What should Apple do with its $12 billion pile of cash?

“What would you do with $12 billion? You might have two ideas in mind, neither of which is necessarily exclusive of the other: First, do some good; and second, make sure that money keeps growing,” Arik Hesseldahl writes for BusinessWeek.

“It’s the kind of question that the financial minds over at Apple (AAPL) have to consider, for that is about the amount of cash the company had on its balance sheet the last time it reported earnings on Jan 17,” Hesseldahl writes.

Hesseldahl writes, “If the last year is any judge, Apple’s cash position—the combination of its cash on hand and short-term investments that can quickly be converted to cash—is growing at a rate of about a billion and change per quarter. It’s high time Apple spread some of that cash around, and I think one good way to start would be to launch a venture capital fund.”

Full article here.
Keep $2 billion on hand, pay $500 per Windows machine with the purchase of a new Mac (one per family), and net 20 million switchers – doubling the Mac OS X user base – before the start of summer?

84 Comments

  1. One thing I don’t want to see Apple do is hand that money back to share holders in the form of a divident payment. If you want a “dividend” payment, invest in a utility company. Apple is a forward thinking growth stock, not a settled into a rut divident payment company.

    If they do anythinig at all with that money it should be to push the envelope forward in markets that they are already doing well in, or that make sense along side what they are already working on. Namely multimedia, music, movies, digital content creation distribution and consumer markets.

    Stuff like Apple TV and iPod and iPhone and things that make sense to go along with them.

    Buying Adobe I don’t think makes sense for Apple right now, maybe someday but I think Apples efforts and money are better spent elsewhere, currently.

  2. Huh? Start a VC fund? Puleeze. Right now the VC marketplace is flooded with money. What Hesseldahl suggests is called “deworsification” by investment genius Peter Lynch. Companies do best when they stick to their knitting. $12 billion might sound like a lot to you and me, but put this in perspective to Apple’s sales and earnings. That $12 billion is an insurance policy that keeps Wall Street more at ease. If not for a good pile of cash at the company’s low point in the 90s, Apple could have collapsed before Steve Jobs came back and resurrected the company.

    Ask any successful investor or CFO and they will tell you: cash is king. It’s the first thing anyone looks at on the balance sheet, the second being long-term debt. Yes, it would be great to see Apple start paying out dividends. That often helps a stock as an investment, and in fact, many of the best stocks for long-term holdings are those with strong dividends. But in Apple’s case, don’t hold your breath.

    Something tells me that Mr. Hesseldahl was looking for something for his Thursday column deadline.

    In short: there’s nothing to see here, folks. Please move along.

  3. “It’s the kind of question that the financial minds over at Apple (AAPL) have to consider”

    He states this fact as if Apple’s financial team, Steve, etc. woke up one day and said, “Holy buckets, we’ve got a lot of money in the checking account!”

    I’m sure Apple does a lot of good work that doesn’t get publicized, and quite frankly, what Apple does with its money is Apple’s business. Apple obviously spends plenty on R&D, so the real issue is how much does Apple want to have in the bank as a war chest?

  4. Step 1 : Buy Autodesk.

    Step 2: Make a Mac version of Autocad.

    Step 3: Sell Autodesk for a substantial gain, but retain a significant share and a seat on the board.

    Step 4: Watch architects and designers worldwide flock to the Mac platform.

  5. I am still sad Apple didn’t buy Macromedia. At least they could buy Corel for 305 Millions (a bargain) and Creative. Buying Autodesk would be a dream come true, the 30″ display will be out of stock in a months. Most of my friends with macs are still using Windows for two reasons:
    1. AutoCAD
    2. AnyDVD & CloneDVD

  6. They should do a mega Naming Rights deal for a new stadium (in Europe) to reinforce their presence here.

    Then with the rest they should pay back their shareholders

    No foolish acquisitions please

    Just a thought

    Java

  7. Here’s a suggestion that will warm the hearts of all long term Apple employees:

    Set aside a cool million dollars as an investment trust for each employee with over 15 years of service with the company. After they complete 20 years, they are fully vested with the trust and can begin to draw on the interest generated by the trust starting on their 62nd birthday.

