Want a safer PC?  Dump Windows and get a Mac

“Microsoft on Monday revealed the results of a 15-month test of its Malicious Software Removal Tool. The utility that seeks out and destroys malware reported malicious programs, or bots, on six out of 10 Windows computers it examined,” Jennifer LeClaire reports for TechNewsWorld. “Microsoft made the announcement at the Tech Ed conference in Boston, leaving little doubt that bots are pervasive on the Internet. Bots are automated programs that scan systems and Web sites. Search engine spiders that crawl the Web are good bots, but hackers use this same technology to control PCs so they can spread spam, attack Web sites or steal a victim’s identity. ‘The malware environment out there is worse than most people even dream of,’ Mike Murray, director of vulnerability research for nCircle, told TechNewsWorld. ‘This report underscores the need for people to understand their security and the need for vendors to work towards security as a goal of their product.'”

“Microsoft scanned 5.7 million consumer and small business PCs on which its Malicious Software Removal Tool was installed between January 2005 and March 2006. The results reveal that about 20 percent of the participating PCs had been cleaned, then re-infected, typically with a different kind of bot. In addition, about 35 percent of the bots were installed after victims opened e-mail or IM attachments, or downloaded data files from peer-to-peer networks. The majority of the remaining bots spread without any required action by the victim,” LeClaire reports. “At least one ‘backdoor Trojan,’ a malicious computer code secretly installed onto PCs, was discovered on 3.5 million computers. That’s 62 percent. Most of the backdoor Trojans functioned as bots communicating over a private messaging channel to a remote attacker.”

Full article here.

“The statistics also show how computer worms never really go away. For example, the ‘Blaster worm,’ which first surfaced in August 2003, is still the 10th-most-removed piece of malware, according to Microsoft. Indeed, Redmond found that in about 20 percent of cases where it removed malware in March 2006, the intruder was something the removal tool had previously nixed. The continued high rate of Blaster infections no doubt is due in large part to the number of people who re-install Windows for whatever reason and do not immediately apply security updates or take other precautions necessary for surfing the Internet with a Windows machine, such as using firewall and anti-virus software,” Brian Krebs writes for The Washington Post.

Full article here.

By the end of 2005, there were 114,000 known viruses for PCs. In March 2006 alone, there were 850 new threats detected against Windows. Zero for Mac. While no computer connected to the Internet will ever be 100% immune from attack, Mac OS X has helped the Mac keep its clean bill of health with a superior UNIX foundation and security features that go above and beyond the norm for PCs. When you get a Mac, only your enthusiasm is contagious.

Connecting a PC to the Internet using factory settings is like leaving your front door wide open with your valuables out on the coffee table. A Mac, on the other hand, shuts and locks the door, hides the key, and stores your valuables in a safe with a combination known only to you. You have to buy, configure, and maintain such basic protection on a PC.

On a Windows PC, software (both good and evil) can change the system without your even knowing about it. In order for software to significantly modify Mac OS X, you have to type in your password. You’re the decider. You approve changes to your system.

People attempting to break into computers may disguise a malicious program as a picture, movie, or other seemingly harmless file. You might download such files from the Web, or get them via mail or chat. A PC just blindly downloads them without a peep. A Mac, however, will let you know that you may be getting a wolf in sheep’s clothing. The Mac web browser, Safari, can tell the difference between a file and a program, and alerts you whenever you’re downloading the latter.

A Mac gets much of this out-of-the-box protection from its open source UNIX heritage. The most critical components of Mac OS X are open for review by a worldwide community of security experts. Their input helps Apple continually make Mac OS X ever more secure. And it’s simple to update a Mac with the latest advances. By default, a Mac checks for updates weekly. For pure peace of mind, you can set a Mac to download security updates automatically. Apple digitally signs the updates, so you can be sure they come from a trusted source.

To get a sense of just how big the virus problem is, search for “virus” at both Apple and Microsoft. Compare the number of results. What’s more, the 100 most virulent attacks cause 99.9% of damage from malicious software. None of these attacks work on a Mac. Don’t you deserve such protection?

More info: 114,000 viruses? Not on a Mac.

Advertisements:
• Introducing the super-fast, blogging, podcasting, do-everything-out-of-the-box MacBook.  Starting at just $1099.
• Get the new iMac with Intel Core Duo for as low as $31 A MONTH with Free shipping!
• Get the MacBook Pro with Intel Core Duo for as low as $47 A MONTH with Free Shipping!
• Apple’s new Mac mini. Intel Core, up to 4 times faster. Starting at just $599. Free shipping.
• iPod. 15,000 songs. 25,000 photos. 150 hours of video. The new iPod. 30GB and 60GB models start at just $299. Free shipping.
• Connect iPod to your television set with the iPod AV Cable. Just $19.
• iPod Radio Remote. Listen to FM radio on your iPod and control everything with a convenient wired remote. Just $49.

Related articles:
Microsoft hides fact that ‘Windows Genuine Advantage’ antipiracy spyware phones home every boot up – June 09, 2006
Apple: ‘Get a Mac. Say ‘Buh-Bye’ to viruses’ – June 01, 2006
Mafiasoft launches Windows protection racket – May 31, 2006
Apple Boot Camp’s ‘Windows Insecurity Blanket’ helps buyers decide to switch to Macs – May 19, 2006
Microsoft: recovery from Windows malware becoming impossible; better to to wipe and rebuild – April 04, 2006
FBI: Viruses, spyware, other computer-related crimes cost U.S. businesses $67.2 billion per year – February 01, 2006
Tech writer: ‘virus-and-spyware-prone Windows isn’t the way to go – get a Mac’ – January 31, 2006
eWeek: Intel transition a ‘security non-issue’ for Apple Mac – January 30, 2006
Microsoft Windows virus spreads rapidly; Apple Macintosh unaffected – November 28, 2005
Microsoft apologists and why Apple’s Mac OS X has zero viruses – October 24, 2005
How to avoid viruses and malware? Dump your Windows PC and get an Apple Macintosh – August 22, 2005
ZDNet: How many Mac OS X users affected by the last 100 viruses? None, zero, not one, not ever – August 18, 2005
16-percent of computer users are unaffected by viruses, malware because they use Apple Macs – June 15, 2005
97,467 Microsoft Windows viruses vs. zero for Apple Mac’s OS X – April 05, 2005
68,736 Microsoft Windows viruses vs. zero for Apple Mac’s OS X – March 12, 2005

91 Comments

  1. Why am I not surprised? I wonder why people put up with that crap? One wouldn’t accept those kinds of numbers from any other industry. It’s like people turn off their brains when it comes to computing/computers.

  2. This is all good. Now if we can get Steve to quit releasing Apple products before they are ready….

    i.e., MacBooks that double as space heaters, whine and moo, and made of inferior plastic that rapidly deteriortes and turns your shiny white laptop to ugly yellow.

    If Steve doesn’t fix these issues the emerging opportunity to significantly cut into M$soft will be lost forever!

  3. I’m in my Applications folder on my Mac and I can’t find the “Malicious Software Removal Tool”. I checked the Utilities folder also. Nor is it in System Preferences. Is it a unix commandline only thing??

    I’m running Tiger. Please help!!

  4. JadisOne….you hit the nail on the head. WAKE UP, PEOPLE!!

    Even if they have no interest in switching to Mac, why on earth aren’t millions screaming and rioting and suing Microsoft? Oh, that’s right, they shut off their brain.

  5. Just goes to show that when a Windows fanboy comes out of the woodwork and says that he’s never had a trojan, virus or spyware, we can say to him, “how do you know for sure?”

    Even the best anti-virus/spyware/trojan application doesn’t get them all, there could still be one lurking on your hard drive, hiding itself, and reinstalling itself when needed.

