“Let’s introduce the competitors in our first bout,” Michelle Thatcher writes for CNET Reviews. “In this corner, we have the 15.4-inch MacBook Pro running Mac OS 10.4 and equipped with a 2.0GHz Intel Core Duo (T2500) processor; 2GB of DDR2 SDRAM (666MHz); an ATI Mobility Radeon x1600 graphics card; and a 100GB hard drive spinning at 5,400rpm. (Note: this is a different configuration than the one we reviewed in March.) In the opposite corner, the Acer TravelMate 8200, running Windows XP Professional and equipped with a 2.0GHz Intel Core Duo (T2500) processor; 2GB of slightly slower DDR2 SDRAM (533MHz); an ATI Mobility Radeon x1600 graphics card; and a slightly larger 120GB hard drive spinning at 5,400rpm.”
Thatcher writes, “These two laptops are as evenly matched as any two you’re going to find. Only one can win. Let’s ring the bell, and let the fight begin!”
After going through the eight “rounds” of this “CNET Prizefight,” Thatcher figures that the Acer TravelMate 8200 bests the Apple MacBook Pro, 5 to 4.
Full article here.
[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “Too Hot!” for the heads up.]
MacDailyNews Take: CNET needs to just do away with these ridiculous “Prizefights.” The outcomes are always weirdly skewed, whether Apple wins or not, because they stupidly weight each of the eight “rounds” equally. And it makes the hapless “reviewers” that CNET forces to conduct these shams just end up looking like idiots. Look what they did to the “performance” category: the MacBook Pro was tested with apps that weren’t even Universal! Gee, the Acer is soooo much faster! Give us a break.
So, what’s the point, CNET? Your end result is utterly meaningless and your publication and reviewer look idiotic. Any computer user with a brain would want a MacBook Pro over an Acer TravelMate 8200 (sounds like a Thermos cooler). Imagine an auto magazine review pitting BMW against a Ford and devising a “prizefight” where the Ford “wins.” Can you say laughingstock?
To top it all off, the CNET review can’t even execute the basics right, totally missing features and ports included on the MacBook Pro, some of which the Acer cannot match (built-in iSight, backlit keyboard with ambient light sensors for automatic adjustment of keyboard illumination and screen brightness, etc.). Plus, as we’ve mentioned, the equal weighting of each “round” works about as well as Windows’ security. Can the Acer run both Mac OS X and Windows? Can the Acer run iLife? How much are just those two morsels worth? This whole “Prizefight” exercise makes CNET look ridiculous. When are you guys and gals going to finally cut the crap, CNET? It’s beyond really tired and, regardless of this current piece, your reputation as “anti-Mac” can never be undone. When it comes right down to it, Apples’ MacBook Pro didn’t “lose,” CNET did.
We have nothing against the Acer. We’re sure it’s a fine laptop that we’d never wish upon our worst enemy (we’d stick them with a Dell), but, let’s get real, the Acer simply does not “beat” the MacBook Pro in any “prizefight” outside of CNET.
Advertisements:
• Get the new iMac with Intel Core Duo for as low as $31 A MONTH with Free shipping!
• Get the MacBook Pro with Intel Core Duo for as low as $47 A MONTH with Free Shipping!
• Apple’s new Mac mini. Intel Core, up to 4 times faster. Starting at just $599. Free shipping.
• Apple’s brand new iPod Hi-Fi speaker system. Home stereo. Reinvented. Available now for $349 with free shipping.
• iPod. 15,000 songs. 25,000 photos. 150 hours of video. The new iPod. 30GB and 60GB models start at just $299. Free shipping.
• Connect iPod to your television set with the iPod AV Cable. Just $19.
• iPod Radio Remote. Listen to FM radio on your iPod and control everything with a convenient wired remote. Just $49.
Also no FrontRow…
Man, you need to learn to relax. Your ranting, even when you are right, makes you sound like a lunatic.
DC Guy,
MDN doesn’t sound like lunatics to me, they sound like people telling the truth. CNET is “anti-Mac.” These “Prizefights” are ridiculous. And anyone who picks the Acer over the MacBook is a moron who deserves to run Windows on an Acer for the rest of their life.
DC Guy = CNET Editor in Chief
“Sounds like a Thermos cooler.”
Bwahahahahahaha!
“We have nothing against the Acer. We’re sure it’s a fine laptop that we’d never wish upon our worst enemy (we’d stick them with a Dell)…”
Bwahahahahahahahahahahahaha!
Thanks for the laughs, MDN!
Interesting that the MacBook Pro is also CHEAPER!
Acer makes good laptops.
The problem is that the Mac is now being thought of as a standard “PC”, rather than remaining in a class of its own where it has always been. You can’t compare Apples and Oranges fairly, CNET. It’s about productivity.
Quite right MDN.
CNET most definitely IS agenda driven.
I’d love to line up 100 potential notebook buyers and let them have 10 minutes with each and then decide which they would have…
thats so dumb lol, why didnt they just compare time to apps like final cut…..oh no, not on pc. best compare an emulated app so the pc wins lol
Only one can win? Right. The one running Tiger.
