
“When movies shifted from videocassettes to DVD, retailers simply cleared the tapes off the shelves to make room for discs. That’s not so easy now that movies appear poised to follow music onto the Internet,” Joshua Freed reports for The Associated Press.
Freed reports, “The number of DVDs sold grew 5 percent last year, but that was down from a 9 percent increase during the previous year. Selling prices for both music and movies have declined. And NPD said DVD sales would have slid faster if not for the growth of TV programs offered on DVD.”
“Even if movie and music downloads don’t drive shoppers into stores, they at least keep retailers like Best Buy in the movie and music business,” Freed reports. “Wal-Mart Stores Inc. is the farthest along after selling 3,000 movie downloads in its first month, February.”
MacDailyNews Take: Bzzzt! Try again, Josh. Apple is farthest along, not Wal-Mart. Wal-Mart’s not even in the game compared to Apple. For perspective, something this AP reporter and report obviously lack, at the rate reported, it would take Wal-Mart 3.5 years to equal Apple’s first week of movie download sales. Apple sold over 1.3 million movies in the first 3 months and has been selling for approximately 7 months so far. Wal-Mart would only be “farthest along” if Apple had stopped selling movie downloads after 3 months and Wal-Mart continued at their current rate for the next 8 1/3rd years. Not putting Apple’s sales into the article is shoddy reporting, due to incompetence or by intent, that fails to provide important context and pertinent information for the reader. Related articles:
Fortune: Apple Inc. is America’s best retailer – March 08, 2007
Disney film sales via Apple’s iTunes Store rise sharply; over 1.3 million sold in first three months – February 02, 2007
Disney sells nearly 500,000 movies via Apple’s iTunes Store in less than two months – November 09, 2006
Disney sells 125,000 movie downloads via Apple’s iTunes Store in first week – September 19, 2006
Freed continues, “Meanwhile, some online businesses already have tech-savvy customers. Netflix Inc., the online-only service that ships DVDs through the mail, is rolling out a streaming-movie option. And of course there’s Apple, which has begun selling movies at its iTunes store online. Video-on-demand from cable offers another option for avoiding a trip to the store. Amazon.com Inc. offers downloadable movies that can be sent to your TiVo, and Microsoft Corp.’s XBox Live marketplace does, too, some of them in high definition.”
Full article here.
We eagerly await Joshua Freed’s next article for The Associated Press which will explore the soft drink industry while barely mentioning Coca-Cola and incorrectly crediting Fred’s Cola as industry leader.
Last week The Associated Press issued an Apple TV hit piece laden with conjecture and now this, which will also be syndicated to hundreds of media outlets. What exactly is going on here, AP?
Contact:
Related article:
Laptop Mag reviews Apple TV: ‘The best digital media adapter yet,’ 4.5 out of 5 stars – April 06, 2007
RUMOR: Apple TV team prepping update with new ‘Net-centric features – April 05, 2007
Additional Apple TV models coming? – April 05, 2007
AP writer criticizes Apple TV video quality – April 04, 2007
Apple TV USB support is now enabled via hack – March 30, 2007
Digit hands-on with Apple TV: ‘simple to set up, a delight to use’ – March 29, 2007
Newsweek: Apple TV has a lot going for it – March 29, 2007
Apple overriding Apple TV hacks? – March 29, 2007
Hacking Apple TV: Joost successfully run on Apple TV – March 28, 2007
Apple TV software hints at future DVR functions? – March 28, 2007
Ten Apple TV myths – March 28, 2007
Ars Technica in-depth review: Apple TV ‘impressed all those who touched it’ – March 27, 2007
The chips inside Apple TV – March 27, 2007
Analyst: Apple TV is a platform, not a single product – March 27, 2007
Digital Trends reviews Apple TV: 7 out of 10, ‘huge phenomenon will challenge conventional thinking’ – March 26, 2007
Automatically convert video files for Apple TV with Apple’s Automator – March 26, 2007
Apple TV, iTunes, iTunes Store: BusinessWeek’s Wildstrom blows it – March 26, 2007
iLounge gives Apple TV a ‘B’ in hands-on review: ‘recommended’ – March 24, 2007
CNET reviews Apple TV: ‘Very Good’ – 7.7 out of 10 – March 24, 2007
Video: Apple TV menu and interface walkthrough – March 23, 2007
Analyst: Apple TV will change the TV business – March 23, 2007
G4’s ‘Attack of the Show’ host Olivia Munn licks Apple TV – March 23, 2007
Xvid fully functional on Apple TV – March 23, 2007
