Apple shares fall almost 5% on AT&T’s iPhone activations

&ot

“AT&T Inc., reported a 61% rise in second-quarter net income amid recent acquisitions and said it activated 146,000 iPhone subscribers the last two days of the quarter, 40% of whom were new AT&T Wireless customers,” Kevin Kingsbury reports for The Wall Street Journal.

Full article  here.

Rex Crum reports for MarketWatch, “Apple Inc. (AAPL) saw its shares fall $6.70, or almost 5%, to $137.10, after AT&T Inc. released its iPhone sales figures for its second quarter.

“The numbers are seen as a barometer for measuring total iPhone sales because all iPhones, even those sold in Apple retail outlets, must be activated through AT&T’s wireless network. Many analysts were looking for sales around 200,000, with some projections as high as 500,000 iPhones sold in the last two days of the quarter,” Crum reports.

Full article  here.

Notable Calls reports, “CIBC’s Ittai Kidron is out with monster call on Apple saying based on their store checks, they believe that demand for the iPhone has seen a significant decline in the past 10 days. CIBC has noticed decent inventories at stores, and thin demand at best. In fact, most Apple store visitors were not looking at the device and only a very small subset bought it.”

“With the weakness, they wouldn’t be surprised to see AT&T and Apple step up their marketing efforts. Firm’s channel checks suggest Apple is actually looking to introduce a 3G version of the iPhone for the U.S. market in November, ahead of the holiday season and earlier than currently expected,” Notable Calls reports.

“CIBC now believes the ‘improvement’ could come soon,” Notable Calls reports.

Full article  here.

TheStreet.com reports at AT&T said “sales of the Apple iPhone ‘have been robust.’ AT&T activated 146,000 iPhone subscribers in the last two days of the quarter. “Sales of the iPhone continue to be strong in July with store traffic above historical levels,” AT&T said.

Full article  here.

99 Comments

  1. Am I crazy or did AT&T have server issues the first couple of days (from all the people activating iPhones) that prevented everyone from activating their iPhones. Like “R” said:”Key word: activated.” Besides, is there another smart phone that sold 146,000 units in 2 days?

  2. All purchased iPhones have to be activated. That’s no distinction. Early adopters would be too excited to postpone activation. Phones not activated immediately were probably purchased to be resold on ebay. Unfortunately, iPhones weren’t selling on ebay b/c buyers understood that the Apple stores weren’t sold out of iPhones. Phones not activated were probably returned to the store for refunds. 146,000 is an awful number. Far lower than anyone would have guessed, even the shorts. I’m just surprised the stock isn’t down 20% today.

  3. AT&T did have some technical difficulties. But at the time, didn’t they say it was only affecting a small percentage of all activations?

    The only thing keeping this stock from going down further is the rumor that a 3G phone will be coming out sooner than expected. What happens to the stock if that rumor is dispelled?

  4. AT&T did have some technical difficulties. But at the time, didn’t they say it was only affecting a small percentage of all activations?

    The only thing keeping this stock from going down further is the rumor that a 3G phone will be coming out sooner than expected. What happens to the stock if that rumor is dispelled?

  5. AT&T did have some technical difficulties. But at the time, didn’t they say it was only affecting a small percentage of all activations?

    The only thing keeping this stock from going down further is the rumor that a 3G phone will be coming out sooner than expected. What happens to the stock if that rumor is dispelled?

  6. AT&T did have some technical difficulties. But at the time, didn’t they say it was only affecting a small percentage of all activations?

    The only thing keeping this stock from going down further is the rumor that a 3G phone will be coming out sooner than expected. What happens to the stock if that rumor is dispelled?

  7. In some ways it is almost funny to watch some people unload thier AAPL stock on such news. Out there somewhere “someone” jumped out at $137, only to watch it recover in a matter of hours. Go ahead and panic, the rest of the world deserves a bargain now and then.

  8. Well now, let’s see, WinTrolls:

    Your beloved MSFT is presently sitting at $31.10, all the way up from $30.50 six months ago. You’re right; that’s something to revel in.

    Right now AAPL is sitting at $139.85, up from $85 six months ago. Hmmmm.

    I double-dog-dare you pathetic WinFanTots to invest $100,000 dollars of your money into MSFT and/or DELL and come back here in six months with the results.

    If it’s over 2-4% to the good on either equity, I’ll grovel at your feet.

