Apple and Adobe at war?

“Over a year ago on June 6, 2005 Apple announced that it would move to replace Motorola chips as its core CPU and switch to using the industry standard Intel chip, which every other PC uses. On January 10 this year Apple launched the new Intel based computers onto the market,” The Business News Source writes.

“In order to facilitate the transition to the new Intel platform Apple released an update of its developer software that would allow companies like Adobe to ship updated versions supporting both the older Motorola chips and the newer Intel chip Macs, called a Universal Binary application,” The Business News Source writes.

“Photoshop is one of Adobe’s flagship programs, but allegedly sales on the Mac side have been stalling as users [continue to] wait for the Universal Binary version. Adobe has indicated that this may not be released until next year, a full year and a half after the announcement of the Intel switch,” The Business News Source writes.

The Business News Source writes, “Meanwhile, Apple has released a major update of Aperture, its professional photographic production workflow program, beating Adobe to its own game, in its core market. Adobe has a similar program Lightroom, but it’s still a beta release and isn’t likely to go commercial until next year, by which time Apple will have established itself firmly in that market.”

“So, some see the delay of Universal Binary versions of software in the Apple market as being a way of punishing Apple for entering its core market. And sending clear signals to Apple that it is not happy with the situation. Certainly the release of Contribute 4, a major update, and not providing support for Apple’s new platform indicates one of two things, either Adobe lacks the skills and engineers to carry out the transition, or perhaps that it will not move to Universal Binary apps for anything but its core applications,” The Business News Source writes.

“We think that this is a serious miscalculation by Adobe, although Apple only has less than 4 percent of the global PC market share, it is estimated that they represent between 40 and 50 percent of the shipments of Photoshop. Apple customers are remarkably loyal to Apple and if Mr. Jobs feels forced into going ‘head on’ with Adobe over Photoshop releasing an Apple equivalent then the market for Photoshop would likely collapse in a few months. Apple already demonstrated that the technology built into new Macs with Quartz Extreme and Core image would make developing a similar product to Photoshop trivial for Apple,” The Business News Source writes. “Any loss in the media market will be for Adobe, not Apple.”

Full article here.
Adobe needs an attitude adjustment. There’s no excuse for making a large portion of your users – the very users of the platform that made your company, by the way – wait for so long to run your products natively.

Related articles:
Analyst expects Adobe Creative Suite 3 release on May 1, 2007 – October 04, 2006
How long must we wait for Adobe to produce Universal applications for Apple’s Intel-powered Macs? – August 21, 2006
Adobe CS3 sneak peek shown on Apple MacBook Pro as Universal Binary application – May 25, 2006
Cringely: Apple must replace Microsoft Office, buy Adobe Systems for attack on Microsoft to succeed – April 28, 2006
Adobe CEO: Universal version of Photoshop due in spring 2007 – April 21, 2006
Adobe software engineer explains why Photoshop for Intel-based Macs is taking so long – March 24, 2006
Should Apple buy Adobe as leverage against Microsoft? – December 16, 2005
Adobe prefers (and promotes) PCs over Macs – March 24, 2003

80 Comments

  1. Well….. I’m not sure trivial quite describes creating something like Photoshop, but certainly it’s doable if Apple has the will to do it. Would be pretty ironic if Apple released some Photoshop-like program before Adobe got round to fixing their version!

  2. No doubt the problem is that Adobe should have started the Migration to XCode a long time ago, but waited until it was a requirement. Now instead of only having to recompile their apps and performa bit of tweaking, they have to completely rewrite more than a decade of legacy code to bring it up to date. When they are done, I’m sure the entire Creative Suite will be much better off for it, but expect the first version to be buggy as all hell. Essentially CS3 will be more like a 1.0 release.

  3. Well, if adobe wants to jump the gun and not produce for apple.

    The there are many alternatives in the open source that beat of match the best of adobe.

    Apple could just pick one of them and sell it the mac way.

    We really don’t need that bloatwer software from adobe.

    my two cents!

  4. you know..I’d hate to say..as much as I love Apple and their products..but I think Adobe fans are as hardcore as Apple fans..and if push came to shove, Adobe fans will follow photoshop wherever Adobe goes…even PC Vista.

  5. “”So, some see the delay of Universal Binary versions of software in the Apple market as being a way of punishing Apple for entering its core market”

    So the writer has no proof for his comment that they are at war, he is just speculating that they are because UB photoshop isnt out yet.

    I guess thats the new journalism. Inventing news.

  6. I’ve been watching my wife struggle with Adobe indesign, should be called indigestion, and it’s such a mess compared to the simple elegance of Quark…

    Makes me think there has got to be a market for a simpler and cleaner app to compete with PS.

    And I’m ready to avoid all Adobe products from now on.

    They are arrogant, bloated, and their products are no longer elegant or cutting edge.