Apple TV does not require Widescreen TV or HDTV, works with standard TVs – March 23, 2007
CBS looks at Apple TV on ‘The Early Show’ (with video) – March 23, 2007
Scoble: ‘Apple TV rocks’ – March 23, 2007
Apple TV hard drive upgrade works – March 23, 2007
Apple TV dissection photos – March 22, 2007
Apple posts Apple TV User’s Guide online – March 22, 2007
Enderle: ‘Apple’s attractive and well packaged Apple TV likely to set the pace’ – March 22, 2007
David Pogue demos Apple TV in humorous NY Times’ video – March 22, 2007
PC Magazine review gives Apple TV 4 out of 5 stars – March 22, 2007
NY Times’ Pogue: ‘Apple TV offers a gracious, elegant, effortless, delightful experience’ – March 21, 2007
Mossberg hands-on with Apple TV: ‘beautiful design, easy-to-use, classic Apple: simple and elegant’ – March 21, 2007
Apple TV projected to surpass TiVo, Netflix – March 20, 2007
Former Microsoft ‘Enthusiast Evangelist’ Gartenberg looks at impact of Apple TV – March 20, 2007
Apple TV ships – March 20, 2007
The article seems to emphasize the efforts of brick-and-mortar retailers. Sure it would’ve been nice to get analysts to quote on Apple, Inc.’s efforts, but we’re talking about some writer on a deadline. Anything about the iTunes store would require more comprehensive coverage. For Josh’s editors, what we read here suffices. When more movie studios adopt the iTunes sales model, and when more Apple TV capabilities are unleashed, we will read more about how Apple will dominate the currently infant movie download market.
Referring to the first MDN take: it appears to me that the AP writer is referring to retail stores (the sell DVDs) that are now moving into the downloads business. This doesn’t apply to Apple so they shouldn’t be mentioned here.
That’s far from blowing it. Apple just happens not to apply in the context the author is writing.
The point of the article is to look at what traditional and large-scale DVD/CD brick and mortar retailers are doing in regards to downloadable movies. They are already in trouble in music due to Apple/ITS eating away at CD sales. And that will only get much worse. Apple is a retailer, but it is not a broad consumer electronics/DVD/appliance etc. chain like those mentioned (Wal-Mart, Best Buy, etc). That’s why they get less ink. That said…
I do fault the writer for not saying how well Apple or even Microsoft are doing, which would have made his story much more informative to average readers (consumers) and chain execs and employees (A better hook: “Non-tradtional retailer Apple and software giant and Xbox 360 maker Microsoft are leading the movie download revoultion. Wal-Mart and other tradtional brick-and-mortar chains that dominate physical CD and DVD sales today are not even in the game. Once again, those who owned the market for content distribution are going to lose it, just like they did with music.”).
AP articles are just so slanted that I don’t even read them anymore
Unless a reader were deeply knowledgeable about the movie download business and knew about Apple’s efforts in this area, this article would be deeply misleading. Those claiming that this article focuses on the entry of brick and mortar retailers in this business are wrong in excusing it. Selective or poorly written reporting can be just as misleading as straight out inaccuracies. Any normal reader will conclude that Wal-Mart is the leader in the nascent movie download industry, not just among brick and mortar retailers. Since AP articles are carried by literally thousands of newspapers across the country, we should expect more from them than an article that wouldn’t be up to the standards of a good college paper.
More like MDN blows it with their misinterpration of the article.
I think the problem is that many people are having a difficult time adjusting thier paradigm to the fact that Apple is a LEADER in many industries rather than just a low market share PC maker struggling to survive.
Welcome to Steve’s Bank. I’ve got your money in a safe place – right here, in my left, front pocket!
You didn’t read the article very well MDN. And Freed didn’t write it very well either. But his point is that big box retailers with businesses of established retailr DVD sales are toying with movie downloads. He segregates Netflix and Apple and others that are “tech savvy” into a group that isn’t included. But he threw them a bone.
Very poorly written. Most journalism 101 students would have made his point more clearly. This guy must be a part-time writer. Maybe he’s a comedian who doesn’t want to be a waiter? 😀
He’s a bozo, and MDN is a bit of a bozo for giving him attention.