  9. My activation barely mad the quarter, so this may be understated. Also, how many people used to old cell phones, bought their phone and charged it overnight before activating.

    In any event, my friends is being shipped direct from China – So inventories are low, so demand is high. Thanks for the buying opportunity on the stock!

  10. The problem was activation issues on AT&T’s end. My iphone didn’t get activated until Tuesday due to delays. Some iphones sold may actually been gifts and their activations would be delayed also. The true measure would be how many iphones were sold.

  11. Yes, many early adopters would activate right away, but those who bought them as gifts wouldn’t, and many of those who tried to activate were delayed the activation process until Sunday. Some were even delayed until Monday.
    As for 146,000 being an awful number, can you name any phone that has ever sold that many in two days? How is it possible for a world record to be an awful number?

  12. “Phones not activated were probably returned to the store for refunds. 146,000 is an awful number. Far lower than anyone would have guessed, even the shorts.”

    Oh that’s funny. Yeah, hella refunds, I can see it. As for the “awful” number…

    “Motorola reported their 2nd quarter earnings and revenue that beat Wall Street’s predictions. Moto Q sales eclipsed 150,000 units during the first 30 days it was on sale.“

    It’s all academic at the moment anyway. Don’t. Panic.

  13. “Well now, let’s see, WinTrolls:
    Your beloved MSFT is presently sitting at $31.10, all the way up from $30.50 six months ago. You’re right; that’s something to revel in.”

    Well now, let’s see, FanBoy:

    2 weeks ago all the fanboys were running around here spouting that Apple had sold 500,000 – 700,000 phones the opening weekend. Some of your predicted maybe a million….

    Welcome to iPhone, Apple’s answer to the Zune.

  14. Ah, the stupidity of the day-trader.

    Consider this: Most people buying their phone on the Saturday would have been out for the whole day, started to charge their phones when they got back home in the mid-afternoon, and then get ready to go out on Saturday evening only activating on a Sunday morning.

    Also, they obviously didn’t read the really important bit: 40% of activations were new to AT&T!

    If that carried on for the first 3 million units which Apple allegedly had in stock for launch, that’s 1.2 million units which may be paying Apple $11 a month for the next two years and the other 1.8 million units will pay $3: where I come from, that’s $223 million dollars per year for the next two years in near-pure profit.

    Normally to generate that kind of money, Apple would have to sell about a million Macs.

  15. Didn’t Cramer TELL you to sell “some” of your shares yesterday? Not out of “lack of confidence”, but so you could buy them back cheaper “real quick”? Yes, he DID! Didn’t he. And so many of you made “Poo-poo” noises in his direction.
    Points made:
    a) technical problems slowed activations
    b) many charged their new iPhones overnight before activating
    c) the stock CAME BACK

    DLMeyer – the Voice of G.L.Horton’s Stage Page Pod-Cast

  16. @Wintroll

    Not to make you seem more stupid than your idiotic posts already does, but it was not “fanboys” who were throwing around 500k-1mil in iPhone sales. No, no.. it was analysts. Now, try and say it with me me analysts. Don’t forget to sound it out an-al-ists. There, that’s a good little mutant.

  17. Considering that EVERY AT&T location was SOLD-OUT of iPhones after Friday and nearly all Apple locations were SOLD-OUT after Sunday, this number is indeed very misleading… Also Apple store on-line orders are not included..

    There is no doubt in my mind that Apple sold AT LEAST 250,000 iPhones through Saturday.

  18. iPhone doesn’t have to just beat Motorola Q sales. (I’m not aware that Motorola’s stock ramped up as much as AAPL in anticipation of the Q’s and iPhone’s launches, respectively.) iPhone has to beat expectations of what the market had expected iPhone sales to be. It’s because the market – and many people on this board – have expected 700,000 or a million sales in the first 2-3 days of sales that the stock has run up as fast as it has.

    Some good points were made by readers, e.g. some people charged their iPhone over night, thus delaying activation. Also, the point about gift giving delaying activation. Also, the delays in activation due to technical difficulties. Do these things explain the difference between 146,000 activations and what we had been expecting? We’ll see.

  19. iPhone doesn’t have to just beat Motorola Q sales. (I’m not aware that Motorola’s stock ramped up as much as AAPL in anticipation of the Q’s and iPhone’s launches, respectively.) iPhone has to beat expectations of what the market had expected iPhone sales to be. It’s because the market – and many people on this board – have expected 700,000 or a million sales in the first 2-3 days of sales that the stock has run up as fast as it has.

