BBC incorrectly reports Omnifone music subscription price (plus: why the phone networks are suckers)

“Omnifone, a London-based company which has been working secretly on a music service for the last four years, has come to Barcelona to launch Music Station,” Rory Cellan-Jones reports for BBC News. “It is a subscription service offering users unlimited access to a huge catalogue to download to their phones for £1.99 a month. It is attractive to the networks because it allows them to keep control of their music business rather than simply hand it over to Apple.”

MacDailyNews Take: Whatever they’re smoking lately over at the Beeb, it certainly guarantees mistakes that, for some strange reason, never seem to come out in Apple’s favor. Omnifone’s subscription service will be £1.99 (US$3.87) per week, not month. So, it actually costs £8.62 (US$16.79) per month on average. In other words, Omnifone is US$6.84, or 69%, more per month than the beleaguered Napster subscription service currently charges (US$9.95/month). The mobile phone networks are suckers because they, like every iTunes Store victim on the planet, want to control the customer instead of giving customers the control they want — even to the point of buying into this repackaged, over-priced, proven failure that’s called “Omnifone” this time instead of “Napster.” People want to own their music, not rent it. Apple gives customers what they want while other outfits want so badly to reap a weekly/monthly payment ad infinitum that they keep trying to ignore reality. The mobile phone companies are deluding themselves with visions of recurring weekly charges that simply aren’t going to exist in worthwhile numbers.

Cellan-Jones continues, “It looks as though the iPhone will not accept downloads, with users having to transfer their music from their computers. Rob Lewis, Omnifone chief executive, said customers would now have a choice: ‘They can buy an expensive device from Apple – or use our service on just about any of the world’s handsets and get their music wherever they want it.’ …Omnifone has said it has signed partnerships with 23 mobile network operators…”

MacDailyNews Take: Sheesh. That’s the same old subscription music sales pitch that nobody bought the first how-ever-many-times countless also-ran outfits tried it, except now it costs even more!

Cellan-Jones continues, “But one word of caution. A subscription service does not give you ownership of any music – stop paying, and it disappears. In the past that’s made similar services on PCs and for portable devices much less attractive than Apple’s iTunes. Barcelona will see plenty of glitzy launches and extravagant claims about compelling new mobile services. None will generate quite the buzz which surrounded the iPhone launch but companies here are confident that their phones will sell better and prove more profitable than Apple’s device.”

Full article here.

MacDailyNews Take: All of these music subscription peddlers (just like the would-be “iPod Killers”) were confident before launch. Now they’re either dead, calling people stupid or worse for not buying into neverending subscriptions, or looking for some other suckers to buy their struggling companies because people don’t want what they’re trying to sell no matter how badly they dream of selling it.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader “nerdbrain” for the heads up.]

Related articles:
Omnifone to challenge Apple’s iPhone, iTunes Store – February 12, 2007
Beleaguered Napster hires UBS to evaluate possible company sale – September 18, 2006
Beleaguered Napster circles bowl, subscribers drop 7 percent, Gorog won’t rule out sale of company – August 03, 2006
Free, legal and ignored: Mac- and iPod-incompatible beleaguered Napster dying at colleges – July 06, 2006
Napster does the math: layoffs commence with 10-percent of workforce lopped off – January 25, 2006
EMI Music Chairman: Music subscription services like Napster and Rhapsody haven’t beeen huge – January 23, 2006
Report: Napster executives do the math, consider selling or shutting down, layoffs imminent – January 16, 2006
Do the math: Napster posts $13.6 million second-quarter loss – November 02, 2005
Napster: the only thing missing is the sock puppet – August 04, 2005
Napster, other Windows Media-based music services ‘chasing a niche opportunity’ – June 29, 2005
SmartMoney: Napster is a snooze, gushing money and renting music is un-American anyway – July 06, 2005
Napster To Go Soon? Reports $24.3 million net loss on $17.4 million net revenue – May 11, 2005
Napster is a joke – April 05, 2005
Users thwart Napster To Go’s copy protection; do the music labels realize the piracy potential? – February 15, 2005
Why ‘Napster To Go’ will flop – February 03, 2005
The de facto standard for legal digital online music files: Apple’s protected MPEG-4 Audio (.m4p) – December 15, 2004
Napster 2.0 posts US$15 million relaunch loss – February 08, 2004

