“Last month, in Law Technology News’ Tech Counsel column, California attorney Ed Siebel sang the praises of running his law office with Apple Inc. computers and peripherals. Today, I’m singing a different tune. In fact, right now, I’m completing an online ad to sell my Power Mac G5 Dual 2.7GHz computer,” Larry Bodine writes for Law Technology News.
MacDailyNews Note: Please see “Attorney gets the job done with Apple Macs since 1988” – September 22, 2006
“I was suckered in by the hype about freedom from viruses, simplicity of computing and versatility. Instead, I bought a boat anchor that can’t view Web sites properly, is not compatible with Microsoft Word and can run only dumbed-down versions of regular software,” Bodine writes. “This time, I’m buying from Hewlett-Packard Co. or Dell Inc. — anything that runs on Windows. (I’ll assume the risk of flaming batteries.) Goodbye Steve Jobs, hello Bill Gates. I’ll be lucky to get half of the $4,552.71 I paid for the Mac on May 21, 2006.”
“I realized it was time to unload the silvery box of frustration when I had to buy a ‘Dummies’ book on how to operate it. I’m smart; I shouldn’t need this. Aren’t Macs supposed to be intuitive and easy to learn? My mistake,” Bodine writes.
“The signs of doom were there on day one, but I ignored them. I pretended that I liked the one button mouse. I quickly started using click + command keys (and other keyboard shortcuts). I really missed the little scrolling wheel in the center of the mouse,” Bodine writes. “I noticed it was slow; I saw that stupid spinning colored wheel a lot. The Mac would hang up; the TV ads said Macs didn’t do that. The widgets were cool and snappy, but after a while I stopped using them. They were fun — for five minutes. I did like the Finder because it was quick in locating files, but it would turn up a lot of false hits. It was comparable to the Google Desktop searcher on my PC.”
“What drove me nuts was that I would open Word for Mac and couldn’t delete files while I was in Word. There is no File | Delete option. So the documents took up space on my hard drive, until someone told me I had to find the document in Finder and then move it into the trash from there. This seemed stupid to me; I just wanted to highlight a file and tap ‘delete,'” Bodine writes. “Word files transferred from the Mac were missing pictures. PowerPoint files transferred from the Mac would lose their formatting. PCs and Macs are not compatible, regardless of what they say.”
Bodine writes, “The multiple clicking to accomplish simple tasks was a constant annoyance. Things I could do with a PC in two keystrokes took four or five clicks with the Mac. To do a “fast print” required clicking File, Print, find Copies & Pages, click Paper Type/Quality, click Normal and finally clicking Fast Draft. And there was no way to leave the setting as the default. I had to do it manually every time.”
Bodine writes, “Doing a simple screen capture was an immense chore. On a PC you just press Alt and tap PrtScr. With the Mac I had to download and launch special programs to accomplish this simple task.”
“I didn’t even bother with the Mac’s iCal or Mail, which required me to buy an @mac.com address. Instead, I went straight to Outlook for Mac. A lot of the software for Mac — such as AOL for Mac OS X — was dumbed down and missing may features of the current PC versions,” Bodine writes. “For me the killer was the Web browser. Safari simply cannot read Flash. It is, quite simply, a second-rate browser. I even called Apple headquarters and asked when a better version would be available and was told that Apple is in no hurry to improve it. On the suggestions of friends, I downloaded Netscape and Firefox, which were no better.”
“I run several Web sites, all optimized for IE 5.5 or higher. I couldn’t operate my own Web sites with the Mac. That was the straw that broke the camel’s back. Then the hard drive croaked on me after only three months of owning the machine. I couldn’t tell what was going wrong and had to hire someone for $125 an hour to come over and tell me what the heck was happening. Apple replaced it for free, but I became leery of what other hardware would fail unexpectedly,” Bodine writes. “I let the repaired shiny Mac sit on the floor for weeks, and instead used my reliable IBM ThinkPad, and rediscovered how much I enjoy it. Wish me luck on selling the Mac.”
Full article here.
Rather than rip the poor guy, as he obviously has been ruined by years of being shackled to Microsoft’s upside-down and backwards Windows OS and their Office software, let’s just make some points and realize that Apple has a lot of work to do in helping personal computer users to unlearn bad Windows habits and learn how to properly use Macs:
• Mr. Bodine bought a Power Mac G5 at pretty much exactly the wrong time. That’s unfortunate. If he had not purchased a PowerPC Mac (and why did he get a Mac tower, when he was replacing an IBM laptop?) and instead purchased an Intel-based iMac, Mac mini, MacBook or MacBook Pro (all of which were available on May 21, 2006), he would be able to run Windows for applications he can’t figure out how to use on Mac or that don’t meet his requirements.
• Whoever sold him that Power Mac G5 did him more than a bit of a disservice by not anticipating his needs or informing him about the Intel transition. If he bought it himself without asking a Mac savvy person for advice, he made a mistake.
• He certainly bought way too much Mac and the wrong Mac model for his needs. He spent far too much; an inexpensive Intel-powered Mac mini would have sufficed.
• So, to make it absolutely clear: all Macs purchased today run Windows. Buying an HP, Dell or other OS-limited PC now makes no sense whatsoever.
• Mr. Bodine may indeed be “smart,” but he ignorantly seemed to expect a Mac to work like Windows. It doesn’t. He should have actually read his “Dummies” book, it would have helped immensely.
• Macs, including the Mac he bought, all ship with a multi-button, scroll ball Apple Mighty Mouse. If his didn’t for some reason, he could have easily and inexpensively purchased one or any multi-button USB scroll wheel mouse and it would work just fine with Mac OS X.
• That a Mac such as his was “slow” and “hanging up” is a warning sign that something was wrong. That Mac should have been blazingly fast for the basic tasks he describes. That he used so much Microsoft software is also a warning sign and could be a contributor to those issues.
• When he talks about “Finder” he is really talking about Spotlight. It sounds like he didn’t take 5 minutes to learn how to use it properly.
• Microsoft makes Word for Mac, not Apple. If you don’t like something about it, that’s a Microsoft complaint, not an Apple Mac complaint.
• To delete a file or files on a Mac, select the file(s) in the Finder and hit Command-Delete to move them quickly into the Trash for quick deleting.
• Microsoft makes PowerPoint for Mac, not Apple. If you don’t like something about it, that’s a Microsoft complaint, not an Apple Mac complaint.
• Apple’s Keynote presentation program makes better presentations than PowerPoint, by the way.
• You can do things as quickly or more quickly with a Mac than with a PC, but the Mac won’t magically remove your bad Windows habits and explain the proper way to do things. He should have used his Mac’s built-in help system, read his “Dummies” book, and asked a Mac user for some help.
• To make a new print setting with a Mac, save a preset in the Print dialog box with your desired settings. Choose that preset to quickly print however you’d like.
• Mac’s screenshot ability is unmatched by Windows:
– ⌘-Shift-3 (Command-Shift-3): Take a picture of the entire screen and save as a file
– ⌘-Control-Shift-3 (Command-Control-Shift-3): Take a picture of the entire screen and copy to the clipboard
– ⌘-Shift-4 (Command-Shift-4): Take a picture of the dragged area and save as a file
– ⌘-Control-Shift-4 (Command-Control-Shift-4): Capture dragged area and copy to the clipboard
– ⌘-Shift-4 then Space bar (Command-Shift-4 then Space bar): Capture a window, menu, desktop icon, or the menu bar and save as a file
– ⌘-Control-Shift-4 then Space bar (Command-Control-Shift-4 then Space bar): Capture a window, menu, desktop icon, or the menu bar and copy to the clipboard
– You can also take pictures of the screen using the Grab application (in the Utilities folder).
• iCal or Mail do not require a .Mac account. It’s too bad he didn’t try the applications.
• Third-party software complaints are for the companies making the software, not Apple. Oftentimes, the features Windows users want within Mac versions of software are there, they just can’t seem to shed their Windows ideas of how to accomplish them and/or explore the Mac program’s features.
• If you short-sightedly limit your Web sites by developing only for Microsoft IE, it is not Apple’s or any other browser’s fault that you “can’t operate your own Web sites with the Mac.” There are Web standards for a reason. Follow them and any browser will work correctly. Mr. Bodine has no right to complain about this issue.
• Hard drives fail. Even in Macs. Backup regularly. Apple did replace it for free.
• Mr. Bodine should not be recommending people don’t buy Macs. He knows very little about how to use a Mac. However, articles of this stripe are informative and should give Apple and the Mac community the impetus to figure out ways to better help such users.
• Some Windows users have a huge mountain overcome when it comes to shedding bad habits and learning how to use a Mac properly. Hopefully Apple and all of us who are so inclined can help new Mac users to acclimate better.
• Mr. Bodine should sell that Power Mac and get himself a MacBook or MacBook Pro. He should install Windows for applications he needs and take the time to learn about the Mac while still accomplishing his work. Over time, he would realize that the Mac is a far superior personal computer.
I am glad that MDN used the words “may be smart”. I don’t think so.
He’s a Dell plant. No one and I mean no one can be as stupid as this guy sounds. I am a blue collar trades person and I picked up the Mac with no problems. I just used logic. What the hell is this guys problem. Smart by a half.
<i>I run several Web sites, all optimized for IE 5.5 or higher. I couldn’t operate my own Web sites with the Mac. That was the straw that broke the camel’s back</i.>
That’s what happens when you glue yourself to Microsoft’s proprietary technology!
Well, very nice of MDN for not flaming him. I really suspect, though that he is an imaginary person concocted by the other side. FUD. Have to buy a .mac address to use mail? What the f___. Did he even BROWSE the dummies book? No two button mouse? Did he even look into that? I love my mighty 4 button scroll wheel mouse.
This is a classic example of fear based advertising. Don’t jump! You’ll regret it! Redmond is scared. expect mor eof this smear campaign in coming months- especially leading into Xmas.
I understand how he feels. The same thing happened to me when I traded in my Ford Escort for a new BMW 5 Series. All the buttons and switches were in different places… it was so quiet that I couldn’t tell if the engine was misfiring… so many discouraging things. I unloaded that piece of junk and bought me a Ford Pinto.
Is it really that smart to spend $4000+ on a computer you’ve never used? He could have at least learned something about the OS first. People tend to test-drive cars for example, they do research. They read related literature before, not after the purchase. We visit potential new homes, make inquiries, find strengths and weaknesses. Few hand over their life savings sight unseen. Those people end up on Dateline or 20/20 as examples of what not to do.
So, this guy is a Dateline expose of NOT being smart. Could he find no answers about keyboard short cuts, for instance, on the internet? Aside from this article feeling as if it was written over a year ago and released as some sort of odd October-surprise, his objections and complaints suggest this guy can’t find his way out of a paper bag. He belongs to the Dell-borg.
Smart. Yeah, whatever.
I have a law firm as a client, and believe me this man is quite typical of the breed. Lawyers spend all of their time concentrating on the case they’re working on. If something doesn’t work the way they expect it, it’s the fault of everyone other than themselves.
The helpdesk guys who support computers at any law firm deserve medals for the crap they put up with. Bodine unfortunately here didn’t have IT staff to sack, and because he’s a lawyer and therefore always right, it had to have been Apple’s fault.
Really, that’s how they think.
Well, now …let’s see. Children in America have no problems learning to use a Mac. And here comes this dolt, and he can’t figure out how to use a Mac? It’s like saying arithmetic is a waste of time and we should not use it because he can’t figure out 1+1=2.
One idiot lawyer does not make a trend.
Well, if he was really that unhappy, he could install Windows XP on his new mac. Why sell the one of fastest PC’s in the world and run Windows on it……instead, he is going to sell a PC to buy another PC.
I have to so this guy is not at all as smart as he says he is.
Hello Boot Camp, Hello Windows.
He can’t install Boot Camp because he has a G5. Are you a lawyer?
Notice there’s not ONE word about the Mac not getting infested with viruses, not crashing, or not needing an OS reinstall.
So instead we get a whiney pice about no file delete option in Word (um, Finder?) and how his Safari won’t do Flash (Flash stinks anyway, turn it off). The screen capture bit is especially hilarious: try Cmd-Shift-3 and Cmd-Shift-4. As for the dead hard drive, sorry to hear about it. BUT if he’s dumb enough not to think a 3-month old machine just might be under warranty, he deserves the bill. Tell me a Dell never had a drive go bad.
This guy is definitely a plant.
Hmmm….I would have posted a few comments about that guy, but I’ll keep it short with a little one (But, note that I respect every stance in matter of choice, Windows is for some ones and OS X does it for some others. I’m not going to enter in this territory):
“”I didn’t even bother with the Mac’s iCal or Mail, which required me to buy an @mac.com address”
Mail requires to buy what? Where did he read that? Why I am using Mail and iCal without one @mac.com address. Does this guy know how to read?
Well, if he is a lawyer I think I’d do better managing my own defense in a trial.
I cannot take seriously his comments when he’s proven that cannot use real arguments to defend his preferences in computing stuff (which, I already said, do respect)
Law schools are not as selective as they once were, but insolence is just as debilitating as it always was.
He’s a NeoCon!
Nobody else could be that clueless, dumb or gullible. I’ll bet you he swallows all the BushCo sh*t. Authoritarian types like conformity.
He bought a $4,552.71 machine to surf the internet and do accounting. The dude is retarded.
This also smells fishy. Maybe a planted story. I’m not buying it.
I pity da fool takin legal advice from this sucka…!
I do hope that MDN has politely, gently, and VERY simply told this gentleman the error of his ways!
I see that the adults are in charge at MDN today
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
For the record: my attorny’s entire office is Mac.
maczealot: you must be a lawyer.
Last: this guy has to be fake. No one can be that incredibly stupid and then write about.
I’m glad that MDN pointed out the first thing I was thinking while reading this: The person that sold him this machine failed. They sold him the wrong thing, and obviously didn’t address a single concern this guy might have.
That’s assuming, of course, that this guy went somewhere for help. He seems like the kind of guy that wouldn’t ask for directions even if he was lost for 24 hours in a Map Store. He probably went to CompUSA, pointed to the one with the biggest price tag and said “Mine”.
I have a daughter in college and one of her classes is an online IE 6.0 or better. (I got her a macbook. She loves it). She could not get into the web pages because of MS IE. We installed bootcamp/Windows SP2 just to get her to the web pages. More $$. Is there a safari patch for this?
Mac does have a problem of not helping with how to use its software. Yes they have help files, but it does not all ways help. I have had to look at apple support and mac rumor sites to find help some of my problems. This one I cant find.
