“I’m not your typical Apple Fanboy; despite the fact that I have recommended a Mac to almost 70% of the people who ask me what PC to buy (a true Fanboy would recommend a Mac to 100% of the people he meets, defying logic when asked why). To understand my logic behind recommending the Mac to 70% of the people and not the rest, you’ve got to understand Apple’s logic behind the Mac, as it stands right now,” Varun Singh writes for Techtree.
“Now, first, the Mac isn’t so much the hardware that is cobbled together to make the machine as it is the OS that runs on top of that machine; it is the OS and the apps on it that is center to the Mac strategy, has always been! The reason why I concur with Apple when they say OS X is the most advanced operating system on the planet, is because it is the only desktop OS that has been written ‘grounds-up’ to integrate the most cutting edge technologies in the last decade and isn’t a rehash of existing systems. (Windows XP is still very much Windows NT at the core and so is Linux, which still retains the basic structure of the first kernel and the communications between programs [APIs]),” Singh writes.
“If you look at Mac OS X and the intricate web of applications that makes it the most user friendly desktop computer ever, you’d notice a clear pattern of ‘focus’ on specific computing areas; those being creativity, multimedia and day-to-day home computing tasks,” Singh writes. “It isn’t meant to be a do-it-all machine, at least not yet. The area Apple is weakest at when compared to the PC platform is gaming.”
“Creativity on the fringes is something [Apple has] already handled pretty well with great products like iMovie, iDVD, iPhoto, Garage Band on the lower-end and Final Cut Pro, Adobe Photoshop for Mac OS X etc. on the higher end,” Singh writes. “And then, they’re going after what most of us call Office Productivity (Apple calls it iWork). If you’ve seen what Pages, their new ‘Word Processor’ can do, you’d never want to use Word again. Keynote 2, the presentation tool, is ages ahead of anything PowerPoint can imagine. Apple’s going to do a lot in the next three years to make your life easier… Sony and Microsoft can go kill each other on Electronic Gaming!”
Full article here.
MacDailyNews Take: 30% of the people Singh recommends a computer to are mainly interested in games? Why not tell them to get a Mac and a Playstation and give them the best of both worlds? Even Windows-maker Microsoft seems to realize that the PC isn’t the best place for games or why would they be bothering with their Xbox console effort?
Gaming is a huge deficiency for the mac, and it leads to aproblem that pisses me off, a lack of retail graphics cards for the mac. Oh sure, they’re there, but they don’t have what you want (ADC anyone?).
Also, macs are waaaaaaaaaayyyyyy behind in another 3D area, CAD/CAE/CAM. There are older UNIX programs out there for sure and they might run in X11, but as a Mechanical and Aerospace Engineer, and a faithful Mac user (for 1-2 yrs now), this is a big disappointment. I know it’s not really Apple’s fault, but if 3rd parties won’t come out with a industry leading mac CAD package, well, then Apple needs to buy someone with that 6.5 Billion in cash that they have. I mean, holy crap buy out whoever makes some windows only thing, and make another “Pro App” category with engineering in mind. And if you say that there’s Maya for 3D, well, yeah, if I was making a movie and only cared about looks, not solid parametric modelling.
Alright, enough mac-engineer-nerd venting for me.
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
In the consumer space PC games are still a big deal. Another reason to love the Mac Mini! Just get the mini and a KVM switch and you have the best of both worlds!
You are right to the point Stev M. Let’s see what Steve J answers..
I still like playing games more on my computer than on a console though. Not being a major gamer it is not that important though. However, I have heard comments from some hard core gamers that if you want to reach the very difficult upper levels you pretty much have to do it on a Computer and not a console.
Anyway, “get a console”, while it may be the answer for some, is definitely not the answer for all. I hope that as Apple market share gains with the mini, more games will come sooner to the Mac. What Apple should really do if they want to capture some of the hardcore gamer market is come up with a killer game that can only be played on the Mac. It only takes one. Hard as it may be to believe, a lot of people would end up buying a whole new computer just to play a game if you make it good enough. And if anybody can make it good enough, Apple can.