BBC, others scared as Apple preps launch of iTunes TV and movie sales in Europe? – February 12, 2007
BBC columnist doesn’t believe Steve Jobs’ Apple would stop using DRM if music labels would allow it – February 12, 2007
BBC integrity questioned, accused of promoting Microsoft and Windows Vista – February 09, 2007
BBC revises article, clarifies where music downloaded from the iTunes store can be played – February 08, 2007
BBC reporter blows it, says ‘music downloaded from the iTunes store can be played only on iPods’ – February 07, 2007
Ask the BBC make upcoming iPlayer on-demand service Mac compatible – February 01, 2007
Report: Europe gets iTunes TV and movie sales this spring – January 31, 2007
BBC: Hackers assault Windows PCs every 15 minutes, ignores obvious solution: Get a Mac – October 09, 2006
BBC signs web deal with Microsoft – September 28, 2006

46 Comments

  1. If it doesn’t function like an iPod, any music service or phone won’t make a splash. Sony Ericsson has made several walkman phones, and I don’t seem to recall any major press or any anticipation of the devices.

  2. Why are phone companies delusional? Because they saw how much money people spent on ring tones. And then kept on spending each month from people that didn’t realize they were only renting their ring tones. The charge is hidden in their monthly statements that most people never read.

    When they don’t get the music numbers they think they are entitled to they will blame Apple and their stranglehold on the music industry, not their own incompetence.

  3. I should point out, particularly to John, that MDN does no actual reporting. What they are is a digest. They cull the media for reports they think might be interesting to us and then post them here. An MDN Take is not reportage. It is commentary. Spot-on many times, I might say, but commentary nonetheless.

  4. MDN puts itself forward as a “News” site. A “digest” is a report by another name. And it frequenty misinterprets events to suit its own agenda, witness recent reports/digests of BBC misreporting iTunes being tied to the iPod. MDN is not impartial by any stretch of the imagination. THe basic recipe of the site appears to be 1) find articls that are in some way anti-mac 2) stir in some rehotoric about how said articles are wrong/anti Mac users 3) let Mac users flame away. And all of this it does anonymously. At least when the BBC gets a fact wrong there is a procedure in place to correct it. They are accountable to their users. MDN on the other hand just spouts out its flame bait, reglardless of whether they are abiding by the truth.

  5. @John:
    1) The article MDN sites are not anti-mac. The articles are full of FUD. Hence, MDN’s take on clarifying the FUD. See for yourself in each take.
    2) There is no rhetoric. There is only truth. MDN only asks for the balanced reporting–which makes the majority of these reporters biased or they do not know the product they are covering.
    3) Mac users do not always flame away. Mac users flame away because of stupid reporters that MDN points out. These reporters do not know the first thing about reporting. As a reporter, you are supposed to provide a balanced view. Then you let the consumer make the decision. Often times, if not most, they make the decision for the consumer.

    Hence, MDN’s take is spot on.

  6. The BBC.

    The BBC is the original model of a ‘content-download’ pre-paid subscription service.

    As technology develops, the organisation is fiercely manoeuvring to protect and profit from the model it was the first to use.

    Perhaps what many people outside of the UK don’t know is that if a UK citizen hasn’t paid his or her ‘subscription’ (called a ‘licence fee’ in the UK), it is illegal to own a television set – regardless of if the TV set owner never views BBC channels. It is also technically illegal to own a radio set as the subscription fee also covers the BBC’s five terrestrial radio stations and numerous digital ones.

    Traditionally, the BBC justified and defended its subscription service model by claiming the revenues it generated enabled the corporation to broadcast content which would not be available on commercially-funded services – as the underlying goal of all commercial broadcasters is to attract as large an audience as possible to deliver to advertisers.

