“Once again, Apple’s iPod is expected to be the hottest gift of the holiday season. That should be great news for the recording industry, right? After all, many of the 10 million or so new iPod owners surely will rush to Apple Computer Inc.’s iTunes Music Store to load up on songs,” BusinessWeek reports. “Apple, which launched the digital music revolution, may now be holding it back. Critics say Apple’s proprietary technology and its refusal to offer more ways to buy or to stray from its rigid 99 cents a song model is dampening legal sales of digital tunes. ‘The villain in the story is the iPod,’ says Chris Gorog, CEO of Napster Inc., which sells both subscriptions and downloads. ‘You have this device consumers love, but they’re being restricted from buying anything other than downloads from Apple. People are bored with that.'”
BusinessWeek reports, “Apple will continue to take flak. That’s because an army of companies has rolled out new ways to provide music — from legal peer-to-peer sites to established players such as Real Networks Inc. and Napster that offer all-you-can-play subscriptions for a monthly fee. The thing is, very few work with the iPod. “I have half a million subscribers who would love to use an iPod with my service,” says Napster’s Gorog… Still, subscriptions are a tough sell to mainstream customers. ‘The concept of a jukebox in the sky is not something most consumers intuitively get,’ says Dan Sheeran, a senior vice-president at Real. If Apple came in, it could change the game.”
Businessweek reports, “Then there’s pricing. Three music companies have publicly pressured Apple to loosen up its 99 cents approach. Jobs is convinced that having a simple, acceptable price is crucial to lure music fans away from free file-sharing sites. ‘It might make sense to raise prices in the future,’ says a source close to Apple. ‘But now is not that time.’ …So will Jobs change his tune? Not unless he has to. Apple can barely keep up with demand for iPods, which reap as much as 25% gross margins, vs. minimal profits for each iTunes track. So right now there’s no reason for the company to alter the way it sells music or make its player compatible with other services. But if download sales don’t bounce back, music companies could start looking beyond Cupertino for answers.”
Full article here.
As is its CEO, Napster is a joke. According to Gorog, people who buy iPods are “stupid.” So, now he wants “stupid” iPod owners to use Napster? Calling customers that you desperately want “stupid” is an interesting marketing strategy for an outfit that’s hemorrhaging cash. If Gorog really want to save Napster, he should forget about the music service and turn his focus towards making Napster-branded iPod accessories instead.
We have to wonder if Gorog has done the math. Sour grapes from a struggling outfit that’s getting steamrolled by Apple change nothing. Apple isn’t holding back the music business, they’re revolutionizing it. People aren’t “bored” with iTunes, obviously. Napster just wants you to think that, of course. When Napster makes it’s weak service with half the music library of iTunes available to both Mac and Windows users, like Apple’s inclusive, cross-platform iTunes Music Store, then maybe Gorog can shoot his mouth off a bit. Until then, he should just continue to silently helm Napster’s march into oblivion. Gorog’s incessant whining is unseemly.
Advertisements:
• The New iPod with Video. The ultimate music & video experience on the go. From $299. Free shipping.
• Connect iPod to your television set with the iPod AV Cable. Just $19.00.
• The New iMac G5. Built-in camera and remote control. From $1299. Free shipping.
• Apple USB Modem. Easily connect to the Internet using your dial-up service. $49.00.
Related articles: Do the math: Napster posts $13.6 million second-quarter loss – November 02, 2005
Napster President: Apple CEO Steve Jobs has ‘tricked people into buying a hardware trap’ – August 22, 2005
Apple’s roadkill whine in unison: ‘incompatibility is slowing growth of digital music’ – August 12, 2005
Napster: the only thing missing is the sock puppet – August 04, 2005
Napster, other Windows Media-based music services ‘chasing a niche opportunity’ – June 29, 2005
SmartMoney: Napster is a snooze, gushing money and renting music is un-American anyway – July 06, 2005
Napster To Go Soon? Reports $24.3 million net loss on $17.4 million net revenue – May 11, 2005
Napster is a joke – April 05, 2005
Napster CEO Gorog: Steve Jobs ‘must be pretty frightened’ of Napster To Go – March 14, 2005
Napster’s math does not add up – February 28, 2005
Users thwart Napster To Go’s copy protection; do the music labels realize the piracy potential? – February 15, 2005
Napster CEO Gorog: ‘it’s stupid to buy an iPod’ – February 10, 2005
$10,000 to fill an iPod? Napster’s going to end up with egg on their face – February 04, 2005
Why ‘Napster To Go’ will flop – February 03, 2005
Napster CEO: We’re ‘the biggest brand in digital music, much more exciting than Apple’s iTunes’ – February 03, 2005
The de facto standard for legal digital online music files: Apple’s protected MPEG-4 Audio (.m4p) – December 15, 2004
Napster CEO: ‘it would be great’ if Apple iPod supported WMA – March 09, 2004
Napster CEO: Apple iTunes, iPod ‘consumer-unfriendly experiences’ – March 09, 2004
Napster 2.0 posts US$15 million relaunch loss – February 08, 2004
Damn, that villian the iPod. They tricked me into buying two of them. Now I’m really screwed because the only way I can get music is to:
Buy CDs (mostly used ones) and rip them
Buy music from iTMS which I do occasionally
Buy music from other online stores that don’t use DRM
Use p2p , Usenet or IRC if the RIAA insists on using DRM on everything
Apple started this revolution. I’m bored with all the whining coming from the me too’s of the world.
Why do they have a caveman CEO? Wasn’t Gorog one of the characters in ABC’s “Land of the Lost” back in the late 70’s?
I think Business Week has the wrong title for the article. It should be along the lines of “Falures in Digital Music Want Cheese with Their Whine”
I think the comment that is striking is that if digital sales don’t increase, record companies will turn away from Apple. Why would record companies turn away from the company that has the most players? I think they underestimate the number of people who burn their CDs onto the devices and buy the occasional tune from iTunes. Most people just want the device that works and everyone else has. That’s the iPod, and it’s going to remain the iPod for the forseeable future. You don’t lose market share that quickly. Co.’s like Napster are just upset they’re not part of the gravytrain. They picked the wrong side to be on and are now paying for it.
Who needs a subs service when you can use Pandora for free instead ?
Jobs gave them a chance to be partners, but greediness got the best of them. Now it’s “sour grapes” times!. Link your wounds Goroc!
you guys don’t actually believe that because Apple jump started this market they are the only ones that can help it move forward?
APPLE IS HOLDING BACK THE INDUSTRY. for the simple reason that they control everything and limit innovations. There are several other companies out there that could be working on ways of improving DRM or iTunes, or even the next MP3 players. but because Apple is not licensing the technology, companies are limited to iPod accessories. (how fancy is that?) and at that, they are requiring that the companies pay a tax to carry “Made for iPod” tags to their products. Is that a way to treat your partners that will in the long run strenghten your products? i don’t buy it.
Personally, i believe we would have had DVR, and Movie downloads already had Apple open up their interface. Instead we are having to wait a couple more years untill Apple introduce their own products. 2 years. that is 2 years i am having to wait since i just got my original iPod. WTF…
anyway, i am not buying this kool aid that you guys are selling. All Apple products are not the best. and they should not be the only ones. Open market encourages innovations. Not MONOPOLIES.
