“Microsoft Corp.’s forthcoming Windows Vista will take much harsher steps to curtail piracy than previous versions of its operating system, including crippling the usefulness of computers found to be running unlicensed copies of the new software,” The Associated Press reports.
AP reports, “The world’s largest software maker said Wednesday that people running a version of Windows Vista that it believes is pirated will initially be denied access to some of the most anticipated Vista features. That includes Windows Aero, an improved graphics technology.”
MacDailyNews Take: “Most anticipated?” By whom? They must mean “anticipated” by those who haven’t been using Apple’s vastly superior Mac OS X for over half a decade already.
AP continues, “If a legitimate copy is not bought within 30 days, the system will curtail functionality much further by restricting users to just the Web browser for an hour at a time, said Thomas Lindeman, Microsoft senior product manager. Under that scenario, a person could use the browser to surf the Web, access documents on the hard drive or log onto Web-based e-mail. But the user would not be able to directly open documents from the computer desktop or run other programs such as Outlook e-mail software, Lindeman said.”
“The company also said it has added more sophisticated technology for monitoring whether a system is pirated. For example, the system will be able to perform some piracy checks internally, without contacting Microsoft, Lindeman said,” AP reports. “Microsoft has already instituted tougher piracy checks for Windows XP users who want to get free add-ons such as anti-spyware programs. But until now, the warnings and punitive measures were mainly seen as annoying, rather than debilitating”
“Analyst Roger Kay with Endpoint Technologies Associates noted that Microsoft has the right to curtail illegal distribution of its software. The new piracy measures, he said, ‘seem harsh only in comparison to how lenient it has been.’ Nevertheless, Kay said he expects that the anti-piracy tactics will keep some people from upgrading to Vista from the current operating system, Windows XP. ‘There will be an XP backlash, which is to say people (will) cling to XP in order to avoid this,’ he said,” AP reports.
Full article here.
Apple trusts their customers. Mac OS X Tiger, with all features enabled no less, costs just US$129 (and only $199 for the 5-user “Family Pack”). All Macs come with Mac OS X Tiger pre-installed. Get a Mac.
Related articles:
Infoworld: Microsoft’s WIndows Vista not so revolutionary after all – September 11, 2006
Pirillo: Windows Vista RC1 disappointing, schizophrenic, disordered, inconsistent, and sad – September 07, 2006
Key Microsoft exec exits as clock ticks down on oft-delayed, much pared-down Windows Vista release – September 06, 2006
$399 for Windows Vista Ultimate?! (Hint: Get a Mac) – August 29, 2006
Apple’s Mac OS X Leopard is 64-bit done right, unlike Microsoft’s Windows Vista kludge – August 14, 2006
Microsoft Windows Vista: If you can’t innovate… try to impersonate Apple’s Mac OS X – August 10, 2006
Analyst: Apple’s new Mac OS X Leopard sets new bar, leaves Microsoft’s Vista in the dust – August 08, 2006
Symantec researcher: At this time, there are no file-infecting viruses that can infect Mac OS X – July 13, 2006
Sophos: Apple Mac OS X’s security record unscathed; Windows Vista malware just a matter of time – July 07, 2006
Computerworld: Microsoft Windows Vista a distant second-best to Apple Mac OS X – June 02, 2006
Microsoft’s greatest trick: convincing the public that the Wintel PC platform is open – March 06, 2006
Defending Windows over Mac a sign of mental illness – December 20, 2003
Gates and Ballmer are an eye patch and a parrot on their shoulder away from showing the world their true nature.
This move by MS is redundant. Any computer running Vista will already be debilitated.
ha.
MacDailyNews Take: “Apple trusts their customers.”
Microsoft trusts its customers, too. It´s the non-customers, the pirates of their software and users of pirated software, they don´t trust or want.
“Most anticipated?” By whom? They must mean “anticipated” by those who haven’t been using Apple’s vastly superior Mac OS X for over half a decade already.”
