Can Steve Jobs help end the Hollywood writers’ strike?

“As picketing continues outside studio gates, everyone from talent agents to George Clooney has been mentioned or tried their hand at mediating between the Writers Guild of America (WGA) and executives of the TV networks and film production companies. But here’s a name that hasn’t crossed too many minds: Steve Jobs, Apple’s bearded, music-loving chief executive officer,” Ron Grover reports for BusinessWeek.

“Consider this scenario: On Jan. 15, as the writers’ walkout drags into its eighth week, Jobs will take the stage for a keynote at his annual Macworld conference. He’s expected to announce that at least two—and possibly as many as five—studios have signed up to offer their movies for download to Apple’s video iPod and Apple TV products. That will no doubt generate big headlines—everything Jobs announces at Macworld does—and could make the notion of downloading movies from the Web a hot topic after years of false starts,” Grover reports.

“In doing so, Jobs could also put a Hollywood-style klieg light on the major issue separating the writers and movie moguls: how to cut in the unions for a share of the revenue from a new market that the studios have insisted isn’t yet big enough to share,” Grover reports. “‘It could validate everything that we’ve been saying,’ says WGA Assistant Executive Director Charles Slocum. ‘If he also announces that it will be in high-definition and you can order from the TV, it will mean the creation of a whole new market.'”

“During the short-lived negotiations this December before the writers hit the picket lines, the studios offered the same 1.2% for TV shows that are streamed on the Net, though not until after they have already been online for six weeks at a fixed rate of $250,” Grover reports. “The big thing that has kept the two sides from coming together is that studio executives insist there’s no market as yet for new media and they don’t want to get caught up in making expansive deals with the unions until there is one. Indeed, in their first go-round, the studios suggested they conduct a three-year study to determine the size of the market.”

Full article here.

The studios’ are full of it. Who cares what the size of the market is today? The percentage is all that matters. If you make a buck or a billion bucks, how much is the writers’ work worth? Figure out the percentage. The bigger the market grows, they more you all make. This has nothing to do with how big the market is, what size it will be sometime in the future, three-year ruses, and blah, blah, blah. It’s all about the percentage.

71 Comments

  1. First of all, why should writers or actors or anyone else EXCEPT the person, persons, or entity that owns a copyright work continued to be paid for its use?

    Writers are no different than anyone else. If I own a studio, and I pay you to do a job, i.e. write a script, you’ve been paid. Thank you. Get out.

    You don’t see anyone else whining when their work gets used again. I wrote software over a decade ago in banks that is still in us today, and has been repurposed many times. It’s what they paid me to do. Just because they turned around and used it for something else doesn’t mean I should get a royalty check.

    I don’t personally care if they eve come off strike. This is great!

    Hire some freaking new writers. Give new creative minds a chance. This striking crop of jokes is as bad as a Letterman or Leno routine. No one really wants to see it, we’d just like to see the guests make fools of themselves.

    Lumping Steve Jobs into this circus is just silly.

  2. Geez, TheloniousMac’s arrogant rant besmirches both the names he has stolen, Monk’s and Apple’s. Mr. Mac needs a new logic board.

    And MDN, howzabout knocking off those wretched pop-up ads which sneak by Safari’s blocker? This site is the only one in the Mac community that gives me those damned things. This site has become a virus.

  3. The market has a way of correcting itself. If the writers feel like they are not getting the proper compensation for their labor, they should find a different way to sell their work. Perhaps they should produce “TV” shows without a studio and sell them directly to the consumer via iTunes. If it catches on, the studios will capitulate.

  4. theloniousMac, Writers are no different than anyone else. If I own a studio, and I pay you to do a job, i.e. write a script, you’ve been paid. Thank you. Get out. Amen, brother thelonious.

    Unions are the great leveler. Everyone sinks to the bottom level.
    In the 1800’s unions were needed, now there are labor laws.
    The biggest unions are in government. Jobs for life, no matter how little you produce – Oh! that’s right, government produces nothing – except taxes. The best companies have no unions, or onions for that matter!