    I know of a friend who bought a bargain basement PC for his step-son, only to have to throw it away (literally) after 6-12 months because it became unusable, because of all the unknown malware slowing it down.

    Taking it back to where he bought it (twice) to get it fixed, they tried to sell him some different anti-everything software, (replacing what came bundled with the PC). In the end he bought a new PC (with a different anti-everything subscription) for his step-son and a iBook for himself – (under my persuasion).

    If people are simply buying a new Windows PC because their old one is simply gummed-up with malware after 6-12 months, this makes the PC to Mac market share numbers look a bit suspect doesn’t it?

    And to revisit a previous (misconstrued) post, any Windows fanboy stating that if he’s not clever enough to know how to protect his PC, then he doesn’t deserve to have one, then they are really missing the point.

    I have a Mac because I want to get work done, I shouldn’t have to spend time babysitting it, telling it not to install that application that just appeared off the internet without my permission.

  6. To many people, the ‘just good enough’ solution will always be the more attractive one when it comes down to perceived price. There is also the ‘me too’ factor. People figure if everyone is doing it, then they should to, or they shall be branded as outcasts.

    Just a couple reasons why people continue to fly into the flame known as Windows.

  7. Microsoft is the number one reason Windows users have switched to Macs. I once worked at an Apple store and can tell you that 50%+ of the Macs I sold were to people sick and tired of Windows issues. Viruses, re-installing the OS, protection software unable to predict future viruses so what good is it, on and on.

    Once Adobe hits the streets with native Intel softwae for OS X, the graphic-laden Mac base of buying will kick in. Add this to the group of Windows users, and Apple will get back to their run of more market share.

    Yellow MacBooks? Apple stores have more people playing with these laptops than anyone anywhere. They look just fine.

    Try washing your hands after changing the motor oil before diving in on the MacBook – it does wonders.

  8. – The majority of the remaining bots spread without any required action by the victim –

    OK, you know my feelings on Vista, but I’m not feeling like waiting for it anymore. The more I know about winXP the more it scares me onto a Mac. I just don’t feel like learning something new tho.

  9. Anecdotal evidence aside, the stories told here and on other Apple Pumping Boards do not translate into any significant gains for Apple in market share.

    Vista is going to address most of the criticisms expressed here regarding important system files being changed without the users knowledge.If it’s a locked down as some beta testers have suggested, I can’t see what your complaint is.

  10. Right before my eighth regeneration, I finally deleted windows and installed Tiger on the Tardis. In case you’ve been keeping up, that’s why it doesn’t break down and malfunction like it used to.

    It was a real pain in the arse before I switched. I’d get the blue screen of death and always end up in Cleveland in the 1970’s.

  11. I’m in my Applications folder on my Mac and I can’t find the “Malicious Software Removal Tool”. I checked the Utilities folder also. Nor is it in System Preferences. Is it a unix commandline only thing??

    Assuming you’re serious, re-read the article. “Malicious Software Removal Tool”, a.k.a. MSRot, is a Windows-only software tool from Micro$oft. Not needed on a Mac (unless you’re running Windows on your Mac underBootCamp or Parallels, but that’s a whole ‘nother kettle of putrid fish)

    If you’re a WinFanBoy, please go play in heavy traffic

  12. “……I can’t see what your complaint is…..”

    No koolaid here …

    How do you feel about MicroCrap selling you the faulty OS …
    then, charging you once again (and again and again, etc) for a way to keep malware from infecting it ?? .. (which never totally works, btw)

    And how do you feel about a WinDoze fanboy revealing that
    Windows IS .. a trojan ?? …. Spyware
    that phones home to let Billy boy know whats on your hard drive and whether its legal or not ??

    Theres gotta be some privacy laws being broken here ..right ?

    Oh ..Here is the article … Scroll down to “Short Takes” .. to read it …

  13. I was utterly non-serious. 😀

    Tiger = no need for such time-wasting rubbish anti-virus software.

    But thanks for helping. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

  14. VistaRox: … I just don’t feel like learning something new tho.

    It’s easy to go from XP to OS X. A few little things here and there — no biggie.

    I use both (only because I have to — but vastly prefer my Mac) and let me assure you you’ll make the switch easily and you’ll LOVE OS X!

  15. Oh My:

    I feel the same way about it as I would when driving a car and it gets a flat tire. I don’t expect it to be perfect.

    I can’t remember the last time I’ve gotten an virus on my computer. I have trendmicro pc-cillin and it’s never been a problem.

    People who have pc knowledge do just find with windows. People who are newbies, grandmas, kids, those who don’t know a cd holder from a cup holder should be given a MAC.

    WIndow users are NOT of equal ability and should not be painted with the same brush. SHould I assume that all MAC users are artists? Phototgraphers? musicians? HARDLY.

  16. No koolaid here,

    No, don’t assume that all Mac (not MAC) users are artists (as normally defined).

    But you can assume that all Mac users don’t get VIRUSES. And you can know there’s absolutely no need to distinguish between “people who have knowledge” (the elites) and the “newbies, grandmas, kids …” (the others).

    Simply put: the Mac is not perfect but it’s a far better tool for getting most WORK DONE.

    By the way, how many CPU cycles or network bandwidth does your pc-cillin use up to check your PC and to update itself?

  17. “…I can’t remember the last time I’ve gotten an virus on my computer. I have trendmicro pc-cillin and it’s never been a problem…”

    So, does this mean you are eagerly anticipating the release of LongHorn / Vista … so you are able to purchase Billy Gates “Anti-Malware” solution .. right along with it … just because of you’re PC knowledge ?

    You miss the point … the question you should be asking yourself is …

    “Why should I be forced to even think about such things ?”

    You dont.. if you have a secure system out of the box … ya kno ..
    one like Mac OSX …

    Oh …. Has Billy given you “Stealth Mode” yet ?

    Ask a Tiger user about that … it’s wonderful !!

  18. Mark:

    The cpu usage is sub 1 percent. NOt sure about the bandwidth requirements, though in this day and age of dsl and cable seems negligible at best. Unless you have link that shows otherwise. I quick check on google didn’t reveal anything unusual about it being a resource hog or such.

  19. Every major city in the US should hold a public forum, video conference with Bill Gates and his top os engineers. And only one question should be asked:

    “Why can’t Microsoft build an operating system that is not so prone to viruses as the Apple os is?”

    I would love to here the answer to that from any of those guys – and not from “know-it-all” posters on sites.

    Is it that he has a deal with Symantec and McAfee to build a lesser os so that the anti-virus makers can stay in business or is it that his engineers are all recent college grads who only got a 2.2 GPA in Liberal Arts?

  20. “The utility that seeks out and destroys malware reported malicious programs, or bots, on six out of 10 Windows computers it examined.”

    There solution is only 60% effective?!?!? That’s a failing grade in any school (well, except Ivy League schools). Typical Microsucks.

  21. And I can still hear RealityCheck and Mac and PC Guy saying: we’ve never had a virus or anything like it. Run antivirus and you’re just fine with Windows.

    This just PROVES that antivirus progs are USELESS. If 60% and more were infected it is inconceivable none of those ran antivurus progs.

    WIndows is an effing DISASTER.

  22. better than searching or googling for virus for Windows/Mac just go to the site: http://www.ciac.org/ciac/bulletinsByType/bul_vendor_list.htm

    Concerning what Bill Gates or other Microsoft reprs would reply to the “why do not build a OS as safe as Mac OS X” the answer is the usual BS: “we are as safe if not better than Mac OS X. We get all these attacks because we are the greatest target. If Apple had our market share you would be in even worst situation because they are not used to these kind of attacks”

    And believe me, it works with IT, it works with Joe Six Pack, it works with the average Windows user. They truly drink this BS from MS.