…Sounds like he should have bought ProCare, hehe
Well I’ve got to agree with MacBones, this is FUD underhand advertising for the Redmond camp…
If not, all it illustrates is some pseudo-computer-savvy hack who wants to run a windoze box on a mac.
I really think “Mr Bodine” (or is that Bovine? one with long horns?) should’ve been flame-grilled to a within an inch of his ficticious/pretentious life. MDN was too lenient on this one…
all new mac users NEED ProCare (a year of 1-on-1 training on all mac software and how to use their systems) for 99$ that’s the most affordable training you can get. go to an apple store and get it.
I’m with G-Spank on that one: I’m not buying it either…
When I was learning to use my Mac, the help tab at the top of every page was immensely helpful. I could type in any question and the answer appeared before me. Also, the biggest problem I found that i had was overthinking things. Could deleting a photo from iPhoto really be as easy as highlighting it and hitting ‘delete’? Why, yes it can. Also, Apple used to send out these emails every couple of weeks that had a did you know section that talked about features on your Mac. I learned a lot of stuff that way and looked forward to getting those. Wonder if they still do that.
By the way, the entire exerience was an absolute joy compared to the 12 year suffering with Windows that I had just gone through. I have gotten dozens of my friends and family to switch and this story is the polar opposite of what I have heard from every single one of them.
EVEN IF he had all the issues that he describes – and is as positively neanderthal as he seems – macs have one AMAZING feature for the real dummies:
You can go onto a mac user forum, and find someone nearby who is so totally utterly IN LOVE with their Mac, that they would come over and spend a FEW HOURS with you showing you exactly how to get the most out of it all for FREE – or at worst, maybe for the price of being served some lunch.
Try finding a fan of windows so dedicated….
why can’t we just leave these people alone and let them be ignorant and naive. Stop saving them.
MDN word: Rot
Anyone else notice that he bought a dual 2.7 GHz PowerMac on May 21, 2006, about 8 months after Apple stopped selling them? Last October, Apple updated the PowerMac line, and the top of the line machine after that was the Quad 2.5 GHz. So he’s probably just making this whole thing up because Dell and HP paid him to.
tterbo – Since we upgraded my router at work, Safari chokes on certain websites. I have discovered a fine patch to fix the problem. It’s called Firefox.
Don’t use that guy for your lawyer needs. He obviously is NOT smart.
I can sorta relate to this guy, but only insofar as Windows habits encroaching on the new. When I switched 5 years ago, I had that problem with trying to use the Mac the same way I used my old Windows PCs. While they are similar in many ways, they are quite different, too. The problem is changing the way of thinking. Shedding the old habits to learn new ones. This stubborness by former Windows users is nothing new, but it *IS* the single hardest thing to overcome when switching Windows users to Macs. My friend in Florida is a prime example of that. I can’t help her directly though because I am so far away (I live in New York). But I am determined to get her problems taken care of one way or another. This is the dedication to helping new users that MDN was talking about. People dislike change, as much as they all say “Change is good”. Change is never always good, but it is necessary. Patience is a must for everyone involved. This fellow just didn’t have enough of it. His experience is not typical or even common, and some of the problems he had were problems of his own, in perception and willingness to learn. I hope he can give the Intel-based Macs a try down the road.
follower- it does not work.
Update Note: His dad must actually be Jethro.
Look it up.
tterbo – Hmmm. Those are some tough websites.
As for Larry Bodine – didn’t Phil Hartman used to play this guy on Saturday Night Live…? And I don’t know if I’d trust my legal business to someone with the same last name as Jethro from the Beverly Hillbillies.
Damn you, Cheney! You beat me by a second!
Deleting files through Word? He must be related to this other guy who felt like he was shackled and shutdown when his Word shortcut was removed and he called me to let me know he can no longer manage his files and was wondering if he should buy the upgrade to Word. Yes, he even asked me if there were any additional file navigation features.
This guy here appears to be so out of mind, I can’t believe he really exists.
Only way to get this IE to work is go get MS SP2 or go through a server with windows.
I wouldn’t buy services from a guy who can’t even figure out how to use a Mac. Even my four year old twins know how. What an idiot…
You’ll never ever quit smoking if you are not commited to do it.
You will look for all kinds of reasons and excuses to go back to it.
I don’t know if this will help your daughter’s specific case, but eneabling Safari’s hidden debug menu provides the option of changing the user agent to Windows MSIE 6.0, effectively tricking the server you’re trying to access into thinking you’re using MSIE. It’s not for the fainthearted, though, as you have to get under the hood and type a command into the Terminal app.
Type the following command in the Terminal (/Applications/Utilities/Terminal.app) while Safari is NOT running:
% defaults write com.apple.Safari IncludeDebugMenu 1
Then close the Terminal and launch Safari; the Debug menu will be at the end of the Menu bar. Change the User Agent to ‘Windows MSIE 6.0″ and have her attempt to access the site in question. This works a lot of times for me — it’s the only way I can access the KCATA bus schedule site using Safari! Then when you’re done with that site, you can change it back to “Automatic” and surf like a person using a modern web browser would. Or you can leave it on MSIE all the time, but you may not get the benefits of sites with Ajax or other technologies that MSIE can’t or won’t support…
Another option is to download and try another browser – Firefox and/or Opera tend to work on those pesky MSIE-built sites for which changing the User Agent in Safari won’t work. YMMV.
Hope this helps!!
I’m glad this guy ditched his mac. It makes me feel better that dumbass’ like him won’t be using the same type of computer i do. I wonder if i could trick him into selling me that PMG5 for cheap…..
What do you call 1000 lawyers at the bottom of a cliff? A good start. And this guy should be the first over.
Yeah, he’s “smart”. Uh huh.
Oh, emailing him you get:
“I am traveling on client business and will return to the office on Tuesday, October 17. Until then please call Administrator Laura Kresich at 312.217.3895 or Consultant Debbie Thompson at 708.203.3424.”
Ok. Wonder if he figured out North and South yet. Did you Larry? Do we need to send out the search party yet?
this guy can’t be real. since when does safari not do flash? and please someone point out how apple started logical key commands: open apple P for print.. control P on the pee cee. etc..
Well, I have to say he did mention a few things that are a pain. I really like Mac. I have been using for the past 20 years, however, certain annoyances do creap in. He is right about formatting and picture issues in Powerpoint. I had a friend of mine borrow my laptop one night for a project at the school. She lost some points on her presentation because the presentation she did on windows did not look right on the Mac, and yes, I have the latest updates on MS Office 2004. It wasn’t necessarily her fault. I too was surprised that there were formatting issues present, but it happened nonetheless. As for the new intel chip units, I have looked extensively at upgrading my Powerbook G4 1.67 for a new 17 inch MBP. The reality is that I have to send a lot of documents in MS Word. While it is true that the much vaunted “Rosetta” allows for emulation, it is just that emulation. It is slow. I do not type all that fast and I was able to out-type the cursor on a MBP 17 inch 2.16 ghz with 2 gigs of RAM. I am not advocating windows over PC’s, however, Some of us are solidly in the Mac camp and we will remain there. Folks coming over from the windows world are not going to like some of the bottlenecks. Apple should have done a better job of getting more software ready for the Intel units. When I returned the MBP yesterday I noted less and less software on display in the Apple store. The average consumer might just conclude that there is little software available for the mac because of the scant display. As for the hardware, Apple should also do a better job of making sure their units are tested before they are put into production. Apple still leads the pack, and yes, I still will choose Apple over any windows unit out there, so this is not meant as a flame.
for Edgeley Exile 14
hey, do think that only damn lawyer work hard in the business? that’s why they don’t have time to learn simple mac? that’s absolutely no sense at all. yeah, they’re important. but I am also professional as much as they do. I am an architect to have responsibilty for designing all type of buildings. I use mac. it’s very easy to use. if you’re not an infant, you can very easily learn mac in a short time. lawyer? come on. the occupation can’t be excuse because they’re simply busy.
Lawyer or not, this guy is obviously mentally-challenged; but he does make one good point if I understand him correctly. On the Mac, it is not possible to delete files from the Open/Save dialogue box while working in an application (Word, for example). I have been wishing for this feature for over 20 years and it’s still missing. Perhaps this little trick is already possible in Windows and, if so, the guy definitely has a point. One point out of a hundred isn’t so bad.
Try Camino too.
It sometimes works for me in difficult situations.
John
Ha, I just ran his website through the WC3 validator and his website has 53 errors on it. I wish there was an IE only validator to compare it against the standards.
Sheesh…
I find it obscene that an self described “smart” individual could not “figure out” how to use a MAC. I am a recently new to mac’s (about 5 months now), and everything was so much easier to learn how to use. I will admit that the first couple of day’s I was thinking the M$ way about things, I just needed to become a free thinking (READ: not assymilated to the M$ world) and look at what was on my screen. I loved it so much, I bought my wife, who has trouble figuring out a solar powered calculator, an iMAC. She figured things out right away, and, to pull out the Apple standard of marketing, IT JUST WORKS!!!!!
The most hilarious part is when Mr Bovine says: “I am smart” EHHAHAHAHUHUHAHHOHAHOHAHUAHUHHAUHAHU
Really, smart? HAHHUHHAHHUHHUHHAOHHAOHHAHHOHAUHHHAOHH
Hard to believe idiots such as this guy truly exist. Mr Bovine, are you there listening? if yes, moooooohhh back to us so we know you’re a real bull.
What a dolt.
He probably went to college too.
My 12 year old grand-daughter is more savvy.
MW–major–as in, his major was in dumb.
Word in Rosetta slow? How fast are you tying Bill? My secretary does consistently between 90 and 100 wpm. Word on the Mac just follows her tying. Slow? We do not see performance issues wrt Word on a Dual PowerPC 2GHz.
Bravo MDN for a well articulated response that will go a long way to clear these sad little tirades. We human beings get so attached to things that are familiar. So much so that anything that is new can be perceived emotionally as a threat. I feel that’s why we read many of these venemous little articles.
Personally, I feel a little lucky. I started using computers about 13 years ago and had to work on Macs and Windows machines including Windows NT back about 8 or 9 years ago. On both systems I became familiar with navigating menus, using shortcuts, troubleshooting which included watching our IT person resolve more complicated issues.. I have had my frustrations with both systems.
After all these years of working both sides of the isle I can say with confidence that if someone were to give me a Windows machine I would just turn around and give it away. I wouldn’t use a Windows OS in my personal life because I have a choice. I don’t have to tell you why. Any Mac user already understands how fluid you computer experience can become on a Mac…..and anyone who has needed to work on both systems knows how much the Windows OS can get in your way.
Oh, and one more thing. Just imagine if there were no Apple Computer…no MacInstosh.
Far be for me to defend Microsoft and a Windows user, but I’m willing to cut this guy some slack over his formating problems with Word and probably PowerPoint,too. Most likely they are related to font issues which have to do with the goofy-assed way Apple has implemented font use in OS X. I know that is the main culprit behind formating issues I have had in dealing with Word docs from Windows using client.
Dealing with fonts and managing multiple font libraries has always been a major pain for print graphics pros, and the Apple implemented font control in OS X did not help us, at all. Apple should have implemented font usage in a manner similar to the way third party font managment programs do. Through a single font library outside of the system folder.
1st thing there is no file/Delete in Word for Windows. By def. in windows you can’t delete files that are open. So either someone wrote a macro for closing and then deleting the file and placed it in his file menu, or he was using Windows Explorer! (There is another more likely explanation, but its rude to call people idiots, so I won’t)
I am relatively new to the Mac universe (switched last year), and yeah there were some growing pains (1st week) – mainly me doing things manually instead of letting the mac handle it. IE going into finder and rearranging my photo library, instead of using IPhoto. It took me a while to realize that yeah it really is that easy. I don’t have to do all the work. And Boy was that a wonderful relevation.
My other big issue was using the apple key when i was used to using the control key for shortcuts, it took me a while to get used to it, but now I find myself hampered on my work windows box, since I find myself using KB combinations that don’t work – no expose, no using the keyboard to go forward and back. And other little things that I don’t realize how much I use until I am doing somethign and then realize “oh, can’t do that, this isn’t a mac.”
But on the bright side, maybe I can buy his PowerMac from him dirt cheap. 😀
I guess Macs aren’t idiot-proof, because this one sure didn’t understand it. I was nearly crying reading the summary. MDN, don’t blame MS. I understood Mac and I was using Windows since 3.1. Its not MS, it’s him. And who the heck buys a $4,000 system to use Word?! He deserves not got understand Mac. I cracked when I read you needed a .mac account for Mail… NO YOU DON’T, YOU THICK-HEADED MORON! DID YOU EVEN CARE TO LOOK IN THE DROP-DOWN BOX IN THE WIZARD!? And stop inflicting pain and suffering by making your sites only work with IE. Get Firefox! AND IT’S ENTOURAGE, NOT OUTLOOK! *sigh* Some people…
delete files from the Open/Save dialogue box
amounts to being able to stop the computer using the START menu.
Windows do lots of stupid things in wrong places. Apple has GUI guidelines and no dolt is allowed to do seemingly brilliant things that are plain wrong. Who but Windows users could possibly think about finding a DELETE option in a Open/Save dialogue box.
It is just wrong. The fact that Windows Word does it does not change the thing. Word for Mac is done at REDMONT, by MICROSOFT and — thanks Jobs — they too have to stick to GUI guidelines, hence no STOOPID allowed on the Word for Mac GUI: no crazy DELETE option on a Open/Save interface.
Lipstick on pigs is not a good idea, sorry to break it on you ex-Windows users. No pigs allowed (or corrupted, wrong, misleading GUI)
This message is in response to @tterbo. Although your solution is correct about ‘tricking’ the server into accepting Safari as IE 6.0, there is a far easier and less adventuresome method. Simply download Tinkertool 3.6.1 from http://www.bresink.com/osx/TinkerTool.html. Install it and enable the ‘debug’ command from the setup dialog box. The drop-down menu ‘Debug’ will appear in the top menu. Scroll to User Agent and choose MSIE 6.0. Very easy.
This guy does smell very fishy. I also expect to see lot’s of Pee Cee switchers complaining in the comming weeks, especially since Vista won’t be here for the holidays. It’s amazing how a little FUD just paralyzes folks.
The guy did have a very good point though, one that I struggle with when recommending Apple to long-time PC users. Generally, some of the software written for the Mac isn’t as good as the PC software out there (functionality built in). Office is a good example, in addition to the Powerpoint issues pointed out, there are some missing functions (charting) in Excel, (i learaned this from trying to help my son on this Physics homework, yuck) Also, Quicken for the Mac is really a poor second cousin to Money and Quicken on the PC. (I’m a CPA, been using both sides for years PC at work, Mac at home) For many home users, this is a big deal, especially for the more well healed users considering Mac. Intuit’s been taking Mac users for granted for years!