    However, with the advent of satellite and digital broadcasting, the BBC has increasingly (and surreptitiously) shifted its position. Internationally, the vast growth in TV channels has opened up a market for the BBC to sell its programming on to – creating a highly profitable new source of income. This has resulted in a commercialisation – or ‘dumbing-down’ – of the BBC’s programme content as it is increasing tailored to be an attractive ‘product’ to sell-on to markets where the population would not understand much of the idiosyncratic UK cultural content that is exactly the type of ‘in-depth’ quality the BBC has always pointed to as a justification of its subscription fee to UK citizens.

    In the UK, the host of new commercial channels has put intense pressure on the BBC to justify the continuation of its enforced subscription service placing the corporation in the untenable position where it now paradoxically undermines its ‘reason-to-exist’ in order to grab audience share and thereby prove its ‘reason-to exist’.

    Further to this, an increasing amount of the revenue the BBC generates from the subscription fee charged to UK citizens – exclusively for TV and radio programmes – is now syphoned off to build and maintain a vast web empire which is, of course, accessible to anyone anywhere… regardless of whether they have paid the subscription fee used to finance it and to obliterate any web-based commercial competition.

    The BBC is now getting into bed with Microsoft. Many people in the UK are curious about the pricing model the BBC develops for iPlayer as well as the restrictive DRM it will introduce to prevent access to its programming. Subscription fees payers (which, remember, includes everyone in the UK who owns a TV set) are questioning whether the BBC can charge them a second time for what they have already paid for – and if the corporation can use digital rights management to deny UK citizens access to what, in fact, they already own.

    As you can see – the BBC and Microsoft very much sing from the same hymn sheet.

  7. John:
    MDN exists because of the large anti-Apple, anti-Macintosh bias that has existed for over 23 years in many large organizations. Since the original Mac, many, even most people in IT have felt threatened by it, and for good reason. Any computer with significantly lower tech support costs than the PC means fewer IT jobs and lower wages.

    Because many news outlets are large organizations, MDN has always had a significant number of ant-Apple reporting to alert us to, and there are more these days, as many “news” outlets no longer attempt any pretense at unbiased reporting. If you’re looking for objective reporting, I have no idea where you can find it, and I doubt that you do, either.

  8. Back to the issue at hand, MDN is exactly right: why do they keep trying subscriptions despite ample evidence that it will fail? They just want that recurring revenue stream so badly!!!

    Omnifone is Napster-redux.

    To: mobile network operators who don’t like MDN’s Takes in this article for obvious reasons, you can stop posting now, suckers, and concentrate on failing.

  9. So, if I am a decent talker, I have to be on a high tier plan for minutes, say $55 and up. Plus, I will end up subscribing to some sort of media plan which allows me unlimited texts, et cetera for another $15. On top of that, if I want music, charge me another $16?

    Yeah, this will have a <i>huge<i> following and bring Apple to its knees…

  10. It didn’t work for DIVX (Digital Video Express). Ever see one of those police car toys with the switch on the front bumper that’s supposed to make the car change direction? Subscription services have a broken switch.

    Bump! Bump! Bump!

  11. Caustic Truth:
    They keep trying because they see people renting apartments instead of owning a house or condo. They see people leasing cars instead of buying. These are big ticket items that people get suckered into spending much more for by renting. The temptation to think they’ll also be suckers when it comes to music is great. What they don’t realize is that people expect their music to stay with them forever, whether it really will or not. That’s different from cars that wear out, or homes they’ll probably leave within a decade. When a consumer looks at leasing music, they tend to look at it as the subscription price multiplied by infinity – a fairly accurate calculation – and that’s a lot more than paying a dollar per song.

  12. MDN: The mobile phone networks are suckers because they, like every iTunes Store victim on the planet, want to control the customer instead of giving customers the control they want — even to the point of buying into this repackaged, over-priced, proven failure that’s called “Omnifone” this time instead of “Napster.”

    Has anything truer ever been written?

  13. I’m not sure if you can actually say subscription based music services are all failures. With a combined 13.6 million subscribers satellite radio seems to be doing well. This is compared to Napster’s and Rhapsody’s half million each. But satellite radio offers a lot more than these would be Ipod/Itunes killers, and they don’t directly take on Apple’s products.