S.
The AP are liars, they have always been liars and will always be liars.
Most newspapers are just copy machines for the AP.
They never get contested so they say whatever they want.
Nice editorial staff MDN has working for them.
Next time: read, then jerk knee.
MDN is, of course, devastatingly correct.
One can lie by omission. AP is trying to minimize Apple’s role in the very industry this article purports to cover while inflating Wal-Mart’s role to an insane degree.
Anyone who can’t see that is mentally deficient.
Money changed hands here, as is usually the case with the AP.
. . . but we’re talking about some writer on a deadline.
So what? A deadline is as much of an excuse for errors as the dog ate my homework. Every news story is written before a deadline.
“The AP apologizes for stating that the sun went nova, California floated out to sea and the Zune surpassed the iPod in sales. The stories had been written on a deadline.”
Since when did iTunes become a retail store? Read the article again MDN.
Including headline, the article says the word RETAILERS 10 times.
Yep. MDN just blew it this time. I love ’em but they are just wrong.
This article is clearly meant to be about how physical retail chains are dealing with the move to digital media.
There is no reason iTunes should be mentioned here.
Allen,
The iTunes Store became a retail store the day it opened.
For those of you trying to defend the article, this is hardly different from Microsoft claiming to be the number two supplier of 30 GB Hard drive based mp3 players. Both are technically correct, yet completely irrelevant to the truth of the market. Wallmart isn’t even close to the number one one line seller of video – as the article leads people to believe – and MS is far from being number two with mp3 players.
You can’t honestly write about downloading movies without talking about the iTunes store any more than you can honestly claim that the Zune is number two in the market.
Chris, okay you’re right, iTunes is a retail store, but it is NOT a brick and mortar retail store which is what the article is talking about..
Im going to have to go with MDN here.. the AP story is shoddy and leaving out Apple makes it pointless to write a story about music or movie sales moving onto the internet.
What is this, “Retard Day?”
You will note that MacDailyNews included the article, “Fortune: Apple Inc. is America’s best retailer – March 08, 2007,” in their related articles list for a reason.
Newsflash: Apple is a brick and mortar retailer.
Apple is also an internet retailer that OWNS the market about which this AP pile of crap supposedly reports.
MDN correctly busts AP.
AP sounds like they’re on the take from Microsoft.
Retard day? Um no… The Apple store is a brick and mortar shop, but the iTunes store is NOT.
“One can lie by omission. AP is trying to minimize Apple’s role in the very industry this article purports to cover while inflating Wal-Mart’s role to an insane degree.
Anyone who can’t see that is mentally deficient.”
There’s a horde of mentally deficient people on this board here.. “read the article MDN” I read the article its junk. It’s minimization of Apple’s roll and hyperinflation of Best Buy and Walmart’s roll would be criminal if these were legal proceedings.
The article is worse than worthless with this level of white washing it borders on paid for propaganda.
Apple is as much a brick and mortar retailer as is Walmart, especially when it comes to downloading movies. You can’t download a movie from Walmart in the store, but with the wifi access at Apple, you very well could.
Wow, it appears Walmart’s video downloading is less brick and mortar than Apple. Who would have thunk it?
Allen,
Wal-Mart is a brick and mortar retailer trying and failing to sell downloads online.
Apple is a brick and mortar retailer actually selling vast quantities of downloads online.
Get it, yet, poster child for “Retard Day?”
Cpt. Oblivious,
Including headline, the article says the word RETAILERS 10 times.
Did Apple shut down their rapidly growing worldwide network of 170+ retail stores or are you just a knee-jerk moron?
Amazing how people are trying to defend this article nit picking how Apple’s retail stores are not the “type” of Brick n Mortar the article cherry picks out so it can totally ignore Apple’s online presence.
Frankly if Apple had no retail stores this article would be just as bogus. Its overwhelmingly dominant presence in the internet media delivery space dwarfs Walmart and Best Buy and all the other also-rans-that-never-were.
That they specifically mention the amount of downloads that the “market leader Walmart” has sold without mentioning Apple’s numbers is just.. its not defensible. Period.
There’s plenty of times MDN is off base, but they nailed this one. Sorry.
