“Contois Music Technology last week asked a Federal Court to stop the iPod maker from distributing its iTunes jukebox software and is seeking damages over an alleged patent violation by the iTunes software,” Kasper Jade and Prince McLean report for AppleInsider. “The suit, filed on June 13th in Vermont District Court, alleges that Apple’s iTunes software design infringes on Contois’ six-year old design patent (US Patent No. 5,864,868) entitled ‘Computer Control System and User Interface for Media Playing Devices.'”
Jade and McLean report, “The Essex Junction, Vt.-based Contois is seeking a preliminary and permanent injunction enjoining Apple from further distributing its iTunes software in its current form. The company also asked the Court for an unspecified amount of monetary damages resulting from Apple’s ‘copying and willful infringement’ of its design patent as well as reimbursement of legal fees associated with the lawsuit.”
Full article with more information and images of Contois’ Exhibit Comparing Both Software Application Interfaces here.
When will the insanity END???
Since its launch in Jan. 2001, Apple’s iTunes software has grown to serve an installed user base of millions and is distributed free-of-charge via Apple’s website as well as with each iPod digital music player the company sells. The iTunes software is also the primary access point to Apple’s industry-leading iTunes Music Store, which is available in 19 countries and has served more than 450 million songs downloads worldwide.
Lawyers for Spink & Miller, PLC., the Virginia-based firm representing Contois, where out on business and did not responded to inquiries for comment by press time.
Contois is seeking a trial by jury.
Preferably the Michael Jackson jury.
WTF!
And the attempts to kill innovation continue….
And how many years has iTunes been out on the market and only now they think they own the rights to some interface? Come on people you can do better than that.
It looks like Apple’s legal team will be getting a few more lawyers at this rate.
its nice that they took 4 years to realise that this was a problem. do you think they waited for itunes and the ipod to take off so they could maximize their profits from this.
Why did it take them FOUR years to finally sue apple? Sounds like a scam to me.
There has to be some limit to when these guys can decide to start suing. This is ridiculous. They’re probably looking for some cash to keep their business going.
At least the beatles sued the minute iTMS got going.
Wonder if this would have proceeded had the iTMS not been successful
Wow.
It took them five years to notice that iTunes existed?
it’s only the look and feel of it
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”raspberry” style=”border:0;” />
I guess they’ll be going after RealPlayer and Windows Media Player next…
No?
Well then, WTF is this doing clogging up the courts??!!
So what, they have a copyright on the “PLAY” button?
before you can sue, you have to find legal representation willing to take the case. It’s entirely possible it took the guy a year or two to get someone interested, since nobody could have foreseen the success of iPod/iTunes at the outset. Plus you have to build a case before you can actually file, and that takes time as well. Sure they’re bringing the suit now, but you can bet that A LOT of thought and work has gone into it already…
Don’t blame them. They are just taking advantage of a very stupid patent system.
Wait till someone gets a patent on ass wiping. We’ll all be in trouble then.
Pete,
Not an attempt to kill innovation. More like an attempt to get Apple to settle out of court on a vague copyright. As has been opined here before, it’s time for the copyright system in this country to receive a major overhaul. People register very vague copyrights, and later try to sue anyone that has anything similar to theirs. Bad. Baaaaaaaad.
best of Liberace – just for that it should be thrown out
Isn’t there some rule like with trademarks where you have to defend your right on the patent, and if you don’t you lose by default?
Geez, I think that NExT’s multi-paned file browser interface preceeded this stupid design patent. I expect this suit will be dismissed quickly, should Apple counter sue for their (NExT) design patent which is clearly being breached by these jerks.
And if I patented many years ago a design for “an interface for playing media files, such as movies, etc. with buttons for play, pause, etc.” I could have a patent to cash in all those DVD player software?
I have a patent on stirring. Pay up everybody.
Well that means Sony, Napster, Microsoft, and Real should be sued also
What I don’t like about these patents is that it’s all on paper but these companies have no marketable product. Isn’t filing a patent to protect the idea AND the product you are going to sell, so that other can’t simply copy your innovation, your product on the marketplace? But if you don’t market your idea within a reasonable time-frame and wait to cash in on violations on your idea, that’s bogus. I believe that patents shouldn’t be about owning an idea, but protecting the idea AND the product you are going to sell. But these companies behave like they OWN an idea without having a product an the market. How, then, does Apple cause damages to the company that holds an patent idea, which it doesn’t have any products for?
lol. Wonder if they’re gonna go after Cassady & Green, too? pfffttt.
These guys are reportedly suing over search capabilities such as sorting music tracks by their genre, artist and album attributes, amongst other things.