  23. Concerning the usual “I use Windows, I know how to pamper it and protect it, I never got a virus”: it means absolutely nothing. The answer is in the large numbers. When you get a large sample of Windows installation there is 100% certainty that whatever the protection in place, hundred of thousands of users will be infected. AND no, it is not silly users but most of them are in corporation with BILLIONS of dollars spent is protections, firewalls, IT working 100% of their time to protect their park and still they get creamed EVERY TIME.

    So to all single Windows user coming here and saying “all exaggeration, I never had a virus”, sorry pal, you are irrelevant. Go explain that to all those corporate institutions shut down by every new coming virus that they should hire you instead of their teams tens-strong of highly paid MS techies graduate. THEY are helpless, go help them.

    Get real!

    How many times have we read “Company X saved by their Department Y using Macs. ALL others were creamed by virus Z”

  24. Finally, the comment People who have pc knowledge do just find with windows. People who are newbies, grandmas, kids, those who don’t know a cd holder from a cup holder should be given a MAC. is so out of touch with reality it is amazing anyone with a grain of salt could have formulated it.

    Are you smoking? You truly believe it is enough to have PC knowledge to avoid malware? HAHAHHAHHHUEHUHUHUAHHAHAHAHAHA

    That explains why Windows users infection is around 60 % or more every time. They are so amazingly naive!

    Baby, systems in places like CERN, ESA, Imperial College, University of Berkeley, the US Coast Guards, banks all over the world, get corrupted and infected and PCs need to be removed from their network to be cleaned up. All Moms and Pops working there?

  25. yes, Microsoft’s numbers show it finds malware once in every 311 scans or, for the mathematically challenged, 0.32% of the time.

    One way to look at this is that roughly at any given point in time 0.32% of PCs which are set up to use the tool have malware. hardly what the average Head Up Arse Mac User would have you believe.

    The 62% number is that the Bot was found on 62% of the 0.32% that were compromised, or 0.20% of actual scans.

    And in case the Apple users don’t understand, this software is free and runs automatically on an XP SP2 system (as it comes out of the box).

    gagravaar, following your logic, “Even the best anti-virus/spyware/trojan application doesn’t get them all” if you don’t run ANY antivirus, how do you know a super secret Mac virus isn’t running on your Mac, just waiting for it to be activated by the signal from Bill’s black helicopters?

  26. “People attempting to break into computers may disguise a malicious program as a picture, movie, or other seemingly harmless file. You might download such files from the Web, or get them via mail or chat. A PC just blindly downloads them without a peep”

    You can’t be serious believing that. Go use an XP SP2 PC, see what it actually does.

  27. No koolaid here:

    You said: “Vista is going to address most of the criticisms expressed here regarding important system files being changed without the users knowledge.If it’s a locked down as some beta testers have suggested, I can’t see what your complaint is.”

    Vista beta had 10,000 viruses/malware for it the DAY IT WAS RELEASED! Yeah, sounds like Microsoft is working overtime – to develop its own subscription malware protection racket. As for securing the OS, it will never happen. Especially once Microsoft starts getting users to subscribe to services from Microsoft to protect them against products by Microsoft.

    What’s wrong with that picture?

  28. virus, you need to reread the article. The tool has been installed on 5.7 millions PC. Over a period of 15 months the tool “reported malicious programs, or bots, on six out of 10 Windows computers it examined”.

    And that is 60% of the PCs where the tool was installed.

    “about 20 percent of the participating PCs had been cleaned, then re-infected, typically with a different kind of bot”

    “about 35 percent of the bots were installed after victims opened e-mail or IM attachments, or downloaded data files from peer-to-peer networks”

    “At least one ‘backdoor Trojan,’ a malicious computer code secretly installed onto PCs, was discovered on 3.5 million computers. That’s 62 percent.”

    You are smoking crack as usual. And as usual, Windows users are totally blind when talking security.

  29. No iPodder, virus simply believed the sample was the entire population of PCs in the world, that is, just another Head Up Bill’s Arse Windows User.

    Nothing new to report. Windows users are infected by the truck loads, the very Microsoft tests over 5.7 millions PCs shows a rate of 60% infection, a rate of 20% RE-infection, a rate of 35% of bots having infected via means that should be totally safe – as they are on the Mac – a 62% of presence of a backdoor for stealth infection and the average Windows idiot spouts: “EXAGGERATION, it is 62% of the 0.32% that were compromised”

    IDIOT, it is 3.7 Millions infected out of a sample of 5.7 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Q: Does it sux to be so frigging moronic in the Windows world?
    A: No, they are proud to be MORONS

  30. “Microsoft scanned 5.7 million consumer and small business PCs on which its Malicious Software Removal Tool was installed between January 2005 and March 2006. The results reveal that about 20 percent of the participating PCs had been cleaned, then re-infected, typically with a different kind of bot. In addition, about 35 percent of the bots were installed after victims opened e-mail or IM attachments, or downloaded data files from peer-to-peer networks. The majority of the remaining bots spread without any required action by the victim,” LeClaire reports. “At least one ‘backdoor Trojan,’ a malicious computer code secretly installed onto PCs, was discovered on 3.5 million computers. That’s 62 percent.”

    Read the above ten times before meals till you know it by heart.

    MICROSOFT sampled 5.7 Millions PCs and found not less than 3.5 Millions INFECTED. THAT’s 62%.

    And the announcement shocked the audience. I wonder why, since at peak infection for major virus strikes the number of PC infected is about… you guessed… 60% !

    Nice to see Microsoft confirms they SUCK!

  31. Nice to see Microsoft confirms they SUCK!

    Nice to see average Windows user Virus confirmed Microsoft excuse (Balmer and Gates comments) for their infection rate: “our problem is our Windows user base. You cannot protect yourself from dumb users”.

    But no Virus, we know it is not the fact that you are dumb at fault, as Microsoft Head Up Arse Executives want us to believe. We know it is because THEY SUCK!

  32. and – of course – iPodder – Microsoft *scanned* 5.7 Millions PCs where the tool was installed over a period of 15 months. But I get from your posting that you had that understood anyway.

    We do not know how many PCs are currently running the tool but the 5.7 Millions sample is not bad in a population of some ~200 Millions PC. Actually quite a large sample that would allow to conclude that at least 120 Millions PCs in the world have a corruption/infection of some kind.

    Way to go MicroSUCK!

    BTW Virus, the results tell you that you have 6 chances out of 10 to have – unknowingly – a stealth infection.

    How do you think cracker can sell PC zombies by the hundred of thousands at the time for hefty dollars? Where do you live? in an asylum?

  33. Guys… I hate to break it to you, but Virus is right. I went and looked at the raw data which is available here:

    http://download.microsoft.com/download/3/d/e/3de2470b-ab9a-4a7f-b760-ee2421df294a/WindowsRemovalToolWP.doc

    According to Microsoft, 270,000,000 unique computers were scanned… not a sample… ALL of them. Of those 270 million, only 5.7 million were found to be infected and cleaned. That is about 2.1% of all computers scanned.

    Of those 5.7 million, 3.5 million were infected with a Trojan as well as the other malware. That is the source of the 62%…

    62% of the only the malware infected computers also carried a Trojan… not 62% of the entire population of scanned computers.

    It is actually only ~1.3% of the entire population of 270 million that carried a Trojan.

  34. The AMAZING thing is that there is not ONE class-action lawsuit, even though this M$ sh*t is costing BILLIONS in damage every year.

    ahh yeah, the iPod has some scratches and how many cclass-action lawsuits were filed.

    Is this evidence that PC people are just less intelligent?