Chaz
The free “Safari Enhancer” is an application for enhancing the functionality of Apple’s Safari Web browser.
Safari Enhancer current has the following features:
• Enabling the Debug Menu
• Removing underlines from hyperlinks
• Increasing the font size in the bookmarks sidebar
• Disabling Safari’s web content cache
• Forcing the download of all PDF files
• Changing the colour of hyperlinks
• Switching between the Brushed, Aqua and Unified Title/Toolbar application appearances
• Disabling the website icon cache
• Importing bookmarks from the Internet Explorer, Mozilla, Netscape, Omniweb and iCab browsers
• Adding of a “New Tab” button to the Safari toolbar
• Configuring of the history retention settings Safari uses
• Changing the search engine used in the Safari toolbar
• Choosing whether background imagery is printed
• Choosing whether to display complete URLs in Safari tooltips for links
• Changing what browser Safari identifies itself to websites as
Approved for use with Safari 2.0.4 with several new search engines added.
http://www.celestialfrontiers.com/safari_enhancer.php
Astroturfing of highest order
how embarassing for this guy! Can you imagine how dumb you would feel to publish an article like this that just shows you can’t even figure out how to delete a file? And then he tries to blame others for this! Truly embarassing.
Well, I sent a Letter to the Editor of Law.com including the words “libel”, “completely and entirely wrong”, and “reputation.”
You can easily do the same from the Law.com website.
It appears that Bodine is a real person. His websites are extremely “interesting.” I surfed as much of them as I could stomach. I used my powerful iMac 400 DV SE. Not even a hint of a problem.
Check out his website it’s a joke. It is barely a step above “dial a Lawyer”. He should stop spending time on computers and spending more of it in his car chasing ambulances.
I wouldn’t hire anybody that dumb.
First, a nice new iMac (Intel) would have done fine. A high-end PowerMac for basic office use is incredibly dumb.
Second, Firefox or Camino can handle the very few web pages that Safari renders weird. BTW- The fault is not Safari- it’s the non standard sh*t that IE tolerates. Nothing like Front Page crap, is there?
Third, the effing moron should have hired a Value Added Reseller to do it right. Why anybody would put their livelihood’s tools at risk by not hiring expert help and indemnification. I always thought legal people were risk averse.
http://www.apple.com/services/consulting/
http://agents.apple.com/
http://consultants.apple.com/at_a_glance/prescient/
Re: Delete from Application’s Open/Save Dialog
Apple has clearly separated application functions from Finder functions. The primary reason for this is to help prevent user mistakes. It is not as if the file cannot be overwritten from Open/Save if you want to. (Although, I have found that many people are unaware that you can click on a grayed-out existing file in a “Save As” dialog list, and it appears in the file name text block, so you may quickly replace it.) To delete a file, you must intentionally go into Finder to do it, and then delete the Trash. Deleting a file is a Finder specific function much as getting file info, duplicating it, moving it around or playing with the sidebar.
The Mac OS is designed so you can keep your Open/Save dialog window open and still go into the Finder and make adjustments. The changes will instantly be reflected in the Open/Save dialog; closing and re-opening it is not necessary.
I have absolutely no doubt that much time and thought went into the Finder at the original Mac OS inception, and I am quite sure Steve and Woz’s design decision was based on making deleting files an intentionally cumbersome process. The alternative is to make deleting files as easy as saving them which doesn’t make any sense… unless you’re Microsoft.
What Outlook for Mac did he run? There is no Outlook that will run under OS X.
re: missing pictures in Word/Powerpoint files from Mac.
This has been a problem going back over half a decade. If you copy and paste a pictures into any Mac MS Office program, it shows up fine–until you move it to Windows.
See more here: http://www.pptfaq.com/FAQ00534.htm
Worse, the so-called “Compatibility checker” in Office 2004 doesn’t flag this as an error. So a Mac user is made to look like a fool when s/he hands over a perfectly good (to the Mac user) Office document to Windows users, as a deliverable/assignment/presentation, and in one fell stroke Macs AND Quicktime are marked as “not being compatible (enough)” with Windows. Imagine doing a PPT presentation to a room full of people and your images not showing up!
I believe dragging and dropping image files (JPG, GIF, PNG) into the document itself gets around this, but the only guaranteed way is to Insert > Picture. Which negates one of the biggest advantages the Mac brought to the world back in frikkin’ 1984, copy and paste between programs!!
A fix would be as simple as auto-converting pasted images into PNG or whatever format copy-paste images are saved as in Windows (not BMP; resulting filesizes are way too small). MS has billions at its disposal, so it’s obvious they have NO intention of removing this hidden time bomb.
Being a Mac user since the 1980’s, it always amazes me when I see stories like this (I have two brothers-in-law that switched, and behaved similarly). However, I think the point that was made in the MDN Take is very valid – – – either we as an Apple community or Apple corporate need to work better to help people transition from Windows to Mac. In my industry, we have a very similar problem when people switch from our competitor’s gear to our products. There is no simple solution (not all of the customers who transition have the same needs when learning something new). Many people aren’t willing to take the time to learn something new that, oh by the way, will enrich their lives.
Maybe it’s time for Apple to convene a brainstorming session with both “die-hard” Mac people and switchers to develop a real transition methodology. In the end, everyone would win.
Edward said
“hey, do think that only damn lawyer work hard in the business? that’s why they don’t have time to learn simple mac? that’s absolutely no sense at all. yeah, they’re important. but I am also professional as much as they do. I am an architect to have responsibilty for designing all type of buildings. I use mac. it’s very easy to use. if you’re not an infant, you can very easily learn mac in a short time. lawyer? come on. the occupation can’t be excuse because they’re simply busy.”
My friend, you miss my point. I’m not saying that lawyers are any more important than other careers, but that they all have a tendency to focus solely on their workload, even to the point where they honestly believe they don’t have the time to learn anything different. They also have a tendency to believe themselves the most important person in the room, which makes life hell for a tech consultant like myself to implement anything into their office because EVERY single person wants it done their way.
MDN: “”…articles of this stripe are informative and should give Apple and the Mac community the impetus to figure out ways to better help such users.”
Amen to that. MDN has moments of rightness, which are sadly usually lost among the mountains of blind cheerleading.
This article is probably a plant, but his problems are exaggerated versions of the problems all switchers have had and will have when approaching the new platform. The Mac user community has got to reach out to these people and help show them the way, rather than calling them ignoramuses who deserve what they get.
Powerpoint problems are Microsoft’s fault. The inability to delete a file in an Open or Save dialog is and has always been a problem with OS X. That’s not MS’s dialog box, it’s OSX’s dialog box. You ought to be able to create and rename folders and delete files and folders from ANY standard OS file dialog. Windows has this right — a file dialog is just a modified instance of the explorer window, and OSX’s file dialogs SHOULD be modified instances of Finder windows.
Gee, I hate working on a Saturday.
delete files from the Open/Save dialogue box
I think the point was that it may be possible in Windows to delete files that are NOT open from the Open/Save dialogue. There used to be a utility for OS 9 that added that feature. Personally, I would love to be able to do this again.
A guy in a bar stands up and says, “All lawyers are idiots.”
Another guy stands up and says “Hey…I resent that…”
The first guy says, “Why? Are you a lawyer?”
The second guy says, “No. I’m an idiot.”
I recently convinced my office to replace a number of ageing PCs with Mac minis (Core Solos with 1 gig of RAM–for Rosetta, the difference between 1 gig and 512 MB is huge). One of my co-workers, a NOT computer savvy 60-year-old woman who has never touched a Mac in her life got one of the Minis. She had her share of troubles–how do you do this, how do you do that, etc. But she plowed through and I helped her where I could. It’s been two months now, and just last week she walked up to me to say that she really, really loves her new machine. She said, without me prompting her in the least, the way things work make sense and once you understand it, it’s intuitive and consistent. Her one criticism, which I actually agree with, is that you should be able to cut and paste on the desktop and in the Finder. This is a REAL Mac story, with its ups and downs, but also with an understanding that with a little bit of thought and patience, you can switch to a far, far better computer machine. By the way, one of the ways I motivated the Minis is by pointing to Parallels and Boot Camp and the ability to install Windows if needed. Nobody has even has even raised the need to install Windows on any of the machines. Anyway, this lawyer, assuming his story is not a fake, seem a bit of a dolt. How in God’s name do you buy a $4,000 machine without doing any research whatsover? Given what he describes as his needs, a base Mini with 1 gig of RAM would have suited him fine. In May, that would have been at most $700. What the hell is wrong with this guy? He does seem to express the typical stereotype of a lawyer that believes the world exists for his sake–he deserves Windows.
Twat!
Being a Mac user in business isn’t always a rosy proposition.
Apple is fighting an up hill battle “fitting in”. M-Soft has it’s big thumb on Apple when it comes the important business apps and hobbling Office is just one of the tools they have. We can only hope that this is going to change for the average joe, until it does there are going to be lots of examples of people looking to get the job done in the business world and they’ll have to find a work-around. Allot will give up just as this fictitious guy did.
Being 10% market share does cause problems and one of them being active-x. (In IE for Win) Unfortuanately active-x based website are the standard for many companies. We can only hope that these companies will be paying a bigger price for this as Apple pounds the Windows world year after year.
To our rescue? Check out Googles offer of free spread sheet and Doc apps
http://docs.google.com/?action=unsupported_browser
If he runs several websites, wouldn’t he want to design them so people with Macs can access them? Most webmasters with a brain would want to know. In his case, he just wants to stick his head back in the sand where it’s confortable.
That point alone makes me think this guy’s not real.
Deleting a file from within an application is actually not difficult:
Document windows generally have the open document’s <i>Proxy Icon</b> in the window title bar.
You’ve got various options with that:
• CMD-click to reveal the path and select the folder which immediately contains the file: The folder then opens on top, with the document file already selected and visible in its actual context on the disk. A simple CMD-BACKSPACE moves it to the trash. So basically one click to open, one key to delete, CMD-W to close the window again if you want. That’s it.
• Really “well-behaved” applications (such as BBEdit, but apparently not my older Word version) also support direct dragging of the proxy icon to the trash in the Dock. That’s even easier. And at least BBEdit also closes the document window automatically as well.
The proxy icon is also great when editing files and then operating on or with them in a shell window: Simply drag it to the shell window and the path is automatically inserted. You can also use it to append an open document to an email: Again, just drag the proxy icon.
It’s one of the neatest and at the same time least known features in OS X!
I hope the Apple marketing people are reading this. You can learn a LOT from this guy.
First, he represents 99% of PC users — “reasonably” intelligent people (smart enough to do their own day to day tasks with suboptimal tools).
Second, he doesn’t know what to do with is Mac once he has it.
Third, he’s been become so dependent (unconsciously) on proprietary Microsoft technology that he can’t function without it. The opportunity costs to learn how to truly “switch” is too high. He would rather just go on with his work.
The points made that he should not have bought a G5 tower because it has too much horsepower is a good point. At the same time, this kind of person also doesn’t need an iSight camera or any Apple software or OS features (i.e. iLife).
Apple marketing seems to spend all their time telling people how “cool” the Apple is with “life” stuff but doesn’t spend enough time showing people that the “work” stuff is actually BETTER than a PC. All of their “I’m am Mac, and I’m a PC” adds say that the PC does office stuff well and the Mac can also do it.
To substantially gain Apple marketshare in the small business/end user/professional market, they need to prove that their WORK productivity will be better. Currently, they can’t say that because they don’t have a good way of getting people to deprogram and un-Microsoft themselves. There is not one person that I know in corporate America who would be comfortable letting go of their Outlook/Treo/Excel macros and templates lifestyle for Entourage/MissingSync/Excel without comparable keyboard shortcuts.
Intel architecure or Parallels is NOT a solution or replacement to facilitate this transition.
For this lawyer dude’s needs, a $400 Dell laptop is the best solution.
I think I’d rather represent myself than have a counselor that openly and proudly admits to the world that he’s too retarded to use a Mac.
Bugs Bunny would have called him a maroon.
This says it all. I sent it off after reading the guy’s rant
This is a reply to ‘Don’t Sit Under The Apple Tree’
I hope that the story related in the article does not reflect the author’s approach to his professional services. Aversion to risk has always been a hallmark of the legal profession and this tale shows someone plunging in blind, uninformed and without competent professional counsel. The sad truth is it didn’t have to be this way.
I’ll spare you all of the Macintosh vs. Windows stuff, but many Law Practices and other non-‘creative’ businesses use Macs every day to get the job done and are quite happy with their decision. The difference is in their approach to IT.
To be truthful, most complaints and problems relating to any computer system from whatever vendor come down to incompetent or ill-advised people making the choices or installation. Just as I wouldn’t represent myself in a legal proceeding, I wouldn’t make decisions regarding mission critical work tools without professional advice.
Apple maintains in-house consulting services and an authorized network of third-party agents and consultants for the very purpose of keeping new and continuing customers supported with expert advice, support, training and set-up. They also offer ProCare and Apple Care which extend the support & training options for consumers and professionals. The reputation of these services and providers is among the best in the industry and has been for years. Access to these services is as quick as a trip to Apple’s website, a phone call or a visit to an authorized reseller or Apple retail store.
With proper expert advice, the author could have made an informed decision as to whether switching from Windows to a Mac was advisable for his needs. Further, he could have been presented with a variety of software solutions and option from which to choose. Otherwise, any number of expert advisory options were available to the author, but were not exercised. No Due Diligence- not very Lawyerly.
What we have is nothing but a rant by someone who made a series of ill-advised and uniformed choices. That is not the fault of Apple Computer, it’s software or anyone other than the author. It should not reflect upon Apple or the capabilities of it’s products. Any professional should understand the value of properly trained, informed and indemnified professional service. Especially someone in the legal profession.
Good Enough?
The lawyer in question — Larry Bodine — is obviously and blatantly a paid shill for Micrososft.
There is nothing honest about what he is saying.
It’s all FUD plain and simple. Bought and paid by Microsoft or some hedge fund fronting for Bill Gates.
Ask him:
Lbodine@LawMarketing.com
I am not sure he even exists. The whole thing looks like a Redmond war room campaign to attack Apple.
This is all Microsoft knows to do in the face of better technology.
Spread FUD, and run Psychological Operations from Ballmers office.
Forget about this B.S. because it’s just an aggresive psy-ops to attack Apple.
