Apple’s Mac OS X Dock vs. Microsoft Windows Taskbar

“Those of you who use Windows on a regular basis are undoubtedly very familiar with the taskbar that has been a part of the operating system since Windows 95. It has a variety of components, and although we’ve been able to work with it for quite some time, it’s by no means a perfect representation of what a taskbar should be. For example, if you have an abundance of open items sitting on your taskbar, they can begin to become crammed together, and when this happens, the buttons for each item start to shrink, and this causes any of the useful information that may have been contained within to become just another glob of goop on your taskbar,” Brandon Watts writes for OSWeekly.

Watts writes, “Windows XP does contain a feature called taskbar grouping that can group the taskbar buttons of several windows from the same application into one button, and this helps to some extent, but even with this approach, you’re still not getting the whole picture at a glance.”

Watts writes, “Aside from the taskbar, the dock presents open applications and frequently used programs in its own unique way. When you think of the dock, you probably think of OS X, however, the dock has been around longer than Apple’s latest versions of its operating system; and you can see this by looking at NeXTSTEP and OPENSTEP. Apple’s version is so memorable because they redefined what a dock was, and they then launched it into the mainstream. Computer users suddenly realized that the Windows taskbar isn’t the only solution, and experimentation with this newfangled dock started to take place.”

Watts writes, “Personally, I prefer the dock to the Windows taskbar, and it’s one of the things that really drew me to OS X… it’s nice to look down at the dock and see, in a graphical way, how many e-mail messages and RSS feed entries are available for me to read. Instead of having to open the applications to see this information, it’s already right in front of my face, so I know what to expect. In certain cases, when an application is working on something, you’ll even see a graphical progress bar. It’s also nice to see a snapshot of the content of a window when you minimize it to this dock.”

Full article here.

MacDailyNews Take: We’d prefer a root canal to the Windows taskbar. We’re interested to hear your ideas on how to make the Mac OS X Dock even better and also how you use your Dock. For example, we run our Mac OS X Docks as small as possible, always visible, on the bottom, with magnification disabled (the text rollovers and our grouping and memories work for us to quickly locate what we need. The magnification, while pretty, tends to slow us down since hitting a moving target isn’t as efficient as a stationary one.) We also place folders and hard drive icons in the right side of the Dock on all of our Macs; why Apple doesn’t ship Macs with the hard drive already in the Dock by default is beyond us. We also use Dock separators; Apple should give us something like them as a built-in option. How do you use your Dock?

62 Comments

  1. Why mess with perfection? We are already decades ahead of the competition.

    I prefer hidden with magnification and a folder containing aliases to frequently visited places and apps. but I also use You Control to access many things quickly (kind of replaces the Apple Menu from OS9.

  2. I use Mac OS X and Windows (unfortunately). The dock is far more elegant. The only thing worth mentioning about the task bar is the start menu. For all the things about windows I hate, I love the start menu and having quick access to all my applications.

    You can simulate this on the dock by dragging an alias of the applications folder to the dock. Now the only drawback is the short delay before it opens. So the dock is better in nearly every way aside from the before mentioned delay.

  3. The only plus the Taskbar has over the Dock, I suppose, is the ability to launch applications from it via keyboard shortcuts. For example, Ctrl+1 launches the first app in the taskbar.

    If there is a way to do this in the Dock, PLEASE LET ME KNOW!

    :~)

  4. I use my Dock like this…

    I have ONLY open apps in my dock. Since I use Quicksilver I don’t need to keep shortcuts to frequently used apps. I also make it as small as possible with NO magnification and keep it in the right hand corner of my screen.

  5. Where the Dock excels is muscle memory. I always know that Mail, Address, Book, Safari, and iChat are on the left side, and Transmit, BBEdit and any non-docked app is on the right, then I can begin moving towards my target without knowing exactly where it is yet.

    Compare that with the Windows Taskbar.. one must carefully read each item to know what is it.

  6. Bobby: I actually use Windows all the time as well, and find that the “Start” window is the worst abomination Microsoft has inflicted on the world. Magnified by the fact that on Linux, KDE and Gnome both saw fit to copy it!

    Given that I usually only use a subset of the applications on my computer 99% of the time, the Dock + Spotlight gives me the best way to start applications. On Windows I emulate this as best as possible by having applications “quick linked” next to the start bar and Google Desktop search for the Spotlight replacement.

  7. Heh. Some people never get used to the Dock. My wife still can’t stand it, after nearly 5 years of Mac use. She shrinks it to miniscule size and hides it on the right where she’ll never accidentally activate it. She uses DragThing to put the trash can on the desktop.

