CNET blogger: Apple’s gotten in over its head with the iPhone

Don Reisinger asks via CNET’s Crave, “Is Apple in over its head with the iPhone?”

“Has Apple gotten in over its head trying to play the same game it always has with its other devices without realizing that the cell phone industry is an entirely different beast altogether? Sadly, I think it has,” Reisinger opines.

“If Apple has learned nothing else, the company now knows that in the cell phone industry, relying on good looks and hype won’t get the job done,” Reisinger writes. “Let’s face it — Apple’s Macs perform well because they’re sleek, powerful and run an operating system that most people like. The company’s iPods sell extremely well because they’re easy to use and have always provided an end-to-end solution with iTunes that has yet to be matched. But what about the iPhone?”

Reisinger writes, “Sure, Apple may have already sold 4 million iPhones since June and that’s a success story by itself, but in this business, longevity is difficult to maintain and competitors are always ready to release something better.”

Full article here.

Don, the next time you have nothing of importance to write, don’t write anything.

Click Don’s name and CNET makes this much clear: “Don Reisinger is a technology columnist… [and] a member of the CNET Blog Network… He is not an employee of CNET.” If even CNET is disowning you, you’ve got problems.

Excuse our French, but we’re tired of slogging through nonsense written by fscking idiots.

53 Comments

  1. “competitors are always ready to release something better.”

    That’s completely untrue. Occasionally competitors release a better product than Apple, but usually they can’t match Apple’s offering.

  2. Add my input? Already did. I went to the site and posted a reply. I do have one thing to say good for these people. They helped push Apple stock down to a point where I can afford to buy a share or two. So I guess everyone has a purpose. LOL ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

    en

  3. Um, there are always competitors nipping at your toes. Duh. However, given that the iPhone has not been out for a year yet, and that it already has broken sales records, and that it is becoming an open platform for developers next month, and that it is updated regularly by Apple……how is Apple over it’s head? Apple is totally on top of this market. They have THE STANDARD that all phones are compared to.

    Someone thinking Apple is going to sit around with its lead is not a student of history. Apple will continue to push the boundaries with software updates to the iPhone, and when it releases a new version (summer? who knows), it will further push ahead.

    Bloggers. Really, what has this world come to when some dood still in his underwear can write crap like this and people believe it.

  4. The biggest limitation of the iPhone is being tied to one network in each country. Apple chose that route in order to garner revenue sharing (they learnt that from the music industry).

    If they had sold unlocked phones only the number sold could be anywhere from 4-6M depending on the sale price and assuming no telcom discounts.

  5. “competitors are always ready to release something better.”

    …..no basis for that in the cellphone industry or the music industry. at best they operative in a small trading range of imagination.

    where was the iphone equivalent prior to Apple’s introduction? where is it since its introduction? efforts so far has been just dressing up a pig.

    the ipod, ipod touch and iphone, and even “air” are all siblings….the mobile platform is what Apple is pitching….no one else comes close;

    cell phone is just a service on a chip

  6. Yeah, they should probably stay out of the MP3 player market too. It’s too competitive. There is no way they can come out with a great initial product and keep it going. What’s that? They already have done it and are going strong? Woops. Maybe I have no idea what I am talking about. Maybe there is not that much to cell phones. Maybe it is just a small hand held device like an iPod. Maybe people are starting to expect more from this small device than just making and receiving calls. Maybe you should put a whole OS on there. They did they too? Hmmm, running out of ammo.

    Jokes aside I personally would like to see Apple slow down, take a deep breath, and tie up whatever loose ends there are with their current products. With the market as it is people are looking for any reason to attack. Keep things secret and plug up any holes. Slow down Apple, solidify your current products, do not become the next Microsuck for the love of god.

  7. He seemed to forget to back it up with anything… “Longevity is difficult to maintain”, but who’s to say Apple won’t maintain it?

    I’ve had an iPhone since it came out. Almost everyone I know has one now, and I’ve haven’t heard a real complaint yet. Actually, the longer someone has one, the more they like it.

    “Apple’s Macs perform well because they’re sleek, powerful and run an operating system that most people like.”

    The iPhone is a Mac with a phone app, not a cell phone.