    Some good points were made by readers, e.g. some people charged their iPhone over night, thus delaying activation. Also, the point about gift giving delaying activation. Also, the delays in activation due to technical difficulties. Do these things explain the difference between 146,000 activations and what we had been expecting? We’ll see.

  20. iPhone doesn’t have to just beat Motorola Q sales. (I’m not aware that Motorola’s stock ramped up as much as AAPL in anticipation of the Q’s and iPhone’s launches, respectively.) iPhone has to beat expectations of what the market had expected iPhone sales to be. It’s because the market – and many people on this board – have expected 700,000 or a million sales in the first 2-3 days of sales that the stock has run up as fast as it has.

    Some good points were made by readers, e.g. some people charged their iPhone over night, thus delaying activation. Also, the point about gift giving delaying activation. Also, the delays in activation due to technical difficulties. Do these things explain the difference between 146,000 activations and what we had been expecting? We’ll see.

  21. iPhone doesn’t have to just beat Motorola Q sales. (I’m not aware that Motorola’s stock ramped up as much as AAPL in anticipation of the Q’s and iPhone’s launches, respectively.) iPhone has to beat expectations of what the market had expected iPhone sales to be. It’s because the market – and many people on this board – have expected 700,000 or a million sales in the first 2-3 days of sales that the stock has run up as fast as it has.

    Some good points were made by readers, e.g. some people charged their iPhone over night, thus delaying activation. Also, the point about gift giving delaying activation. Also, the delays in activation due to technical difficulties. Do these things explain the difference between 146,000 activations and what we had been expecting? We’ll see.

  22. The true test will be tomorrow when Apple tells us how many iPhones were SOLD.

    If the figure is disappointing, it’s all the more reason to expand the iPhone family by the end of this year. Even if it means the introduction of a new high end 3G model that will upset the early adopters.

  23. duh I expected 135 to 140 thousand units the first two days. Apple only has 165 stores, and AT&T has 1800. iPhone was not available anywhere else.

    there’s no way less than 2000 stores could have moved 500k (and more) iPhones as had been speculated.

  24. Isn’t that one day and a those fews hours after 6pm on the 29th. It’s hard to tell how many iphones actually went out the door in this 1.5 days. I would wait for actual sales in the first month to get a feeling for how the iphone is doing.

  25. Speaking of stupidity, why would you charge your iPhone before activating? They came fully charged – duh.

    Most people out all day don’t get home before midnight? Perhaps. But not those who rushed to the Apple store first thing in the morning to purchase their precious.

  26. “@Wintroll
    Not to make you seem more stupid than your idiotic posts already does, but it was not “fanboys” who were throwing around 500k-1mil in iPhone sales. No, no.. it was analysts. Now, try and say it with me me analysts. Don’t forget to sound it out an-al-ists. There, that’s a good little mutant.”

    Yeah, everyone is stupid except you. And I’m “Anal” too…

    Why not go back and read some of the post that have been posted here the last few weeks before blabbering about things you know nothing about…

    Wooooo Hooooo Steve!!!!! Apple has changed the game!!!! Blackberry is Toast!!!!! LG is toast!!!!!! Nokia is Toast!!!! MS Is TOAST!!! They’re all SCARED!!!!

    Scared of 146,000 phones that cost $5-600 and who Steve himself has said are “Good enough”..

  27. This story highlights IMO the problem with basing news reports on internet hype, rumors, and irresponsible blogging. After the first couple of days of coverage of the iPhone launch weekend, it was a given that any numbers released that were lower than what was rumored in the media would bring Apple’s stock price down. The product simply can’t live up to that kind of hype.

    You guys are actually pissed that Apple may or may not have missed a rumored sales benchmark after two days of sales? There are 3 benchmarks that are important to me:

    1. First week sales
    2. Quarterly sales
    3. Holiday sales

    Everything else simply isn’t that big a deal IMO.

  28. By all accounts, AT&T stores were only entrusted with a small handful of iPhones to sell. If you monitor the Apple website, you notice that their stores are resupplied with iPhones EVERY DAY. In other words, they are doled out small quantities of iPhones every day, to create the illusion of more demand than supply. They could have just dumped thousands of iPhones into every branch on the first day, but that wouldn’t have manufactured hype as well.

  29. June 29th and June 30th. 2 days is really 1 and 1/4 days.

    Sales did not begin until 6pm on the 29th.