You can write to the idiot at
Lbodine@LawMarketing.com
He’s well paid to write this garbage.
<Larry at the podium>
“Hi, my name is Larry Bodine, and I am a Windows monkey.”
<other Windows monkeys in unison>
“Hi, Larry.”
As stated above by someone, expect much more of this slanted Mac bashing. MS is in deep trouble and they know it.
Did anyone ever see the movie “Tucker”? It is a somewhat corny movie but it shows what power and money can do to the best of intentions.
I actually buy this guy’s stuff. Look, all you Mac savvy people can say whatever you like, thats entirely your opinion. However, after 4 months of research b4 finally committing myself to a Macbook, I’m not exactly sure I made the right desion anymore.
Again, you can say whatever you want, but since the day I got my mac, I’ve been an unpaid advocate for Apple. My friends actually keep wondering why in God’s name I speak so much of Apple. I read Apple news everyday to keep abreast of any Apple news. But frankly, I’m getting fed up of my mac and seriously considering puttin it up for sale. Yes, I do get that spinning coloured wheel A HELL OF A LOT. I got me a Black 2.0 GHz Mac, what the f* is going on. And then MS Word: everytime I try to save a doc, it asks me to perform a Compatibilty Test. Why all the hassle. Dont nobody gimme a hassle abt Word being designed by Microsoft, not Apple, thats baldderdash.
Bottomline is, I like the Mac but I’ll love to get my hands on a 2.0 GHz HP dv200t (Intel) laptop (with 100GB harddrive included) or a similar quality Sony VAIO. The Mac is flashy, fun to look at, people look at you when you take out your computer and admire you BUY HELL! this computer aint practical. Nope, well, not against PCs matching its capabilities.
He claims to be a “Strategic Marketing Consultant”…
http://pm.typepad.com/about.html
http://www.larrybodine.com/About_Us.htm
Sounds like “strategic Marketing” to me.
Forget about this B.S. because it’s just an aggresive psy-ops to attack Apple.
If I didn’t know better, I’d swear MS was running a nasty political campaign; i.e. if you don’t have any substance, smear your opponent from the shadows. The more absurd the claims the better, just keep the other guy on the defensive.
Who knows, maybe Gates & Ballmer are practicing for a White House run after Microsoft implodes.
I checked the appropriate Illinois website. Larry Bodine is not a lawyer (at least a licensed Illinois attorney); he’s merely a marketing guy who preys upon law firms throughout the country from his little home office in a quiet Chicago suburb. The bigger problem is that as a lawyer, I’m looking for more legal software solutions for the MacOS. Once there are more of these, then I can see more law firms switching to the Mac.
this computer aint practical.
You seem to need a bit of actual support; None of what you’re saying is inherently a Mac problem. You might have far too little RAM for the amount of parallel processes you’re using (lots of disk swapping, hence lots of beach balling) and you might not have your Word properly configured.
And yes, if Word screws up, it’s a Microsoft problem and you first need to check how the Word problem could be resolved (it most probably can – I’ve not yet seen the message you’ve mentioned).
Please, send him Mac for Nuts and give me his address, I’ll buy his mac!
i had a law firm as a client: as i said, i had a law firm as a client. they too came from a microshit environ to the mac and somehow didn’t realize that they would have to change the way they thought about using the computer. like knowing corporate law and then going to maritime, maybe a little retraining is involved?
but then again, (like using windoze) when did a lawyer make things easier for their clients?
regarding legal software solutions, I found an interesting OSX app that is analogous to Trial Director or Summation for litigation support:
http://www.trialsmart.com/index.html
And busting the “Macs are more expensive than PC’s” myth on the software side, TrialSmart costs less than half of what Trial Director costs, and about 70% less than Summation.
If you’re a plaintiff’s lawyer, you might already know who Mark Lanier is — if you’re a defense lawyer with Merck Pharmaceuticals as a client, you DEFINITELY know that name!! He uses a combination of Macs and WinXP in his firm, quite successfully I might add:
http://www.apple.com/business/profiles/lanier/
So maybe the idiot who wrote this article proves that it’s the craftsman, and not the tools….
This law firm has won cases against the likes of Merck and they use Macs.
http://www.apple.com/business/profiles/lanier/
He obviously must not be too good if he can’t figure out simple little things. Let him go back to his losing ways and use Windows.
Stupid is as stupid does
“He’s a NeoCon!
Nobody else could be that clueless, dumb or gullible. I’ll bet you he swallows all the BushCo sh*t. Authoritarian types like conformity.”
wow….you sure are an idiot. geeze….I don’t even know how to respond to such a brainless comment. At least I could thank you for exposing yourself as such a moron.
I was a legal assistant for several years and worked with several lawyers. To tell you the truth, they were not good with techology. It was me who had to install all their Westlaw and other legal software and troubleshoot all their techno problems. “If you can’t find an e-mail, just sort the columns and look for their name!!!!” Nice people, they should’ve gotten Macs.
Hea”” I have got it”””
Most lawyers are liberals and I got it “LIBERALISM IS A MENTAL DISORDER “
That is way he can’t figure out a Mac
why
The sad thing is that most Windows users barely know how to use Windows give them a system which is even slightly different and they probably haven’t a chance. In terms of people using windows, part of the blame is Microsoft’s, the number of inconsistencies in the system and totally illogical way some things work means that many people will never figure out the shortcuts or functions that are available to them. Unfortunately not all the blame is Microsoft’s, many people expect to start up a computer – a device that can do hundreds, thousands of different things – and they expect it to somehow magically do all these things for them but in such a way that it’s immediately obvious yet not overwhelming.
No matter the system, you have to take some time to learn how to use it, learn what it can do and how to do it. This is even more important if you’re moving from one OS to another since they’re obviously going to work differently, if they were exactly the same then there would be no point anyone developing them or even ever adding new features.
Does this guy think that Vista will work exactly the same as XP? Does he think that all the new features, every single one of them will be clearly labelled and immediately obvious? That any old quirks/bugs that have been fixed will work in the same way? Of course they bloody won’t, you’ll have to learn how to use them.
Hardware failures happen to every company, obviously it should be a manufacturers responsibility to ensure that the parts they use are up to a certain standard, one comparative to the price you are paying, but failures still occur. The Sony battery problems have highlighted this.
If you have more options available to you then of course it will take longer to select the one you want. Of course once you’ve configured something the way you want it helps if you can then save them as a preset to bypass those steps – luckily OSX offers those with printing.
Certainly there are areas where Apple can improve, areas where certain markets are going to prefer windows just because they are unwilling to change practises to do something a different way. Of course they can run windows but most people aren’t going to bother and just stick where they are. To slam Mac like this when it’s clear that no effort has been made to find out about or adapt to the different ways of doing this is just stupid.
Hey sam –
You still have 512MB RAM in your black MacBook? Replace one of the 215MB chips in there with a 1GB stick, and I guarantee you – your spinning wheels will die down.
Understand this: you’re getting wheels because you have too little RAM for all the apps you have open (or all the data you’re operating on), and your hard drive (serving as virtual RAM) is orders of magnitude too slow to keep up.
Good luck.
What a complete twit. He obviously spent more time thinking about things to complain about and then writing about them than he did using the Mac.
This is nothing more than Microsoft sponsored FUD.
This story is 100% BS propaganda FUD…. or the guy is a complete ASS!
Aside from his hardware problems, I suspect that many of his complaints will be common for long time Windows users that switch to OSX. Without realizing it, most of his complaints regarding what OSX can’t do are actually thing he does not know HOW to do. If a long time OSX user migrated to Windows, without having ever used it, the experience would be largely the same. Though, come to think of it, unlike this twit most people would actually assume it COULD be done, but that they just didn’t know how to do it. Anyway, add me to the list of that concur with MDN’s advice to help switchers.
The one complaint that is an Apple problem is the mouse. The might mouse experience for me was not that good. However, there are plenty of great third party mice that are just like their PC counterparts.
AS: “…you should be able to cut and paste on the desktop and in the Finder.”
Not exactly sure what you mean here, but you can copy and paste files and folders (the standard keystrokes for those or else control-click/right-click) in the finder and the desktop. That may have not been what you meant and you may have already known that, but it you didn’t, hope that helps.
Wow.
All this response for a “legal consultant”?
This is too much to read.
So, I just used my Kensington mouse which is connected by USB to my Gateway keyboard which is connected to the back of my G4 Mac mini, and scrolled to the bottom.
Yeah Sam, I agree with the guy above – on Tiger, 512mb definitely isn’t enough. My brother’s mac mini only had the stock 512 till today and it was really slow with a few apps open – because OS X uses about half of that with no programs open. I recommend you either get 2×512 or 2x1gb sticks though because of the intel graphics, it performs better with matched pairs. My brother seems to be happy with the 1 gig of ram he’s got now, it makes the mac a hell of a lot faster.
The mouse thing seems to be a problem for a lot of new users. The thing is-when you plug in a mighty mouse it sets it up as having both sides being ‘primary button’, so that you can’t right click. It’s annoying a lot of people with the new macs we just got for graphics at my school but I just set it to be a 2-button mouse.
What Apple did wrong here
1: Not enough RAM stock in new Mac’s.
2: Large slow boot drives.
3: G5 to hard drive defect of some sort. (G4’s are faster at accessing hard drives than G5’s)
4: After sale followup.
But most all of this guy’s problems is because he is STUPID
Given how inaccurate this acticle is, anyone who subscribes to Law Technology News should cancel their subscription because it clearly doesn’t have a good factchecker or editing staff.
There is a camera store in the upscale town of Highland Park, Texas.
I used to buy all of my cameras from them used.
Why, because they get all of the new Leicas and
Hasselblads the physicians and lawyers return because they
won’t or can’t take the time to learn how to use them.
How many people would think a Ferrari was a POS if they were used to driving a Ford Taurus? I suspect it would be a shockingly high percentage of people.
Sam:
As has been pointed out in other posts, if you are seeing the beachball you need to check your system because there is something wrong. I would suggest running Disk Utility and fixing permissions first. Secondly the compatibility message IS a an MS problem and I believe you can simply disable the warning dialogue and you won’t have to deal with it anymore.
To say the Mac isn’t practical is just foolish since so many others have the same system and seem to get plenty accomplished. The Mac is not about flash… the flash happens to be an unintended consequence of being so well designed both inside and out.
Get your system checked out, take a pill and open your mind a bit.
That man is a moron. Unfortunately, people are going to read that idiot’s drivel and turn away from Macs. If I could figure out how to use one when I was in 7th grade (all by myself- no dummies book) then a Legal consultant sure should be able to. Good riddance.
The first paragraph says it all “Last month, in Law Technology News’ Tech Counsel column, California attorney Ed Siebel sang the praises of running his law office with Apple Inc. computers and peripherals. Today, I’m singing a different tune.”
It’s a calculated hit on Apple, designed to counter last month’s good news story.
What strikes me as very odd about his account is that people working in the law business ( it appears that he isn’t a true lawyer ) are required to pay incredible attention to details, yet on countless occasions he’s completely missed important points and blames Apple for his oversights.
I’ve helped many PC users to switch to Mac and I’m well aware that they all try to operate a Mac as though it were a PC and create all sorts of problems for themselves in the process, but this guy has made more mistakes than all the switchers I’ve known put together.
If he’s for real, I hope for his sake that he’s exaggerating the problems he describes because otherwise he comes across as being rather foolish. If one ‘lawyer’ can miss so many details and to fail to understand so many principles and then tell the world about it as though it was somebody else’s fault, he would be the last person that I would want representing me.
The one thing I identified with in this guy’s article is the issue of delete. Obviously, you can’t delete an open document. What he’s referring to is that in Windows in ANY file open dialog box you can rename, delete, copy, and paste documents. In OSX (as in previous Mac systems) you can’t: you need to switch to the finder, find the file, and command-delete it or drag to the trash.
It’s absolutely useful to have those file management capabilities in ANY file dialog. I don’t know why Apple hasn’t added them, frankly.
A Long-Time Mac Fan and User
“1st thing there is no file/Delete in Word for Windows. By def. in windows you can’t delete files that are open. So either someone wrote a macro for closing and then deleting the file and placed it in his file menu, or he was using Windows Explorer!”
NOPE. He did NOT specify that he was talking about an OPEN file, just deleting files from within an ‘open/save dialog box’ which you CAN do.
Repeat: Opening and/or Saving WHILE Deleting other files can be performed while using Microsoft Word and many, many other Windoze programs…
@kaekae:
no, actually, in Windows, in an open or save dialog box, you can delete or rename files. Just not ones that are open. But what he’s saying is that you can be opening a file, see some other files you want to delete, and delete them right then and there. That is one nice feature of Windows, but it certainly doesn’t make up for all the bad things about Windows. Where this guy shows his stupidity is when he says that all those files had to stay taking up space on his hard drive due to not being able to delete them. First, ummm Finder? Second… yeah, those HUGE Word files…
This guy is a typical person who knows absolutely nothing about computers, just uses the basic software and gets frustrated easily. He probably throws fits at anything and everything that doesn’t go perfect in his life. That, or he’s fake. If he’s real, let him go back to Windows. He doesn’t fit the profile of Mac users being smarter.
OK, so at least two other people beat me to it while I was typing my long-winded reply!
Obviously, you can’t delete an open document.
As I’ve explained above, you can in fact do that and more (put an open document into the trash etc.).
I keep reading about how the Mac invented the key commands, command-X for cut, command-C for copy, command-V for insert, command-P for print, and so forth, and how evil Microsoft copied them from Apple.
Well, Microsoft may or may not be evil, but they didn’t copy them from Apple. Apple and Microsoft both copied them from pre-existing conventions. These same key combinations, plus more, were present in WordStar, a word processor that ran on CP/M back before Apples had lowercase letters and before MS-DOS was a gleam in Bill Gates’ eyes.
The original key combinations were control+letter and included combinations for moving the cursor, because computer keyboards didn’t have arrow keys back then.
The first alternate shift key to appear on a Mac was the Command key. Apple adopted existing conventions but substituted the Command key for the control key, because the control key hadn’t yet been added to Macintosh keyboards.
This lawyer reminds me of this person:
http://www.snopes.com/humor/business/wordperf.htm
A few of the things he mentions are actually fairly legit. PowerPoint files created on a Mac can and do suffer from font incompitbilities when transfered to a PC for presentations which caqn cause the files to SNAFU on screen. This is more of an issue between Microsoft Fonts and Apple Fonts. Most of the other stuff he talks about is more to do with a lack of knowledge of how to optimise workflows. Mostly the writter seems to be suffering from a very serious case of PEBKAC.