  7. In all fairness to Adobe, it is not a trivial job to convert all their applications to Universal Binaries.

    Remember, almost all of their apps have been around for a long time and therefore can’t do the conversion as effortlessly as an application built using Apple’s own tools. Not to mention their fondness for bundling everything into suites, creating the need for simultaneous release.

    Having said that, I wish Adobe had never bought Macromedia, because if they were still competitors, we would then have a situation of Adobe and Macromedia trying to beat eachother to market with their Universal Binaries.

    Ultimately, I hope Adobe is worried about both Apple and Microsoft as competitors, because, lets face it, who else is there to get them off thier butts?!

  8. This article is flamebait

    The Intel switch caught everyone by surprise, including Apple because they beleived IBM could continue to deliever G5 processors.

    Adobe is working on a completely new version of Photoshop. It makes little sense to release a Universal version of CS2 when Apple provided the Rosetta enviroment that is running CS2 reasonable well until the new multi-threaded version of CS3 arrives.

    You see the entire programming industry is altering their code to be more multi-core friendly and powerful.

    Big programs take more time to convert.

    Adobe is now very happy that Apple is on Intel processors. Adobe only has to code for one processor family now and compile for both OS’s at the same time.

    So really we are not waiting for a Universal Version of CS2, but a brand new, OS neutral, version of CS3.

    Stand by to be happy. You’ll still have to work.

  9. gman I think it’s a bit complex. Yes Adobe users are very loyal but I would bet that most of those loyal Adobe users are also Mac users and I doubt they’d go over to Windows.

    Most graphic designers love Adobe and Apple…the two go together really well.

  10. I had my say on this a couple of days ago. The author and MDN echo my opinions. I don’t believe Adobe customers are as “hardcore” as you think, gman. Customers, in general, will follow a company that shows them disrespect and disdain. Adobe isn’t punishing Apple with their footdragging. They are punishing you and me, and everyone else on the Mac platform that uses their products to make a living. People can say PS is complex and they needed the time, but why is the newly release Acrobat not Universal? A lot of people assume it is, but I can find no evidence from Adobe that it is.

  11. dang… I wish we could edit these posts. Here is my message with typos corrected

    —
    I had my say on this a couple of days ago. The author and MDN echo my opinions. I don’t believe Adobe customers are as “hardcore” as you think, gman. Customers, in general, will not follow and stay loyal to a company that shows them disrespect and disdain. Adobe isn’t punishing Apple with their footdragging. They are punishing you and me, and everyone else on the Mac platform that uses their products to make a living. People can say PS is complex and they needed the time, but why is the newly release Acrobat not Universal? A lot of people assume it is, but I can find no evidence from Adobe that it is.

  12. I bet Apple already has “iPhotoPro” sitting on a shelf somewhere, ready to go alpha, should Adobe decide to get a little too pugnacious. They say they’re waiting for CS 3.0 to go UB… I think they should have started with CS 2.3 to have the industry give it a solid test run, so CS 3.0 would be released without out any kinks.

  13. If there is a war, I will choose apple, because adobe is just milking their flagship products, every new version do not represent a major shift from the previous one, nothing new, just two or three new ajust features and a relocation of the old features.

    Adobe betterr side with apple because microsoft is already shooting to their head and apple with the small percentage of the market represent a lot for them.

    Apple is the only company with the resources and the knowledge that can kill adobe and fight a good fight with microsoft in the business area, I do not what is apple waiting, apple should have bougth the Macromedia Xres application just to have for a feature release, but with the Aperture expertise adobe is feeling the apple heat..

  14. I have been a working graphic artist for over 20 years now, and have seen this business develop from the ground floor.

    One thing I have always said: “The day I have to use windows is my last day as a commercial artist”.

    I am now quite well along in my career, as you might imagine.

    I now make the buying decisions. I have a looooong memory.

    Adobe – don’t fsck with us. You. Will. Be. Sorry.

    Period.

  15. Adobe is no friend of Mac or you. Tho Apple put Adobe on the map they have clearly become a PC company.

    Adobe would love to abandon the Mac except that they still sell a lot of Creative Suite packages to Mac users and the Apple is about the only computer company with any real excitement and pro-sales happening.

    Adobe copy protection is THE WORST! I hate them now!

  16. Speaking of iPhoto, I must say the new version with it’s pretty decent (and easy) correction tools has indeed reduced the number of trips I make to PS on a given day/week. If Apple leveraged iPhoto and Aperture to create a really robust pro program, they would indeed be able to compete with Adobe–and think how cool it’d be to have “photoPro” integrated with Final Cut, Shake (or whatever comes next there), and other Apple apps. Right now integration’s becoming a huge advantage for Apple in the consumer software space. If they can work that in the pro software space, they’ll really have something!

  17. *I’ve been watching my wife struggle with Adobe indesign, should be called indigestion, and it’s such a mess compared to the simple elegance of Quark… *

    To add to my previous post, Qvark Xpres is an example of why you do not fsck with the graphic arts community. R.I.P. Qvark!