    146,000 activations, On a weekend I would think many people would buy the phone at an Apple Store and might not activate it until Sunday or Monday. Why would I think that? Well people are often busy on the weekend with many things such as shopping, yard work and numerous other activities and would postpone digging into the nitty gritty of a new gadget until they had adequate time.

  30. Key word…

    Personally, I wouldn’t even get excited when AAPL announces tomorrow.

    In the world of the sane and reasonable, the first set of results that I’ll care about will be the ones that get issued after the end of the financial year in September; at that point, there’ll be a statistically valid set of data to base investment decisions on.

    If you’ll forgive the vaguely sexist analogy, if people pick their husbands/wives based on the way they play the market, it’s no surprise that the divorce rate is so high: anyone who gets married to a showgirl in Vegas whilst drunk only to wake up next to a pill-popping, gutter-mouthed trollop is probably the sort of person who makes investment decisions based on the sales performance of a product’s first 24 hours on Earth.

  31. I’ve followed this site, and plenty of READERS of MDN were predicting 700,000 or a million units sold in the first 2-3 days.

    There have been some good explanations for why the activations weren’t higher, but do they account for the entire shortfall below expectations? We’ll see.

  32. @Willie G / Wintroll,

    I’ll say it slowly so that even you can understand:

    The – number – of – ac-ti-va-tions – does – NOT – in-di-cate – the – number – of – sales.

    We’ll all find out soon enough tomorrow during Apple’s financial report how many iPhones actually sold.

  33. Read and weep; the Apple discussions, that is.

    I sense that the iPhone’s software is not yet ready for prime time. Where’s the update, already. Even a useful user manual would be helpful.

    AT&T shouldn’t be charging for data, either.

    Rational people have been given good reasons to be cautious about an early iPhone purchase.

    And the silence is deafening.

  34. Being in the UK, I wouldn’t know that iPhones come fully charged.

    Even so, I wouldn’t activate it until I’d given it my first charge – because I don’t trust anyone or anything – and I certainly wouldn’t activate a phone on a Saturday, when I might need to stay in touch with people on a Saturday evening and there might be a screw-up (see my point about not trusting anyone).

    If it were me, it would wait until I was having my croissants, bagels and coffee on a Sunday morning safe in the knowledge that nobody ever calls me on a Sunday.

    Duh!

  35. Best point yet:

    “You guys are actually pissed that Apple may or may not have missed a rumored sales benchmark after two days of sales?”

    By the way, is it just me, or has MDN become THE WORLD’S SLOWEST WEB SITE?

    PS: The stock has mostly recovered already, so what’s the big deal?

  36. Now that you state your fallacy more slowly, it’s soooo much more persuasive. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” /> So there’s no correlation between activations and sales? You’re obviously a lot smarter than me.

  37. How can I be getting personal – I don’t know who you are and I was responding to someone else and I did say “forgive me for the analogy”.

    My, we’re a little thin-skinned, aren’t we?

  38. <snicker…>

    “iPhone has to beat expectations of what the market had expected iPhone sales to be. It’s because the market – and many people on this board – have expected 700,000 or a million sales in the first 2-3 days of sales that the stock has run up as fast as it has.”

    Yes, it’s true. The iPhone will only be a success in the eyes of Wall Street if it meets the tough expectations set by internet chatroom blog posts. Any responsible economist knows this.

    >.<

  39. Wait till tomorrow when we get Apples numbers. They are going to be huge. In the mean time all you little girls who want to whine about these numbers, go ahead and sell all your shares. This stock is going up tomorrow after the real numbers come out.

  40. Response to…

    BTW, nobody’s saying there’s no corrrelation.

    The point is there’s obviously a delayed correlation, because people have to get home and actually do the deed.

    If you can’t see that point, you’re obviously a troll.

  41. The ATT store where I bought mine had received 50 the first day and it is a small store in CA – so if you do the math that All ATT stores got at least 50 phones X 1800 stores sold out that is 90,000 phones sold the first day.. add the Apple stores to that and the ATT numbers might be right but not bad for a new product.

  42. @ Cedric Lane

    No, it was an anonymous source within AT&T that reported 1 million activations in the first week. Playing fast and loose with the facts like this is what gets us into these situations in the first place.

  43. “Are you not aware of why AAPL has run up almost every day…”

    Of course not, I never look at that stock. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”raspberry” style=”border:0;” />

    Are YOU not aware of what I said yesterday?