Hmm… I would have thought the ‘we only have 2.5 percent of the world pc market’ fact would have been a HUGE clue.
Chas, it’s “well heeled”, as in – good shoes.
This guy really, seriously, doesn’t seem smart at all.
Even iam a Pc User. I can still use Mac Os X 10 Tiger fine ok. I wonder if he never used macs in his lifetime. I used macs in Schools. Playing Oregon Trail and SimmCity sometimes. I just liked Simmcity game. Now i dont play games anymore even on pc i dont play games.
This articles are just stupid. There are people that doesn’t eat chicken you know, or others who don’t drink water. It’s a matter of likes. People with bad taste are there just to make variety… and to give us the chance of writting funny comments. I hope that ‘lawyer’ meets this other one who uses Macs… and be sMACked down.. .just for fun.
He’s not the first to be under the misconception you need to have .Mac to use iCal or Mail.
Face it, some people just aren’t cut out to be Mac users. He’s one of them.
It’s absolutely useful to have those file management capabilities in ANY file dialog. I don’t know why Apple hasn’t added them, frankly.
Possible because deleting and renaming in an “open/save” dialogue box is counterintuitive (like pressing Start to shut down!)
This guy has never used a Mac in his life let alone in a business of any kind. The first two sentences give it away. Can’t read a Word document when Word for OSX and Windows are cross compatible. The web is totally transparent no matter what OS or hardware.
He must think people are as stupid as he is writing this FUD.
Oh and yes you won’t be troubled with viruses and spyware because there isn’t any on the Mac period. But this guy is to stupid to know that obviously.
Why in the world did he buy a PowerMac to run such simple tasks? And WTF about “Mail” and iCal? I don’t have a .mac account and I use those programs fine. And Mail works exactly the same in principle as Outlook.
this guy is an idiot and posting such an article only proves what an idiot he is.
I heard there are some really cool Italian sports cars with little market share.
Oh, and I had a problem once. It was using another name.
Total moron stupid retarded Microsoft Windows Butt monkey Lemming Fan Dork who has been stupified by Microsoft’s Cult of Blind Ignorance.
Please buy a Dell you fucktard dumb ass. Enjoy your cheap plastic mediocre virus and spyware ridden crap pc.
“• Whoever sold him that Power Mac G5 did him more than a bit of a disservice by not anticipating his needs or informing him about the Intel transition. If he bought it himself without asking a Mac savvy person for advice, he made a mistake.”
But hang on from previous MDN comments, anren’t all Macs good for 5 years of life? Why’s this one obsolete?
” So, to make it absolutely clear: all Macs purchased today run Windows. Buying an HP, Dell or other OS-limited PC now makes no sense whatsoever.”
Unless you like saving money, or want some features in your PC that are not available in the Mac world.
“• Mr. Bodine may indeed be “smart,” but he ignorantly seemed to expect a Mac to work like Windows. It doesn’t. He should have actually read his “Dummies” book, it would have helped immensely.”
So now Macs are so hard to use that you have to retrain to use them?
“• Macs, including the Mac he bought, all ship with a multi-button, scroll ball Apple Mighty Mouse. If his didn’t for some reason, he could have easily and inexpensively purchased one or any multi-button USB scroll wheel mouse and it would work just fine with Mac OS X.”
Why Why Why not standard?
“• That a Mac such as his was “slow” and “hanging up” is a warning sign that something was wrong. That Mac should have been blazingly fast for the basic tasks he describes. That he used so much Microsoft software is also a warning sign and could be a contributor to those issues.”
Sure, find a way to blame Microsoft for his woes.
“• When he talks about “Finder” he is really talking about Spotlight. It sounds like he didn’t take 5 minutes to learn how to use it properly.”
gain, thet need to learn rather than thingsa just being intuitive.
“• Microsoft makes Word for Mac, not Apple. If you don’t like something about it, that’s a Microsoft complaint, not an Apple Mac complaint.”
The complaint was that it’s not compatible with the PC therefore the myth of easy PC interoperability.
“• To delete a file or files on a Mac, select the file(s) in the Finder and hit Command-Delete to move them quickly into the Trash for quick deleting.”
That’s so obvious, why couldn’t the guy just guess that.
“• Microsoft makes PowerPoint for Mac, not Apple. If you don’t like something about it, that’s a Microsoft complaint, not an Apple Mac complaint.”
The complaint was that it’s not compatible with the PC therefore the myth of easy PC interoperability.
“• Apple’s Keynote presentation program makes better presentations than PowerPoint, by the way.”
Which are likewise incompatible with the PC.
“• You can do things as quickly or more quickly with a Mac than with a PC, but the Mac won’t magically remove your bad Windows habits and explain the proper way to do things. He should have used his Mac’s built-in help system, read his “Dummies” book, and asked a Mac user for some help.”
So Mac is so great and easy to use, and his problem is “bad windows habits” Give me a break. 95% of the world has “Bad Windows Habits” How can Apple expect to get any market share if Mac OS X is so foriegn that they all need to retrain to use it.
“• To make a new print setting with a Mac, save a preset in the Print dialog box with your desired settings. Choose that preset to quickly print however you’d like.”
And that’s intuitive and simpler than Windows’s way?
“• iCal or Mail do not require a .Mac account. It’s too bad he didn’t try the applications.”
Perhaps he wanted “Real” mail and calendaring apps.
“• Third-party software complaints are for the companies making the software, not Apple. Oftentimes, the features Windows users want within Mac versions of software are there, they just can’t seem to shed their Windows ideas of how to accomplish them and/or explore the Mac program’s features.”
They guy’s comment is more about how his Mac as a whole is deficient, so the MDN position is that the basic OS is great, but if all the apps suck and the guy can;t get anything done, that’s not an Apple problem. Perhaps not, but it is a problem for Apple.
“• If you short-sightedly limit your Web sites by developing only for Microsoft IE, it is not Apple’s or any other browser’s fault that you “can’t operate your own Web sites with the Mac.” “
Again MDN wishing the world were one way when in fact it’s another.
“• Hard drives fail. Even in Macs. Backup regularly. Apple did replace it for free.”
Wow, replaced it for free under warranty. How when Apple use the superior high quality hard drives did this “normal” one slip into this guy’s computer. MDN should look into that.
“• Mr. Bodine should not be recommending people don’t buy Macs. He knows very little about how to use a Mac.”
But apparently he knows lots about the switching experience, and that’s what he’s giving advice on.
“• Some Windows users have a huge mountain overcome when it comes to shedding bad habits and learning how to use a Mac properly.”
Again, c’mon. It’s Microsoft’s Fault that this guy can’t easily transdfer his skills to a Mac? Bad Windows Habits?
“Hopefully Apple and all of us who are so inclined can help new Mac users to acclimate better.”
Sure by calling them dumb whan they can’t easily trasfer their skills to the platform, and suggesting that they call up lots of software manufacturers to get software as good a Windows.
“• Mr. Bodine should sell that Power Mac and get himself a MacBook or MacBook Pro. He should install Windows for applications he needs and take the time to learn about the Mac while still accomplishing his work. Over time, he would realize that the Mac is a far superior personal computer.”
Sounds like he’s given it the time and knows which platform is better for him.
I vote this is FUD
@sam…
re the compatibility test issue with Word. It actually is an issue with MS, and was fixed with a recent update. I used to have the same issue on my macs until I ran Microsoft AutoUpdate.
You can find the download here
http://www.microsoft.com/mac/downloads.aspx?pid=download&location;=/mac/download/office2004/mau.xml&secid=4&ssid=11&flgnosysreq=True
Also.. the post above about needing more ram is correct…. I suggest you purchase from Memorytogo.com… cheapest on the net and a lifetime guarantee.
Hope this helps.
MDN word is issue… as in Sam’s issue is solved if he will listen and learn.
“Notice there’s not ONE word about the Mac not getting infested with viruses, not crashing, or not needing an OS reinstall.”
Except the words where he said it was slow and would hang.
“He bought a $4,552.71 machine to surf the internet and do accounting. The dude is retarded.”
Wow, customers who want to spend the money on the high end of the product line are retards? Perhaps Apple should advertise that in a Mac vs PC advert.
“Change is never always good, but it is necessary. Patience is a must for everyone involved. This fellow just didn’t have enough of it. His experience is not typical or even common,”
Yet you have a friend who struggles in the same way, what does that tell you?
“And who the heck buys a $4,000 system to use Word?! He deserves not got understand Mac. “
What, People keep making BMW analogies, then big suprise, the lawyer buys the most expensive BMW, and that’s the reason it shouldn’t have worked for him? Give me a break.
“To slam Mac like this when it’s clear that no effort has been made to find out about or adapt to the different ways of doing this is just stupid.”
Not really, if I broght a car tomorrow and the accelerator and brake were reveresed, I’d wonder why that company had done things in a dumb, different, incompatible way.
“But most all of this guy’s problems is because he is STUPID”
Macs are so easy to use that anyone can use them, except STUPID people who somehow made it through law school?
“As has been pointed out in other posts, if you are seeing the beachball you need to check your system because there is something wrong.”
But you forget, according to the propaganda, nothing every goes wrong with Mac OS X, what’s to check?
“This guy is a typical person who knows absolutely nothing about computers, just uses the basic software and gets frustrated easily. He probably throws fits at anything and everything that doesn’t go perfect in his life. That, or he’s fake. If he’s real, let him go back to Windows. He doesn’t fit the profile of Mac users being smarter.”
Wow, now Macs aren’t easier to use, they can only be successfully used by those who are smarter?
This person is a loser. I don’t even believe it’s real. This person had to be paid to say something so stupid.
Fock off, loser fig.
Ha ha ! What a fucking moron ! He must be joking ?! Anyone checked out his “website”- crapiola !!
I know there are a lot of good lawyers out there, but…
One day I was in a convenience store when a guy who had pumped some gas walked in and asked where the bathroom was. He was told the store didn’t have a public toilet. He informed everyone in a loud voice that state law required they have one, and he should know, he had just graduated the bar, and might file a lawsuit against the chain.
A guy in line who worked for the cable company told him that was just if they sold food for consumption on the premise.
An education can make a person more enlightened, but there are no guarantees…and no substitutes for common sense and common courtesy
“A guy in line who worked for the cable company told him that was just if they sold food for consumption on the premise.”
So now you take your legal advice from Larry the Cable Guy?
Good luck with that…
I see the argument now, Macs are not hard to use, just everybody who can’t use one is a moron.
Imagine if he were complaining about his PC, to MDN the poor beleaguered user would be a victim of Microsoft.
“I heard there are some really cool Italian sports cars with little market share.”
Most of them a finicky, expensive, are harder to drive well, and require an adaption to strange ideas on ergonomics.
Good analogy.
Well if I ever need a lawyer, I am definitely NOT calling him! If he can’t run a mac I’m sure he can’t win a case. I surprised he can even show up on time in court, of course that’s the judges fault, and his staff’s fault, the secretary didn’t remind him he was due in court.
And as usual, he must be an American school graduate–so proud of being stupid that he actually brags about it and let’s the whole world know how stupid he is–bin laden must laughing his ass off about now
This imbecile isn’t worthy of a Mac. He deserves an HP or Dell with Vista.
Geez,
I can’t believe you people don’t do more “due diligence.” Check out:
http://maclaw.org/macworldsf2000.htm
A “God” slighted will stoop to nothing to get even. An A hole? You bet, what else would you expect of a lawyer?
This guy probably paid someone to take the bar for him.
My fiancée DEMONSTRATED deleting in Word
“NOPE. He did NOT specify that he was talking about an OPEN file, just deleting files from within an ‘open/save dialog box’ which you CAN do.”
IMO just another example of how the Windows GUI is all over the place. In windows dialog boxes can do all sorts of stuff that bear no correlation to the menu item you select to open them. You’ll also find that sometimes a dialog will open and you can start typing immediately into it, and other times you can’t. Microsoft’s programmers need to be forced to read some GUI standards.
Backward: I see the argument now, Macs are not hard to use, just everybody who can’t use one is a moron.
No Macs are not “hard to use”, as millions of users can attest.
It is very rare that people are so completely blocked by their inability to even find out that things work in a simpler way than they’re used to.
Unless this piece is indeed paid-for FUD, this guy should simply have relaxed, taken a few minutes to read the documentation (where he actually had a problem) and in the case of still persisting problems he should have checked for online Mac forums.
All his problems would have been resolved with a bit of support, which he could even have gotten for free if he wanted.
Instead he insisted that things absolutely had to work the way he expected them to instead of making even the smallest effort to find out how they’re actually working…
He shot himself into his own foot, repeatedly and now complains that the shoe manufacturer was at fault for it…
Some people just want to be in pain and don’t want to be helped…!
the guy should stick to a pc. i think this guy has in fact one of the worst records for success in the country.
i believe ive heard his name come up before in regard to having had more people sent to death row than anyone else.
ill check back with that.
basically if you couldn’t tell from his busls*it article the guy isnt that smart.
“If he can’t run a mac I’m sure he can’t win a case.”
So now your assertion is that the same set of skills you need to run a Mac are the same set of skills you need to win a case in court. I wonder how lawyers ever won cases before Macs (or PCs) came along.
So in your view the best kind of lawyer is a Cable Guy who can use a Mac. Interesting.
“This imbecile isn’t worthy of a Mac.”
Or the Mac’s not ready for prime time. one of the two. Perhaps no PC user is worthy of a Mac, so they self select into the only platform easy enough for them to use.
Or the Mac’s not ready for prime time.
There are reasons to doubt that it was actually a real experience report, and all his “problems” were in fact not real – he just chose to not resolve them, even where it would have been very simple.
He must be retarded…
Here’s one to refer him to:
http://www.themaclawyer.com/the_mac_lawyer/2006/09/index.html
For anyone defending this idiot..
The guy is reterded. His website, aside from being an ugly mess as you’d expect with his love of Explorer, doesn’t even work at the most basic level. As an example, try and subscribe to his Newsletter, and you get a “Page Not Found”
Crass…clearly part of an underclass that deserve to be made to stay in Windows hell for eternity..!
I endured quite a few Windows pc’s and when the last on died I thought I’d take a chance and get a Mac. I’m sure I don’t have the bucks to throw around like this guy, so I actually did some research into Mac BEFORE I plunked down my hard earned cash! I bought the Mac Mini and now would have nothing but a Mac. I’m sure no whiz on computers, but I had no trouble getting used to it. As a matter of fact, I think when my wife’s Dell craps out we will be getting another Mini,,, it just works, so I don’t have to be a lawyer to use it!!