    Me? I just want to know when the ability to pin the Dock to a corner is going to become official. Every new Mac I buy, I install TinkerTool just to do one thing — put the Dock on the bottom and pin it to the lower-right corner of the screen. Then I hide it. It’s perfect this way! The trash can is exactly where I’d expect it to be, but only when I want to see it.

  8. Bottom. Hidden. Medium size. Magnification is on, but only so that it gives a subtle visual feedback. Not so much that it creates a moving target.

    It wouldn’t bother me if the hard drives were shown in the dock, but unlike MDN, I don’t have them there. I have the apps folder and utility folder, but I don’t really uset hose any more. If I want Grab, I just type command-space grab, cursor down and hit return.

    As for the start menu being faster, well yes, to start with, but locating anything in it is a pain, and sometimes windows will not show you everything, but will hide things it thinks you’re no longer interested in behind a chevron.

    OS-X’s insistence on a flat structure for the apps folder (except where it twists ther rules, a la iWork), is about the only thing I don’t like. My way around it was to have a structured nested set of folders containing aliases of my apps and utilities (i.e. Final Cut, Quicktime etc under ‘video’ etc).

    But, as I said, that’s redundant with spotlight.

  9. I wish the Dock had a way to let you know how many windows for a particular application are open (ex. number of Word documents open or number of browser windows open) and to switch between them easily.

    One of my favorite system add-ons is “Witch”, which (no pun intended) allows you to do just that – view and switch between open windows of an app or switch into another app. It works similar to “command-tab” and best of all, it’s free!

  10. I prefer the Dock to the Task Bar by a long shot, but neither is a perfect app launcher for me. I place my most-used apps in the Dock permanently, but everything else (about 100 or so other apps) I leave out. I use LaunchBar to find and launch what I need, and this combination works very well.

    I previously kept my Dock small with magnification off. But I found I kept click the wrong icon. I’m sure this is due to my poor eye-hand coordination. But I found that turning on a slight magnification slows me down just enough, and increases the target icon just large enough, to prevent nearly all the accidental launches.

  11. cubert: i get around that problem by using cmd-tab to switch apps and setting expose to show application windows at the bottom right hot corner. want to know how many pdfs i have open? cmd-tab to preview, mouse down to the bottom right. bam.

  12. It would be nice to be able to have a Dock item magnify even though Magnify is off by hovering the cursor over the item and pressing the space bar (for example). And it would be nice if the Dock were projected above the computer and controllable with mental commands.

  13. Top Ten Nine Reasons the Apple Dock Still Sucks:
    The Dock is big and clumsy
    Identical icons look identical
    Dock objects have no labels
    Dock objects need color
    The Trash Can belongs in the corner
    The Dock’s locations are unpredictable
    The Dock is a sprawler
    The Dock replaced better objects
    The Dock adds bad behavior

    The Dock’s sole positive attribute lies in its improving the Mac’s “curb appeal” and demoability.

    Apple would appear to be after two separate and distinct market segments. First, the naive consumer who isn’t going to do much with his or her computer anyway. OS X, with its suite of simple apps would appear to be a good fit.

    The other extreme they appear to want are self-identified power users. Why else all the talk about the UNIX underpinning, about “munitions-grade” computing power?

    OS X is a powerful operating system. It deserves a top-level interface that matches. The old Mac handled both sets of users handily. OS X, with its powerful underpinnings and slick graphics support has the potential to do much better. However, the focus on this single object to the exclusion of the kind of information tools power users need must stop. Keep the Dock as long as it helps close sales, but provide the real tools needed by people with serious work.

    http://www.asktog.com/columns/044top10docksucks.html

  14. I use a Butler menu with custom categories by app function or document types or tasks. I can access 98% of what I need through that menu, including windows dedicated to certain tasks with app or document aliases. The dock is my alternative simple launcher and occasional app switcher, but I could do without its intrusion on my screen. A task window is like a dock, only it has an extra dimension. Close it and it’s gone, unlike the dock which hangs around when you don’t need it. I’d rather have it related to the menu bar somehow.

    Same goes for the sidebar; I prefer narrow windows in list view for long lists or icon view for task folders. Saved documents sometimes become a moving target in list view. Weird.

  15. Three monitors, dock at right, hidden, default size, no magnification. I use Drag Thing as my application launcher (centered bottom). Dock is basically demoted to let me know when I got mail or an application needs attention from the bouncing icon. Give me a tabbed dock to organize my similar applications and I’d be happy. I count 66 applications alone right now in my Drag Thing which would overwhelm the dock.