And No I am not a fan of Napster, Dell DJ, or M$. or a troll.
And i do love Apple products. i just hate that they think they are the alpha, and omega of everything. Please..
I don’t want “improved DRM”. I don’t want any DRM at all. Apple isn’t the problem – DRM is the problem. DRM is what is holding everything back. The RIAA and MPAA are the ones who have to have DRM to restrict content from being played on different devices.
How can Apple and the music companies not be making money from iTunes? I can buy a chart CD in the shops for almost the same price as it is on iTunes (about £1 more). Yet there is no shipping, staff, rent, markup or the cost of making the CD in the first place with iTunes it’s pure profit. The record companies want to take the pi$$ with pricing Steve Jobs knows it so do we.
Cheers,
Tim.
uuunnhgg–caveman comments not funny– they make Gorog angry..Gorog now smash you and all you villian ipods..arrrrghhhhh!!!
@Hywel:
Interesting you would mention Pandora. I just discovered it today. Nice service.
Me Gorog. Me hate iPod!
This is sad, when are all the others going to get it. Apple is got the best, and it’s only going to get better. They need to s–t or get off the pot.
“…Wasn’t Gorog one of the characters in ABC’s “Land of the Lost” back in the late 70’s?”
I loved that show! And yes, I believe that Gorog was the head sleestack…
“Oh Please” said “i just hate that they [Apple] think they are the alpha, and omega of everything. “
They don’t think they are the “alpha and omega” of everything – we do.
And as for all these also-rans like “Napster”, they don’t support Mac users so fsk ’em.
Rock on SJ!
Oh please –
Take your HANDS and slap yourself with them.
I buy that restricting your licensing to zero does put a finite wall around innovation – but iPod and iTunes are two PRODUCTS wihtin the industry…not their own industry. If Apple wanted to get monopolistic, they would simply not offer connectivity to the iPod dock. But instead, they offer accessory makers the opprotunity to partner with Apple, via the “Made for iPod” program. It is not unlike Microsoft offering MSDN certification. It’s not that you have to have it. But if you go through the program, your clients can feel that much better about your services. Same thing here.
The thing is “oh please”, is that I would rather wait for Apple to do it right, than to wade through all the junk that the other “innovators” are putting out. There’s nothing at all stopping other “innovaters” to come up with the next greatest thing (ie, downloadable movies and TV shows). It certainly seems to me that Apple is not holding back the industry. That the industry is stale, and trying to go about business the way they have been for 50 years. But when a company like Apple steps up and “thinks different” evereybody whines that they aren’t involved. If it wasn’t for Apple, well, we’d all be stuck with Microsoft, Napster, and the Dell DJ. I say let them have their monopoly, they friggin deserve it.
ONLY source?
There are literally millions of options for buying music for the iPod. They are called brick and mortar CD’ stores. They are called inernet stores.
The only one the iPod is a villain to is this guy’s lame azz company.
MW filled , as in Twinkies are cream filled
Probably 3/4ths (or more) of the music on my iPod is from CD’s or from Albums I own and I ripped into iTunes. I occasionally buy songs from iTunes and think it’s a great source for music. I would never choose to “rent” my music, if I like something, I will buy it to own it.
So far I’ve never been “bored” using iTunes, Apple is always adding more content & features to keep it fresh.
And to those groups or Record companies that don’t have their catalog(s) on iTunes, they’re missing sales like mad.
How is not allowing record companies to rase the price “dampening legal sales of digital tunes?”
BusinessWeek doesn’t explain that.
Why doesn’t BusinessWeek ask Chris Gorog, CEO of Napster to explain why he thinks “people are bored” when iPod sales are through the roof?
Come on BusinessWeek, you can do better than that!
All this crap is just like your car. Say you have a Chevy, should ford and all the others make parts to work with your Chevy, NO and that’s the same thing with Apple and the ipod.
iTMS should raise the bitrate to 160. Apart from that, I’m happy with it.
Never used the new Napster. Doesn’t work with my computer.
One would think that if one could legally buy songs from the big labels without any DRM restrictions, legal downloads would at least quadruple. DRM, in my view, means that legal downloads will be kept below its potential. No DRM will also mean that more people will share (because “beaming” songs from one device to the other will be made very easy). For the latter to be kept to a minimum, there needs to be an attitude change in an DRMless world. People will have to say, “Hey, buy your own songs,” when they are ask to share them.
I’m bored with the iPod FUD. The argument is that Apple should bow to the request to license Fairplay to all of the competitors that missed the boat. Apple took the risk, Apple reaps the reward. There are lots of other MP3 players that can use Napster, so if someone wants to buy Napster music, buy a Creative or a iRiver or a Samsung or a Sony, oops, strike that last one. ; )
Apple is a profit-driven company! They want the industry to be healthy, of course, but their chief concern is the health of Apple. There are many ways to experience music out there, and Jobs and co. doesn’t prevent you from listening any way you want, but remember that iPod belongs to Apple, and they are not obligated to open it up to anyone in any way.
To say that iPod and iTunes has held back the industry is silly. If someone else wants to take the lead, there’s nothing standing in their way but risk and innovation…
already own CDs and use THOSE with iPods. Locked into iTMS? Hardly.
Next most popular choice: people buy new CDs.
Then there’s used CDs.
Then there’s free MP3 services.
Then you have recording from vinyl and from Internet Radio.
Last you have buying from any online place you want, and burning a CD you can convert to iPod.
You have ALL those options with iPod.
What are you missing? Music rental. Pay forever and lose it all. That’s the only option you don’t get with iPod.
What options to you lose with Napster, Real, and Micro$oft? You lose the option to use a Mac. You MUST use Windows.
So who’s the villain? Micro$oft and their thousand “partners,” or Apple?
To “Oh Please”: There is absolutely nothing stopping anyone from making an MP3 player as you can plainly tell by the dozens of brands at any Best Buy or Circuit City. The “problem” is that not one company has come up with a better combination than iPod + iTunes. Is that Apple’s fault? Should Apple turn around and completely redo the iPod and make it a crappy knock-off and make it less appealing so all the other companies have a chance to compete? That would be completely rediculous. Apple makes awesome products, and people love the iPod because its the best product on the market. Why shouldn’t they also tie it in with iTunes, the best music store? The problem with Chris Gorog and all of those other companies is they are quick to point the finger at everyone but themselves. Apple deserves to be at the top because they did the work and made a complete solution. Just because the other companies choose to half-a** their offerings doesn’t mean Apple should prop them up by opening Fairplay. Apple will be on top until someone else makes a better combo than iPod + iTunes…until then, no one can touch Apple, and they deserve the following they have.
To all the boredom with iTunes is with an exciting price increase!
While I do agree that the exclusion of iPod owners from subscription services (not my thing, but I can see the appeal for some) is a negative and may be hurting the rise of THAT TYPE of music distribution, I don’t at all buy the argument that the 99 cent pricing model is hurting download sales. The 0.44% decrease was total legal music downloads – what is the data for iTMS only? Without that, it’s difficult to say that iTMS is in a “lull”. Regarding the alternative pricing structures, no thanks. Seriously, who really believes that the median price of songs is going to drop if they offer older music for less and newer tracks for more? If anyone believes this is anything other than a mechanism to increase the profit margin, you really need to take a rest, guy.