  18. Well there are other alternatives to image editing…thye are smaller applications and probably not as sophisticated yet. However, I recall that when Apple acquired Final Cut from Macromedia they also may have gotten something else….called xRes which was a also another image editing application. Although I cannot confirm that they did acquire that…I hope they did. It had some potential.

    However you can look up all the alternative imaging applications on the Apple website: http://www.apple.com/downloads/macosx/imaging_3d/

  19. For an application like Photoshop, it will cost them thousands, maybe even tens of thousands of dollars to update to a Universal Binary. That’s a lot of money they weren’t expecting to spend, plus hiring engineers that know how to use XCode.

  20. I agree with Poe and Rabid Dog. Adobe has a LOT of work to do to rewrite these very large and complex programs to work natively on Intel chips. This will take some time to complete and I am sure they are doing all they can to complete the transition as quickly as possible; especially since the sooner they get it out to market the sooner they will make millions from Mac customers who have been waiting for quite some time now. Mac users are a significant portion of Adobe’s customers so it would be idiotic for them to alienate them by some ridiculous attempt to “get back at Apple.”

    However, unlike many other applications, a large portion of those who use their software are businesses who use it in their production machines. Adobe must release a very good, stable, fast product with few or no bugs or they will be skewered in the marketplace. So, they must work as quickly as possible through this big transition while ensuring the product is released only when it is ready.

    My 2 cents.

  21. “And I’m ready to avoid all Adobe products from now on. They are arrogant, bloated, and their products are no longer elegant or cutting edge.”

    I’m with that post. Adobe definitely has more in common with Microsoft than with Apple. It’s sad, but true.

    I hope Adobe is listening, because the feelings expressed here today have been around for at least a year or two now….

  22. I agree with Poe and Rabid Dog. Adobe has a LOT of work to do to rewrite these very large and complex programs to work natively on Intel chips. This will take some time to complete and I am sure they are doing all they can to complete the transition as quickly as possible; especially since the sooner they get it out to market the sooner they will make millions from Mac customers who have been waiting for quite some time now. Mac users are a significant portion of Adobe’s customers so it would be idiotic for them to alienate them by some ridiculous attempt to “get back at Apple.”

    However, unlike many other applications, a large portion of those who use their software are businesses who use it in their production machines. Adobe must release a very good, stable, fast product with few or no bugs or they will be skewered in the marketplace. So, they must work as quickly as possible through this big transition while ensuring the product is released only when it is ready.

    I believe Microsoft is in this same position with respect to its Office product. I don’t expect that to ship anytime soon either.

    My 2 cents.

  23. “Over a year ago on June 6, 2005 Apple announced that it would move to replace Motorola chips … “

    I notice that IBM is coming out with lower power consuming versions of .. the G3, of all things! The G5 gets a revamp too, apparently. I keep thinking we havent seen the last of them. Universal Binaries and all that, you know? All that Universal Binary work devoted to legacy considerations with absolutely no expectation of future access to the chip architecture? That seems unlikely, to me at least. I wouldn’t be at all suprised if IBM chips popped up in some future piece of Apple gear or another.

  24. If Apple doesn’t do it someone else just might. Look at Lineform. It’s not as feature rich as Illustrator, but it’s getting high praise in the Mac market. I believe it won an award this year at Apple’s developers conference. Don’t think that was just a coincidence either. Apple gave it it’s official stamp of approval. And I have read several graphic artist’s blogs praising it. So, Apple could buy Lineform and add it’s own Photoshop killer and there you go. By Adobe. That’s what you get for being slow a$$ like M$.

  25. I’ve been one of those “hardcore” Adobe fans for a long time now and in doing that, I would use the best platform for the software which is the Mac. Using the Mac turned me into a huge Mac fan and have since become a major FCP user.

    One thing that I have learned over the years is that Adobe is a group of greedy turds. From Adobe’s history, I would say that the delay is over Adobe wanting you to pay $299 for the CS3 update while most people will only get the update for the UB. Just a UB update, in my mind, is worth $50 so Adobe is forcing the issue my getting people to wait and pay for the major update. It’s a catch 22. Mac professional users want to run PS or AE (Premiere for all intents and purposes is dead in the film industry thanks to FCP which is why the last update for Premiere was about four years ago) on their Macbook Pros. They can’t do that well without UB. So they will want to buy any update that has UB. By making the CS3 update the only update that has UB, Adobe weasel’s out $300 out of users who may not have bought the CS3 update for just it’s features. I know I didn’t buy the CS update for lack of features and seeing as there are not a whole lot of new features in CS3, I probably would not purchase it if it did not have UB.

    We ACE guys are really getting killed by the update wait because Rosetta can run PS just fine for the casual user (that’s less than two hours a day) Try using it for ten and then tell me how you feel.

  26. The switch to Intel did *not* catch Apple offguard. As SJ said in the unveiling keynote, they had OS X running on Intel for years. I suspect they saw the writing on the walls years ago, and wanted to be prepared.