  14. MDN just preaches to the converted, and scrapes the barrel for any story that is remotely anti-Apple to generate flame posts amongs its readership, which in turn generate page hits for its many advertisers. Why does this site have have so ads (many of them for Apple competitors such as Napster, Microsfot, etc. etc) and nasty intrusive popup windows? It is because the site is all about page hits, that is why. And in that context generating hits is as good a method as any. But the last thing this site is is a reliabole source of information. It frequenty gets things wrong and quotes information out of context. If you actually read the linked articles they often turn out to be completely inocuous.

  15. Chris, news flash … not everybody wants to buy “their” music “forever”. Lots of folk out there are well aware of how much of today’s tunes are little more than that – t u n e s ! They are happy to listen to them for a bit then forget they ever existed. Eventually they will be old enough to VOTE and will shift to a more permanent life-style – or, at least, shift in that direction – and move to something less temporary, begin to accrete the remainders/reminders of their “musical memories”.

    DLMeyer – the Voice of G.L.Horton’s Stage Page

  16. Lord 1776, why is it that all you Macfanboy juveniles insist that anyone who doesn’t swallow the flamebait hogwash that MDN puts out must be a “MicroSoft buddy”? For your information, the average Mac user is not one of you rabid venom spewers who frequent this board, they are normal, intelligent people, who don’t need to wear a brand on their sleeve in the hope that it makes them cool by association. Most of us don’t need to menace windows users with statements like “Oh, I suppose you like viruses”.

    John is right. Just get over it.

  17. Sounds to me like John actually works for the BBC. Anyone familiar to trying to make a criticism of the BBC will find words like ‘accountability’ being bandied about no-end by the corporation to justify its relentless move into the marketplace – subsidised, of course, by the UK citizenry who have no choice in the matter.

    The BBC is a rabid wolf which is – these days – dressed up in cloying fluffy sheep’s clothing.

    ‘Accountability’, ‘inclusively’ (and many other words from the BBC’s corporate vocabulary) are directed towards its subscription-payers and the UK government with the sole purpose of the BBC keeping its hands on the billions of pounds it generates through this fee.

    What the BBC would wish you NOT to notice is that it gained its reputation, admiration and the envy of many other broadcasters worldwide by being UNACCOUNTABLE and EXCLUSIVE – having the vision and guts (and, of course, the resources) to take risks in producing programming which no other channel would dare, and gearing much of that programming to minority audiences and interest groups.

    Today’s BBC has stripped its schedules of virtually anything with any peculiarity or depth but still relentlessly relies on milking its historically-won reputation for all it’s worth. Its focus on the ‘market’ has resulted in it becoming a deeply retrogressive organisation, trading heavily on remaking (and endlessly reminding us of) old ‘hits’ from its glory days as a broadcaster whilst being devoid of any the daring thinking-different which actually brought those ‘hits’ into being in the first place.

    Being ‘Accountable’, in the BBC’s deceptive language, is the same as being ‘market-driven’ in the language of any real commercial broadcasting company. Which is fine – except that it results in the same level of programme content and therefore takes away and reason for the BBC to exist.

    And John, perhaps MDN has adverts on its page because it is unable to receive fat sums of free subscription money – and maybe the advertising enables the site so focus its excellent, in-depth content on catering to a minority interest.

  18. Steves Job,

    I call BULLSHIT.

    You are John.

    You are a paid Microsoft shill.

    You post early and hijack the discussion.

    You’re either anti Apple or anti Steve Jobs or anti Mac or anti Mac OS X or pro Apple’s competition.

    We all know you exist, what your job is and who pays your bills.

    BULLSHIT!

  19. Beeg reports: “It is attractive to the networks because it allows them to keep control of their music business rather than simply hand it over to Apple.” I’ve said it before, this is precisely the kind of language used by MS reps when they walk into your company and try to convice you that, unless you move your industry to over to an exclusively MS platform, then you’re just plain stupid. Apple and linux are oftened mentioned by name as being, “…in the way of progress.”