I would rant about the Gorog quote “You have this device consumers love, but they’re being restricted from buying anything other than downloads from Apple”, but Dogfriend already summed it up.
Also one last point to consider: you can play tracks from any store without a portable player. Despite the fact that I am shackled to my iPod, I can still fork over a monthly fee to Napster for a subscription service and listen to the songs on my computer. In fact, I spend more time listening to music that way than with my iPod. Gorog you, buddy!
“The thing is “oh please”, is that I would rather wait for Apple to do it right, than to wade through all the junk that the other “innovators” are putting out”
It’s easy to wait when you don’t have a choice. By keeping their system closed, they’re stifling innovation by making it virtually impossible for small companies or programmers to create a marketable, innovative product.
.
.
.
And John, no, “all this crap” is not like your car analogy.
A real villian is someone who doesn’t mind his own business and worries about some else, like what religion I should believe in or what music player I should buy and which music store I should download from.
Start your own music service and have them burn to a CD and import into iTunes. Simple
Oh please-
99 % of people who have iPods don’t have no problems importing music from other sources in their iPod and people who don’t have iPods don’t complain about importing music into their music player.
It’s people like you who can’t stand Apple Success and whine.
Gorog…. great new name for a Klingon villian!!!
TrevX,
You quite don’t get it.
“The “problem” is that not one company has come up with a better combination than iPod + iTunes.”
Yes, that’s true, but because of Apple’s licensing stance, only a large company would have the funds to create a music player and the software and and a music distribution model. So you could have a great idea for a music player, but there would be absolutely no incentive because you wouldn’t be able to sync with iTunes or use the iTMS. Likewise with a software program; what would be the point if the majority of mp3 player owners couldn’t use it? Apple is stifling innovation because the little guys don’t have the resources to compete, and thus, what could have been a superior product within the Apple system, would never be created because Apple won’t let it in. This doesn’t hurt Apple, but those of us that are consumers are the ones hurt.
I HATE MICROSOFT BECAUSE I CAN”T PLAY SONY PLAYSTATION GAMES ON XBOX. WHINE WHINE WHINE
RE: Oh please. –
– “you guys don’t actually believe that because Apple jump started this market they are the only ones that can help it move forward?”
I certainly don’t believe that, no. But I also don’t see any other companies with the overall hardware/software integration necessary to move things “forward” either. Apple is therefore uniquely (and deservedly) positioned to direct future developments in this field.
– “APPLE IS HOLDING BACK THE INDUSTRY.”
Thanks for the CAPS. Hate to break it to you, but Apple IS the industry – and, again, deservedly so.
– “for the simple reason that they control everything and limit innovations.”
Oh, please… The company widely recognised as being most innovative is stifling innovation…
– “There are several other companies out there that could be working on ways of improving DRM or iTunes, or even the next MP3 players.”
Let them do so; if their products are better than Apple’s they should earn their place in the market
– “but because Apple is not licensing the technology, companies are limited to iPod accessories. (how fancy is that?)”
Hang on; you’re saying these other “innovative” companies require Apple’s knowledge and technology in order to make their own succeed…??
– “and at that, they are requiring that the companies pay a tax to carry “Made for iPod” tags to their products. Is that a way to treat your partners that will in the long run strenghten your products? i don’t buy it.”
Do some background reading on this and you’ll discover what prompted Apple to take this action and how it helps them protect their product and brand.
– “Personally, i believe we would have had DVR, and Movie downloads already had Apple open up their interface. Instead we are having to wait a couple more years untill Apple introduce their own products. 2 years. that is 2 years i am having to wait since i just got my original iPod. WTF…”
Well, 2 years ago Apple had nowhere near the market position (and, hence, leverage) they have now – so where’s the logic in what you’re saying? If some company could realistically have got movie downloads off the ground then they would have done…
– “anyway, i am not buying this kool aid that you guys are selling. All Apple products are not the best. and they should not be the only ones. Open market encourages innovations. Not MONOPOLIES.”
– THANKS AGAIN FOR THE CAPS. Buy the Kool Aid, don’t buy the Kool Aid. Having such choice is the beauty of the open market you praise. And in that open market, people have chosen Apple. If you don’t like their solutions, you and other like minded individuals should seek alternatives elsewhere. If there’s enough of you, you will eventually have an impact on the market, thus encouraging Apple to change their practices and prompting other companies to cater your needs.
– “And No I am not a fan of Napster, Dell DJ, or M$. or a troll.”
Good.
– “And i do love Apple products. i just hate that they think they are the alpha, and omega of everything. Please..”
I love Apple products, too – but don’t confuse or try to pass off your subjective perception as objective fact. Apple has (to my knowledge) never stated that they think they are the “alpha and omega of everything.” Or even that they are “the shizzle”… They’re just doing good stuff which the rest of the world is finally catching on to.
Apple came out with a Music Player and the iTunes store to download music to their product. Thats it. Buy it or buy something else.
“Apple came out with a Music Player and the iTunes store to download music to their product. Thats it. Buy it or buy something else.”
Um, that’s exactly the problem. As an aside, I find it quite ironic that the Apple motto is to “Think Different,” which apparently applies only to the company and not to its consumers.
The slowdown in iTMS music sales can be correlated with the increase in podcasts (free) and now video on the iTMS. Granted, video only works on the latest iPod, but podcasts work across the board.
Also, I find CDs are decreasing in price, regularly selling for 9.99 to 12.99. I’m not sure if there has been an increase in CD purchases in the last 6 months, but that could be it too.
Simply put, now that there are other things to listen to (or watch), music is falling behind. Maybe if the labels agreed to lower prices across the board, music would become a bit more compelling.
Napster … when did they suddenly become all high and mighty?
The problem I see it is that the music industry (and now the film industry) are intent on making us pay for every transfer to a different medium…. eg. vinyl to cassette to CD and now to AAC/MP3/WMA (for film it’s cinema to video or dvd)
You theoretically only rent the stuff anyway, if you keep up with the format changes, but now these Napster people want to rent even more stuff…. Do American’s actually own anything??? They already rent their cars (lease, same thing), houses, cable tv, radio, … and so on. Even Microsoft is considering a rental software model. On that theory alone, Napster should be doing really well.
Are American businesses Hindu or something? It’s just that they worship a rental model which is evidently a huge cash cow…
My name is Chris Gorog and I run Napster.
We have a subscription service but I can’t get enough people to subscribe since it’s kind of difficult for me, my staff and my marketers to explain.
But if Apple offers a subscription service, they can do it better, and Steve can explain it better. Then people will want to use a subscription service.
Maybe they will use mine if they use the Windows OS, but if they don’t and use Apple’s instead, it would put me out of my misery.
Thank you.
Realist
I don’t see any problem or confusion in this. Music can be download from iTunes and imported to an iPod or Music can be imported through another source into the iPod or if you own another music player, the same applies to importing music from another source like MSN, CD’setc. Apple has as much right to open up a music store with downloads for their product. Any manufacturer has a right to have propietary parts in their products and since music is not a part, it can be obtained legially from other sources. So what is the problem.