Yeah sure …
It’s the “American Dream”: get some broad meaningless patent and hope some fool comes along, invests millions and innovates something that if stretched to the nth degree, kinda relates to your “patent”.
Bastards!
Every time Apple has to defend these frivolous law suites, it drives up the cost to us all.
I gonna need to see some pictures of Contois’ interface design — in pixels, not on paper.
Is this Contois Music & Technology, LLC and eMusicGear.com?
http://www.emusicgear.com/
C’mon dudes, you sell Casio keyboards. Get off it.
Flashbacks to TigerDirect fiasco
This case has no merit. Hopefully the judge is smart enough to throw it out before it even gets to the trial phases.
Contols’ claim is analagous to them saying they have patents for the way music CDs are displayed and organized your local record store. At the very least, Contols will get all the patents overturned, which should be the fate of all do-nothing sit-on-your-patents-then-sue “companies.”
Seriously, the U.S. needs to reform tort law and make frivolous lawsuits like this very expensive to the perpetrators.
What crap. I can’t believe they got a patent for that, but that said, why wait over 4yrs before attempting to pursue enforcing it. Admittedly their layout is similar to iTunes, but its also fairly similar to other software as well; before Apple introduced iTunes for Windows I use to use MusicMatch and my layout of it, pretty much matched this drawing. Of course Music Match had that irritating everything was in separate windows things going on. But configuring the layout of genre, artist, album seems second nature. Besides his layout has nothing for playlist, and it doesn’t seem that you can hide album cover as with Apple. So pretty much he’s claiming copyright for navigating album information by genre, artist, album. Isn’t that how the library organizes music?
I’m not a lawyer, but it probablly also won’t help that Contols sat on their patent for more than 4 years before bringing this suit. U.S. law doesn’t look kindly on companies that wait to defend their patents until a financially viable opportunity comes along.
This is BS!
Excuse me… BUT why on earth didn’t they try and sue APPLE years ago when Itunes was irrelevent???
This reaks of money grabbing bull-shit to me!!
Anyone say the word ‘gravy-train’? (as in these guys are in it for the money!)
Besides – APPLE has patents for the itunes interface!!!
hey, that design looks like the one I sketched on toilet paper FIVE years ago.
It is BS. I can predict Apple’s first move will be ask for dismissal of the suit, on the basis that Contols probably never even attempted to enforce their so-called patents once in the last 4 years despite numerous “violators” in the market and secondly, the patents are probably invalid due to prior art (since the idea of an online music store organized in such a way goes back before Contols even exisited).
“First they ignore you … then they laugh at you … then they fight you … then you win.”
We’re at step 3 of 4 it seems.
Get used to it kiddies. All of you wanted Apple to grow, grow, grow!! One step closer to Microsoft.
Perfect example of a broke, haphazardly run company on the verge of going out of business trying to cash in on the success of another company. It’s called “litigious capitalism.”
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
When you try to connect to contois.com, you get redirected to emusicgear.com and nothing happens but a connection timeout. See, they cannot even afford to pay their web hosting company a mere $30 per month to keep their website running.
What a farce.
http://macdailynews.com/index.php/weblog/comments/3114/
Well, for one thing, their from Vermont.
Here’s a link which has a picture of the whole inbred family…
http://www.mmrmagazine.com/mmrmag/mar99/
It contains this little tidbit about the company:
SPOTLIGHT: CONTOIS MUSIC & TECHNOLOGY
Dave Contois has transformed a Vermont family music business into a dealership on the cutting edge of technology and its application to music education.
‘Nuff said.
Here’s a further bio of M. Cartois:
Dave Contois, CONTOIS Music & Technology, LLC and eMusicGear.com
Dave Contois is an owner and partner in eMusicGear.com, a division of Contois Music & Technology, LLC. After attending the Berklee School of Music, Dave decided to return to the family business, which had started as a retailer of pianos and organs in 1971 and transitioned into full-line musical instruments when Musical Instrument Digital Interface (MIDI) came onto the scene.
Dave is in charge of all e-commerce and retail operations using the Internet as his instrument to promote the store, teach his students and sell his products. Combining the small storefront with the World Wide Web, he has been able to remain competitive with larger rivals and has grown the company to be one of the leading Yamaha music product retailers in the United States.
<<<What I don’t like about these patents is that it’s all on paper but these companies have no marketable product. Isn’t filing a patent to protect the idea AND the product you are going to sell, so that other can’t simply copy your innovation, your product on the marketplace? But if you don’t market your idea within a reasonable time-frame and wait to cash in on violations on your idea, that’s bogus. I believe that patents shouldn’t be about owning an idea, but protecting the idea AND the product you are going to sell. But these companies behave like they OWN an idea without having a product an the market. How, then, does Apple cause damages to the company that holds an patent idea, which it doesn’t have any products for?>>>
An idea isn’t patentable according to US Law.