Please please please fix the Magic Word Pop Up Problem.
MDN-“why would they be bothering with their Xbox console effort?”
To make money, stupid.
Steve is still clueless on some of this stuff.
One game justifies getting a high end PC:
Half Life 2
Good luck trying to get the same experience on the incredibly slow PS2 or even the faster XBox. Just can’t handle it.
Mac is great for the majority of things, but we’re not gonna win fans by saying it’s for everything.
My prediction: specialized gaming systems like playstation and xbox will, in the near future, either exceed game performance of PC’s or be very close equivalents.
Unfortunately, I still like M$ for one thing… the XBOX.
I think that as far as gaming goes, it’s the best platform available right now. Combined with LIVE it gives me everything I want in a game console. I know it’s not the most popular platform development wise, but I’ve been extremely pleased with its offerings. A gaming PC is just too costly for me to consider keeping up with.
And when I don’t want to game, my G5 keeps me quite occupied!!
Magic word=”live”!!! Funny? or Scary?
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”big surprise” style=”border:0;” />
Playing games is so lame. Talk about wasting your life away. The difference betweem the average windblows user and a Mac user?
Mac user: Creative and productive
Windows user: Couch potato
There – I said it
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”red face” style=”border:0;” />
Steve M… maybe I am missing something but there are quite a few CAD apps out there. One that I have been using for nearly ten years now is VectorWorks. There are also a ton of 3D apps, may favorite being Cinema 4D XL. Maybe this helps or perhaps I am misunderstanding the specialization that is required in the Aerospace Engineer field as I am in the architectural/engineering field.
HDL = bullsh*t
“…come up with a killer game that can only be played on the Mac.”
If memory serves me correctly, Halo would have been just that, until Microsoft bought Bungie to develop games for the XBox (in the process also taking out continued ‘Marathon’ development and a host of other great OS9 games from Bungie as collateral damage).
I’m sticking with PS2 because of that crap move by M$…
If you take a good look, most of the big gaming systems are built on PPC (or a variant of). The GameCube essentially uses a 500MHz-ish G3. The Playstation 2 uses a PPC variant of some kind. XBox is on x86, but remember all the talk of XBox 2 using G5s?
Plus with all the graphics and 3D stuff thats done on the Mac, I don’t think there’s any deficiency in the hardware. In fact, I’d bet the Mac would make a better gaming platform than the PC from a strictly hardware perspective.
The problem we run into is twofold. Firstly, most game developers write for PC only. The game market is lower for Mac as much as I hate to say it. The second part is, seldom are games written specifically for Mac. Most of them are ports of the PC version. Which means that the code isn’t optimised for Mac OS and therefore doesn’t run quite as good as it could.
All things being equal, the Mac would make a better gaming platform than PC. Unfortunately nobody listens to me… :-b~
MDN you just don´t get the games thing.
Games are much better on the computer. All gaming on the computer is interenational, people playing people all over the world via the internet.
You have to have a computer to do that—unless you want to pay some subscription fee like Xbox has ($50 a year just for XBox Live, plus the cost of your internet service).
Apple fails in the games dept. And this is why Apple will never get any large migration from the consumer market to the Mac.
Games are extremely important. The vast majority of computer users out there need or even want a grand selection of games. However their absense is signifigant because they are important to the programmers and tech geeks that these consumers talk to when they purchase.
The only thing that hurts the mac is the fact that software that people need is more likely to be available on the PC. Sure 90+% of the consumers would not even notice they were missing, but the word of that 10% get around.
In the case of programmers (I am a developer, so I know many). Most of them spend most of their life on the computer (sad but true). Most sing praises of the Mac and OS X but wont buy because it won’t play their current favorite game. I have convinced a few to get mac’s in addition to a PC, but most say thay can’t afford it (a strange concept since they pay twice the price for the ultimate gaming PC – one friend paid the price of an iBook for a graphics card alone).