  5. What’s not mentioned in the MDN info (and even the Busness Week article) is that you could argue that Jobs is techincally under action by the WGA, being as he is Disney’s largest shareholder. Chew on that.

  6. This is Hollywood’s opportunity to try to get me back into watching TV.

    Hire all new writers and start over. The dialog I see on most TV shows is sooooo bad, it’s an insult to my intelligence to think I would be entertained by it.

    TV commercials are even worse. Like, I’m going to buy insurance from a company that thinks a talking gecko will appeal to me. It may be cute & all, but they’re trying to sell insurance for crying out loud.

  7. Folks let’s keep something very clear and in the front of this disscussion. The way a writer makes a living as a career is that they get paid up front for thier work and inbetween jobs the residuals keep them afloat until the next job. If you take away the residual then you are putting the industry that “CREATES YOUR CONTENT” to death.

    When debating this topic please do not forget this very important point.

    end of line

  8. @theloniusMac

    Writers get peanuts and the real compensation comes per ticket/DVD/BD sold.

    Just like composers get paid a certain % when buy a CD. If you accept a deal, where the studio keeps reaping the profits after the movie is finished, you’re a moron.

  9. “…Money demands that you sell, not your weakness to men’s stupidity, but your talent to their reason…”
    Ayn Rand

    It’s absurd to believe that you should continue to be paid by a company for work you did while under the employ of that company. I don’t care if you’re a writer, an actor, a producer, a director, or a janitor. You were hired to do a job. You did it. End of story. Just because you consider your work ooohhhh “creative” doesn’t mean that it isn’t work that was paid for, in full, at the time.

    To believe that you should continue to be paid, that is the height of arrogance.

    If you want to OWN your work, don’t work for someone else.

    Do these simpletons even understand the concept that THEY ARE WORKING FOR SOMEONE ELSE?

    I say leave them on the picket lines. Let them work on writing better signs until they come back crawling for less money.

    GOOD WRITERS don’t have to strike for royalties. They are just given them. Their talent is the only negotiator they need.

  10. @theloniousMac

    *Yawn* Where did you come from? If I develop and patent a new method (software or otherwise) if someone else wants to use it, they can negotiate a royalty. The way the writers/studios relationship is structured, the writers PAYMENT is based on a fixed cost PLUS A COMMISSION. So your argument is a bit like vaporware. Look at most sales jobs, for example. They are structured with a base payment plus a commission. To take it a step further, the studios were saying that the Internet doesn’t really qualify because there are no revenues yet. There should be an easy solution to this and it just requires level heads, not greedy ones.

  11. TheloniousMac

    Well, you see the irony in the argument.

    1. If I buy a DVD, I an use it in any way I want. I can rip, make multiple copies for watching it on TV, computer, and iPod. But, the movie moguls want me to pay for every single use. By your logic, I paid the money for the content. They shouldn’t worry about how I use it.

    2. The problem is that the same people who want money per use, don’t want to share the money per use with people who helped create the content. They want to pay them once, and use them however they want.

    I don’t care which side you support, at least support consistently for all.

  12. @Danno Boano

    Your analogy of writing to sales is at best illogical. A sales person is paid a base salary and in some cases an incentive of a percentage of sales. Just like anyone else they work for the base salary. If the company they’re working for WISHES to pay the additional incentive, that is up to the company.

    In fact, this “royalty” system is like nothing anywhere else in the world. It also does not equate the the patent system mentioned above. If you design something, no one PAID you do to it. You did it on your own, and you then took out the patent. You own it. Of course you can license people to use it.

    If you hire a bunch of engineers and they design it, while under your employ, do you think you should continue to pay the engineers royalties from licensing fees? I doubt it, and it doesn’t happen.

    Do you think the woman who accidentally invented the adhesive on yellow stickies is continuing to be paid by 3M? Do you think that Stepahnie Kwolek continues to receive royalties from DuPont for accidentally inventing Kevlar while under their employ? Heck no!