Is it me or is it uncomfortable being numbered, compared, in the same boat as PCs?
We know what we have, why do we care.
Mac is not about numbers . . .
It is the experience.
It’s like the Toyota commercial, when does your care become more than just that?
My 17″ Powerbook is more than a computer, notebook . . .
It is the experience, the lifestyle, it’s not just a machine, i enjoy using it, lookforward to using it.
Can PC users say the same. It’s a chore to use a PC
Someone needs to redo CNET’s prize fight using real world rounds like total cost of ownership, available software (all Windows, most Mac, most Linux for the Mac, just Windows and Linux for the Acer), productivity, good looks, hardware features, included software, resale value, longevity of unit, et cetera. Fix the rounds so the Mac wins every one and show CNET what a sham, advertiser pleasing exercise they are running.
Why this over reaction? oh wait. Someone has given a better mark to something that’s not Apple. Of course MDN would rant pointlessly.
If CNET had a pointless argument, then MDN’s shouting is irrelevant as always.
Go Acer … Go Acer … !!!
Finally we see what advertisement money can get you!
The Truth … Acer Laptops are descent low priced laptops, however I would suggest a install of Linux.
Are they better than the Mac Book Pro – No they don’t even carry enough features to compare.
c´t magazine in Germany said just about the same thing about the Acer vs. apple.
They liked them both and really liked the lower priced Acer.
I’ve ignored anything that CNET has put out over the past few years and I’d suggest that everyone else do the same. It’s obvious who pays the bills over at that place…
I’d say that was a pretty decent review. Considering that most power users buy the MacBook Pro with performance in mind, it sure is embarassing that the Acer beat the Mac in Image editing, MP3 encoding, Video encoding, and Doom3 performance (awfull Mac Os X performance, embarassing)
MDN forgot to take the xanex today it appears. This site has gone from entertaining to joke status.
People tout why you should pick an Apple over a PC, yet some are saying that it needs to be rated in a category of its own. If you want to see Apple as an alternative, you need to compare it to what it’s an alternative for.
And yes, the ranting sounds a bit over the top. It’s just as easy to point out:
a) They do the speed tests with non-Universal apps, which obviously makes the MacBook Pro slower (not just that, they claimed, at least when I read it, that all but one show the Acer as faster when really it was all but two).
b) They rate each round equally. If you look at the ones where the Mac wins, it wins by a landslide (overall features, screen brightness, etc.).
The ones where Acer wins are usually neck and neck with a slight difference ($400 cheaper, but for a $2500 vs. $2900 laptop that’s relatively small). Yet it allows Acer to pull ahead.
CNet isn’t a dumb group for doing this, and I doubt they’re “anti-Mac”. I think they’re right in a lot of ways here: Acer does have a camera built in (if you read the ratings MDN). And it swivels around to take pictures in front of the computer too! That’s pretty nice if you ask me. And the Acer has other little things that made it win in their minds that wouldn’t hurt Apple to consider for a MacBook.
So let’s stop the insane ranting about “ridiculousness” and “they’re the losers” and think critically a bit. Isn’t that what you’re supposed to learn in education (Apple’s main selling point)?
“I’ve ignored anything that CNET has put out over the past few years and I’d suggest that everyone else do the same. It’s obvious who pays the bills over at that place…”
Yes, Apple. Apparently you are unaware that CNET will petty much give Apple the thumbs up for anything they do.
I suggest you read over prior reviews of all Apple products, including reading the “short takes” that praise Apple whenever they get a chance.
No wonder ppl are anoyed by mac users.
CNET is a paid hack for Microsoft, and that’s what these articles are about. If people are buying Macs, they aren’t buying Windows.
Any definition of ‘whore’ would have to include the “journalists” at CNET. They know nothing, and are prepared to sell themselves to the highest bidder.
Of course, the only firm in the universe that couldn’t get an honest review is Microsoft. Hence the use of journalistic “whores”.
My apologies to the ladies that ply their trade after dark. At the very least you don’t pretend to be something you’re not.
How many of you actually took five minutes to read the original CNet article? Really? If any of you had, you would see that far from being an anti-Apple rant, the review was actually very fair. It made it quite clear that Photoshop was running under Rosetta – the Macbook was slower on all the applications (native or not). It also had worse battery life. And lower screen resolution. And it was more expensive. And a smaller disk. And far fewer USB ports and expansion options. And a worse built in web cam. iLife is not everything – it’s a $70 software package – and not every user needs it. There are also equally functional PC packages for those who want them – some for free, such as Google’s Picasa.
If CNet had wanted to slate the Macbook Pro they could have done. As it was, they declared the Acer a marginal winner. It’s about as fair as any review gets. And far less biased than this site.
LOL
Mac users (mac’ers) really never like to hear anything that says .. Apple lost even a bit by any other vendor.
LOL
Mac users (mac’ers) really feel that you are the Gods.
ROFL at your:
“We have nothing against the Acer. We’re sure it’s a fine laptop that we’d never wish upon our worst enemy (we’d stick them with a Dell), but, let’s get real, the Acer simply does not “beat” the MacBook Pro in any “prizefight” outside of CNET.”