PLEASE. SHUT THIS SITE DOWN. PLEASE. JUST REPORT THE NEWS, SKIP THE TROLL FACTS. PLEASE – I BEG OF YOU.
hasta la vista becomes real
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
The company I work for recently purchased a new Dell laptop direct from the source…2 days after it arrived, they started getting the “this is NOT a genuine copy of Windows” messages. This also happened on a couple of the desktop machines around the office. I wonder how many other folks out there have had this message come up even though they did not copy anything and i wonder how many folks will be locked out of their computer after throwing down a bunch of money for one of the many versions of Vista….why the hell are their sooo many versions of vista anyways?
As much as I dislike MSFT, this is a legitimate excercise to protect their ownership rights. It comes down to this, whether you think Vista has value or not, if you don’t pay for it, you can’t use it. There is nothing unreasonable about that.
“Most anticipated?” By whom?
Ummm, let’s see, BY MILLIONS OS MS FANBOYS? Yeah, MDN, you guys really have your heads buried in the sand sometimes. Go to Fark Tech, read the posts over their in anything regarding Apple, and you’ll get a much better view of how most people still hold Apple.
PLEASE. SHUT THIS SITE DOWN. PLEASE. JUST REPORT THE NEWS, SKIP THE TROLL FACTS. PLEASE – I BEG OF YOU.
I second that motion.
No just ban users like Alex. MDN take is something I come here to read.
This is all redundant, it will only take 2 hours once vista is released for crackers to re-enable these features. If someone is going to go out of their way to pirate windows vista, you can be sure they have the means to crack these features as well. This is a move that won’t work. Next story.
With all the reworked XP code inside isn’t Vista debilitated enough already?
Mind you I wouldn’t know because as I write this Vista is still VAPOURWARE.
Well this is a disaster waiting to happen. Wait until some glitch makes the software shut down even though you have paid for it.
Windows users will see this as another annoyance to deal with…and they’ll probably take it. “sorry man, my computer was shut down for a week because of a dll conflict” “Me too…oh well”.
You have to be a real masochist to be a Windows user
cant wait to see how that “enhanced” scurity hoses a legit version of vista. I am sure that there will be a ton of instances where the ignorant slob who opens up that new Dell bachs will be crippled by a draconian mess that will make the machine un-usable. Can you image the calls to support for that!!
BBBWWWWWAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!
oh wait a dell is unuseable now on XP, sorry about that.
ROTFFL!!!!!!
no sympathies here, i run 5 macs and have one at work, thankfully.
So THAT’s what Microsoft has spent years working on . . . .
I can see it now, a new breed of virii that makes Vista installations look like they are pirated installs, then Vista itself becomes the Virus payload.
Cool. Another reason to stay OSX.
I don’t give a sh*t since I had no plans to buy Vista anyway, but it is quite funny to read about the bullsh*t that Windows users will put up with. I’ve got better things to do than to subject myself to Microsoft’s tactics.
Remove Aero™ capabilities on pirated copies?
Then it’s just Windows XP.
MacDailyNews Take: “Most anticipated?” By whom? They must mean “anticipated” by those who haven’t been using Apple’s vastly superior Mac OS X for over half a decade already.
There is nothing but truth in that brief “Take.” Those that object (Windows-only sufferers, guaranteed) simply can’t handle the truth.
G-Spank, Do you really call yourself “Fanboys?” Is that anything like a fancy lad?
DON’T SHUT IT DOWN JUST CHANGE THE NAME FROM NEWS TO “BITCHING”
MDB
This will simply equate to more switchers.
“crippling the usefulness of computers” They had to include their moto right?
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
This will just keep just about everyone I know from upgrading to SP3
Frankly, I respect the way they are handling this. I think it’s a great idea. The problem, however, is that, in typical MS fashion, it won’t work correctly and legitimate users will be forced to proved their ownership.
Alex, if you don’t like MDN’s editorializing, feel free to not come back. As some wise reader said a couple years ago (sorry I can’t remember who, but a regular), MDN is like the local pub where we all go to cheer on our favorite team (sorry, paraphrasing, but that’s the gist of it). There’s gonna be a lot of talkin’ smack. Get over it.