    The employee will then receive a lifetime pension from Apple based on the annual interest generated by the trust (probably at least sixty thousand a year) until their death. When the employee dies, the original million goes back into the pool for the next employee who becomes eligible.

    With twelve billion in the bank, Apple could easily set aside four billion for the current day employees. This would fund four thousand Apple careerists upon their retirement, and four thousand more after they die, and four thousand more after they die, and so on.

    This would not reduce the Apple’s total amount in the bank by one penny, and would likely increase employee retention enormously. Apple’s desirability as a place to work would climb even higher, making it easier for them to hire (and keep) the best and the brightest from all over the world.

    Heck, Steve-o alone could fund three thousand pensions on this plan out of his own pocket and still be one of the richest people in the country for the rest of his life.

  8. Yes. Buy Adobe. Buy Adobe. Buy Adobe.

    Can you imagine the shock if Microsoft makes a surprise deal to buy them?

    Protect yourself (and us), Apple.

    Buy Adobe.

    (And open an Apple Store in Alaska, with the pittance that will be left.)

  9. How Bizarre !!!

    >>>>>>>>>>
    MacDailyNews Take: Keep $2 billion on hand, pay $500 per Windows machine with the purchase of a new Mac (one per family), and net 20 million switchers – doubling the Mac OS X user base – before the start of summer?
    <<<<<<<<<<

    I posted something in jest at arstechnica almost two years ago suggesting something very similar …

    >>>>>>>>>>
    http://arstechnica.com/journals/apple.ars/2005/6/3/444
    …
    Posted June 03, 2005 @ 8:03PM by Scott Schor
    Prognostications:
    …
    4. iDeal promotions – trade in your old win98 or win2000 towers with original install disks plus $350 and receive new mac-mini in return. You are immediately qualified as a participant in a class action lawsuit against the original issuers of the license disks. (I think the legal argument might be … the license was only for one workstation, not all of the phishers, scammers and other sinister intruders allowed onto your private computer space due to defects in manufacturing of the original licensed software. Note: I’m not a lawyer and clearly I haven’t thought this one all the way through.) Apple can resell the old towers to fortune 1000 companies still too timid to rid themselves of their original investments in hardware, hopefully covering costs with a small profit.
    <<<<<<<<<<

    Kreskin?
    Who knew?

  10. “They should do a mega Naming Rights deal for a new stadium (in Europe) to reinforce their presence here.

    Formula-1 auto racing sponsorship, global presence and by far the most watched international sport. I can see the Macintosh-Apple Red Ferrari now.

    MW-perform.

  11. If it is on deposit or on loan in US denominated securities they are losing money every time the $ declines relative to other securities. Putting some or all of it into precious metals wouldn’t be a bad idea right about now.

    Buying AutoDesk and merging it with Apple-owned FileMaker wouldn’t be a bad idea.

  12. Keep the cash growing. Apple’s pile may be large, but a bigger company could try some sort of hostile takeover. They need to prevent that and have enough extra to buy me something cute for the prom. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”raspberry” style=”border:0;” />

  13. Pay for that new insanely great Apple complex expansion in Cupertino and give your creative teams room to breath. Expand into one product and market at a time in a slow but smart way.
    Oh cool, they’re already doing that.

    Then buy some small country, for the heck of it. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  14. $500 each is a bit too much, but here’s what I’d do…

    I’d give a $300 credit toward the purchase of any new Mac (limit one $300 credit per household please ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” /> ) if they brought in any functioning Windows PC (i.e. it will at least power up, if it’s virus infested that’s absolutely OK)<u>along with</u> the original Windows install discs that came with it.

    I’d also offer a $50 credit toward any future Apple Store purchase if customers simply brought in any legitimate original retail Windows 2000 or XP install CD (sorry, OEM versions or copies are not accepted). Again, limit one per customer please. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

    All of the PCs and the Windows install CDs that were brought in by the customers would then be immediately destroyed and sent to a recycling center. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”cool smirk” style=”border:0;” />

  15. 1. Keep R&D investments strong, funding the best ideas for production.