Your statement only proves that you are loser. You aren’t sport. You don’t want facts. You don’t want to accept reality. Get yourself those notebooks and see it for yourself.
Apple MacBook Pro is an ideal notebook but it is not for everyone. Only for those who want “this” only but not for those who want “this and that”.
Enough said.
I never trust CNET’s reviews for anything. They often run completely contrary to user reviews.
when I read a comment that gave a more balanced look on the Macbook, I submitted a complaint to the moderator that this post was offensive to CNET and their reviewers.
MDN “…the Acer simply does not “beat” the MacBook Pro in any “prizefight” outside of CNET.”
How would you know? You don´t own either one.
MDN your psychotic, illogical, no proof rants are making you look like a delusional idiot that has one foot in the nut house rubber room.
Interesting comparison! Nine tests, each given equal value.
Apple won the ‘appearance’ category. And how this is important?
Acer won the DOOM category. Guys, this is a laptop!
Apple blew Acer away in the ‘included software’ department, but,
Acer managed a win in the battery test by a hair. These are ‘equal’?
Looking at the entire test, I’d say the Apple came out slightly ahead in things that matter – especially as I am not going to give the battery test to Acer based on a less than a 5% ‘advantage’ – that’s a draw. Most of it is either not important enough to matter or close enough to not matter.
Apple loses on the HD and the price.
Apple wins on the included software (including OS X, which they ignored), system security (which they ignored) and warranty and support.
And, ‘R’?
FrontRow comes under ‘included software’. If that matters much.
CNET gets ad revenue every time you visit their pages and load the ad-images. That’s why they have a tabloid style of journalism and that’s why we should simply deprive them of funding by ignoring their stupid stories.
DC Guy: His ranting and posting of trivial Apple related news help get his ad revenue.
iLife….c´mon its a $79 toy.
How many people really use most of it more than to play around with? Nice software, but I am guessing most users rarely use it after the initial “look i made some sound on garage band”.
Does anyone buy an Apple computer solely because of iLife? Would you not buy it if it was not included?
“That’s why they have a tabloid style of journalism and that’s why we should simply deprive them of funding by ignoring their stupid stories.”
The same can certainly be said of this site.
I read the CNET review, I don’t want to sound like a MacHead but the article was definitely skew’ed away from the MacBook Pro.
To say that the Acer beat the MacBook Pro in feautures, performance and battery life was definitely pushed for the Acer by the writer.
I think one or two could have been a draw but not an outright win. The fact she gave a tie for warranty is amazing.
I smell fear on the part of the MS camp.
They use to say Tiger was a rip off of Longhorn/Vista – now that Tiger has launched and Longhorn/Vista may be a year later, the MS crowd has become silent and is now trying another approach to put down Apple.
I think we need to be prepared the FUD will be louder and more of it as the holiday season starts.
They have to prevent the Switchers from switching at the end of the year, because for every Switcher that’s going to be one less Vista buyer in 2007.
The War has started and it will be a bloody battle.
Be prepared!
Weeble: “CNET gets ad revenue every time you visit their pages and load the ad-images. “
So they are just like MDN then. Or did you miss all those ads on MDN?
Oh come on stantheman I have been using Macs for 25 years and for most of that time I have listened to morons on the pc side claiming superiority based on little more than the intelligence of a playground bundle, and the open mind of an Islamic fundamentalist. I am afraid that your own inherent prejudice in your final comment says everything about why that is. They may see a lot but seldom recognise anything when looking in a mirror.
Reality,
We may not agree with ‘who won’, in this, but we agree that the article was written without a huge amount of bias. When one squeaked by the other they said so. The test may have been flawed in design, but the commentary matched the results. They made it fairly easy to go beyond their headline-result to determine how the various results match your own needs.
Greg,
There’s a bridge out there missing its troll, isn’t it time you got back to work?
I don’t think that CNET is necessarily “anti-Mac”, but they definitely are NOT knowledgeable about Macs.
Ignorant, but not anti-Mac.
These are the folks we need to ‘convert’. Flaming them is not useful, educating them is.
MW: Call – as in call every PC user you know and thell them how wonderful Macs are!!
One bit of misinformation in the CNET review. They state an advantage of the Acer is it’s digital audio and S-Video capabilities, when in fact the MacBook Pro has digital audio in and out, and well as S-Video out (using an adaptor cable).
Apparently most users on this site (and MDN included) fail to realize that by consistently appologizing for any Mac flaws, you hurt consumers more than you help them. And thereby hurt Apple.
The only way for Apple to remain competitive is for it to hear that its own customers are not entirely content with all of its products. This forces Apple to improve. isn’t that what we all want? Do all of you mac zealots really believe Apple couldn’t improve the MacBook Pro? How about reducing hear, reducing fan noise, reducing the “whine” noise, not underclocking its video card, reducing its lofty price, creating a 12″ model, increasing standard RAM, increasing battery life, including FW 800 on 15.4″ models, etc.
I seriously hope none of you point any of your potential switcher friends towards this site.
They will either be scared away, laugh their ass off at the zealotry displayed by the comments, or both.
Please, for the good of Apple, keep this joke of a site secret from them, OK?