The reason Apple needs to address games is to entice the programmers. If you get the programmers then the few really important programs that are missing will make their way to the Mac so there will be no objection.
I think Apple should hire a few really great game programers to come up with a Mac only game that is so good that every programmer and tech guy in america will be begging to buy a Mac to play it – then they will fall in love with OS X and start convincing their bosses to go cross platform.
I have watched my friends and co workers go buy a specific console for one game. So Apple – “If you build it they will come!”
yeah I agree with Gamxr. I have rec’d a Mac (and they bought one happily) to about 6 friends, but one friend I had to rec a PC. He’s really into it for games, and playing poker on the Net. His favorite poker site is PC only, so that was a no brainer. I do believe that for some very few people a PC is better. At least until Apple has every game available for them.
Oops – i meant to say the vast majority DON’T need the games.
Why would they be bothering with there Xbox effort?
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”LOL” style=”border:0;” />
It’s certainly not making money. They have been losing money on every Xbox that they have ever sold.
its a domino effect – if the Mac mini is a big hit and Apple gains marketshare, more games will become available, and more people will switch. Here’s hoping the mini is the device that gets this ball rolling…
(and yeah, I totally agree that it would be awesome if Apple came out with a “Halo” type game only available for the Mac)
b, seems you haven’t heard, MS has pumped 10s if not 100s of million into Xbox, no profit in sight. Its a money loser. When you look at Xbox, and all the other money losers that MS has (well documented here in other MDN articles) its a wonder that the the 3 profit centers (MBU, Windows, Office) can sustain such huge money leaks and still be profitable. Oh wait, its cause they OVERCHARGE by an order of magnitude for the 3 profitable things.
I am not suggesting that Apple should make a game console. I am just suggesting a game to run on the Mac. And yes I would be thrilled if it broke even. The market is relativly small for games and they are not worth the effort. However that small market is heavily weighted with the people that drive the over all market and produce the business applications that regular people use. I do not know any game programmers – but every programmer I know plays games. Every network guru I know plays games. These are the people that get asked which computer do I buy? Right now most say you need a PC because more programs are available, or that is what I know and can help you with.
If you get them comfortable and Happy with the Mac then they will start to recommend it. Games are not important as a profit center. These same people are always complaining about Windows, but they keep recommending Windows because they think “Half Life 2” is critical and anything that can’t run it is useless.
We are not talking about normal people making the decisions here. Most normal people ask a geek what to buy, because they think they are better informed – since they live and breath computers. For every one of them you win you may pick up 10 new “regualar” customers a year.
Not to mention if they discover how powerful OS X is they will be screaming to management that every one needs OS X. These are the people who do not want Mac’s in the company because they have to support them. Get them using OS X and they will not be afraid of supporting them – they may even push for them since it will make their lives easier.
Think of it as a loss-leader. You know it is going to lose money, but it gets the masses in the store where they can buy the profit making items.
This is the one area MS excels in – losing money on one think to get you trapped into another. The differance is Apple offers something that does not have to trap them.
“Apple Game Studio” anyone? Didn’t the founder and lead programer of Bungie retire or something?
Even though we might like to think it will happen, we will never have the HARDCORE gamer market. Why? Many of them like to tear apart their systems and rebuild them with the newest parts. We want the average and occassional gamer market, Which means we need games released for the Mac either simultaniously or in a REASONABLE time frame (3 months) from when the PC version is released.
My sons play games via the internet with their PeeCees.
They play for hours.
They have LAN gaming parties at peoples houses (all have peecees).
They play games and talk to each other via the internet.
It is an entire other world out there for those that play games over the internet.
One time I asked my sone how many people are currently on line playing the game he was on. My son checked – over 30,000(!!!). Usually more, he says. Each in little teams, clans, challenging each other from all over the world.