“MacDailyNews Take: “Most anticipated?” By whom? They must mean “anticipated” by those who haven’t been using Apple’s vastly superior Mac OS X for over half a decade already.”
God I love this site! These are my feelings EXACTLY and I, for one, truly appreciate the vitrol! We are kindred spirits, soul mates of the Mac-kind.
I suggest Alex just read his news elsewhere if he doesn’t like this kind of passion. Yes, we’re crazy- so what? And anyway, MDN isn’t journalism per se- it’s commentary on the news and I enjoy their comments and hope they never stop!
As if people need even more reason to avoid Vista. Keep turning the screws on the home users, and drive them into the waiting arms of Apple!
@Alex… chill out dude. This is a pro-Apple website. Your request is like going to a political website and complaining that they made a comment that they made on a news story is inflammatory, biased, or not germane.
MDN is undeniably and overtly partisan when it comes to the Apple vs. Microsoft conquest. I enjoy it. If I want “just the news,” I can go elsewhere.
PLEASE PLEASE DON’T VISIT IF THIS SITE OFFENDS YOU. Idiots.
Oh and talking of rights, what rights do Windows users have whose computers have been trashed by buggy Windows software, hackers and viruses? Let’s see. None.
Microsoft owes an awful lot more than it is owed.
ndelc
I agree the pub image is a better place than news I propose that the name be changed to
Mac Daily Circle Jerk
It sort of rolls of your tongue doesn’t it?
I anticipate a lot of problems with Microslop Vista.
What a lesson in hypocrisy! The biggest pirate of them all expects the little pirates to be honest. Apparently, the Big Pirate hasn’t heard of leading by example.
Google CEO Talks Apple
http://www.macnn.com/articles/06/10/04/google.ceo.on.apple/
Google CEO Eric Schmidt revealed his views on Apple in a recent interview with Time Magazine, noting his personal commitment to the Cupertino-based company. “Apple is engaged in probably the most remarkable second act ever seen in technology. Its resurgence is simply phenomenal and extremely impressive,” said Schmidt. Despite the fact that Schmidt sits on Apple’s board of directors, coupled with Apple and Google’s existing partnership, the executive confirmed his desire to see more partnering between the two tech giants. Schmidt also commented on Microsoft’s competitive stance, saying that “Microsoft continues to claim to enter the market, but we really haven’t seen them yet, they’re just getting started. I’m sure eventually Microsoft will be a competitor.”
I don’t like thieves. But I also don’t like Microsoft. I wonder how many of the millions of people who use WinXP use a pirated copy. Why switch to Macs when pirates figure they can stay on Windows by building their own machines and steal the OS to run the hardware? Many people will apparently put up with a lot of crap when their OS is ‘free.’ Of course, some people like me, well, you can’t give me a PC that I will use. My employer gave me a PC laptop, but it sits in a cabinet unused except for the first several days.
The perfect combination. Get a Mac and use your pirated “ruindous” copy if you really need it. Then use a Mac to surf the net and be safe.
Quote duper “Google CEO Talks Apple”
It’s called damning with faint praise
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
Briantt: Does that mean we’re supposed to stand in a circle around you? I like Mac Daily Hungry, Hungry Hippos instead. Sort of rolls off the uvula, doesn’t it?
i heart the MDN take.
good-bye wintards.
Alex: You remind me of the angry, old person bitching for an hour about a crappy TV show with a remote control right next to him. Get it?
“Vista….why the hell are their sooo many versions of vista anyways?”
Because there are so many varieties of IDIOTS out there buying them!
This is actually the latest security measure in Vista. If programmes can’t run then your PC will not get infected by malicious code. Tadaaaaa, problem fixed, MS style.
I agree with the long-standing bloggers on this site…
We are all pro-Apple. This is for good reason. If you are a Micro$oft fan (poor bastard), then good on ya. Just be prepared to have a vastly inferior computing experience…and then expect to go to pro-Apple sites and complain.