    As for Adobe dragging their heels…it completely blows. Yes, it’s not going to be easy to migrate to XCode, but it’s not only Photoshop. They also own the only really good web development environment (Dreamweaver), and they own FLASH!!! If they don’t migrate that suite over to XCode, that’s bad news for Apple.

    I’ve heard people wish Apple would just buy Adobe. I hope that comes to pass.

  27. >>In all fairness to Adobe, it is not a trivial job to convert all their applications to Universal Binaries.

    In all fairness to Apple, Adobe didn’t update their code base in a timely fashion. They neglected Photoshop for years, and are now paying the price of having to update their disorganized, messy legacy code. If the code had been kept current, the conversion process would not have been nearly as difficult for them. Intuit is facing the same difficulty with Quicken, and it’s just as much Intuit’s fault as it is Adobe’s.

    I have no patience with companies who pass the buck to the consumer when it comes to responsibility for their own products. I’d love for Apple to surprise us all with a Photoshop-killer at Macworld, and I’d love to see Adobe (and Intuit, for that matter) have some competition.

    They need it.

  28. There’s obviously a lot of points to this whole situation. Adobe obviously have a product lifecycle, I don’t know exact dates but without Intel we probably still wouldn’t have seen new versions much sooner.
    There is also the whole thing of their apps being incredibly complicated to bring over. Fair enough, it’s a big job, but they’re a big company and since photoshop it basically it’s main market you would think they would have a large proportion of their staff working on it. Apple would obviously be ahead of everyone in terms of having their apps up to date but it shows that if you have you apps using old legacy code you end up suffering.
    Sales are obviously decreasing because everyone is waiting, you would think they would in turn try and speed up their development. Or at the very least show some real signs of how they’re doing. Nothing.
    Apple have released Aperture and done numerous updates to it in the same time, some arguably better than others but they’ve been done. Lightroom is still in Beta.

    Adobe have either severely dropped the ball or if they’re purposely delaying they’re biting off their nose to spite their face.

  29. Thanks for the Lineform reference. I grudgingly bought Freehand (now a soon-to-be-defunct Adobe product) a couple years ago after an exhaustive search of ALL available vector drawing programs, finding it the one I best related to and the least offensive of the bunch (as opposed to the “best”). I have to believe the core development libraries in OS X are making the development of a new generation of graphics and animation programs more sophisticated and much less costly, hence the $79 price tag for the extremely well-received Lineform compared with $499 for Illustator. If you read reviews of the latest generations of Illustrator and Photoshop, they are not nearly as glowing as they were for the earlier versions 4-5 years ago. Adobe IS resting on their laurels, and STILL charging you and me today’s corporate prices. I resent that, and I am beginning to resent them. Yes, they have some great, deep, flagship products, but is Illustrator $420 better than Lineform? Lineform is an early release and will continue to improve, and I think it’s only a matter of time before a Lineform-quality equivalent for Photoshop emerges as well. I think Adobe’s easy ride will begin to wind down in the very near future and more of their products could go the way of Quark, and frankly I think they deserve it.

  30. All very well and good that Adobe has been hurting Mac users’ “feelings” for a while now and a revolt is brewing. And a large number of casual/small business users may switch away from Adobe’s products. But remember, those Mac users who need to use Adobe’s products for work/large business may not find it so easy to switch. There is such a thing as Industry Standards and compatibility. If your rent depends on sticking with Adobe you.will.stick.with.Adobe. Such is life.

    MDN Magic Word – economic

    I kid you not ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  31. Adobe had better get it’s head out of it’s ass. Microsoft is coming right after you and your primary market. Keep cozying up to Redmond and playing to their BS and you will find yourself PLAYED FER SURE™

  32. Geez! I commented on this almost a year ago. Why develop a Universal Binary version when you’ve already got a Windows version out the door? At the time I was commenting on game developers, but it could just as easily work with Adobe.

    Adobe can simply take their sweet time and make a strictly Intel version of their Creative Suite applications if they really want to. By the time Adobe fixes all their bugs with CS3, all of the professional Mac users will have already moved to Intel Macs.

    We all know how badly Steve Jobs treats his developers, so he kind of deserves this little bow shot from Adobe. I’m sure that Adobe will eventually go Universal Binary, but Steve does deserve to have it rubbed in his face a little bit.

    Still, it’s amazing that a program like Graphics Converter came out with a Universal Binary version of their product last Spring and we’re still waiting on Adobe. On the other hand, Adobe prides its self on total interactivity of all of their Creative Suite products. It isn’t just about Photoshop, but a simultaneous release of Adobe’s entire line at once. No small task.

    Oh, and I use inDesign CS2, love it, and am looking forward to a product that will work on a future Intel based Mac in my future.

  33. allow me to quote Rapid Dog

    This article is flamebait

    The Intel switch caught everyone by surprise, including Apple because they beleived IBM could continue to deliever G5 processors.