    While working for HP, Digital Equipment Corporation, and even Apple I sign agreements that anything I “create” belongs to them. That’s the real world.

    This “you should pay me forever” fantasy world that artists live in is just another form of socialism.

  13. theloniusMac,
    I guess you WISH we were back in the Stone Ages! Where it was kill or be killed. Where working conditions were horrible and amounted to slavery.

    It’s 2008! The real successful organizations (example: Google) believe in treating their employees well. In turn, these incentives mean your employees work harder knowing they have a stake in the company.

    theloniusMac, do you like being treated like a piece of garbage? Do you enjoy being abused? DO YOU like to working in horrible-unsafe-toxic-cancerous-life-threatening conditions?

    You must be incredibly miserable.

    … or sadistically happy.

  14. @ theloniousMac – So that means the retired (unnamed) Boeing executive should not get an amount equal to $50,000 for each airplane Boeing expects to sell for the rest of his life as part of his retirement package? It would make for less expensive airplanes if he didn’t and I don’t see that his continued breathing adds any economic value to Boeings product. But, wait, those payment were part of his contract.

    Your attitude reminds me of the poem:

    You’re paid to stop a bullet,
    It’s a soldiers job, they say.
    So, then you stop the bullet,
    And then they stop your pay

    I think your problem is you just didn’t negotiate a smart enough contract. Or are you drawing retirement benefits from the company that employed you so long ago? Isn’t that continued payment for past work. What would Ayn think of that.

  15. theloniusMac is obviously a discophile of Friedman’s “Free-market economics” in thinking the system will balance itself out, which has proven false from Pinochet, to New Orleans.

    As far Jobs’ intervention in this, I don’t think he will intervene at all, let alone behalf of the writers. I know he has criticized the teachers unions within the US saying that they are organized in the worst-way possible, although he didn’t elaborate if this meant they were poorly organized, or just anti-union rhetoric.

    Jobs aside there was an interview with a WGA member on democracy now last Friday. http://www.democracynow.org/2008/1/11/writers_strike_continues_in_3rd_month

    I’m not trying to plug but this explains pretty clealry as to what is going on.

  16. @Sandy Hum

    Jesus! At what point did being paid for a job become being mistreated in this country?!? How is being paid to do a job being treated like garbage?

    You get paid what the market will bear. When you are WORTH more, you get PAID more. The greater your skills and talents, the greater your rewards. Your VALUE demands higher compensation.

    If there are fewer people who can do what you do, then you make even more money. This is called SUPPLY AND DEMAND. You might have heard of it.

    That’s “stone age” thinking to you?

    Where do you people get these ideas? Yeesh.

  17. I work in a union environment and have been on strike and found out one thing. You will never make up what you have lost. The point you think you are making will be negotiated away later on. The one sad fact remains. He who owns the “Benjamin’s” makes the rules until a revolution. So until the writers start their own studios……they’re screwed.

  18. People should look at the history of the Three Stooges, they died broke, because they had no rights to much of the work they created. The studios job is to have a recurring revenue stream where the studios get paid from one piece of work for nearly a lifetime. It is only fair that a writer or actor who actually creates these works, shouldn’t die penniless. Money is the main reason behind the crappy reality shows, why?, zero production costs. You pay almost no one, no talented writers, or actors, yet reap high profits. This shows the studios are actually trying to get rid of paying anybody, let alone share profits. Writing movies or music, are industries where you definitely need to get paid for previous works. If Elvis Presley or Ozzie Osbourne wound up broke and homeless due to the same issues, i feel most people would change their negative tune. but it is the same, the rights of someone contributing to a work of art, to be properly compensated over time.

  19. It depends on the copyright agreement in the contract. If writers are happy to do write script for a one off fee, fine, but more fool them.

    An original script should surely, like a book, have the copyright staying with the author.

    As a photographer, I sell the rights to my pictures for an agreed purpose at an appropriate price. I retain copyright.