Like you are doing now.
But don’t worry…we Apple folks are used to it. We know you M$ fans are bitter, and THAT is also for good reason. Why not switch from the Dark Side, hm?
Then again, I could just make you switch…but how much fun would that be?
I can’t wait for the stories when Vista accidentally starts “crippling” computers of people who own the software.
You KNOW it’s going to happen!
So, Microsoft has a back door into every copy of Vista that enables them to shut the OS down at will.
Microsoft just told every hacker on the planet that this back door exists and it is always open.
This should be lots of fun as long as you don’t run Vista.
MW door
The nerds will find a way around this because we all know how easy it is to hack WIndows.
Apple trusts its customers? Yeah … to share the latest OS. The Family Pack is out there to pick up a little extra cash from the folk who would be sharing anyway but who can be made to feel guilty enough to spend just a bit extra. Four extra legal licenses for an extra $20 each? A bargain for a clear conscience – especially for a Dad with three or more family Macs in the house and a moral standard he’s trying to set.
There’s going to be suits over this tactic. MS has no right to disable legal programs on systems they do not own. That’s vandalism. Nor have they they right to invade people’s privacy to see what’s running on those people’s computers – not without willing permission. There are other solutions that do not break laws.
Registration is one possibility. Let people know Up Front that their computer Must be attached to the Internet (and the system booted from the DVD) in order to install the OS – and that registration will happen before the actual installation will begin. If someone tries to install a previously-registered copy the local software will check for either remnants of a broken version on the HD or a ‘naked’ HD while the remote software does a quick ping looking for another system running a copy of that software – wrong answers either place and no installation without a call to the MS Help Desk.
If you Windows fanbois don’t appreciate the MDN take, feel free to not visit. See, we don’t shut down sites because you don’t like content.
You can’t handle the truth.
Apple has an even stronger safeguard against piracy. You can’t install OS X on any machine that Apple didn’t manufacture.
Microsoft on the other hand does have a genuine problem. You can install Windows on a computer you cobble together yourself from parts. There can be more pirated copies of Windows than there are copies of OS X, because there are offshore companies that make counterfeit Windows CDs. Many people build their own machines for sport. The problem Microsoft has is coming up with a protection scheme that shuts out real pirates but doesn’t shut out genuine customers. That’s where it can all go wrong.
I don’t think there will be much of an XP backlash. People who use Windows are used to this sort of thing. XP has an activation scheme, but if it goes wrong, there’s a phone number you can call to get it straightened out.
I had Windows software that I had to throw away because the protection scheme was so draconian that I couldn’t re-install it–and the vendor wasn’t Microsoft.
Apple isn’t immune–notice that iWork has activation keys.
I prefer OS X to Windows, but this isn’t one of the reasons.
This will be FUBAR.
See above: “I can’t wait for the stories when Vista accidentally starts “crippling” computers of people who own the software.”
There will be thousands of cases like this, that is, if MS really follows through with this plan.
ALSO, Apple Computer ought to follow the idea that Windows uses must apologize to Apple before being allowed to use Leopard, IN WRITING. I don’t want sleazy windows users around Macs unless they repent, get on their knees, and beg forgiveness.
I’m not sure why this is that big of an issue. Microsoft is merely trying to protect their software from thieves, much like Apple does with Fairplay. Sure, it may cause some problems to a few legitimate customers, but Fairplay also prevents legitimate uses as well, and I don’t hear much complaining about that. If you are not a thief, than this measure taken by Microsoft will be just as tranparent as Fairplay. I’m sure all of you will think of good reasons to support such a protective measure once Apple does something similar with either their software or their Intel chips.
It’s only a matter of time before Apple protect their OS too. Hands up all the readers of this forum who use a “borrowed” version of a MacOS update on their machine?
Yeah, I thought so…
While I absolutely agree that MDN can get carried away at times, I’ll also admit that the name of this site is MACdaily news. If you want totally unbiased news with no commentary, go somewhere else, PLEASE!
