Alleged problems surfacing with Apple iPod Nano screen

“Some owners of Apple Computer’s new ‘impossibly small’ iPod Nano are starting to wonder if the device is also impossibly delicate,” Michelle Meyers reports for CNET News. “The most widespread complaint about the otherwise highly praised device seems to be that the color display screen gets scratched extremely easily.”

Meyers reports, “Nano owner Brian Cason posted one of 250-some threads in response to a recent post on Apple’s discussion board about screen scratching. ‘I don’t really care if the case on my Nano gets scratched but my screen has scratched up so badly that all the images are starting to become distorted,’ Cason wrote, echoing the sentiment of many others in the discussion. ‘I have only carried it in my small pocket in my shorts and nothing is in there to scratch it. I still can’t figure how the screen looks like it has been rubbed with sandpaper when the entire time it has been safe in my pocket (with absolutely no items).'”

Full article here.
While there might be a problem with a batch (or all) of iPod nano screens, a few cynical questions pop immediately into doubting minds:
• Didn’t they already try this with batteries and also fail miserably to dent iPod’s market dominance?
• How much of an idiot do you have to be to try to keep an iPod nano unprotected in your jeans change pocket and expect it not to rub/scratch on denim? Just because Steve Jobs used that pocket to highlight the nano’s size doesn’t absolve you from lacking basic common sense. Get a case for your nano or a pack of those 99-cent plastic screen protectors, at least. Take care of your stuff. By the way, all of our jeans’ change pockets are too shallow to accept and cover the entire iPod nano. We suspect Jobs’ jeans change pocket was altered for the nano’s unveiling.
• Would Apple really fail to take basic product design testing steps that every major company takes in order to make sure the screen design wouldn’t fail as is being alleged by a handful of users? Would Apple fail to do this on such an important product?
• Who would benefit if the public could be convinced that iPod nano units have defective screens?
• Is this all they’ve got left with which to “compete” with Apple?

Again, Apple certainly isn’t perfect (just much closer to it than most other computer and electronics makers). There might very well be a problem with a batch (or all) of iPod nano screens. Or there might not.

Related articles:
Site reports iPod nano screen failures – September 23, 2005
Apple iPod nano takes a beating and keeps on beating – September 12, 2005

46 Comments

  1. At lunch the other day a woman was showing off her nano to her friend. She was thrilled with all the features and how small it was and how great the sound was… and then she just tossed it in to the bottom of her purse. I wonder why these are getting scratched?

  2. I don’t know whether people have had problems or not with the iPod nano screen. I do know that I’ve had no problems. In fact, I dropped my iPod nano on rough pavement, and it suffered not one scratch or dent. I was pleasantly surprised. My wife and I both examined it carefully and were surprised that such a drop on such a surface didn’t dent or scratch it. Therefore I’m sceptical of these in-the-pocket scratch claims.

  3. I’ve been carrying mine (black 4G) around in my pocket for about a week now and I’m getting the same small scratches that I’ve had on all my other iPods. Nothing horrible cosmetically, and definitely not enough to distort the screen.

    People complain… they always complain. Look, now I’m complaining about people complaining. Meh.

  4. I’ve had my nano since it was introduced and have yet to experience any of the problems people have claimed it may have. It would be easy to start a few fake rumors about a product just to scare some people from buying it.

    I have carried my ipod nano in my jeans pocket many many times and never got a scratch on the screen. The ipod nano is no stronger or weaker then any other ipod.

    In fact the ArsTechnia review should be proof enough that the ipod nano is built very well and can handle a few drops and bumps.

  5. Why can’t Apple use a scratch resistant surface? Is it that hard?

    About two years ago, I had a Timex Expedition watch. The crystal on that got so scratched and so marred that I could barely see through the thing anymore. To echo the article’s comparison, it looked like someone had attacked it with sandpaper.

    About a year ago, I bought a new watch… again a Timex Expedition of the same price but of a slightly different style. The crystal on this watch, to this day, has not a single scratch on it, and I’ve treated it no differently. There have been a couple of times, in fact, where I smacked the thing hard against the corner of a wall or something. Gritting my teeth, I examined the crystal, saw the point of impact on the crystal, rubbed it with a thumb, and the “scratch” disappeared.

    If this kind of improvement can be done with a watch, then why not the surface of an iPod?

    Alex

  6. I got Nano a week after introduction, but never have any problem. I never put nano in the jean pockets because my jean pockets get dirty and wet easily. For $250+, it is not some dirty paper money bills or coins, so I do not put in my jean. People should use some common sense and buy armband or some protective case.

  7. The first iPod I got I thought it would be super tough and so I carried it around without a case in my pocket while I was running. Guess what. It got scratched. I then bought a case and it did not get scratched any further. If I get a nano (I am hoping to but may have to wait a bit), I will at the very least get some of the plastic film protectors and probably a good case too. AND I will not keep it in a tight pocket where it will get stressed.