MDN sounds like a man with a small penis and a massive complex about it. Don’t dare say question or slight my manhood (that would be Apple), or I’ll blindly lash out with no reason or thought behind the off base “editorial”.
Amused.. I think you fit your description well. You’re poking fun at MDN for lashing out, without thought.. and yet.. you do it yourself!
Hmmm…
The article was bogus, the omission of Apple was unjustifiable.. and MDN was correct to point it out.
The whole point for the existence of this website is to point out flaws in media coverage which has had a very long history of FUD regarding Apple. If you’re not aware of that fact, apparently you didn’t bother to read this:
“Our mission is to scour the Web for articles that interest Mac and Apple product users, remark on the content of these articles, provide news about Apple Computer, Inc. and their products, and to opine about all things related to Apple and the Mac.
Most importantly, MacDailyNews exists to provide a place for our readers and the Mac community to discuss these daily news items in their own words with real-time feedback.
Why do we do this? Because long ago we received the most important advice a computer user can ever receive, “Get a Mac.” We want to help spread that valuable advice.”
http://macdailynews.com/index.php/weblog/contact/
What exactly is the point of your post?
“Amazing how people are trying to defend this article nit picking how Apple’s retail stores are not the “type” of Brick n Mortar the article cherry picks out so it can totally ignore Apple’s online presence.”
———————–
It’s not that they are ignoring Apple’s online presence, it’s just that the article is not meant to be about online presence. It’s written about how standard brick and mortar shops are dealing with the growing presence of digital downloads.. Apple/iTunes store’s never sold physical dvd’s like Wal-mart and Best Buy do, so Apple is not in the same boat. I think many are way over reacting to this article and it’s intent.
MDN is right, of course,
Did Apple shut down their rapidly growing worldwide network of 170+ retail stores or are you just a knee-jerk moron?
How was your trip to the iTunes store last weekend fucktard?
Allen,
Quick, you retard, the Special Olympics 10 yard dash is about to start! You’re going to miss it, just like the ‘tard that you are. Now, strap your helmet back on, stop banging on that keyboard, and get ready to run, you ignorant, retarded mongoloid. Only a true idiot can have something explained to them so clearly by multiple people and still fail to grasp the obvious. A normal kindergartner could get this, Allen, but you’re not even remotely close to normal, now are you?
The AP is the worst form of journalism, glossed over drive-by-media, there may have ever been.
Allen,
Then why even mention Wal Mart’s online sales? They dont give any context such as retail brick and mortar sales nor compare them to the 800 lb gorilla in the room Apple’s iTunes store.
There is a VERY clear implication in the story that Wal Mart is leading the charge into online sales, which is entirely verifiably wrong.
Compare this:
“Wal-Mart Stores Inc. is the farthest along after selling 3,000 movie downloads in its first month, February”
“And Apple Inc.’s simple buck-a-song pricing at its iTunes online store hasn’t caught on in the movie world, where purchase prices vary widely and many movies aren’t available at all. In many cases, movies bought online can’t be burned to a DVD.”
and
“And of course there’s Apple, which has begun selling movies at its iTunes store online.”
Why mention the “farthest along 3,000 movie downloads” Wal Mart store and gloss over Apple and or point out its flaws?
Nothing wrong with pointing out flaws, but they mention them in context of Apple and not Wal Mart, and mention the sales of Wal Mart but not Apple.
These are subtle but very clear and obvious forms of bias that anyone paying attention can recognize quickly. This article is an agenda driven hit piece bought by MS to marginalize Apple and pump up the MS based retail stores.
If you cannot see that I am unable to help you it’s plain as day.
Cpt. Obvious
“How was your trip to the iTunes store last weekend fucktard?”
Mr. Obvious.. it would see OBVIOUS to me that if you don’t have any point to make, then call someone a name.
By the way, when did you physically pay a visit to Wal Mart’s online store?
Keep trying, maybe you’ll eventually land on a valid point if you keep randomly flailing around.
Cpt. Oblivious,
How was your trip to the iTunes store last weekend fucktard?
I’l let you know a soon as you tell me how your trip to the Wal-Mart movie download store went, you supercilious moron.
Get it yet, dummy?
Spelled out for the IQ-deficient:
Apple has brick and mortar retail stores.
Wal-Mart has brick and mortar retail stores.
Apple has the vastly dominant online movie download store.