    “A nine dollar drop is barely a blip to me, percentage wise, but such volatility is VERY common for AAPL, and if you can’t handle it I suggest you sell all your shares and get out for good.” – ChrissyOne, Jul 23, 07 – 05:31 pm

  44. Roughly 1,800 ATT Stores: Approx. 60 iPhones per store for first two days, equaling 108,000 iPhones sold.

    Apple: Approx. 165 US stores: 500 iPhones sold per store, qualing 82,500 iPhones sold.

    With strong sales numbers, Apple and ATT combined to sell around 190,000 or so iPhones in the first two days. This isn’t rocket science it’s simple math, yet the analysts were way off the mark – some by over double!!!

    Probably 20,000 – 30,000 iPhones were not yet registered on the first two days due to ATT’s network issues, buying them as gifts, etc…

    How elastic is this $500 and $600 iPhone market with a minimum $60 a month plan? Possibly not very…

    If a 3G chip can be delivered to meet Apple’s battery life and size specifications, a November launch is likely. Add this to a $100 lower price point with 3 models ($399 4GB, $499 8GB, $599 12GB), and iPhone could again take off with strong Christmas sales.

  45. AAAAAAGGGGGGHHHHHHhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!

    Please . . . .. Apple users . . .. ignore these Microsoft (and anti-Apple) fanboys. They know the crap that they use is just that . . . . crap. These MS fanboys come here to gloat that Apple is not way bigger than MS, that Apple products are not PERFECT, that — ah crap, just junk of all kinds.

    Ignore them. Do not even try to reply. No answer will satisify them cause they do not use Apple are are happy, they use PC and hate their MS existance. You cannot answer them as they live in another weird and sadistic existance. PERIOD.

    Apple users do not hate PC users, only being forced to use PC software and hardware. (well, OK we have a few wierd people here, but that is everywhere. 🙁 )

    Any posting that tries to point out how Apple is crashing cause:
    Steve showed up at an event,
    Steve did not show up at an event,
    Apple stock rose,
    Apple stock dropped,
    People liked the iPhone – iMac – iPod,
    Some weird person hates Apple yet buys all their products so they can return them,
    etc, etc, etc . . . . . . .

    I just say to them . . “Bite me” and then ignore their responce. Period.

    Later,
    en

  46. Cedric Lane,

    correct me if my memory isn’t serving me well, but wasn’t that an unofficial leak from someone who claimed to work at AT&T?

    But I hope it’s correct. If Apple announces over a million sold in the near future, AAPL will shoot back up.

  47. So, let’s see,I order my iphone online from the Apple store. Shipping takes several days. How do I activate before the quarter ends?
    Common sense seems to indicate there should be at least a “few” more sales than were currently counted for in ATT activations!

  48. I think it’s a little premature to say that sales of the iPhone have been disappointing. Many people–myself included–couldn’t purchase their iPhones the first couple of days that they went on sale because we don’t live in large cities with Apple or AT & T stores (that carried the iPhone). Also, I didn’t activate mine for a week because I was waiting for my Verizon contract to expire. We’ll find out soon enough how successful this launch was on Wednesday.

  49. “Now that you state your fallacy more slowly, it’s soooo much more persuasive. So there’s no correlation between activations and sales? You’re obviously a lot smarter than me.

    Obviously I am.

    1. As MCCFR stated, nobody said there was no correlation between sales and activations. Buy some glasses.

    2. AT&T’s activation figures were based on activity on Friday and Saturday or roughly 1 1/2 days of actual sales; the fiscal quarter ended on Saturday. Care to venture a guess how many people activated their iPhones on Sunday?

    3. AT&T’s numbers don’t reflect sales of the iPhone during the same period through Apple’s Online Store, who obviously had to wait to get their phone before they could activate it.

    4. AT&T already publicly said that initial sales of the iPhone have already topped those of the RAZR in it’s first month, which is the best selling mobile phone in history.

    5. One thing you can’t leave out: the number of people who probably didn’t get until much later that you need the latest version of iTunes to even activate the iPhone.

    The reality is the actual iPhone sales numbers will be a lot higher than AT&T’s 1 1/2 day activation numbers. If you’re going to troll, practice more beforehand.

  50. As several have pointed out, the quarter didn’t include Sunday, and so we’re leaving out about half of the weekend when comparing against projected figures for weekend sales.