Matrix3 said:
“They have to prevent the Switchers from switching at the end of the year, because for every Switcher that’s going to be one less Vista buyer in 2007.”
Wrong!
With Leopard on Intel comes the probability that more folks will switch and bring their Security Blanket – a copy of either Vista or XP – with them … just in case. More than a few who normally buy high-end WIntels are trapped in that world by apps they MUST have available and cannot get for a Mac OS. These folks – ones who have no problem paying Mac rates – will now be able to switch. This may hurt Dell a little, but Microsoft will enjoy the extra revenue from an end-user copy of an OS rather than an EOM copy.
helloworld,
Good points. I love Macs and I love my wife, but nothing is perfect.
I can’t speak to the noise of a MacBook as I’ve never even seen one – I’m not in that market and not that curious. The under-clocked video card bit them in the C/Net compo … cost them the DOOM section, which is a joke on a laptop anyway.
Forget the 12″ model. Rumor has it the iBook replacement will be a 13.3″ Cinema-screen model – ten percent more screen real estate without making it any ‘deeper’. Still very compact but better for old folk like my wife, my mother and me.
When someone has to cheat to win, theyve already lost.
And since in a broader sense theyre really representing the broader PC market place as a whole, i think this is another one of those instances where the loyal PC side are clutching at straws, feeling their once relatively secure market crumbling before their very eyes.
Its not IF but HOW LONG is it going to take before apple take back the personal computer market through greater innovation and a will to empower the people that want to be empowered.
We witnessed a revolution, a computer revolution coming of age that will not stop anytime soon, and like alot of revolutions, once they gain momentum they build speed fast.
Apple along with some amazing innovations and beautiful design of both hardware and software, made some mistakes. Mistakes that cost them market share and put them on the back foot. When Jobs arrived back things turned around, and were starting to see this hard work pay off now.
PC folk can do as many biased computer reviews as they want. In the end Apple will be back on top.
Its not IF, but WHEN.
Honestly, I totally tired of the ‘Windows vs. OSX’ and ‘Mac vs everybody else’ comparisons. I will continue, like most reading here, to buy Apples. Heck I was buying Macs when it was running System 6 then 7,8, & 9 (aack!) Back then it was tough to argue for Macs/OSX over the other stuff. But I wanted it so I bought it. Nothing more.
People will buy what they want. And these comparisons just provide a rational reason for the emotional purchase.
Mac users like simplicity, reliability, and exclusivity. Window users like to be lemmings or at least part of the mainstream. Mac users don’t. Big deal. And heck, would any of us really want OSX to become the default operating system. I know that I wouldn’t. I feel comforatably smug supporting the underdog.
Come on now. Nobody really thinks CNET is anything but entertainment anymore. Just look at the comments on their reviews. Even the PC fanboys are turned off of them when they give a crappy product a good review or a good product a crappy review (guess the check didn’t come).
You should equate their “prizefight” articles to MTV’s “Celebrity deathmatch”. It’s pure entertainment. Next they will be picking a Walkman over an iPod. It could be tongue in cheek, you never know with some geeks.
The BMW and Ford analogy is getting really old, MDN!
Ford makes a lot of great cars. This elitist BS that most American branded cars are junk is not true anymore.
Corvette, Chrysler 300, Mustang, Cadillac STS, etc. Excellent machines, to name a few.
I will take a Ford GT40 any day over any BMW.
BMW is making bug-ridden cars that look like crap. The last attractive/superlative car they made was the Z-8.
Your perception of Ford is similarly skewed to the perception that most Windows-users have about the Mac. There is a big difference between perception and reality, both in computers and cars.
Heck, I bought a new Scion (a Toyota product) that I PERCEIVED would be of much higher quality than my previous American brands. It has had more issues, including numerous rattles and bogus warning lights. Everybody can make a lemon, Apple included.
You need to come up with a better analogy next time.
Yes, Apple design has consistently been superior to that of the competition, but that apparently is not what everybody cares about! BMW design used to be in high regard. Not anymore!
Dismissive of the bundled software that comes with the MacBook Pro C/NET states: “To help us focus, though, we return to our starting premise, which asks which laptop is better if you configure a PC and a Mac with identical components.”
Well, there’s the problem that biases this “competition”. The premise is invalid. The product configuration has been jimmied from the outset if you ignore one of the real world components that the Mac comes with. Therefore, the price comparison is invalid.
The other flaw is comparing the Mac’s performance with the Rosetta handicap. What would the test results have been, for example, if they had used the Universal app GraphicConverter for the image editing test? The C/NET approach is rather like comparng the performance of a Honda Civic to a Porsche to which you’ve tied a 1 ton anchor.
@DLMeyer- I hear what your saying but the war is even bigger than Vista.
Steve is after the brass ring – Boot Camp isn’t just about Switchers it’s about putting a stop to the upgrade cycle at MS.
Look MS is trying to move their users to their new platforms.
But they are also held back by their legacy software – the old Windows-95, etc.
Here’s the sweet spot – this legacy software is also the handicap for MS.
If people stay with an old copy of Windows XP, which MS want’s to get away form, using Boot Camp.