Wal-Mart has an online movie download store that cannot match Apple’s first week sales in 3.5 years.
The Associated Press describes Wal-Mart’s store as “the farthest along” in the online movie download business.
If you don’t see a problem with AP’s article, you must be a product of U.S. public schools.
Tired of retards,
Well if you consider regressing to name-calling and elementary school tactics when you can’t win an argument normal, then no, I’m not normal.. But I can tell you that if your above post is the best argument you can present, then there’s no point in me even trying as the concept appears to be beyond your grasp of understanding..
Allen,
Stop typing for a second and read the post above your 11:59am post from “MDN is right, of course.”
twilightmoon@mac.com, since the point of the article is about B&M movie sellers looking to sell online, NOT about iTunes who only sells online, then MDN zinging them for it is not relevant. But that is a common theme about this site. I come here because I am a recent switcher and like the legwork they do on finding articles on my new platform. However, the ridiculing of everything non-Apple gets old and hurts, not helps, getting more people to switch. MDN comes accross as petty far too often when it doesn’t need to. They simply reinforce the zealot stereotype of Mac users.
MDN is right, of course,
Click the link and read the full article..
If you do, you will understand that it is not an article about who is selling the largest amount of digital downloads.
Instead, it is an article about how brick and mortar shops like Circuit City, Best Buy and Wal-mart whom have been selling Cd’s and DVD’s for years are responding to the decline in foot traffic and physical media sales.. Apple’s iTunes store sales are not mentioned because Apples iTunes store is not dealing with a decline in foot traffic and physical media sales. Why? Because Apple’s iTunes store has never been a brick and mortar shop that used to sell physical media. It’s really simple..
Allen,
My post included quotes from the article, and no name calling of you whatsoever..
No hyperventilating whatsoever, just simply pointing out why you’re wrong about your take on this article and why you’re wrong to defend this hit piece. The title of the article and the focus of the article do not give them a free pass to make false, inaccurate, or misleading statements.
If they just want to mention that Wal Mart and Best Buy are moving online fine.. then don’t mention sales unless they include Wal Marts brick and mortar sales and compare them to Apples sales. At least that would not be misleading and disingenuous. And the fact that Wal Mart is the leader of the brick and mortar stores but is irrelevant since it is so far behind Apple.
Neither the title of the article, the general focus, nor the fact the writer is on a deadline take away from the clear bias evident in the article in favor of MS solution stores and against Apple’s iTunes store.
I stand firm in my conviction that this article is a hit piece designed to look like a news article and was paid for by Microsoft.
“If you don’t see a problem with AP’s article, you must be a product of U.S. public schools.”
Ain’t that the truth!
Apple never made a business of selling physical DVDs that it is now trying to migrate over to digital downloads. WHICH IS WHAT THE ARTICLE IS ABOUT.
Allen:
“Apple’s iTunes store sales are not mentioned because Apples iTunes store is not dealing with a decline in foot traffic and physical media sales. Why? Because Apple’s iTunes store has never been a brick and mortar shop that used to sell physical media. It’s really simple..”
Apparently I read the article better than you because Apple is mentioned.. not only once but twice. I even quoted both parts of the article where Apple was mentioned in an above post which you have made an effort to ignore.
Apparently facts and evidence about the clear bias of this article are too difficult for you to confront directly. I clearly read the article and I still claim its bias, the fact that you now claim Apple was not mentioned in the article makes me wonder if in fact YOU read it all the way through.
Go back and read the entire article, including the parts where Apple is mentioned and see if you still feel the same way you do now.
Twilightmoon,,
The title of the article is “Retailers look to benefit from movies online.” In the full article, retailers is described as standard B&M shops..
Cpt. Obvious
“Apple never made a business of selling physical DVDs that it is now trying to migrate over to digital downloads. WHICH IS WHAT THE ARTICLE IS ABOUT.”
No, thats only a portion of what the article is about.
“Wal-Mart Stores Inc. is the farthest along after selling 3,000 movie downloads in its first month, February.”
Mentioning this without context of the 800 lb Gorilla iTunes store? How do you justify this exactly? Calling Wal Mart the “furthest along” ? How is that not misleading.
The brick and mortar part doesn’t need to have Apple in it at all..
BUT..
The second part of the article is about DOWNLOAD sales.. there.. Apple is very relevant and that second half of the article is what MDN is calling them on, and I agree with them on that.