  8. Oh Apple just set a paradigm with the iPhone. FTARDS can’t see how the cell phone industry is now racing to try and catch up. Before Apple, Cell Phone makers went with their hats in their hands begging the carrier to sell their phone, making minimal profits from that privilege. Cell phone makers were constantly tweaking the phones to meet the carriers restrictions just so they’d sell their phone. Apple then came along and set their own terms to the carriers. And their selling a crap load of iPhones and the carriers are getting the rewards for that. The only ones in over their heads right now is the old cell phone makers because the model changed and they have yet to adapt. Some will fail and some will survive, the customer in the end will win because the free and low cost phone sponsored by the Cell Phone Networks will start to go away, as that happen the over all rates will go down as carriers are no longer buying the customer a cell phone.

  9. This poor guy is clueless. Once the SDK is released, it will go from being the best phone to being the best phone + even more killer apps. The ability to customize via SDK will open up the business market. Add to that that the current generation is not even 3G, demand for the next generation release before Christmas will be likely be off the charts and make up for any “shortcomings” in sales to date. Frankly, any way you slice it, this phone is a huge hit with consumers, in addition to being the best communication device on the market. The future is looking very bright for iPhone.

  10. This blog would have made sense right after last years keynote when Steve had just announced the iPhone. It would have been wrong, but in that context it might not have sounded so stupid.

    Right now the only thing that Apple is in over it’s head in, is money. Billions and Billions of greenbacks.

  11. @DogGone

    “The biggest limitation of the iPhone is being tied to one network in each country. Apple chose that route in order to garner revenue sharing (they learnt that from the music industry).”

    I disagree with our statement. I don’t like being tied to one carrier either, but I think they had to offer this exclusive deal to a carrier to get the features (Visual Voicemail, etc.) and the rates plans (unlimited data) that they needed to make the iPhone work the way they wanted. US carriers would not have just implemented this stuff to make Apple happy because these changes cost AT&T;a lot of money to get ready for the iPhone. No carrier is just going to do that out the goodness of their heart. Apple had to make an exclusive deal with a carrier. Apple gets the features and control they want and the carrier gets a BIG draw for new subscribers. Remember that no other handset maker has as much control of their product in the US market as Apple does with the iPhone and that is why they had to make a “deal with the devil”.

    Once the carriers backs are broken over 5 years and more control goes to handset manufacturers then Apple will probably move to an unlocked model. Apple is a corp and they made the best deal they could (revenue sharing) when they joined forces with AT&T;. You are right that an unlocked phone would sell more phones, but the cool features that Apple has implemented wouldn’t exist on any carrier if Apple hadn’t made this deal. They’ve managed to enter the market, turn it on its head, and set sales records in less than a year. Apple’s not perfect but I think they’ve managed this pretty well so far.

  12. The ipod has been out since 2001. Has it’s presence made other players better in order to compete? Yes.
    Are other players better than the ipod/itunes ecosystem given the fact they’ve had years to copy and match it? No.
    No amount of time allow competitors to match or better the iPhone/Touch/iPod.
    The touch is way cool. Why? Software. These other companies are too into appearance. The software is very cool on the touch, just try one (or iPhone).
    It’s Apple move as far as do they go after the low end phone market and risk canabalising the NANO? Is it an equal trade off for the company? Curious about there next move.

  13. “Along those lines, why was Apple caught off guard by the immense unlocking community that has done all it can to make sure the iPhone would work on any GSM network? Didn’t the company know that unlocking is commonplace in the business? If it did, why did it fail to realize that by locking the iPhone down, an enormous group of individuals would blaze the path that ultimately led to about a 30 percent unlocking rate?”
    If the iPhone isn’t the most attractive piece of technology, why are so many trying to use it all over the world? A really poor analysis by someone who has not used this wonderful device.

  14. I like that most people have an ipod (ave $200) and razr like phones (ave $200).

    And the smart people get the iphone ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

    No really. It is such a good deal for what you get. And have yet to meet someone who owns one that is not impressed.

