and now have THE best camera in it’s class. Meanwhile, Canon recently had a 1DsmarkIII, a $8000 camera, with autofocus issues. What? How the hell did that happen? Maybe resting on their laurels? The point is, regardless the technology, companies must embrace forward thinking, and Quality Control. Blackberry has made a derivative product, that cant even copy the winner correctly. People at Blackberry AND Verizon need to be fired over this debacle, the investors MUST see to it.

  23. I didn’t notice anyone get fired over the MobileMe disaster. A product that needs some tweaking is one thing (what DOESN’T need a update or two in this day). Failure to provide a service as advertised or worse yet actual losing email and then saying there is no backup is pretty much as bad as it gets.

    I guess Apple / at&t;have some fired people too with all the dropped calls, reboots, lockups prior to the number of updates iPhone has had.

  24. “The funny thing about this is the absolutely fawning review of the Storm by that bastion of intellectual honesty, Gary Krackow of TheStreet.com. I think he’s the only person who likes the thing.”

    You should this review at the Sci-Fi channel DVICE site… another bastion of PC weinies.

    http://dvice.com/archives/2008/11/blackberry_storm_review.php

    As a life long SF fan, I’ve always taken a bit of pride (falsely, I guess) in the notion that SF people were more open minded and receptive of new things. I am embarrassed by the narrow mindedness (and general anti-Apple/Mac stance) of reviewers and fans of a site oriented towards the SF community.

    Of course this is a channel (one whose founders was the SF giant, the late Isaac Asimov) whose operators decided to cancel a number of original hit SF series and dropped some SF programming in favor of wrestling… so what should I expect?

  25. …and yet after so much negative publicity most of which is conveniently summarized by MDN, Verizon order page now shows Storm device delivery 12/15 instead of 12/8 just day or two ago.

    Sad, really sad having people willing to wait so long before they can have Storm blackberry experience first-hand.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.