“Of course you can dismiss the touch as an over-priced gimmick – and many people will, justifiably. Its sound quality isn’t the greatest in the world and just 16GB of storage space in a device costing £265 will be more than many technological spendthrifts can stomach,” Jonathan Bray reports for TrustedReviews
“But that would be ignoring the sheer software and hardware engineering genius that’s gone into making this product viable – and the pleasure you’ll derive from using it. Put simply, if you want to experience the cutting edge in interface design, this is the best way of doing it without saddling yourself with a £35 per month phone bill. Apple has done it again,” Bray reports. “Bravo!”
Bray’s scores:
Sound Quality: 8/10
Usability: 10/10
Value: 7/10
Overall: 8/10
Full review here.
[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “Island Girl” for the heads up.]
“So can a simple touch screen really be worth paying this much for? The short answer is yes, but you don’t want the short answer, so here’s why… The touch’s touch-sensitive control system really is a revolution in user interfaces – I can think of no other way of describing it. In the same way that Apple’s clickwheel has never really been bettered, I can’t see any other manufacturer coming up with anything superior to this for years either. It’s the best touch sensitive interface I’ve ever used on any device and the software behind it is some of the best put-together on any pocket device I’ve used too.”
Splendid.
LAST!
“Its sound quality isn’t the greatest in the world…”
Why do reviewers say this? Is it because they can’t think of anything negative at all to say, so they make subjective comments like this? I’ve never noticed anything wrong with iPod sound. I wonder what constitutes, “the greatest sound quality in the world”? I bet it costs more than $400!
I’m waiting for Revision 2.
Then again I always wait for Revision 2.
I even find myself waiting for myself.
When Revison 2 of myself appears, then I’ll quit waiting.
He had to knock 2 points off because it wasn’t 3G.
When, oh when will Apple get around to that 3G iPod touch we all want?
From the Article:
“I kicked off the listening tests with a touch of undemanding country and western and Shawn Colvin’s Wichita Skyline. The pianos, and the mix of acoustic and electric guitars came across well. Perhaps there wasn’t quite as much clarity and presence as with the Trekstor Vibez, my current benchmark for sound quality, but it was still very good. Moving onto something more fast-moving – Green Day’s American Idiot – and the touch’s weaknesses were exposed more, with less punch and bite than the Vibez and the sound a little compressed, but once again the differences are small and unless you’ve a really good pair of headphones (replace the white ones that come with it – they’re not very good), this probably won’t bother you in the slightest.”
@Revision 2:
The iPod Touch icould be considered a revision 2 product.
It’s based off of the iPhone which you might say is the revision 1 of the iPod Touch.
Just a quick thought.
Meant to say version not revision.
I love the “Sound Quality” complaint. To make a 16GB player viable, you need to compress the music, thus killing quality from the start.
I have an iPhone and let me tell you this device is awesome!!!! I too agree that this is the first mobile cell phone I actually enjoy using. Amazing!!!
Betteroff with a Zune!
Many have asked what the three play buttons are about:
The Zune 2 and ZuneMini supports the latest thing! Yes, Multi-track-triplay!
Listen to up to 3 songs all at the same time!
Imagine hearing Love Song, Radar Love and Handel’s Messiah all at the same time! WOW!
You will love Triplay! Combine your favorite tunes, hear it all!
The new cutting edge Zunes alone support this cool cutting edge technology!
Also featuring the optional ZuneRing! Wear you ZuneMini anywhere, so your Zune is “Always On Hand”.
Available December 22, 2007! Pre-order once MS makes the official announcement.
http://fakesteveballmer.blogspot.com
Ballmer. You suck. Please. Stop.
Usability is 10 out of 10! That’s crazy! You can’t change the volume without taking it out of your pocket! Apple crippled the calendar so you can’t add new events!
I wanted to love (and purchase) the iPod touch so bad, but I just can’t bring myself to buying one.
The iPod Touch is never going to be 3G since it is not a phone. I think we should knock 2 points off the author!
“if you want to experience the cutting edge in interface design, this is the best way of doing it without saddling yourself with a £35 per month phone bill.”
Best way is to buy an iPhone and hack it.
I need 30 GB before I would get one. Guess I will just have to wait.
I have to agree with MacMarc to a point. My wish list for the Touch is too long (maybe) for me to get one. Artificially keeping out a mail app, google maps, bluetooth, being able to input anything, is disappointing. They have the absolute coolest pda-type device in their hands, but they don’t want to give it to us. I know, I know, it’s an iPod, not a communicator! That doesn’t stop me from wishing it was something more. I’m not going to b*tch and complain about it, but I might not buy one for those reasons. I played with one at my Apple store. It was awesome.