  16. I think the Dock is a nasty piece of eyecandy. I’ve used Macs since 1992, OSX for 4 years.

    Here’s my work around:

    1. ‘DockBlock’ quits and launches the Dock instantly. http://www.sideburn.com/dockblock/ (this is what Apple should have BUILT IN to OSX all along… CHOICE!!)

    2. ‘Butler’ keeps a neat row of your favourite App icons permanently in the right-hand free space of the menubar, drag & drop, launch. etc http://www.petermaurer.de

    3. expand ‘Recent Items’ in the Apple menu to include 20 or so of your latest documents, for easy access

    4. ‘Windowshade X’ returns collapsible windows throughout OSX. http://www.unsanity.com/

    5. Oh, and any number of free desktop trash cans available to download

    Works perfectly!! no Dock eyecandy getting in the way of my projects, hogging screen space, sitting over Application pallets, jumping up and down, being a moving target etc, trying to be ‘clever’ in the distinctly Windows Clippy way.

  17. Dock on the left, almost as small as it will go with magnification as high as it will go. I must have the screen space but when I want to see the icons in the dock, I want them nice and big.

    Task Bar is just horrid..

  18. what id like is the ability to drag a file onto the finder icon in the dock and that to open the finder.

    i have my dock quite small, with a small amount of magnifyi for feedback. sitting at the bottom.

    Id like the mail icon to display bigger numerals for the amount of emails in inbox.

    I also use the right side to have shortcuts to networks.

  19. On the bottom with just a little bit of magnification. I keep my most used programs in the dock at all times. I access my favorite AV programs thru buttons in finder. I dont’ use them that often, but when I do, I want to be able to see and choose the ones I want quickly, without having to go thru the finder. I suppose I could create a folder of aliases, but for now this works. What I would like is a separate dock, that when I open audacity or MtR it will show a dock that has the others ones I use as well. I have a feeling that might be part of leopard tho – cause different spaces require different docks.

  20. Dock is on the right side of the screen with shortcuts to all applications that I commonly use in it. However, at work I do have shortcuts in the taskbar for all my programs that I use. I never use the start button in windows. Too many levels to go through to get to anything. Although, I do find the dock to be more helpful with the information it provides over the windows task bar. However, if I could get expose in windows my job would be so much easier. Unfortunately, the 3D application switcher thing that is supposed to be in Vista doesn’t look to be useful; cool looking, yes but not useful.

  21. I have to admit I find the Windows Taskbar superior to OSX dock. The dock is clunky, unintuitive, and obtrusive. Until OSX develops something comparable to Windows Start Menu, I will consider OSX lagging. I still can find a way to locate and launch apps with snap. The APP folder on the dock takes 2-3 seconds to respond to a click before it expands. It doesn’t cut it, and it never will. I think everything should launch from the blue apple, much like RECENT ITEMS. My 2 cents.

  22. I seem to be a little different here- I sorta like the dock and use it alot, more like a login app launcher (which I do not use) in that I have a small core of apps that I want on at most times, and there they are together to click on. I do want, desperately, to have a simple way to quit the damn thing, because I _don’t_ use Dashboard, at all (is there a way to totally disable it?) and I hate having to open up Activity Monitor just to stop all the damn widgets from opening up. Yeah, I suppose I could just take out all the damn widgets…, but that wouldn’t stop Dashboard from actually opening. Otherwise, I keep it on the bottom, where it fills the space, and use a slight magnification, just to let me know I’ve actually moused over the right app. I use Cleardock to remove the _very_ unsightly background. In fact, if I couldn’t transparency the Dock, I don’t think I’d actually use it.

  23. I have my dock on the left side, pretty small but with magnification turned on. The Dock is always visible, and only shows currently running apps. I use a DragThing dock with multiple tabs to organize my apps, folders, and files.

  24. The icon-based OS X Dock is a great addition to Macs and a vast improvement over the Windows Taskbar, but Apple’s Dock is overburdened. So, I use the Dock for applications only and the invaluable Dock Separators to organize Dock applications into categories. However, I also use Unsanity’s FruitMenu/Application Enhancer “haxie” to elegantly display and organize all OS X-related Utilities in the Apple menu! No Utilities are in the Dock, opening it up for more apps or larger icons! My Apple Menu Utility aliases are organized as follows:

    About This Mac
    10.0.1.5 (Network ID)
    Location>
    – (Line Separator from FruitMenu)
    Software Update
    System Preferences >
    customize FruiteMenu
    – (Line Separator from FruitMenu)
    A/V HDTV Utilities > (folder)
    Chat Utilities >(folder)
    DAs > (folder)
    Graphics Tools > (folder)
    – (Line Separator from FruitMenu)
    OS X Utilities (folder)
    Network Utilies (folder)
    Disk Utilities (folder)
    Utilities (folder)
    – (Line Separator from FruitMenu)
    Automater
    AppleScript
    Backup
    Carbon Copy Cloner
    iSync
    – (Line Separator from FruitMenu)
    Recent Applications > (limited to 5)
    Recent Documents > (limited to 5)
    – (Line Separator from FruitMenu)
    System Services > (popup for Force Quit, Sleep, Restart, Shutdown)
    Log Out

    The FruitMenu-powered Apple menu restores OS 9-like functionality to OS X. It can be used to customize the Apple Menu, Contextual Menus and Application Menus, but limiting it to just this one function alone is worth the minimal cost and it turns the Apple menu into what it should be — a launch pad for all OS-related Apple tools. Setting up Fruit menu with aliases is a manul process and can be a bit tedious, but once you do this, FruitMenu utilizes a Preferences pane to customize menus and this works very well. Better still, FruitMenu has survived all OS X updates so far, (including 10.4.8). However, I did have to add Unsanity’s free Menu Extra Enabler (v1.0.3) so that FruitMenu wouldn’t interefere with the tiny menu extra icons I’ve turned on for the top menu bar.

    I wish Apple would purchase this technology from Unsanity so that power users could choose to further customize their systems like this…

  25. I have my dock on the left, reduced (but not minimized) in size, and pinned to the upper-left corner of the screen. This keeps the application icons in a fixed location; icons that are added dynamically grow the dock downwards. I also have a folder of application aliases for the subset of apps that I’m more likely to use (besides the handful of app icons that permanently reside on the dock). I’m not yet desperate enough to install a haxie which puts the apps in the Apple menu.

    At work I have my Windows taskbar on the left also — so that the Start button is at the upper-left corner of the screen — like the Apple menu.

  26. Claudio, I have one response to 8 out of 9 of your “Ten” most notable reasons why the OS X Dock sucks: What??? Eight out of nine of your ten complaints is user configurable – Get off of Windtoes and start learn’n something about your Mac dude.

    I use the Doc and a Haxie called WindowShade to manage my windows. I use a tiny little bit of magnification in the dock, animation turned on, and auto-hiding engadged.

    My only real wish for the dock is that it could be moved anywhere on the screen.

  27. Dock on right edge of screen instead of bottom. A very small amount of magnification to high-light where the mouse cursors is pointed.

    Added Applications folder to Dock, to allow easy click-hold (or right-click) access to all apps, not just the ones “on” the Dock.

    Added folder with aliases to all my hard drive volumes (including networked volumes such as my iDisk space). This allows easy click-hold (or right-click) access to all files and folders. I copied and pasted the icon for a hard drive onto the folder holding the aliases, so that it would look appropriate on the Dock (not look like a plain folder).

    That’s about it. I can access any app or file with one click.

  28. The Dock should be optional. i preferred the old MultiFinder.

    Since editing the Apple menu is no longer an option, I use Unsanity’s FruitMenu to create a categorized Alias folder. I know one can place an Alias folder in the Dock, but the Dock is so slow I always end up yanking the folder off the Dock.

  29. I keep my dock on the right edge and always visible with no magnification. Programs tend to open on the left side if the dock is visible there it hides some of the program. I feel the right side is the most unused piece of real-estate. On the right side it does not hide the hard drive icons. I place applications in the dock that I tend to drag and drop and item on to use. I use Safari and keep FireFox in the dock then just drag and drop the link on the icon to open it in FF. FireWorks and iPhoto so I can drag and drop a pic on the icon to launch. I use the Function keys for my most common programs, Safari, Mail, Word…. and I could not live with out LaunchBar or QuickSilver. I keep a few every day or work in progress folders at the bottom of the dock.

  30. I like the dock, but not its limited funcionality.
    My dock hides at the top of my screen.
    I use a dock replacement called WorkStrip by Soft Chaos software.
    Works very much like OS X traditional but I can have both multiple docks based on needed tasks. Plus, every dock icon can have it’s own functionality, like showing what’s in a folder icon and it will also show live previews of images and movies without having to launch Preview app or QT or having to switch to column view in a open window to do this.
    Just to name a few.

  31. Hywel (and any others who launch apps with Spotlight):

    I am SOOOO surprised more people don’t know about Cmd-Enter/Return (it’s a shortcut for ‘open the top hit’).

    Just type in the first few letters of the app you want (in your case Grab), and press Cmd-Enter. Zippo.