America’s national sport is NOT baseball, it’s litigation.
So I’m assuming Microsoft, Real and Napster (among others) are also on the hit list???
It’s just more of the same story…
Someone “wins the lottery” and people come out of the woodwork trying to take a piece of it…
Apple made a great, original product and there is little doubt Apple’s Patent attorney’s researched things thoroughly and even if there was a similarity, patent laws are clear… Innovation makes it unique and patentable, even if it is based on another patented concept.
in the end, it’s the attorneys who always win these things.
Right from the USPTO.gov web site…
“A patent for an invention is a grant of property rights by the U.S. Government through the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. The patent grant excludes others from making, using, or selling the invention in the United States”…
…”A patent cannot be obtained on a mere idea or suggestion. Patent applications are examined for both technical and legal merit.”
Notice that this does not say the invention must be marketed or sold by the company or person(s) that were granted the patent. It is fully legal to invent something, patent it, and never sell it. Companies do it all the time. It is still the intellectual property of the company- that doesn’t change whether the invention is sold or not. The invention must have documentation to back up what is being claimed by the invention. This can include design sketches, test data, etc., that proves the idea actually was realized and the claims can be substantiated with data.
The problem I have with this story is that Contois waited so long before they decided to file suit. Have they been living under a rock? As others have mentioned, iTunes has been out for years.
After re-reading mypost, it sounds like I’m trying to defend Contois. I am definitely not! I posted the USPTO info for those who are a little confused about patents.
Must be Casio keyboards aren’t selling too hot and they need some cash!
bill gates can’t be for :p
<<stabtheman (the surreal one) Jun 20, 05 – 07:43 pm Well, for one thing, their from Vermont. Here’s a link which has a picture of the whole inbred family…>>
OK Stabtheman… fun is fun when you are making fun of sputnik and stantheman, but you don’t go making fun of an entire state! Especially when it’s Vermont (beautiful Green Mountains). Geez! you can’t even spell “their” in the correct context.
Alright, now for the real fun. Get ready to be blown away. You probably don’t know this (obviously), but the original PowerPC 970 (aka: G5, duh!) is …. MANUFACTURED IN ESSEX JUNCTION, VERMONT. Way before Fishkill could get it’s multi-billion dollar fab to yield enough silicon to be usable, IBM gave the Essex Jct. Plant the nod to produce the first lots of PPC970’s to deliver to Apple. This fabrication in VERMONT continued for over 2 years until the 90nm Fab in Fishkill, NY was operational. I wouldn’t be surprised if the G5 iMac 970’s are still made in VT.
I was standing in the room (in VT) with 40+ IBM engineers during Job’s G5 introduction where he promised to deliver 3Ghz G5’s …. There was a collective hush in the room, then several of them piped up, I don’t remember us promising that. Jobs was already unlocking the back door at that point for his ultimate coupe de gras… Sell Apple to Intel!
Anyway, It’s probably not much info, but Contois Music in Vermont happens to be less than 2 miles down the road from the IBM plant where they make the 970’s… but that’s pretty much coincidence.
My personal opinion is that this suit may have legs, as if you read apple-insider and Wikipedia accounts, Mr. Jeff Robbin who was an Apple employee at the time of Comdex 95, may very well have looked a little too close at Mr. Contois’ program. Mr. Robbins later developed SoundJam for Cassidy & Greene while still an employee at Apple. Then later, Apple aquired the rights to SoundJam for conversion to iTunes. Then Mr Robbin became lead on the iTunes project.
So, Mr. Contois WAS at Comdex selling his product, when along came Mr. Robbin to look at this software, later to become his iTunes brainchild.
The real question is, did Jeff Robbin get to look “under the hood” of Contois’ program? Did he buy a copy? Did he do nasty things with it late at night to unwrap it’s secrets of programming?
But, if Robbin, walked by Contois’ booth at Comdex looked down at the program, remarked to Contois “nice app”, walked away and said to himself, “I could do better”, then Contois’ ain’t got nuthin’ on Apple.
oh, & by the way, VERMONT is freakin’ awsome! Can you say Phish?
The patent, in its entirety, can be viewed here…
http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=/netahtml/srchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5,864,868.WKU.&OS=PN/5,864,868&RS=PN/5,864,868
webmaster’s apprentice:
Thanks for pointing out my erroneous use of “their”. I should be knuckle-rapped. And as for making fun of Vermont, well, okay. I live in Rhode Island, so take a jab and get even.