Smells fishy. No one could be this dumb. A plant by MS or Dell or HP or some other PC industry force that sees the writing on the wall. Lawyers in general have no problem letting the truth get in the way. Here is what may also be going on. This guy is a PC troll from way back. You know the loser type that thinks Apple “copied” Windows 1.0. An opportunity arrises…write this clump of defecation of an article and hope MS sees it, and wants to do business with him. We all know there is a honeymoon with companies that experience a boom. This toilet bowl muffin figures maybe he can get into this early and make a few bucks.
Small potatos.
In the end he will most likely be reguarded as a dork who couldn’t read directions.
Uhh…sorry, meant to say that after the “honeymoon” & “boom” there is a backlash. Led by the media to water and nurture hate. To make money. This loser wants to cash in from MS as they try to convince the public that Macs are terrible in the end.
“There are reasons to doubt that it was actually a real experience report, and all his “problems” were in fact not real – he just chose to not resolve them, even where it would have been very simple.”
Not sure what you’re saying.
That this guy’s experience was not real, but that his problems were and the solutions to them are simple?
“don’t have the bucks to throw around like this guy, so I actually did some research into Mac BEFORE I plunked down my hard earned cash!”
So your contention is that if he’d done the research first, he wouldn’t have ended up with a problematic Mac and that consumers need to know which Mac models are good to buy and which are bad?
“The guy is reterded. His website, aside from being an ugly mess as you’d expect with his love of Explorer, doesn’t even work at the most basic level.”
It works fine on Windows. You just have a compatibility problem with your Mac. Are you trying to make this guy’s point for him?
“This loser wants to cash in from MS as they try to convince the public that Macs are terrible in the end.”
or he’s a consumer who’s had a bad experience and wants to save other people the anguis of repeating his mistake.
a) It sounds fake. Hard to believe somebody could actually be so incompetent – and so unwilling to solve any difficulties.
b) The alleged “product defects” have nothing to do with the respective product.
c) All his alleged problems would have been easily resolved.
And this guy is a “web & marketing consultant” — that’s rich. Really, really rich!
He must have gone to the Mr Hinky School of Poo – graduated with di-stink-shun…
FOOL!
What an imbecile. This guy needs a bullet. I think that says it all, really.
As for the deleting in the file open/save dialog box, what I was responding to was him saying “There is no File | Delete option” in Word for Mac. There is no file/delete in Office for Windows. yes you can delete from the Open/save dialog box (which I do often), but it isn’t File/Delete. I am very literal when it comes to computer commands.
Oh and if anyone wonders, in Windows you can’t delete (or move) open files. The ability to delete open files in Mac is great – I often will download several files to read once, after open them all, I delete them and after I am finished reading them, I can either empty the trash or undelete files I want to keep. It just makes my life a little easier.
I wonder why this self-proclaimed “smart” guy never tried using the “help” menu, which is right there at the top of the display, all the time?
One thing’s for damn sure: if I ever need a lawyer, I’m not going to hire one who can’t even figure out how to take a screen shot on a Mac.
A wise man once said: “you can make a system foolproof, but you can’t make it damn fool proof.”
-jcr
I AM A MORON
Here’s an idea…
At the Apple store, if you’re a firsttime Mac buyer, (I don’t know how you’d prove it), they could give you a copy of one of the “missing manual” books for the current version of the Mac OS, for free with the purchase of a new Mac.
They’d only be giving them away to “first time” buyers, and only with the purchase of a new Mac. It would hardly lose money. And it would greatly help the people who have literally never touched a mac before.
Bugs Bunny would have called him a maroon.
What’s a maroon?
http://www.randomhouse.com/wotd/index.pperl?date=19970731
What an ultra maroon:
http://www.the-ocean.com/looney/sounds/embesal.wav
Lost Ballmer voicemail to Jobs on Vista:
http://www.the-ocean.com/looney/sounds/doom.wav
A kornukope . . .a cornyoukopi . . . a cornukopi . . . a whole bunch
http://www.the-ocean.com/looney/looney.html
Smart ass
You must be the guy this article is about, which, in that case, yes, I would prefer to have Larry the Cable Guy on retainer. At least he has a sense of humor compared to some who have no sense at all….
RE: “”A guy in line who worked for the cable company told him that was just if they sold food for consumption on the premise.”
So now you take your legal advice from Larry the Cable Guy?
Good luck with that.”
Well, apparently the cable guy knew more about that particular aspect of law, so…………maybe it pays for some of you to learn to do research and think for yourself once in a while.
I am just finishing getting my public school teaching certificate now, after 30 years in the real world, in another profession The new young college grads who I compete with for jobs have nothing to relate their “education” to, since they have no life experience, and they can’t compete with our “old guy” experience added to the “book larnin.” Sorry. (No, I’m not)
That’s probably the case of this particular lawyer. When he has a few years experience, he won’t need a mid-level secretary to guide him around so he can do the basic job functions.
Yhanx to all those who have bashed me for my comments, some of them were actually insightful. SO, compatibilty is a MS problem, BUT I DO HAVE 1gb RAM and I still see the spinning wheel. Look, if I wasnt interested in learning abt Apple I wont have got the Macbook, but I guess I expected too much. And I like the computer for some stuff that looks really cool (like Pages) but for my everyday thing, its a lot of work using the Mac. I’ll another example. when I’m on the internet, I open up ALOT of pages that interest me, so that Idont keep hitting the back button and opening another article. Thedesktop gets soooooooooo cloged up its a hassle searching for what I want. Enter F9, F10 or F11 right? Cool, btu the idea that I have to have one hand draped over any of these buttons everytime I’m done readign a page isnt too comfortable (so shud I replace my table now). Fine! I’v been using Windows all my life and all the pages just line up right in the task bar and I can SO easily find what i’m lookign for. With the Mac, its some work.
As I’v said before, I like the Mac, but maybe I expected it to be as smooth a transition as possible. Thats hasnt been as I expected. Would certainly appreciate the insightful thots again , as I’m still deciding whether to trade it (convince me otherwise)
SO, compatibilty is a MS problem
And again a resolvable one, from the comments above.
BUT I DO HAVE 1gb RAM and I still see the spinning wheel.
That’s not actually all that much nowadays, especially when you’re running multiple larger applications with many windows at the same time.
Memory Monitor is an excellent utility which helps you monitor memory usage and – even more importantly – swapping activity. If it often shows major swapping activity (and especially if that turns out to be the source of your particular beachball problems), you simply need more RAM. Memory Monitor shows no swapping while the beachball is shown, it’s the application’s fault. Is it only in a specific application that it shows up?
The “beachball” tells you that the application the mouse cursor is above right now hasn’t responded to the system event manager for at least several seconds.
That can happen either due to massive swapping (the respective application is held up while that’s going on, hence more RAM can help) or because the application user interface is badly designed (for instance function execution holding up further event processing).
The “beachball” is nothing magical – it just means event handling in the app the mouse points to has been held up. And except for “swapping orgies” (which usually affect all applications equally), you can always still move the mouse curser elsewhere and you’ll see that the other applications are still responsive.
Look, if I wasnt interested in learning abt Apple I wont have got the Macbook, but I guess I expected too much. And I like the computer for some stuff that looks really cool (like Pages) but for my everyday thing, its a lot of work using the Mac.
Don’t worry – it just takes a bit of getting used to and finding the ways to do what you want to do. In most cases that’s actually easier than you may be used to.
I’ll another example. when I’m on the internet, I open up ALOT of pages that interest me, so that Idont keep hitting the back button and opening another article. Thedesktop gets soooooooooo cloged up its a hassle searching for what I want. Enter F9, F10 or F11 right? Cool, btu the idea that I have to have one hand draped over any of these buttons everytime I’m done readign a page isnt too comfortable (so shud I replace my table now). Fine! I’v been using Windows all my life and all the pages just line up right in the task bar and I can SO easily find what i’m lookign for. With the Mac, its some work.
I’m not sure I understand your problem here…
You can find all the open windows of an application simply by right-clicking on that application – and the full names will be displayed, not the cut-up mess as in Windows’ task bar; It will also not jumble together all open windows but each application has its own window list.
It’s neater and lets you do the exact same thing.
Plus, there’s Exposé: “Show all application windows” would be wat you’d need in this case.
Also, if you’re keyboard-minded, Witch is an excellent tool which lets you navigate either all windows or the windows of the front app just like CMD-TAB navigate entire applications.
Finally, you can simply click open a new link in a new tab in the same Safari window without having to open a new window at all by simply holding a modifier key when clicking.
So in short, you have more and better possibilities to deal with multiple windows than under Windows, you just need to know them a bit…!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
As I’v said before, I like the Mac, but maybe I expected it to be as smooth a transition as possible. Thats hasnt been as I expected.
I think you’ve gone into it with a bit too much of the expectation of everything “being like Windows” – and that is not the case. It is not like Windows in many, many respects, and in most cases (with the one exception of the missing all-borders-resize) it’s good that it’s not!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
Another utility I highly recommend is MenuMeters – it lets you keep an eye on what’s going on in your Mac, including harddisk activity indicators, graphical network and CPU activity monitoring and more.
Would certainly appreciate the insightful thots again , as I’m still deciding whether to trade it (convince me otherwise)
Don’t be discouraged so easily – there is yet much to be discovered, and you’ve already paid for but not really used many of the best things there…!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
Thanks, To Ampar! That was funny!
Being a web developer, the web thing gets to me the most. If he couldn’t see his pages on a mac or on firefox, then neither can anyone else.
Sam
are you using tabs (you’re using Safari or Firefox I assume)? This allows you to open many web pages in one window instead of many many windows. You can just click between tabs to view your pages.
In Safari, go to the Safari menu and preferences. Click on the tabs button at the top and choose “Enable Tabbed Browsing”. If you’re coming from Windows and used to using Internet Exploder, I can see how this would be frustrating.
Usually with the Mac, there is a simpler, easier way of doing things.
My wife switched a couple of years ago and hasn’t looked back. She loves her Macbook (we maxed it out to 2gb of RAM and she almost never gets the spinning wheel).
There are some very nice things about the Windows print dialog, wouldn’t mind if Apple would copy some of those things.
Other than that, this guy is a Dee Dee Dee.
It is NOT true that you can’t delete a document from the FILE menu in Microsoft Word for the Mac.
You can. Here it is directly from the Word Help bar:
“Delete one or more versions of a document
1. On the File menu, click Versions.
2. Click the version of the document you want to delete.
To select more than one version, hold down z as you click each versio3. Click Delete.”
It is not Apple’s fault that Microsoft buried it under “File/Versions” but there it is, right in the File menu. I wonder where Microsoft put that option in their Windows version of Word.
Yes, it only applies to other versions of the document you presently have open, but isn’t that the only instance in which it would make sense to be deleting documents from inside MS Word?
He’s got a new post about reactions about his original post at
http://pm.typepad.com/professional_marketing_bl/
I posted a comment there, but doubt he’ll post it, it being moderated by him (the comments section).
What I wrote in his comments is that he has no idea how foolish he looks by publishing his noob problems with OS X with such a ‘blame the OS not me’ attitude.
His style of writing (which reflects his maturity and computing skills) is what sinks him.
Everyone has difficultys in learning a new OS, but my god use a little google, apple help, forums etc to figure out these things.
“Well, apparently the cable guy knew more about that particular aspect of law,”
Did you actually verify that, or take what the cable guy said as true because you didn’t like the lawyer? Can you point to the relevant statute?
“so…………maybe it pays for some of you to learn to do research and think for yourself once in a while. “
And on that note, seems like this guy had legitimate gripes, perhaps, according to people posting here, they would have been resolved if he had an expert Mac user looking over his shoulder to guide him and troubleshoot his system, but it seems like his main point is that Macs don’t just work, and the switch isn’t necessarily easy.
The fact is he couldn’t just turn his PC off one day and be productive with the Mac the next, and that his mac had problems.
Most people here seem to think that makes him a moron and that it’s his fault. Now that may well be true, but it doesn’t change the facts for Apple. The world is full of people for whom knowledge of every aspect of their OS is not a priority. They just want to get their job done. They expect the interface to be intuitive. Most of them don’t like reading manuals to find that command-delete will delete a file or that hitting command-control-shift-3 will do the same as the button clearly labelled “print screen” on the PC keyboard.
Most people learn an interface by exploring it, not by reading manuals. magical hidden features are great as shortcuts, but shouldn’t be the only way to achieve something. The day you make it a requirement that you need a manual or online help to make basic use of a PC or Mac, you’ve lost the battle.
“Most people learn an interface by exploring it, not by reading manuals. magical hidden features are great as shortcuts, but shouldn’t be the only way to achieve something. The day you make it a requirement that you need a manual or online help to make basic use of a PC or Mac, you’ve lost the battle.”
Debatable.
But in this case, the time it takes for the dude to publish his anti OS X article, he coulda taken even less efort and time to find out the way to do the things he had “problems” with.
And on that note, seems like this guy had legitimate gripes,
No, he did not. Assuming that it wasn’t just fabrication to be used as marketing FUD, let’s go on:
perhaps, according to people posting here, they would have been resolved if he had an expert Mac user looking over his shoulder
Absolutely not. He could have resolved all his problems easily with a bare minimum of initiative, instead of apparently being completely focused on proving to himself and to the world “proof” that he wasn’t capable of using a system which little old ladies and tiny children have no problem getting into.
to guide him and troubleshoot his system,
His system was in perfect working order, apart from a harddisk which would have failed exactly the same whatever system it would have been mounted in.
but it seems like his main point is that Macs don’t just work, and the switch isn’t necessarily easy.
It is obvious that his entire piece and apparently the acquisition of the system itself was nothing but an attempt to make that point, regardless of the fact that he is pretty much alone in this – no legions of disgruntled Mac users to back up his claims.
The fact is he couldn’t just turn his PC off one day and be productive with the Mac the next, and that his mac had problems.
Wrong. He (or should I say you?) had the problem – not the machine!
Most people here seem to think that makes him a moron and that it’s his fault.
Pretty much actively preventing any difficulties to be resolved would make him a moron – or possibly a paid shill for an increasingly desperate Microsoft, as suspected above.
Now that may well be true, but it doesn’t change the facts for Apple.
Indeed it doesn’t – Apple is clearly on the right track; The relatively few actually apparent areas for improvement weren’t even touched upon in the article.
The world is full of people for whom knowledge of every aspect of their OS is not a priority. They just want to get their job done. They expect the interface to be intuitive.
And people like that use Macs by the millions – with substantially greater ease than their Windows-afflicted and usually frustrated counterparts do.