    Point number 2 from the Peabody Wayback machine this morning: (and please read my lips) I do not want to be obligated to use iTunes music store in a subscription fashion. I want to be able to pay as I go. If subscription type services can be ADDED to iTMS for those that might want to pay for pre-packaged service, fine, but we Americans have waited too long to be able to buy and watch ONLY the programs we want to watch and nothing more, and to buy just the songs we like from an album without having to buy the entire album, to have that stripped away from us before its even all of the way out of the birthing canal.

    Have a great day, and, Go Apple!

  20. No, I do not work for the BBC. I have been posting here as John for quite a while now. Seems like some people cant stomach the truth. It is all right criticising others but MDN is not big enough to own up to its own failings.

  21. Twenty Benson said:[/b

    Further to this, an increasing amount of the revenue the BBC generates from the subscription fee charged to UK citizens – exclusively for TV and radio programmes – is now syphoned off to build and maintain a vast web empire which is, of course, accessible to anyone anywhere… regardless of whether they have paid the subscription fee used to finance it and to obliterate any web-based commercial competition.[/i

    There is plenty of content on the BBC sites that is restricted to U.K. “licence” holders only; only those computers connected by U.K. ISPs can access it. I certainly can’t.

    I’ve stopped going to the various BBC sites because in addition to the BBC’s slide into yellow, junk jounalism, links are increasingly hit or miss, whether because of licence/tax restrictions or because the BBC slags Mac users.

    The BBC has become a gelded mouthpiece of corrupt government, a New Labour Potemkin Village, a ruby-red-lipped, webbed-stocking “news” outlet that can be found leaning on any streetlight waiting to rent its “services” by the hour to anyone with the cash. Just ask Bill Gates.

  22. Wait a minute. Today’s music consists of just “tunes” and not music that means something? Really? Are you really quite sure of that? How many *insert non-mainstream genre* bands do you know of? How many do you suppose exist? How many composers would you say exist today? How many avant-garde artists? Music people want to keep their music around. Non-music people buy “emotional wallpaper” and let it go at that. But as for all today’s music being just “tunes”, I have to say that nothing is further from the truth. Open your ears, man!

  23. One minor wording error does not mean that BBC is populated with hordes of idiots. However, BBC’s advocating digital music subscription services does seem to support that hypothesis. Consider this, if the subscription service goes out of business or if the artist withdraws participation in the service your music is completely unavailable and the consumer gets nothing except a notice of consolation. Thanks for nothing, BBC, but I prefer to keep the music that I paid to enjoy.

  24. Well said Big Al. Wow, that idiot calls ME a “rabid venom spewer”! I thought I was being way too nice to that moron. I guess since the truth has been coming out about his lifelong hero and idol Bill Gates, he is getting a little defensive. Truly pathetic. But anyway, I still don’t see what’s wrong with offering a subscription service to those who want it. I would bet that if Apple did, it would be much more succesful than all those other companies. Just my opinion.

  25. Antivenom,

    Excellent point. I think you will find he is a rabid venom spewer, in that he is rabid, and is spewing venom – two separate conditions. The venom itself may, or may not, be rabid – this has yet to be determined. So for the sake of accuracy, I suggest we rule out the option of him being a rabid-venom spewer, and settle on the fact that he is most probably a pratt. A rabid, venom spewing pratt.

    Hope this helps.

  26. Freedom of speech… Brilliant! Freedom of choice… Brilliant! Want a Mac… buy one! Don’t want a mac… don’t! Want pay per track on your iPod via your connected PC and credit card… do it! Want to download music direct to your phone using subsciption via your always connected mobile phone for a £1.99 per week… do it! Competition… brilliant! Freedom of choice… Brilliant!

  27. For those of you who wish to pay for your music in-perpetuity, step right up.

    There’s one born every minute.

    For those of you who have finished high school, listen up.

    Buy a nice Sony AM-FM Sports Radio. It’s light weight, comes with decent ear buds, takes disposable batteries, gets about 36 hrs for $1 worth of batteries, is extremely portable and waterproof and costs less than one month of a subscription service.

    You simply tune it to the radio station that plays your kind of music and use it for the rest of your life.

    In the end you will have listened to live news and weather, live left or right wing commentators, live sports, and almost every music genre you could possibly want. All for $3 or $4 worth of batteries per month.