The old MS users can still use their OLD software, don’t have to upgrade to Vista/Longhorn/Whatever.
Steve has shutdown the need for businesses to upgrade, they can stay with their old software, have compatiblity and start down the road of OSX.
Who needs Vista?
So for every old MS user of XP, Win95, etc he can keep from upgrading to Vista and stays with Windows XP is a break in the MS upgrade cycle.
Sure, MS will get an additional sale of Windows XP but that will be the last sale.
It will be a downward sprial from there.
It’s a great plan by Steve.
Is anyone surprised that the word ridiculous is attached to the post title? But it pains MDN to agree with Dvorak.
Posted in todays forum at PCmag by “vmpglenn”:
I bought an Acer 8204 when it came out. What a piece of junk. Sure, the carbon fiber looks nice, but the computer shipped from Acer without a working network port (had to wait 2+ months for a firmware upgrade), the USB ports would cut in and out at random, the video driver conflicted with something else Acer had pre-installed, and on and on and on. Nobody has cornered the market on poor quality control, believe me (as a small business owner, I’ve had multiple HPs, IBMs, and Dells die inexplicable deaths).
I returned the Acer and bought a MacBookPro. My MacBookPro is no worse than any other computer out there in terms of quality, but it hasn’t crashed yet (in either Windows XP or Mac OS X), it runs my core apps (Photoshop, After Effects, Illustrator) as fast as anything else in our studio (in Windows for now), and the drivers actually all work with each other.
Pundits are paid to be controversial, otherwise no one would read anything they wrote. Find a MacBookPro running XP and see for yourself.
so boring…
So let me recap:
The Acer is faster (from its performance on Doom, I would suspect that its graphics card isn’t underclocked).
The Acer’s screen has a higher resolution (in fact, it’s the same res as Apple’s $800 cinema display).
The Acer also has a bigger hard drive.
Okay, the Acer is twice the size of the macbook pro, and it’s butt-ugly…..
…..but it’s also $400 *cheaper*. You can buy a decent 20 inch monitor for the difference.
CNET concluded that, on balance, the Acer was a better buy than the Macbook Pro.
Sounds reasonable to me.
An addiitonal comment to clarify my previous post:
What C/NET did was to remove a handicap of the Acer by ignoring the Mac’s superior set of bundled software, but retain a Mac handicap by running performance comparisons with Rosetta apps. That adds up to a stacked deck from my point of veiw and I think MDN is right to yell FOUL!
I read the review, and it is mostly fair. The MacBook Pro won on looks/form factor, included software, and the display. The Acer won on battery life playing back a DVD, price, features (it simply has more ports), performance (no native Photoshop on Mac, graphics card is way underclocked on the Mac), and they had the same warranty.
Photoshop ran faster on the MacBook if you booted up in Windows (faster RAM in the Mac), but I agree that such a test doesn’t make up for Mac Photoshop running a fraction of the speed of Windows Photoshop – blame Adobe, not Apple.
I do agree that the review failed to notice the backlit keyboard and the built-in iSight camera, and I don’t think the Acer has optical audio in/out ports or a FireWire port. I think they should have tied on features, and therefore tied the contest.
The car analogy is lame.
For one thing, everyone would agree that Ford and BMW engines are completely different. Both the Acer and Apple have the same “engine.” Exactly the same engine. Further, the two notebooks have exactly the same graphics engine.
Backlit keyboard equates to a really nice steering wheel. Cool.
Design? Design only matters to people who care about design. It is a completely superficial and subjective choice. Let’s call it Armani vs. Old Navy.
So, let’s pit the Ford GT400 against the BMW 318i. Ford dominates the BMW in every way imaginable.
MDN you’re so sad.
Acer? Are they still around? I haven’t seen anyone with an Acer since the mid-90s. They came with telephones attached, remember?
My mom had a piece of junk Acer that she bought in 1997. Ugly, loud. Got taken out by an Outlook virus. She’s been using an eMac ever since.
I can’t believe anyone would put an Acer above an Apple. Acer is legendary for craptastic quality.
Look at the average user ratings of these 2 machines on the CNET size:
MacBook Pro: 8.4
Acer Thermo: 6.7
doesn”t really reflect CNET’s ratings!!! Who would you trust?
Jooop: “She’s been using an eMac ever since.”
LOL
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”LOL” style=”border:0;” />
Guys, guys, guys. It’s obvious that CNET is ignorant about Macs. It’s obvious that their testing methodology is bogus. It’s obvious that their readership doesn’t agree with them. Why is this news?
I agree that the Ford vs. BMW analogy is lame. The new Mustangs are sweet! If I had the $$, I’d buy one tomorrow. Conversely, BMW has never interested me. German engineering? Phah. Americans went to the moon. That’s engineering for ya.
Remember when the Ford Cordova beat the Mercedes?
In terms of resale value, the car analogy fits. Any American car will rapidly drop in value once you drive it off the lot, since everyone knows the USA makes disposable cars. Do any other countries import Fords, Chryslers, Chevys, Dodge? Of course not. Do any countries other than Germany have lots of Porsches, Mercedes, Audis, VWs and BMWs?