    Adobe is working on a completely new version of Photoshop. It makes little sense to release a Universal version of CS2 when Apple provided the Rosetta enviroment that is running CS2 reasonable well until the new multi-threaded version of CS3 arrives.

    You see the entire programming industry is altering their code to be more multi-core friendly and powerful.

    Big programs take more time to convert.

    Adobe is now very happy that Apple is on Intel processors. Adobe only has to code for one processor family now and compile for both OS’s at the same time.

    So really we are not waiting for a Universal Version of CS2, but a brand new, OS neutral, version of CS3.

    Stand by to be happy. You’ll still have to work.

  34. I would have thought a complete collapse of Photoshop for Mac sales would make Adobe double their efforts and get a UB version out the door. Especially if 40-50% of the sales are to Mac users as stated in the article.

    It would be stupid of them to allow a competitor to gain traction in the Mac market, thinking Windows sales will see them through. As history has proven, any company who captures the Mac market has a solid base from which to take the Windows market too.

  35. Scriptablility

    While I appreciate the options to Adobe products given here, I believe the scriptablility (applescript) of the CS products is given short shrift. This is a big deal for business, even small graphic design firms like mine.

  36. I think creating an Apple photo manipulation tool to rival Photoshop would be way more than trivial. Photoshop is the result of 15 years of development. That being said, it does seem as if Adobe is dragging their heels. Apple should just buy Adobe and be done with it.

  37. AAPL Dude,
    Apple already has an “iPhoto Pro”, it’s called “Aperture”.

    All of Adobe’s products, except Photoshop, suck balls! I am so glad that I don’t have to use Acrobat Reader anymore. Thank you Preview!

  38. Here’s a question for the programmers, wouldn’t it be faster for Adobe to recompile the current Windows/Intel version of Photoshop than to rewrite the Mac/PPC version to UB? Obviously they already have a version of Photoshop written for Intel chips!

    BTW, I switched entirely away from film to digital about four years ago, since then I find I have less and less need for Photoshop, I haven’t bothered to upgrade from CS, and probably won’t. I have only had my iMac G5 for a few months and I really don’t care if Photoshop goes UB or not. For the most part I have gone open source with NeoOffice and GIMP. I also like Digital Photo Professional which came with my Canon 10D and iPhoto, of course.

    MW = analysis
    as in, that’s mine!

  39. TheConfused1,

    “When did Adobe become the new Microsoft?”

    It’s been an ongoing process for many years.

    It’s ironic, really, considering that Adobe used Quark’s very similar MS-type, “we own our users, because where else are they gonna go,” corporate attitude against them in marketing InDesign.

    Nowadays, like Quark and MS, Adobe’s corporate attidute towards their customers is that Adobe seems to consider themselves indispensible. If they don’t wake up and smell the coffee, someone is going to give them a real surprise, like Apple did when they released Final Cut. I would be very surprised if Apple hasn’t had the basics of a potential PS competitor in development.

  40. “Here’s a question for the programmers, wouldn’t it be faster for Adobe to recompile the current Windows/Intel version of Photoshop than to rewrite the Mac/PPC version to UB? Obviously they already have a version of Photoshop written for Intel chips!” – FUDsucker Proxy

    No. PS for Windows are compiled using Windows APIs which does not exist on Mac OS X. You need to use Mac OS X APIs if you want to develop Mac OS X native applications. Even if Adobe figured out how to recompile Windows’s PS for the Mac, the result would be disastrous as users would see a mess of a GUI inconsistent with the rest of the systems. Do you recall Word 6 for Mac which was recompiled from Windows version? It was the most un-Mac-like commercial app for which customers were duped into paying hundreds of dollars. It was a failure that MS re-wrote Word for the next Mac version (and if my memory serves, founded Mac Business Unit to be in charge of it).

  41. We will get the Universal PhotoShop update But now that we are using Aperture for much of what we use to depend on PhotoShop for, that will be the last PhotoShop update we will pay for. With PhotoShop is no longer the primary photo-editing program, the current version is good enough.
    And who knows? Maybe Aperture may (in the far future) take over the rest of what we use PhotoShop for.

  42. What if it is something apple and adobe planned? Maybe the new version of Photoshop (and others for that matter) AND 10.5, Leopard, are made “for eachother? A true 64bit version optimized for dual, quad und up cores….. just a thought.

    MacB

  43. the worst aspect of this is not even photoshop and illustrator (theyre bloated pieces of crap these days just download LineForm and shit its quick!!!)

    The bigger problem for me is Flash.

    Its an important web technology but I think basically its died in the ass as soon as adobe bought macromedia.

    ADOBE today do not support the apple community like they used to, Bruce Chizen is a salesman whos concerned with the bottom line. Hes not concerned with producing great graphics apps.

    thats why Adobe in my opinion are basically the same as Microsoft these days, big and bloated.

    I mean how much has changed in photoshop and illustrator in 5-10 years?? realistically stuff-all. Theres no innovation.