    2. Continue to invest in Apple Stores.

    3. Spend a bit picking up companies that are a good fit and will add significantly to the company.

    4. Send some of the EOL Macs & iPods (plus some from the refurbished inventory) to the wounded solders going through long rehab for lost limbs, etc. in the military & VA hospitals. The cost for that would be far cheaper than the price those guys & gals have paid.

    5. Keep MOST of the case, however, for downturns in the market. Also, the world today is rather fragile, especially with terrorists growing day by day. A company that has strong cash holdings will be able to survive another 9/11 – or something worse. Those with weak cash holdings are going to be lucky to survive. I would put this as priority one.

  16. I’ve said it before:

    AutoCAD (maybe SolidWorks)

    AND

    Adobe

    Those two would be a nail in the coffin for Microsoft’s dominance. Instantly Apple would have the “business” street cred it so needs to be adopted by all those reluctant IT departments. Whether they want them or not. AutoCAD more so than Adobe.

  17. Make a 60″ iMac/AppleTV with blueray/video ichat/telephone with a wireless keyboard and laser mouse and completely enter the living room with an all everything in one device the thickness of an existing iMac. Don’t enter the living room…instead BECOME the living room. Do it for under 3 grand and people will come…do it for under 2500 and you will turn the world into an Apple. Then sell Apple couches and chaises as accessories instead of socks.

  18. Create a 60″ iMac/AppleTV with blueray/video ichat/telephone with a wireless keyboard and laser mouse and completely enter the living room with an all everything in one device the thickness of an existing iMac. Don’t enter the living room…instead BECOME the living room. Do it for under 3 grand and people will come…do it for under $2,500 and you will turn the world into an Apple. Then sell Apple couches and chaises as accessories instead of socks.

  19. Take that money and build the largest 802.11N wireless network for the entire country
    which includes video, cell and data traffic. Charge every person in the country $25.00 a month to be connected anywhere.

    Lets do the math, 298,444,215 people * $25.00 per month = $7,416,105,375 Billion
    One time purchase of iPhone: 298,444,215 * $599.00 = 178,168,084,785 Billion

    Total Yearly Subscriptions(not even talking about iTunes) $ 88,993,264,500 Billion
    iPhone Purchases = $178,168,084,785 Billion

    Total Sales for my idea $267,161,349,280 Billion

    My Commission 5% $13,358,067,464 Billion (Steve, I’ll take that in small unmarked bills)

    Oh Shit I was suppose to spend it!!! Brewsters Millions Syndrome – Loads of Money Yields More Loads a Money

    Just a thought

  20. RIGHT ON BOB! I had a gay guy over here on day and he saw one of my Jessica Alba desktop pictures (). He said “who’s that!?” I told him it was Jessica Alba. He stared at the picture in total silence with his mouth partially open (as if he was beginning to say “oh my…”. After about five or six seconds, he said “I wanna suck face with her.” GAD, she can convert homos!!!! So what’s a few billion plus change to plain ol’ hetros with $12B? They can buy her and some island somewhere. You can have your own posse of midgets to provide security and bring you your drinks. Bimbos on tramolines… *erk* OK, back to reality.

    P.S. If anyone is offended by the above, TOUGH. It’s fantasy-based humor. Don’t tell me how I may think or express my thoughts.

  21. How bout buying a bunch of toilet paper and TPing Balmer’s and Gate’s houses…

    Just another thought.

    ps. my widget calculator could not handle the math I did above.
    Thank god apple’s calculator was available, go Apple!!

    All for now

  22. Adobe is to Apple what legs are to humans.

    There’s a minor problem in the Adobe shopping trip.
    They’d have to ask mommy or daddy to give ’em 10 B $ extra…

    It would be nice if Apple owned Adobe. MS wouldn’t try anything funny.
    Spending all their cash and taking out loan would be as dumb as it can get.
    That 12 billion dollars is Apples bullet proof vest. You can die, but you can also take a hit or two.

    New cheaper Mac ($449) would encourage switchers who don’t use computers that much and just want a new machine that works.