    If anyone wants to read more on this, John Harrington fights long and hard for pro-photogs not to give up copyright…

    http://photobusinessforum.blogspot.com/
    So, don’t agree with you Thelonious.

  20. @lurker

    Uh, no, I’m not quite retirement age, lol.

    Where did all you closet socialists come from. ROFLMAO.

    Those old retirement plans I would hope are a thing of the past. Look at the damage they’ve done to the American Automotive Industry. They are ticking time bombs for the likes of Ford, GM, and Chrysler.

    And guess who’s going to foot the bill in the long run. You got it, the American tax payer.

    Even those retirement plans, as bad as they are, don’t compare to the nuttyness of entertainment royalty systems.

  21. @Macday…

    You really don’t get it. You own the copyright to your work. Fine. It’s yours. If I want to use one of your images, I SHOULD pay you.

    If I hire you to go out and do a job and part of that contract is that I own the image, I own them. Not you. If you refuse to work under that scenario, then fine. If I think, “But that guy is sooooo good that I’m willing to give up copyright” and I hire you anyway, better for you.

    This assumption that no matter what you should payed continuously is absurd and economically insane though.

    Ultimately you do agree with me. You hold on to your copyrights. That’s fine. It’s not the same thing at all.

  22. @maclover

    Very sad story about the Three Stooges. It still doesn’t change the fact that they were paid for the work they did.

    Work is work. I don’t care if it’s so called “creative” or slapping stucco on a building. Should a construction worker be paid every time a building he worked on gets sold? You probably don’t think so because you seem to think there is something “special” about writing dialog for 24 or something.

    It’s a skill like any other. Some people are good at it, most are not. Some people are very talented writers. Most are not.

    Based on some of the logic represented here, if I have coronary bypass surgery, I should have to continue to pay the doctor every time I earn a dollar.

  23. Here’s news. BBC iplayer has streamed 3.5 millions shows to 1 million people since christmas day. I know I’m going to get comments on how it can’t download for mac, but this proves that there is a market out there for internet TV.

  24. I agree with MDN on this. If you’re willing to share the profit, it shouldn’t matter if “there’s not that much of a market” for something, but that there is a market for it at all. Smaller market simply means less %-age of profit sharing—or same %-age, less money. Ah well, just another clear example of how greed can really screw stuff up.

  25. If I own a studio, and I pay you to do a job, i.e. write a script, you’ve been paid. Thank you. Get out.

    You might want to look into IP law since this is not true. Unless a contract is signed that explicitly states that an employee is creating work for hire before the work is created, the creator owns the copyrights, not the employer. You do clear this up in the comment just above, though.

    This assumption that no matter what you should payed continuously is absurd and economically insane though.

    This ignores what corporations are doing. Refer to Disney and Mickey Mouse. If it were up to Disney, they would own the rights to Mickey forever, which is wrong. Intellectual Property law, as opposed to most people’s misconception of it, is actually meant to preserve the rights of people to have access to common culture without the need to negotiate rights. The transient creator monopoly is to encourage artists to create and reap the benefits for a while but after a time, the art should be freely available to all.

  26. Work is work. I don’t care if it’s so called “creative” or slapping stucco on a building.

    If you can’t understand the difference between applying stucco and designing the house, you should shut the fsck up.

  27. @ theloniousMac

    I agree completely. I’m in the same sort of situation as you are, except instead of being a programmer I am an a graphic artist.

    I am paid by how much time and effort I have in a project (by which I set my own rate). If I were to propose that I get paid my rate AND royalties on how many times its printed, viewed, etc etc, I would be laughed at and the next ad schmuck would get the contract.

    I don’t see any difference in the writers situation. You are contracted for your services, you take into account all the factors, you set a rate, you execute the project, the project launches, the client makes money if you did your job well. If they are happy you get asked back to do another project.

    End of story.