Imagine I gave you directions on how to get to someone’s house without mentioning that you’re walking through a mine field part of the way there.. sure my directions might be accurate.. and the point of me telling you directions was accounted for.. but the OMISSION of the mine field is an entirely relevant fact, not some irrelevant side issue.
Twilightmoon,
Yes, Apple is mentioned, but in regards to being increased competition for standard B&M shops.. It doesn’t change the fact that the article is about how these B&M shops are responding to a decline in physical sales. It’s not about which online retailer is selling the most downloads..
“How do you justify this exactly? Calling Wal Mart the “furthest along” ? How is that not misleading.”
—————–
It’s not misleading because Wal-mart is the furthest along of the B&M shops who’ve begun selling online.. Now if they said that Wal-mart was furthest along of all online sales then yes, it would be misleading, but that is not the point they are trying to make..
Jeez Louise, this is why some Apple fans get called names.
Drop the verbiage for a second and try to understand what the article is about. MDN clearly read throught the article quickly and missed the point entirely. As many of us did on the board.
The article is, very clearly, about how retailers who have depended on the sale of DVDs and CDs to lure customers into their stores are dealing with the move to digital downloads.
Apple has *never* sold DVD movies or CDs in its stores.
Apple has only ever sold songs, films, and iPod games via digital download.
This article is not in anyway relevant to what Apple does and, therefore, is not at fault for mentioning iTunes. You can’t write about Apple’s struggles to adapt to the digital download environment because they have *not struggled* in any way! They pioneered it and are amazingly successful.
Some of you guys take your support of Apple entirely too far.
I have no problem with the focus of the article.. no problem with them mentioning Wal Mart (that’s sort of a no duh).. I have a problem with them making misleading statements about hyper-inflating the relevance of the online Wal Mart movie store by implying its in the lead (which its not even close) and not mentioning Apple for some context.
If they want to just make the point of saying that B&M stores are moving online, then omit this line: “Wal-Mart Stores Inc. is the farthest along after selling 3,000 movie downloads in its first month” or edit it to include how they compare to Apple who is the Wal Mart of online digital stores.
As it currently stands, this article inaccurate and misleading. It’s fixable tho, if the point of the article is to inform and not to spread propaganda.
MDN word “half” as in half the truth is more often a lie.
It is not the obligation of every media outlet to give Apple a verbal blowjob when discussing any space that Apple operates in. Sure, Apple operates in the digital download arena. They were not, however, faced with the task of transitioning from physical DVD sales to digital ones.
I’m sorry the author of the article didn’t stroke Apple enough for your taste. There are much bigger and more relevant fish to fry than this guy.
Maybe some smart reporter not on a deadline can find out how many iTunes gift cards the Walmart chain sold this year in the same time frame. I know that the iTunes store is not brick and mortor but neither is the the movie dowlnoads store at Walmart. Does any body else sell Walmart download cards?
Cpt. Obvious
“I’m sorry the author of the article didn’t stroke Apple enough for your taste. There are much bigger and more relevant fish to fry than this guy.”
Okay I’ll grant you this one. We agree on something!
See, that wasn’t so hard, was it?
Are you sure that AP is part of the Fox News Network!
The point of the article is irrelevant. Until you can burn movie downloads onto a DVD, I don’t consider movies purchased from any of these services as actually being owned.
Lord, man.
Wal-Mart is farthest along of *stores that rely on selling DVDs* which is what the article is about! It isn’t a slam against Apple for God’s sake.
Seriously, I hope no sane human stumbles across this board. Not only will it reinforce stereotypes about Apple fans, it will make them think we can’t read.
Total knee jerk reaction. Reread the article. Read it charitably, not with a chip on your shoulder. The article is about the steps retailers like Walmart, Bestbuy, etc. are taking to deal with the loss of DVD sales. Some are trying to make up for that with an online presence. Apple is something entirely different.
The real problem with this article is that this is the Associated Press, not some wannabe blogger. This is a well-established source of mainstream news. Don’t you have to wonder how important good old-fashioned accuracy is to the AP when they get a simple story so incredibly wrong?