Vista will debilitate you and then phone home to get you help-NOT.
Apple does have a much better pricing structure for OSX however if Apple had 10’s of millions of pirated OS’s floating around out there you can bet they’d come up with some pretty tough anti-pirating schemes.
Microsoft does have a real problem and they have a right to try and stop it and the real challenge is to find a way to accurately determine which OS is a pirated one vs. legitimate.
You have to wonder how much smaller America’s trade deficit would be if everyone worldwide had to pay for every copy of software, movie or song that should have been legitimately purchased. The lost revenue of 100 million copies of Win2k/XP run to almost $30 billion!
See, this is why Microsoft is superior, ’cause it has better ….. LOL I can’t continue, ha ha ha, sorry!

” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
“Hands up all the readers of this forum who use a ‘borrowed’ version of a MacOS update on their machine?
Sorry, RC. My hand remains firmly at my side.
One of the interesting differences between Apple and Microsoft in this instance is the “Family Pack.” For an extra $70, I get a five user license. In most of the Vista pricing I’ve seen, a five-user version will run me something like $400.
DLMeyer, I got one thing to say regarding Microsoft’s rights: EULA.
Click “Agree” to agree to the terms of this post.
Jay said, “While I absolutely agree that MDN can get carried away at times, I’ll also admit that the name of this site is MACdaily news. If you want totally unbiased news with no commentary, go somewhere else, PLEASE!”
Ok, so here’s the deal. If no one can complain about MDN being biased, then MDN cannot link an article from a Windows site, and then complain about them being biased.
It’s actually pretty lenient. It at least gives you 30 days and limited functionality. Apple’s DRM doesn’t let you do ANYTHING with a illegitimate copy of a song.
Hmmmm,
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” /> So, I think its pretty even, actually. LOL
To Alex and Gregg:
If you think this site is bad, try going to a windows fan site. Boy do they hate Macs, and for every and no reason in partictular.
As far as Microsoft goes: I think that they have every right to protect their software. Its just that they do it so badly.
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” /> When Windows XP first came out, one of the tech writers was on a plane with his LEGAL version of windows when it decided he was using an illegal copy and shut him down. He called MS and they agreed that he had a legal copy.
After days of trying, nothing anyone could do would make his XP software work again. MS finally had to ship him a new disk with a new number. The days of total downtime just because of their crappy software is criminal.
Microsoft just does not use their head when designing their software. Its MS first, last and always. The customer does not even count. And why should they, they were stupid enough to buy the software in the first place (JMHO
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” /> ). LOL
N.
If you really prefer MS, then I feel happy, er sad for you. Eitherway, have a nice day.
I love my Mac (cant call me a wintard).
I love reading Mac news (MDN is good for that, gets updated regularly etc etc).
But I hate the ‘MacDailyNews Take’. Its tiresome.
Thats my ‘take’ on the subject
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
PLEASE. SHUT THIS SITE DOWN. PLEASE. JUST REPORT THE NEWS, SKIP THE TROLL FACTS. PLEASE – I BEG OF YOU.
You don’t actually come here from news, do you? Go to http://www.macnn.com or http://www.macminute.com for that. I just come here to laugh at some of the dumb remarks that bunch of 12 year olds make (that would include first and foremost, the one running this site).
MDN MW – “your” as in this isn’t your source of mac related news.
Spot on, hypocrite.
I like the “local bar” reference that Ndelc made, but some of the respondents here treat MDN more like a local mosque with their jihaad-style commentary. There is a shocking number of people above who blindly assume that critique on an MDN take “must” mean that they are windows-users, and bash them blindly accordingly.
There is no need for that. Actually, before MDN a difference of opinion was appreciated within the Mac community.
But not so anymore by some it seems…
hypocrite:
You obviously didn’t understand, or read, what I said. My comments were directed at DOZE IDIOTS who make comments on an obviously Apple oriented site. This site, and the commentary therein, is NOT always objective, and we make no claims to being so.