  35. Swordmaker, sorry but it does not add up. According to the article on TechnewsWorld Microsoft 5.7 Million computers were scanned out of the 270 Millions of installs. This last is the number of computers where the tool has been installed. And also this figure is amazing. The article also mentions data from “participating PCs” and “participating consumers and small business”. In addition, the user can choose for the tool NOT to report back to Microsoft.

    All above points to the fact that data where not collected from ALL installations: “The utility that seeks out and destroys malware reported malicious programs, or bots, on six out of 10 Windows computers it examined”.

    Comments from experts reflect a situation that is bad: “The malware environment out there is worse than most people even dream of” that would not be consistent with a figure of only 0.32% infection. That would be phenomenal security, even better than Unix.

    “This report underscores the need for people to understand their security and the need for vendors to work towards security as a goal of their product.” With 0.32% infection the comments would be “We have won the war against malware!”

    TechNews titles: “Disturbing Figures

    Microsoft scanned 5.7 million consumer and small business PCs on which its Malicious Software Removal Tool was installed between January 2005 and March 2006. “

    0.32% a disturbing figure? The disturbing figure is the confirmation – and admission by Microsoft at the Tech Ed in Boston – that the rate of infection is around 60%.

    In addition to that, 270 Millions computers and the doc reports installs on computers running Windows XP, Windows 2k and Windows Server 2003. Of those Windows versions, only XP is possibly in the hands of consumers, the rest is the segment of “participating businesses”.

    The same doc states that when the tool finds a possible infection it prompts the user to send the results to Microsoft. The user can deny that.

    All above means that it is simply impossible and statistically meaningless to think that the sample is the entire installed base of the tool.

    It points though to where Virus got his numbers so at least he has not invented them – so sorry for having made fun of you pal, part of the game – but remains that when you read something you must have a critical eye and people at the Boston tech event where flabbergasted by the BAD results, not happy for an amazing 0.32% infection rate.

    Clearer now?

  36. First off, you need to know what MSRT doesn’t do. It doesn’t protect you against every known form of malware. And it doesn’t scan your hard drive for files containing malware the way antivirus software does. Instead, it scans your system’s memory for any evidence of currently running malware found on a list Microsoft maintains and updates regularly.

    MSRT can’t do everything antivirus software does, so if there are other instances of that entity stored in files on your hard drive and not yet activated, MSRT won’t detect or wipe them from your system. And if the active entity has infected or damaged other files on your system, MSRT won’t detect this either or try to repair them.

    So not only MSRT found that 6 out of 10 of the participating PCs (ie scanned) are infected, it does not detect all possible infections.
    Not surprisingly the report at the Tech Ed in Boston was “disturbing”

  37. the 0.32% rate is the number of MONTHLY cleaned computers out of the installed base, one every 311 computers every month which amounts to some 800k infections every month. This number has been roughly consistent from July 05, when MS started to collect data from participating PCs. The tool was first released on Jan 05 but from Jan 05 to June 05 MS was not collecting *any* data from any one.

    To say the least, since MS does not receive data from the all 270 millions PCs the derived percentage is just a MS spin-doctor to make so that careless readers get the impression that the results are actually good.

  38. To reinforce the analysis of the report. From BBC News of the 21st August 2003:

    The Sobig Windows virus that overwhelmed e-mail inboxes around the world is one of the fastest growing viruses ever.
    E-mail filtering firm MessageLabs said it had intercepted more than a million copies of Sobig F in 24 hours, more than for any other virus.

    Net service giant AOL said it had stopped more than 23.2 million copies of the virus since it first appeared on 18 August.

    So, I stress the figure: 23.2 MILLIONS copies of the virus reported.

    Do you want to know how many computers MSRT reports as being cleaned by Sobig? 6371 !!!!!!!!!

    Still convinced the report is from data coming from 270 Millions PC?

    To the tally of Sobig there are then some 23.1 MISSING.

    Get real.

  39. Another interesting comment from Microsoft reported in Boston:

    “… most of the removals are from Windows XP SP2, with Windows XP composing 89% of all removals by the tool. This high number
    of disinfections from Windows XP SP2 computers is expected because most of the executions of the tool are on Windows XP SP2
    computers.”

    Windows XP SP2 is supposedly greatly and vastly more secure than other versions (non SP2 or ME, or 98, 2k, you name it, which still are the majority out there). And still, it makes for 89% of entries of the infected PCs. Also from this one could get that MSRT data do not come from “at least 270 Millions PCs”.

  40. Sorry for the multiple posts, this is my last to reinforce the main message: it is a SMALL sample result.

    Again from Microsoft: “The tool is also available for deployment through
    Windows Server Update Services (WSUS). […]. The tool does not transmit any information back to Microsoft on computers that are updated by a WSUS server.”

    Hence, once again, 270 Millions is the installed base of the tools. A small part of these, “participating users and businesses”, have reported data back to Microsoft and the results are that “6 out of 10” have reported infections.

    Peace

  41. read an original article iplodder.

    “Since the initial release of the MSRT, the tool has been executed approximately 2.7 billion times by at least 270 million unique computers.”

    The tool gets run automatically in the background when you download updates to XP. Installation of the tool means running the tool.

    There are 270 million unique users of the tool.

    5.7 million is the number which showed malware ever.

    5.7 divided by 270 million is 2.11%

    Of those 5.7 million 20% got reinfected.

    From the original report: “Thus, of the 5.7 million unique computers from which the tool has removed malware, a backdoor Trojan was present in 62% of computers”

    Of those 5.7 million 62% had one particular CLASS of malware.

    “On average, the tool removes at least one instance of malware from every 311 computers it runs on.”

    And since it runs on every auto updated XP computer every month, you can reasonbly imply at any given time, one in 311 of these computers has malware of the type that the tool detects, or 0.32% of the user base has malware that the tool detects.

    shesh.

    technewsworld is selectively reporting statistics that seem alarming, and you’re taking it hook line and sinker.

    Look in the reports at the stats for XP SP2 for infections and cleaning vs other older OS variants to see just how far Microsoft has come.

    finally from the report: “Most of the computers cleaned with each release of the MSRT are computers from which the tool has never removed malware.”

    That is to say, once you get clean, 80% of the time you stay clean.

    I know guys it’s tough to have your illusions shatterd by cold hard facts.

    Yes, Windows PCs are chosem by more customers.

    Yes the Intel processor is faster than the power PC

    Yes the virus problem on PCs is nothing like what Mac fanboys make it out to be.

  42. Virus, I read the original article. The tool is installed on 270 millions machines and does NOT automatically send data to Microsoft.
    Microsoft had only a fraction of data available from computers where MSRT was installed and announced in Boston that “6 out of 10 PC” reported infections.

    There is nowhere in any article that allows to do a 5.7 Millions divided by 270 Millions as the tool does NOT report automatically data in most conditions. Sorry but 270 millions is just the installed base not the sample.

    Unix is considered very secure with an infection rate of about 5%. Would security expert in Boston reacted to the news of a 2.11% as “Disturbing figures”, “bad news”, “malware out there worst than anyone could dream of”

    ????

  43. Virus, my quotes are from the original PDF from Microsoft with figures, and MS itself quotes that the tool does NOT automatically send data to MS, hence the article in TechNews reporting the “participating customers and businesses”.

    The 0.32% is the average monthly infection since MS started to received data (July 05). Monthly there has been something close to 800k PC infected, most of them NEW infections. And 800k is what you get when you do a 1 every ~311 computers (from the installed base).

    I think you simply want to get a non-corroborated-by-anyone, not even Microsoft, that the sample is the 270 Millions. Buddy, believe what you like but in Boston Microsoft would have screamed VICTORY!!!!!!!!!! WE ARE THE SAFEST OF ALL, not ‘disturbing report’.