  28. Oh, gee–we’re all feeding the troll now.

    I recognize theloniousMac’s nonsense. I heard it from silly kids in junior high school who thought they knew how everything worked according to their schedule. They hadn’t yet had the opportunity to factor in real life experience and the way the world really operates. They thought that by postulating sensible-sounding arguments they could bend reality to their concept of it.

    Most of those kids have since grown up and can function rationally. But not all, obviously.

    But the one thing a troll CAN do is generate message traffic. Congratulations.

  29. Some participants here are either ignorant, or pretend to not understand how the system works.

    Tom Cruise get $20 million dollars for his creative work on a motion picture. This is an effort of about a few months. In it, he uses his talent, skills and prior experience. Upon completion, he collects his $20M and has no subsequent rights to the work.

    Meanwhile, the person who actually wrote the words Tom Cruise is saying in that motion picture is paid about 1-3% of what Tom Cruise is paid. According to his contract, PART of his earnings is paid as an up-front advance. The REST is paid as royalties.

    This is how the system works pretty much in EVERY country on this planet. The writer of that script took months and often years to write and re-write it, only to sell it at a fraction of a price only ONE single star receives for showing their face in it.

    There are situations where the studio pays a hefty sum upfront, but then buys the creative ownership from the writer. Studios rarely do this for movies. They NEVER do it for TV shows. Why would any studio want to pay FULL price for a script up-front, when there’s a chance that the show will flop? If the show is a success, it can sell overseas and in syndication, therefore, they’ll just pay the royalties as it sells. Either way, writers can only receive their work’s full value after years of receiving royalties for their work.

    In a way, people who’s work is creative are probably the only ones that don’t get paid up-front (or soon after delivery) for their work. Some of them receive their rightful fee over the period of 20 to 30 years. They would love to be able to collect an up-front fee (like our Thelonius Mac) and sell the ownership of their work to the studio. Unfortunately, no studio is prepared to do this. Therefore, they get a token fee, followed by months (and years) of small installments.

    Anyone else here not clear about this?

  30. Poor theloniousMac got himself stuck in the corner and frothing at the mouth.

    The marketplace strongly disagrees with theloniousMac. It needs the writers, the writers formed a bargaining group, and the two forces continue this arrangement for their own well being. They are the market forces, not fucktards like theloniousMac who are not involved and are severely distorted.

    When theloniousMac talks about the marketplace, and then says the existing situation is “all screwed up”, he severely contradicts himself since the marketplace is upholding the relationship. The marketplace already pays residuals for creative work, so again it disagrees with theloniousMac and the other retards that are not involved and have no mind in this matter.

    The marketplace also needs the other actor, director, producer, cinematographer, and editor unions, and has to soon negotiate with them, too. Which is the main holdup here, since the writers were first.

    Again, trolls, the market obvious disagrees with you since the status quo is far different than your bleary-eyed view of it.

  31. Well put Predrag, I think that clears it up.

    The question is why have the writers allowed themselves to be pushed around by the studios? Is it the starving artist with bad business sense scenario? “I’ll take the shaft to get my name out there (just so I can get the shaft even more if I make it)”.

    Ad Agencies sure don’t let their clients pay “only if the campaign works”. Clients pay ad agencies a handsome sum up front and in some cases pay a retainer to keep the ad agency.

    The reality is that there are no guarantees. There are only educated guesses backed by market research. Its crazy for the studios to want more than that.

  32. @theloniusMac

    Even Ayn Rand would disagree with you, hell- cut you a new one.
    Listen: The Fountainhead, have you heard of it? Howard Roark signs a contract to design a building, in which he stipulates that the building is to built exactly as he designs it. When the OWNERS of that building change his design to conform with “the popular taste”, he blows it up, and goes to court saying that it was his right to do so since the OWNERS had broken the contract. The jury agrees with him, he is released from custody, and the building is rebuilt to his plans. { A rather extreme way to resolve a contractual dispute, lawyers are usually more effective than dynamite, but this is her fantasy, not mine}
    The writers and other creatives have formed an organization to pursue a freely signed contract for payment of a base payment + commission etc as Danno Bonano and the rest have pointed out. It’s contract between free people, nitwit. If the studios want to pay serfs like yourself a flat rate, they are free to do so in the hope that the work those serfs will produce a product that people will pay for. Or they can agree to the terms that these creative people have come up with that include terms beyond a flat rate.
    Have you noticed that businesses have a habit of including conditions of sale, beyond payment of cash? Does your limited world view allow for this?
    Your employers must love you, when they see you coming, they cry out, “Hey Rube!”