    New desktop line with better (upgradeable) GPU wouldn’t hurt.
    Bootcamp will be part of the 10.5, so it could encourage non-hardcore Win Gamers to switch.
    HCWCs are hopeless, not that most MDN readers care.

  23. Paying people $500 to switch is probably anti-competitive behaviour. If Apple were Lenovo and they tried this, it would be called “dumping” and would prompt sanctions.

    Apple must invest their cash so as to provide a return to shareholders. They cannot give it away – it does not belong to the company and the directors of the company will be removed if the shareholders feel they are mismanaging the shareholders’ funds.

    I think Apple should continue to accumulate cash until they have enough to buy their own voice network. Or they could make small but key acquisitions in the areas of:

    – gaming
    – film back-catalogues
    – music back-catalogues
    – Business software for selected vertical markets (professional markets such as architecture, legal, financial for instance?)
    – technologies for the home entertainment market

    Apple can increase investment in R&D

    – MS Office replacement software
    – OS/X Server based solutions

    If Apple cannot find enough ways to spend the dosh they will probably have to give it back to shareholders via a share buyback or some large dividend payouts…

    They could always hang around for the Microsoft break-up. That may not be too far away if present trends continue.

    Q: Which bits of Microsoft would Apple buy if they were placed on the market?

  24. I think Apple is piling up the cash for a massive R&D campaign to make OS 11. I think the hallmark of OS 11 is going to be touchscreen multi-touch technology. Apple brought the mouse into this world and it is going to take it out!

  25. “They need that cash to make sure another company can’t buy them!!!! If apple was without that cash google could try a hostile takeover.”

    This proves that Apple computer users clearly do NOT work in business. Stick to your creative work please.

    Nothing attracts a hostile takeover like a big pile of cash. The first thing the buyers do is take that pile of cash to pay down the money they just borrowed to buy the stock. Having said that, the current market cap is high relative to the asset balance so is not a big issue. It is fairly surprising that nobody bought Apple when the stock was at the low point and the cash on the balance sheet was 50% of the market cap.

  26. Hey Critic!!

    What the F@ck are you talking about!! ” They need the cash to make sure another company can’t buy them!!!” Next paragraph after you
    dissed everyone on this board with “This proves that Apple computer users clearly do NOT work in business. Stick to your creative work please”
    And then you do this 180 and say “Nothing attracts a hostile takeover like a big pile of cash”.

    Again and for the last time, What the F@ck are you talking about!!

    Please keep watching Jim (I’m Crazy) Cramer and post on his board because you sound just like him….. Someday perhaps not soon but someday you will make a little more sense.

    Here’s my creative work, your DUMB and it hurts my head that I ever read your post.

    Not just a thought, a fact

  27. MDNs suggestion isn’t bad. But I wouldn’t give more than 250€ per family.

    Problem with big continuous discounts is that they back fire.
    Mac Mini costs $349 USD for a month. Not only does Apple lose money, but they wont make any. Like that isn’t enough – people start thinking that $349 is normal price for Mac Mini.

    Once you start giving something for less it’s hard to ask more later. That’s why Dell is being chased by the reaper man.

    That discount campaign should be fast and effective.
    Say, 3 days (fri-sat-sun). Bring us your old PC (with the Windows license) and get $250 off when you buy a Mac.

    Advertise that like a muhfucka and no fleet of delivery truck is big enough to carry away those beige/metal-looking-plastic boxes.

  28. $500 for a windows pc? No way. That’d be a racket. I’d go buy a $250 Dell or eMachine just to take it to Apple and get a $250 discount on my next Mac.

    …. wait … maybe this is a good thing. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  29. @rasterbator:

    That is a great idea. Buying RIM, PocketMac and LG phone division would give Apple a strong foothold in the phone market, AND in the enterprise market. Most companies that use Blackberrys have Blackberry Enterprise servers. These could be made to support the LGs that Apple would keep (Chocolates) and the new iPhones.

  30. I realize that a lot of the ideas and suggestions were “tounge-in-cheek”, But I am sure glad that Apple is in charge of that cash! ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

  31. Nope. There will be Apple-shaped-apple-pie instead of ice cream.
    Bring your own booze, pie is on the house 😀
    My choice is Two Dogs – lemon brew with “Pie”.

