Musical mobile phones not ‘iPod killers’ yet

“There’s only one thing truly holding mobile phones back from trampling the iPod shuffle. The trouble is, they might never overcome it,” Charles Arthur writes for Netimperative. “The attractions of playing your music on your phone are obvious. You don’t need to buy an iPod shuffle. You don’t have to swap headphones when a call comes in. Transferring the songs is about as easy as putting them on an MP3 player. (Slightly easier, if you’ve been using some of the Windows-based jukeboxes that aren’t Apple’s iTunes.) It fits in your pocket. You already carry it around all the time.”

“So why don’t I think music on phones is quite ready to displace MP3 players like the iPod? Actually to some extent, they will. They are going to encroach on the low end of the market (particularly, the flash memory-based ones like the iPod shuffle and MuVo) as the year progresses. But phones have fatal flaws in a key department: the user interface, specifically data navigation,” Arthur writes. “That’s why, until the user interface side is sorted out, you’re still going to see companies like Apple walking off with the proceeds of iPod sales, and phone companies struggling to sell music downloads with any conviction. It’s not about the content. It’s about how you get to it.”

Full article here.

Related MacDailyNews articles:
Motorola CEO: Apple iTunes mobile phone on track for July debut, carriers not balking – May 18, 2005
Motorola expects to launch first Apple iTunes phone this summer, second iTunes phone in 4th quarter – May 11, 2005
Motorola’s Apple iTunes phone software screenshots posted online – May 11, 2005
Will cellphones eat Apple’s iPod or vice versa? – May 09, 2005
Bona fide Apple iPod killer? Nokia’s 4GB mobile ‘jukebox’ phone due by Christmas – April 28, 2005
Can mobile phones and telecoms kill Apple’s golden iPod+iTunes combo? – April 26, 2005
Motorola CEO Zander: Apple iTunes phone due ‘in the next few months’ – April 20, 2005
RUMOR: Apple’s iTunes Mobile 1.0 to be ready by June – April 20, 2005
Verizon, Sprint, other wireless companies balk at carrying Apple’s and Motorola’s ‘iPod phone’ – April 19, 2005
Motorola to unveil iRadio – PC to Mobile to Car Stereo service – April 18, 2005
Will Motorola’s Apple iTunes phone make it to market? – March 28, 2005
BusinessWeek: What’s going on with the Motorola Apple iTunes mobile phone? – March 24, 2005
So who’s really delaying the Motorola iTunes phone anyway? – March 21, 2005
Motorola exec: Apple iTunes phone debut delayed by Steve Jobs; phones will launch in 2005 – March 16, 2005
Motorola’s Apple iTunes phone in trouble? – March 14, 2005
Motorola says iTunes phone unveiling delay not caused by dispute with carriers – March 10, 2005
Motorola says it’s working on more iTunes phones, some models ‘can store eight hours of music’ – March 10, 2005
Motorola indefinitely postpones Apple iTunes phone unveiling – March 10, 2005
Motorola’s ‘ROKR’ Apple iTunes mobile phone to be unveiled this Thursday – March 06, 2005
Motorola’s yet-to-be-unveiled ‘ROKR’ phone will be first Apple iTunes phone – February 16, 2005
Nokia to use Microsoft’s music formats on its handsets – February 15, 2005
Motorola E1060 not, repeat not, the iTunes phone – February 16, 2005
Motorola executive previews iTunes Phone at CES, syncs to iTunes like an Apple iPod – January 06, 2005
Apple’ prodigious hardware and software design skills may help Motorola create iPod phone – December 28, 2004
Apple, Motorola iTunes on cell phones a harmonious deal that benefits both companies – August 05, 2004
Motorola posts Steve Jobs’ Apple iTunes announcement video – July 28, 2004
Apple, Motorola iTunes deal not exclusive, debuts Apple’s licensing of FairPlay DRM – July 27, 2004
Motorola and Apple to bring iTunes Music Player to Motorola’s next-gen mobile phones – July 26, 2004


  1. I think the UI can be sorted out, and will be. (I still have not sorted out how to text message with any proficiency.)

    But the reason I’d never use a cell phone to listen to music, or play games for that matter, is battery life. My phone never goes dead at a “good” time. Perhaps it is because I think of my phone as a communications tool that I need to work when I need it to work.

  2. With all this iPod killer this and iPod killer that, the iPod must be the most hated piece of equipment out there. Every other electronics company out there has tried to dethrone the iPod. None have succeeded.

    So all articles about iPod killing gadgets, are henceforth attributed to iPenis (ahem iPod [a genuine Freudian Slip there]) envy.

  3. Additionally, the form factor. I exercise with my iPod shuffle hanging around my neck. I would not want to do this with a cell phone (or regular iPod for that matter).

  4. You want to know why music on phones will never catch on? Same reason why comsumers hate having to go onto the internet using their phone wire–cause they want the internet for the internet and they want a phone to be a phone–cause they need the phone to talk on–when you add funtionality to a phone that takes away its intended use–its a bad idea–
    If you want to say that its an okay idea because people need not listen to music on their phone if they dont want to but just in case they do want to they can–okay its an okay idea. But it isnt an IPOD. Next?

  5. Queen Elizabeth bought an IPOD cause she doesnt need a phone. I bet she will only be allowed to download like pomp and circumstance and Beatles stuff–Apple should buy Apple and the Beatles portfolio. I think that guy above is right about phones and battery life–people are not going to want to use a phone for music. Nevertheless Apple should have had a phone using some sort of Apple operating system years ago.

Reader Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.