AP article refers to brick and mortar retail outlets. . .anyone with half a brain would realize that.
http://www.blackfriarsinc.com/blog/2007/04/itunes-store-data-proves-its-growth-is
Black Friar’s article (also linked on MDN front page):
“Remember Apple’s announcement that in the first week or so of movie sales, it sold 125,000 movies? Well, today’s Boston Globe reported the first month’s sales from Wal-mart’s online movie store were a whopping 3,000 movies. If we were to graph that on the log scale graph above, we’d need to add another decade of graph below where Apple numbers are just to see the Wal-mart sales.”
The point here is that such a huge gap between one and the other is significant aspect to their own story about B&M stores moving online. It’s not a different story about something else. The fact that Wal Mart, America’s largest retailer doesn’t even show up as a spec in Apple’s tail lights is important means to judge their relative success (or in this case lack of it).
Twilightmoon,
As others have said, you seem to be missing the point. The article is not comparing Wal-mart sales to iTunes sales. The article is comparing Wal-mart online sales to other brick and mortar retail outlets that sell physical dvd’s onlines sales. Big difference. You are trying to compare oranges to apples (no pun intended.)
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />
You are taking the statements about Wal-mart being ahead out of context with the whole point of the article.
We all know that iTunes is the overall leader of digital movie downloads. However, that is not the point.
Stop embarrassing yourselves, and this forum, with ill-informed mudslinging and name-calling.
Since this is an issue of the AP article’s credibility, please read the source article before commenting on it.
I would separate judgment about the writer’s journalism talent (average, not great) from an assessment of his article’s thesis.
And on that point, Allen is largely correct. A complete reading of Freed’s piece shows that MDN probably did oversimplify, at best, his main point.
Freed is writing about the impact on-line DVD sales have on the brick-and mortar retail stores that have used discount pricing of CDs and DVDs to drive foot traffic into their stores. Retailers such as Target, Best Buy, and Wal-Mart usually cut retail prices of music CDs and movies to cost or even below cost, willing to take little or negative profit on low-cost content sales in order to draw in more customers and increase chances of selling more volume of their other merchandise. For Best Buy, that means more high profit margin electronics gear. For Target and Wal-Mart, it means more soap and socks.
Freed stumbles the most when discussing Wal-Mart’s attempts at online sales. Legitimate online retail sales of music and movies are just one of many assaults on brick and mortar sales of CDs and DVDs. Blame for the slumping sales of traditional CDs, especially at brick-and-mortar stores, is spread widely: too much focus on marginal quality “hits” by vacuous and/or aging “stars”, not enough exciting new music or new artists, too much free peer-to-peer sharing (even post-Napster), competition from other media and entertainment alternatives (YouTube, gaming) and even general and generational disinterest in the traditional music business.
As Freed says, tech-savvy customers who do buy content on-line don’t represent the consumers that Wal-Mart targets. It’s more likely that Wal-Mart offers on-line sales for customer retention purposes – to give brand-loyal Wal-Mart customers who are tempted to try online sales a WalMart option instead of losing them.
Future physical sales of DVD’s in stores will be driven by many other factors beyond Wal-Mart’s, or even Apple’s, current online movie sales offerings. Freed’s final point is that the future business model for digital movie distribution is still unformed. Retailers like Wal-Mart and Best Buy are trying to get in the game now so that they’ll be better positioned to protect their retailing interests as the new marketing and sales technologies begin to take shape.
Could, or should Freed have given more ink and attention to Apple’s nascent success as an on-line movie retailer? Absolutely. If history is a lesson, Apple may well end up coming up with a crucial innovation that drives and defines revolutionary change in video content distribution. It’s not the iTunes store, yet. Freed’s beat, as a journalist, is probably traditional retail businesses, and technology speculation would be better left to a reporter who’s more familiar with the topic.
My take: it’s overly aggressive to castigate Freed for what he left out of his article. He had a fair point to make, did so fairly well, and at least mentioned (awkwardly, and inadequately) that tech savvy retailers like Apple are already setting the pace and figuring out how to make it work.
You know…far too often the reader posts at MDN take on aspects of Swift’s famous satire, “Gulliver’s Travels.”
Much ado about nothing.
Yeah, the AP piece is flawed for obvious reasons, but when it comes right down to it, a sale online or a sale via B&M doesn’t matter.
A sale is a sale.
Remember, in order to become a reporter for the AssPress, all you have to do is hate America….
These people are such ass clowns, can you imagine the “quality” of “news” you are getting from this pathetic company….