    I wish Apple would produce a Photoshop ‘competitor’ Id switch immediately.

    The interface for photoshop is absolutely horrid in my opinion. Too cluttered. its a sh*tfight.

    Im waiting Apple…

  44. Adobe does indeed need an attitude adjustment.

    I worked at Adobe from the late 80’s to mid 90’s, back when John Warnock and Chuck Geschke ran the company. Before the suits took over, as they did when the founders retired. As they also did at Apple with the arrival of John Scully and the departure of Steve Jobs.

    Adobe was an amazing place to work back then, but those days are long gone at Adobe. And Photoshop, brilliant as it was back in 1990 when Adobe shipped Photoshop 1.0, has remained pretty much the same program for more than 16 years despite many welcome improvements. The really curious thing is that Photoshop has never had any serious competition, and it shows. As every great athelete knows, peak performance is impossible without a challenge.

    In the computer world, the spark required to ignite the flame of innovation can come from the inside or the outside. In the case of a visionary like Steve Jobs, the spark comes from within. The visionary sees what doesn’t yet exist; and his challenge is to make that vision a reality. In the case of a company like Adobe, which evidently has no visionary guides to inspire the creativity of its very capable employees, the challenge has to come from outside competition. No competition, no spark. No spark, no ignition, no blast-off, no innovation.

    Personally, I’ve been waiting for at least five years for Apple to take on the Photoshop challenge and beat Adobe at their own game. Not to mention the Dreamweaver challenge, now that Adobe owns the most-used (though in many ways woefully inadequate) web authoring application.

    I don’t know how much energy Steve Jobs has for extending his reach to include the many other things (like more professional software) that he and his team could be doing. But it sure would be great to see a real horse race in this corner of the universe. I don’t wish for Adobe’s demise. I’d just like to see them get up off their fat asses and remember what it was like to do something great instead of just making money.

  45. I can do everything I ever needed to do with photos in Photoshop 5.0. Other than PS, I seldom use any other Adobe apps, or should say, “used.” For a time I was a heavy user of Dreamweaver/Fireworks (up to version MX 2004) but now that MS has digested Macromedia, I’m all for alternatives. Competition was key between the former competitors (Adobe and Macromedia) and now I’m not interested. Adobe can just count me out. For photo optimization and web design/development there are plenty of alternatives. I’d prefer my apps to be mean and lean, and quick, rather than top-heavy and loaded like my grandfathers Lincoln Continental, which was impressive, but a real tank. If I want to do post-shooting photo adjustments (not multi-layered, multi-masked, creative nonrealistic works of fantasy) I want an intuitive, simple and effective, non-resource-hogging tool. That’s it. Why is this so hard to get, Adobe?

    Also, I hate bundled apps that you can’t unbundle (sorry Apple, but it’s true.)

  46. I’ve got no hatred for Adobe. No loyalty either.

    I am buy their products.

    But I think they are the MS of the design world:

    1. Expensive products
    2. Buggy products
    3. Terrible UI (by design to force a learning curve lock-in)
    4. Anemic upgrades we have to buy because we mostly need the major bug fixes
    5. Proprietary file formats
    6. Programs take minutes to load

    I’m not hoping Adobe gets crushed like Microsoft, but I would be really happy if Apple came out with a Photoshop killer. I’l love to have that product.

    I don’t really care if Adobe sucks. And it’s certainly no surprise that the company with these quality and innovation issues are getting crushed by Wall Street.

    But I would like to learn how to manipulate photos, and I don’t want to deal with Photoshop, it’s slowness and 20 year old interface.

  47. Forcing me to use Quark again (switched for 3 years then dumped it again) would be as horrible as being forced to use Winduhz.

    My love for Apple far surpasses my affection for Adobe CS2. However I can’t live without EITHER.

    This sucks.

  48. Always amazed to hear people say that Photoshop hasn’t changed over the years – this may be true to a certain extent if you’re using PhotoShop purely for the tasks it was originally designed , i.e. colour correction/resizing/filters/saving to different formats – these are the areas where Apple is competing directly in developing Aperature.

    But PhotoShop these days offers really great compostioning and production features, like layer adjustments, smart objects, live type layers, actions, vector shapes – these might seem like bloatware features if all you need to use PhotoShop for is image manipulation, but trust me, in our office we use these features day in day out and they’re real timesavers, and not at all gimmicky.

    Put it this way, if I had to use PhotoShop 4 for my job now, everything would take 10 times as long, with different versions of files all over the place – but I reckon 70 percent of users only use features which have been around since v.4. To them, yeah, PS CS2 must seem like the most bloated piece of software ever, but all that stuff is there for a reason… to be used.

    Think it’s too bloated? Fine, go use iPhoto.
    But you’ll prise Smart Objects out of my cold, dead hands.