As I said, if you want (maybe I should have said EXPECT) unbiased news with no commentary, go somewhere else.
To all of the MS defenders on this thread:
MSoft’s “solutions” to their piracy problems are a pain in the ass to legitimate end users. Anyone who says, “MS has a right to…” hasn’t had MS’s “rights” screw up days of work.
Computers (especially Windows machines) need upkeep, upgrading, wipes, and clean installs. Making a phone call to MS “support,” staying hold for 25 minutes, and explaining to an Indian that I’m really not a criminal every time I want to make a system change is a tremendous ordeal.
And on top of this there are all the “false positives” of MS’s sophisticated anti-piracy tools that hamper legitimate systems. After spending 300 bucks for an OS, I just want it to work.
Points…
1) MDN does not set rules for the whole “Apple community”. There is an MDN community, and that’s that. So please no more tighty-whitey complaints about the “level of discource” being cheapened, or your feelings being hurt, or whatever general prissiness you spout off. THIS IS MDN. Put on your big-girl panties and deal with it.
2) I don’t think MDN’s problem with articles is bias, it’s that the articles are factually incorrect, and written in such a way to generate an impression that is also fallacious. It may be a hopeless cause, because most tech writing is worse writing than porn, but at least they try to set the record straight.
Once again, M$ shows what their real idea of security:
making sure that you cannot cheat them out of a software usage payment
NOT
protecting your data
“Put on your big-girl panties and deal with it.”
I’m way ahead of you. Mmmm, snug.
BustingTheSkullsOfIdiots,
The point of discourse imho is not so much MDN per se, but a part of its “followers” who display such a hostile attitude towards even others Mac-users – who only happen to have another opinion – that the resulting atmosphere is as dark and cumbersome as it must be in Redmond HQ.
I do not know when these kind of “mac users” with their superior race mentality have crawled out of the woodwork, but it is not exactly an enrichment with regards to how it used to be.
I do not know why you typecast those who differ with your opinion as “girly”, “pantsy” or whatever other Redneck level of IQ you can find, but if it makes you feel better about yourself, have another go and some more fun with it.
what about the 20% of users that Microsoft themselves says are wrongly identified by their current WGA Windows Genuine Advantage software.
Can you imagine all the people with Vista that may truely own legit copies and they get locked out if MS’s system wrongly says it is an illegal copy !!
There would be one heck of a lot of really annoyed people about and i wonder if they could sue the pants off MS for wrongfully identifying them as pirates
could be interesting
Glad I dont have that hassle to worry about with OS X
As always pirates will find a way around these measures and distribute the solution widely and happily compute away while legitimate users have to phone in and deal with the infamous ‘false positive’ situation.
If I owned a legitimate copy of Windows Vista (ack), I would place it beautifully on a shelf and install a cracked pirate copy instead. Because the pirates offer a superior experience.
I thought the software industry learned this lesson in ’80s? I thought this was now solely the folly of the record companies?
The very last thing you want to do is offer your legitimate customers an inferior user experience to the pirate users. Talk about shooting yourself in the foot.
I would be willing to pay a software pirate the retail cost of Windows Vista to provide me with a version of the software that never phones home and will never deactivate.
If this trend continues, the pirates are really going to start to go pro en masse.
Time to switch to Linux. Er, I mean Mac. 😀
If Microsoft spent half as much time on actually finishing Vista as it does on these elaborate anti-piracy schemes, they’d have released Vista by now. After all, piracy is meaningless for a product that is never going to see the light of day.
MDN: Mac OS X costs just $69 brand new for a single user copy that can be installed on up to 3 computers (according to the license agreement) if you are a student, teacher, or work in an educational institution (such as an administrator).
I can see it now — some kid hacks vista, play around with the codes and bingo 100 million copies of vista’s suddenly decides that there not true copies and disables themselves!
OK
And IT managers near and far are going to race out today and order/buy their 10,000 copies just so they can have that little feature close at hand – right? I don’t think so!