…and this crap is regurgiated by every other news outfit… how pathetic!
“Freed is writing about the impact on-line DVD sales have on the brick-and mortar retail stores”
…. Apple pioneered online movie sales and is still dominating and the leader of this technology.
Robert, no matter how long your comments are, any article that ignores that fact is very poorly written and misleading.
But then the AssPress always does with everything they write.
…. Apple pioneered online movie sales
——–
Actually, I think Amazon Unbox service beat out iTunes by a couple of weeks with digital movie sales..
Just checked… Yes, Amazon was first. However, you are correct that Apple is the dominant leader, just not the pioneer.
MacGuy:
I encourage you to read all of the article, and all of my post above, before responding.
Short version: Apple’s role IS leading: technology, innovation, sales. BUT the “killer” business model of online movie distribution isn’t here yet, and it’s not the current iTunes. Freed DOES give Apple credit as a leader driving the future, he COULD/SHOULD have written more and better on that topic, but it’s not his expertise, nor his main thesis. Article flawed? Yes. But this extreme criticism of Freed and AP is NOT warranted.
Walamrt has a website????!?
What some of you are missing is that, regardless of how “accurate” this article is, it leaves the wrong impression: that Wal-Mart is the leading retailer of online digital downloads. A selective statement of the facts can be just as misleading as an inaccurate misstatement of the facts.
Jake:
“A selective statement of the facts can be just as misleading as an inaccurate misstatement of the facts.”
My point exactly. Freed makes an error of omission in his article about B&M stores, a selective statement that can be misleading.
But since he’s not really writing about the online video business per se, Apple is only peripherally relevant, and only peripherally harmed, certainly not intentionally or significantly slighted.
MDN and many of its defenders, on the other hand, commit the same offense against Freed. The difference is that this selective and inaccurate interpretation of his article attacks him directly, viciously, and unfairly.
It’s hard to imagine that any reader of the original article, if they didn’t fall asleep first, would come away actually believing that WalMart is the most successful player in the nascent and technology-driven world of online video sales. I’m willing to guess that Freed assumed people would know when he says “farthest along” his audience knows he’s not referring to tech leaders like Apple and Amazon.
BUT, no one reading MDN’s redaction gets the impression that Freed is anything but an idiot. You have to read the entire original to see that MDN is off-base. The real harm from “selective statements” is done by MDN, not Freed, and MDN doubly so: not only against Freed, but by exaggerating an unrelated minor point into an imaginary assault against Apple, calling even more attention to it than it aks for.
Boo hoo
@Allen,
Amazon did produce downloads first. Although, to give them the title pioneer simply because they beat apple’s elelgant solution by a couple of weeks is like saying that the Soviets beat us to the moon because their Luna spacecraft crashed on the surface a couple days before the Apolo spacecraft landed in ’69.
Jake — just as selective reading of a statement can lead to misinterpretation of the facts. Or as misunderstanding of how the process works can lead to misinterpretation.
In terms of selective reading, Freed clearly includes quotes that the B&M retailers are at a disadvantage in this space before making the comment about Apple (and others). In the latter case, this in an interview-based report. The comments are coming from analysts and consultants. And in all reporting there are deadlines and space limitations.
So, let’s just take one of many possibilities for the “selective statements.” Let’s say Freed was on deadline and reporting from the floor of a retailing convention (there is a always a word count limit, so we’ll just take that as a given). Apple had no representatives present. The latest press release I found with a quick Google search was from September 2006, so let’s say he needed current stats and calls Apple — either they refuse to comment or don’t return his call before the deadline. Would you rather have Freed say, “Apple did not return our calls seeking comments on its total downloads,” or “Apple refused to comment on its total downloads?” Then you’d really be screaming about how skewed the article, because that clearly would sound much worse. Rather (having done this sort of work before), my presumption is that with no current quotable source of data, he simply made the “safe” implication that the retailers will have a tough time competing.
Whoops, forgot one other important point regarding process — Freed may have included information about Apple download counts and the editors dropped it for lack or space, lack of currency, and/or lack of an authoritative (quotable) source.
AP is a wire service. It dosn’t worry about space. That’s the poor slob’s job at a newspaper who has to make it readable.
I saw this article online this morning when I was eating breakfast. Thought about sending a notice to MDN but didn’t do it. Oh well.