  49. Rapid Dog: Did you mean to type Rabbid Dog? That would make more sense.

    Adobe is calling the kettle black here. They entered the page layout market by purchasing FrameMaker and PageMaker, firing two warning shots across Quark’s bow. Then they released InDesign which is taking over the market. Adobe’s marketshare with InDesign, PageMaker and FrameMaker is HUGE. Of course people were willing to leave Quark in a heart beat because of their poor pricing (no discounts for multiple copies) and terrible customer serice

    Now Apple is releasing Aperture as a shot across Adobe’s bow, but that was not the first shot. It was Apple Production Suite which makes Adobe’s video programs look like shareware. So Aperture is the second shot across the bow, and these shots were to answer Adobe releasing CS on Windows faster than on Macs. In my opinion, Adobe’s customer service is poor like Quark’s, and if Apple did release a PhotoShop competitor, people would switch.

    If you don’t think people are ready to switch, take a look at the number of folks using GIMP these days. Do it Apple. Make me switch. I dare you.

  50. To say that there are open source alternatives to Photoshop is just ridiculous, from a professional’s perspective. Gimp, etc, are NOWHERE near as good as Photoshop. For doing non-pro web stuff, home photography, sure, but not for professional print work. Not even close. And for Apple to come up with a Photoshop equivalent that is suitable for professionals is not even close to trivial. And InDesign is a fantastic application for those who know how to use it. It constantly amazes me how many people say it’s junk. I work at one of the largest prepress providers in the US, and both CS and CS2 (CS2 is much better, btw) serve us very well.

    It all comes down to professional use and non-professional use.

    But that’s not to say it couldn’t be done. The apps that are out there have a very long road ahead to compete with Adobe in the pro market though.

  51. I am also a Photoshop pro and there’s no way that I would trade Photoshop for any other image editing application available today. I also wouldn’t want to go back to Photoshop 3.0, the first version to offer layers. But for me, the point is that I could. I can do everything I really need to do using a 12 year-old version of Photoshop. CS2 is faster if one happens to work in a
    high-volume, pressurized environment (which I don’t), but that’s not really saying all that much for 12 years of development.

  52. I’ve been raving like a lunatic for about a year now, saying that Apple should buy Adobe and discontinue the Windoze versions of all products (Like they did with Logic).

    I JUST NOW revised my thinking. Apple should absolutely still buy Adobe, but there is too much money to be made off of Windoze sufferers, so here’s what they should do: Ship All Mac Pros with CS3 pre-installed… for Free! Windoze users get to pay the $799 or whatever it is that Adobe usually charges for upgrades. Oh, and the Windoze versions get released 6 months AFTER the Mac version and lack some key features.

    So your choices are now – get a mac that can run OS X AND Windoze AND comes with all of the best Apps for free – OR get a DELL that only gets viruses under Windoze, costs more to buy and then costs EVEN MORE if you want Photoshop.

    APPLE! DO IT! NOW!

    MDN Magic Word: History

    HAHAHA How Appropriate! Adobe, You’re HISTORY!

  53. I want a simple straightforward workflow. I don’t want to jump from one application to another. I want a none-destructive editing environment, where I can sort and categorize my images, colour correct them, fix perspective, apply filters or plugins, then finally export from raw to print, email, post on the web, etc.

    I’m getting nervous about Adobe. Their programs are getting heavier and heavier, to the point where it’s getting in the way of doing relatively simple things. Just to do photography, currently I have to contend with Bridge, Raw Converter, Photoshop, and sometimes DNG converter. Adobe has said that Lightroom is not going to replace the Bridge, so what the heck are we supposed do we do with it? I’ve tried all of the beta versions of Lightroom, and I’m still not convinced that Adobe has the right formula. The file management and metadata implimentations are still lame. And, just like Photoshop, it’s really slow. I know, it’s a beta program.

    After ten years of continued Adobe support, I purchased Aperture two days ago. I can only hang out at the local Apple store for so many hours testing Aperture. I will now see how it performs in my studio.

  54. “The switch to Intel did *not* catch Apple offguard. As SJ said in the unveiling keynote, they had OS X running on Intel for years. I suspect they saw the writing on the walls years ago, and wanted to be prepared.”

    Ever wonder if it’s now Adobe who can see the writing on the wall for Mac OS X and are putting their efforts where the future is?

  55. Lots of great discussion…although gman is high if he thinks Adobe fans aren’t really Apple fans who attached their love to Adobe because they saw a similar set up with Adobe/Quark as they saw with Apple/Microsoft.

    For a long time Adobe was the best at coming to us for feedback and working with us to get their products right. That’s why I personally cheered them on to take on and overtake Quark. And whoever called InDesign ‘indigestion’ obviously hasn’t worked for 20 years as a designer. Quark is not elegant. It’s a piece of crap. It forces me to think like a programmer instead of like a designer (I’m a creative director, not an IS person, so take my word on something me and my team use as the core tool in our work).