German cars hold their value well, just like Macs do. I buy a new Mac laptop every time an interesting upgrade appears, and sell my previous one on eBay for 85-95% what I paid for it.
Macs vs PCs: B O R I N G.
Can we have some interesting news, please?
>I agree that the Ford vs. BMW analogy is lame.
Yes I’d trade my BMW for a Ford GT tomorrow, you can’t be serious comparing any BMW to a Ford GT and saying that Ford GT doesn’t win, can you?
> I buy a new Mac laptop every time an interesting upgrade appears…
Welcome to the world of rapidly depreciating Macs built on commodity hardware. Macs held their value because it used to take Apple so damn long to update anything and even then it was a baby step forward not a leap. No longer will that be the case now that they are Intel PCs.
“Welcome to the world of rapidly depreciating Macs built on commodity hardware. Macs held their value because it used to take Apple so damn long to update anything and even then it was a baby step forward not a leap. No longer will that be the case now that they are Intel PCs.”
LOL
I could sell my MacBook Pro on eBay right now and make about $50 profit.
Stick to the facts, man.
>I could sell my MacBook Pro on eBay right now and make about $50 profit. Stick to the facts, man.
Ok, try that in 6 months, see how well you do. I can see someone wanting to pay more for your old Yonah notebook than a new Merom one. Yep Right.
Yeah, in 4 months I’ll sell it for 95% what I paid for it and buy a Merom-based MacBook Pro. Like I said, Macs hold their value extermely well.
So anyways, back to my original point, how well do you suppose the average Ford holds its value vs the average BMW?
I did some checking for you, “FordGT”.
2000 Ford Mustange GT – MSRP $21,000 – current bluebook retail – $11,000
2000 BMW 328i – MSRP $34,000 – current bluebook retail – $20,000
…so the Ford has depreciated 48% in 6 years, the BMW has depreciated 41% in 6 years, judging from MSRP.
Nick, what exactly about a Macbrook pro is “BMW” compared to “Ford” of other laptops when the components come out the same factories as the components from Dell and other vendors?
Same CPU, same memory, same graphics card, hard drive, etc… and a poorly optimized motherboard.
This “BMW” perception is delusional fantasy that zealots like you need to cling. Yes, there ARE better laptops out their than a Macbook pro, accept it.
While the Dell Inspiron E1705 performs pretty poorly given its CPU speed, the MacBook Pro is actually even worse. The E1705 holds about an 8% performance advantage over the MacBook Pro with an 8% faster CPU; however, neither Winstone test scales 1:1 with CPU speed increases so Dell’s faster CPU is most likely only buying it another 3% performance advantage here. Obviously neither notebook comes anywhere close to the performance of the ASUS offerings, which continue to be the fastest I’ve ever encountered in a Core Duo notebook.
I don’t really have a good explanation for the MacBook Pro’s disappointing Windows XP performance, because all of its hardware is built out of the same major components that ASUS and Dell use for their notebooks. The only thing I can think of is that out of all these companies, ASUS is far more experienced with tweaking and tuning their motherboards for every last ounce of performance while honestly, Apple has never had to really care. Given that ASUS actually manufactures some of Apple’s machines, it may be time to enlist its help in performance optimization as well.
http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2740&p=15
Apple has an extremely important responsibility to its users not to release questionable hardware. Spending the past few days surfing through Apple’s support forums it’s all too often that I’ve come across the statement that Apple’s quality control has gone down hill as of late. As the only provider of hardware for the Mac OS X platform, that should not be a statement that’s frequently encountered. Yet it is, and it seems that the statement has quite a bit of truth behind it.
While I would definitely recommend a MacBook Pro because of all of the positive things I’ve said in the past about OS X and about Intel’s Core Duo processor, I would strongly urge you to wait and get a model with all of the kinks worked out.
http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2740&p=16
Nick, I do believe “FordGT” was referring to the $150,000 Ford GT supercar, not the commodity Mustang GT. With this sudden bit of knowledge that you learned, I’d like you to make a proper reponse to Ford GT’s original point of “Yes I’d trade my BMW for a Ford GT tomorrow, you can’t be serious comparing any BMW to a Ford GT and saying that Ford GT doesn’t win, can you?“
And BTW, I like how you play the numbers game, comparing two unequally valued vehicles. In pure dollar terms the BMW lost more face value than the Ford you compared. However, you’re comparing two different cars that’s not even within the same value range. Here’s a better comparison:
2000 BMW 328i Sedan 4D: MSRP $33970
http://www.internetautoguide.com/reviews/45-int/midsize-cars/bmw/3-series/2000/index.html
2006 KBB, default options, 60000 miles, zip 32824: $19,515 43% drop
http://www.kbb.com/kb/ki.dll/kw.kc.ucp?kbb&32824;&;560507&;;ucr;&7;BM;A2
2000 Ford SVT Lightning: MSRP $30710
http://auto.consumerguide.com/Auto/New/reviews/full/index.cfm/id/15220/Act/Prices/
2006 KBB, default options, 60000 miles, zip 32824: $17,545 43% drop
http://www.kbb.com/kb/ki.dll/kw.kc.ucp?kbb&32824;&;165341&;;ucr;&7;FT;D0
Well lo and behold, the same depreciation for both.