    Amazing you do not see it. Kool-aid?

  44. And it is not Mac fan boys claims, it is Microsoft executives having given the DISTURBING FIGURES to people in Boston.

    The news is reported as a scary one in others magazines as well. Oh, and does not come from Mac web sites:

    Matt Braverman, the Microsoft program manager who collated the data, said: “The numbers speak for themselves,” Braverman said. “We’re seeing a significant amount of new variants every day.”

    The data also confirms that rootkits on Windows machines are a “potential emerging threat,”

    A potential emerging threat with 0.32% infection? Pleeeassse. If all those 270 Millions PC had reported data, which Microsoft EXPLICITLY says IT AIN’T so, so to justify your – and yours only, not even MS dares to say that – conclusion the mood would be that of victory over malware not of defeat:

    Roger Thompson, chief technology officer at Atlanta-based Exploit Prevention Labs, however, said Microsoft’s low rootkit detections are not an accurate reflection of the threat. “They’re only finding what they’re looking for. The tool will not find the rootkits we don’t know about,” Thompson said.

    Braverman echoed an earlier statement by a Microsoft security official that businesses consider investing in an automated process to wipe hard drives and reinstall operating systems as a practical way to recover from rootkit infestation.

    Again, WIPE HARD DRIVES as measures against infection with a practically zero rate? (0.32%, keep dreaming Windoze boy).

    Microsoft is giving only absolute data from the “participating” customers, never explicitly said it collected data from the installed base – 270 Millions -, explicitly says that the tool does not send automatically data to MS, and in at least one case it NEVER does, but there is poor Windoze Virus user that sticks to his illusions.

    Buddy: sorry to remind it to you “6 out of 10 PC”. Microsoft statement.

    Oh wait, they are so IDIOTS in Redmond that they forget to call the press in all world and announce “ONLY 0.36% of Windows PC get infected” and not sue all the magazines reporting instead: “Microsoft warns: 60% of PC infected”.

    What a bunch of wankers.

  45. “It is against this backdrop that Fathi takes over as Microsoft’s new security chief to guide the company through a crucial period in its history.

    Fathi, who most recently served as general manager for storage and high availability in Microsoft’s Windows division, will use the TechEd conference to deliver a strategic briefing on building trust in computing.

    Fathi is expected to highlight Microsoft’s investment in security technologies—in the enterprise and consumer markets—and position the company as a leader in developing trust in an interconnected world.

    Mike Nash, Microsoft’s long-serving corporate vice president who has handed over the security portfolio to Fathi, said Fathi’s “first priority is Vista. The second priority is Vista. The third is Vista.””

    Dreams are your reality buddy. Keep dreaming.

    PS
    Source of the text: Microsoft.

  46. Virus…. p0wned again.

    C’mon virus, it is so blatantly evident I am worried for your sanity. Nowhere you may claim 5.7 millions infection reported by 270 Millions PC.

    Microsoft would have loved that figures and – rightly so – made everyone delighted and screaming all over the places. ONLY 0.32% of PC infected. Better than Fort Knox.

    What they come out with instead? Wake up.

  47. eWeek: “Microsoft sounds Malware alarm”

    alarm with a 0.32% infection rate? Try 60% !

    YNot industry news: “Microsoft anti-malware team found that “Backdoor Trojans,” which can allow an attacker to control infected computers remotely, “are a significant and tangible threat to Windows users..”

    significant and tangible threat to 0.32% of users there? Try 60% !

    Microsoft also emphasized that the MSRT “does not target spyware and potentially unwanted software.”

    “Windows users should download and install an up-to-date antispyware application to detect and remove spyware and potentially unwanted software from their computers,” Microsoft states in the malware report. “We highly recommend that Windows users install and maintain an up-to-date antivirus solution offering real-time protection and a complete antivirus signature database.”

    How many users? 0.32% ? LOL, try 60% !

    holy_father, the creator of the Hacker Defender rootkit, claims the MSRT (Microsoft Software Removal Tool) cannot successfully detect newer versions of the offensive rootkit:

    “Microsoft claims that Windows Malicious Software Removal Tool for XP/2000/2003 (MSRT) can detect Hacker Defender. I always test the latest MSRT with Hacker Defender, and the latest MSRT does not even detect the latest public version of Hacker Defender (hxdef 1.0.0 revisited), which was published weeks ago and is available for download to everyone, with full source code.”

    Do not worry Virus, that rootkit will only infect 0.32% of users. HAHAHHAHAH. That’s 60% for you buddy, but don’t say it around!

    eWeek: “This announcement comes at a crucial time for the Redmond, Wash., company, which is struggling to cope with a dramatic rise in malware infections on Windows systems.

    Based on statistics culled from the company’s MSRT (malicious software removal tool), Microsoft rates the danger from backdoor Trojans and bots as “a significant and tangible threat.”

    Nahhh, not to worry, Microsoft is struggling to squash the last 0.32% of Windows installations from malware, then it will be over. spfffff, hhhehhoeommme, uhuuuhhhu, can’t resist! UHOHHAHAHAHAHAHAH.
    60% baby, it is 6 out of 10 PC. Now that’s struggling!

    ZDnet: “Peter Watson, chief security advisor for Microsoft Australia and New Zealand, told ZDNet Australia that Client Protection will be released as a beta product for “selected customers” by the end of 2005.
    “It is a combination of our Malicious Software Removal Tool (MSRT) and our Anti-spyware tool. We are looking to productise it and make it available into the enterprise space,” said Watson.
    The MSRT is currently available free to consumers from Microsoft’s Web site but Watson explained that the new product has been redesigned to be used by enterprises and will contain a central management interface.
    Watson said Microsoft would announce pricing details closer to the time of their actual launch — after the beta testing phase”

    to how many PC users are they going to sell this? 0.32%. WOW, what a loss. Ahh wait, for some weird reasons Microsoft expect to sell to at least 60% of its customer base. Wonder why?

    The Register: “Stats from its use present a new perspective on how bad the Windows malware problem really is.”

    bad problem? BAD with only 0.32% of infection rate? Wait, Microsoft says “6 out of 10 PC” showed infection. Ahhh, 60%, now THAT’s a bad problem!

    TechWeb Business Technology Network: “At its Tech Ed 2006 conference in Boston today, Microsoft’s acknowledgement of what the rest of the industry already knew: Windows is full of security bugs. In the white paper, Microsoft calls backdoor Trojans a “significant and tangible threat to Windows users.”

    what? full of security bugs? With only 0.32% infections. What? ahhh, 60% infected PC is the actual conclusion. Statement is clearer now. LOL

    “It’s a bit like the character in ‘Casablanca’ who’s shocked to find gambling going on,” says Andrew Jaquith, senior analyst with The Yankee Group. “It’s nice to see Microsoft confirming these things, but it’s not exactly news.”

    What? going on? it is squashed per Virus understanding of only 0.32% infection. Malware is dead. pssssst, it is 60%, now you get why the statement of shocked about gambling going on? ROFLMAO

    Do we really need to go on?

  48. Head Up Bill’s Arse Virus Windows user SUES Microsoft for not revealing to the world his truth – Virus’ truth that is.

    While he was carried away from asylum nurses he was heard screaming “We are safe, we are safe, it is only 0.32% of infected PC out there, hear me, HEAR ME, it is 0.32 perceeeeeeeennntttt”

    Then the ambulance door was shut and the dreamer never heard of again.

  49. “It appears that MSN has been struck by a vindictive new worm, according to security company Panda Software. The worm, acting in the vein of movies like the Ring and FearDotCom, delivers a fateful terror message and then proceeds to disable most of your protection software like anti-virus,firewalls and even your Windows control apps (TaskManager, Regedit). It distributes itself to all your MSN contacts by sending a video called ‘Fantasma.'”