It is a amazingly large world community that is only open to those using peecees.
Why? No Mac versions of the games available.
Call of Duty, Half Life, Warcraft, on and on.
Sure the Apple version soemtimes eventually comes out (except Half Life – never will), but by then everyone is burned out on the game and the next new one is out.
Apple can forget any person playing computer games to switch to a Mac.
$125 Million dollars on Day One of Halo 2 is nothing to sneeze at.
Halo skips too much on the iMac 20/1.8/1.0/250, in fact it skips a bit in my 2_x_2.5! Call of Duty is skippy in the iMac, just good on the 2 x 2.5. Massive Assault, a decent replacement for those who liked the early Strategic Conquest, is totally bloated and has memory issues: slow on anything but better’n nuthin’.
Get a Mac and a Playstation is so totally wrong, sorry to have to say it. CoD on the Mac has made our Playstation an orphan. We have two CoDs and CoD United Offensive — the latter has better multiplayer maps. One kid on the iMac and ano-(cough)-ther on the PowerMac get to battle online on the same or opposite sides. They look so forward to it that they’ll complete their homework and chores toute suite in order to get to the comp.
Mac gaming is an issue — the problem is that no one has the gonads to talk to Uncle Steve about it — and the business suffers for it. MDN: you’re flat out wrong. Get a Mac and another Mac rather than a Playstation. For the serious gamers it’s a PC and another PC if they can get it to work. I won’t even go there, and as for the XBox, I won’t touch the devil’s box, full-stop.
There’s enough games for the Mac to keep your kids out of PC-envy, unless your Mac can’t handle it. The iMac 1.8 barely can. I find that sad.
HAHAHA, your joking right?!?
Enough games on the Mac?!?
Please…I love Macs as much as the next person, but I’d rather keep some credibility by facing reality. You can’t play the majority of the top games on the Mac.
On top of that, video cards for the Macs are hardly as plentiful as they are on the PC side.
It’s this dumb talk that puts off people from trying the Mac. The Mac is great at a lot of things, but games is not one of them. There is just not enough support for it.
“Want a computer and games? Get a Mac plus a Playstation and get the best of both worlds”
I’ve been saying this to everyone for over 2 years now. A PS2 just works, just like a Mac. You simply turn the thing on, load the game disc in and there you go. Plus with online gaming capabilities as they are today, the PC really doesn’t have any major advantage over the consoles anymore.
Besides, you can buy both a Mac mini (for $499) and a Sony PS2 (for $149) for far cheaper than you can buy a decent PC gaming rig. And you have no viruses or other crapware issues to ever worry about either.
“No Mac versions of the games available. Call of Duty, Half Life, Warcraft, on and on.”
Call of Duty
World of Warcraft
But you’re right–no Half Life.
By the way, I play CoD and Halo. It’s not the platform–it’s the player. I’ve had some pretty kick-ass sessions on Halo with my PowerMac G5 Dual 2Ghz (D3adB33f). You should hear the kiddies whine when I tell them I use a Mac. Of course, then they usually gang up on me…
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”tongue wink” style=”border:0;” />
The hardcore PC gamer is a very tiny niche of the overall consumer computing base. The majority of people are satisfied with console gaming and aren’t going to shell out the big bucks it costs for a decent PC gaming rig. How many people really shell out $400+ for a graphics card strictly for games anyway? It’s a very, very small minority of consumers out there, that’s for sure. I can assure you that far more people own a game console (PS2, XBox or GC) than they do a mid to high end PC gaming rig. Why do you think Sony and M$ are tripping over themselves to get their hands on as big of a piece of the console market as they can? It’s because the console gaming market is far bigger than the PC gaming market is.
Enough games to keep your kids out of PC envy, I said if you’re referring to my comment, Chomper. And if enough pay, as I pay for the good ones, we’ll get more games for the Mac. And if enough switch, we’ll get even more. But I agree that the Mac, in general, is not great at games. Apple has been blind to that for too long.