Most of them don’t like reading manuals to find that command-delete will delete a file or that hitting command-control-shift-3 will do the same as the button clearly labelled “print screen” on the PC keyboard.
CMD-Delete is only a shortcut – which happens to be blatantly obvious when you’ve selected a file, very obviously opened the “File” menu and looked at the entry “put into Trash”. The shortcut is visible right next to it in the menu. You can also – even more obviously – simply drag the file to the trash basket.
If you’re incapable of finding obvious stuff like that, you should not operate technical machinery and maybe should consider joining the amish people. You’d probably need some other capabilities and especially a bit more diligence in that case, however.
As for screenshots, simply type “screenshot” in the Apple help window and press return. See above.
Most people learn an interface by exploring it, not by reading manuals.
That’s why people generally have a much easier time using a Mac – unless they’re clinging to the exact way they had to do things under Windows, that is.
MacOS is MacOS and not Windows. After grasping this particularly obvious fact, pretty much everybody does just fine, with or without a bit of help and with extremely rare exceptions.
magical hidden features are great as shortcuts, but shouldn’t be the only way to achieve something.
There’s nothing magical about typing the name of a requested feature into the help window. Or looking next to the menu entry you’re pointing to with the mouse. If that is beyond your intellectual capacity, you might not want to look for a job which requires anything beyond making an “X” for your signature.
He’s posted a reply on his blog. “These Mac zealots are unusually defensive. They are just realizing that they have bought orphan technology. Macs are the Betamax of the 21st Century.”
He’s posted a reply on his blog. “These Mac zealots are unusually defensive. They are just realizing that they have bought orphan technology. Macs are the Betamax of the 21st Century.”
Yeah. Great comparison – when the “winning” VHS format is just about now headed for the museum!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
The classic MacOS may have been like betamax in some ways (better in several respects, lower market share, mainly used by professionals up to this day), but MacOS X is clearly giving Windows a run for it’s money – quite similar to the beginning of the digital video wave.
Some metaphors cut both ways…!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
That article sounds made up.
Quote from ping:
“Most of them don’t like reading manuals to find that command-delete will delete a file or that hitting command-control-shift-3 will do the same as the button clearly labelled “print screen” on the PC keyboard.”
Nice try, but “Print Scrn” is a terrible argument for you to propose. It is not as simple as pressing the “Print Scrn” key. It requires a great deal of non-intuitive work (which, when this behaviour bit me in the early days of Windows 2000, was very difficult to resolve).
According to an internet article:
“This is what you have to do:
To make Print Screen work, you must save an image of what’s displayed on-screen to the clipboard and then paste it into a document where it can be printed.
Windows Help: Print Screen
To do this, follow this procedure:
1. Maximize the window you’d like to capture.
2. To copy/capture the current window, hold down ALT + Print Scrn at the same time. To capture the entire screen, just press Print Scrn.
3. Open a new document in MS Word, MS Photo Editor, or Adobe PhotoShop.
4. Paste the screen shot by holding down CTRL and V at the same time.
5. Print the document when you’re finished pasting screen shots.”
I don’t see any of those instructions on the “Print Scrn” key. You’re not even 1/4 of the way there when you have pressed the “Print Scrn” key. With a Mac, command-shift-4 (or related command) and you’re all done.
Macintosh. It just works.
Quote from ping:
Actually, I was merely quoting from “Smart”‘s previous post… my own debunking followed right below.
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
You’re quite right regarding your own response, of course.
Clearly if he was getting all those viruses on his PC, he can’t even load and operate anti-virus software. So, we conclude, he can’t work a PC either! He’s simply not qualified to comment!
This guy was not willing to make the switch. All of these things are sometimes problems when going fro PC to PC. The other things he was just ignorant about.
Poor lawyer. If he isn’t able to work with a Mac, how is he going to work with Windows Vista? He is lost…
“Wrong. He (or should I say you?) had the problem – not the machine!”
Again, blaming the user for the machine’s shortcomings. That’s a great way to convince people to get Macs.
What’s your position, Macs are easy to use, but when you can’t use it or it doesn’t work, it must be because you’re stupid? That goes directly against the common Mac user argument that macs are so simple that anyone can immediately use them.
Now we’re saying that you have to be prepared to read manuals, understand that what you learned on Windows cannot be directly applied and that you must learn the new platform. Ok, Fine. But that’s not Apple’s message.
Their message is that you shut your PC down one day, turn your Mac on the next and you’re good to go.
“And people like that use Macs by the millions – with substantially greater ease than their Windows-afflicted and usually frustrated counterparts do.”
Can you back up that assertion on “Ease” or is that just your subjective opinion.
“MacOS is MacOS and not Windows. After grasping this particularly obvious fact, pretty much everybody does just fine, with or without a bit of help and with extremely rare exceptions.”
So you accept that they’re different and magically your brain is filled with the knowledge of all differences? That’s amazing technology. I can see now why some people would say that using a Mac is a religious experience, like being in a cult.
Smart: “Again, blaming the user for the machine’s shortcomings. That’s a great way to convince people to get Macs.”
The main issue is in the apparent unwillingness to even try in earnest, but still deriving all-encompassing conclusions from a trial which was never seriously conducted.
That is your problem here and that is what undermines your credibility and the legitimacy of the article. (Still operating under the assumption that you’re the author.)
What’s your position, Macs are easy to use, but when you can’t use it or it doesn’t work, it must be because you’re stupid? That goes directly against the common Mac user argument that macs are so simple that anyone can immediately use them.
That is indeed the experience – “stupidity” doesn’t really enter into the equation; Apart from relatively few weirdnesses and quirks (especially few relative to Windows), people of all ages, backgrounds and educations have found it easy and even enjoyable to switch to a Mac (or use a Mac as the first computer).
Your problem seems to be that you didn’t even try to resolve the issues which you encountered.
Which is merely unfortunate for you personally, but it completely invalidates any attempt of a proper journalistic presentation of the platform as such.
Frustration can always occur, the question is just whether one attempts to overcome (minor) obstacles by looking in a few obvious places (as explained above) – or not.
Now we’re saying that you have to be prepared to read manuals, understand that what you learned on Windows cannot be directly applied and that you must learn the new platform. Ok, Fine. But that’s not Apple’s message.
A little straightforward experimentation or a look into the documentation would have resolved most of the issues right away.
Most people simply try the obvious – and under MacOS X, the obvious approach actually works as expected in most cases! Under Windows it just doesn’t – you need to learn that it will almost never work as expected, and this negative expectation taints everything thereafter. That is one of the main problems Windows users encounter when they switch – they have stopped even trying the obvious and the logical. “It just can’t be that simple!” seems to be the sentiment – but in fact, it can!
Their message is that you shut your PC down one day, turn your Mac on the next and you’re good to go.
That would be irresponsible, and neither Apple nor most Mac users don’t claim such a thing.
You’re immediately ready to go to start using the new Mac, that much is correct; But it takes a few days and some getting used to until it all starts making real sense to you – and after that point, it’s all getting easier and easier.
Can you back up that assertion on “Ease” or is that just your subjective opinion.
The clear majority of people who have some actual experience with both platforms choose to use the Mac for themselves. You learn to use a PC because you must, but you usually choose a Mac for yourself.
So you accept that they’re different and magically your brain is filled with the knowledge of all differences? That’s amazing technology. I can see now why some people would say that using a Mac is a religious experience, like being in a cult.
No magic present or required – just rather decent design in both hard- and software with a consistent concept throughout (well, to a large degree, not exactly 100%).
What makes many people “fans” of the Mac is their own experience that their Mac simply gets hardly in their way and is a pleasant and well-crafted tool to do what they want to do. Especially opposite the constant – if often low-key – aggravation when working under Windows.
It’s not an experience as if your brain was forcibly extracted – it’s much more the experience that things just work most of the time. And after a while, you simply stop expecting the computer to be your adversary.
The Mac is designed to act as your assistant, not as your drill sargeant!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
wow. you have to be some special kind of stupid to not be able to figure out a Mac. the Windoze fanboys i know of think of Macs as “PCs for idiots.”
so this guy must be the Grand High Poo-bah of Idiots.
so this guy must be the Grand High Poo-bah of Idiots.
Well, not necessarily; Could be all kinds of things – including the frustration of having painfully learned “how computers work” and now realizing that he just knew how Windows works, and that it’s not even necessary to make all the detours and pointless voodoo to get stuff done.
Not getting the hang of things right away may have had a lot to do with simple misguided expectations, but with the apparently “simplest system there is” it might feel particularly embarrassing at first. Embarrassment and scorn are close neighbours, so there you go…!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
But even in that case this feeling vanishes after that first wall out of the ditch has been climbed…
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
“I even called Apple headquarters and asked when a better version would be available and was told that Apple is in no hurry to improve it.”
This is a lie, a bald-faced lie. A number of things in the article were suspicious, but this one takes the cake. Isn’t it obvious that this guy is just a complete liar? Apple ought to sue that ‘lawyer’ for libel.
First, what in the world is ‘Apple headquarters’? The main campus is in Cupertino, California, but individual customers can’t just call up an Apple Vice President or something. You can call AppleCare with problems, but AppleCare isn’t Apple headquarters (you’re usually calling Texas, actually). Second, Apple is notoriously secretive and tight-lipped about future product plans. Indeed, it doesn’t even inform its own employees of those plans; most of them are on a need-to-know basis. An AppleCare phone representative is not going to know anything at all and is almost certainly under strict orders not to talk about future product plans. Any employee who reveals confidential information to some idiot ‘lawyer’ would be immediately fired. Finally, if the Mac rumor sites are to be believed, Apple has already made improvements in Safari for Leopard.
In conclusion: liar, liar, pants on fire.
I rather liked MDN’s professional approach in it’s take. I wish more of them were like that. I wonder if the poor rube was a lawyer and able to defend himself contributed to it?….
Somehow, I doubt this guy is getting a pile of hate e-mail like the college newspaper writer, Enderle, etc….
Some Windows users have a huge mountain overcome when it comes to shedding bad habits and learning how to use a Mac properly.
It’s one thing to say that Mac OS X and Windows work differently and that there’s a learning curve to migrate from one to the other (in either direction).
It’s another thing to say that the conventions of use for Windows amount to “bad habits”. They’re not bad habits, they’re different habits.
It’s terminology like this that makes the Windows user feel looked down upon and less willing to adapt.
This is the stupiest thing I heard today.
Another reasons why I got an apple is b/c of message boards like this. when there’s a problem with a mac, you’re not the only one experiencing it, and there’s usually a lot of support for or against the fact by avid “mac-ers”, and thus there’s a bigger voice that apple can listen to and respond according. there’s no such thing for any other computer manufacturer (at least, none that i know of), so i’v got to thank this mac-following.
scottland,
thanx for the insight on tabbed browsing, make life so much easier now for me. neater desktop.
ping,
thanx for the words of encouragement. the mac isnt a bad computer afterall, its just that there’s so much to learn and get used to again, which i havent had much time for. skul works huge.
thats not the last of my problems with the mac, but as they surface, I’ll seek help with it first b4 i toss it, and like ping noted, i bought it already. i’ll stick it out and see where it gets me. maybe i’l bash some else in the future for thikin the mac is a shit computer.
I know you’re not suppose to mention other sites while responding to something in another site, but I’m a MacNut and only Job’s words are holy. “^)
Please sent lawyer to
http://www.macsimumnews.com/ and do a little searching.
They seem to be working very hard at helping the Win/Mac transfer for professionals. Dentists, doctors, accountants, newspaper people, dog catchers and all of the rest. They may get paid by software companies and such, but they do lay things out in 1., 2., 3., 4., steps on how to leave the evil side, I’ve been very impressed. Bet even a lawyer could do it, if he didn’t charge himself the going rate.
Hyper
maybe i’l bash some else in the future for thikin the mac is a shit computer.
That’s not actually necessary… just keep at it, and ask if necessary!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
I’d be the first person to say that Bodine is right on a few of those factors. Apple should have never made claims about TextEdit being MS Word compatible and the little Safari’s Debug -> User Agent -> Windows MSIE 6.0 menu command still doesn’t show those funky proprietary Microsoft dependent version of HTML. Apple, you lied to us about that.
Also, the whole way that the Mac networks with Windows networks needs a lot more work at the Infinite Loop campus. A Mac user practically needs to be a registered Microsoft engineer to figure out the different terminologies to get a Mac on a network or to print to a network printer.
However, a lot of what happened to Mr Bodine was brought on himself. If a businessman depends upon MS Word on his Macintosh, he should have bought MS Word for the Macintosh. You don’t have to be a brainiack to figure that one out. Also the multiple buttoned mouse. Yes, you can buy that one too for the Mac.
The guy who sold this Macintosh to Mr Bodine should have been there for him after the sale to make sure that he was a satisfied customer and to make even more sales in order to support this buyer better. This Mac dealer really screwed the pooch.
“The clear majority of people who have some actual experience with both platforms choose to use the Mac for themselves. You learn to use a PC because you must, but you usually choose a Mac for yourself.”
The clear majority of people choose Windows for themselves. Almost all consumers know both platforms exist. I guess, by your argument, we now know now which is easier to use.
As to all the other comments, the point is that for the most part people are not saying that this guy doesn’t have a point, just that he should have tried harder to overcome the obstacles that using a Mac presented.
The clear majority of people choose Windows for themselves. Almost all consumers know both platforms exist. I guess, by your argument, we now know now which is easier to use.
You choose to ignore the essential difference: Most people who have some actual experience with both platforms choose a Mac.
Big difference between just “knowing about” and “actually knowing” the platform. You do understand the difference, don’t you?
As to all the other comments, the point is that for the most part people are not saying that this guy doesn’t have a point, just that he should have tried harder to overcome the obstacles that using a Mac presented.
Millions of people have no problem with it whatsoever – but some people fail in the challenge of changing a light bulb at home as well, so I guess the exception confirms the rule, in a way…!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
Although it’s increasingly difficult to suppress the suspicion that we’re indeed dealing with paid Microsoft “astroturfing” here; The “horrible problems” are really a bit too bizarre – actually below the difficulty of changing a light bulb…
“Big difference between just “knowing about” and “actually knowing” the platform. You do understand the difference, don’t you?”
I understand that that’s an assertion which is impossible to prove therefore probably gives you some comfort in the face of a reality which completely contradicts your position.
You can’t claim outright that the OS you like is more popular because it clearly isn’t.
You can’t claim that the consumer didn’t know that he had options when he came to make his purchase, because clearly there is a strong awareness of Macs in the marketplace.