    <b>Nothing to worry though, only 0.32% of Windows users will be infected<b>

    What? approaching the million already? IMPOSSIBLE!

    ROFL

  50. Magazine Articles, Read the original Microsoft paper, look at the numbers, see what was actually said.

    Don’t rely on what some journalist mis-interpreted was said.

    Then maybe you’ll stop guffawing like an idiot and realize you’re wrong.

    Whoever said you shouldn’t run an antivirus program as well?

    Viruses are a signigicant and tangible threat to all Windows users.

    100% of Windows users should run an antivirus. That’s how you avoid the virus problem. If you don’t you will likely become infected sooner or later.

    There’s no doubt it’s a problem but there’s also no doubt that the solution is very straightforward.

    Get a grip on logic, infection rates are low because the countermeasuresd are effective, not in spite of them.

    “Wait, Microsoft says “6 out of 10 PC” showed infection. ”

    No they say 6 out of 10 pcs which were infected were infected by a trojan you dumbass.

  51. LOL, in total denial. IDIOT, did you ask yourself why Microsoft shuts the fuck up, contrary of you?

    And nope, they say “6 out of 10 PC” were infected, for a disturbing figure of 60% infection rate. Then, of the 5.7 million of scanned PC there has been a 62% having a trojan for a total of 3.5 Millions.

    The more you post the more shit falls on your head.

    Retarded? HOHOHEHAOHAHAHAHAHAHA ROFLMAO

    Sux big time being so frigging stupid!

    LOOOOSEER

  52. Whatever you all say guys, the 0.32% figure is meaningless. It only comes from the reported infection from MS tool and Microsoft itself says that reports are not automatic, users can say no, and tools installed via Software Update never talk back to Microsoft.

    0.32% is a careful spin to hide the truth that was apparent to tech people in Boston.

    Virus, if there will be a Microsoft hit back at all these magazines and articles than they will say how it is. In lack of this, sorry, but Microsoft is caught red handed and with pants down.

    If it was a bashing on Mac one could possibly argue it is the usual pundit bashing of Apple. But FER CRISSAKE, these comments are from Windows apologists that usually lick Bill’s arse. Does not ring an alarm bell at your place?

  53. Yahoo News: “Microsoft on Monday said that it found and removed malicious programs – called “bots” – from six out of 10 Windows computers checked during a recent 15-month period.”

    Trojans? Nope, bots. Of those 62% had trojans as well.

  54. if you’re looking at the wrong article yes.

    Look at the paper Microsoft actually published.

    Then you might feel a bit foolish.

    “Sux big time being so frigging stupid!”

    At least the first step is recognising your problem. With time you will learn to read. The comprehend, then you might become smarter.

    “why Microsoft shuts the fuck up,”

    Microsoft published this info. Again work on that reading comprehension and logic. They probably have special ed classes at your school. Get your mum to talk to the counselors about it.

    It ran on 270 million computers. of those 270 million 5.7 million had some malware removed, of those 5.7 million 62% had a backdoor trojan.

    Not 62% of the total it ran on. 62% of the machines from which malware was removed.

    I will repeat the relevant line here a few times ahead of the main text since you seem a little slow.

    “Thus, of the 5.7 million unique computers from which the tool has removed malware, a backdoor Trojan was present in 62 percent of computers.”

    “Thus, of the 5.7 million unique computers from which the tool has removed malware, a backdoor Trojan was present in 62 percent of computers.”

    “Thus, of the 5.7 million unique computers from which the tool has removed malware, a backdoor Trojan was present in 62 percent of computers.”

    “Thus, of the 5.7 million unique computers from which the tool has removed malware, a backdoor Trojan was present in 62 percent of computers.”

    To quote the whole summary:

    Microsoft delivered the first version of the MSRT on Jan. 13, 2005, in 24 languages to users of Windows 2000-, Windows XP- and Windows Server™ 2003-based computers. The tool is designed to help identify and remove prevalent malware from customer computers and is available at no charge to licensed Windows users. As of the writing of this report, Microsoft has shipped 15 additional enhanced versions of the tool and continues to ship a new version on the second Tuesday of each month, each adding new prevalent malware to detect and remove. Since the initial release of the MSRT, the tool has been executed approximately 2.7 billion times by at least 270 million unique computers.

    This report provides an in-depth perspective on the malware landscape based on the data collected by the MSRT, and highlights the impact that the MSRT has had in reducing the impact of malware on Windows users. Key insights from the data are summarized below and are covered in greater detail in the body of the paper.

    • The MSRT has removed 16 million instances of malicious software from 5.7 million unique Windows-based computers over the past 15 months. On average, the tool removes at least one instance of malware from every 311 computers it runs on.

    • Forty-one of the 61 malware families targeted by the MSRT from January 2005 to February 2006 have been detected less frequently since being added to the tool, with 21 of the families experiencing decreases greater than 75 percent.

    • Backdoor Trojans, which can enable an attacker to control an infected computer and steal confidential information, are a significant and tangible threat to Windows users. The MSRT has removed at least one backdoor Trojan each from approximately 3.5 million unique computers. Thus, of the 5.7 million unique computers from which the tool has removed malware, a backdoor Trojan was present in 62 percent of computers. Bots, a subcategory of backdoor Trojans that communicate through the Internet Relay Chat (IRC) network, represent a majority of the removals.

  55. Jason Garms, architect and group program manager in Microsoft’s Anti-Malware Technology Team, shared statistics culled from the worm cleansing tool in an interview with Ziff Davis Internet News and warned that the high rate of rootkit infections confirm fears that virus writers are using the most sophisticated techniques to hide malicious programs.

    Shall we rely on Microsoft statement or are they mis-interpreted or mis-reported? Wow, MS will win big from all those pending lawsuit against slur, libeling and misinformation damaging MS image.

    Garms continues: “For the most part, the rootkits are being detected and removed from Windows XP (gold) versions but infection rates on XP SP1 and XP SP2 machines are also high.

    The Ispro rootkit, for example, was prevalent on 50 percent of all Windows XP machines without a service pack. About 20 percent of all scans of machines running XP SP1 and SP2 also found the rootkit.”

    infection rates are high? 50% of vanilla XP infected by Ispro? 20% of those with SP1 and SP2 infected as well?

    Impossible. Head Up Bill’s Arse Windows user Virus claims the infection rate is no greater than 0.32% . Who is this Garms architect and group program manager in Microsoft’s Anti-Malware Technology Team idiot anyway? We better believe our beloved fool Virus.

    VIRUS for ever!

  56. Virus, you still do not get it right?

    270 Million machines run the tool but the data do not come from 270 million machines. The tool does not automatically send data to the motherbase.

    So forget about your calculation on 270 Million. It comes from the spin saying that 5.7 reports from machines represent 0.32% of installed base. But nowhere it is said that the 270 Millions machines actually reported regularly.

    Again, in the very same article you keep referring to Microsoft states that the tool does not phone back home automatically. Hence there has been a sample and the 0.32% is a meaningless spin effort to bait Windows faithful like you.

    Why don’t you get Garms mum to talkt to your counselors?

  57. Yep, the truth’s out:

    100% of machines from which the Microsoft malicious Software Removal Tool removed malware had malware on them.

    Shock. Horror.

    Good luck with learing to read and comprehend “Magazines reports”

  58. Fantastic, not even Microsoft architect and group program manager in Microsoft’s Anti-Malware Technology Team understands his reports and spouts non-existing infection rates of 50% while alone in the world our own troll of the month sees it clearly.

    As was stated above, till Microsoft does not come out with the actual number of monitored machines the report only gives absolute values.