I’ll even say this: I’d trade the most fashionable, minimalist, mini-form Mac for a reasonably uglier and bigger Mac if it’s going to get me more — bang for my bucks, even if it has an external radiator to cool the two G5s. ‘Course, I’d like to have my cake and eat it too.
I have no need for a cheap Mac mini. I need to buy a third Mac for my kids for gaming. Problem is, Apple isn’t addressing that market.
It’s an interesting problem, but a difficult one to fix. To be honest, I don’t think you can fix the Mac games issue with games. I know, I know, stick with me here. I don’t think the problem is that Steve doesn’t get gaming, I think the problem is that there’s not much he can do about it. The only way to fix it, in my view, is to get the Mac back to a large enough base that developers will find it worthwhile to spend money making Mac games. Right now, that’s just not the case. When they can develop for consoles that you know the specs of and know they aren’t going to change for a few years, and they can develop for a PC base that is like it or not the vast majority of computer users, there’s very little incentive to spend money and time trying to capture that small remaining bit of the market. The law of diminishing returns, as they say. Besides, even if a developer wants to do a Mac game, they’re certainly not going to push back the release of it on PCs/consoles in order to spend the time making a Mac version at the same time. That’s just lost sales because they could be using those resources to get it out sooner. That means the Mac version isn’t going to come out until later, and by then most people who really want to play it will own it for PC/PS2/Xbox or whatever, so there is a very limited market left for it. But if the Mac can regain enough market share that they get over that threshold and become a big enough target, developers will come back. Nobody is going to pass up money for no good reason. Then you will see a shift in momentum as more and more developers enter the arena. So I guess it’s just one more reason to pray for the iPod halo effect, right?
Of course the console market is larger, cos’ it’s CHEAPER to build the hardware. However, the PC game market is still large enough to warrant large projects like Half Life 2.
The market is still worth pursueing, or else why would they even green light something like Half Life 2 which has cost many millions to make?
I’m not bashing the Mac, like I said, I’m fan of Apple, but an injection of reality is needed.
You can’t refute the fact that not many games are made for the Mac. That’s simple math.
However, the Mac definitely does a lot of things better than a PC.
shempzilla,
You have identified Apple’s conundrum:
Get more market share and you get more apps – get more apps and you get more market share.
Apple has been attacking one side of this equation – the market share side. Though there is some small signs of recent success, this is after years of failure to the point that Apple could double their share and not get the programs (games and others) to come to the mac platform.
So I suggest attackint the opposite side – bring more applications to the Mac. Apple has done this in a small way with applications like iMovie and iDVD that can entice people to change.
My suggestion is to attack this market head on. Really go after the developers. Re-release openstep for windows development – and increase the availability of Mac versions. Games are a small piece to this puzzle – but a critical one. Apple needs the “killer game,” the one that all the geeks and programmers just have to buy a mac to run.
Create a cross-platform game engine that is better than anything out there. Always release versions first on the mac, so that developers will start to target the Mac first and PC’s as a follow up.
Create developer progrms that encourage companies to choose Apple tools even for windows.
If apple can get the developers, then they can artifically stimulate the software availability and increase market share. then as the market share increases then the software offering will increase even more.
The game market is just one part of a much bigger plan, but it is the easiest to address. When you are the underdog, you have to go outside the box with your stratagy, target smaller markets that you can address. With all the consoles going PowerPC over the next few years, not would be the perfect time for apple to attack this market, as they could leverage that market to it’s advantage as well.
“No Mac versions of the games available. Call of Duty, Half Life, Warcraft, on and on.”
Call of Duty – Released for PC August 18, 2003, Released for Mac 5/14/2004
And From the review: “Of course, the highest quality of detail isn’t available for all machines, but for those that have a Dual 2.0 G5, every thing runs perfect with no slow down.” (Well, that leaves out most Macs…)
I am guessing the reason Apple is not aggessive with Games is that Steve J. is not into games. (Too old????)