RE: Oh please,
I completely understand. Open up the technology to the world so there will be improvements and things will be better for all, like Microsoft did with Windows. You know the way you can buy so many diverse Win PC’s, with so much technological innovations. Things are so great with open standards. That’s why Open office is just so great, so innovative so unlike anything else. It never crashs, it never fails, the hardware is just so cool.
Open standards may have great potential as does pure socialism. Perhaps when people change human nature your ideas will have merit. Unfortunately I think there’s a long, long wait for that.
I have 3 thousand songs on my iPod and none of them were bought from iTMS.
@iJavaJoe
We are taking about a music player and songs, not communicating, linking up with a Klingon ship and downloading data from it.
Gorog is in Startrek. He is from the “Cling-on” Empire!!!
Yes…Apple has a monopoly; a vertical one however unlike Microsoft’s whose is horizontal.
The biggest issue for “the others” is that they want to get into the universe that Apple created. No, they didn’t create the industry. However, the created a solution that the general public could grasp.
Secondly, Apple only controls part of the equation; they do not create music. Apple just controls the movement of that music to a playing device.
Third, any other player that is out there can use songs downloaded from iTunes…just burn them to a CD first! Unfortunately, I haven’t seen transfer and cataloging solutions as problem free as iTunes.
Fourth, the real problem is actually with iTunes, not the iPod. iTunes “locks” out the competitors and only allows synching with the iPod. Let’s get our facts straight.
Fourth, the real problem is actually with iTunes, not the iPod. iTunes “locks” out the competitors and only allows synching with the iPod. Let’s get our facts straight.
Why do you have the desire to only purchase from the iTMS.?
You can import music into the iPod from any other source by importing into iTunes and nobody is forcing you to use the iPOD or iTMS.
“So what is the problem”
One problem is that it stifles innovation.
Secondly, it’s not good for the consumer. It may not hurt right now, but it will in the future. It is far better to have universal standards for things like music. Imagine if every music label or movie studio distributed their product with unique DRM-like protection that requires a different device to play it.
Do you live in the US? Remember when you couldn’t change cell phone networks without having to change your phone number? It was decided that ultimately the consumer would benefit. Yes, it may have hurt some networks who saw their customers leave once they weren’t tied into one specific network, but that just encouraged innovation and competition with the best providers winning? If you are so confident in Apple’s ability to innovate, then you surely are not threatened by having an open standard that would allow other potential innovators to have a chance.
‘The villain in the story is the iPod,’ says Chris Gorog, CEO of Napster Inc., which sells both subscriptions and downloads. ‘You have this device consumers love, but they’re being restricted from buying anything other than downloads from Apple. People are bored with that.'”
iPod is the hereo. Restricted?, Bored? How about neither Gorog. It’s the best online store bar none and it works for both Mac and PC users not like yours which is Windows only crap. Your the one that is restricted and people are bored with. That’s why iTunes and the ipod are kicking Napsters butt.
You guys are missing the point here. Yes Apple jump started the market. Yes they are the market leader. But i do feel that they could open up the architecture (software and hardware) for 3rd party companies to tinkle and develop their own applications.
For one open up iTunes. You will find that MP4 is the de facto standard because of Apple great strides in the music business. Because of that, much companies will sooner than later ditch WMA in favor of the large iPod owners and tie-in their own applications. Let’s take the Cell phone and Cellular providers as an example: Verizon will much sooner adopt AAC than whatever they are using right now for tunes download if Fairplay was licensed. This type of adoption will spread Apple’s fortune much faster. Instead, Apple is closing off that market and driving the tunes download toward download to PC or Apple then transfer to phone. not exactly what the millions of users who have downloaded over-the-air tunes are a looking for.there are many other markets this example can be applied.
My point also is that Apple’s vision should not be the only one. May i remind you that Apple has also miss the boat on several other technology. they are not infallible. So why should we rely on them only?
Yes they have invested their own R&D. they are ripping the profits, blah blah blah… yes that is all fine and dandy. but as a consumer, i want more and faster.
@realist
I really don’t know what the innovation part is.
“any song can be imported into Itunes and imported to the iPod”
What was this “Gorog” guy thinking? iPod a villain? Geez. I agree with The Other Mark. This dude better get his facts straight.
Why don’t you whine about why I can’t use a Cannon lens on my Nikon. The threads are not open standards. That’s not fair
Photographer’s right. They’re different brands, and sometimes different brands’ products don’t work with one another.
Hey realist, why is this so complicated. Apple’s music store is not the only source to get music and put it onto the iPod and the ipod is not the only music player in existence.
Usually, when a company is just about ready to tank, they usually whine about the competition. The reason the iPod is successful has been well-stated by everyone–they build the best device, the best interface, the best store, and the best software–then they make it all work so seamlessly.
Companies have a right to defend their intellectual property. Apple doesn’t want to license its technology for any number of reasons: maintain profits, keep away garbage hardware, build a vision of where they want to take Apple–who knows.
Is Apple perfect? No way. For example, I would never buy another CD if I could buy Lossless songs from ITMS. Why they don’t go in that direction is beyond me, but it probably has something to do with bandwidth, etc.
I laugh at people with competing technologies. You should read the XM411 board, where people are constantly predicting the downfall of the iPod with the advent of some new XM device, or XM’s partnership with Napster. Of course XM broadcasts at around 70 kbps, so the sound is so filled with artifacts and compression that I actually only use XM to listen to the NHL, MLB, ESPN Radio, NPR, and the such. Musically, I take my iPod into my car.
Apple is the most innovative company around. Real and Napster know this simple fact, so since they cannot win on innovation, they whine. Customers are smarter than that. Usually.
It’s like complaining that your Xbox disc won’t work on your Playstation 2. THEY JUST DON’T GO TOGETHER!
AppleFan1,
I refer you to my earlier post about cell phone networks.
“Apple’s music store is not the only source to get music and put it onto the iPod and the ipod is not the only music player in existence.”
And that is most certainly not the only issue.
Yeah that is true, but I’m reffering to “Gorog’s” actual “iPods are villians!” statement. And if he wants to be able to have his Napster music being compatible with iTunes, then this is surely a step in the wrong direction.
Yes, I agree that Gorog’s an idiot.
If I were him, I’d be smacking myself in the face for giving that statement. I guarantee you he’s going to regret it.
http://macdailynews.com/index.php/weblog/comments/7862/
^
This will give you a good laugh.
Realist, then what is the issue? Is it becuase Apple is making money or you you don’t know how to burn a CD from a CD, purshase from TowerRecords or MSN and import it into itunes?
>> You have this device consumers love, but
>> they’re being restricted from buying anything
>> other than downloads from Apple. People are
>> bored with that.
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Name one person who is “bored” by this.
Here’s a sentence I don’t ever hear: “Wow, my iPod is so cool, but I sure wish I could buy music from walmart.com to play on it. I’m so bored not being able to do this.”