    I guess the nanos are tougher than mini hard drive iPods in that they have solid state memory. That doesn’t mean you can abuse them and expect them to come thru unscathed – especially the outer casing.

  8. Michelle Meyers reports for CNET News: “…the color display screen gets scratched extremely easily.”

    Get a fscking case for the nano.

    Idiot.

    MaWo: ‘couldn’t’. As in, ‘Michelle couldn’t find her ass if it were sitting in both her hands.’

  9. I got the first iPod nano at my apple store and have been using regularly everyday. Having owned a smattering of various iPod models, I can say that this model DOES scratch a LOT easier than the others. Is the scratching obscently horrible, no. Is it enough to make the screen hard to read, yes.

    Apple just needs to adjust their manufacturing process to harden the outside surface. They coated the nano in some sort of shiny reflective coating that is not as resilient as the hardened plastic polymer underneath.

    I was going to buy a second one for my wife, but I’m going to hold out until version two.

  10. My new nano got scratched very easely also. Just with a cotton tshirt !! I bought a invisible plastic cover from Power Support and now all goes well. I think Apple should sell nanos with such a protection (on the front and back sides), like some cellphones with screen protection. The cost would be minimal for Apple, and there would’n be such bad publicity. Most pople won’t even notice it when discovering the device. Then purists may remove the protection…

  11. it wouldn’t kill Apple to make the iPod a little tougher on the outside. My 3rd Gen I’ve had for about 18 months, and though I try to be careful it is a little more scratched up than I would like. My Sony Discman was a piece of sh*t but the case held up a lot better than the iPod has, thus far.

  12. I did not take plastic film that cover the front pf nano off. I only cut small part of the plastic film, so I can put in the armband and plug in audio jack. There a couple small scratch on the platic film cover but not the nano itself. I use over 9 hours a day both at work and jog with my dog. I do not see the problem, but I will buy the colour plastic wrap and protective case to better protect my $250+.

  13. I take exception to the tone of the MDN Take and some of the comments here. I have had quite a few Apple products over the years, and as much as I love using them, Apple has disappointed me a couple of times with quality control issues. Examples:

    • My 15″ Powerbook fell victim to the widespread screen “white spots” issue. Apple replaced the screen for free.
    • The battery failed in my first iPod mini after two months. Apple replaced it.
    • The second iPod mini failed within one week. Apple replaced it AGAIN. (the third mini is still working, though battery life is generally poor)
    • I have kept my Powerbook in a protective case since the day I got it, yet somehow the beautiful aluminum case still has a few scratches.

    Apple products are great, but they often are not perfect. To suggest this article is motivated by an anti-Apple conspiracy kinda just makes you look silly.

  14. Well, I saw some pictures of these said scratches, and they look more than just scratches, or at least the scratches we are thinking of. These are more of screen melt downs. Where the crystal liquid actually burns and turns black. And it seems to be consistant, and over one of the chips that are inside the nano. Take a look for youselft. It does look like there is a problem with some of the Nanos. http://www.flawedmusicplayer.com/

  15. I got my 4gb white nano last Thursday and have used it everyday. Over the weekend my 8 year old daughter dropped it in a bowl of salsa at a local Mexican rest. after playing games on it for over an hour. I wiped it clean and put it back in my pocket….with no ill effect.

    Is it showing any scratches….some, but nothing surprising. Like my other IPODS, it just needs a silicon jacket.

    My only concern is battery life…still not sure yet what time I can expect. I’m spoiled by the shuttle which can sit in my gym bag for days with no drain. (the beauty of a simple off switch)

  16. I was on the verge of buying one for my wife’s birthday when I read last week’s piece. Problem or not I decided on a mini instead. And beatsme is right about the 3rd gen. ipod as well. I’ve got scratches on my 3rd gen. and it’s been in a protective case or connected to the hi-fi. Like it or not news like this could cruel ipod sales.

  17. Anyone that carries a nano or any other iPod in their pants pocket with no case or any other protection is asking for it anyway. I have one and it has absolutely nothing wrong with the screen, but then again, I don’t jam it in my pocket along with my keys and coins either…

  18. It seems that having one’s nano’s screen scratched in their own demin pocket is a sin or some stupid behavior. I sigh, because it is such a blind emotion to those who got hostiled by other’s misfortune. What kind of mentality is it?

    I believe Apple fans can be more than that! They can be wise and cool, plus being hunger for perfection; that they can also request more from our Apple team, so that the next coming products of Apple can be even more user-centric.

    In fact, I have bought 2 nanos, both black (4GB) and white (2GB), and I also got one as gift for my grandpa (who loves listening to some local podcast programmes).