Bobby Skinner, your point is well taken, but there’s a fundamental problem with it as well, in that you can’t force developers to do something. I would love to see Apple go after developers more, but there’s only so much they can do. Where I agree with you is on the development tools area. What they ought to do is put together a terrific package of tools for making games, then show it off by creating their own “killer app” game. It won’t be a true killer app, I’m afraid, for a very simple reason: price. A console can have a killer game, because if I really really want to play Halo 2, and I don’t have an Xbox, I can justify shelling out the $150 for the console I’ll need to play it. But is there any game that could be cool enough to make me spend $500 (more really because that’s a bare bones system that would need more RAM, etc., and assumes I have the moniter, keyboard, and mouse already too) if I didn’t already have a Mac? Probably not. But at least it would show developers how these tools can be used to make a great game. And for crying out loud, Apple, can you do something about the total lack of support for controllers and joysticks?
Developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers…
…
…
Developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers, developers!
The movie-like scrolling line of credits at the end of Call of Duty’s last maps attest to the effort that went into developing the game. The costs must’ve been something! Four disks on my household attest to its quality and success, as well as the importance of including the Mac market. And we’ll have six if they ever release a Pacific campaign.
The main issue for me is that an iMac should be able to play them reasonably well, not marginally. Apple should stop nickel and diming when it comes to video cards and memory. The iMac comes with two 128 MB of memory for chrissakes — dumped for two 256 MBs.
There will be no great games on the Mac until Mac people are willing to take games serious, and I just don’t see that happening. In this whole discussion it has not been mentioned once that there used to be great games on the Mac (and I mean: developed for, not ported to the Mac), ten, fifteen, twenty years ago.
How many here even know what I’m talking about when I say Chipwits, Glider, Ishido, Spaceship Warlock, SimTower, Cabol II?
I long ago noticed that it is always more difficult to find out details about the Mac version of games than about the versions for other platforms: when was it released, was it black & white or color, was there any at all. There are many data bases on the web that try to list all the games for a platform – but not for the Mac.
If you ever really want to attract gamers, you have to appreciate games as an art form. The attitude “games aren’t important, get a Playstation” won’t help.
Considering the size of the Mac market I am very satisfied with the selection of Mac games. Enough of the best games get ported to OS X for me not to care about the rest. How many games do you think I have money to buy and time to play?
By the way, consoles are over-rated. These days, hand-held is where it’s at.
Sol: “How many games do you think I have money to buy and time to play?
By the way, consoles are over-rated. These days, hand-held is where it’s at.”
Someday Sol when you are out of school have a real job and can afford to buy things you will see the light. And then you will buy a PC to play the games….
I totally agree with steve m (first post)’s opinion and to address Doctrine . I am a Macs & some PCs tech support for a few companies and I do get to see a few companies that uses autocad. Both the users as well as the management have expressed that they’re pissed off with PCs and would turn to Macs IF THERE IS A AUTOCAD VERSION FOR MACS in a heartbeat. (I hope someone from Autodesk reads this)
The top management have switched to Mac and a couple of the cad designers got Macs for their own personal use. But for their design work, its still PCs.
If anyone were to suggest that Archicad is available for macs, think of Archicad = iMovie ver 3 and Autocad = FinalCut Pro HD
and be PLAYING, not fighting malware.
Never really got the whole console thing. Give me a real first-person-shooter any day.
darknite, I didn’t say MS was making money, I’m just saying that was their reason. MS likes to control the standard, to make money in the long run. They’ll try to do it even if they lose money for a while. They want to control DRM as well, Why? $$$$$$$ I’m sure that MS didn’t get in the game box market because they feel that it’s superior to the PC for gaming (as MDN suggests). I’m sorry but that’s just stupid.
Just for the record, Massive Assault has a patch that fixes the slowdown issue.