    And, when it is all over and they are ready to plant you, your music experience will have been the same and your music collection will be just as big as those idiots that paid an absurd subscription price all of their lives.

  28. … or you can access internet radio.
    … or you can hum a tune or sing a song.
    … or you can play an instrument.
    … or you can load a playlist from your collection of archived songs.

    Yes, there are other options to musical entertainment that avoids having to buy permission to a fleeting supply of songs from a fly-by-night distributor.

  29. Steve

    Your type of knee-jerk, not-invented here reaction is comical/typical – what are you smoking geezer? Dismissed out of hand before you even understand the plot?; you have so missed the point in your iPod/iPhone world domination and no other, pop – consumer choice/something different/better is what’s on offer here. Not everyone wants to own/pay for an iPhone, leastways not in Europe/Asia, whose mobile (cell) markets are light-years ahead of uncle sam’s in any case, nor do they want to be tied-in to a single provider…ring any pc/mac bells ?

    “None will generate quite the buzz which surrounded iPhone launch…”? …well maybe, we’ll wait ’til the fat lady finishes the aria on that one, but I’d wager your prescience is mere hubris

    Seems to me, and many others around the known/inhabited/multicultural world, that the ever-growing Omnifone global partner list is savvy enough to know leading technology when it sees it; even if it wasn’t born in silicon valley or the like, or is that because of it?

    I don’t see Omnifone taking a swipe at Apple, quite the reverse if you read-on…you are clearly being very selective in what you have read/seen and commenting upon. One thing you can be certain of is that you are not alone out there….in being proven wrong in the not too-distant.

    Have a nice day.

    Cros’

  30. BBC BIAS AGAINST APPLE

    I received this email from the BBC today:

    Thank you for your e-mail.

    I understand you have concerns that the BBC is biased towards Microsoft and
    against Apple.

    However, I assure you that this is not the case and I would like to direct you
    to the following website where the issue has been addressed by ‘Newswatch’:

    http://search.bbc.co.uk/cgi-bin/search/results.pl?scope=all&edition=d&q=newswatch+microsoft

    The video is titled ‘Is the BBC too soft on Microsoft?”

    Please be assured that your comments have been fully registered and added to our
    daily audience log. This is an internal document that is made available to all
    BBC staff, including the BBC News production team and senior BBC management.

    Once again, thank you for taking the time to contact us.

    Regards

    Paul Kettle
    BBC Information

    And sent this reply:

    Dear Paul

    Thank you for your reply. I would like to watch the video on my Mac but I note that you only support Microsoft and Real Player formats.

    The bias in the BBC against Apple seems to be well entrenched in some quarters. Your recent “informercial” on Vista created a storm of comment in the Apple environment and the BBC’s decision to make your iPlayer video material only available to users on the Microsoft platform FOR AT LEAST TWO YEARS has given rise to considerable anti-BBC feeling amongst the Apple community.

    I have been in this industry for 30 years, most of it in the Microsoft arena, so I am not a rabid Apple fanatic. But I am currently moving my business to the Apple platform for reasons of cost, security, performance, ease of use and simplicity of implementation and operation. Since becoming an Apple user in the last 18mths or so, I have noticed a significant amount of either anti-Apple sentiment in BBC reports, or just poor journalism which shows Apple in a bad light.

    The very fact that your video link does not support Quicktime (the standard and preferred option for all Mac users) just proves my point about bias. No broadcaster can afford to antagonise a significant share of their audience. When this share is the Apple userbase who are well known for being loyal and vocal, and is growing at between 37% and 67% per annum (depending on what market and whether you are talking desktop or notebook sales), it seems very foolish indeed.

    Whatever you think of the BBC’s attitude towards Apple and Microsoft, the Apple community now perceives the BBC as hopelessly biased. Heaven forbid that Apple’s marketshare grows to 50% in the next few years.

    This is a wake up call. The commercial arrangement with Microsoft should be canned, your journalists should be sent to Apple training school, and your organisation should undergo a top to bottom review to ensure even handedness.

    Proceed at your peril!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.