SmartMoney publishes compendium of iPod FUD’s Noah Rothbaum has penned a complete collection of iPod FUD all in one convenient article. We’ll pick them off one-by one.

Rothbaum covers the following in his “10 Things Your iPod Won’t Tell You” article:

1. iPod’s reign may be coming to an end (MacDailyNews Take: 2006 edition. See previous 2005, 2004, 2003, 2002, and 2001 editions. According to Rothbaum, the end is near supposedly because of the proprietary iPod+iTunes symbiotic relationship that, by the way, continues to gain market share. Remember, in FUD-land, Apple’s solution that works on both Macs and Windows PCs is “proprietary,” but all other stores and players that use Microsoft’s Windows-only WMA format aren’t.)

2. Customer Service isn’t what it used to be (MacDailyNews Take: If you don’t pay Apple — consistently rated tops in consumer satisfaction by leading purveyors of such surveys — $59 for the AppleCare Protection Plan which allows you two years of unlimited calls, you have to pay $49 per call after getting one free in the first 90 days. Yeah, so?

3. If you drop the iPod it might break (MacDailyNews Take: As opposed to those also-ran players from Sony, Creative, etc. that just Bumble bounce right back up into your hand unscathed. Oh, yeah, iPod screens scratch, too. Get a case.)

4. It’s easy to load your iPod with music, but to appease music labels, Apple’s made it difficult to get music off of iPods (MacDailyNews Take: iPodRip or any number of other similar utilities. It isn’t hard. Do also-ran players let you copy music off of them by default?)

5. iPod battery’s don’t last forever (MacDailyNews Take: But rechargeable batteries in every other device on earth never wear out.)

6. iPods will make you go deaf (MacDailyNews Take: But every other device on earth that makes sound makes it so pure that you’ll never harm your hearing, no matter how far you crank it up.)

7. iPods are updated too frequently, making them “out of date” too soon (MacDailyNews Take: Rothbaum would perhaps prefer a total lack of innovation and stagnation? He must use Windows.)

8. iPods spark crime (MacDailyNews Take: As opposed to wallets, purses, watches, vehicles, expensive sneakers, jewelry, etc. that are just the innocent victims of crime.)

9. Apple “nickel-and-dimes” you any chance they get (MacDailyNews Take: Apple charges separately for accessories that people might want instead of charging everyone more by including them all in every box – even though many don’t want or need them. If your iPod fails out of warranty, it’ll cost a lot to fix – again, supposedly unlike those from the also-ran player makers or the makers of any product of any sort that comes with a warranty.)

10. Once you go iPod, you’re locked in for life (MacDailyNews Take: That’s fine with us. This is how locked in we are: we can play iTunes Music Store-purchased songs on Macs, Windows PCs, iPod models for every budget, and burn them to CDs to play in CD players or import into other computers and/or music players. If we join a subscription service or use another à la carte service (Windows-only) with some “soon-to-be-discontinued, won’t-intgrate-with-my-vehicle, has-no-accessories, parent-company-is-hemorrhaging-cash or reorganizing” digital media player, do we get less lock-in or more?)

Full article here.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “Arthur” for the heads up.]

Get the new iMac with Intel Core Duo for as low as $31 A MONTH with Free shipping!
Get the MacBook Pro with Intel Core Duo for as low as $47 A MONTH with Free Shipping!
Apple’s new Mac mini. Intel Core, up to 4 times faster. Starting at just $599. Free shipping.
Apple’s brand new iPod Hi-Fi speaker system. Home stereo. Reinvented. Available now for $349 with free shipping.
iPod. 15,000 songs. 25,000 photos. 150 hours of video. The new iPod. 30GB and 60GB models start at just $299. Free shipping.
Connect iPod to your television set with the iPod AV Cable. Just $19.
iPod Radio Remote. Listen to FM radio on your iPod and control everything with a convenient wired remote. Just $49.


  1. Nice Bumble reference. That thing scared the crap outta me when I was a kid. Still kinda gives me the willies until the very end when the dentist elf has pulled all his teeth out and he’s become tame and lovable.

  2. Holy crap, this quote from the article is priceless:

    “Apple’s edgy designs ‘tend to be more attractive, but also more fragile’ than other players, says industry analyst Rob Enderle.”

    He quoted Rob “dumbass” Enderle? Do I even need to point out exactly how intellectually bankrupt this article is?

  3. Yaah, uhhh, what’s the so-far-unknown “news” that’s causing AAPL to fall today?

    This company rules and it gets treated like sh*t by the assclowns on Wall Street. F-ckers.

  4. No negative Apple news, so this is just another bear raid on AAPL. It happens, chumps freak out and sell, then pros pick up cheap stock and make a killing.
    Moral of the story: don’t be a chump.

  5. Uhh, the whole market is “tanking” today. Any “smart money” knows that a single day does not make a trend, which tends to prove that “Investor” is hardly an investor.

    Compared to AAPL in February, the stock is up more than 15%!

    It’s always funny when people try to act like they know what they are talking about by throwing around numbers out of context.

  6. the market is taking a beating across the board – it isn’t an appl thing

    as I write this, aapl and goog are both down 3%

    one final thought: “SmartMoney” is a serious misnomer.

  7. It looks like “SmartMoney” isn’t.

    (I’m only making this joke because I can’t believe no-one else has yet.)

    Bashing iPods is so two years ago. These days, nearly everybody falls into one of three categories:

    — Has an iPod
    — Wants an iPod
    — Isn’t interested in a digital music player

    Outside of that, there’s the itty-bitty iRiver cult and people who buy other brands out of sheer ignorance. That’s pretty much it.

  8. Apple – no longer beleaguered

    Now –

    They are a menace to the competition.

    Time to spread the FEAR – what next; terrorists use them?

    Oh yeah … and BOO!

    Hey “investor” everything is down smart guy. Must mean a market crash! Not.

  9. Apple is “tanking” … down nearly 4% on the day!

    Well … that should be no surprise. It’s trailing P/E is nearly twice Dell’s (~34 vs ~16) and it’s market cap is still higher than Dell’s (~$57B vs ~$56B). That could certainly inspire some profit-taking.

    Oh, yeah, we were talking about iPods! I forget when I bought mine. Well, not exactly. It was the first day the 30GB 3Gs went on sale … I just don’t remember the date. Anyway, it was WAY more than 18 months ago … and it’s been to six states (excluding my home) with me and survived several months of daily use in NYC – and it still works just fine and it still offers more than I need. Maybe I’ll upgrade when I get a digital camera?

    I could listen to it eight hours a day, every day, for a month, without a repeat. 99% of it was paid for (ripped from my own legal CDs or from iTMS) or legally free – I’m working on the rest.

  10. “Speaking of “Smart Money”, AAPL is tanking.

    67.99 (-2.61)”

    It’s not AAPL that is tanking – it is the ENTIRE market. Take a look at the overall market before you start assuming something is wrong at Apple. BTW, driven a car much lately? How about that gas pricing?

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.