    By Microsoft own statements, even in its own report, 270 million PC is just the installed base, not the sample.

  59. It ran on 270 million computers. of those 270 million 5.7 million had some malware removed, of those 5.7 million 62% had a backdoor trojan.

    I dare you to find the above statement on the report. It is your interpretation even with Microsoft saying that the tool does NOT REPORT if the user does not want, and tool installed with Software update NEVER reports back.

    270 millions gullible Windows for sure. 270 millions monitored PC my ass.

    What do you need, a call from Balmer asking you to shut up?

  60. The tool runs on over 270 Million PCs. Some of them are setup so to report back data when they find malware. Those reports amount to 5.7 Millions PCs.

    Percentage of infection? Stating that Microsoft is unreliable anyway, hence the 50% of the MS architect above might be balooney anyway, there is no way to know what % those 5.7 Mill reports are in that we do not know how many of those 270 Mil install do actually report when the PC is infected.

    Certainly not all the Windows 2k and Server 3000 installations in that they receive the tool via Windows or Microsoft Update. AND those kind of installation, Microsoft says in the whitepaper, NEVER reports data back to MS.

    So only the XP installation could actually report but the user is prompted with a confirmation panel asking whether it has to send data to Microsoft. The user can say NO.

    So a subgroup of those 270 Mil can report data back. A subgroup of the subgroup could report the data if the user says YES. Hence a certain percentage of the subgroup of the subgroup of 270 Mil install has reported data back. They amount to 5.7 Millions.

    0.32% ? Impossible. Only if all 270 Mil were able to report and with users only knowing the word YES. Microsoft ensures us that this is not possible as the tool obtained via Windwos Update NEVER sends data back.

    0.32% is then balooney. But we can’t provide a meaningful % from the report either.

    One has to hope for MS that at least his own security team architect knows what is talking about when he states infection rate of 50%.

    But, seeing the general quality level of MS software also the above would be a miracle.

  61. What do you mean, doesn’t send back information?

    Here’s the info on what it sends back. no PERSONALLY identifiable information. Just how many people do you think edit the registry to disable it reporting back?

    Remember the way this works is, if you have Windows automatic updates turned on (which you do unless you actually manually turned them off) every 2nd Tuesday of the month, a new version (or update if you already have it) downloads, scans your PC and reports back to MS if it finds anything.

    So they know when you ran the tool, they know what it found.

    I mean c’mon guys, read the report before spouting off about what they did and didn’t do, what their methodology is etc.

    Data Collection Details

    To enable the Microsoft Antimalware Team to obtain accurate data about the state of malware within the Windows ecosystem, the MSRT collects select infection-related information from customer computers, none of which can be used to personally identify a specific user. This information is sent to Microsoft only in the event that the tool detects malicious software on a computer. Users also have an option to prevent the software from reporting back to Microsoft by modifying the registry. The tool does not transmit any information back to Microsoft on computers that are updated by a Windows Server Update Services server.

    The following information is sent back to Microsoft:

    • The name of the malicious software detected on the computer
    • The result of the attempt to remove the malicious software
    • The operating system version, including the service pack number
    • The locale of the operating system
    • The processor architecture
    • The version number of the tool
    • An indicator that denotes whether the tool is being run from WU/AU, from the Download Center or from the MSRT Web site
    • An anonymous GUID that is used to track the number of unique computers that have removed malware. It is generated explicitly for this scenario.
    • A cryptographic one-way hash (MD5) of the path and file name of each malicious software file that is removed from the computer. Because they could be considered personal information, neither the actual path nor the file name is sent.

    In cases where the tool detects software on a computer that may be potentially malicious, users are prompted to send the file(s) to Microsoft along with the cryptographic one-way hash (MD5). The Microsoft Antimalware Team analyzes the submissions and adds them to the threat database if necessary.

  62. And before you say it doesn’t get info if updated thru Windows Server Update Services, just how many home users do you think have a Windows server running Windows Server Update Services rather than just going straight to the Microsoft site?

    Likely the malware status of such centrally maintained corporate PCs is lower than the general population.

  63. from the above it seems corporate user will not comunicate data back (update via WSUS). Concerning how many users would not allow the report… honestly I think quite a lot.

    So I tend to stay on the camp that not all 270 Mil was actually able or allowed to report data back even in case of an infection.

    Then, Virus, MSRT has not a complete data base: even MS says it is not a replacement of an anti-virus. On the MS document, only 4 virus are there, the rest are rootkit, bots and trojans.

    It certainly is not a report that could allow anyone to conclude to a 0.32% overall infection rate for Windows. Apart all the commentaries, even from security experts, all around the “Microsoft is vulnerable more than expected” leitmotiv, c’mon Virus, if Windows had a 0.32% infection rate from malware would anyone point at anything but Windows as reference in security?

    Would there be major virus attacks and world havoc every time a new malware comes out? I hope you realize 0.32% infection rate means practically nothing, practically invulnerable OS. I hope you do not really believe that, or do you?

  64. Likely the malware status of such centrally maintained corporate PCs is lower than the general population.

    not exactly if one has to judge from corporation shutting down at every major new effective virus. Anyway, just the above would allow anyone to conclude that one cannot take the 270 millions as monitored PC and use that to get 0.32%

    By the way, corporate users is a very big chunk of Windows users.

  65. and frankly, MS reprs would be all over the place if they could truly say that infection rate is a minuscule 0.32% , don’t you think? That is way better than any Unix flavor has shown in the past.

    I searched for this Garm guy from Microsoft. He says at least 70% of XP installs does not have yet SP2 nor SP1. That the majority of users do not keep their Windows updated with security and that he expect a 50% infection rate on XP (with the above conditions).

    Is he crazy?

  66. Being reading a lot. There is the benefit of doubt. One can conclude that XP features much better than other Windows flavors (which can’t run the tool anyway). But I still do not see where one can get the actual number of PC Microsoft have been monitoring or which base actually was able to report an infection if it was present.

    From the 270 Mill and more installation of the MRST and various reports and statement one can conclude that 270+ Mil is just the installed base, not the size of the sample.

    But I agree that with all pundits around claiming ‘bad bad results’ everywhere, and MS reprs warning everyone to use anti-malware software because it is crucial one cannot reasonably believe to such low infection rate of 0.32 which would be phenomenal. Heck, even 2% or 3% would allow Microsoft to cut short discussions of vulnerability and claim “We did it!”

  67. Guys, not to put water on fire but do you realize that Windows recognized malware virus like tally is over 140,000 and that MSRT cover 4 virus and a bunch of bots and trojans?

    It might even be that you get infected one over 311 for those, and 9999 out of 10000 for the others.

    The report has been anyway received as bad news and used by Microsoft to urge its customers to buy into its soon to be released security program.
    Could not sell it if it could claim to be safe as Virus claims or seems to imply.

  68. Remember it’s not all corporate users not reporting, it’s corporate users who are running Windows Server Update Services rather than letting people go straight to the MS site who are not reporting. Now how many corporate uses is that?

    I would argue that corporate users overall have better antivirus policies, better PC update policies and more sophisticated firewalls and mail filtering capable of blocking threats, and have IT departments who are more adept at removing spyware, so are better of compared to most home users.

    But in any case, just because some classes of customers were not included in the sample doesn’t mean you can’t make inferences about the class of customers who were.

    iplodder, how you can’t get to 270 million is because you don’t understand how this tool works. the windows update installs it, runs it once and reports. there’s not even an icon on the desktop you can use to re-run it without specially installing it. For the auto installed version, INSTALLING IT MEANS RUNNING IT. MS Says the’ve installed via the update site it on 270 million unique PCs which means if you beleive MS, it’s been run on that many. You can’t disable reporting of known malware without running regedit doing some manual registry editing and turning it off, that’s not something most people would likely do.