Well it looks like you can’t click on the KBB links since its done in real time. Put in the year/model, leave default options, and the same mileage/zipcode and you get the same numbers. The more exact depreciation percentage is 42.5% for the BMW and 42.8% for the Ford, barely a difference at all.
“Spending the past few days surfing through Apple’s support forums it’s all too often that I’ve come across the statement that Apple’s quality control has gone down hill as of late.”
It seems that the media never think of surfing the Dell’s support forums. Dell has it’s share of bad batches and defective designs too, but we don’t hear about it in the news… Maybe this is what people normally expect from Dell so it’s not news worthy.
Acer doesn’t seem to have a public support forum… I wonder why?
From my experience, Acer is “obviously” an el-cheapo second-grade company. Everything I bought from them had one problem or another, and had a very low-quality feel to it.
Acer is a cheap company, and people that buy cheap products usually don’t complain about it when they go bad. Many people expect/want perfection from Apple, so every little or big problem is magnified while Dell and Acer’s problems go under the radar.
Journalists scans the Apple support forum for any recurring problem and create much more visitors when they start to talk about it in the media. With Macsurfer.com as a central Mac related news hub, you can see how these can be blow out of proportions compared to Acer’s problems…There is no Acersurfer.com after all.
I noticed that the price comparison is with 2GB of factory installed ram. Anyone that actually looks at what they are buying when they buy from apple.com/store will see that going from the standard 1GB to 2GB is $300. If you buy 1GB from crucial its $153. so the price difference drops from the *whopping* $400 down to about $250. After my $200 educational discount, $50 dollars.
as was also mentioned above, they got the audio thing wrong. The MBP speakers are much better, and the audio I/O ports are dual characteristic: analogue and optical. Acer makes you deal with 5 audio ports which give the same functionality as apple’s two. Talking about clutter, they touted Acers hardware switches to turn off wireless signals. What they don’t bother to mention is that with OSX, turning off your airport or bluetooth is so easy (one click!) that’s a stupid feature for a computer running OSX. One the other side of that coin, when you have to wipe your Acer because it has spyware and viruses, and you install a fresh copy of XP or Vista, the drivers for all of these components will not be included with the OS. So these buttons (along with the wireless card itself) will be dead in the water until you can find and install the right drivers. (My roommate has a gateway laptop thats in this situation right now, he’s been using my powerbook to check his email for the last 2 months) Besides playing down the fact that the MBP is thinner and lighter, which is the most important consideration for a portable computer, CNET also misses the bundled remote/frontrow. And they forgot to mention that the Acer HAS PORTS ON ALL FOUR SIDES! That is going to look like medusa when you plug in your digital camera’s and mouse/keyboard/whatever. Acer has more ports only because of legacy (VGA, PC card, 56k modem) and redundancy (5 audio ports?). It lacks, however, a 6-pin firewire port. With only a 4 pin(and idiotically placed in the front), it can not provide power through firewire. missing feature.
Conversation with myself:
So this great swivel camera, i assume it comes with built in software that will allow you to have full resolution, 30fps, beautifully rendered H.264 video-conferencing with 3 other simultaneous PCs with just a few clicks. No? So at least it comes with a little “photo-booth” .executable that lets you easily take pictures with live previews, using the screen as a flash, and then apply effects and filters in real time using system level graphics technologies. No? Oh, windows doesn’t have that yet? Oh, so in 2007 when i have to purchase an upgrade to vista, then i’ll get that, right? No, i just get the underlying technology, not the built in app? Okay
review from notebookreview.com, indicative of most of the reviews on that site:
Sparkles. I didn’t know that this issue exsisted when I bought the laptop and I didn’t know what the problem was called until just an hour ago, when I found refferances to the issue on “www.notebookforums.com”, in those cases affecting Dell’s fitted with an LG LCDs. Well my Acer 8202 has the same issue. Games look great but webpages with a white background look terrible. I thought I as being stupid and that the problem would go away, but after spending several hours using the laptop. I’ve recided to return it. IT IS COMPLETELY UNUSABLE if like me you spend a lot of time looking at black text on a white background. Other problems include: Loose Express Card cover that just keeps falling out. Dark shadows in the bottom corners of the LCD (light leakage). The vent on the right is a problem when using a mouse. And the speakers are pathetic. However the deal breaker is the Sparkles. They make web development a real eye strainer.
I guess text doesn’t really look all that good on the Acer after all. And you might have to wear a thermal glove on your right hand. Oh and the express card covers on apple computers don’t come out btw, they are built-in sliding covers that show another “attention to detail” that the acer lacks. Too bad about the light leakage. Add on a couple of pounds and $50 for portable speakers while you’re at it. Did you notice how the hooks above the screen that hold the laptop closed stay out even when they’re not needed? Yea, i guess it was too much trouble to have magnet activated hooks like the MBP, just like the magsafe power adaptor that will keep you from ruining your machine when you yank the cord by accident.
i could continue, but i’m even tiring myself out.