  33. @ theloniousMac: “closeted socialists”? “Your analogy of writing to sales is at best illogical”?

    Dude, a sales rep lands an account, gets paid a percentage of the sale AND a percentage of all future sales generated by that account. I might make a couple bucks with that initial sale, but the real money comes with the repeat orders.

    Same for TV and movies. Maybe a writer gets $40k for one movie script, but then he (or she) spends the next 18-24 months trying to sell another script to a studio and has no big paydays coming in. But thanks to the residuals that they do get for their past projects they get a coupe hundred buck each time the movie they wrote is repeated on a cable network (or 4¢ for each DVD sold). It is only fair that they get similar residuals for downloads.

  34. Man, this is not that complicated.

    When your builder or plumber does some work for you, you rarely have a chance to turn around and make several billion dollars off that same work.

    However, a good script can generate billions in income for a studio.

    The writers are simply asking for a “fair” fee, the problem in the creative/entertainment field is that is it very difficult going into a project to figure out what “fair” really is. A studio might spend millions on one project that totally bombs—in spite of high-priced stars, production, sets, location filming, etc. and lose everything whereas another cheap project generates billions.

    Clearly, the studios do not want to take the risk of offering the writers millions of dollars up front, so why not give them a small cut of the pie on the back end and everybody can win or lose together.

    I think the studios are cutting off their noses to spite their own faces. The longer the strike drags on, the less people will return to TV when it’s over. Remember, content is king. I don’t think a gaffer’s strike would have brought the TV studios to their knees.

  35. @theloniousMac
    What a stupid statement! One can see that you just consume art or culture like a peace of some sort of softice or gelly!
    How many ours do you think a writer is spending on having a good book out of press? And how many cents do you think he earns from a sold book?

  36. @ theloniousMac – This is getting away from the issues of the writers strike, but it’s kind of my doing so I’ll give the short (ha) answer.

    I agree, all those traditional retirement plans would be a ticking time bomb, except that the companies that promised them were supposed to be putting money aside to cover their future obligations while the workers were still actively working. They’re only a time bomb for the companies that didn’t do it, or the ones that were taken over by corporate raiders who stripped the pension funds from the company for their own benefit.

    Back to the writers strike. The true value of a show or a script isn’t known at the time of writing. It’s only known in the context of the completed work: the show as it’s seen by an audience. Despite the greatest writing possible, if a show is poorly produced or badly acted, it won’t make money. At the time of writing, no one knows if it will just click and become almost cult-like in its popularity or be a flop. So the general deal is the writer is paid a salary plus a cut of any future earnings, which the writer has little control over. The company may not offer the show on ITS, so no revenue or it may flop, so no revenue. This allows the studio to pay less for the writing up front and keeps everyone interested in the future earnings of the show. A good deal for all.

    The strike is because the producers have identified a new revenue stream (the internet) that they don’t want to share with the writers. Actually, the producers are saying there is no revenue stream to share. That makes it easy. If there’s no revenue, they can agree to 100% to the writers, since 100% of nothing is nothing. Wonder why they won’t do it?

    @ron – Your work can only be viewed in one place. If the writers work were only used once, there would be no future revenue stream. If the shopping center believes your work added to their revenue stream, they’ll probably call again, maybe for a second sign. Are you going to say “You already paid me once, I’ll do it for free?”