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Oh my, I’m so bored wih my brand new iPod nano because I can’t get songs off of Napster! I’m bored to death! *chokes* *dies*
Here little old Gorog is at Apple’s mercy, and what does he decide to do? He insults the iPod, calling it the “villian of the story”. My dog has more sense than him.
Confused,
Did you even read through the comments in this thread?
Realist:
I believe I understand your concern that everything music will be controled by the gatekeeper Apple if they don’t open up their “closed” system.
I think you might be in error with your logic.
If there is a better way to distribute music “any” company can come in and create it. If you think small companies can’t compete I think you should look at the industry as a whole for music: it really is only big companies that hold the content: Sony, Warner, etc. There aren’t any small companies in the bunch.
Your idea that if Apple opens up it’s system that the little guy will have a chance to get in on the action is Naive.
The only ones that would benefit are the big music companies and big hardware makers.
They are all being run by bean counters that think the only way to raise revenue is to charge more.
They look at the historic rate they received when CD were no lower than $25 and say we want to be there again. The problem is the boat has left.
If they think that raising prices and restricting the content with bulletproof DRM will force everyone to pay more since you can’t get it anywhere else – they will see sales drop like lead.
They are the true restrictors of the music business.
If there is a player that is the “must have” – consumers would buy it. Yes, people are downloading from iTms but it’s just another route of distribution and hasn’t replaced other forms. Consumers are still buying music in stores.
And you can feed your iPod from other music supply sources. The thought that you can’t is FUD being pushed by the music companies and the MS licencees of Play for Sure.
eh.. OF COURSE RECORD COMPANIES want to change the pricing scheme.. it’s their revenue source. pfft.
let’s make the most available songs on p2p MORE EXPENSIVE
friggin morons
you can use other players if you burn to CD first, and you can use some of them with iTunes as well to transfer music. Before I got the nano, i had an non-apple that worked fine for ripped mp3 music. its not a complete lock-out by iTunes.
What these companies don’t get or don’t want to admit is that apple’s solution worked because mac users were the early adopters and made it successful, whereas these other services often don’t even bother with mac users.
Sure Gorog considers Apple’s iPod a “villian.” It “stole” all of his potential customers and brought them to the iTunes Music Store instead.
Oh, almost forgot, fsck you, Gorog. Napster’s dead.
matrix3,
The music distribution method is certainly part of the issue but by no means the entire issue. I’m talking about software, hardware, accessories (ones that can’t play Apple’s DRM), and any other idea that’s out there that doesn’t stand a chance of being tried because it doesn’t have the ability to create a whole new system.
All your song are belong to us
You are (were) on the way to destruction.
Make your time.
Napster was dead long before iPods became the hot item.
But surely you’ve seen all the iPod compatible accesories that have been made. Why doesn’t Napster make an iPod compatible music player/browser that gets access to the Napster Music Store? Just an idea.
Or why not make a deal with Apple instead of insulting them, so that the Napster and iTunes stores become somehow combined. Both companies would benefit, Apple having more songs for users, and Napster having its songs on a more popular music player.
Realist,
I read the thread. Unless you, yourself have a company that is ready to compete with iTMS or iTunes your comments make no sense at all. If you really want to sell to iPod users sell them DRM free AAC’s or MP3’s at a higher resolution. You wouldn’t need software from Apple and even at $1.50 a tune I would buy.
iPod owners have many great choices right now. First they rip their CD’s. Then they load their iPods and play their music. If they have a free MP3 collection from their past, good old pirate days they also load them on their iPods. There are many legal MP3 sources as well, both free and for payment. Then there are DRM’ed tunes from many other stores that can be burned to CD and reripped to iTunes.
What more is needed? What is missing? Movies? TV? Audio and Video Podcasts? iTMS has them. Programs to rip your DVD’s and your PVR’ed TV into iPod compatible files? Good ones are available for Mac and Windows.
Realist, tell us, what could you offer?
Subscriptions? Get real! Tell us about something we want.
Big Al says it all. So now what is the issue?
Here’s one—Why can’t I put a standard DVD into my PSP?
Gorog: “Mommy, mommy, those other boys over there don’t want to play with me. Go tell those ‘villians’ that they have to.”
sounds about right…
I find it surreal that a CEO of a company (napster) that was founded on “sharing” music and depriving musicians all over the world of their legitimate royalties would cast dispersions and call Apple “villains” for creating a legal market that allowed those same musicians to be treated fairly.
How anyone in their right mind can argue that Apple is in anyway obligated, or required to open up their technology for the benefit of the other companies that they are competing with is not only naive, it’s simply childish. That’s not the way the real world works.
In the early 20th century Ford didn’t owe GM, or Oldsmobile the blueprints to the model “T” to help them compete, or to help them innovate. They didn’t give the founders of the other companies factory tours to help them understand how to make a product cheaper, with better quality, in a larger quanity. Hunger for market share drove them to innovate, and they did.
The American Auto manufactures didn’t owe the Japanese Auto manufactures anything in the early 50’s and 60’s to help them innovate or to gain market share. Hunger for $$ did that.
Companies that want to survive must innovate and create. The key to business success is figuring out where the market is going, get there first with the best product and service, charge a fair price, and take care of your customer.
Napster is a dead duck, they won’t die of legal battles, they’ll die because they don’t innovate, they just steal.
Let’s say you have a great idea for a music distribution method. Now you need the content, so you go to the music labels and they say they love the idea, as long as you protect the music with some type of DRM. So now you have three choices; use Apple’s, MS’s, or create your own. Well, you don’t have the resources to create your own. Even if you did, it wouldn’t work on the majority of players out there. You definitely don’t want to use MS’ format, so you go to Apple, who in turn tell you to go screw off. You manage to find a way to seamlessly sync with the iPod, but you remember what happened with Harmony and decide that that option won’t work. Well, you know full well that a distribution method without good software and a good device isn’t going to compete with Apple, so you decide to try to sell your idea to Apple. They ask you what’s so great about your idea, and then after getting enough of the details, they tell you that your idea doesn’t match the direction that Apple want to take as a company. With no hope of being able to create a marketable product, you decide to just give up and try something else. A year later you see your idea incorporated into the next version if iTunes.
APPLE IS A VILLIAN?
What about allowing hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people to download subscription based music and simply rip off the sound card to keep it forever without paying the artists?
<b>Who’s the fscking villian?</a>
FSCK U CRAPSTER
You know what, it really gets to me when 1 cellular company has more customers because they have better phones. It’s not fair when Cingular has better phone than Verizon. You should be able to use any phone with any service by some standard.
Sometimes you have to admit you dont have anything in your cards and walk away from the table or even before you sit down at the table take into account the players. Personally Id rather find a way to be Apples partner rather than try to compete.
Alright, it looks like it’s beat on “Oh Please” day, so here goes… I’ll try to use a “logic bat”.
From: Oh please.
“APPLE IS HOLDING BACK THE INDUSTRY. for the simple reason that they control everything and limit innovations.”
• Apple isn’t in control. The 30 million & counting people who have bought an iPod are. I don’t own one. I’ve thought about it, and the new iPod with video capabilities is intriguing, but I’ll wait ’til they have a bigger screen, and more “practical uses” than just music & video. And, granted, Apple hasn’t released iTunes for any of the gazillion-odd breeds of Unix (other than MacOS X itself), but otherwise they’re not forcing their will on anybody.