    More experienced an iPod user I am, I still get some minor scratches on the first few days of use when the accessories are not yet ready off-the-shelves in HK. Nevertheless, they still look sleek and cool so far. But my grandpa (who also loves wearing jeans) and wanna show off the little things to his neighbor (especially it is a gift from his grandson) got his white nano’s screen much smeared.

  19. I have to disagree with MDN’s comments on this one as they are unfair and really of the mark.

    As an owner of a white iPod and a mini I can say with confidence that the display screen on the mini is NOT made with the same durable protective coating.

    Sure, scratches are to be expected, but the scratches on my nano are excessive. The fibers of a kleenex left sever marks on my nano screen after I tried to remove fingerprints… I am treating this thing extremely carefully and just from casual handling it looks worse than my two year old white iPod.

    Yes, I understand that a case could prevent some casual scratches, BUT it was Apples oversight to ship this unit a month before any cases were available. Add to that Steve Jobs himself demoed the product by pulling it out of his jean pocket so that would lead me to believe that you should be able to do this without destroying the device. And if as MDN says his jean pocket was altered than I would say Apple is using deceptive advertising.

    This is not just a handful of owners who are complaining there are nearly 500 complaints on a single thread in the Apple discussion forums. This is a serious design flaw and it needs to be addressed soon!

    Again, the nano screen is NOT made of the same quality of previous iPods. Casual handling will damage the screen and make it look terrible in a matter of minutes.

  20. Apple makes the most delicate display or screen in the world. The screen on any Apple product simply is not in marketable condition on the day it is sold. And its buy at your own risk because Apple isnt going to honor any warranty on their displays and they certainly cant find any one to insure the displays. Apple to consumer: “try duct tape”. Apple could be
    the greatest entertainment company the world has ever seen but it has to start thinking just a bit a smaller and begin to make their products work.
    The Sony walk man works. Sony makes movies and develops recording artists. Apple should spend a little money and buy the Beatles porfolios
    from Mj and Apple from Apple. And how smart is it of Jobs to go after people who use the word ipod–I wish everyone used the word–Im happy that podcasting is called podcasting.

  21. • Didn’t they already try this with batteries and also fail miserably to dent iPod’s market dominance?

    Sorry, but just having a complaint about Apple is not reason enough to assume they’re a competitor, or assume some conspiracy theory.

    • How much of an idiot do you have to be to try to keep an iPod nano unprotected in your jeans change pocket and expect it not to rub/scratch on denim? Just because Steve Jobs used that pocket to highlight the nano’s size doesn’t absolve you from lacking basic common sense. Get a case for your nano or a pack of those 99-cent plastic screen protectors, at least.

    The other iPod models do not seem to scratch so easily, so treating the nano like any other iPod is lacking common sense? Job’s demo was exactly intended to imply that the nano can be carried around in a pocket, not just to demo the size, and I don’t recall Jobs using a protector. In any case, you admit that the nano is very prone to scratches, unless you buy an accessory. Should you really have to buy an accessory if it would only cost several cents for Apple to make it better in the first place?

    • Would Apple really fail to take basic product design testing steps that every major company takes in order to make sure the screen design wouldn’t fail as is being alleged by a handful of users? Would Apple fail to do this on such an important product?[/b

    Circular reasoning. Obviously they did fail to do this. Just because you don’t think they would, doesn’t mean anything.

    • Who would benefit if the public could be convinced that iPod nano units have defective screens?

    Maybe consumers?

    • Is this all they’ve got left with which to “compete” with Apple?

    Another conspiracy theory. <sigh> It’s like your delusional minds are not capable of believing what you don’t want to believe.

  22. Stevo did not just use his pocket to highlight the size of the nano… His exact words were.

    “Did you ever wonder what this pocket is for?”

    No doubt the Nano is a beautiful, but if a case is required to keep the screen functional then a case should not be an accessory, it should be included.

  23. I have not had any problems with the screen failing or scratches, but I’ve also been real careful not to carry it in my pocket unprotected. The casing is very delicate and you have to baby it, if you don’t it will scratch very easily.

    I have, however, had problems with the battery. My battery gets maybe 10 hours each charge and 5 to sometimes 6 hours real world use. I charged the nano all the way and then let it run without touching it to see how long it would go and it went 10 hours before shutting down. I have charged the nano and run out the battery several times in the last week and I have restored the nano and no luck. With a fully charged nano, I can work out for 2 hours and the battery meter will read half full. Also, the battery meter, even when fully charged, will not show completely filled.

    I love the nano, it’s a great product and I believe I simply got a defective battery. I will be exchanging it at The Apple Store today.

    P.S. Get a white nano, the black ones show the scratches much more easily. The one I saw on display in The Apple Store looked a mess.

  24. • Didn’t they already try this with batteries and also fail miserably to dent iPod’s market dominance?

    It’s not about denting iPod’s market dominance, it’s about correcting a product design flaw and defect.