    And remember the 0.32% is approximately the number infected at ANY ONE TIME, not the number ever infected, that was that 2.1% of machines have ever been infected.

    And yes, it’s only a limited number of viruses/bots but the criteria for including them is that the’re malicious and actually being seen on a reasonable number of machines in the wild. this is NOT a replacement for your normal antivirus. but lets face it it’s 1% or less of the viruses that cause 99% of the havoc, and MS is targeting those. But again this is NOT a replacement for your antivirus. Run without antivirus, you likely WILL become infected.

    So while the tool’s not finding much malware, nobody’s saying that if people dumped thier antivirus products and malware cleaning products that they wouldn’t quickly become infected.

    But many a Mac user would have you beleive that the average PC user can’t get anything done because his PC is so loaded down with malware and viruses. That’s certianly not my real world experience, nor is it a finding this survey supports. Quite the reverse.

  69. Here is what Microsoft ACTUALLY said:

    “Combining the data shown in Figure 1 with that shown in Figure 3 allows us to determine that, in the most recent release of the MSRT (March 2006), the rate of infected computers per executions of the tool was 0.28 percent. In other words, the tool removed malware from approximately one in every 355 computers on which it ran. The average rate across all releases from June 2005 to March 2006 is similar, at 0.32 percent, or approximately one in every 311 computers. This infection rate has remained relatively constant across the measurable releases, with the high being 0.4 percent in August 2005 and the low being 0.24 percent in September 2005.”

    That would make these articles, and the erroneous interpretation of the statistics, FUD.

    urther reading shows that Microsoft was NOT all inclusive in their Malware report… Microsoft’s report also states:

    “The tool does not target spyware and potentially unwanted software. Windows users should download and install an up-to-date anti-spyware application to detect and remove spyware and potentially unwanted software from their computers. Windows Defender, Microsoft’s anti-spyware solution, in beta at the time of this report, is offered to genuinely licensed Windows users at no charge at http://www.microsoft.com/windowsdefender.”

  70. K, made up my mind and sharing with you, for what is worth.

    The number of installations is more or less the base. Unless corporate users are a lot which MS does not states. I still think they are a considerable chunk of the installations but there is no way to get that numbers. What is anyway truly sloppy – sorry but it is sloppy – is that percentage is obtained by the total number of installation while the total number of installation is bigger than the number of reporting tools. This is what MS itself says. Corporate users via Windows Servers Update Service do not report (and in corporate I do not see IT dept letting users do the update themselves). So essentially the actual base for the statistic results is practically the consumers which explains as well the figure of 98% of reports from Windows XP users.

    As Virus points, it is not a substitute for protection although it will make part of the future MS protection service, via a fee.

    Amazingly, MS also announced that XP SP1 support has been discontinued.

    The % is the monthly rate of infection – using as base the total base. Using the real base would change this figure but only MS knows by how much.

    The db essentially covers what MS consider the most virulent and dangerous malware around. This explains why only 4 virus are in the tool db while most are bots (for zombie PCs pool creation).

    With all these taken into account I understand better why security expert took the report as bad news.

  71. In cases where the tool detects software on a computer that may be potentially malicious, users are prompted to send the file(s) to Microsoft

    The above is still mysterious. Which cases are those? malicious activity not present in the data base?

    Not flaming, but after much mulling over it, the report keeps lots of dust under the carpet. My thesis supervisor would have rejected it.

  72. But many a Mac user would have you beleive that the average PC user can’t get anything done because his PC is so loaded down with malware and viruses. That’s certianly not my real world experience, nor is it a finding this survey supports. Quite the reverse. — Virus

    I disagree with what the report actually shows since it does have a limited db. It is indeed a very limited scope.

    Sure, as you say, the most virulent are the ones that are targeted but, again as you say, they constitute a very small sample of the malware around.

    In my real world experience I see quite few times Windows users having to wipe out the disk and re-install from scratch everything because their PC is not in a recoverable state even after many passes of their incredible large set of protection tools – ie working and with initial spiffness -.

    Incidentally, the practice is what MS security representatives have suggested as practice for business as a default procedure. Which, by itself, should be an eye-opener.

  73. iplodder, the key in virus protection is not to get hit because you are protected (or at least have a very narrow window of vunerability to any given virus that you don’t have signature for and which can slip past virus programs “suspicious activity” filters) rather than to try to clean up after the fact.

    How do you recover well from rm -r / or it’s equivalents? You’re looking at this from the wrong end so perhaps have unreasonable expectations on how “magic” a virus cleanup utility can be.

    and yes iplodder with respect to your suspicious activity question, most virus programs look for activity that might be a virus, even though it’s not in the signature file.

    The other thing you can look at is that 60% of the attacks were trojans, so the major fault was located between the keyboard and the chair. If only we could stop people running things like naked britney.jpeg.exe, or opening every mail from their friends which says “run this it’s really cool”, then a lot of problems would go away. If you’ve seen the evolution of Windows over time there’s a lot of work going in to solving that particular class of problems.

    Remember too, this group is the sample of people who are doing things right (albeit perhaps without knowing it since it’s now automatic with XP SP20. they are patching their systems automatically when new patches come out, getting the latest updates to protect against holes and make social engineering attacks more difficult. The most fertile fields for attacks are people who don’t do that.

  74. If only we could stop people running things like naked britney.jpeg.exe, or opening every mail from their friends which says “run this it’s really cool”, then a lot of problems would go away. If you’ve seen the evolution of Windows over time there’s a lot of work going in to solving that particular class of problems.

    You can’t stop people doing that, that’s why the problem has been solved already on the Mac. Getting fscked just by opening emails is truly ridiculous.

    the jpg.exe as well: why Windows can’t warn the user that it actually is double-clicking on an executable and not a picture?

    In addition to that: why Windows cannot work with external ports closed so not to let virus in in the first place. Exactly: the key issue is not in cleaning up but not let the shit in.

    The Mac is even invisible to ping. Essentially it is by default in a stealth mode. Virus can try all the ports they want at a given IP but gets no reply from a Mac.

    Windows on the contrary screams out loud: “Hey I am here, anyone wants to talk to me?” Open house all the time, not just on weekends.

    Maybe they’ll do it in Vista if it ever gets out. More and more it looks like XP SP3.

  75. and the problem is…

    The problem isn’t solved on the Mac. Windows does warn, people say run it anyway because they’re dumb, and they think that looking at the word jpeg in the name means it’s safe despite all the warnings. Send a bad file to a Mac user which they run despite the O/S warnings, same result. the Mac is no safer in this regard.

    Now before you say it only runs with the privileges of the user who opens it, open a command prompt, type

    rm -rf /

    and see if you don’t loose a bunch of stuff you really wish you hadn’t. Go on, do that before posting back how safe the Mac is because the thing that gets run doesn’t have root privileges.

    And unless you’ve been living in a cave, you do know that there have been exploits which let you run arbitrary code on a Mac.

    With the SP2 firewall, most ports are closed by default.

    Do you even know what happens with the Windows Firewall when you enable it ant tell it “no exceptions”?

    Apparently not. Try pinging the box then…

    So get with the latest state of Windows security, not how it used to be 10 years ago…

  76. I might get flamed for this, but you don’t need a Mac to be safer. There is free software available for the PC that blocks spyware before it ever installs. It’s called SpywareBlaster. You can learn about it here: http://natron.blog.ca/2006/07/04/you_can_stop_spyware~933309

    I’m not try to say anything bad about Mac. They run an Intel CPUs, so they can run windows and Mac software, which I think is cool. But for people who already own a windows PC, installing some free software is cheaper and easier than buying a Mac.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.