So you need to find another explanation, it’s that these consumers would have chosen Macs if only they actually used a Mac and understood the OS.
However that most consumers have gone the other way is a demonstrable fact.
On one side, the simple explanation, people know about Macs and don’t buy them.
On the other side, people know about them, but the process of selling a Mac is so complicated that the person who’s contemplating one needs to understand the OS, retrain, spend some time with the unit before he sees that it’s the right choice for him. Then you’ll always have the argument that he didn’t choose the Mac because he should have spent just a little more time.
In either case, it’s bad for Apple because the result is the same – No Sale.
“The “horrible problems” are really a bit too bizarre – actually below the difficulty of changing a light bulb…”
As a general rule, once you’ve used a platform or piece of software for a while (Windows, Mac OS X, whatever) you are no longer in any position to evaluate how “easy” it is to use for a newbie. So what you see as “simple” and “obvious” because you’ve done it a thousand times a week for years may not be so for a brand new user.
I am a relative newbie and I say the problems are bizarre. As for people knowing “about macs” most people I know think (or thought) that computer = windows. They don’t realize Linux or Mac OS X exist. Or they think Macs are just for graphics, etc. so no they don’t “know” anything about Macs.
I wish someone would do a random survey and see what people really think about Macs.
Oh and I work in a highly technological field, where people (mainly engineers) work on computers allday, so it isn’t as if they aren’t intelligent or never use a computer.
I do question how “smart” this guys is… but for a different reason. If you are happy and productive using Windows and MS products, WHY WOULD YOU SWITCH?? Whether it is “bad habits” or just the Windows UI, it’s a tool, if it works for you, use it.
I NEVER try to get people who are happy with Windows to switch. You’ll just get guys like this (if he’s for real… I wonder just because why the f– did he try to switch.)
If you want a slightly better Windows, don’t get a Mac! It’s a better computer but it’s also different. If you don’t want a change, don’t change! Doh! (Yes the mac now runs Windows, but if ALL you want is Windows, I think you’re better off with it preinstalled.)
Apple and the rest of us will do just fine without the 10 or 20% of Windows users that applies to.
And… let’s have the same attitude to Mac users who are productive on their macs!
Me… I’m a mac guy forced to use Windows for work… and I monitor the performance of Parallels closely to decide when I’m coming back.
“Big difference between just “knowing about” and “actually knowing” the platform. You do understand the difference, don’t you?”
I understand that that’s an assertion which is impossible to prove therefore probably gives you some comfort in the face of a reality which completely contradicts your position.
It is actually very easy to demonstrate. People who “know about” the Mac platform make many assumptions which are physically verifiable to be false. Such as features allegedly missing which actually do exist.
Your own article is full of such assumptions which have been demonstrated above to be factually false.
You can’t claim outright that the OS you like is more popular because it clearly isn’t.
You’re completely confused, apparently. “More popular” always refers to specific group.
Within the group of all users (those who do and those who don’t know the Mac from experience), Windows is obviously “more popular”.
The interesting thing, however, is that among the group of people who have practical experience with both systems, the Mac is apparently more popular.
So it seems the popularity of Windows among the majority depends wholly on the majority not knowing the Mac.
And relying on people’s ignorance is not always a good long-term strategy, because they might clue up eventually…!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
You can’t claim that the consumer didn’t know that he had options when he came to make his purchase, because clearly there is a strong awareness of Macs in the marketplace.
Which in fact leads to a very healthy rise of Mac sales as we speak.
But still many people know of the Mac, but most of them have never had an actual look at the Mac or even practical experience with it.
So you need to find another explanation, it’s that these consumers would have chosen Macs if only they actually used a Mac and understood the OS.
It’s borne out by practical experience in very many cases already. No need to fabricate anything.
Standing on the article above, your credibility with this kind of insinuation is highly questionable.
However that most consumers have gone the other way is a demonstrable fact.
Many people once smoked – today, not quite as many…
Very similar principle.
In either case, it’s bad for Apple because the result is the same – No Sale.
Rubbish. Apple sales have never been better, and the trend is strongly upwards.
As a general rule, once you’ve used a platform or piece of software for a while (Windows, Mac OS X, whatever) you are no longer in any position to evaluate how “easy” it is to use for a newbie. So what you see as “simple” and “obvious” because you’ve done it a thousand times a week for years may not be so for a brand new user.
Typical last-ditch defense. No, sorry. It has been demonstrated above that there simply were no “horrible problems” (see kaekae’s post), but merely a personal unwillingness to even try overcoming any obstacles.
Kind of like stomping your foot and holding your breath until the perceived problem “magically” resolved itself – which usually doesn’t happen.
Yeah, in the USA you can sue a manufacturer for that, too – but don’t expect to be taken even halfway seriously after that!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
The criticism is not really for being stupid (pretty much everybody is an idiot every once in a while) – it is for being disinterested and after that dishonest, either out of personal insecurity or for hire.
“The interesting thing, however, is that among the group of people who have practical experience with both systems, the Mac is apparently more popular.”
Show me one survey, one shred of evidence from an independent party to back that up. Until then the most neutral evidence we have is which one sells better.
“Rubbish. Apple sales have never been better, and the trend is strongly upwards.”
Again you have nothing to back this up. The facts show the opposite. Apple’s market share has been significantly better for most of it’s history. At the moment you’re at the bottom of a long decline, showing some signs of improving.
Perhaps the share losses will be reversed, perhaps not. One or two good quarters after a major product transition compared to the previous quarters where people were holding off purchases until that transition completed doesn’t reverse a decade long decline.
“So it seems the popularity of Windows among the majority depends wholly on the majority not knowing the Mac.”
Again you have nothing to substantiate this. The popularity of Windows comes from 95 sales in every hundred being for a PC instead of a Mac.
“It’s borne out by practical experience in very many cases already. “
Anecdotal evidence (Like my cousin’s mate’s sister’s boyfriend switched to a Mac and he had no problems), not anything else. Show me some independent study that shows this result, rather than they you once knew a person who though this way.
“And relying on people’s ignorance is not always a good long-term strategy, because they might clue up eventually…! “
That’ll be a bad day for Apple.
Its so funny. You guys made my day by funny comments. I wont tease no one even the Legal consultant. But If he wants to move back to pc. And still want Secure Os with No viruses or Spyware as Mac Os X Tiger. As it was the main reason he switched to Mac. He still can use Linux Fedora 5 or Mendrake Linux distro. Which has a desktop Gui to. I hope he dont say Linux or openoffice application sucks because its freeware program and Linux Os is opensource Free. It might be diffrent from windows but its stable and secure on Standard Intel Hardware. Bye take care.
I’ve been working with Macs & PC’s for 14 years in the print media end of things. Nobody wants windows…it’s what you get stuck with based on price. Can I show you evidence ? A study ? No. And I couldn’t possibly expect you to read it if I had it and mailed it to you. You would continue to believe what ever you wanted to. Anyway, I’m telling you a concrete and steel FACT. I could blow away any PC shop with my Mac based shop amy day of any week. We talk to PC designers on the phone. Man, Cuckoo Cuckoo ! Buy a clue Einstein.
FACT = Apple has never been in as good of Financial shape. What you say doesn’t matter. Market Share on the way up.
Business sales, mostly leases and scheduled upgrades make up a huge portion of windows sales. How many Dell’s out there, on there side, as a cash register. Truth is Apple is not competing in this “market”. Anyway, most companies never bought a pc for windows…they bought an IBM compatible box. IBM made MS. Bad business by IBM is why you know Gates’ name. If IBM had a clue…MS long dead or purchased.
Most normal folks, by normal I mean someone who likes products that work, I talk to think windows is bloated beta release junk. I know like 2 people who like windows. Whether you like it or not a lot of people are getting rid of pc junk boxes and getting a more refined machine.
Sorry, you are a dinosaur. See ya.
“I’ve been working with Macs & PC’s for 14 years in the print media end of things. Nobody wants windows…it’s what you get stuck with based on price. Can I show you evidence ? A study ? No. And I couldn’t possibly expect you to read it if I had it and mailed it to you. You would continue to believe what ever you wanted to. Anyway, I’m telling you a concrete and steel FACT. I could blow away any PC shop with my Mac based shop amy day of any week. We talk to PC designers on the phone. Man, Cuckoo Cuckoo ! Buy a clue Einstein.
“
I’ll take that as you’re going to stick with the anecdotal evidence. And I dont doubt that you’re hearing what you’re hearing, just those people are not enough to make a dent on Windows market share.
Your “concrete and steel FACT.” is really just an opinion, not a fact.
Post a link to a study, of course I’ll read it. The real problem is that you can’t post anything because there’s nothing to back up your position.
“Anyway, most companies never bought a pc for windows…they bought an IBM compatible box. “
Now that’s just a silly statement. Part of the “IBM Compatibility” is that it runs the Windows software they wish to run. What IBM were they going to run on their IBM compatible? OS/2? PC-DOS?
“Most normal folks, by normal I mean someone who likes products that work, I talk to think windows is bloated beta release junk. I”
Most normal folks don’t give a shit. I can hardly imagine you talk to many “Normal” people who start discussing their computer’s OS. Windows works well enough for them. They have no need to move to an OS that “Designers” like.
“ACT = Apple has never been in as good of Financial shape. What you say doesn’t matter. Market Share on the way up.”
The iPod has a lot to do with the financial results, and the market share numbers, while trending up the last couple of quarters are still very low compared to Apple’s historical numbers, or other Windows PC vendors in the marketplace.
Being a about 2% compared to 15% in Apple’s heyday, it’s a long climb back for Apple to even match past share numbers let alone exceed them.
The results pretty much shut the fuck up of this silly thread. Apple growth is over 30% on a YoY base, over 3x the market growth. Apple shipped 1.61 million Macs and 8.72 million iPods during the last quarter, got over 10 Billion in cash and revenues of 27% more in US and 26% more in Europe.
Over 50% of sales at Apple stores are from people declaring it is their first Mac.
All the arguments posted by Smart and that silly bovine layer are nullified by these results. Even that Apple is not selling or that it is in decline.
The silly Larry even posted that Apple has a small declining market share (says just above 4%) not realising that Apple climbed from 2.1% in the US and now IDC gives a 5.8% while Gartner a 6.1%. Apple surpassed Toshiba in sales and it a hair below Gateway.
Can anyone be more blind than these two guys? Difficult.
“The interesting thing, however, is that among the group of people who have practical experience with both systems, the Mac is apparently more popular.”
Show me one survey, one shred of evidence from an independent party to back that up.
It’s a rather widespread experience; There might even be surveys to that effect, but why bother digging them up for you? You’re apparently completely committed to find fault with the Mac platform no matter what, so an ordinary level of debunking will have to do!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”cool smirk” style=”border:0;” />
Until then the most neutral evidence we have is which one sells better.
The Windows PC platform has seen its peak, but it has begun to decline again, while tha Mac platform is gaining ground, fast!
“Rubbish. Apple sales have never been better, and the trend is strongly upwards.”
Again you have nothing to back this up. The facts show the opposite. Apple’s market share has been significantly better for most of it’s history. At the moment you’re at the bottom of a long decline, showing some signs of improving.
Complete nonsense yet again. Apple’s latest financial statement (see the latest quotes on the main page) states exactly what I’ve written:
– Apple has never sold more Macs in its history – ever!
– Mac sales are strongly growing year-over-year.
– The Apple Stores have made a major push into the public consciousness – ever more people have an opportunity to have an actual look at the Mac, with competent advice and information from Apple employees. And it obviously pays off.
– Earnings and margins are extremely healthy and the product range is obviously attractive and in continuous development, so future sustained growth is very plausible.
– Response from the market – both in reviews and customer response – almost couldn’t be any better.
“So it seems the popularity of Windows among the majority depends wholly on the majority not knowing the Mac.”
Again you have nothing to substantiate this. The popularity of Windows comes from 95 sales in every hundred being for a PC instead of a Mac.
Ah, the age-old “Billions of flies eat crap – it must be delicious!” argument!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”cheese” style=”border:0;” />
Simply ask people – most will tell you they think they had no choice but going with Windows. It almost borders on a revelation when you’re explaining to them they do actually have a choice!
“And relying on people’s ignorance is not always a good long-term strategy, because they might clue up eventually…! “
That’ll be a bad day for Apple.
Then why do the Apple Stores work so well? Why does Apple consistently top the consumer satisfaction ratings? Why do advocacy sites like this one not exist for Windows in proportionally larger numbers?
Why?
Now that’s just a silly statement. Part of the “IBM Compatibility” is that it runs the Windows software they wish to run. What IBM were they going to run on their IBM compatible? OS/2? PC-DOS?
He actually presented the accidental rise of Microsoft and IBM’s role in it pretty accurately. You should acquaint yourself with the actual history of personal computing – you might find it interesting.
Most normal folks don’t give a shit.
To a large degree because they’re frustrated and disillusioned – “I don’t have a choice anyway!” is a widely prevalent notion. It’s one of the reasons why those same people sometimes become ardent Mac fanatics once they’ve recognized that the aggravation and frustration are actually not a necessary part of using a computer!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
The iPod has a lot to do with the financial results
“A lot”? Yes. But the Mac platform contributes just as much – with its own strong growth contribution.
and the market share numbers, while trending up the last couple of quarters are still very low compared to Apple’s historical numbers
The market has grown a lot since then, so the actual numbers are still higher than they ever were before, especially the installed base of many million Macs in the hands of generally satisfied users.
And again: Both total sales and market share show a strong growth.
or other Windows PC vendors in the marketplace.
On the other hand, Apple is already one of the largest “vendors” in the market. Most of them are actually smaller than Apple is!
Look, I can’t be entirely sure what the reason for your rant in the article and in here was, but I see two alternative possibilities:
• If it should really have been part of one of Microsoft’s usual “astroturfing” efforts, I’d really ask you to revise your priorities – spreading disinformation for money is about as low as it gets, and the morning shave can get a bit difficult when you can’t stand to look yourself in the face…!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />
• If you actually made the experience as you’ve presented it, you probably had a bit too much inner reluctance to actually deal with a platform change. It is not rocket science and most grandmas or little children cope with it without any major problems, so you can do it just as well. You just need to recognize the fact that while things will be a lot smoother after a while, you’ll still need to invest a bit of active interest and a minimum of effort to get through the initial “newness” phase.
In that vein, I wish you all the best, and better luck next time!
” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />
Good Grief.
Is MacDailyNews going to find every Tom, Dick and Harry’s blog rant against Apple products newsworthy? Does this really warrant such a lengthy response?
Get a grip – try commenting on something substantive.