But while we’re here, and to prove I read your entire post, I point to my own nit to pick: Paragraph 6, last sentence:
Then later, Apple aquired the rights to SoundJam for conversion to iTunes. Then Mr Robbin became lead on the iTunes project.
You are missing a “c”.
Oh, and yes, Vermont is awesome. Particularly in Autumn.
webmaster’s apprentice,
I like your logic on the Contois patent. From the press release about the suit, it mentioned current and future Apple employees visiting the booth. I wonder what kind of mementos were left behind or given away? Demo floppies (it was ’95) in exchange for a business card or entry in a guest book?
This one should be interesting!
The patent states “A computer user interface menu selection process for allowing the user to select music to be played on a music device controlled by a computer…”
They constantly state (rather vaguely) “…playing the selected song item … on the computer responsive music device…”
“..sending a data stream from the computer to the computer controlled music device..”
“…receiving the data stream by the computer controlled music device from the computer…”
It further uses a player piano as an example of a “music device”… “playing the selected song title on the player piano”.
“…a pause play button that will temporarily suspend the player piano from receiving the data stream…”
“…wherein the media information includes movie videos and the media playing means is a video player…” This is a very vague patent that itself may even infringe upon other computer software devices of the time (1996) that controlled video tape decks and other such devices. It can also be a stretch that the software within a Sony Walkman infringed upon their patent, too.
iTunes is of itself a music player and does not control external music devices. Even if you think that iTunes plays the CDs on the computer’s CD drive, a CD drive is not a music device but a computer data device.
There are numerous existing devices more similar to their patent such as MIDI software that utilize similar play/stop icons and file management for actual “musical devices”.
Never does the patent mention the software actually doing the playing of the music. All it outlines is something very similar to FileMaker for categorizing files, as well as displaying images and playing music connected to those files.
I strongly feel that ANYONE would see that the patent is for controlling MUSIC DEVICES, and does NOT apply to the controls self-contained on the music device itself. If so, they could claim the sort of interface is infringed by numerous electronic music devices. I personally know that my parents had an electronic organ (made in late 80’s) with a similar method of saving (recording) and playing music.
Mr. Robbins later developed SoundJam for Cassidy & Greene while still an employee at Apple. Then later, Apple aquired the rights to SoundJam for conversion to iTunes. Then Mr Robbin became lead on the iTunes project. So, Mr. Contois WAS at Comdex selling his product, when along came Mr. Robbin to look at this software, later to become his iTunes brainchild.
The only problem with the above said is that SoundJam looks nothing like iTunes and was more of a WinAmp wannabee (though WAY better). I was sort of sad to see SoundJam go and was very close to buying it before iTunes came out of nowhere and for free.
It’s all about money, like “Meja” said.
Jack Arends:
“America’s national sport is NOT baseball, it’s litigation.”
…nice!
It won’t hold. In fact Apple can sue back. As you remember Apple bought the software called SoundJamMP in the late 90s. This was created well before this patent. SoundJamMP became iTunes.
scotty
Apple has a Patent on it already… Maybe they should sue the patent office…
Link here: http://macdailynews.com/index.php/weblog/comments/3114/
i hope apple crush these scumbags like gnats
re: stabtheman (the surreal one)
I get the impression that this ‘dave’ guy is running a one man band type company – prbably from his bedroom!
Apple deserves this for the dispicable attitude they have towards other peoples or companies innovation. They will pay like it or not.
Apple should sue Microsoft for using “windows” as a means of interfacing with and organizing computer data files.
Oh, wait…
Scott Jackson,
“Apple bought the software called SoundJamMP in the late 90s. This was created well before this patent.”
The Contois patent was granted in 1996. SoundJam was published in 1999. Apple’s patent for a media player interface was filed in 2001.
I’ve just patented nose picking. All you slow typists pay up now.
Isn’t it funny that when a company claims Apple is infringing on their patent, everybody screams that its stifling innovation. But when Apple gets ridiculous software patents, its for protecting their intellectual property.
Folks, software patents are evil. Whether Apple gets them or someone else. I think Richard Stallman said it best yesterday here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/online/comment/story/0,12449,1510566,00.html
Software should be copyrighted, not patented. Their patent is nothing more than a very crude FileMaker data base with an audio and image data fields.
They do not explain HOW the “music device” is to be controlled. All they present is a vague concept for the user interface for such a device. This is much more art than device and should copyrighted. While iTunes may be similar in appearance, there are many more differences and is not enough to claim that Apple copied it. Everything they present ALREADY EXISTED, such as the pause/play icons and “their concept” of file retrieval by category.