    Also… Cmd-Clicking on a Spotlight item will reveal that item in the Finder.

    If you already knew that, forgive me.

  32. “The best and easiest way to switch (or switch-hide) between apps was taskmenubar.

    An OS X version is needed.”

    Mark – I totally agree, taskmenubar was a brilliant little app – very much missed (I think the guy who made it went over to the dark side).

    Do try out Butler though it’s very close, the only drawback is it doesn’t include open docs.

  33. Mine’s on the right-hand side of the screen so that the Finder icon is at the top and the Trash is at the bottom. (Makes it a bit more like the old Mac OS.) I’ve got a bunch of icons. Let’s see… 34, not counting the Trash. And magnification is turned to the size of the Dock when the OS was first installed.

  34. Why do you have to go to the START menu in order to shut down?? Real brains there, Micro$oft.
    START the viruses aroll’in is more like it.
    START the sheep at the front of the herd before the back of the herd
    START the blue screen of death on your black Dell
    START the swiss cheese IE penetration
    START the START of the end of your machine
    START unintuitiveness
    START the ten second count before your computer is invaded by some form of eventual death.
    START the suffocation of technological prowess and progress

  35. multiple docks would be nice:

    for instance: left dock holds the usual stuff, like apps and minimised windows;
    then imagine there is a ‘right’ dock as well, which could offer quick and hierarchical access to recent items, frequently used folders, scripts, system prefs (like screensaver settings), spotlight etc. All the things you need quick access to, to manage your mac in general terms.

    Ooh, and some kind of integration of Quicksilver, that brilliant can-do-all-app!

  36. Geo’s cheer for FruitMenu goes a long way with me.

    Nearly everyone has a preference for how they like to see (or not see) the Dock. But the point that still seems to stand is just how useful it is for keeping regularly used apps in a handy and predictable spot. Regardless of how you like it to look, few seem to dislike it’s main purpose.

    What I DON’T like is how OSX makes me do something unintuitive to access the -less-than-regularly used apps. Before Spotlight, I had to bore down to the Applications folder if I wanted to avoid overloading the Dock with a bunch of icons I rarely click. With Spotlight, while it’s easier, I’m still using a tool that I’d rather reserve for legitimate power searching (it’s main purpose).

    The ‘happy middle’ was – and still is – some form of the Classic Apple Menu. There I can load up every damn app & file that doesn’t classify as regularly used, but that I still like to get at a moments notice (without spelling it’s name or doing a slightly slower search). The Apple Menu as provided in OSX now is needlessly spartan and overly restricitive. Recent Items should be My Items, and configurable by me. Why do I need Dock Preferences in there when the same thing is in System Preferences, and moving the Dock around is for most people a fairly rare action? I should be able to get rid of it. Software Update is fine, but Mac OSX Software is clutter – the latter would be better served by simply putting a prominent tab for it on Apple’s main web page.

    I’m not trying to rant, just point out that ‘in the old days’ none of those questions/critiques needed to be answered by anybody because I could configure the Apple Menu ANY WAY I WANTED, so that it worked best for me. Now, unless I buy extra software and take on the added worry that a new OS update might break it, I have to try to make the Dock do/hold everything. The frustration of trying to make that happen is what I think leads the Dock-Haters to their position.

    How about it Jobs? Not everything from your past was bad. Bring back the original functionality of the Apple Menu.
    ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”cool smile” style=”border:0;” />

  37. I too have to use windows at work. I prefer the dock because it has all my applications handy-without the overbloated start button that brings up everything-but my lunch-so I just made short cuts on the desk top. I have a powerbook 12 in. so I need all the space I can get. I have it hidden on the righ with maginification on. Keep it going steve!!!!

  38. The Task bar actually makes sense in some cases, at least when working with a lot of open windows inside of Windows. Different strokes for different folks.

    The only time I use Exposé on my Mac is when I accidentally hit the F keys when I’m deleting something. I’ve since moved the Exposé keys to a different set of F keys where I won’t hit them accidentally.

    I use Desktop Manager if I want to see what windows that are available. I’m able to spread everything out and work with it easily I’m happy to see that Apple will be moving closer to this kind of set up in their future OS X upgrade. I hope that Apple will develop a pager type graphic representation as a permanent docklette like you see in other Unix distributions.

    Oh well, this is just my opinion.

    –Rudge

  39. Oh, I almost forgot. I keep my dock kind of on the small side at the bottom where the icons enlarge as I mouse over it. I keep a folder full of less-used alias applications so I can simply hold down the mouse button and then go up to the application that I need. It works even better than the Start-up thing on Window’s Task-Bar.

    –Rick

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.