“There are several other companies out there that could be working on ways of improving DRM or iTunes, or even the next MP3 players. but because Apple is not licensing the technology, companies are limited to iPod accessories… Is that a way to treat your partners that will in the long run strenghten your products? i don’t buy it.”
• Licensing the iPod and iTunes, and “opening up” the iTMS is no different than if Apple were to start licensing MacOS X on x86. You can’t limit it to only the “best of breed” manufacturers, because tiny little “Backwaterville Unstable Computers & Lawnmowers, Inc.” will sue Apple because they were denied a license to make trendy flourescent green, but otherwise-beige, boxes held together by duct tape and paper clips…
“Personally, i believe we would have had DVR, and Movie downloads already had Apple open up their interface. Instead we are having to wait a couple more years untill Apple introduce their own products. 2 years. that is 2 years i am having to wait since i just got my original iPod. WTF…”
• The internet is still too slow for movie downloads – I know somebody who has used P2P sites for Movies, and it took 5-6 hours for one movie, sometimes he’d let it chew on it all night. It’s getting better, but unless all spammers, virus-builders and porn sites dropped off the face of the earth tomorrow, the Net just “isn’t up to speed” yet. And that’s not Apple’s fault. And Apple’s interface is part of MacOS X – you can’t have one without the other (see previous comment above regarding licensing).
“All Apple products are not the best. and they should not be the only ones. Open market encourages innovations. Not MONOPOLIES.”
• I would think that the definition of an “open market” is one in which consumers have the right to choose what products they wish to buy & use. And 30 million plus have chosen iPod + iTunes + iTMS over the lame innovations and knockoffs of the likes of Creative, iRiver, Thomson, Real, Napster, Microsoft, et al. And, similar to drug dependency, one of the last stages before acceptance & recovery is denial & anger – Napster & Real taking potshots at Apple, Creative trying to bluff its way with a lameass patent that never should have been granted (wasn’t a heirarchical menu system part of MacOS 7?).
• Now, a monopoly is wherein one company comes to dominate a vital industry by coercing manufacturers to use only their technology/product, while at the same time using its legalistic and/or financial might to bury and/or cowtow any potential innovators and/or competitors… That’s what they call Antitrust, and that’s why Standard Oil (J. Paul Getty)was busted up, and that’s why Ma Bell was busted up into the RBOCs (Regional Bell Operating Cos. and AT&T). That’s why Microsoft should have been divided into 3 OS companies, 1 applications company, and 1 internet services company…
•• Finally, I went to the BusinessWeek article, and left the following comment:
Big record companies control about 70% of the market – many “independent labels” are not. Artist’ royalties are (approx.) 12.5% on a “physical” CD sale, but only 6.5-8% on a digital download, where record companies have zero costs for the CD, jewel case liners, shipping, etc. Yet they take about 65% of that 99 cents Apple charges for each song…
Most new CDs are on sale the first week, then jump up to about 20 bucks (HIGHER if you shop at Richard Branson’s pricey Virgin Megastores).
When CDs first appeared in the 80s, didn’t music execs brag they would be cheaper than cassettes? And music-quality hasn’t improved (1 good song on a 20 buck CD). So who’s greedy and driving people to illegal downloads?
And don’t get me started on “inside the box” Real/Napster, Creative, et al… They’ve clearly shown they can’t design a “must have” product, so I’m glad Apple doesn’t need to share with them.
Nobody forces a person to buy an iPod or use the iTMS. People made a choice…
• So, “Oh, Please”, sorry about the “logic bat”, and take 2 aspirin…
HELP!…
I was just mugged. My assailant was white and about 4 inches high, with a face that lit up. He had a large round wheel with a button in the center positioned on his abdomen. He had a thin white wire coming out of the top of his head and was singing Manic Depression by Jimi Hendrix.
Still I donn’t get it. Buy a Creative labs music player and download from another source or buy a SOny music music player and download from another source. Don’t like Apple products and the way they do business, dont buy it. I’ve see a homeless person using a music player other than an iPod and doesn’t whine like Apple owns everyone something.
What’s an iPod, I still use a boombox
My iPod just held a gun to my head and told me to download “highway to hell” from the iTMS.
Now that’s gangster.
Napster System Requirements
PC only, <u>Windows XP/2000</u>, <u>Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.1</u> or higher, <u>Windows Media Player 7.1</u> or higher, Internet connectivity
Note: Windows XP and Windows Media Player 10 are required to use the Napster To Go™ service.
Terms and Conditions
<u>Importing Tracks</u>. … The Client currently only supports MP3 and Windows Media files.
<u>Loss of Rights by Napster</u>. Napster may at any time lose the right to make certain Tracks and/or Materials available. In such event, you will no longer be able to obtain [play] these Tracks….
Currently, the Service is only available to residents of the United States.
<i>If you wish to burn Downloads to CDs or transfer them to compatible portable devices … you will need to pay for them as Purchased Tracks…. In order to play any Download after the end of a Subscription Month … you must log on to the Service so that Napster can renew your rights for those Tracks…. Napster automatically renews your rights to all of your Downloads at the beginning of each Subscription Month (as defined below) so long as your subscription remains current.</i>
So … pay extra to download, cancel the service eventually, or move anywhere other than US, Canadam UK, Germany and you would lose your rights to the track. Unless you’ve burned it.
ABOUT NAPSTER: Napster is the most recognized brand in online music.
INVESTOR RELATIONS: <u>Napster</u>, the biggest brand in digital music, is a subscription service….
The numbers per month during 3-mo. period to Sep’05 (MM=Millions)
+7.8 MM Net Revenues
-6.1 MM Cost of Goods Sold
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
+1.7 MM Gross Margin
-1.0 MM R&D
-3.5 MM Sales & Mktg
-1.6 MM General & Admin
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
-4.4 MM Loss
Sep’05 Cash & Similar $127.6 MM at a 4.4 MM burn rate equates to over two years’ lifespan. Stock has halved for the year.
All you people out there complaining about iPods and iTunes, I have a challenge for you: Try creating your own mp3 player and music player/browser that surpasses Apple’s. Now as you can see, you shouldn’t be complaining, and instead be content that someone made these things at all, so that you don’t need to.
Windows only?
Why is Gorog even talking about Apple then?
Geesh, I’ve owned an iPod for 4 years and never complained about problems related to importing music. Now I read all these big shots not involved with Apple success complaning and whinning and all the PC fan boys following them waging their tails. It’s pathetic.
Remember the scene from Dr Strangelove where Slim Pickins rides the bomb down to its target? Gorag is riding the bomb, and the bomb is Napster.
“people who buy iPods are stupid”
Gorog has insulted me, my mother, my sister, my best friend, several people from my school, and many others from my swim team. What an a**.
But you got to give the guy credit. He was the one who started the whole free music download craze.
To Warner, Sony, Universal, etc. Nobody is stopping you from designing your own music player, making it, selling it, running your own DRM, encoding your own music, & distributing it on your bandwidth. Correct? Yes.