  15. What these other companies don’t get, whether it’s the Mac, iPod, or iPhone, is that the look and design is only the start of the product. Apple uses quality hardware – the iPhone and iPod Touch sport glass screens instead of plastic. Ever see a Treo or Blackberry with a glass screen?

    The real killer is the software, and now, specifically OS X. No phone or mp3 player manufacturer can come close to OS X.

    Finally, the other manufacturers think that if you dress up a phone/mp3 player with cool-looking plastic and a flashy splash screen that you’ll fool the masses and win new customers. You can put lipstick on a pig, but it’s still a pig, and still acts like a pig.

    Until these other manufacturing companies figure that out, Apple will have very little competition.

  16. If you cant see that Apple is so far ahead of the rest – you are stupid, and we can not help you.

    No-one can match the iPhone, and in 2 years when they get close, Apple will have moved even further ahead.

    Maybe Micro$hit will bring out a new zzunephone?
    ROTFLMAO!

    These analysts have a serious case of recto-cranial inversion.

  17. “competitors are always ready to release something better.”

    he does have a point, Apple doesn’t have to worry about that on OS side of things…. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  18. MDN – shouldn’t the link to the article be flagged “Think before you Click ™” ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

    Hmmm – so what is the deal in Germany? Their population is about 1/4th of the US – so is that iPhone is not 3G the issue over there?

  19. “”Let’s face it “

    I love when dipsh!ts start off with “Let’s face it” like he’s privy to some information we all don’t know, and then just blabbers about his opinion without any facts to back them up.

    BTW, Apple doesn’t just create a product that is “relying on good looks and hype”. If that were the case, the iPod would have just been another also-ran digital music player. We all know how that one turned out.

  20. “While the story maybe garbage Mac Daily News take on anything Apple is that Apple can do no wrong.”

    Actually no. Been reading this site for years and I can say if Apple f’s up, MDN does call them on it. The problem is, Apple gets so many things right that it just SEEMS like they are kissing Steve’s butt.

    What they DO here is call out retard bloggers and writers who talk out their asses and make commentary based on false or misleading (or in some cases zero) information.

  21. “Sure, Apple may have already sold 4 million iPhones since June and that’s a success story by itself, but in this business, longevity is difficult to maintain and competitors are always ready to release something better.”

    Damn. I guess it really is a shame that Apple has stopped all iPhone development since the initial release. It really is too bad that they didn’t have the foresight to continue R&D;, and plan improved models in the future. Or… Do you suppose that maybe, just maybe, Apple does have plans of revisions in the future? Nah, of course not.

  22. ” longevity is difficult to maintain”

    Well it may be difficult to attain but once you’ve had a long life, you’ve had longevity and that can’t be taken away even if you die so there’s no issue maintaining the attribute.

    Even so, Apple is far from having longevity in the cell phone market so there’s nothing to maintain yet. Longevity is still to be attained and, as far as I can see, Apple is on its way for that.

    So many words, so little meaning.

  23. I dunno. There may be a germ of truth here. Apple has clearly lobbed a grenade onto the crowd of the other players in the cell phone arena. So far, they haven’t really recovered or responded. It seems to me that it is too soon to tell whether the other players are killed, wounded or merely temporarily stunned. The iPhone is a great phone, even, arguably, the greatest phone ever, but still, it isn’t for everyone, just like the MacBook Air is marvelous, but not right for everyone.

  24. “in this business, longevity is difficult to maintain and competitors are always ready to release something better.”

    I think iPhone is still quite NEW.
    And since it’s introduction – NO ONE has even MATCHED it’s capabilities. Nor has any competitor made anything as COOL.

    Apple doesn’t just make COOL devices and hardware. THEY make INSANELY great products.

    Don Reisinger – go back to sleep you grizzly bear… and put on some clothes next time you show expose yourself. Ahhh.

    Dougless

  25. Oh yeah the iPhone is so last year.
    I couldn’t possible agree less with Donnie.
    He’s so – nerdy… hee hee… that’s like a magnet 4 me.

    So, yeah, this i-ness thing with like that phone…
    You know… like – I am so over it now.
    Did it – done it. OMG…

    So when is the Zune Phone coming?

    Cos – gee wow – I need to carry a brown device to match my new slacks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.