    InDesign has some GUI issues, but it’s by far the most designer-friendly and design-centered layout program on the market. It’s handling of type alone is reason enough for every designer on the planet to dump Quark. I’ve switched our entire corporate user base from Quark to the Creative Suite (Mac and PC…over 50 seats). And every person that took the proper amount of time to learn InDesign all thanked me for making the switch…yes, even those who all previously swore they would always prefer Quark.

    However, that doesn’t mean I’ll stick with Adobe over the long haul if Apple goes one step further and creates a CS-like product that integrates with the operating system. I think we can see the beginnings of this concept in Pages and Keynote.

    My allegance is with innovation. I always get that with Apple…not as much lately with Adobe. I’m hoping they’ll revamp their entire product line to be truly integrated…not this kinda-sorta integrated we currently have (placing native (and layered) Photoshop and Illustrator docs into InDesign is awesome; Adobe Bridge/good, but could be a lot better; Version Cue/bad, but a great idea; integrate all these technologies into a single document center and they might have a winner). Oh…and why not kill off Illustrator and just put all it can do inside InDesign? I know…all the illustrators out there want to kill me, but it would make sense if you think about it. How many designers even open up Illustrator anymore after CS2? And how many of those because it’s a force of habit instead of a real need? ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”smile” style=”border:0;” />

    Anyway, now that Adobe has bought out Macromedia and Quark is a flailing, Apple needs to step into this arena (or encourage another company to do so) to drive competition that creates innovation in the market (a key market for Apple). I’m not sure that Adobe feels compelled to do this. It looks like we’ll have to wait until May, 2007 to find out.

  56. Adobe is the MS of photo processing, meaning we should move away. Actually, MS is acting nicer with the Apple community than Adobe does. I find it very impertinent that Adobe is giving priority to Lightroom rather than working more on the UB of their existing applications for OS X.

    For the Photoshop users: why not use Gimpshop? It’s Gimp with Photoshop-like menu, it’s Universal and it’s free. Do you have Photoshop plug-ins? Good, because they will work, too. Just make sure to install “Turn on X11 focus follows mouse.app”, bundled in the installation kit.

    For serious DTP, I see no real rival to Quark in terms of features and time-effectiveness. Otherwise, one could use Scribus, an open source DTP program.

    Missing Acrobat? SupaPDF should do it.

    Vectorial design: I have no idea of a powerful free alternative for Freehand or Illustrator.

    What Mac OS X environment is still missing is AutoCAD, which (like it or not) is the standard for CAD (they also have a serious GIS). But that is another story.

    I was sad when I found out that Adobe bought Macromedia, but there was a big risk that Microsoft would aquire it for the same first reason that Adobe did (Flash). Macromedia guys were great, they managed to keep the Aldus way — a decade and a half ago Aldus Pagemaker and Freehand could be installed from a floppy disk (not that I am missing the floppy).

    Buying Adobe is not worth for Apple, they can make their own “CS” equivalent for far less money and better (including faster and frustration-free). Some years ago, after Adobe refused to make a video procesing application for Mac, FinalCutPro came out. Now FCP became THE standard (the fact that Premiere came out after a while remains secondary). Carry on.

    Finally, I think Apple should buy Corel ($318M) in order to get a complete vector/raster processing suite, a very mature office suite and Kai’s software – one of the few Apple-style programs available in the Windows world. It’s a bargain. Anyway, I really hope someone at Apple will read this forum.

  57. Apple often shows an interesting development pattern. They start with a key innovation and then aggressivly refine it for the target market. Three examples are iPod/IMS, Final Cut Pro, and Appature.

    I bet Apple is watching Adobe very carefully. Appature could substitute for Pshop in many situations. Apple does not have a substitute for InDesign. That fight would be a long hard slog. Look at how long it has taken for InDesign to take the market from Quark.

    I think Apple would be better buying Lineform than Adobe.

    Adobe looks like other software companies that are run by the sales department. No intrinsic feel for their product. No real innovation.

  58. It seems that everyone thinks that there are great free/cheap alternatives to PS, ID, or AE but if you ever send gimpshop to a printshop, two things will happen. One, the printshop will just print it and not care about your or the fact that all the colors and “masks” (gimpshop does not have true masking or blend modes) are way off. Or option 2, they will fix it with PS and charge an arm and a leg for it.

    Now, the alternatives are great for pictures that were taken at the bars and need help but you have to be out to lunch if you think that gimpshop can even remotly compare to PS. Look at PS Elements. It has the same structure of PS: histogram manipulation (levels, curves, hue, etc), layers, color channels, alpha channels, masking, advanced tools (like the healing brush; all of which is more manipulation abilities than any of the alternatives yet it is not considered professional. 80 percent of what makes PS professional is fully profiled CMYK
    gamma and blending modes. Emphasis on profiled. There is huge collaboration between the printing press and PS software to directly corellate what you see on the screen comes out on paper.

    If you do not use those features, then quit using PS and quit complaining because your whining about a program that you do not actually use.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.