What are you whining about? By the end of the month Apple should have an installed base of well over 40 million iPods and have sold around 1 Billion songs for you. Apple has done the hard work and is taking the smallest cut. You have done the least and are getting the largest cut.
I could say you (RIAA members) are greedy, but that wouldn’t be nice. True, but not nice.
Idiots, imbeciles, stupid mutha’s. So if I’m the next product on the market that is innovative and successful I’m going to have a bunch of sharks whining that they can’t get to me to pull the meat from my bones? All because I build a cage to protect me from them and allow me to lock my own environement in which I like to work. I can still let in other people that I like (import my own cd’s/add mp3’s etc…) but I don’t have to let in a Maco or a Great White that is going to gut me and leave a dried out shell for the rest of the scavengers to pick over.
That’s alright I’ll leave my door shut, they are welcome to try the cages on the other people’s boats.
If there’s a definition of “sell-out” Napster fits it.
What part is locked out? I can burn music from iTMS onto a CD or I can burn music into a CD from MSN for example and import it unto iTunes to my iPOD. I can buy music from a music store and import the CD to an iPod or another music play. I still don’t get it.
I have a bakery in this little town, 10,000 people, 3 other bakeries, ‘competitors’.
Some time ago, I created this wonderful tasting cookie. Of course, I keep the recipe secret, and customers are raving about it.
Wonderful, they are coming in by dozens more then before, and because nobody really wants to go to two shops, I’m selling a lot more other products as well.
The other bakers are complaining now and want my recipe and tell everybody I’m not fair to them. I don’t understand why? Before they had their own successes, and giving the recipe to them will make me loose my extra profit.
My neighbour, a grocery, does profit from it. My customers would go there because I tell them to try, quality is very good there.
Sell me the recipe and i’ll give you 20% of the profit.
Dear Mr. Gorog,
I can make you following offer:
If you sell anything that can be used with my cookies (a nice tray, a special coffee-brew, etc) then let me test it. If I think the quality is good and if you would pay me 5% of your profit, then you can use ‘made for my cookies’ stickers to promote your products. I will also tell my customers about your products and you can display them and sell them in my shop.
This way, we both maximize the returns on our products and are not competing with each other. Sounds good I think. I look forward to your favorable reply.
The Baker
Here’s an idea for Gorog and the rest of the Apple wannabe’s. If you’re going to attack Jobs for keeping the iPod locked into iTunes, then why not go after all cell phone companies, all video game console makers and automobile manufacturers on the same basis. Why can’t I use my Sprint phone on Cingular’s network? Why can’t I use my PS2 games on my XBox? How come Ford parts don’t fit my Chevy? It’s a closed system. They aren’t selling one or the other – they are selling you the experience. If you can’t understand that, then you’ll never get it. If you want to take on Apple, the come up with a music store that people can actually enjoy using, like iTunes. Most of us don’t get our televisions at the rental store – we feel the same way about our music. Let us buy it and keep it. Give us a player that is simple, elegant and reliable. No more Korean, neon, Batman-looking crap. The problem for the other manufacturers of players and music stores is that instead of working as Apple did to create a seamless, enjoyable experience, they all attempt to rely on Microsoft’s flawed and frustrating WMA architecture. I’ll at least give thumbs up to Sony for trying to get it right and based on the new look of their Connect store (iTunes with a skin), they seem to be finally figuring things out. The rest will ultimately fail because in the end, its not always about price, as Microsoft might have you to believe. Most people will be willing to pay a little bit more to get a much better experience, hence Apple’s market share.
Wow 500000 gorogs on one planet. Now thats scary
Team Zissou,
Your analogy falls apart in several places. Most notably in the fact that certain parts of your examples may indeed have closed portions, but other parts need to be open. Your Sprint phone can indeed call someone from a Cingular network. Both the PS2 and Xbox will work on any TV. Both Ford and Chevy can be driven on the same roads and use the same gasoline. All computers and all media players should be able to play the same music.
The problem with the other manufacturers that you bemoan is not that they try to compete using Windows architecture, they have to because they have no choice.
You guys simply do not comprehend that this is not just a simple choose Apple or choose non-Apple choice. I mean really, do you guys actually understand the position you’re taking? Do you understand that the “burn to CD and re-import” option is really not that seamless and/or practical? There are better ways than that, but we won’t see them because Apple won’t let non-Apple guys even have a chance.
hmmm 500000 subscribers and at least 50% don’t even remember that they are still paying for the music they never listen to.
How could anyone be “bored” with something that is evolving so quickly?
“The problem with the other manufacturers that you bemoan is not that they try to compete using Windows architecture, they have to because they have no choice.”
Realist, I do understand some of your analogy-explanation, but, your argument on Windows architecture does not make sense if Apple users don’t have a choice for their computers but to use iPods+iTunes+iTMS.
Didn’t Apple start iTunes for Apple-users first but they opened up for Windows-users as well? With that in mind, why are other manufacturers complaining? They did not do the same yet, they are locking people out of the basic service they claim should be opened up…(I know, iPod was the main issue, but iTMS is as much part of the discussion imho)
All this arguing about opening up or not is simply rediculous. If you made tons of money because you had this marvelous idea, would you share it with me because I want you to share?
Answer is short and simple,….no.
Why don’t you guys get it. Apple has a goose with golden eggs and it was legally obtained. Untill the moment Apple decides they had enough of those golden eggs, nobody with more than 2 braincells at Apple would even think of bringing that goose to the butcher for X-mas dinner.
If anybody wants to profit from that idea, of course, go ahead, there’s a very simple way to pocket money from iPod’s……
BUY AAPL-SHARES…….
nuf said
from the article: “Music labels say they’d sell and earn more by offering an old Uriah Heep tune for 39 cents and a new Usher track for $1.29. “I’d be the kind of guy looking for older music at a lower price,” says David Rosenblum, an 18-year-old political philosophy major at Harvard University and a singer who performs as Dev Avidon.”
Who are they trying to kid?? Rec companies are still charging $15-$20 for albums that are 30+ years old, and they want iTunes to come up to that rate. If they want to sell older music for a cheaper amount let them start with their CD’s. iTunes would need to charge less for those songs to match the CD price. (Incindentally, I’m a Uriah Heep fan and I did buy UH from iTunes.)
The RIAA is continually trying to screw the consumer by charging inflated amounts that are NEVER shared proportionally with the Artists.
PS: A philosophy student (he still goes to school) who plays ‘who’? Where do they find these people to get comments for their articles anyway, a raffle?
MDN-age: I’m old enough to actually have been around for Uriah Heep and others
sometimes I feel like arguing with PC owners is like arguing with the stupid kid in high school that would say anything cool to fit in (even though they had NO IDEA what they were talking about). Most mac users came from PC’s previously (some were fortunate enough to not have to deal with the swiss cheese OS).
Windows users are that way by default.
OSX/Apple users are that way by choice.
Now, because they are 30 and are still trying to fit in, they just get online and bash apple wherever they can – without knowing what they are talking about.
This, by far, is the most interesting part to these conversations.
Luc,
I’m not sure why everyone just assumes that if they were to license Fairplay, suddenly they’re not going to be profitable anymore.