    @Tom – The writers don’t get to set their own rates. They get paid in accordance with their contract. The income to producers from syndication (and internet) sales for a TV show are frequently greater than the original run.

    Plus, I’d bet your work only applies to one thing, a poster for a concert, or a particular ad campaign, with little continuing value, except as art, of course. If you produced a piece for continuous sale for its intrinsic artistic value and aren’t getting a royalty, that’s a bad deal. Of course, how original is it if “next ad schmuck” can do just as good of a job.

  37. Predrag:

    FYI, Tom Cruise and other “A-List” Hollywood stars get a flat fee AND a percentage of receipts PER FILM. Also, there are very few writers – neither in the film nor the music business (where I work) – who “work for hire”; that practice went out in the early 80’s. The majority of WGA writers are freelancers who do not work explicitly for the studios, rather for the production companies (sometimes individuals) who pitch the shows to the studios, in which case they have every right to demand a bigger cut of royalties from digital receipts, which is what they are striking about. The studios know that digital distribution is about to become a lot larger than it is now, and they don’t want to give up that money. They are using the same reasoning that allowed the music industry to get away with not having to pay artists for ringtones (the biggest racket in the industry), and that’s not fair.

    TheloniusMac’s comments are simply based on a lack of understanding of how the situation works. Don’t be too harsh on him ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  38. Right Wing “Objectivist” kindergardeners seem not to even recognize when they’re distorting rational debate to meet their preconceived conclusions. They wind up in circular arguments or defeating themselves unless they can actually define all the terms a priori. Rand’s fiction works because she can do just that… because it’s fiction. Her characters’ philosophy works for the the same reason that Micheal Valentine’s equally silly philosophy does: because an author shaped the world around it to make it so. Do you guys think you’ve got a Heisenberg compensator in your basements, too?

    The WGA is engaging the free market here. They are doing exactly what you suggest; they’re saying “We’re not working for you under those terms: agree to better ones or no scripts for you.” The fact that they are doing TOGETHER is they only leverage they have. Organized labor, while flawed, is the best tool our society has yet devised to work together in such situations.
    Someone mentioned that we no longer need unions because now we’ve got labor laws… but why is that? Because of the Labor Movement. And wouldn’t all the so called “Objective” thinkers do away with those protections, too? Once again, they’d end up shooting themselves in the foot because even Roark winds up validated by a court: i.e. the evil government that can’t do anything right. That’s right, the same entity that keeps you safe from environmental and food toxins, not to mention terrorists and invasions and burglars, assures that your meds work, and built the road you got to work on. And the guys who invented the internet and the frickin computer in the first place.
    Remember them? The ones that just take your money and never produce anything?

  39. Thank you, MDN, for the take. As a writer, you know I side with the “little guy” in these negotiations, rather than corporate bean counters trying to squeeze every cent from their product.

    Hopefully this will shed a little more light on what’s going on in H-wood right now.

  40. Forwarded the thread to a friend of mine, a graduate of the London School of Economics. His comment:

    >>Libertarians really seem not to get the idea of collective bargaining at all, though, and it is perhaps the greatest single indicator of how hypocritical and (arguably) self-serving is their ideology. The fact is that assuming a free market, negotiations between actors are effectively unrestricted, meaning that if I want to form an association of workers and re-negotiate a contract on our collective benefit, I should have the freedom to do so. The union-busting nonsense promulgated by those on the right is therefore the worst possible implementation of government regulation, because it “distorts” the market in favor of an inequitable, rather than equitable, outcome.