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”raspberry” style=”border:0;” />
Nicky Nicky Nicky
You are obviously totally clueless with respect to Ford’s products. Not a good point to start an argument about their relative merits from.
You have confused a Ford Mustang GT with the Ford GT, a supercar which evokes the great Ford GT 40 Le Mans racer.
To answer your question on depreciation. After the Ford GT production run finishes, I expect the prices continue to go up. After all some people are already trying to get $75k over list for them now. I further expect them eventually reach ridiculously high levels.
I don’t expect the same for a Mustang GT, or just about any other car on the planet and certainly not for any production BMW.
Do you think on the Dell site they fight about operating systems?
It’s a *computer*, people!!!!
The Kool-Aid is over here.
GET A LIFE
LOL who cares about a Ford “super car”. Who is going to spend that kind of money on a Ford? It’s totally irrelevant to this conversation. Are we talking about $150,000 super laptops? I didn’t think so. Would anybody use the Ford GT as their everyday car? I didn’t think so. It would be a pain in the ass driving that thing in traffic – you would feel every little bump, it would be all squirly in first and second gear (wanting to go faster), and you would get crappy milage (akin to crappy battery life).
We’re not talking about extreme performance here, we’re talking about build quality, refinement, and so on. The Acer is a big plastic ugly thing. After a year it will have squeeky hinges. The Apple is a thin, lovely aluminum laptop. Why do you see Mac laptops in so many ads (even ones on Microsoft’s site) – they look a lot better than PC laptops. Why don’t Germans buy American cars? They are unrefined looking and unreliable in the long run. Why do Americans buy German cars? They look better, feel better and run better in the long run.
PowerBooks used to be slow compared to PC laptops, and they STILL held their value well because of the awesome form factor. MacBooks have all the strengths of PowerBooks, with massive performance gains, AND the ability to run Windows natively. They are far more desirable than the PowerBook in every way. They are obviously going to hold their value even better.
>LOL who cares about a Ford “super car”.
That comment doesn’t address your ignorance, but we’ll assume you’re suitably embarrassed.
The Ford GT is a premium product, with great design and awesome performance.
Similar claims have been asserted about a Mac.
So explain why anyone would care about a “Super PC” with a “Super Design” and a “Super OS” and a “Super price tag” to match.
After all the Macbook does retail for about 4x the price of a “basic transportation” notebook. That makes it a premium priced product in anyone’s book. Please don’t argue that the features justify the price because that’s not relevant, it still doesn’t change the fact that it is a premium priced unit.
Show me a prettier German car than a Ford GT, you might have me convinced that the GT is irrelevant to your BMW vs Ford argument.
Show me one that outperforms it for the same or less money. Might also have me convinced.
The point is that Ford, when they choose to can kick the German car industry’s arse, and that the current top of the line Ford is a lot better than the current top of the line BMW.
An old Caddy or Lincoln absorbs those street bumps better than a BMW, but would you prefer that? I don’t think so, so how is that relevant when the discussion as about design and performance?
Trust me, when you buy a $150,000 car, last thing you’re worrying about is gas mileage.
Anyway the basic premise was that if a Ford lined up aginst a BMW, the Ford would lose and the comparisin would be laughable. The GT is relevant because it proves that point to be laughably false.
It also shows how MDN have this perception of “Ford” vs “BMW” and how that differs from reality. If they can be wrong in their perception of “Ford” vs “BMW” then they are also probably wrong in their perception about a great many other things.
Stop talking about the $175k Ford GT. The new Vette Z06 is $70k with the same performance, and it’s a Chevy, not a POS Ford.
CNet always has biased reviews. Their original review of the MacBook 1.83 was a 6.9 because there “isn’t enough software for Intel Macs yet”.
>Stop talking about the $175k Ford GT.
I guess if the comparison MDN made was BMW vs a Chevy, we’d be talking about the Chevy and it would also win that comparison.
Money no object, the GT still wins, but Z06’s have always been a great bargain for what you get.
Macs are great don’t get me wrong. BUT:
Acer laptops will give you more bang for your buck-period. for a 500$ difference acer definately outperforms the mac. Mac users pay premium for eye candy and fancy/deluxe features such as the self illuminating keyboard.. but in the end you can install mac os x on the acer, forget about the fancy keyboard, and save yourself 500 bucks; and then buy an ipod with that who knows!
WHo said you can’t run Mac os on Windows?
Jut use VMware Workstation and deng, you got a MAC OS.
Dude, you’re a loser, every single person that still uses a MAC should be dragged into the street and shot (in my humble opinion…) I truly believe there is life after Mac. Anyways, and what was that dildo’s rant about 5 audio ports on the Acer? Are you blind or were you drunk when you looked at the device?
Okay, I admit, I didn’t even read through every Acer bash here, cos it seems you guys have small-willy syndrome. I don’t own either one of the two but I sure as hell don’t see Acer owners freaking out about the MacBook like you geeks do… This reminds me very much of the *nix fags that absolutely hate Windows, but the Windows guys just carry on, knowing that they own the market, and no matter what any *nix geek says, it will never change!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />
Viva Bill, Viva!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”raspberry” style=”border:0;” />