    Also, it’s worth mentioning that a lot of people ordered their iPhones online at the Apple Store website. None of these end-of-quarter online sales would show up as ATT end-of-quarter activations.

    I think the ATT number is perfectly compatible with 500,000 or more sales in the first weekend.

  51. People, people….

    The iPhone went on sale at 18:00 on 6/29. The quarter ended at 23:59 on 6/30. That’s a 30-hour window, rounding up to the nearest minute.

    Now, let’s assume that all Apple and AT&T stores stayed open until midnight on Friday, and opened at 08:00 on Saturday (which, of course, most didn’t, but this is a “worst case” scenario.) So, that’s 8 hours out of our 30-hour sales window.

    The upshot is that Apple & AT&T sold AT LEAST 146,000 phones in 22 hours of sales. By any measure, that’s remarkable. If we extend that to the whole weekend, it’s no inconceivable that they hit well over a quarter-million sold on the weekend alone.

    I’d say that’s pretty darned good for a first showing from a newcomer to the phone business.

    MW: “least”, as in “T-Mobile is suddenly the least of Verizon’s problems”

  52. nice…. You seem to have a difficult time following the action, my mentally challenged compadre. What I was disputing was the claim that “fanboys” have been going around claiming sales figures of 500k, when in fact it has been analysts making such claims.

    I never said the “fanboys” weren’t going around making bold claims, merely that specific sales estimate numbers have been exclusive to analysts.

    And yes, I am well aware that activations do not equal sales, nor did I ever claim they did. It is amazing we continue to function when so many people have such a non-ability to pay attention to detail.

    You sadden me

  53. i bought my iphone online that first weekend and just received it and activated it yesterday. There’s gotta be a lot of people like me. The only reason i had to buy online was because all of the apple stores and at&t stores in austin were already sold out by saturday afternoon.

  54. 146 K iPhones activated in 2 days.
    ? iPhones bought but not activated
    ? iPhones bought ONLINE and not even delivered yet.

    For comparison:
    Rim sold 2.4 million Blackberrys in their last quarter.
    That’s 52.7 K in two days. WORLDWIDE

    Palm sold 0.75 million Treos
    That’s 16.5 K in two days. WORLDWIDE

  55. Those against Apple will take this or anything else as bad regardless, but the facts are:
    ATT earnings are up 61%
    ATT is also stated: “Sales of the iPhone continue to be strong in July with store traffic above historical levels”
    and most importantly, we do not have final sales figures from Apple. In any case the stock is coming back up so…

  56. Reality check time, folks.

    Some random thoughts on the “bombshell” from AT&T. And no matter how we try to spin this, these figures, if they turn out to be the actual sales figures, will be a major disappointment.

    In cold hard stats, 146,000 in sales is not bad at all for the first two days of any product. But with the hype that was generated, the lines that were formed outside stores, the amount of ink and airtime the iPhone got, this would be a major letdown.

    Perception is, unfortunately, often reality. A movie that makes $90 million has every right to be considered a roaring success. But the perception is that any movie that does not cross the $100 million mark is considered a failure these days.

    And I would put the blame squarely at the door of Apple and, to a lesser extent, AT&T for not moving quickly and in a timely fashion to dispel what may turn out to be overblown speculation about how many units were actually sold at launch.

    If the 146,000 figure turns out to be the sales figure, then these companies should have quickly dampened the 500,000 and over sales speculation that became accepted as fact, in large part because Apple and AT&T did not deny it.

    They were not obligated to do so, but if this sales figure holds true during Apple’s quarterly call tomorrow, the damage to the company’s reputation as the highest high-flyer may be more than passing.

    If nothing else, the aura of invincibility will be shattered.

    The iPhone is not, and will not, become a failure. It is too good a product to not eventually become a roaring success. But if the initial sales are equal to the announced activations, it will leave a lingering bad taste, and perennial suspicion about how future offerings will actually fare.

    I don’t even want to speculate on what the Balmers, Enderles, Dvoraks and Lauras of the world are going to do. They must be gleefully practising their dance steps.

    I still harbor the suspicion that the AT&T announcement is meant to be a tricky teaser before Apple lifts the gloom tomorrow with an astounding sales figure, but I also have a nagging feeling that that’s a long shot.

  57. Now I see why AT&T had server and activation problems (pushing A LOT of people to Monday). 150,000 activations in two days is brutal to the system, regardless what major Telecom company you are.

    That’s a huge bump in 52 new activations pre minute….with weekends staffing….