Once again, iTunes does NOT control a “music device”. They might have a better chance at going after Apple for GarageBand and its control of MIDI devices, but then GarageBand doesn’t look anything like their device other than the ubiquitous pause/play icons.
To those saying there is nothing in the patent to show control of music you may have missed this:
“According to the suit, persons who were at the time employed by, or later became employed by, Apple were present at both trade shows and viewed Contois’ software.”
So, there was some software demonstrated on which the patent was based. That is what will show you how it was played.
This one seems a little more than just cyber-squatting or the idiot suing TiVo.
I’d say good luck to them. Why did it take so long and only now they want to sue. Another company trying to get rich quick scam.
I wonder if these people are the same people who were running SCO. Whatever happened to that lawsuit about them owning the Unix operating system yet they never proved one line of code was there’s to date.
So, if I patent tele-porting as an idea does this mean I can sue anybody who eventually gets it to work ?
I think not. Another bonkers case for a lawyer to rack up an expenses claim.
Hey…..
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”tongue wink” style=”border:0;” />
I just found a finger in my iTunes!
I am gonna sue
Hiya all,
Just a little reminder of how the Apple Lisa’s column browser looked like back in 1980:
It’s quite obvious that this hierarchical folder/content mode has been floating around for a while, and has been adapted to a lot of applications, namely the 1988 NeXT file viewer:
Nowadays, this way of presenting content (ANY kind of content, not just music) is part of various other pieces of Apple and 3rd party software. It’s part of the Mac OS X GUI guidelines as well.
Nothing new…
u guys are idiots.
read the patent.
they aren’t sueing apple because they have the three pane look.
the are sueing on how itunes organizes music.
stupid blind fans…. when are u guys gonna stop licking job’s arse?
I think I will sit back and wait. I demonstrated a menu system using the cursor keys and on screen navigation for selecting files and then launching the relevant application (which could include a music player) at the West Coast Computer Fair in 1979. I met both Mr Gates and Mr Jobs as well as the Woz and a bunch of others on that trip from Oz to the USA. I even have the original source code backed up on 8″ floppy, 5.25″ floppy and 1/2″ reel to reel tape. It was the first commercial program I wrote and owned myself and I sold over 10,000 copies in the next few years.
If this jerk, wins I’ll sue it all off him.
As for the time it has taken him to file, he could have (and should have) launched his case by self filing and then adjourned to ensure proper representation. At the very least if he issued formal notices of intent to sue he should make those public.
It just seems a little convenient to me. I wonder if his lawyers have any clients in Redmond?
In order for them to prove any infringement, they’ll have to prove that software code had been pilfered. They purposely configured the iTunes browser to mimic the choices on their software. There are many more choices that are available in the browser than what they show in their graphic. And it’s pretty low to put a bow-tied Liberace in the iTunes window just because they had some bow-tied guy who looks more like Merv Griffin in theirs.
I would say that Contois’ lawyer needed to make a payment on the ol’ BMW so he’s allowing a patently frivelous lawsuit to go through, which he must know hasn’t got a snowball’s chance, so he can soak 10 or 20 grand from him.
“[they] are [suing] on how [iTunes] organizes music.”
How else would music be organized? Certainly not by the color of the album art or the number of letters in the artist’s last name. You organize by name, genre, album name, etc. It’s logical. You can’t patent that. Brick and mortar music stores have used similar classifications forever. And if it’s the listing of names in column format, sorry, that’s a generic concept as well.
Besides, the original “intent” of the patent was for music playing devices, like player pianos or their digital equivalent (MIDI?). These are just a bunch of greedy leeches. They, and the sleazebag lawyers they rode in on, can rot for all I care. The Patent Office should get the blame for this too. Issuing patents for vaporware… idiots. Only issue patents for an existing prototype and you’ll avoid this nonsense.
I think this says it all…
“The first embodiment relates to the use of a computer system and user interface to control which music is to be played upon a player piano. Although one skilled in the art will know how a MIDI system works and how a computer controlled solenoid operated player piano operates, these two topics are provided for background purposes. A second embodiment of the invention relates to the use of a computer system and user interface for allowing a user to select which movie video will be played upon a computer controlled video media playing device or the like. One skilled in the art of computers and video control will understand how the system operates in view of the discussion of the player piano operation. “
oh, by the way, I just got the patent for LIFE. pay up.
The statute of limitations is 1 year or should be.
Check out this introduction article on Patent attorney:
http://www.articleworld.org/Patent_attorney