Nate,
Um, who’s the PC user? It’s definitely not me. Oh, I think I get it now. Mac users are not allowed to criticize Apple because everyone knows that Apple can do no wrong. So if someone has something to say that is anything but positive about Apple, then surely he is a PC owner?
Realist, you totally missed the analogy (happens sometimes). Try taking a Sprint (PCS/CDMA phone) and using it on Cingular’s (GSM) network. Cannot be done. While they work the same, both are “cell” phones, the technology is quite different and wholly incompatible. You buy the PCS phone, you can only use it on a PCS network. They intentionally made it that way – not only to keep customers on their system, but to maintain reliability, control testing, support costs, etc. Yes, both an XBox and PS2 play games on a TV. Try taking a disc from one in playing it in the other. For that matter, try using a Nintendo cartridge in a PS2 or an Atari 2600 catridge. Yes, they all play games on a TV. The point is they are closed systems. The manufacturer develops the hardware and the software that runs on it. Yep, a Ford and Chevy both use gas and run on the road (damn, you’re perceptive). However if you take a Ford engine control unit and try to place it in a Corvette, you get a dead Corvette. Again, both cars, but closed systems.
Beyond that, you miss the entire point of my comment, which was if you don’t like Apple’s system, go out and invent your own instead of relying on Microsoft’s crap. THEY DO HAVE A CHOICE. Real Networks doesn’t rely on WMA, however they have yet to develop a hardware solution. If they did, they could pose a credible threat. Sony has finally developed a decent online store and has great hardware – their only hangup has been that they are controlled by Sony Music, which initially put so many restrictions on their downloads that users got scared away.
In time, Sony will pick up ground. In time, someone will invent something of their own that may give Apple a run for their money. I’ve never mentioned the “burn and re-import” solution. If anything, Apple computer has extended themselves to more users by making iTunes, a core piece of iLife and one of their “draws” to the Mac OS avaiable to Windows users at no cost. Yes, the catch is we give you the software, but you have to use our hardware. Kind of what the cellular providers do with giving you a free phone, but you have to subscribe to our plan.
What you and the critics seem upset about is that Apple’s system works, but requires you to stick with Apple. Before iTunes and the iPod, most Windows users thought Apple was crap. They’d never consider using their stuff. The solution that Apple produced has been so good that it has won people over. As someone said a week or two back, it may not last. Remember when Netscape controlled the browser market? My only point is that Napster needs to quit complaining and start innovating. If any should be applauded its Mark Herd at HP. He decided that HP would walk away from Apple’s solution (regardless of how much money it was making for them) and that HP will later “invent” their own digital music solution – which, by the way, will not rely on Microsoft’s WMA.
Luc nailed the point on the head. For now, this is what is driving Apple’s future. They know they will ultimately face credible challengers. They need to keep their system closed until the market requires them to open it. Utilize the cash flow, the publicity, and the credibility with users to gain ground in other areas. If there are truly better players or services that start to take their share, they will either make iTunes and Fairplay open or they will open the iPod. Its the market that is driving things now. Apple is like the pretty girl that gets Homecoming Queen and class president. You shouldn’t hate her because shes popular….
Realist, come on, you should know better than that. it’s not that everyone assumes Apple is not going to be profitable after licensing Fairplay, it’s about everybody assuming that Apple is keeping their model (iTMS+iPod+iTunes) locked as this combination is the golden egg, not only iTMS, not only iPod, it’s the combination.
You might be able to argue on it, but once more, iPods sell not only because of design, but also because of pod-casts, video-downloads and music-downloads and of course it’s ease of use.
If I look at the products that Apple ships, and being someone who appreciates clean and good design (very subjective, I know), than there is nothing that I could personally complain about. I am very eager to see the next big thing, but I am also very happy about the fact that Apple does choose to deliver the total experience, because that is the key to good design.
Team,
I did understand the analogy completely, I just don’t think it’s that applicable for exactly the reasons I mentioned earlier. Yes, some parts may be closed systems, but it is of benefit to the consumer if the common aspect is open. Your analogy would be more appropriate if I was trying to say that Apple should allow competitors to be able to use their clickwheel, or have access to the iTunes code. Instead, I’m saying that the common factor, music, should be open in the same way that the common aspect of the examples you gave are open.
Using your wireless phone comparison, it was decided that it is ultimately better for the consumer if the networks shared access to phone numbers. In other words, when you drop a network, you can take your phone number with you. The networks didn’t like it because it could potentially mean lost customers. Intead, it just forced the networks to compete and innovate, which is also good for the consumer.
.
.
.
Luc,
I am very grateful for the whole system that Apple has created. They’ve done very well with creating a great overall user experience. However, opening it up does not mean that the user experience that Apple has created will be lost. For example, I love using the iLife suite. I think it works great in combination with OS X. However, I am also glad that I can use software that is not made by Apple, including even MS Office. Yes, Apple makes most of the software I may ever possibly need, but not everything. I’m happy that Apple is not only allowing me to install software for the things that Apple does not provide, they also let me install software that directly competes with the software they’ve created allowing me to choose which software I prefer to use. And they allow me to install it without having to jump through hoops to do it, such as having to install it onto a Windows PC first and then recompile to another format and then reinstall back onto my Mac.
PC only, Windows XP/2000, Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.1 or higher, Windows Media Player 7.1 or higher, Internet connectivity
Note: Windows XP and Windows Media Player 10 are required to use the Napster To Go™ service.
Download iTunes 6 free for Mac or Windows.
Mac OS X v10.2.8 or later
Windows 2000 or XP
Gorog, do we need to say more?
I think not.
a realist is a pholisophers a&&hole;
yes, its ‘pholisophers’: someone who thinks about so many things at one time, he can’t get one thing right
Somehow I don’t have a problem with Apple maintaining a marketshare leader position with products and services they developed and support. Consumers have decided to purchase these products and services and continue to do so. Development of these products and services is ongoing and indicates a long-term strategy for continuing to lead in these various product categories. Competitors have attempted to develop their own products and services in these segments and have been unable to penetrate successfully. That’s fine.
In fact, that is precisely how a market-driven economy is supposed to WORK.
Napster whining about Apple’s dominence? They would *LOVE* to have iTMS’s market position and would absolutely protect it if they had it. It’s like Creative whining about flash memory availability on the open market…if you can’t compete on the merits of your own products and abilties then guess what, you’ve LOST.
Realist:
If each of the individual music labels came out with their own DRM and their own “decent” hardware AND had really solid hits on their hands – they would have no trouble in getting consumers to switch over to their closed system.
The problem is that they don’t have hits and they are not concentrating on developing the music.
Look at Sony – they have their own decent hardware and they have their own DRM – But they are missing the key part which is the music.
Look if you have a great system for distribution – you don’t need the reecord labels. Go straight to the musical talent.
It seems to me if you have a great method of distibuting music and go to the grass roots of the supply (talent) you could beat the big labels at their own game.
Don’t hold yourself back by blaming Apple – they won’t use my system. Use your method of distribution, get the real talent out there and the big labels and maybe Apple will come to you.
Just my two cents.
“realist”, you’re going to end up like Gorog. You have quite a few enemies now, don’t you?