    And yes, they did try this with batteries and Apple corrected the issue with a battery replacement voucher.

  25. “The question I would like to know the answer to is whether the nano has the same composition on screen and body as the full size iPod…”

    No, it is not. And that is where the problem lays. The screen on the nano is extremely prone to scratches, much more so than previous iPods.

  26. A lot of clothes manufacturers will use sand or other abrasives to wash their products in order to soften them. Some of this grit can remain after this process. That is why a Nano can get scratched when you carry it in your pocket.

    Solution – try washing your clothes with the pockets pulled out.

    Better solution – get a screen protector for the Nano

  27. The good news is that Apple is aware of the issue and they are not denying there is a problem.

    I was told by Apple support that they are “looking into it.”

    In the meantime, don’t clean your nano with a cloth as even cotton or tissue will scratch the surface, and do not put the nano in a pocket without a case or protective coating.

  28. Common sense should be the words of the day. Buy a case or some even use an infants sock but protect it somehow. That’s why they make those clips that let it hang around your neck. Or those cases that strap around your arm. To protect it from getting scratched and smashed in your pockets.

  29. A similar thread popped up on /. yesterday. Several guys recommended Brasso brand polish to buff scratches out. I have had some luck using toothpaste to buff scratches off my sony cell phones’s screen when it became too scratched to see in the daylight. I would use a lens cloth or an old dollar bill to buff it out (USD’s are made of cloth/linen not pulp paper which can scratch too).
    Mac heads are creative need to get the DIY spirit and not wait for Steve-o to hold their hand and tell them what to do. I am a Mac-nut and not a total DIY guy but I’m trying to change my ways.

    MW= glass, like be careful with that nano because there is glass in thar

  30. These are complaints similar to when the original iPod came out. People complained of surface scratching and fingerprints. Neither of which are going to go away. That said, I order my iPod nano the day after the presentation and it has one minor scratch on it, from when I dropped it. Otherwise, I do keep it in my top jean pocket. I should also note, that this has caused me to avoid wearing one of my favorite pairs of jeans, since it’s change pocket is to shallow to fully cover my nano. But it fits fine in most of my Old Navy jeans.

    I figure, eventually some one will start selling those clear sticky plastic face covers for the nano; like they use to for your Palm pilot. It protected the screen from scratching. But I can’t blame Apple for this, I have scratch resistent glasses that have scratches all over them; and I’m not an excessively careless person. So I expect anything I carry around in my pocket to get a little banged up. I’ve been more surprised at how durable the little bugger is.

  31. Really, dude, being a Mac-loyal guy is great; I’ve been one since 1984. Bu… damn. You gotta remember that Apple was in a rush to get the nano to market in time for the Christmas buying season. It seems more likely than not that these complaints are legitimate. And if Steve is going to demo having the nano in his change pocket, then the thing should certainly be able to survive well there. iHuman makes a good point about jeans mfgs using abrasive (pumice) to “stone wash” their products. Excluding possibility that some customers’ nano screens are being pumiced to death, the nano’s screen SHOULD be able to withstand hazing due to simply being in an empty pocket. I’m a mechanical engineer. There are affordable surface hardening treatments available for clear screens that can make them withstand attack by STEEL WOOL! If the nano doesn’t have this treatment, it should. If it is supposed to, some could be that some nanos are defective.

  32. Solution for those who does not like the protective case option many times suggested above – do not take your iPod away from the dock and just do not touch it.
    Seriosly I like the look and feel of a “naked” iPod much better than any case and would prefer to have a scratch-proof iPod.

  33. Call me crazy but this whole thing smells like organized FUD.

    Sure there are probably valid complaints amongst this.

    But I suspect that the MS & Creative FUD machine is using this “weakness” and uses “agents” that blow the story out of proportion, hoping to hurt Apple’s sales. (Because, at this point, this is the only thing that they can do). I’m sure many MS and Creative employees participate in the FUD feast free of charge.

    Have you read the recent article on Thuridiot’s site where MS execs are talking about Apple at some event?

    One exec praised the nano, then told everyone that his nano stopped working after one day, and everyone laughed. He then said “It looks like they have a moisture problem” and everyone laughed again. So as you can see the execs are aware that diffusing and repeating a (fake, but based on some possible problem) story like this could hurt the iPod, it’s almost a running gag for them.

  34. <<Stevo did not just use his pocket to highlight the size of the nano… His exact words were.

    “Did you ever wonder what this pocket is for?”

    No doubt the Nano is a beautiful, but if a case is required to keep the screen functional then a case should not be an accessory, it should be included.>>

    Ok, then explain to me how (if they’re as delicate as some here claim) that the nano survived for a full 45 or so minutes in Steve’s jeans pocket prior to him pulling it out to show it off? The one he had on stage was working just fine as he held it up to the audience with the screen on…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.