    All of that goes beside the point in any case, of course. Anyone who doesn’t understand that railroads, postal services, telecommunications networks, energy extraction, processing, and delivery systems, environmental health and safety, and several kinds of industry-transforming research are empirically impossible without the kinds of centralized direction and policy intervention necessary to overcome the market disincentive to produce public goods doesn’t really know *anything* about market economics to begin with.<<

  41. Actually he’s a venture capitalist. Now that your ad hominem has been dealt with, would you care to actually make an argument?
    Not everyone who believes that capitol is just a tool, one of many that humans have developed, is a socialist.
    the right wing is defined by people with one answer. To the religious fundamentalists, all answers are God. To the economic fundamentalists, the answer to everything is deregulation and tax cuts, until every endeavor except profit by any means is gutted. I wonder why that is… my best guess is that they just don’t like anyone telling them what to do and don’t like paying taxes, and they never grew up enough to realize that that’s part of playing a productive role in a society. When the economy is booming they say tax cuts to give taxpayers what they’ve earned! When the economy is slumping they say tax cuts to stimulate enterprise! Get some perspective. And some values that can’t be expressed on a balance sheet.

  42. Since this discussion has completely moved past any Apple news….

    In any case, a contract protects both sides of the negotiation. Once the writer’s stike is resolved, the writers know their wage and the studios know their writing costs. Nothing too complicated.
    BTW, I do side with the writers here even though I am usually anti-union. The studios are playing games with the contract definitions.

  43. And just for fun, in case anyone’s still reading:
    “I see in the near future a crisis approaching that unnerves me..
    and causes me to tremble for the safety of my country…
    Corporations have been enthroned…
    an era of corruption in high places will follow…
    and the money power of the country will endeavor to prolong its reign by working on the prejudices of the people…
    until the wealth is aggregated in a few hands…
    and the republic is destroyed.”

    — Abraham Lincoln

  44. Sorry~ decided to check that quote (as I should have done BEFORE posting) and it’s a fake.
    Lincoln was a strong supporter of labor, though, stating:
    “Labor is prior to, and independent of, capital. Capital is only the fruit of labor, and could never have existed if labor had not first existed. Labor is the superior of capital, and deserves much the higher consideration.”
    in an 1861 speech (att. historian Merrill Peterson in “Lincoln in American Memory”, via Snopes)

    That’s what I get for having reckless fun and not checking sources.

  45. >Back on topic, why would Steve piss off the studios when he’s courting them for iTunes?

    This is the key point, to discuss the actual article, and why Steve won’t/can’t use his influence on the writers’ strike. Besides, if Master Negotiator Steve hasn’t been able to move the movie studios to get their stuff on iTunes (something that would make them $$$), how’s he supposed to get them to give up money to the writers?

  46. Yes Steve will end the writers strike…

    In the near future, the writer/producer hybrid will produce and own what they write and delivery the finished show direct to the people. They will edit on Final Cut Pro, finish and grade in Apple’s Color, composite in motion 4, and score/audio post in logic studio. Then with one click publishing they will upload their content to itunes HD and Apple will take it from there. (For a fee)

    At first people will buy the major studio films but soon word will get out that a smart indie can be just as good and sometimes better then the recycled hollywood templet. Near the end, the studios will loose control of the channels and be limited to just another content provider.

    Apple will help define many new roles as they road map the future on the entertainment interface.

  47. Sure are a lot of non-creative types pontificating about matters far beyond their comprehension (i.e. “Ron”)

    “writers are just like everybody else” Yeah right, Ron, ya f’n moron.

    “Do you think the woman who accidentally invented the adhesive on yellow stickies is continuing to be paid by 3M?”

    theloniousMoron: The man who invented the adhesive is still being paid by 3M. A simple google would clue you.

    Being stupid is your only excuse.

  48. People should look at the history of the Three Stooges, they died broke, because they had no rights to much of the work they created.

    HMMM couldn’t be that they did not plan or manage their own money could it? Why is this the studios fault? It is called PERSONAL ACCOUNTABILITY.

    What scares me most about this tread is all you people with this sense of entitlement.

    theloniousMac is right, if you want the royalties, you should OWN the content. When you are employed by someone and your job is to write, create graphics, write software, etc. You have been paid regardless of what the creation is, it is not yours. You were on company time, being paid to create, now it is the companies product. You should be happy if it is successful, the company prospers and your reputation grows. Use this to negotiate a raise or go to another firm that will pay you more based on prior success.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.