    Ahh anywise, I think next quarter will set the record straight.

  58. @ Doubletrouble

    I sense that the iPhone’s software is not yet ready for prime time. Where’s the update, already. Even a useful user manual would be helpful.

    You sense? Alright Obi-Wan, good luck with that. For those of us with an iPhone it’s clear as day that the software rules.

    Also, there is a 90+ page user manual that you can download at Apple.com, so maybe check your facts next time, or, I dunno, ask.

    Finally, when the first software update comes out it will add functionality. Apple is waiting until the roar from the unveiling dies down so they can ride another wave of, “Amazing!”

  59. Don’t forget, any Windows users who bought iPhones had to wait for Windows to boot up before they could activate their iPhones.

    Cheap shot, I know, but I thought the tone of this discussion was becoming too reasonable and civilized.

  60. Yeah, Apple is big enough that when their stock falls, the index falls! They went up $25 in a month, then when it falls $6 based on partial information, everybody goes nuts. It will come back up tomorrow when Apple tells their side of the story.

    Microsoft went down a greater percentage of value in the last two or three days, and it’s not even news. Go figure!

  61. I bet Apple will not even reveal the total number of iPhone sales beyond the 2 days remaining in that quarter. So we still will not know how well the iPhone has done in the first near month of sales.

    While the number of activations seems low…. it still is a ton of units. iPhone is a rev 1 device that many are waiting until rev 2 comes out… it is Apples first run at a cell phone making some even more anxious about buying rev 1. So, while these numbers are lower then the pie in the sky numbers people shot out after opening weekend… they are still not bad.

    I will admit that I had the knee jerk reaction that the number of activations was low, after thinking about it I came to my senses and realized, that is a lot of phone activations for 2 days.. and if my math is correct, and low-ball assuming only 500.00 per phone… that is 73 MILLION dollars is sales for 2 days (based off activations).

    The Dude abides.

  62. The Dude…

    If only your numbers were valid, but – under the 24-month accounting process that AAPL is adopting for TV and iPhone – they will (if I understood the statement correctly) either realise only 1/8th of the 73 million or (even worse) 1/24th which probably equates to a figure of around either $10.5 million or $3.5 million.

    Personally, I was only ever expecting a realisation of $12 million based on the 1/8th model – because I was working on the basis that Apple were prepared to release only about 800,000 units for the first weekend and hold back more stock so there’d be availability during the July 4th holiday week – so I don’t see how a $1.5 million shortfall justifies the ridiculous over-reaction of a $7.6 billion drop in market cap.

    That said, a lot of people took a bath today – including Research In Motion – and all things are cyclical; the stock will still be at $160 by the end of the year and that’s the only thing that matters.

  63. Like “R” said:”Key word: activated.” Besides, is there another smart phone that sold 146,000 units in 2 days?

    You can bet At&T looked for the best number possible and would have counted everyone in the system who had an activation in progress.

    “Early adopters would be too excited to postpone activation.”

    Correct, there’s no way any significant number of people who waited in line for hours for an iPhone didn’t try to activate it that day.

    ” wouldn’t activate it until I’d given it my first charge – because I don’t trust anyone or anything”

    And you’d put it on charge and within minutes you’d see it was fully charged. Then activate it, right?

    “The true measure would be how many iphones were sold.”

    Yet when it comes to Vista, apaprently MDN readers think the true measue would be the number activated. Get some consistency!

    “In other words, they are doled out small quantities of iPhones every day, to create the illusion of more demand than supply.”

    Not likely. Check the availability tonight. What you will see is a situation which indicates that almost all Apple stores have the phones in stock and if you could look back at it, you’d see they have for some time. That points to one thing, an excess of supply over demand.

  64. These activations go on credit cards right? Buy something on Saturday afternoon and it goes on your account when? I have a feeling those 146,000 were the phones activated Friday night, with may a few from Saturday morning.

  65. Stock falls–greedy bastards–lettem I’ll take the money. “gee we were looking for 200,000–200.000?!?!?!? in 48 hours?!?!?!?! how greedy and unrealistic can you get?! I guess all you analysts need another speed boat to water ski behind?!?huh?!?? I can’t stand these guys, they make nothing, they create nothing, the sit on their fat (very fat) asses and chide anybody who doesn’t “measure up” or “disappoints” you people suck
    BTW 146,000X600 = $87,600,000 gee I guess if I only produced that for my boss in 48 hours I would probably get fired

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.