    Damn, I’m gonna create a mold with two parts: one for the fruit and one for the leave. Pie, bitch!

    In an earlier post I mentioned something like “Alternative marketing strategies for Macintosh user experience” as a way to spend cash wisely. Maybe it was that shot of Scotch that made me have an idea.

    What IF Apple partnered with some other companies (like Canon, HP, Nikon…) and organized a tour through US (and maybe Europe). Trained personnel would teach people how to shoot better photos, film better home movies and edit them with software that comes with every Mac. Teach people about iWork, iLife, whatever-they-want-to-know-about and all the advantages that Mac platform has, while doing some myth busting.

    And they offer some 10% off coupons to the people who dont own a Mac.

    Just my 2¢

  32. I’m sure a good chunk of the cash should be held in reserve for emergencies/opportunities. The use of a few $billion to buy flash memory a while back was brilliant. Apple got supplied while its competitors saw their supplies dry up.

    But I would like to see some of the cash horde used to buy back AAPL stock. Apple management should be authorized by the BOD and shareholders to buy back stock opportunistically when the hedge fund parasites spread FUD and go short. It would allow Apple to buy the best investment in the market — itself — cheaply and also screw the fscking scum who profit from their anti Apple lies. The hedgie parasites might have to look for another victim to practice their trade.

  33. 1) Give away a billion songs on iTune.

    2) Take One billion and start an Open Source foundation that strictly focuses on porting and updating all Open source programs for the Mac platform.

    3) One billion for Productivity Apps. and home software R&D

    4) One billion for Mobile software and hardware R&D.

    And then save the rest for further investment.

  34. MDN – No. Subsidizing the Mac platform is a bad idea. Sure, it might create awesome switcher momentum for a short-term gain.

    But I think the Mac base needs to grow by adding people who are truly motivated to switch by the platform experience rather than $500 free bucks or whatever. People coming over need to be weaned off the “cheap crap PC” mentality, in which they pay a couple hundred bucks for a throwaway computer — otherwise Apple will just have a PR and support mess on its hands, not to mention a huge user base with skewed expectations.

    Part of switching to Mac is coming to accept that it’s OK to pay $1000+ for a computer system if it works well, lasts a long time, and adds value to your computing activities.

  35. Hey Tacoma, next time, look more closely at posts before you have a hissy fit. The first line was in quotes, because it was a statement made BY SOMEONE ELSE in a previous post. Did you drop out of school before the lesson on quoteation marks?

    My further comment about sticking to creative projects should be identified as SARCASM, and reflects the fact that there are a lot of posts made here on a regular basis that demonstrate a complete lack of understanding of business and corporate finance.

    As for the Jim Cramer comment, I don’t see how you can criticize the business acumen of someone who managed to make several hundred million for himself on Wall Street.

    Finally, you are ignorant and have serious reading comprehension problems.

    Not just a thougt, a fact.

  36. Apple should sell Leopard for $50 a copy ($80 for family pack) with a $50 rebate (one per household). This would:

    a) devastate any concept of Apple being more expensive – but would do nothing for PC switchers this time around.
    b) make Vista’s 8 variations at prices of $100 to $500 (US) look like a total joke
    c) show that Leopard is ready for primetime, and all the drivers work the day it’s released!
    d) guarantee that it works on all Macs built in the last 5 years without requiring any upgrades!

    I rest my case…

  37. ^^ that is the last thing i think apple should do. Selling OSX to pc’s would be a terrible mistake i believe.

    Right now apple makes its hardware, and its OS..that way they work hand in hand, and apple only has to worry about one type of hardware, and security for it. If apple sold OSX, they would have to cater for alot more hardware, meaning that OSX would most likely not be as secure as it is on macs, therefore losing its reputation of being virus free.

    I for one would love to see apple buy either nintendo or adobe, but i can’t really see it happening. Realistically i’d like to see apple put some money towards producing a small size (12-13″) MacBook Pro, and a Pro-sumer tower (something to fill the gap between the iMac and the MacPro).

    Just my thoughts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.